Conclusions: Theoretical Implications - Conclusions: Theoretical and Practical Implications

Part III. Conclusions: Theoretical and Practical Implications

Chapter 9. Conclusions: Theoretical Implications

K_\X`df]k_`jjkl[pnXjkfX[mXeZ\k_\\dg`i`ZXcXe[k_\fi\k`ZXcle[\ijkXe[`e^f]dfiXc#

gfc`k`ZXcXe[jfZ`\kXc[`d\ej`fejf][\gcfpd\ek$i\cXk\[dfiXc[`jki\jj#Xe[k_ljZfeki`Ylk\

kf k_\ ZfeZ\gk f] dfiXc `ealip Xe[ giXZk`ZXc `ek\im\ek`fej kf X[[i\jj Xe[ gi\m\ek dfiXc

[`jki\jj%@XZ_`\m\[k_`jYp\oXd`e`e^dfiXc[`d\ej`fejf]\og\i`\eZ\jf][`jki\jj#Xe[k_\

ifc\f]gfc`k`ZXcgiXZk`Z\jXe[glYc`Zg\iZ\gk`fej`e\og\i`\eZ\jf]dfiXc[`jki\jj`e;lkZ_YXk

Xe[K=Lm\k\iXej%@ek_`jZ_Xgk\i#@kXb\jkfZbf]dpÏe[`e^j#Xe[[`jZljjk_\`i`dgc`ZXk`fej

]fik_\ZfeZ\gkf]dfiXc`ealip%

AU]bFYgYUfW\:]bX]b[g

@efi[\ikfY\XYc\kfZfeki`Ylk\kfdfiXc`ealipk_\fip#@kffbXZi`k`ZXcjkXeZ\kfk_\Zlii\ek

ZfeZ\gkf]dfiXcèalipXe[XepZfeZ\gklXc`qXk`fef][\gcfpd\ek$i\cXk\[jlɕ\iè^%KfY\^è

n`k_#@\ogc`Z`kcp[`jkè^l`j_\[Y\kn\\ek_\ZfeZ\gkXe[g_\efd\eXf]dfiXcèalipZXccè^

k_\ÏijkÅdfiXcèalipÆXe[k_\j\Zfe[ÅdfiXc[`jki\jjÆ #k_lji\]iXèè^]ifdi\`]pè^ÅdfiXc

èalipÆXjXefYa\Zk`m\k_è^%@]fle[k_XkXck_fl^_k_\ZfeZ\gkf]dfiXcèalip`j\ogc`Z`kcp

èk\e[\[kfX[[i\jjdfiXcXjg\Zkjk_Xkk_\ZfeZ\gkf]GKJ;]X`cjkfîXjg#`k]fZlj\jdXècp

fek_\Å`ealipÆn_`c\Xɝ\e[`e^kffc`ɝc\kfk_\ÅdfiXcÆ%8cjf#Xjn`k_k_\GKJ;ZfeZ\gk#`k

fm\icffbjk_\n`[\iZfek\okf][\gcfpd\ek$i\cXk\[jlɕ\i`e^%8jdpi\j\XiZ_]fZlj#k_\i\]fi\#

@Z_fj\k_\kf$[Xk\`ejlɖZ`\ekcpX[[i\jj\[dfiXcXe[jfZ`fgfc`k`ZXc[`d\ej`fejf]dfiXc

[`jki\jj#kfX[mXeZ\k_\ZfeZ\gkf]dfiXc`ealip%

@e k\idj f] i\j\XiZ_ jkiXk\^p# @ X[fgk\[ X hlXc`kXk`m\# ^ifle[\[ k_\fip XggifXZ_#

\eXYcè^ d\ kf è[lZk`m\cp jkl[p g_\efd\eX XYflk n_`Z_ \o`jkè^ k_\fip `j c`d`k\[% Dp

ZXj\ jkl[`\j ]fZlj\[ efk aljk fe ZfdYXk Á k_\ Zlii\ek ]fZlj f] dfiXc `ealip i\j\XiZ_ Á

YlkXcjffeg\XZ\b\\g`e^%Jg\Z`ÏZXccp#@XeXcpq\[k_\;lkZ_YXkXe[K=Ld`jj`fej#XÅYcl\

_\cd\kÆ LE g\XZ\b\\g`e^ d`jj`fe d\k n`k_ _Xij_ glYc`Z Zi`k`Z`jd Xe[ X Å^i\\e _\cd\kÆ

E8KFZflek\i`ejli^\eZpd`jj`fek_Xk\eZflek\i\[d`o\[glYc`Zi\jgfej\%@[`[efkj\c\Zk

XjXdgc\f]m\k\iXejn_fdXkZ_\[k_\jpdgkfdj[\Ïe\[`ek_\Zlii\ekZfeZ\gkf]dfiXc

èalip#Ylkn\ek]fiXdfi\fg\e#lejg\Z`Ï\[j\c\Zk`fef]m\k\iXej#èZcl[è^m\k\iXejn`k_

dèfi fi ef gjpZ_fcf^`ZXc gifYc\dj Xk Xcc% =èXccp# è XeXcpqè^ k_\ ZXj\ jkl[`\j# @ n\ek

Y\pfe[k_\gi\[fd`eXekcpgjpZ_fcf^`ZXcg\ijg\Zk`m\f]k_\Zlii\ekZfeZ\gkf]dfiXc`ealip#

Xe[X[fgk\[XZfdY`eXk`fef]gjpZ_fcf^`ZXc#g_`cfjfg_`ZXc#Xek_ifgfcf^`ZXcXe[gfc`k`ZXc

jZ`\ek`ÏZg\ijg\Zk`m\j%Kf^\k_\i#k_`jXccfn\[d\kf\oXd`e\\og\i`\eZ\jk_Xkfm\ijg`cck_\

Yfle[Xi`\j f] k_\ Zlii\ek ZfeZ\gk f] dfiXc `ealip Xe[ \ogcfi\ fk_\i k_Xe gjpZ_fcf^`ZXc

`ek\igi\kXk`fej]fik_\\og\i`\eZ\j%

KXbè^ k_\ jkfi`\j f] +' ;lkZ_YXk Xe[ +' K=L m\k\iXej Xj jkXikè^ gfèkj# @ \oXdè\[

dfiXc[`d\ej`fejf]\og\i`\eZ\jf][`jki\jj#Xe[k_\ifc\f]gfc`k`ZXcgiXZk`Z\jXe[glYc`Z

g\iZ\gk`fej`e\og\i`\eZ\jf]dfiXc[`jki\jj#[li`e^Xe[Xɘ\i[\gcfpd\ek%K_\m\k\iXejÆ

i\cXk\[k_\ìi\Xjfej]fiafèè^k_\d`c`kXip#k_\ì\og\ZkXk`fejf][\gcfpd\ek#k_\i\Xc`kpf]

169

Chapter 9 Conclusions: Theoretical ImplicationsPart 3 Conclusions: Theoretical and Practical Implications

[\gcfpd\ek#k_\`i\og\i`\eZ\f]i\klie`e^_fd\#k_\[`jki\jjk_Xkjfd\[\m\cfg\[#Xe[_fn

k_\pi\jgfe[\[kfk_`j[`jki\jj%@kY\ZXd\Zc\Xik_Xkn_\em\k\iXejjkil^^c\[#k_\`ijkil^^c\j

n\i\e\m\iZfeÏe\[kf[\gcfpd\ek#YlkXcjfcXp`ek_\gifYc\djf]i\jld`e^Z`m`c`Xec`]\%

Jg\Z`ÏZXccp#dXepm\k\iXeji\cXk\[Xgfjk$[\gcfpd\ekjg`iXcf]^l`ckXe[Xe^\i#c\X[`e^kf

destructive and neglecting behavior toward themselves and their loved ones, increasing k_\`i ^l`ck Xe[ Xe^\i# Xe[ jf fe% N_`c\ \XZ_ f] k_\ jkfi`\j @ _\Xi[ gifm\[ kf Y\ le`hl\#

kf^\k_\i k_\p i\m\Xc\[ `ej`^_kj `ekf dfi\ k_Xe aljk k_\ mXi`\kp f] m\k\iXejÆ \og\i`\eZ\j%

K_\pXcjfj_fn\[gXɝ\iej%K_\j\gXɝ\iej`eZcl[\[dXepgXiXcc\cjY\kn\\ek_\jkfi`\jf]

;lkZ_YXkXe[K=Lm\k\iXejXjn\ccXjY\kn\\ek_\jkfi`\jf][`jki\jj\[Xe[efe$[`jki\jj\[

m\k\iXej# n_`c\ k_\ [`ɕ\i\eZ\j Y\kn\\e k_\j\ ^iflgj klie\[ flk kf Y\ cXi^\cp ^iX[lXc#

efk]le[Xd\ekXc%@XeXcpq\[k_\gXɝ\iejXe[[`ɕ\i\eZ\j@]fle[n`k_k_\_\cgf]\o`jk`e^

\m\eklXccp [\m\cfg [`jki\jj Yfk_ f] n_`Z_ klie\[ flk kf Y\ m\ip j`d`cXi % 8eXcpq`e^ k_\

jkfi`\j#@ki`\[kfle[\ijkXe[_fnjfc[`\ijg\iZ\`m\k_\`igif]\jj`fe`ek_\ÏijkgcXZ\Xe[

è`k`Xccp# kf \dgcfp aljk`]pè^ j`dgc`ÏZXk`fej kf i\jfcm\ k_\ k\ej`fe# i\cpè^ fe k_\ Y\c`\]

k_XkXccj`klXk`fejXi\lck`dXk\cpleZfdgc`ZXk\[Xe[jfclYc\%=fi`ejkXeZ\#]XZ\[n`k_dfiXc

Z_Xcc\e^\jfe[\gcfpd\ek#k_\pdXpk\cck_\dj\cm\jk_XkÅjfd\k_`e^jaljk_Xgg\e`enXiÆ#fi

k_\pdXp\dgcfp]fidlcXjjlZ_XjÅ@aljk_Xm\kf]fccfnfi[\ijÆ#Å`knXj_`dfid\ÆfiÅ@ki\Xk

k_\dXjk_\pki\Xkd\Æ%8cjf#kfi\jfcm\gfjj`Yc\k\ej`fejXi`j`e^]ifdY\`e^Yfk_Xjfc[`\i

Xe[ X Z`m`c`Xe# k_\p dXp ZfdgXikd\ekXc`q\ k_\`i d`c`kXip Xe[ Z`m`c`Xe j\cm\j# gi`fi`k`q`e^

k_\]fid\ièd`c`kXipZfek\okjXe[Xccfnè^k_\cXɝ\ikfjlg\ij\[\èfk_\ij%K_\m\k\iXejÆ

jkfi`\jj_fn\[k_Xkjfc[`\ijdXp`ek\igi\kk_\ZfdgXikd\ekXc`qXk`fek_\p\dgcfp#f]n_`Z_

k_\pXi\fɘ\eXnXi\#Xjk_\e\Z\jjXipYli[\ei\hl`i\[Ypk_\`igif]\jj`fe#n_`Z_Xccfn\[

k_\dkf`ek\igi\kjfc[`\i`e^XjdfiXccpi`^_kefkin spitef]k_\]XZkk_Xkk_\pXi\Z`m`c`Xejkff#

but because f]`k%

J`dgc`ÏZXk`fe Xe[ ZfdgXikd\ekXc`qXk`fe Xgg\Xi\[ `e m`iklXccp Xcc m\k\iXejÆ jkfi`\j#

[`jki\jj\[ fi efk% P\k# k_\ jkfi`\j j_fn\[ k_Xk k_\j\ jkiXk\^`\j ZXe ]X`c% @e :_Xgk\i -# @

\oXdè\[ k_\ jg\Z`ÏZ dfiXc [`d\ej`fe f] dfiXc [`jki\jj# _feè^ è fe k_\ jkfi`\j f]

m\k\iXej n_f i\gfik\[ dfiXc [`jki\jj% @e \oXd`e`e^ k_`j [`d\ej`fe# `k Y\ZXd\ \m`[\ek

k_Xk k_\ dfiXc Zfdgc\o`kp f] gXik`ZlcXi hlXe[Xi`\j ZXeefk XcnXpj Y\ j`dgc`Ï\[ Xe[ k_Xk

gXik`ZlcXiXZk`fejZXeefkXcnXpjY\le\hl`mfZXccpaljk`Ï\[fi\oZlj\[%K_\j\XZk`fejn\i\

Zfe[\de\[%P\k#aljkXjm\k\iXejn\i\leXYc\kfle\hl`mfZXccpaljk`]pfi\oZlj\k_\j\XZk`fej#

170

Part 3 Conclusions: Theoretical and Practical ImplicationsChapter 9 Conclusions: Theoretical Implications

k_\pljlXccpZflc[efkle\hl`mfZXccpZfe[\dek_\d%N_\ek_\`ek\im`\n\[m\k\iXeji\cXk\[

dfiXccp [`jki\jjè^ \og\i`\eZ\j# k_\ì jkfi`\j jgfb\ f] mXcl\ ZfeÐ`Zkj è n_`Z_ X[_\iè^

kffe\mXcl\è\m`kXYcpd\Xejm`fcXkè^Xefk_\i#f]dfiXc[\kXZ_d\eki\jlckè^]ifdk_\

fm\in_\cd`e^ j`^e`ÏZXeZ\ f] X j`klXk`fe# Xe[ f] j\ej\c\jje\jj% K_\j\ j`klXk`fej [`[ efk

èmfcm\jkiX`^_k]finXi[dfiXckiXejî\jj`fejk_\]fZljf]Zlii\ekjkl[`\jfeÅdfiXcèalipÆ #

Xe[k_lj[fefkXccfnZc\Xi$Zlk`ek\igi\kXk`fejn_`Z_jfc[`\ijk\e[kf\dgcfp %N_`c\dXep

m\k\iXej YcXd\[ k_\dj\cm\j fi fk_\ij ]fi k_\j\ j`klXk`fej# k_\p fɘ\e ]\ck leZ\ikX`ekp

Xe[ ZfeÐ`Zk n`k_ i\jg\Zk kf al[^d\ekj% K_Xk `j# Y\j`[\j ^l`ck# j_Xd\ Xe[ Xe^\i# dfiXccp

[`jki\jj`e^\m\ekjfɘ\e\e^\e[\i\[Xgif]fle[j\ej\f]dfiXc[`jfi`\ekXk`fe%DXepm\k\iXej

dXbè^ Xe[ ]iXdè^ jliifle[è^ d`c`kXip d`jj`fej Zfeki`Ylk\j kf k_\ \d\i^\eZ\ f]

gXik`ZlcXidfiXccp[`jki\jjè^\og\i`\eZ\j]fijfc[`\ijÅfek_\îfle[Æ#Yfk_[liè^Xe[Xɘ\i

[\gcfpd\ek%N_`c\m`iklXccpXcck_\`ek\im`\n\[m\k\iXejjgfb\XYflk_fngfc`k`ZXcgiXZk`Z\j

_X[X[m\ij\cpXɕ\Zk\[k_\ì[\gcfpd\ek#`knXjk_\m\k\iXejn_fi\cXk\[]XZè^[`jkliYè^

j`klXk`fej [l\ kf gfc`k`ZXc giXZk`Z\j n_f jgfb\ XYflk _fn gfc`k`ZXc ]X`cli\j _X[ niXgg\[

k_\ì d`jj`fe è gXè% I\dXibXYcp# Xck_fl^_ k_\ ;lkZ_YXk d`jj`fe nXj X g\XZ\ d`jj`fe

n_`c\K=LÆjd`jj`fenXjXZflek\ièjli^\eZpd`jj`feèmfcmè^ZfdYXk#ZfdgXiè^k_\ì

j`d`cXilei\jfcm\[ZfeÐ`Zkj#èZcl[è^[`jZi\gXeZ`\jèk_\n_pfm\iXiZ_è^gligfj\ #n_Xk

fYa\Zk`m\j Xe[_fni\jfliZ\jXe[gfjj`Y`c`k`\j f]k_\d`jj`fe#XdY`^l`kpi\^Xi[`e^k_\

n_p#n_XkXe[_fnf]k_\d`jj`fe#[`jZi\gXeZ`\jY\kn\\ejfc[`\ijÆfg\iXk`feXc\og\i`\eZ\

Xe[ gfc`k`ZXc eXiiXk`m\j# Xe[ cXZb f] gfc`k`ZXc XZbefnc\[^d\ek f] jlZ_ `jjl\j Xe[ k_lj

f] k_\ ifc\ f] gfc`k`ZXc giXZk`Z\j `e [`jki\jj`e^ \og\i`\eZ\j% 8j Y\ZXd\ \m`[\ek# gfc`k`ZXc

Zfdgifd`j\j[fefkXcnXpjd\Xek_XkgifYc\djXi\jfcm\[%Fek_\ZfekiXip#iXk_\ik_Xe

=èXccp# è :_Xgk\i /# @ \oXdè\[ k_\ ifc\ f] glYc`Z g\iZ\gk`fej f] d`c`kXip d`jj`fej

Xe[k_\d`c`kXip`e^\e\iXc`e\og\i`\eZ\jf]dfiXc[`jki\jj%;lkZ_YXkm\k\iXej]XZ\[_Xij_

Zi`k`Z`jd#n_`c\k_\K=Ld`jj`fe\mfb\[Yfk_e\^Xk`m\Xe[gfj`k`m\i\XZk`fej%;\jg`k\k_\

[`ɕ\i\ekglYc`Zi\jgfej\j#k_\knf^iflgj_X[jki`b`e^gXiXcc\cj#XjnXjk_\ZXj\n`k_i\jg\Zk

171

Chapter 9 Conclusions: Theoretical ImplicationsPart 3 Conclusions: Theoretical and Practical Implications

kfgfc`k`ZXcgiXZk`Z\j%N_`c\k_\;lkZ_YXkm\k\iXej`ek\im`\n\[^\e\iXccpi\gfik\[Xjkife^\i

j\ej\f]]iljkiXk`feXYflk;lkZ_glYc`Zg\iZ\gk`fejk_Xek_\K=Lm\k\iXej[`[#Yfk_^iflgj

jgfb\f]Xe^\i#j`c\eZ\#[`jfi`\ekXk`feXe[\jkiXe^\d\ek`ei\cXk`fekfk_\;lkZ_glYc`Z%Dp

Ïe[`e^jj_fn\[k_Xkm\k\iXejg\iZ\`m\[Yfk_glYc`ZZi`k`Z`jdXe[X[d`iXk`feXjj`dgc`jk`Z

[`jkfik`fejk_Xk[`[èaljk`Z\kfk_\ì[\gcfpd\ek\og\i`\eZ\%K_\î\Xk\ik_\[`jki\jjn`k_

n_`Z_m\k\iXejjkil^^c\[[l\kfk_\`i[\gcfpd\ek\og\i`\eZ\j#k_\dfi\k_\pn\i\ljlXccp

Xɕ\Zk\[YpglYc`Zg\iZ\gk`fej%N_`c\k_\ì\og\i`\eZ\dXpègXikY\\ogcXè\[èk\idjf]

d`j^l`[\[]\XijXe[al[^d\ekjfek_\`igXik#`kXcjfklie\[flkk_Xk`eYfk_d`jj`fejglYc`Z

eXiiXk`m\j [`[ `e[\\[ Zfem\p iXk_\i fe\$[`d\ej`feXc `dX^\j f] g\ig\kiXkfi Xe[ m`Zk`d#

efidXcXe[XYefidXc#Xe[^ff[Xe[\m`c#n_`Z_jkff[`ejkXibZfekiXjkkfm\k\iXejÆg\ijfeXc

\og\i`\eZ\%DXepm\k\iXej\og\i`\eZ\[k_`jfe\$[`d\ej`feXc`kpXjjfZ`\kXcd`ji\Zf^e`k`fe

f]k_\`i[\gcfpd\ek\og\i`\eZ\j#n_`Z_gXik`ZlcXicpXɕ\Zk\[k_\m\k\iXejjkil^^c`e^n`k_

k_\`i\og\i`\eZ\j#c\X[`e^kfXj\ej\f]\jkiXe^\d\ekXdfe^k_\d%@e]XZk#k_`j\og\i`\eZ\

f]jfZ`\kXcd`ji\Zf^e`k`fefɘ\e\e^\e[\i\[efkfecpXj\ej\f]\jkiXe^\d\ek]ifdjfZ`\kp#

YlkXcjf]ifdk_\dj\cm\j%

FYɕb]b[h\Y7cbWYdhcZAcfU`=b^ifm

;iXnè^dpi\j\XiZ_Ïe[è^jkf^\k_\iXe[alokXgfjè^k_\dn`k_k_\Zlii\ekZfeZ\gkf]

dfiXcèalip#k_\]fccfnè^ZfeZclj`fej\d\i^\j\\KXYc\+ %@ecè\n`k_k_\Zlii\ekZfeZ\gk

(Litz et al%)''0#)'(,#EXj_Xe[C`kq)'(* #dpÏe[è^jè[`ZXk\k_Xkk_\]\\cè^jf]^l`ck#j_Xd\

Xe[Xe^\in`k_n_`Z_m\k\iXejdXpjkil^^c\i\hl`i\XeXggifXZ_k_XkkXb\jk_\j\]\\c`e^j

j\i`fljcp%M\k\iXejÆdfiXc\dfk`fejXe[al[^d\ekjZXeefkj`dgcpY\cldg\[kf^\k_\ile[\i

k_\ldYi\ccXf]jlYa\Zk`m\\og\i`\eZ\#`]fecpY\ZXlj\k_\pdXpe\\[[`ɕ\i\eki\jgfej\j%K_\

m\k\iXen_fYcXd\j_`dj\c]]fi_Xm`e^jlim`m\[XeXɝXZbn_`c\_`jZfcc\X^l\[`\[d`^_kY\

_\cg\[dfjkYp_Xm`e^_`jk_fl^_kjZ_Xcc\e^\[Xe[_`j]\\c`e^jf]^l`ckXcc\m`Xk\[#n_\i\Xj

k_\m\k\iXen_f]\\cj^l`ck]fi_Xmè^XZk`m\cp_likfk_\ig\fgc\dXpèjk\X[Ïe[d\Xeè^

dfjk`e_Xm`e^_`jj\ej\f]XZZflekXY`c`kpZfeÏid\[Xe[j\c]$]fi^`m\e\jj%@efk_\infi[j#

m\k\iXejÆ dfiXc [`jki\jj j_flc[efk Y\ i\X[`cp \ogcX`e\[XnXp Xj d`j^l`[\[#Ylk i\hl`i\j

Zfej`[\iè^k_\ìdfiXcal[^d\ekjXe[\dfk`fejXjgfjj`YcpXggifgi`Xk\%K_`j`jècè\n`k_

k_\Zlii\ekdfiXc`ealipZfeZ\gk%

172

Part 3 Conclusions: Theoretical and Practical ImplicationsChapter 9 Conclusions: Theoretical Implications

KXYc\+1K_\:lii\ekXe[XI\Ïe\[:feZ\gklXc`qXk`fef]ÅDfiXc@ealipÆ

Current

concept FYɕbYX7cbWYdh

Individual level

Political context

Societal Context Moral

beliefs

Coherent

system Complex constellation with potentially competing beliefs Morally

injurious event(s)

Moral transgression

and/or Perceived moral failure

Perceived political violations of trust and dependency

Perceived societal misrecognition

Moral injury Blame of self UbX#cfch\Yfg Self-handicapping behaviors, self-injury

and/or Ethical struggle

Seeking political reparation

Seeking societal recognition

Factors

° The event

° Belief in the self and world as good and meaningful

and /or

° Belief in the self and world as logical, coherent and fair

AcfYgdYW]ɕWVY`]YZg e.g. ‘can-do’

° Discrepancies between the why, k\UhUbX#cf\ckcZh\Ya]gg]cb

° Ambiguity regarding the why, what UbX#cf\ckcZh\Ya]gg]cb

° Discrepancies between political narratives and operational reality

° Lack of political acknowledgment of aforementioned issues

° Black-and-white narratives

dYfdYhfUhcf/

dfiXc i\hl`i\d\ekj Yp d\Xej f] jkiXk\^`\j f] j`dgc`ÏZXk`fe Xe[ ZfdgXikd\ekXc`qXk`fe#

k_\j\jkiXk\^`\jdXp]X`c`ek_\ZXj\f]dfi\j\m\i\ZfeÐ`Zkj#n`k_gXik`ZlcXi`dgc`ZXk`fej%

DpÏe[è^j[\dfejkiXk\[k_XkÅdfiXccpèali`fljÆj`klXk`fejdXpèmfcm\dfi\XdY`^lflj

Xe[ XdY`mXc\ek \og\i`\eZ\j k_Xe le\hl`mfZXc kiXej^i\jj`fe# n_`Z_# dfi\fm\i# dXp _Xm\

`dgfikXekjfZ`fgfc`k`ZXcXjg\Zkj%@fɘ\e]fle[k_Xkm\k\iXejgXiX[fo`ZXccp]\\cYfk_^l`ckp

Xe[efe$^l`ckp#Yfk_i\jgfej`Yc\]fik_\`ifneXZkjXe[Y\kiXp\[Ypk_\gfc`k`ZXcc\X[\ij_`g#

Yfk_ d`ji\Zf^e`q\[ Yp jfZ`\kXc j`dgc`ÏZXk`fej Xe[ i`^_kcp al[^\[ Yp jfZ`\kp ]fi k_\`i

XZk`fej%=le[Xd\ekXccp#k_\pdXp]\\ck_\p]X`c\[dfiXccpYlkXkk_\jXd\k`d\[\m\cfgk_\

@ecè\n`k_k_`jdfiXcZfdgc\o`kp#dpÏe[è^jj_fn\[k_XkdfiXc[`jki\jjdXpèmfcm\dfi\

JlZ_ \og\i`\eZ\j dXp gifmfb\ X mXi`\kp f] Y\_Xm`fiXc i\jgfej\j% 8j `e[`ZXk\[ `e

\o`jkèî\j\XiZ_fedfiXcèalip#k_`jèZcl[\jj\c]$_Xe[`ZXggè^Xe[j\c]$èalipY\_Xm`fi

=iXeb]likXe[=iXq`\i)'(- %8[[`k`feXccp#dpi\j\XiZ_j_fn\[k_Xkm\k\iXejdXp\e^X^\`e

Xe\k_`ZXcjkil^^c\n`k_gi\m`fljdfiXc\og\ZkXk`fejXe[Y\c`\]j%8e[k_\pdXpj\\bgfc`k`ZXc

i\gXiXk`fe#[\dXe[`e^gfc`k`ZXcXd\e[jXe[ÏeXeZ`XcfijpdYfc`ZZfdg\ejXk`fe%=lik_\i#

k_\pdXpj\\bjfZ`\kXci\Zf^e`k`fe#jg\Z`ÏZXccpjfZ`\kXcaljk`Z\]fik_\`i\og\i`\eZ\j%

I\^Xi[`e^kpg\jf]gfk\ek`XccpdfiXccp[`jki\jj`e^\m\ekj#k_\Zlii\ekZfeZ\gkf]dfiXc

`ealip XZbefnc\[^\j k_Xk efk aljk XZkj f] Zfdd`jj`fe \%^% b`cc`e^ Ylk XZkj f] fd`jj`fe

]X`c`e^ kf gi\m\ek _ldXe jlɕ\i`e^ dXp Xcjf \e^\e[\i dfiXc [`jki\jj% E\m\ik_\c\jj# k_\

c`k\iXkli\ fe dfiXc `ealip ]fZlj\j Xcdfjk \oZclj`m\cp fe Zfem\ek`feXc nXi Xe[ ZfdYXk

j`klXk`fej#gXik`ZlcXicpk_\`dgXZkf]b`ccè^j\\\%^%9`ZX(000#C`kqet al%)''0#;i\jZ_\iet al%)'((#9ifZbXe[C\ɝè`)'() %@ek_\knfd`jj`fej@\oXdè\[#_fn\m\i#Yp]Xik_\dfjk

i\gfik\[[`jki\jjè^\og\i`\eZ\nXjefkXZk`m\èÐ`Zk`fef]_Xid#Ylkinability to act in the ]XZ\f]_ldXejlɕ\iè^%K_\gfk\ek`Xcf]efe$XZk`feY\è^dfiXccp[`jki\jjè^#k_lj#j_flc[

XcjfY\kXb\e`ekfXZZflek%

N`k_i\jg\Zkkf]XZkfijfk_\ik_Xek_\\m\ek#k_\Zlii\ekZfeZ\gkf]dfiXc`ealipgf`ekj

kfk_\YXj`Z_ldXeXjjldgk`fek_Xkk_\j\c]Xe[k_\nfic[Xi\^ff[Xe[d\Xeè^]lcC`kqet al%)''0#EXj_Xe[C`kq)'(* %DpÏe[è^jè[`ZXk\[k_XkY\c`\]jXYflkk_\j\c]Xe[k_\nfic[

Xjcf^`ZXc#Zf_\i\ekXe[]X`idXpXcjfgcXpXe`dgfikXekifc\`edfiXc[`jki\jj#gfk\ek`Xccp

\e^\e[\i`e^gif]fle[dfiXc[`jfi`\ekXk`fen_\em\k\iXejXi\Zfe]ifek\[Yp\m\ekjk_Xk

k\jk`]pk_Xkk_\j\c]Xe[k_\nfic[Xi\lɝ\icp`ccf^`ZXc#`eZf_\i\ekXe[le]X`i%K_\jXd\^f\j

]fifk_\iY\c`\]j#jlZ_Xjk_\d`c`kXipÅZXe$[fÆXɝ`kl[\n_`Z_Zfej`[\ij[flYkj#ZfeÐ`ZkXe[

leZ\ikX`ekpYX[k_`e^j%

9\j`[\j g\ijfeXc Y\c`\]j# dp i\j\XiZ_ `e[`ZXk\[# Zfek\oklXc ]XZkfij jlZ_ Xj gfc`k`ZXc

giXZk`Z\j Xe[ glYc`Z g\iZ\gk`fej fɘ\e gcXp Xe `dgfikXek ifc\ `e dfiXc [`jki\jj% N_`c\

@ [\jZi`Y\[ m\k\iXejÆ \og\i`\eZ\ `e k\idj f] perceived gfc`k`ZXc Y\kiXpXc Xe[ jfZ`\kXc

d`ji\Zfê`k`fe# @ Xcjf dXèkXè k_Xk k_\j\ k_\d\j Xi\ dfi\ k_Xe X dXɝ\i f] jlYa\Zk`m\

\og\i`\eZ\%K_`j`jècè\n`k_\g`jk\dfcf^`ZXc]fle[Xk`fejf]k_`jjkl[p#n_`Z_èmfcm\Xe

XggifXZ_kf_ldXe\og\i`\eZ\èk\idjf]d\Xeè^$dXbè^gifZ\jj\jn_`c\Xggi\Z`Xkè^

k_Xkg\fgc\Æj\og\i`\eZ\jXi\efkaljk`ekiX$gjpZ_`ZgifZ\jj\jYlkXcjf`e]fid\[YpZfek\oklXc

]XZkfij%9l`c[è^fek_\j\ZilZ`Xcèj`^_kj#@XeXcpq\[m\k\iXejÆjkfi`\jèi\cXk`fekf\o`jkè^

174

Part 3 Conclusions: Theoretical and Practical ImplicationsChapter 9 Conclusions: Theoretical Implications

c`k\iXkli\fek_\;lkZ_YXkXe[K=Ld`jj`fej#Xe[k_`jc\[d\kfXi^l\k_XkaljkXjm\k\iXejÆ

in which competing political and public perspectives and interests surrounding a mission are [\Xckn`k_Xi\i\c\mXek%=fi`ejkXeZ\#`]i\jki`Zk`fejXi\`dgfj\[feXÅ^i\\e_\cd\kÆd`jj`fe

`ei\jgfej\kfgfc`k`ZXcXe[glYc`ZfYa\Zk`fej#XjnXjk_\ZXj\`ek_\K=Ld`jj`fe#jfc[`\ijZXe

]\\c_\cgc\jj`ek_\jXd\nXpk_XkÅYcl\_\cd\kÆg\XZ\b\\g\ijZXe]\\c%K_\fk_\inXpXifle[#`]

jfc[`\ijXi\Xjb\[kflj\ifYljk]fiZ\`eXd`jj`fek_Xk`jjlggfj\[kfZ\ek\ife_ldXe`kXi`Xe

XZkj# k_\p dXp Zfd\ kf i\î\k k_\ì XZk`fej è i\kifjg\Zk% >\e\iXccp# [`jZi\gXeZ`\j Xe[

XdY`^l`k`\j`ek_\n_p#n_XkXe[_fnf]Xd`jj`fe#Xe[cXZbf]gfc`k`ZXcXZbefnc\[^d\ekf]

jlZ_[`jZi\gXeZ`\jXe[XdY`^l`k`\jj\\dkfèZi\Xj\k_\i`jbf]jfc[`\ij[\m\cfgè^]\\cè^jf]

^l`ck#j_Xd\#dfiXc[`jfi`\ekXk`feXe[Y\kiXpXc%Kf[XpÆjd`c`kXip`ek\im\ek`fejfɘ\e`emfcm\

dXep gXik`\j Y\j`[\j k_\ eXk`feXc ^fm\ied\ek# èZcl[è^ èk\ieXk`feXc XZkfij# gXic`Xd\ek

Xe[k_\glYc`Z#i\jlckè^èZfeÐ`ZkjXe[Zfdgifd`j\j%:fej\hl\ekcp#dpÏe[è^jjl^^\jk#

dXepgi\j\ek$[Xpd`jj`fejXi\c`b\cpkf_Xm\dfiXc[`jki\jj$`e[lZ`e^gifYc\djf][`jZi\gXeZp#

XdY`^l`kpXe[cXZbf]gfc`k`ZXcXZbefnc\[^d\ek%

@eX[[`k`fekfgfc`k`ZXcgiXZk`Z\j#jfZ`\kXcg\iZ\gk`fejdXpgcXpXifc\`edfiXc[`jki\jj%

N_`c\ `k dXp Zfd\ Xj ef jligi`j\ k_Xk glYc`Z Zi`k`Z`jd ZXe X[m\ij\cp Xɕ\Zk m\k\iXej# dp

Ïe[`e^j j_fn\[ k_Xk fm\icp jpdgXk_\k`Z i\gi\j\ekXk`fej# kff# ZXe Zfeki`Ylk\ kf k_\

\d\i^\eZ\fig\ij`jk\eZ\f]dfiXc[`jki\jj#Y\ZXlj\k_\pkliem\k\iXej`ekfXZXi`ZXkli\%

AcfU`=b^ifmUgUAUb]ZYghUh]cbcZ@UhYbhHYbg]cbg

8ck_fl^_k_`jjkl[p]fZlj\[feg\ijfeXcjlɕ\iè^#`k`jXcjfèj`^_k]lcèXdfi\^\e\iXc

j\ej\% 8j X jkl[p f] d\ekXc ÅYi\Xb[fnejÆ# `k efk fecp j_\[ c`^_k fe k_\ Yi\Xb[fnej

k_\dj\cm\j#YlkXcjfdX[\dXe`]\jkle[\icp`e^jkilZkliXck\ej`fejXe[mlce\iXY`c`k`\jk_Xk

efidXccpi\dX`e_`[[\e%Kf[iXnfe=i\l[ÆjZipjkXcd\kXg_fi#ÅR`T]XZipjkXc`jk_ifnekfk_\

îfle[#`kn`ccYi\Xbèkfg`\Z\j#efkèXiXe[fdnXp#YlkXZZfi[è^kfjg\Z`ÏZ]Xlck$cè\j

n_`Z_#Xck_fl^_k_\pXi\`em`j`Yc\#_Xm\Y\\egi\[\k\id`e\[Ypk_\jkilZkli\f]k_\ZipjkXcÆ

=i\l[Z`k\[è:fim\c\pe)''0#g%/. %9pèm\jk`^Xkè^k_\ZipjkXcg`\Z\jf]dfiXc[`jki\jj#

k_`jjkl[pfɕ\i\[èj`^_kèkfYfk_jfZ`fgfc`k`ZXc]Xlck$cè\jf]d`c`kXipgiXZk`Z\Xe[]Xlck$

c`e\jf]k_\_ldXegjpZ_\%K_Xk`j#`kdX[\dXe`]\jkdfiXck\ej`fejk_Xkd`c`kXipgiXZk`Z\

and its sociopolitical aspects poses to all jfc[`\ij#n_\k_\ifiefkk_\p[\m\cfg[`jki\jjXjX

i\jlckf]k_\j\k\ej`fej#Xe[fɕ\i\[`ej`^_k`ekfYXj`Zmlce\iXY`c`k`\jkfdfiXc[`jki\jjk_Xk

dfjkg\fgc\j\\dkf_Xm\`eZfddfe#n_\k_\ifiefkk_\pXi\jfc[`\ij%

Jg\Z`ÏZXccp# k_`j jkl[p `e[`ZXk\[ k_Xk d`c`kXip giXZk`Z\ Xcdfjk `e\m`kXYcp Zfd\j n`k_

tensions between being both a human agent and a political instrument, and both a civilian and Xjfc[`\i%8cjf#`kj_fn\[k_Xkjg\Z`ÏZgfc`k`ZXcgiXZk`Z\jXe[glYc`Zg\iZ\gk`fejdXpX^^iXmXk\

k_\j\k\ej`fej%:feÐ`Zkè^gfc`k`ZXcèk\i\jkjdXpi\jlckèZfdgifd`j\jk_XkgXjjk_\ZfeÐ`Zkj

kfk_\^ifle[c\m\c#Xe[glYc`Zj\ej`k`m`k`\jdXp\e^\e[\i[`jkfik`e^j`dgc`ÏZXk`fejf]jfc[`\ijÆ

Zfe[lZk`eXd`jj`fe%JlZ_j`dgc`ÏZXk`fej#`eklie#dXp\eZfliX^\k_\Zi\Xk`fef]gifYc\dXk`Z

gfc`k`ZXc Zfdgifd`j\j# Xe[ m`Z\ m\ijX% 8k k_\ jXd\ k`d\# k_\j\ gifZ\jj\j k\e[ kf ZfeZ\Xc

k_\dj\cm\j%Gfc`k`ZXcZfdgifd`j\jgXjjZfeÐ`Zkjkfcfn\ic\m\cj`eXnXpk_Xkj`dlckXe\fljcp

fYjZli\j k_`j ]XZk# Xe[ jfZ`\kXc j`dgc`ÏZXk`fej Xk feZ\ [`jkfik jfc[`\ijÆ fne jkfi`\j Xe[

i\e[\i k_\d lei\Zf^e`qXYc\% :fej\hl\ekcp# k_\ ifc\ f] gfc`k`ZXc Zfdgifd`j\j Xe[ jfZ`\kXc

j`dgc`ÏZXk`fej è jfc[`\ijÆ n\cc$Y\è^ k\e[j kf jkXp flk f] k_\ g`Zkli\% 8k c\Xjk è gXik# k_`j

gifYc\d`jaljkXjè\m`kXYc\Xjk_\`jjl\f]jfc[`\ij_Xmè^kfèZfigfiXk\k_\dlck`gc\ifc\jf]

j\ej\ Xe[ _Xj X Z\ikX`e fi[\i Xe[ ]X`ie\jj kf `k# \m\e n_\e k_\p j`dlckXe\fljcp befn fe

Xefk_\ic\m\ck_Xkk_`j`jefkXcnXpjk_\ZXj\j\\Xcjf<n`e^(00'#AXefɕ$9lcdXe(00)#:f_\e

)''( % 8ck_fl^_ k_`j Y\c`\] j\\dj gXik`ZlcXicp jkife^ Xdfe^ jfc[`\ij# n_fd k_\ d`c`kXip

_XjkXl^_kkfi\cpfeXÅZXe$[fÆXɝ`kl[\#`k`jjfd\k_`e^k_Xkdfjkg\fgc\_Xm\`eZfddfe#

jfc[`\ijXe[Z`m`c`XejXc`b\%@edfjkg\fgc\Æjc`m\j#k_`jY\c`\]n`ccY\m`fcXk\[dXepk`d\j%@k

j\\dj jX]\ kf Xjjld\# k_\e# k_Xk jfd\ [\^i\\ f] dfiXc [`jfi`\ekXk`fe Xe[ dfiXc [`jki\jj#

iXk_\ik_XeXZfe[`k`fek_XkY\]XccjfecpXele]fikleXk\]\njfc[`\ij`jjfd\k_`e^k_XkdXep

g\fgc\ n`cc \og\i`\eZ\ `e k_\`i c`m\j% @e[\\[# Xj jl^^\jk\[ Y\]fi\# dfiXc [`jki\jj `j dfjk

XZZliXk\cpi\gi\j\ek\[efkXjXp\j&ef[`Z_fkfdpYlkXjXZfek`elldiXe^`e^]ifdi\cXk`m\cp

176

Part 3 Conclusions: Theoretical and Practical ImplicationsChapter 9 Conclusions: Theoretical Implications

d`c[#k\dgfiXip]\\c`e^jf]^l`ckXe[Xe^\ikfXgif]fle[cp[\jkilZk`m\jg`iXcf]e\^Xk`m\dfiXc

\dfk`fej%K_XkjX`[#dfiXc[`jki\jjXcjfZc\Xicp_XjX]le[Xd\ekXcXjg\Zk%@ek_\ZXj\f]\m\ip[Xp

dfiXc ZfeÐ`Zk# g\fgc\ n`cc fɘ\e jlZZ\jj]lccp lj\ j`dgc`ÏZXk`fej Xe[ aljk`ÏZXk`fej n`k_flk

\m\eY\`e^XnXi\f]`k%9lkdXafidfiXcZfeÐ`Zkj#`ejk\X[#dXpi\m\Xck_\lɝ\i`cclj`fef]jlZ_

Zfg`e^jkiXk\^`\jXe[^`m\i`j\kfdfiXc[`jki\jj%@efk_\infi[j#`kdXb\jX_l^\[`ɕ\i\eZ\

n_\k_\ik_\X]fi\d\ek`fe\[ZipjkXc`jjZiXkZ_\[Ylk`efe\g`\Z\#fi]iXZkli\[Y\pfe[i\gX`i%

In document Proefschrift 'Soldiers in conflict, moral injury, political practices and public perceptions. (pagina 169-177)