The Complex Nature of Moral Beliefs

8[\hlXk\cpk_\fi`q`e^k_\ifc\f]dfiXc`kp`edfiXc[`jki\jj`jZilZ`Xc]file[\ijkXe[`e^n_Xk

ÅdfiXc`ealipÆ\ekX`cj%N_\ehl\jk`fejXYflkk_\Zfdgc\oeXkli\f]dfiXc`kp^fleX[[i\jj\[#

lejlYjkXek`Xk\[ Xjjldgk`fej XYflk kiXldXÆj dfiXc [`d\ej`fej Xe[ `kj `dgc`ZXk`fej Xi\

\Xj`cp`eZfigfiXk\[#c\X[`e^kfk_\i`jbf]Zfdgc\o`jjl\jY\`e^XggifXZ_\[i\[lZk`m\cp%@e

k_\Zlii\ekZfeZ\gk#k_\^\e\iXc`[\X`jk_XkdfiXc`ealip`jk_\i\jlckf]XeXZkk_Xkm`fcXk\jX

jfc[`\iÆjY\c`\]jXYflki`^_kXe[nife^\%^%C`kqet al%)''0#;i\jZ_\iet al%)'((#EXj_et al%)'(*#

MXi^Xjet al.)'(*#:lii`\iet al%)'(, %K_\ZfeZ\gkjg\Xbjf]m`fcXk`fejf]fe\ÆjÅ[\\gcp_\c[

dfiXcY\c`\]Xe[\og\ZkXk`fejÆC`kqet al%)''0 #Xe[Xi\jlckXekÅcfjjf]kiljk`egi\m`fljcp

[\\gcp_\c[Y\c`\]jXYflkfe\Æjfnefifk_\ijÆXY`c`kpkfb\\gflij_Xi\[dfiXcZfm\eXekÆ

EXj_ Xe[ C`kq )'(*# g% *-/# j\\ Xcjf =Xiejnfik_ et al% )'(+# C`kq et al% )'(,# =iXeb]lik Xe[

=iXq`\i)'(- %8g\ijfeÆjdfiXcY\c`\]jXi\k_ljle[\ijkff[XjXZf_\i\ekjpjk\df]mXcl\jk_Xk

dXpY\m`fcXk\[Yp`ekil[`e^XZkj%P\k#efZfej`[\iXk`fe`j^`m\ekfk_\gfjj`Y`c`kpf]mXcl\j

Y\`e^`eZfeÐ`Zkn`k_fe\Xefk_\ij\\XcjfDfc\e[`abet al%)'(/ %K_`j`dgc`Z`kXggifXZ_

kfdfiXcY\c`\]jXjX_Xidfe`fljle`kp^`m\ji`j\kfhl\jk`fejn_\eZfej`[\i\[]ifdk_\

g\ijg\Zk`m\jf]g_`cfjfg_`ZXcXe[jfZ`XcjZ`\ek`ÏZjkl[`\j%8e`dgfikXek`ej`^_k[iXne]ifd

k_\j\[`jZ`gc`e\j`jk_XkXe`e[`m`[lXc\dYf[`\jdlck`gc\Xe[gfk\ek`XccpZfdg\k`e^dfiXc

Y\c`\]jXe[Xjjldgk`fej\%^%N`cc`Xdj(0.*#9XXi[XXe[M\in\`a)''-#Q`^fe)''/#?`kc`eXe[

MX`j\p)'(*#DZ:fee\cc)'(+#K\jjdXe)'(+ %@ek_`jj\Zk`fe#@n`cc[`jZljjk_`j`jjl\Xe[`kj

`dgc`ZXk`fej`edfi\[\kX`c%

8 g\ijfeÆj dfiXc Y\c`\]j Xe[ \og\ZkXk`fej Xi\ \jj\ek`Xccp Yfk_ g\ijfeXc Xe[ jfZ`Xc

9Xe[liX(00(#?X`[kXe[Afj\g_)''+ %N_`c\jg\Z`ÏZdfiXcY\c`\]jXe[\og\ZkXk`fejdXp

[`ɕ\i`eg\fgc\#k_\p[fefk[\m\cfg`eXjfZ`XcmXZlld%@e[`m`[lXcj[\m\cfgk_\dk_ifl^_

k_\jfZ`Xc`qXk`fegifZ\jjf]Y\Zfd`e^d\dY\ijf]XZfddle`kp%K_\Zfddle`kpgifm`[\j

Xjjldgk`fej Xe[ d\Xe`e^j k_ifl^_ n_`Z_ k_\p le[\ijkXe[ k_\`i \og\i`\eZ\ Xe[ dXb\

moral judgments about what is acceptable and unacceptable conduct, creating a moral ZfdgXjj k_Xk ^l`[\j k_\`i XZk`fej Z]% 9Xe[liX (00(# ?X`[k Xe[ Afj\g_ )''+# Q`^fe )''/#

?`kc`eXe[MX`j\p)'(* %:_`c[_ff[Zfejk`klk\jXe`dgfikXekg\i`f[f]dfiXcjfZ`Xc`qXk`fe#

p\kk_\gifZ\jjf]`ek\ieXc`q`e^dfiXcY\c`\]jXe[\og\ZkXk`feje\m\ijkfgj%@ek\iXZk`e^n`k_

fk_\ij Á `eZcl[`e^ gXi\ekj# ]i`\e[j# Zfddle`k`\j Xe[ jfZ`Xc `ejk`klk`fej Á Xe `e[`m`[lXc

Zfek`elfljcp\cXYfiXk\jXe[Xck\ijXZhl`i\[mXcl\jXe[efidj#Xe[X[fgkje\nfe\jZ]%MXe

>\ee\g(0'0#9Xe[liX(00(#<i`bj\e)''(#Q`^fe)''/ %

Jf# n_\i\Xj jfd\ dfiXc ZfeZ\iej dXp Y\ ]fle[ nfic[$n`[\ ?X`[k Xe[ Afj\g_ )''+#

:XjjXe`k`Xe[?`ZbdXe)'(+ #dfiXc`kp`jÅk_`ZbÆ#d\Xe`e^k_XkmXcl\jXe[efidjXi\j_Xg\[

Yp k_\`i jg\Z`ÏZ jfZ`f_`jkfi`ZXc Zfek\ok NXcq\i (00+ % 8e `e[`m`[lXcÆj dfiXc Y\c`\]j Xi\

[\m\cfg\[n`k_i\]\i\eZ\kfk_\[`ɕ\i\ek^iflgjf]n_`Z__\`jXd\dY\i#jlZ_Xji\c`^`flj

^iflgj#^\e\iXk`feXc[`jk`eZk`fejXe[fi^Xe`qXk`fej%8ZZfi[`e^cp#dfiXc`kpZXeYfk_j\im\Xj

X^cl\Y`e[`e^^iflgjkf^\k_\iXe[Y\XjfliZ\f]ZfeÐ`ZkY\kn\\e^iflgjQ`^fe)''.#)''/#

?`kc`eXe[MX`j\p)'(* %Dfi\fm\i#ZfeÐ`ZkdXpXi`j\n`k_`ek_\`e[`m`[lXc%8g\ijfec`m\jXe[

XZkjfeX[X`cpYXj`j#n`k_`eXiXe^\f]jfZ`Xcc\m\cj\%^%^iflg#fi^Xe`qXk`fe#eXk`fe Xe[X

36

Part I GYɛ]b[h\YGhU[Y Chapter 2 Toward a Broader Theoretical Approach to Moral Distress

iXe^\f]jfZ`XcZfek\okj\%^%[`ɕ\i\ek\k_e`ZZlckli\j#gif]\jj`feXcZlckli\j j\\\%^%<i`bj\e

)''(#?XeeX)''+#9XXi[XXe[M\in\`a)''- %8jXi\jlck#iXk_\ik_Xefne`e^Xefi[\icpXe[

_Xidfe`fljjpjk\df]mXcl\j#Xg\ijfe\dYf[`\jdlck`gc\dfiXcZfdd`kd\ekj#n_`Z_Xk

k`d\jdXb\ZfeÐ`Zk`e^[\dXe[j#Zi\Xk`e^k\ej`fejk_Xke\\[kfY\dXeX^\[?XeeX)''+#

9XXi[XXe[M\in\`a)''-#CX`[cXn)'(+#DZ:fee\cc)'(+#K\jjdXe)'(+ %

DXeX^`e^dfiXck\ej`fej`jefkXiXk`feXc\e[\Xmfi#c`b\jfcm`e^YiX`ek\Xj\ij%Fecp`e

cXYfiXkfip \og\i`d\ekj n`k_ _pgfk_\k`ZXc j`klXk`fej Zflc[ fe\ Zfd\ Zcfj\ kf X j`klXk`fe

n_\i\ g\fgc\ XggifXZ_ dfiXc `jjl\j Xj XYjkiXZk glqqc\j% @e giXZk`Z\# g\fgc\Æj al[^d\ekj

Xi\efkd\i\cp^fm\ie\[Yp]fidXci\Xjfe`e^#n_`Z_iXk`feXccpn\`^_jXcci\c\mXekmXcl\j

fe\ X^X`ejk fe\ k_\ fk_\i# Ylk Xcjf Yp [\\gcp ]\ck \dfk`fej% 8e^\i# [`j^ljk# j_Xd\ Xe[

ZfdgXjj`fe#kfeXd\YlkX]\n#`e]fiddfiXcg\iZ\gk`fejXe[[\Z`j`fejj\\\%^%?X`[k)''(#

Skoe et al%)'')#?Xii`j)''*#;\>iXXɕet al%)'(+ %=lik_\idfi\#k_\jg\Z`ÏZjfZ`XcZfek\ok

gcXpjXe`dgfikXekifc\%<og\i`d\ekjYpD`c^iXd(0.+ Xe[Q`dYXi[f)''/ gifm`[\g\i_Xgj

k_\dfjkefkfi`flji\d`e[\ijf]k_`j%K_\`i\og\i`d\ekjj_fn\[k_Xkn_\eg\fgc\Xi\gcXZ\[

`ej`klXk`fejn`k_gXik`ZlcXi^iflg[peXd`Zj#jfZ`Xcgi\jjli\jXe[gfn\ii\cXk`fej#k_\pdXp

dfi\i\X[`cp\e^X^\`eY\_Xm`fik_\pnflc[fk_\in`j\Zfej`[\i`ddfiXc%⁴F]Zflij\#k_\j\

\og\i`d\ekj n\i\ iX[`ZXc Xe[ \oki\d\# Xe[ `e jfd\ i\jg\Zkj k_\`i [`i\Zk Xggc`ZXY`c`kp kf

i\Xc$c`]\j`klXk`fejdXpY\hl\jk`feXYc\\%^%9XelXq`q`Xe[DfmX_\[`(0., %E\m\ik_\c\jj#

YpZi\Xk`e^k_\j\\oki\d\Z`iZldjkXeZ\j#k_\\og\i`d\ekjdX[\XggXi\ekn_Xk`jfɘ\eefk

jffYm`flj1g\fgc\ÆjdfiXcjkXe[Xi[jXe[Y\_Xm`fijXi\kfXe`dgfikXek\ok\ekj_Xg\[Yp

Zfek\okXe[k_\jfZ`Xcifc\jg\fgc\Xjjld\`ek_`jZfek\ok\%^%9Xe[liX(00(#?XeeX)''+ %

K_`jd\Xejk_Xkk_\jXd\g\fgc\dXpX[fgk[`ɕ\i\ekdfiXcjkXe[Xi[j`e[`ɕ\i\ekZfek\okj%

n`k_flkk_`eb`e^flkY\]fi\_Xe[Q`^fe)''/ %K_`j`jefkkfjl^^\jkk_XkdfiXc[\Z`j`fejXi\

YXj\[feefk_`e^#YlkiXk_\ik_Xkk_\pXi\efkgi`dXi`cpk_\i\jlckf]i\Ð\Zk`fe%8ZZfi[`e^cp#

g\fgc\ Xi\ ^\e\iXccp leXnXi\ f] _Xm`e^ dlck`gc\# gfk\ek`Xccp Zfdg\k`e^ dfiXc Y\c`\]j%

K_\p c`m\ k_\`i c`m\j n`k_flk ZfejkXekcp \og\i`\eZ`e^ ZfeÐ`Zk Yp n_`Z_ k_\p dX`ekX`e# Xj

<n`e^(00' ZXcc\[`k#XeÅ`cclj`fef]n_fc\e\jjÆ%K_\pk\e[kfk_`ebf]k_\dj\cm\j`ek\idj

f] Zfdgc\k\e\jj# Zf_\i\eZ\ Xe[ Zfej`jk\eZp# efk `e k\idj f] ]iX^d\ek\[# j_`ɘ`e^ j\cm\j

<n`e^(00'#Q`^fe)''/ %

@ec`e\n`k_k_`j#g\fgc\Æj\ogcXeXk`fejf]k_\`iY\_Xm`fiXi\fɘ\eal[^d\ekjdX[\`e

_`e[j`^_k%K_\j\Xi\fɘ\e#Xkc\XjkgXik`Xccp#gfjk$_fZiXk`feXc`qXk`fejiXk_\ik_XeZfdgc\k\cp

XZZliXk\i\Ð\Zk`fejf]n_XkfZZlii\[Xkk_\dfd\ek?X`[k)''(#K\jjdXe)'(+ %LjlXccp#

g\fgc\fecpZfd\lgn`k_i\Xjfe\[Xi^ld\ekjn_\ek_\pY\Zfd\XnXi\f]Xe`eZfej`jk\eZp

`e k_\`i dfiXc al[^d\ek# \`k_\i Y\ZXlj\ k_\ `eZfej`jk\eZp ^\e\iXk\j [`jZfd]fik ?X`[k

4 In the Milgram experiment, participants were ordered to administer what seemed to be agonizing dangerous electric g\cW_g hc k\ca h\Ym h\ci[\h kYfY ch\Yf jc`ibhUfm dUfh]W]dUbhg/ aUbm X]X A]`[fUa %-+(" =b N]aVUfXcÄg GhUbZcfX

YldYf]aYbh dUfh]W]dUbhgkYfYd`UWYX]bUg]hiUh]cbk]h\ghfcb[`mUgmaaYhf]WdckYffY`Uh]cbg/gcaYdUfh]W]dUbhgkYfY

made prisoners, others were made guards. Many ‘guards’ resorted to disrespectful and even sadistic behavior toward the Ãdf]gcbYfgÄN]aVUfXc&$$,"

37

Chapter 2 Toward a Broader Theoretical Approach to Moral DistressPart I GYɛ]b[h\YGhU[Y

)''(#KjXe^)'') fiY\ZXlj\Xek`Z`gXk\[Zi`k`Z`jdYpfk_\ijiX`j\jk_\e\\[]fialjk`ÏZXk`fe

9`cc`^(00-#?X`[k)''( %@eXepZXj\#Yfk_X[$_fZXe[gfjk$_fZ`ek\igi\kXk`fejXi\nXpj`e

n_`Z_g\fgc\\m\eklXccpZfd\kfle[\ijkXe[k_\j`klXk`fe`en_`Z_k_\pn\i\`emfcm\[Xe[

k_\ifc\k_\pgcXp\[`ek_`jj`klXk`fe%Fi^Xe`q`e^Xe[jkilZkli`e^d\dfi`\j`ekfd\Xe`e^]lc

eXiiXk`m\j\eXYc\jg\fgc\kfdXb\j\ej\f]k_\`i\og\i`\eZ\j%8jjlZ_#k_\jkfi`\jk_Xkg\fgc\

ZfejkilZkf]k_\`i\og\i`\eZ\jY\Zfd\g\ijfeXckilk_jf]n_Xkk_\p_Xm\j\\eXe[[fe\Z]%

Bc\`edXe(0//#>ff[(00+#?X`[k)''(#Dfc\e[`abet al%)'(- %

Kf klie YXZb kf k_\ `jjl\ f] Zfdg\k`e^ dfiXc Zfdd`kd\ekj# k_\j\ Xi\ dfjk fYm`flj

`edfiXc[`c\ddXj%KfY\^`en`k_#c\kd\^`m\Xe\oXdgc\k_Xkjfc[`\ijafb\[XYflk`eXe

\k_`ZjZflij\@fYj\im\[%K_\pjb\kZ_\[XjZ\eXi`f`en_`Z_Xjfc[`\iÆj^`ic]i`\e[Xjbj]fi_`j

fg`e`fef]_\iki\e[pÐfn\i$gi`ek\[a\Xej%8j_\iYfp]i`\e[#k_\jfc[`\i[f\jefknXekkf_lik

_\i#YlkXj_`jdfk_\iÆjjfe#_\[f\jefknXekkfc`\%?\eZ\#_\`jZfe]ifek\[YpX[`c\ddX%

N_`c\k_`j\oXdgc\nXjd\XekXjXafb\#`kn\cc`ccljkiXk\jk_Xk\m\ipfe\\dYf[`\jdlck`gc\

dfiXc Zfdd`kd\ekj Xe[ k_Xk \m\ipfe\ \eZflek\ij eld\iflj dfiXc [`c\ddXj \m\ip [Xp#

fɘ\en`k_flkY\`e^XnXi\f]`k%Dfi\fm\i#`k[\dfejkiXk\jk_XkXdfiXcZfeÐ`Zk[f\jefk

e\Z\jjXi`cp\e^\e[\i[`jkliYXeZ\fi[`jki\jj%

K_Xk jX`[# X jfc[`\iÆj nfic[ Zfejk`klk\j gi\$\d`e\ek Zfe[`k`fej ]fi dfiXc ZfeÐ`Zkj k_Xk

[f \e^\e[\i j\i`flj [`jki\jj% Jfc[`\ij dXp _Xm\ kf lj\ Xe[ n`ke\jj m`fc\eZ\ `e [Xe^\iflj

Z`iZldjkXeZ\j%N_`c\k_\pXi\`ejkild\ekjf]k_\jkXk\n_fdljkX[_\i\kfgfc`k`ZXcefidj

Xe[ c\^Xc ilc\j# k_\p Xcjf i\dX`e dfiXc X^\ekj n`k_ g\ijfeXc mXcl\j 9XXi[X Xe[ M\in\`a

)''- %<m\en_\ek_\pX^i\\n`k_Xcck_\pXi\fi[\i\[kf[f#k_\pi\dX`ed\dY\ijf]XjfZ`\kp

n_`Z_ dXb\j m`fc\eZ\ kXYff Z]% >ifjjdXe (00, % >`m\e k_Xk jfc[`\ij _fc[ dlck`gc\ dfiXc

Zfdd`kd\ekj `e k_\ Zfek\ok f] nXi Xe[ m`fc\eZ\# `k `j efk _Xi[ kf `dX^`e\ k_Xk k_\p dXp

\og\i`\eZ\[`jki\jj`e^dfiXcZfeÐ`Zkj%@e\oki\d\ZXj\j#k_\pdXp]XZ\kiX^`Z[`c\ddXjn_`Z_

]fiZ\k_\dkfZ_ffj\Y\kn\\eknf\m`cj#c\Xm`e^k_\d`e\m`kXYcpn`k_Å[`ikp_Xe[jÆ#efdXɝ\i

k_\`iZ_f`Z\\%^%NXcq\i(0.*#9XXi[XXe[M\in\`a)''-#GXii`j_)''.#9cXɝY\i^)'(, %

N_Xk`jk_\gjpZ_fcf^`ZXc`dgXZkf]kiX^`Z[`c\ddXjXe[fk_\idfiXccpZi`k`ZXcj`klXk`fej6

K_\ c`k\iXkli\ fe k_`j kfg`Z gifm`[\j ef Zc\Xi Xejn\ij% G_`cfjfg_\ij _Xm\ gi\[fd`eXekcp

[`jZljj\[k_\kfg`Z`eefidXk`m\[\YXk\jfe\k_`Zj#Xe[k_\jg\Z`ÏZgjpZ_fcf^`ZXc`dgXZk

f]k_\j\XZkj_Xjk_\i\]fi\efkY\\ek_\`idX`eZfeZ\ieNXcq\i(0.*#N`cc`Xdj(0.*#DXiZlj

(0/'#N`aq\)'',#)'()#K\jjdXe)'(+ %?fn\m\i#n_\e[\j`i`e^kfle[\ijkXe[dfiXc[`jki\jj#

`kj\\djk_Xkgi\Z`j\cpk_`j`je\Z\jjXip1kf\oXd`e\`e[\gk__fng\fgc\\og\i`\eZ\Xe[Xi\

Xɕ\Zk\[YpkiX^`Z[`c\ddXjXe[fk_\idfiXchlXe[Xi`\j%K_\ZfeZ\gkf]dfiXc`ealip[f\j

Xɝ\e[ kf k_\ gjpZ_fcf^`ZXc \og\i`\eZ\ f] dfiXc hlXe[Xi`\j# Ylk k_\ gifYc\d `j k_Xk k_`j

ZfeZ\gkk\e[jkfXggifXZ_Xg\ijfeÆjdfiXcY\c`\]jXjX_Xidfe`fljle`kp%@ejk\X[#[iXn`e^

fek_\XYfm\d\ek`fe\[`ej`^_kj#k_`jjkl[pZfej`[\ijk_XkXg\ijfeÆjdfiXcY\c`\]jZfejk`klk\

X Zfdgc\o kfkXc f] dlck`gc\# gfk\ek`Xccp Zfdg\k`e^ mXcl\j% 8j k_\ ]fccfn`e^ Z_Xgk\ij n`cc

dXb\ Zc\Xi# dfiXccp [`jki\jj`e^ \og\i`\eZ\j Xi\ fɘ\e dfi\ Zfdgc`ZXk\[ k_Xe Zc\Xi$Zlk

kiXej^i\jj`fej# Xe[# XZZfi[`e^cp# dfiXc [`jki\jj `j dfi\ Zfdgc`ZXk\[ k_Xe le\hl`mfZXc

]\\c`e^jf]^l`ckXe[j_Xd\%

38

Part I GYɛ]b[h\YGhU[Y Chapter 2 Toward a Broader Theoretical Approach to Moral Distress

In document Proefschrift 'Soldiers in conflict, moral injury, political practices and public perceptions. (pagina 35-38)