Political and Societal Dimensions

K_\ `ej`^_k k_Xk jfc[`\ij \dYf[p dlck`gc\ dfiXc Zfdd`kd\ekj Yi`e^j d\ kf X j\Zfe[

`ejlɖZ`\ekcpX[[i\jj\[`jjl\`ek_\Zlii\ekZfeZ\gkf]dfiXc`ealip1k_\gfk\ek`Xc ifc\f]

gfc`k`ZXcXe[jfZ`\kXc]XZkfij`edfiXc[`jki\jj%@ei\Z\ek[\ZX[\j#`k_XjY\Zfd\`eZi\Xj`e^cp

Zc\Xik_XkY\j`[\jk_\eXkli\f]nXiXe[`e[`m`[lXcjljZ\gk`Y`c`k`\jZfek\oklXc]XZkfijgcXpX

ZilZ`Xcifc\`ek_\fej\kf]nXi$i\cXk\[jlɕ\i`e^#\%^%9i\jcXlXe[;Xm`j(0/.#Jldd\iÏ\c[

2000, Perilla et al%)'')#;\Afe^)'',#Jk\`eet al%)''.#=`ec\p)'((#JlXi\q)'(* %8kk_\jXd\

k`d\# dfjk i\j\XiZ_ fe nXi$i\cXk\[ jlɕ\i`e^# Yfk_ `e k\idj f] GKJ; Xe[ dfiXc `ealip#

[\Zflgc\jk_\jlɕ\i`e^]ifd`kjn`[\iZfek\ok`Y`[ %

K_\ZfeZ\gkf]GKJ;`jg\ij`jk\ekcpZi`k`Z`q\[]fi]X`c`e^kfXɝ\e[kfZfek\ok%8jmXi`flj

jkl[`\j _Xm\ Xi^l\[# `k ]iXd\j nXi$i\cXk\[ jlɕ\i`e^ Xj X Zfe[`k`fe ZfekX`e\[ n`k_`e k_\

`e[`m`[lXc# k_lj ]X`c`e^ kf XZZflek ]fi `kj jfZ`\kXc Xe[ gfc`k`ZXc Zfek\ok \%^% Jldd\iÏ\c[

)'''#;Xj)''.#N`k_l`jXe[Dff`a)'('#=`ec\p)'((#?Xlkq`e^\iXe[JZXe[cpe)'(*#DXZC\`j_

)'(* %8jXd\[`ZXcZfeZ\gk`kk\e[jkf^`m\nXim`Zk`djk_\jkXkljf]gXk`\ekjBc\`edXeet al%(00.#Jldd\iÏ\c[)''(#N`k_l`j)'') %@ei\jgfej\#jkl[`\jfen_Xk`j[lYY\[ÅjfZ`Xc

jlɕ\i`e^Æ Bc\`edXeet al% (00.  _Xm\ \oXd`e\[_fn m`fc\eZ\ `j ^\e\iXk\[Xe[j_Xg\[Yp

gfc`k`ZXc#\Zfefd`ZXe[ZlckliXcjkilZkli\j#dfjkcp`eefe$N\jk\iej\ɝ`e^j#Xɝ\jk`e^kfk_\

dXepnXpj`en_`Z_jfZ`Xc]fiZ\jZXegif[lZ\_ldXejlɕ\i`e^\%^%Bc\`edXe\kXc%(00.#

Jldd\iÏ\c[)'''#;Xj)''.#B`\eqc\i)''/ %K_\j\jkl[`\jZ_Xcc\e^\k_\Y`fd\[`ZXcefk`fej

k_XkZ_XiXZk\i`q\jlɕ\i`e^XjXe`ekiX$`e[`m`[lXc[`j\Xj\%

8ck_fl^_dfjki\j\XiZ_feÅjfZ`Xcjlɕ\i`e^Æ]fZlj\jfeZ_Xcc\e^`e^Y`fd\[`ZXcefk`fejXj

N\jk\ieZfeZ\gk`fej9iXZb\eet al%(00,#Jldd\iÏ\c[)'''#B`\eqc\i)''/ #`k]fccfnjk_Xk`e

N\jk\iej\ɝ`e^j#kff#nXi$i\cXk\[jlɕ\i`e^dXpY\Zfej`[\i\[dfi\k_XeXe`ekiX$`e[`m`[lXc

[`j\Xj\%8ÅjfZ`Xcjlɕ\i`e^$c\ejÆj\\djgXik`ZlcXicp`dgfikXekn_\ekip`e^kfle[\ijkXe[

dfiXc[`d\ej`fejf][\gcfpd\ek$i\cXk\[[`jki\jj%8j[`jZljj\[XYfm\#`e[`m`[lXcj[\m\cfg

k_\`idfiXcY\c`\]jXe[]fidk_\`idfiXcal[^d\ekjefk`eXjfZ`XcmXZlldYlk`e`ek\iXZk`fe

n`k_]Xd`cp#]i`\e[j#Xe[]fidXcXe[`e]fidXc`ejk`klk`fej9Xe[liX(00( %Jg\Z`ÏZXccpn`k_

i\jg\ZkkfXjfc[`\iÆjZfe[lZk#hl\jk`fejf]i`^_kXe[nife^Xi\efkÅfne\[ÆYpk_\jfc[`\iYlk

\ogc`Z`kcp[\YXk\[Ypk_\jfc[`\iÆjjfZ`Xc\em`ifed\ek%@k`jXkk_\jfZ`\kXcXe[gfc`k`ZXcc\m\c

k_Xk[\YXk\jkXb\gcXZ\XYflk#]fi`ejkXeZ\#k_\c\^`k`dXZpf]d`c`kXipd`jj`fej%

>\e\iXccp# k_\ d`c`kXip [f\j efk fg\iXk\ `e `jfcXk`fe ]ifd gfc`k`Zj Xe[ jfZ`\kp# Ylk

Zfej`jkjf]Åg\fgc\n`k_XidjÆn_fXZk`ek_\eXd\f]Åg\fgc\n`k_flkXidjÆIlbXm`j_e`bfm

Xe[Gl^_)''-#g%(*( %K_`jd\Xejk_Xk`eZXj\f]d`c`kXipfg\iXk`fej#k_\d`c`kXip`j^iXek\[

\o\dgk`fej]ifdZ\ikX`ejkXe[Xi[jk_XkjfZ`\kp_fc[j]fi`kjZ`k`q\ej%N_`c\nXiXe[m`fc\eZ\

Xi\^\e\iXccpZfej`[\i\[`ddfiXcXe[Zi`d`eXc#`k`jXcjfdX`ekX`e\[k_XkÅb`cc`e^dXpY\

e\Z\jjXip kf jXm\ c`m\jÆ Xe[ k_Xk Åk_\ [\mXjkXk`fe f] nXi dXp Y\ i\hl`i\[ kf gi\m\ek k_\

[\jkilZk`fe f] [\\gcp _\c[ mXcl\jÆ N`cc`Xdj Xe[ :Xc[n\cc )''-# g% *'0 % 8e[ jf# d`c`kXip

XZk`fe`jZfej`[\i\[Åaljk`Ï\[_XidÆJ_l\)'',#g%.+* %P\k#k_`j`jfecpk_\ZXj\Y\ZXlj\`kj

aljk`ÏZXk`fe`jefkleZfe[`k`feXc%Fek_\ZfekiXip#k_\aljk`ÏZXk`fef]Xe`ek\im\ek`fei\jkj

fek_\Zfe[`k`fek_Xk`k`jjlYa\Zkkfilc\jXe[ZfejkiX`ekjDXZ=XicXe\)'')#B\ee\[p)''-#

9\ibfn`kq)'(* %

K_\ gfc`k`ZXc Xe[ glYc`Z [fdX`e k_lj gcXp Xe `dgfikXek ifc\ `e j_Xg`e^ jfc[`\ijÆ

[\gcfpd\ek%K_\j\[fdX`ej[\k\id`e\k_\Zfe[`k`fejle[\in_`Z_jfc[`\ij_Xm\kffg\iXk\#

39

Zi`k\i`Xk_XkXi\Zfej`[\i\[`dgfikXekj\\\%^%DXZ=XicXe\)'')#EXi`e\)'(- %8Y`[`e^kf

`ek\ieXk`feXcgi`eZ`gc\jXe[Zi`k\i`XeXiifnjk_\gfjj`Y`c`k`\jf]`ek\im\ek`feXe[j_Xg\jk_\

eXkli\f]Xd`jj`fe#YlkXjjlZ_k_\pXcjf\e_XeZ\k_\d`jj`feÆjc\^`k`dXZp%>fm\ied\ekj

dXp]fccfnjlZ_gi`eZ`gc\jXe[Zi`k\i`X]fij`eZ\i\i\XjfejÁkfi\XZ_Xi\XjfeXYc\Zfej\ejlj

Xe[ XY`[\ Yp dfiXc jkXe[Xi[j Á fi# Zfem\ij\cp# kf dXjb j\c]$Z\ek\i\[ dfk`m\j Xe[ YpgXjj

dfiXchl\jk`fejZ]%9\ibfn`kq)'(* %

8kk_\eXk`feXcc\m\c#[\Z`j`fe$dXb`e^i\^Xi[`e^d`c`kXip`ek\im\ek`fe`jfɘ\e[`i\Zkcp

`eÐl\eZ\[ Yp gXic`Xd\ekXip [\dXe[j Xe[ `e[`i\Zkcp Yp glYc`Z j\ej`k`m`k`\j Xe[ Xɝ`kl[\j

<m\ikjXe[@j\ie`X)''*#Bc\g)'((#>iXe[`X)'(,#;`d`ki`lXe[>iXX])'(- %<sup>5</sup> Parliamentarian [\dXe[jXe[glYc`Zfg`e`feljlXccp`eÐl\eZ\k_\[\Z`j`fekfZfeki`Ylk\eXk`feXckiffgjkf

Xd`c`kXipd`jj`fe#Xjn\ccXjk_\nXpj`en_`Z_k_`jZfeki`Ylk`fekXb\jj_Xg\#YpdXb`e^k_\

^fm\ied\ekX[[jf$ZXcc\[eXk`feXcZXm\Xkjc`d`kXk`fej ]fi`kjfnekiffgjkfk_\dXe[Xk\

f]k_\d`jj`fe%=fi`ejkXeZ\#glYc`Zj\ej`k`m`k`\jXe[i\jlckXekgXic`Xd\ekXi`Xe[\dXe[jZXe

c\X[X^fm\ied\ekkf]fZljk_\d`jj`fefe_ldXe`kXi`XeXZk`m`k`\jXe[i\jki`Zkk_\lj\f]]fiZ\

Xccfn\[Z]%9fieet al%)'('#g%)( %?fn\m\i#k_\^fm\ied\ekdXpXcjfXɝ\dgkkf^X`eglYc`Z

jlggfikYpkip`e^kfjnXpgXic`Xd\ekXipXe[glYc`Zfg`e`feXe[dfY`c`q\jlggfik%@kdXp]fi

k\iifi`jkÅk_\dÆ9_Xk`X)'',#:_XdY\ij)'() #Xe[Ypi_\kfi`ZfeeXk`feXcj\Zli`kp>fc[jk\`e

)'(' Xe[&fic`Y\iXk`feXe[Z`m`c`qXk`fe8Yl$Cl^_f[)'')#B\cce\i)''+ %JlZ_]iXd`e^dXp

`e`k`Xccpgifk\Zkjfc[`\ij]ifdnfiip`e^XYflkk_\`id`jj`fe#Ylkk_`jm\ipgifk\Zk`fedXpXcjf

c\X[k_\dkf[fk_`e^jk_\pd`^_kcXk\ii\^i\k#Xe[]fin_`Z_k_\pd`^_kY\Zfe[\de\[`e

k_\`i_fd\ZflekipC`ɘfe(0.*#J_Xp(00+#9`ZX(000#>lkdXeeXe[Clkq)''0#9fl[i\Xl

)'((#J_\idXe)'(( %=fi`ejkXeZ\#9flib\(000 #C`ɘfe(0.* #J_Xp(00+ Xe[K`Zb\)'', #

[\jZi`Y\k_\gif]fle[j_fZbLJjfc[`\ij\og\i`\eZ\[n_\ek_\M`\keXd\j\Å^ffbjÆk_\pn\i\

jlggfj\[kf_Xk\klie\[flkkfY\_ldXe#aljkc`b\k_\d%9`ZX(000 j`d`cXicpefk\jk_Xk

) H\Y]bɘiYbWYcZdUf`]UaYbh]gYgdYW]U``mghfcb[]bWcibhf]Ygk]h\ai`h]!dUfhmgmghYag`]_Yh\YBYh\Yf`UbXg k\]W\acfY

cəYbh\Ubbch\UjYWcU`]h]cb[cjYfbaYbhgUbXUdckYfZi`dUf`]UaYbh"5`h\ci[\aiW\`]_Ych\Yf[cjYfbaYbhg h\Y8ihW\

[cjYfbaYbh cɏW]U``m \c`Xg h\Y YlW`ig]jY dckYf hc XYd`cm hfccdg  dUf`]UaYbh YlYfhg Wcbg]XYfUV`Y ]bɘiYbWY cjYf h\Y

[cjYfbaYbhÄgXYW]g]cb!aU_]b[WZ"KU[bYf&$$* d"(-"K]h\fYgdYWhhcfYWYbha]gg]cbg h\Y8ihW\[cjYfbaYbh\UgU`kUmg

tried to gain a majority of parliamentary support for a mission. With respect to public opinion, it is true that political leaders cəYb Xc bch Wcad`YhY`m Zc``ck diV`]W XYaUbXg  g]bWY h\Ym U`gc k]g\ hc Zi`ɕ`` Wcaa]haYbhg WcbWYfb]b[ ]bhYfbUh]cbU`

cooperation. Yet, they are also unlikely to completely ignore the impact of public pressure or the threat of decreasing electoral support (Ringsmose and Børgesen 2001).

40

Part I GYɛ]b[h\YGhU[Y Chapter 2 Toward a Broader Theoretical Approach to Moral Distress

k_\j\jfc[`\ij]\ck[\\gcpZfe]lj\[n_\ek_\pjXnk_\Ådpk_Æf]k_\nXii`fiXjefYc\Xe[

_\if`ZZildYc\`enXi%Dfi\fm\i#J_\idXe)'(( [\jZi`Y\jk_\[\Z\gk`feLJjfc[`\ij]\ckfe

i\klie`e^]ifd@iXhXe[[`jZfm\i`e^k_Xkk_\`i^fm\ied\ekÆjZcX`djXYflk@iXhjkfZbg`c`e^

n\Xgfej f] dXjj [\jkilZk`fe n\i\ lekil\% <o$DXi`e\ 9fl[i\Xl )''/# )'((  jki\jj\j k_Xk

gfc`k`ZXc Xe[ c\^Xc aljk`ÏZXk`fej dXp \eZfliX^\ jfc[`\ij kf [f k_`e^j k_\p cXk\i ZXd\ kf

i\^i\k#gf`ek`e^kf_`jfnei\dfij\]fik_\_\Xmp_Xe[\[XZk`fej_\fi[\i\[`e@iXh%

K_\jkl[`\jZ`k\[XYfm\Xcc]fZljfenXiXe[ZfdYXkfg\iXk`fej%9lkn_XkXYflkfk_\i

kpg\jf]d`jj`fej6I\Z\ekp\Xij_Xm\dfjkcpj\\eg\XZ\d`jj`fej]fin_`Z_k_\eXk`feXcXe[

`ek\ieXk`feXcc\X[\ij_`g`dgfj\[k`^_ki\jki`Zk`fejfek_\lj\f]]fiZ\I`\km\c[)''0 %K_\

LEd`jj`fej`ek_\]fid\iPl^fjcXm`XXe[InXe[X`ek_\(00'jXi\n\cc$befne\oXdgc\jf]

jlZ_d`jj`fej#fiiXk_\if]k_\gfjj`Yc\[fnej`[\jf]jlZ_d`jj`fejMXe[\iD\lc\e(00/#

Bc\gXe[N`ejcfn(000 %K_\pj_fnk_Xkn_`c\i\jki`Zk`fejfek_\lj\f]]fiZ\dXpgifk\Zk

jfc[`\ij]ifd[f`e^k_`e^jk_\pd`^_ki\^i\kcXk\i#k_\pdXpXcjfi\e[\ijfc[`\ijgfn\ic\jj

n_\e Zfe]ifek\[ Yp j`klXk`fej k_Xk [f i\hl`i\ ]fiZ\% K_\ kiXldX c`k\iXkli\ [\jZi`Y\j k_\

gif]fle[gjpZ_fcf^`ZXc`dgXZkk_Xkgfn\ic\jje\jjdXp_Xm\?\idXe(0-.#)'(( %

@ej_fik#gfc`k`ZXcgiXZk`Z\Xe[glYc`Z[\YXk\j_Xg\k_\nXpj`en_`Z_jfc[`\ijXi\[\gcfp\[

Xe[_fnk_\pXi\g\iZ\`m\[Xk_fd\%N_`c\k_\Zlii\ekZfeZ\gkf]dfiXc`ealipb\\gjdfiXc

[`jki\jj\eZXgjlcXk\[Xkk_\c\m\cf]k_\`e[`m`[lXcjfc[`\i#k_\i\`jdlZ_i\Xjfekf\og\Zk

k_Xkgfc`k`ZXcgiXZk`Z\Xe[glYc`Z[\YXk\dXpgcXpXe\hlXccp`dgfikXekifc\`edfiXc[`jki\jj%

@k`jk_\i\]fi\nfik_\oXd`e`e^\oXZkcp_fngfc`k`ZXcXe[jfZ`\kXc`eÐl\eZ\jXɕ\Zkjfc[`\ijÆ

\og\i`\eZ\#Xe[gXik`ZlcXicpn_\k_\iXe[_fnk_\j\`eÐl\eZ\ji\cXk\kfdfiXc[`jki\jj%

@Y\^Xek_`jZ_Xgk\iYp[`jZljj`e^k_\gfk\ek`Xcf]k_\ZfeZ\gkf]dfiXc`ealip]fiZXgkli`e^

dfiXc [`d\ej`fej f] [\gcfpd\ek$i\cXk\[ [`jki\jj# p\k jlYj\hl\ekcp efk\[ k_\ Zlii\ek

ZfeZ\gkÆj]X`cli\kfX[[i\jjXe[`eZfigfiXk\k_\Zfdgc\o`kpf]dfiXc`kpXe[k_\ifc\f]n`[\i

jfZ`fgfc`k`ZXc Zfek\okj `e dfiXc [`jki\jj% K_\i\]fi\# @ Zfdgc`ZXk\[ k_\ ZfeZ\gk Yp X[[`e^

g_`cfjfg_`ZXcXe[jfZ`XcjZ`\ek`ÏZg\ijg\Zk`m\jfedfiXc`kpXe[k_\`dgXZkf]jfZ`fgfc`k`ZXc

]XZkfijfejfc[`\ijÆ\og\i`\eZ\%=`ijk#@\jkXYc`j_\[k_XkXjfc[`\iÆjdfiXcY\c`\]jZfejk`klk\

X Zfdgc\o Zfejk\ccXk`fe iXk_\i k_Xe fe\ Zf_\i\ek jpjk\d% J\Zfe[# @ Zfek\e[\[ k_Xk k_`j

Zfdgc\o`kp`ji\cXk\[kfk_\]XZkk_Xkjfc[`\ijXi\efk\ek`i\cpXlkfefdflj#Ylk\dY\[[\[`e

XjfZ`fgfc`k`ZXcZfek\ok%Jfc[`\ijXi\#f]Zflij\#`e[`m`[lXcj%P\k#k_\pXi\Xcjf`ejk`klk`feXc

`ejkild\ekj# Xe[ Z`m`c`Xej Xj n\cc% K_\j\ Zfek\ek`fej c\[ d\# Ïijk# kf gifgfj\ ]lik_\i

\oXd`eXk`fef]dfiXc[`d\ej`fejf][\gcfpd\ek$i\cXk\[jlɕ\i`e^#Xe[j\Zfe[#kfgifgfj\

YifX[\e`e^k_\i\j\XiZ_jZfg\kf\oXd`e\k_\ifc\f]gfc`k`ZXcgiXZk`Z\j`eZcl[`e^[\Z`j`fe$

dXb`e^ Xe[ d`jj`fe ]iXd`e^  Xe[ glYc`Z g\iZ\gk`fej `eZcl[`e^ glYc`Z [\dXe[j Xe[

Zi`k`Z`jdi\^Xi[`e^d`c`kXip`ek\im\ek`fej `edfiXc[`jki\jj%@[fjf`ek_\gi\j\ekjkl[pn`k_

k_\g\ijg\Zk`m\jXe[`ej`^_kj[`jZljj\[_\i\j\im`e^XjXk_\fi\k`ZXc]iXd\nfib#lck`dXk\cp

kfX[mXeZ\k_\ZfeZ\gkf]dfiXc`ealip%

4 1

Chapter 2 Toward a Broader Theoretical Approach to Moral Distress Part I GYɛ]b[h\YGhU[Y

3

43

In document Proefschrift 'Soldiers in conflict, moral injury, political practices and public perceptions. (pagina 38-43)