H\YFYgYUfW\DUfh]W]dUbhg - Proefschrift 'Soldiers in conflict, moral injury, political practic

K_`j j\Zk`fe [`jZljj\j k_\ Z_XiXZk\i`jk`Zj f] k_\ /' `ek\im`\n\[ m\k\iXej% @e c`e\ n`k_

k_\jXdgc\Zi`k\i`X#_Xc]f]k_\m\k\iXejn\i\j\ekkfk_\]fid\iPl^fjcXm`X#`efiXifle[

Ji\Yi\e`ZX#XjgXikf];lkZ_YXkfiXɝXZ_\[kf;lkZ_YXk#jlZ_Xj`eXd\[`ZXcle`k%9\kn\\e

(00+Xe[(00,k_\pn\i\[\gcfp\[]fij\m\iXcdfek_j#`efe\fifk_\if]k_\]fliifkXk`fej

f];lkZ_YXk%¹K_\fk_\i_Xc]f]k_\`ek\im`\n\\jn\i\[\gcfp\[kfJflk_8]^_Xe`jkXeXjgXik

f] KXjb =fiZ\ Lilq^XeÆj 9Xɝc\ >iflgj# fi Xj gXik f] X le`k XɝXZ_\[ kf k_\ 9Xɝc\ >iflgj%

9\kn\\e)''-Xe[)'('k_\pn\i\[\gcfp\[]fij\m\iXcdfek_j#XjgXikf]fe\f]k_\\`^_k

ifkXk`fejf]K=L%K_i\\èk\im`\n\\jj\im\[èYfk_;lkZ_YXkXe[èK=L%F]k_\;lkZ_YXk

m\k\iXej#k_\dXafi`kp_X[c\ɘj\im`Z\#n_`c\f]k_\K=Lm\k\iXej#XYflk_Xc]_X[c\ɘj\im`Z\%

8c`b\cpi\Xjfe]fik_`j[`ɕ\i\eZ\`jk_Xkk_\d`jj`fef];lkZ_YXkc`\j]lik_\i`ek_\gXjkk_Xe

k_\K=Ld`jj`fe%

Knf `ek\im`\n\\j Xi\ ]\dXc\# Yfk_ ;lkZ_YXk m\k\iXej% K_\ X^\ f] k_\ `ek\im`\n\\j Xk

k_\jkXikf]k_\`i[\gcfpd\ekmXi`\j]ifd(0kf+-p\Xij#Ylkk_\dXafi`kpnXjY\kn\\e)'

Xe[*'p\Xijfc[%K_\`iiXebXkk_\k`d\f][\gcfpd\ekiXe^\j]ifdgi`mXk\kfZfcfe\c%Dfjk#

_fn\m\i#n\i\Xgi`mXk\#ZfigfiXcfiefe$Zfdd`jj`fe\[fɖZ\iXkk_\k`d\f][\gcfpd\ek%

N_`c\k_`j[`jki`Ylk`fe`jècè\n`k_k_\[`jki`Ylk`fef]iXebjèk_\d`c`kXipgfglcXk`feXk

cXi^\Ák_\cfn\ik_\iXeb#k_\_`^_\ik_\eldY\if]\o$ jfc[`\ijÁ`k[f\jd\Xek_Xkjfd\

iXebjXi\Y\ɝ\ii\gi\j\ek\[k_Xefk_\ij%

N`k_i\jg\Zkkfk_\`jjl\f]dfiXc[`jki\jj#k_\Z_XiXZk\i`jk`Zjf]k_\`ek\im`\n\\jXi\

dfi\ [`ɖZlck kf \ogi\jj `e Ï^li\j% @] gcXZ\[ fe X Zfek`elld YXj\[ fe k_`j Zi`k\i`fe Á

iXe^`e^]ifdm\k\iXejn_fi\gfik\[efgjpZ_fcf^`ZXcgifYc\djXkXcckfm\k\iXejn_fjgfb\

f]p\Xijf][\Y`c`kXk`e^jlɕ\i`e^Á`kZflc[Y\jX`[k_XkXYflk_Xc]Xi\fek_\c\ɘj`[\#Xe[

k_\fk_\i_Xc]Xi\fek_\i`^_kf]k_\Zfek`elld%Kfi\g\Xk#k_`j[`jki`Ylk`fe`jgifYXYcpefk

1 =h]gbchkY``!_bckbh\UhUəYf8ihW\VUh=== cbYWcadUbmcZh\Yd`UbbYXZcifh\fchUh]cbcZgc`X]YfgkUggh]``XYd`cmYXhch\Y

former Yugoslavia.

52

Part I GYɛ]b[h\YGhU[Y Chapter 3 Methodological Choices and Considerations

i\gi\j\ekXk`m\f]k_\;lkZ_d`c`kXipgfglcXk`feXkcXi^\%IXk_\i#`k`jk_\flkZfd\f]k_`j

jkl[pÆjX`dkfi\XZ_XjlYjkXek`XceldY\if]gXik`Z`gXekjn`k_[\gcfpd\ek$i\cXk\[[`jki\jj

j\\ÅJXdgc\J\c\Zk`feÆ %

=`eXccp# `k `j nfik_ efk`e^ k_Xk k_\ jkl[p jXdgc\ `j efk c`d`k\[ kf X jg\Z`ÏZ jfZ`Xc fi

èjk`klk`feXce\knfib%Dfjkèk\im`\n\\j#èZcl[è^k_fj\èk\im`\n\[Ypk_\E\k_\icXe[j

M\k\iXej@ejk`klk\#n\i\efkXZk`m\cp`emfcm\[`e\`k_\ik_\E\k_\icXe[jM\k\iXej@ejk`klk\

fi fk_\i XjjfZ`Xk`fej% 8cjf# Y\ZXlj\ @ [i\n fe dlck`gc\ jfliZ\j# k_\ `ek\im`\n\\j n\i\

XZhlX`ek\[n`k_fecpXZflgc\fk_\i`ek\im`\n\\jXkdfjk%

8UhU5bU`mg]g

@eXZZfi[XeZ\n`k_^ifle[\[k_\fipd\k_f[j#XZilZ`XcgXikf]k_\XeXcpk`ZXcgifZ\jj\ekX`c\[

Zf[`e^k_\Zfcc\Zk\[dXk\i`Xc%K_\Zf[`e^k\Z_e`hl\j\im\[kfcXY\cXe[fi^Xe`q\k_\[XkX#

jfk_XkXeXcpj`jXe[k_\[XkXÆjkiXejcXk`fe`ekfk_\fi\k`ZXcZfeZ\gkjfZZlii\[jpjk\dXk`ZXccp

9ipdXe)'()#g%+') %@Zf[\[k_\[XkXn`k_k_\_\cgf]k_\hlXc`kXk`m\[XkXXeXcpj`jgif^iXd

8KC8J%k`%=fik_\Zf[è^gifZ\jj#@]fccfn\[îfle[\[k_\fip^l`[\cè\jljlXccp\dgcfp\[

]fieXiiXk`m\XeXcpj`j:_XidXq)''-#CXc\kXc%)'() %@ek_\`e`k`XcZf[`e^g_Xj\#@Zf[\[

i\Zlii`e^g_iXj\jXe[fk_\ii\^lcXi`k`\jXkXcfnc\m\cf]XYjkiXZk`fe%;li`e^k_`jg_Xj\#@

ZfejkXekcpZfdgXi\[k_\\d\i^`e^Zf[\jn`k_k_\[XkXXe[n`k_fe\Xefk_\i#`efi[\ikf

`[\ek`]p X[[`k`feXc i\c\mXek i\^lcXi`k`\j Xe[ kf \ejli\ @ _X[ efk c\ɘ flk i\c\mXek Zfek\ok

n`k_i\jg\Zkkfk_\i\^lcXi`k`\jXci\X[p`[\ek`Ï\[%N_\ee\Z\jjXip#@i\eXd\[Xe[df[`Ï\[

Zf[\j#fid\i^\[k_\dèkfe\nfe\j%@ek_\]fZlj\[Zf[è^g_Xj\#@îflg\[k_\Zf[\j

`ekfdfi\XYjkiXZkXe[k_\fi\k`ZXcZXk\^fi`\jXe[\ogcfi\[k_\i\cXk`fej_`gjY\kn\\ek_\d%

8^X`e#@i\$\ogcfi\[k_\[XkX`eZfdgXi`jfen`k_k_\ZfejkilZk\[ZXk\^fi`\j%<m\eklXccp#@

\jkXYc`j_\[ÅZfi\ZXk\^fi`\jÆ%8gg\e[`o9gi\j\ekjXjZ_\dXk`q\[i\gfikf]k_\Zf[\jk_Xk

\d\i^\[]ifdk_`jXeXcpk`ZXcgifZ\jj%

:f[`e^ Xe[ XeXcpj`j fZZlii\[ `k\iXk`m\cp# n`k_ k_\ i\j\XiZ_ hl\jk`fej Xe[ k_\fi\k`ZXc

]iXd\nfib`ed`e[#n_`Z_Xccfn\[]fiZfejkXeki\m`j`fe%@ZfejkXekcpZfdgXi\[k_\[XkX

n`k_k_\gi\c`d`eXipk_\fi\k`ZXc]iXd\nfib#j\XiZ_\[]fie\nk_\fi\k`ZXcc`k\iXkli\YXj\[

fe \dgì`ZXc Ïe[è^j# Xe[ hl\jk`fe\[ \d\i^è^ le[\ijkXe[è^j Yp \ogfjè^ k_\d kf

[\\g\i[XkXXeXcpj`j%=lik_\i#@i\^lcXicpgi\j\ek\[dp\d\i^`e^Ïe[`e^jXkjpdgfj`XXe[

kf j\m\iXc f] k_\ èk\im`\n\[ m\k\iXej# n_f j\im\[ Xj X jfle[è^ YfXi[% K_\ Ïe[è^j f]

k_`jjkl[pXi\k_ljk_\i\jlckf]Xe`k\iXk`m\gifZ\jj`en_`Z_[XkXXe[k_\fipZfek`elfljcp

`e]fid\[fe\Xefk_\i%8jjlZ_#k_\pXi\k_\i\jlckf]ÅXY[lZk`m\`e]\i\eZ\ÆI`Z_Xi[jfeXe[

BiXd\i)''- 1k_\pXi\i\^lcXi`k`\jXe[XjjfZ`Xk`fej[\k\Zk\[`ek_\\dg`i`ZXcdXk\i`Xc]fi

n_`Z_k_\fi\k`ZXccpj\ej`Yc\\ogcXeXk`fejZflc[Y\^`m\e%

Kf`ccljkiXk\k_\Zf[`e^gifZ\jj#k_\]fccfn`e^\oXdgc\[\jZi`Y\j_fn@Zf[\[XZZflekj

f]gfk\ek`XccpdfiXccpZ_Xcc\e^`e^j`klXk`fej%@e`k`Xccp#@Zf[\[fek_\YXj`jf]k_\]XZkfij

\mfb\[Ypk_\`ek\im`\n\[m\k\iXej\%^%ÅX[i\eXc`e\Æ#Åfi[\ijÆ#Å`knXj_`dfid\Æ Xe[k_\

nXpj `e n_`Z_ m\k\iXej `ek\igi\k\[ k_\ j`klXk`fe \%^% i`^_k# nife^# efe$dfiXc % @ k_lj

XeXcpq\[m\k\iXejÆXZZflekjYp]fZlj`e^j`dlckXe\fljcpfeZfek\ek\%^%k_\j`klXk`feXe[

k_\]XZkfijèmfcm\[èk_\j`klXk`fe Xe[d\Xeè^\%^%\mfbè^fi[\ijkfaljk`]pX[\Z`j`fe#

53

Chapter 3 Methodological Choices and Considerations Part I GYɛ]b[h\YGhU[Y

fi#Zfem\ij\cp#kfZfe[\deXj`klXk`fe %K_`jgifZ\jji\jlck\[`eZf[\jjlZ_XjÅilc\jXe[

èjkilZk`fejÆXe[ÅdfiXc[`jkXeZè^Xe[eldYè^Æ%@ek_\]fZlj\[Zf[è^g_Xj\#@îflg\[

Zf[\jk_Xk_X[\d\i^\[èk_\è`k`XcZf[è^g_Xj\èkfdfi\XYjkiXZkZXk\^fi`\j%@e`k`Xccp

@ki`\[kf[`jk`e^l`j_Y\kn\\e[`ɕ\i\ekmXcl\jfimXcl\j\kj#Ylk]fle[k_Xk[`j\ekXe^c`e^

m\k\iXejÆXZZflekjèk_`jnXpnXjmìklXccp`dgfjj`Yc\%=fièjkXeZ\#@]fle[k_Xkgif]\jj`feXc

mXcl\jjlZ_XjfY\[`\eZ\kfÅilc\jXe[`ejkilZk`fejÆn\i\fɘ\eXcjf[\\gcpg\ijfeXcmXcl\j#

n_`c\g\ijfeXck\e[\eZ`\jjlZ_XjÅdfiXc[`jkXeZ`e^Xe[eldY`e^Æn\i\efkXcnXpjj\\eXj

ZfekiX[`Zkfipkfgif]\jj`feXc`jd%Dfi\fm\i#@]fle[k_Xk[`j\ekXe^c`e^m\k\iXejÆXZZflekj

c`b\ k_`j nflc[ \c`d`eXk\ k_\ dlck`gc`Z`kp Xe[ Zfdgc\o`kp f] jfd\ \og\i`\eZ\j# n_`c\ X

efk`Z\XYc\]\Xkli\f]dXep[`jki\jj`e^\og\i`\eZ\jnXjk_`jm\ipdlck`gc`Z`kpXe[Zfdgc\o`kp%

K_\i\]fi\# @ [\Z`[\[ kf îflg k_\ \d\i^è^ ZfeZ\gkj ]ifd è`k`Xc Zf[è^ èkf ZXk\^fi`\j

jlZ_XjÅaljk`ÏZXk`fejXe[iXk`feXc`qXk`fejÆXe[ÅèZfej`jk\eZpèèk\igi\kXk`fejÆ%=èXccp#@

`[\ek`Ï\[k_\j\ZXk\^fi`\jXjZfgè^d\Z_Xe`jdj#jg\Z`ÏZXccpXjnXpjf]ÅdXbè^jfc[`\iè^

c\jjZfdgc\oÆ#Xe[k_lj^iflg\[k_\j\ZXk\^fi`\j`ekfXZfi\ZXk\^fipn`k_k_`jcXY\c%=`^li\

-Xe[KXYc\)j_fnk_\\d\i^`e^Xe[ÏeXci\jlckjf]k_`jgifZ\jj%

K_\lck`dXk\X`df]k_\Zf[è^Xe[XeXcpj`jnXjkf^Xèèj`^_kèkfdfiXc#gfc`k`ZXc

Xe[jfZ`\kXc[`d\ej`fejf]m\k\iXejÆ\og\i`\eZ\jf]dfiXc[`jki\jj%K_\`k\iXk`m\gifZ\[li\

dX[\`kgfjj`Yc\kf^\e\iXk\k_\fipiXk_\ik_Xed\i\cpk\jk\o`jk`e^k_\fip n_`c\\ejli`e^

k_Xkk_\\d\i^\ekk_\fipnXj\dg`i`ZXccp^ifle[\[%@efk_\infi[j#k_\gifZ\[li\dX[\`k

gfjj`Yc\kfZfeki`Ylk\kfk_\ZfeZ\gkf]dfiXc`ealip%

Figure 6: Example of the Coding Process in ATLAS.ti

Table 2: Example of the Coding Results

Initial codes Focused codes Core categories

Doing good things

>igh]ɕWUh]cbgUbX

rationalizations Inconsistency in

interpretations Making soldiering less complex Rules and instruction

Reciprocity

Distancing and numbing

Bc^igh]ɕWUh]cbbYYXYX Bc^igh]ɕWUh]cbbYYXYX

54

Part I GYɛ]b[h\YGhU[Y Chapter 3 Methodological Choices and Considerations

7fYX]V]`]hmUbX;YbYfU`]nUV]`]hm

K_`j j\Zk`fe [`jZljj\j k_\ `jjl\j f] Zi\[`Y`c`kp Xe[ ^\e\iXc`qXY`c`kp% :i\[`Y`c`kp `j k_\

hlXc`kXk`m\ \hl`mXc\ek kf n_Xk `e hlXek`kXk`m\ i\j\XiZ_ `j i\]\ii\[ kf Xj `ek\ieXc mXc`[`kp

9ipdXe )'()# gg% ).+Á, % @k i\]\ij kf X _`^_ c\m\c f] Zfii\jgfe[\eZ\ Y\kn\\e n_Xk fe\

nXekjkfjkl[pXe[n_Xk`jXZklXccpjkl[`\[Z]%>fcX]j_Xe`)''*#9ipdXe)'()#g%).* %K_`j

jkl[p^Xk_\i\[[\kX`c\[hlXc`kXk`m\dXk\i`Xc#[i\nlgfemXi`flj[XkXjfliZ\jlj`e^j\m\iXc

d\k_f[j#Xggc`\[XcXi^\cp`e[lZk`m\XggifXZ_#Xe[ZfejkXekcpZfdgXi\[[XkXXe[k_\fip#

j\\b`e^Yfk_ZfeÏidXk`feXe[[`jZfeÏidXk`fe%8cck_\j\d\k_f[j_Xm\Y\\e`[\ek`Ï\[Xj

\e_XeZ`e^Zi\[`Y`c`kpY\ZXlj\k_\p\ejli\ki`Xe^lcXk`fef][XkXXe[d\k_f[j#Xe[Ïidcp

îfle[ k_\fip è \dgì`ZXc dXk\i`Xc ;\eqè )''-# 9ipdXe )'() % @e gXik`ZlcXi# k_\j\

d\k_f[j\ejli\_`^_Å\Zfcf^`ZXcZi\[`Y`c`kpÆ#d\Xe`e^k_Xkdpi\j\XiZ_Ïe[`e^j[fefkXggcp

aljkkf_pgfk_\k`ZXcfi\og\i`d\ekXcj`klXk`fej#YlkkfeXkliXcjfZ`Xcj\ɝ`e^jXjn\cc;\eq`e

)''-#9ipdXe)'() %

I\^Xi[`e^ k_\ `jjl\j f] ^\e\iXc`qXY`c`kp# k_\ Z_fj\e jXdgc`e^ d\k_f[ `j i\c\mXek kf

Zfej`[\i%@ZfejZ`fljcpZ_ffj\kflj\k_\fi\k`ZXcjXdgc`e^j\c\Zk`fef]k_\fi\k`ZXccpi\c\mXek

[XkX iXk_\ik_XeiXe[fdjXdgc`e^j\c\Zk`fef]jkXk`jk`ZXccpi\gi\j\ekXk`m\[XkX %DpX`d

nXjefkkfgifm`[\hlXek`kXk`m\`e]fidXk`feXYflkk_\gi\mXc\eZ\f]jpdgkfdjXjjfZ`Xk\[

n`k_ÅdfiXc`ealipÆ%J\m\iXcfk_\ijkl[`\j_Xm\Xci\X[p[fe\k_`jDX^l\eet al%)''0#I`\km\c[

2009, Drescher et al%)'((#EXj_et al%)'(*#MXi^Xjet al%)'(*#:lii`\iet al%)'(,#JZ_lk)'(,#

9ipXe et al% )'(- % IXk_\i# dp X`d nXj kf ^Xè k_\fi\k`ZXc èj`^_k èkf dfiXc [`jki\jj% 8j

d\ek`fe\[# k_`j jkl[p [f\j efk \oXd`e\ hl\jk`fej jlZ_ Xj ÅZXe X Zfii\cXk`fe Y\ ]fle[

Y\kn\\e dfiXc [`jki\jj Xe[ X gXik`ZlcXi fk_\i ]XZkfi6Æ# Ylk jlZ_ hl\jk`fej Xj Å`] m\k\iXej

\og\i`\eZ\[`jki\jj[l\kfdfiXcZ_Xcc\e^\j#n_Xk[f\j`k\ekX`c6Æ%N_`c\iXe[fdjXdgc`e^`j

lj\]lcn_\e\oXdèè^k_\Ïijkbè[f]hl\jk`fe#k_\fi\k`ZXcjXdgcè^`jdfjkXggifgi`Xk\

]fik_\j\Zfe[b`e[%@k`eZi\Xj\jk_\gfk\ek`Xc]fik_\fi\k`ZXc^\e\iXc`qXk`fe#k_Xk`j#]fik_\

kiXej]\iXY`c`kpf]k_\jkl[pÏe[`e^jkffk_\ij\ɝ`e^jZ_XiXZk\i`q\[Ypj`d`cXigifZ\jj\jXe[

Z`iZldjkXeZ\j#Y\ZXlj\`kdXb\j`kgfjj`Yc\kfk_fifl^_cp\oXd`e\gXik`ZlcXid\Z_Xe`jdj

Xknfib`eg_\efd\eXZ]%>cXj\iXe[JkiXljj(0-.#:_XidXq)''- %Jf#n_`c\k_`jjkl[p`j

jlYjkXek`Xccpc`d`k\[n`k_i\jg\ZkkfjkXk`jk`ZXc^\e\iXc`qXk`fe#`ki\c`\jfei\cXk`m\cpjkife^

d\k_f[j]fik_\fi\k`ZXc^\e\iXc`qXk`fe%

FYgYUfW\YfFc`YUbX=ggiYgcZ=bhYfdfYhUh]cb

@e k_`j j\Zk`fe# @ Zfej`[\i dp fne ifc\ `e k_`j jkl[p Xe[ `jjl\j f] `ek\igi\kXk`fe dfi\

^\e\iXccp%C\kd\jkXikYpjkXk`e^k_Xkefi\j\XiZ_`jj`dgcpXefYa\Zk`m\gi\j\ekXk`fef]k_\

nfic[%K_\nXpk_\i\j\XiZ_\i\ek\ijXi\j\XiZ_j\ɝ`e^`e\m`kXYcpj_Xg\jk_\i\jlck%I\j\XiZ_

hl\jk`fejXe[k_\fi\k`ZXcXggifXZ_\j#Xjk_\p^l`[\k_\XeXcpj`j#XcnXpjZfcfik_\i\j\XiZ_%

=fi`ejkXeZ\#k_\]XZkk_Xk@]fZlj\[fejfZ`fgfc`k`ZXc[`d\ej`fejf]dfiXc[`jki\jji\jlck\[`e

Ïe[`e^jfek_\j\[`d\ej`fej#n_`Z_dXp^`m\k_\]Xcj\`dgi\jj`fek_XkjfZ`fgfc`k`ZXc]XZkfij

Xi\\ek`i\cpi\jgfej`Yc\]fik_\gi\mXc\eZ\f]dfiXc[`jki\jj%P\k#k_\]XZkk_Xk@`[\ek`Ï\[

Xi\cXk`feY\kn\\edfiXc[`jki\jjXe[jfZ`fgfc`k`ZXc]XZkfijiXk_\ik_Xefk_\i]XZkfij `jX

55

jfZ`Xc i\j\XiZ_\i kf k_`eb `k `j gfjj`Yc\ kf j`dgcp Y\ X ÅÐp fe k_\ nXccÆ% 8ck_fl^_ @ Zflc[

ki`Xe^lcXk\dpfne`ek\im`\njn`k_k_fj\Zfe[lZk\[Ypk_\E\k_\icXe[jM\k\iXej@ejk`klk\#

`kjk`ccj\\dji\c\mXekkfi\Ð\Zkfe_fnk_\m\k\iXejÆg\iZ\gk`fejf]d\dXp_Xm\j_Xg\[dp

dXk\i`Xc%8jX]\dXc\Z`m`c`XeXZX[\d`Z#@nXj^\e\iXccpj\\eXjXgXik`Xcflkj`[\i%N_`c\X

Zfdgc\k\cpèj`[\igfj`k`fe`jle[\jìXYc\Xj`kgi\j\ekjk_\i`jbf]Å_fd\Ycè[e\jjÆ<i`bj\e

)''(#g%*' #Y\`e^g\iZ\`m\[XjXZfdgc\k\flkj`[\idXp_`e[\ik_\\jkXYc`j_d\ekf]iXggfik%

@ek\im`\n\ijXcnXpj]XZ\`jjl\jf]Yl`c[`e^kiljk#Xe[Xjefk\[#k_\j\`jjl\jXi\\oXZ\iYXk\[

`e i\j\XiZ_ fe j\ej`k`m\ jlYa\Zk dXɝ\ij JZ_lcdXe$>i\\e et al% )''0 % @e[\\[# m\k\iXej

would sometimes comment that ‘people who have not been through the same thing cannot le[\ijkXe[`kÆ%8kc\XjkgXik`Xccp#@Zflc[Zfdg\ejXk\]fik_`jc`d`kXk`feYpdp]Xd`c`Xi`kpn`k_

feXZ\ikX`e\mXclXk`m\cfX[ÆJXp\i)''0#g%./) %8jd\ek`fe\[#jfd\m\k\iXej@`ek\im`\n\[

Zfdd\ek\[k_Xkg\fgc\n`k_flkj`d`cXi\og\i`\eZ\ZXeefkkilcple[\ijkXe[n_Xkk_\p_Xm\

@ ZXd\ kf le[\ijkXe[ m\k\iXejÆ jkXk\d\ekj k_ifl^_ k_\ efk`fej f] kiXej]\i\eZ\ Xe[

Zflek\ikiXej]\i\eZ\% @e`k`Xccp [\m\cfg\[ `e k_\ Ï\c[ f] gjpZ_fXeXcpj`j# k_\j\ efk`fej Xi\

èZi\Xjè^cpXggc`\[èjZ`\ek`ÏZi\j\XiZ_\%^%GXlc(0/0#N`k_l`j)'') %@ei\j\XiZ_Zfek\okj#

kiXej]\i\eZ\`jlj\[kf`e[`ZXk\k_\kfkXc`kpf]]\\c`e^jXe[i\XZk`fejf]k_\i\jgfe[\ekkfnXi[

k_\i\j\XiZ_\i%:flek\ikiXej]\i\eZ\#`eklie#`jd\Xekkf[\jZi`Y\k_\]\\c`e^jXe[i\XZk`fej

f] k_\ i\j\XiZ_\i kfnXi[ k_\ i\jgfe[\ek Xe[ _`j kiXej]\i\eZ\ `Y`[ % 8j IfYY\e (00- efk`Z\[è_`jfnei\j\XiZ_fegfc`k`ZXcm`fc\eZ\è8i^\ekèX#XdXafii`jbf]\oXdèè^

`dgi\jj`feXYc\jkfi`\jf]jlɕ\i`e^`jk_Xkk_\pdXpfm\in_\cdi\j\XiZ_\ij%:fej\hl\ekcp#

i\j\XiZ_\ijdXpleZi`k`ZXccpi\gif[lZ\k_\nfic[$m`\njf]k_\`ii\jgfe[\ekjn_`c\Y\c`\m`e^

k_Xk k_\p _Xm\ ^Xè\[ X kil\ le[\ijkXe[è^ f] k_\ì gXè% :fem\ij\cp# Xj N`k_l`j )'')

56

Part I GYɛ]b[h\YGhU[Y Chapter 3 Methodological Choices and Considerations

j`^eXc\[# i\j\XiZ_\ij dXp Xcjf [\ZcXi\ k_\dj\cm\j jg\\Z_c\jj Xe[ i\]iX`e ]ifd XeXcpj`j

flkf]i\jg\Zk]fik_\jkfi`\jf]fm\in_\cdè^jlɕ\iè^k_\p\oXdè\%?fn\m\i#XjIfYY\e

Xe[ N`k_l`j Xcjf \dg_Xj`q\# Zi`k`ZXc XeXcpj`j `j \oXZkcp n_Xk dXb\j X jZ`\ek`ÏZ i\j\XiZ_

mXclXYc\%AljkXjXZi`k`ZXcXɝ`kl[\`jefkk_\jXd\XjZi`k`Z`q`e^fk_\ij#\dgXk_p`jefkk_\

jXd\XjXYjfiY`e^fk_\ijÆg\iZ\gk`fej%N_`c\`ki\dX`ejkil\k_XkXe\dgXk_\k`ZXɝ`kl[\

`jè[`jg\ejXYc\]file[\ijkXe[è^g\fgc\Æj\og\i`\eZ\j#`kjg`k]Xcc`jY\è^c\[XjkiXp]ifd

fe\ÆjjZ`\ek`ÏZfYa\Zk`m\jkfnXi[Xjlg\iÏZ`XcXeXcpj`j%JlZ_Xjkl[p`jkfeffe\ÆjY\e\Ïk%

P\k# N`k_l`j )'') # IfYY\e (00- Xe[ fk_\ij \%^% GXlc (0/0 Xcjf Zfek\e[ k_Xk

kiXej]\i\eZ\Xe[Zflek\ikiXej]\i\eZ\#n_\ei\Zf^e`q\[#ZXeXZklXccpY\e\Ïkfe\Æji\j\XiZ_%

@ec`e\n`k_gjpZ_fXeXcpk`Zle[\ijkXe[`e^j#k_\pjkXk\k_Xkk_\d\Z_Xe`jdjZXeY\lj\[Xj

XeXeXcpk`ZXckffc%K_Xk`j#k_\`ek\iXZk`fejY\kn\\ei\j\XiZ_\iXe[i\jgfe[\ekjZXeXcjfY\

j\\eXj`ej`^_k]lc[XkX%@e[\\[#m\k\iXejÆi\jgfej\jkfdpi\hl\jkjXe[dpfnei\jgfej\j

kf k_\`i jkfi`\j n\i\ gXik f] n_Xk dp i\j\XiZ_ nXj XYflk1 k_\ `dgXZk f] \og\i`\eZ\j f]

gfn\ic\jje\jj# ]\\c`e^j f] `jfcXk`fe Xe[ d`jkiljk kfnXi[ fk_\ij# Xgg\Xcj ]fi i\Zf^e`k`fe#

[`jZfd]fikèfk_\ijn_\e_\Xiè^jkfi`\jf]m`fc\eZ\Xe[gXè#Xe[jffe%Le[\ijkXe[è^

dpèk\iXZk`fejn`k_m\k\iXejXjjlZ__\cg\[d\kfi\]iXèYfk_]ifdleZi`k`ZXccpXYjfiYè^

m\k\iXejÆ g\ijg\Zk`m\j Xe[ ]ifd ]fiZè^ è[`ɕ\i\eZ\ flk f] X ]\Xi f] efk Y\è^ fYa\Zk`m\%

Dfi\fm\i#`kXccfn\[d\kflj\k_\j\`ek\iXZk`fejXjXjfliZ\f]`e]fidXk`fe%

9h\]WU`7cbg]XYfUh]cbg

K_\ gi\m`flj j\Zk`fe [`jZljj\[ k_\ \k_`ZXc `jjl\ f] [f`e^ Zi`k`ZXc i\j\XiZ_ n`k_flk [f`e^

`ealjk`Z\kfk_\i\j\XiZ_gXik`Z`gXekj%@ek_`jÏeXcj\Zk`fe#@Yi`\Ðp\ogcX`e_fn@[\Xckn`k_

fk_\i \k_`ZXc `jjl\j% Fm\iXcc# @ ]fccfn\[ k_\ \k_`ZXc ^l`[\c`e\j ]fi ^ff[ i\j\XiZ_ giXZk`Z\

[\Ïe\[Ypk_\8jjfZ`Xk`fef]JfZ`Xc8ek_ifgfcf^`jkj8J8 )'(( #n_`Z_Xi\k_\i\jlckf]YifX[

hlXc`kXk`m\i\j\XiZ_\og\i`\eZ\Xdfe^dXi^`eXc`q\[fifk_\in`j\mlce\iXYc\gfglcXk`fej%

KfY\dfi\jg\Z`ÏZ#@ÏijkdX[\jli\k_XkXccdpi\j\XiZ_gXik`Z`gXekjn\i\XnXi\f]dp

`[\ek`kpXjXi\j\XiZ_\i%@XcnXpj\dg_Xj`q\[k_Xk@XdefkXk_\iXg`jkfiXgif]\jj`feXcXYc\kf

fɕ\iè]fidXk`fefiX[m`Z\%@fecpèk\im`\n\[è[`m`[lXcjn_f^Xm\è]fid\[Zfej\ekkfk_\

i\j\XiZ_%@ek_\gi\gXiXkfip#fi`\ekXk`feg_Xj\@fecp`ek\im`\n\[m\k\iXejn_f_X[Xci\X[p

jgfb\eglYc`ZcpXYflkk_\`i[\gcfpd\ek\og\i`\eZ\%@Xjb\[knfd`c`kXipZ_XgcX`ej]fiX[m`Z\

fek_\\k_`ZXc[`d\ej`fej%Fek_`jYXj`j#@[\Z`[\[kf`ek\im`\nm\k\iXejn_f_X[Xci\X[p

ZfeÏ[\[ k_\`i \og\i`\eZ\j kf Xk c\Xjk fe\ fk_\i g\ijfe# n_`Z_ @ dX[\ jli\ nXj k_\ ZXj\

Y\]fi\dXbè^Xeèk\im`\nXggfèkd\ek%8kk_\jkXikf]\m\ipèk\im`\n#@XcnXpjd\ek`fe\[

k_\n\Yj`k\f]k_\M\k\iXe\ecfb\kÅM\k\iXeFɖZ\Æ k_XkZXe^l`[\m\k\iXej`eÏe[`e^_\Xck_

ZXi\%8cjf#@\ogc`Z`kcpjX`[k_XkgXik`Z`gXekj[`[efk_Xm\kfXejn\iXephl\jk`fe`]k_\p[`[

efk nXek kf% @ Zcfj\cp fYj\im\[ _fn k_\ `ek\im`\n Xɕ\Zk\[ k_\ m\k\iXe# Xe[ `] `k j\\d\[

e\Z\jjXip@nflc[Yi`\Ðpjk\\iljkfXc\jj\dfk`feXckfg`Z%Kf\ejli\m\k\iXejÆXefepd`kp#

@lj\gj\l[fepdj`ek_`jjkl[p%8cjf#n_\i\`k[f\jefkZfdgifd`j\k_\j`^e`ÏZXeZ\f]k_\

jkfi`\j#@_Xm\fd`ɝ\[fk_\i[\kX`cj#jlZ_Xjjg\Z`ÏZ[Xk\jXe[cfZXk`fej%

In document Proefschrift 'Soldiers in conflict, moral injury, political practices and public perceptions. (pagina 51-57)