University of Groningen
Evidence-b(i)ased psychiatry
de Vries, Ymkje Anna
IMPORTANT NOTE: You are advised to consult the publisher's version (publisher's PDF) if you wish to cite from it. Please check the document version below.
Document Version
Publisher's PDF, also known as Version of record
Publication date: 2018
Link to publication in University of Groningen/UMCG research database
Citation for published version (APA):
de Vries, Y. A. (2018). Evidence-b(i)ased psychiatry. University of Groningen.
Copyright
Other than for strictly personal use, it is not permitted to download or to forward/distribute the text or part of it without the consent of the author(s) and/or copyright holder(s), unless the work is under an open content license (like Creative Commons).
Take-down policy
If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim.
Downloaded from the University of Groningen/UMCG research database (Pure): http://www.rug.nl/research/portal. For technical reasons the number of authors shown on this cover page is limited to 10 maximum.
*? Ti2` 8
*Bi iBQM /BbiQ`iBQMb BM i?2 HBi2` im`2
QM i?2 b2`QiQMBM@i` MbTQ`i2`@HBMF2/
TQHvKQ`T?BbK M/ Kv;/ H
+iBp iBQM
CQD MM2F2 X " biB Mb2M- uKFD2 MM /2 o`B2b- J `+mb _X JmM 7ǁ "BQHQ;B+ H Sbv+?B i`v UkyR8V- d3 U3V- 1j8 @ je
*? Ti2` 8
#bi` +i
a2H2+iBp2 +Bi iBQM K v +QMi`B#mi2 iQ i?2 T2`bBbi2M+2 Q7 bi`QM; #2HB27b BM `2b2 `+? }M/BM;b 7Q` r?B+? i?2 bi`2M;i? Q7 2pB/2M+2 Bb [m2biBQM #H2 Q` /2+HBMBM;X 6Q` i?2 HBi2` im`2 QM i?2 Tmi iBp2 bbQ+B iBQM #2ir22M i?2 b2`QiQMBM i` MbTQ`i2` TQHvKQ`T?BbK U8@>hhGS_V M/ Kv;/ H +iBp iBQM- /Bz2`2M+2b #2ir22M +Bi iBQM ` i2b 7Q` TQbBiBp2 M/ M2; iBp2 bim/@ B2b `2 Q#b+m`2/ #v H `;2 /Bz2`2M+2b rBi?BM i?2 M2; iBp2 ;`QmT, r?2`2 b bim/B2b i? i +H BK iQ ? p2 7QmM/ M 2z2+i UBM bTBi2 Q7 M2; iBp2 }M/BM;b BM/B+ i2/ #v bi M/ `/Bx2/ K2i @ M HviB+ TT`Q +?V `2 +Bi2/ b Km+? b TQbBiBp2 bim/B2b- bim/B2b i? i M2Bi?2` `2TQ`i MQ` +H BK i?2 2tBbi2M+2 Q7 M 2z2+i UBX2X- dz`27mi iBQMǴ bim/B2bV `2 ivTB+ HHv Qp2`HQQF2/X JQ`2Qp2`- i?2 K DQ`Biv Q7 `2+2Mi bim/B2b B;MQ`2 i?2 K2i?Q/QHQ;B+ H Bbbm2b ` Bb2/ #v K2i @ M HvbBb M/ QMHv K2MiBQM i?2 T`2b2M+2 Q7 bB;MB}+ Mi K2i @ M HviB+ 2z2+iX _2@ b2 `+?2`b b?QmH/ 7Q+mb QM i?2 Mm M+2 M/ + p2 ib Q7 T`2pBQmb rQ`F BM i?2B` `iB+H2b M/ #2 2M+Qm` ;2/ iQ Tm#HBb? M/ +Bi2 `27mi iBQM bim/B2bX
dk
*Bi iBQM #B b BM i?2 8@>hhGS_ @ Kv;/ H +iBp iBQM HBi2` im`2
a?Q`i `2TQ`i
b2KBM H }M/BM; BM BK ;BM; ;2M2iB+b Bb i? i + ``B2`b Q7 i?2 b?Q`i UaV HH2H2 Q7 i?2 b2`QiQMBM@ i` MbTQ`i2`@HBMF2/ TQHvKQ`T?B+ `2;BQM U8@>hhGS_V 2t?B#Bi M BM+`2 b2/ Kv;/ H `2@ bTQMb2 iQ M2; iBp2 2KQiBQM H biBKmHB (kN8)X h?2 Q`B;BM H `iB+H2 #v > `B`B M/ +QHH2 ;m2b ? b #22M +Bi2/ Qp2` R-yyy iBK2b bBM+2 Bib Tm#HB+ iBQM BM kyykX
Hi?Qm;? K2i @ M Hvb2b ? p2 b?QrM bi iBbiB+ HHv bB;MB}+ Mi U#mi bK HHV 2z2+i +`Qbb Tm#HBb?2/ bim/B2b- i?2 p HB/Biv Q7 i?2b2 }M/BM;b Bb mM/2`KBM2/ #v i?2 T`2b2M+2 Q7 Tm#HB+ @ iBQM #B b (kNe- kNd)X JQ`2Qp2`- i?2 bi`2M;i? Q7 2pB/2M+2 ? b /2+HBM2/ Qp2` iBK2 (kN3- kNd)X >Qr2p2`- i?2 bi`2M;i? Q7 #2HB27 /Q2b MQi b22K iQ ? p2 /2+`2 b2/ +QKT ` #HvX 6Q` BMbi M+2- `2+2Mi `2pB2r KBMbi M+2- BMiBMbi M+2- BM2/ i?BMbi M+2- i mT iQ 8W Q7 /Bz2`2M+2b BM BMbi M+2- Kv;/BMbi M+2- HBMbi M+2- BMbi M+2- +iBpBMbi M+2- iBQM +BMbi M+2- M #2 2tTH BM2/ #v p `B iBQM BM i?2 8@>hhGS_ (kNN)X
PM2 7 +iQ` i? i K v +QMi`B#mi2 iQ i?2 T2`bBbi2M+2 Q7 #2HB27 BM M 2z2+i Bb T`272`2MiB H +Bi iBQM Q7 TQbBiBp2 bim/B2b (99)X 6Q` i?2 M2irQ`F Q7 bim/B2b `2TQ`i2/ BM i?2 KQbi `2+2Mi K2i @ M HvbBb QM 8@>hhGS_ M/ Kv;/ H +iBp iBQM (kNd)- +Bi iBQM /Bz2`2M+2b #2ir22M TQbBiBp2 UM 4 RyV M/ M2; iBp2 bim/B2b UM 4 R8V- Hi?Qm;? T`2b2Mi- `2 MQi p2`v T`QMQmM+2/X q?BH2 9yW Q7 bim/B2b `2 TQbBiBp2- i?2v `2+2Bp2 88W Q7 rBi?BM@M2irQ`F +Bi iBQMb M/ edW Q7 +Bi iBQMb pB q2# Q7 a+B2M+2 U9NW 2t+Hm/BM; > `B`B M/ +QHH2 ;m2b- kyyk (kN8)VX TQbBiBp2 bim/v Bb +Bi2/- QM p2` ;2- #v jNW Ua. 4 jkWV Q7 bm#b2[m2Mi bim/B2b BM i?2 M2irQ`F- M/ M2; iBp2 bim/B2b `2 +Bi2/ #v k8W Ua. 4 k9WVX AM q2# Q7 a+B2M+2- p2` ;2 v2 `Hv +Bi iBQM ` i2b 7Q` M2; iBp2 M/ TQbBiBp2 bim/B2b `2 RR Ua. 4 RRV M/ k9 Ua. 4 jkV iBK2b- `2bT2+iBp2Hv- rBi? i?2 H ii2` /2+HBMBM; iQ R8 Ua. 4 RdV iBK2b r?2M > `B`B M/ +QHH2 ;m2b UkyykV (kN8) Bb 2t+Hm/2/X
>Qr2p2`- +Bi iBQM ` i2b Q7 M2; iBp2 bim/B2b + M #2 +QM7QmM/2/ #v bim/B2b rBi? BM~ i2/ +H BKb Q` dzbTBMǴ BM i?2B` #bi` +ibX aTBM Bb i?2 UBMi2MiBQM H Q` mMBMi2MiBQM HV mb2 Q7 `2TQ`iBM; bi` i2;B2b iQ 2KT? bBx2 i?2 T`2b2M+2 Q7 M 2z2+i- 7Q` BMbi M+2 #v 7Q+mbBM; QM bi iBbiB+ HHv bB;MB}+ Mi }M/BM;b 7`QK bm#;`QmT M Hvb2b Q` b2+QM/ `v Qmi+QK2b (Rd3)X Ai r b T`2pBQmbHv b?QrM i? i K Mv Q7 i?2 bim/B2b BM Jm`T?v 2i HX UkyRjV (kNd) K F2 bi`QM;2` +H BKb BM i?2B` #bi` +ib i? M Bb r `` Mi2/ #v i?2 `2TQ`i2/ / i r?2M bi M@ / `/Bx2/ M HviB+ H TT`Q +? Bb 2KTHQv2/ (jyy)X 6B;m`2b 8XR M/ 8Xk BHHmbi` i2 i? i dz+H BKǴ bim/B2b Ĝ i? i Bb- M2; iBp2 bim/B2b i? i +H BK iQ ? p2 7QmM/ M 2z2+i- #mi 7Q` r?B+? bi M/ `/Bx2/ M HvbBb /Q2b MQi BM/B+ i2 bi iBbiB+ HHv bB;MB}+ M+2 2pB/2M+2 @ `2 +Bi2/ +QKT ` #Hv iQ TQbBiBp2 bim/B2bX
AM +QMi` bi- bim/B2b i? i M2Bi?2` `2TQ`i MQ` +H BK i?2 2tBbi2M+2 Q7 M 2z2+i UBX2X- dz`27mi @ iBQMǴ bim/B2bV `2 Qp2`HQQF2/X _27mi iBQM bim/B2b- 7Q` BMbi M+2- `2 +Bi2/ #v QMHv R9W Q7 bm#b2[m2Mi bim/B2b rBi?BM i?2 M2irQ`F U};m`2 8Xk- H27i T M2HV M/ i?2v `2+2Bp2 QMHv 9W Q7 +Bi iBQMb BM q2# Q7 a+B2M+2 U6B;m`2 8XR- `B;?i T M2HVX _27mi iBQM bim/B2b TT2 ` iQ 7 +2 /Qm#H2 /B{+mHiv BM +QMi`B#miBM; iQ M/ +? M;BM; i?2 +QKKQM T2`bT2+iBp2, MQi QMHv Bb Bi ? `/ iQ Tm#HBb? i?2K- #mi i?2v `2 HbQ +Bi2/ BM7`2[m2MiHv QM+2 Tm#HBb?2/X aim/B2b `2
5
#bi` +i
a2H2+iBp2 +Bi iBQM K v +QMi`B#mi2 iQ i?2 T2`bBbi2M+2 Q7 bi`QM; #2HB27b BM `2b2 `+? }M/BM;b 7Q` r?B+? i?2 bi`2M;i? Q7 2pB/2M+2 Bb [m2biBQM #H2 Q` /2+HBMBM;X 6Q` i?2 HBi2` im`2 QM i?2 Tmi iBp2 bbQ+B iBQM #2ir22M i?2 b2`QiQMBM i` MbTQ`i2` TQHvKQ`T?BbK U8@>hhGS_V M/ Kv;/ H +iBp iBQM- /Bz2`2M+2b #2ir22M +Bi iBQM ` i2b 7Q` TQbBiBp2 M/ M2; iBp2 bim/@ B2b `2 Q#b+m`2/ #v H `;2 /Bz2`2M+2b rBi?BM i?2 M2; iBp2 ;`QmT, r?2`2 b bim/B2b i? i +H BK iQ ? p2 7QmM/ M 2z2+i UBM bTBi2 Q7 M2; iBp2 }M/BM;b BM/B+ i2/ #v bi M/ `/Bx2/ K2i @ M HviB+ TT`Q +?V `2 +Bi2/ b Km+? b TQbBiBp2 bim/B2b- bim/B2b i? i M2Bi?2` `2TQ`i MQ` +H BK i?2 2tBbi2M+2 Q7 M 2z2+i UBX2X- dz`27mi iBQMǴ bim/B2bV `2 ivTB+ HHv Qp2`HQQF2/X JQ`2Qp2`- i?2 K DQ`Biv Q7 `2+2Mi bim/B2b B;MQ`2 i?2 K2i?Q/QHQ;B+ H Bbbm2b ` Bb2/ #v K2i @ M HvbBb M/ QMHv K2MiBQM i?2 T`2b2M+2 Q7 bB;MB}+ Mi K2i @ M HviB+ 2z2+iX _2@ b2 `+?2`b b?QmH/ 7Q+mb QM i?2 Mm M+2 M/ + p2 ib Q7 T`2pBQmb rQ`F BM i?2B` `iB+H2b M/ #2 2M+Qm` ;2/ iQ Tm#HBb? M/ +Bi2 `27mi iBQM bim/B2bX
a?Q`i `2TQ`i
b2KBM H }M/BM; BM BK ;BM; ;2M2iB+b Bb i? i + ``B2`b Q7 i?2 b?Q`i UaV HH2H2 Q7 i?2 b2`QiQMBM@ i` MbTQ`i2`@HBMF2/ TQHvKQ`T?B+ `2;BQM U8@>hhGS_V 2t?B#Bi M BM+`2 b2/ Kv;/ H `2@ bTQMb2 iQ M2; iBp2 2KQiBQM H biBKmHB (kN8)X h?2 Q`B;BM H `iB+H2 #v > `B`B M/ +QHH2 ;m2b ? b #22M +Bi2/ Qp2` R-yyy iBK2b bBM+2 Bib Tm#HB+ iBQM BM kyykX
Hi?Qm;? K2i @ M Hvb2b ? p2 b?QrM bi iBbiB+ HHv bB;MB}+ Mi U#mi bK HHV 2z2+i +`Qbb Tm#HBb?2/ bim/B2b- i?2 p HB/Biv Q7 i?2b2 }M/BM;b Bb mM/2`KBM2/ #v i?2 T`2b2M+2 Q7 Tm#HB+ @ iBQM #B b (kNe- kNd)X JQ`2Qp2`- i?2 bi`2M;i? Q7 2pB/2M+2 ? b /2+HBM2/ Qp2` iBK2 (kN3- kNd)X >Qr2p2`- i?2 bi`2M;i? Q7 #2HB27 /Q2b MQi b22K iQ ? p2 /2+`2 b2/ +QKT ` #HvX 6Q` BMbi M+2- `2+2Mi `2pB2r KBMbi M+2- BMiBMbi M+2- BM2/ i?BMbi M+2- i mT iQ 8W Q7 /Bz2`2M+2b BM BMbi M+2- Kv;/BMbi M+2- HBMbi M+2- BMbi M+2- +iBpBMbi M+2- iBQM +BMbi M+2- M #2 2tTH BM2/ #v p `B iBQM BM i?2 8@>hhGS_ (kNN)X
PM2 7 +iQ` i? i K v +QMi`B#mi2 iQ i?2 T2`bBbi2M+2 Q7 #2HB27 BM M 2z2+i Bb T`272`2MiB H +Bi iBQM Q7 TQbBiBp2 bim/B2b (99)X 6Q` i?2 M2irQ`F Q7 bim/B2b `2TQ`i2/ BM i?2 KQbi `2+2Mi K2i @ M HvbBb QM 8@>hhGS_ M/ Kv;/ H +iBp iBQM (kNd)- +Bi iBQM /Bz2`2M+2b #2ir22M TQbBiBp2 UM 4 RyV M/ M2; iBp2 bim/B2b UM 4 R8V- Hi?Qm;? T`2b2Mi- `2 MQi p2`v T`QMQmM+2/X q?BH2 9yW Q7 bim/B2b `2 TQbBiBp2- i?2v `2+2Bp2 88W Q7 rBi?BM@M2irQ`F +Bi iBQMb M/ edW Q7 +Bi iBQMb pB q2# Q7 a+B2M+2 U9NW 2t+Hm/BM; > `B`B M/ +QHH2 ;m2b- kyyk (kN8)VX TQbBiBp2 bim/v Bb +Bi2/- QM p2` ;2- #v jNW Ua. 4 jkWV Q7 bm#b2[m2Mi bim/B2b BM i?2 M2irQ`F- M/ M2; iBp2 bim/B2b `2 +Bi2/ #v k8W Ua. 4 k9WVX AM q2# Q7 a+B2M+2- p2` ;2 v2 `Hv +Bi iBQM ` i2b 7Q` M2; iBp2 M/ TQbBiBp2 bim/B2b `2 RR Ua. 4 RRV M/ k9 Ua. 4 jkV iBK2b- `2bT2+iBp2Hv- rBi? i?2 H ii2` /2+HBMBM; iQ R8 Ua. 4 RdV iBK2b r?2M > `B`B M/ +QHH2 ;m2b UkyykV (kN8) Bb 2t+Hm/2/X
>Qr2p2`- +Bi iBQM ` i2b Q7 M2; iBp2 bim/B2b + M #2 +QM7QmM/2/ #v bim/B2b rBi? BM~ i2/ +H BKb Q` dzbTBMǴ BM i?2B` #bi` +ibX aTBM Bb i?2 UBMi2MiBQM H Q` mMBMi2MiBQM HV mb2 Q7 `2TQ`iBM; bi` i2;B2b iQ 2KT? bBx2 i?2 T`2b2M+2 Q7 M 2z2+i- 7Q` BMbi M+2 #v 7Q+mbBM; QM bi iBbiB+ HHv bB;MB}+ Mi }M/BM;b 7`QK bm#;`QmT M Hvb2b Q` b2+QM/ `v Qmi+QK2b (Rd3)X Ai r b T`2pBQmbHv b?QrM i? i K Mv Q7 i?2 bim/B2b BM Jm`T?v 2i HX UkyRjV (kNd) K F2 bi`QM;2` +H BKb BM i?2B` #bi` +ib i? M Bb r `` Mi2/ #v i?2 `2TQ`i2/ / i r?2M bi M@ / `/Bx2/ M HviB+ H TT`Q +? Bb 2KTHQv2/ (jyy)X 6B;m`2b 8XR M/ 8Xk BHHmbi` i2 i? i dz+H BKǴ bim/B2b Ĝ i? i Bb- M2; iBp2 bim/B2b i? i +H BK iQ ? p2 7QmM/ M 2z2+i- #mi 7Q` r?B+? bi M/ `/Bx2/ M HvbBb /Q2b MQi BM/B+ i2 bi iBbiB+ HHv bB;MB}+ M+2 2pB/2M+2 @ `2 +Bi2/ +QKT ` #Hv iQ TQbBiBp2 bim/B2bX
AM +QMi` bi- bim/B2b i? i M2Bi?2` `2TQ`i MQ` +H BK i?2 2tBbi2M+2 Q7 M 2z2+i UBX2X- dz`27mi @ iBQMǴ bim/B2bV `2 Qp2`HQQF2/X _27mi iBQM bim/B2b- 7Q` BMbi M+2- `2 +Bi2/ #v QMHv R9W Q7 bm#b2[m2Mi bim/B2b rBi?BM i?2 M2irQ`F U};m`2 8Xk- H27i T M2HV M/ i?2v `2+2Bp2 QMHv 9W Q7 +Bi iBQMb BM q2# Q7 a+B2M+2 U6B;m`2 8XR- `B;?i T M2HVX _27mi iBQM bim/B2b TT2 ` iQ 7 +2 /Qm#H2 /B{+mHiv BM +QMi`B#miBM; iQ M/ +? M;BM; i?2 +QKKQM T2`bT2+iBp2, MQi QMHv Bb Bi ? `/ iQ Tm#HBb? i?2K- #mi i?2v `2 HbQ +Bi2/ BM7`2[m2MiHv QM+2 Tm#HBb?2/X aim/B2b `2
*? Ti2` 8
`2r `/2/ 7Q` K FBM; TQbBiBp2 +H BKb #v ?B;?2` +Bi iBQM ` i2b- `2bmHiBM; BM HBi2` im`2 i? i T`2b2Mib /BbiQ`i2/ BKT`2bbBQM Q7 i?2 bi`2M;i? Q7 2pB/2M+2X
Within−network Web of Science
Studies Citations Studies Citations 0 25 50 75 100 Percentage Refutation Claim Positive
6B;m`2 8XR, S2`+2Mi ;2 Q7 bim/B2b Q7 2 +? ivT2 UTQbBiBp2- +H BK- M/ `27mi iBQMV M/ i?2
T2`+2Mi ;2 Q7 +Bi iBQMb `2+2Bp2/ #v 2 +? ivT2 Q7 bim/v 7Q` rBi?BM@M2irQ`F +Bi iBQMb M/ q2# Q7 a+B2M+2 +Bi iBQMbX 6Q` rBi?BM@M2irQ`F +Bi iBQMb- i?2 }M H bim/v rBi?BM i?2 M2irQ`F r b MQi BM+Hm/2/ BM i?2 MmK#2` Q7 bim/B2b- b Bi +QmH/ MQi ? p2 #22M +Bi2/ rBi?BM i?2 M2irQ`FX
1z2+i 2biBK i2b #v K2i @ M Hvb2b `2 MQi z2+i2/ #v bTBM M/ Q7i2M brB7iHv #2+QK2 i?2 M2r bi M/ `/ BM i?2 }2H/X Hi?Qm;? K2i @ M Hvb2b + M TQi2MiB HHv Qp2``B/2 i?2 2z2+ib Q7 +Bi iBQM /BbiQ`iBQM- i?2v + M HbQ H2 / iQ 7m`i?2` /BbiQ`iBQM r?2M BKTQ`i Mi Bbbm2b i?2v ` Bb2 `2 M2;H2+i2/X hrQ BM/2T2M/2Mi ` i2`b +Q/2/ r?2i?2` i?2 jd T22`@`2pB2r2/ 1M;HBb?@ H M;m ;2 `iB+H2b +BiBM; Jm`T?v 2i HX (kNd) UbQm`+2, :QQ;H2 a+?QH `- LQp2K#2` kyR9V `272``2/ iQ i?2b2 mi?Q`bǶ +QM+2`Mb #Qmi Bbbm2b Q7 bi iBbiB+ H TQr2` M/ Tm#HB+ iBQM #B b-Q` QMHv K2MiBQM2/ i?2 T`2b2M+2 Q7 bi iBbiB+ HHv bB;MB}+ Mi 2z2+iX
h?`22 K2i?Q/QHQ;B+ H `iB+H2b /B/ MQi //`2bb i?2 Qmi+QK2 Q7 i?2 K2i @ M HvbBb- M/ QM2 /B/ MQi T`QpB/2 2MQm;? BM7Q`K iBQM 7Q` +Q/BM;X P7 i?2 `2K BMBM; jj `iB+H2b- QMHv b2p2M `2TQ`i2/ Jm`T?v 2i HXǶb +QM+2`Mb- M/ QM2 `iB+H2 /Bb+mbb2/ bBKBH ` Bbbm2b KQ`2 #`Q /HvX AM Qi?2` rQ`/b- deW Q7 `2+2Mi bim/B2b +Bi2 i?2 K2i @ M HvbBb b 2pB/2M+2 7Q` i?2 bbQ+B iBQM rBi?Qmi 2tT`2bbBM; +QM+2`M `2; `/BM; i?2 p HB/Biv Q7 i?Bb +QM+HmbBQMX
q?Q M/ r? i Bb +Bi2/ +QHQ`b i?2 +QKKQM T2`+2TiBQM Q7 M 2pB/2M+2 # b2X 6Q` i?2 bbQ+B@ iBQM Q7 8@>hhGS_ ;2MQivT2 rBi? Kv;/ H +iBp iBQM- r2 ? p2 b?QrM i? i `27mi iBQM bim/B2b `2 ivTB+ HHv B;MQ`2/ M/ K2i?Q/QHQ;B+ H +QM+2`Mb `2TQ`i2/ #v K2i @ M HvbBb `2 Q7i2M Qp2`HQQF2/X _2b2 `+?2`b b?QmH/ 7Q+mb QM i?2 Mm M+2 M/ + p2 ib bbQ+B i2/ rBi? Mv `2bmHi UBM+Hm/BM; i?Qb2 /2`Bp2/ 7`QK K2i @ M HvbBbV BM i?2B` `iB+H2b- M/ b?QmH/ #2 2M+Qm` ;2/ iQ Tm#HBb? M/ +Bi2 `27mi iBQM bim/B2bX `2+2Mi bim/v Tm#HBb?2/ BM/BpB/m H UMmHHV `2bmHib iQ;2i?2` rBi? M mT/ i2/ K2i @ M HvbBb- M TT`Q +? i? i KB;?i ?2HT BM@ +`2 b2 i?2 pBbB#BHBiv Q7 `27mi iBQM bim/B2b (kN3)X *Bi iBQM M HvbBb Q7 Qi?2` iQTB+b +QmH/
d9
*Bi iBQM #B b BM i?2 8@>hhGS_ @ Kv;/ H +iBp iBQM HBi2` im`2
Within−network
Web of Science
Positive Claim Refutation Positive Claim Refutation 0 20 40 60 80 0 20 40 60 80 % of possible citations
Yearly citation rate
6B;m`2 8Xk, W Q7 TQbbB#H2 rBi?BM@M2irQ`F +Bi iBQMb UǬR a.V M/ v2 `Hv q2# Q7 a+B2M+2
+Bi iBQM ` i2 UǬR a.V 7Q` TQbBiBp2- +H BK- M/ `27mi iBQM bim/B2bX
?2HT +H `B7v r?v +2`i BM #2HB27b `2K BM /22THv `QQi2/ BM i?2 }2H/ M/ bmTTQ`i `2b2 `+?2`b BM /BbiBM;mBb?BM; 7 / 7`QK 7 +iX
5
`2r `/2/ 7Q` K FBM; TQbBiBp2 +H BKb #v ?B;?2` +Bi iBQM ` i2b- `2bmHiBM; BM HBi2` im`2 i? i T`2b2Mib /BbiQ`i2/ BKT`2bbBQM Q7 i?2 bi`2M;i? Q7 2pB/2M+2X
Within−network Web of Science
Studies Citations Studies Citations 0 25 50 75 100 Percentage Refutation Claim Positive
6B;m`2 8XR, S2`+2Mi ;2 Q7 bim/B2b Q7 2 +? ivT2 UTQbBiBp2- +H BK- M/ `27mi iBQMV M/ i?2
T2`+2Mi ;2 Q7 +Bi iBQMb `2+2Bp2/ #v 2 +? ivT2 Q7 bim/v 7Q` rBi?BM@M2irQ`F +Bi iBQMb M/ q2# Q7 a+B2M+2 +Bi iBQMbX 6Q` rBi?BM@M2irQ`F +Bi iBQMb- i?2 }M H bim/v rBi?BM i?2 M2irQ`F r b MQi BM+Hm/2/ BM i?2 MmK#2` Q7 bim/B2b- b Bi +QmH/ MQi ? p2 #22M +Bi2/ rBi?BM i?2 M2irQ`FX
1z2+i 2biBK i2b #v K2i @ M Hvb2b `2 MQi z2+i2/ #v bTBM M/ Q7i2M brB7iHv #2+QK2 i?2 M2r bi M/ `/ BM i?2 }2H/X Hi?Qm;? K2i @ M Hvb2b + M TQi2MiB HHv Qp2``B/2 i?2 2z2+ib Q7 +Bi iBQM /BbiQ`iBQM- i?2v + M HbQ H2 / iQ 7m`i?2` /BbiQ`iBQM r?2M BKTQ`i Mi Bbbm2b i?2v ` Bb2 `2 M2;H2+i2/X hrQ BM/2T2M/2Mi ` i2`b +Q/2/ r?2i?2` i?2 jd T22`@`2pB2r2/ 1M;HBb?@ H M;m ;2 `iB+H2b +BiBM; Jm`T?v 2i HX (kNd) UbQm`+2, :QQ;H2 a+?QH `- LQp2K#2` kyR9V `272``2/ iQ i?2b2 mi?Q`bǶ +QM+2`Mb #Qmi Bbbm2b Q7 bi iBbiB+ H TQr2` M/ Tm#HB+ iBQM #B b-Q` QMHv K2MiBQM2/ i?2 T`2b2M+2 Q7 bi iBbiB+ HHv bB;MB}+ Mi 2z2+iX
h?`22 K2i?Q/QHQ;B+ H `iB+H2b /B/ MQi //`2bb i?2 Qmi+QK2 Q7 i?2 K2i @ M HvbBb- M/ QM2 /B/ MQi T`QpB/2 2MQm;? BM7Q`K iBQM 7Q` +Q/BM;X P7 i?2 `2K BMBM; jj `iB+H2b- QMHv b2p2M `2TQ`i2/ Jm`T?v 2i HXǶb +QM+2`Mb- M/ QM2 `iB+H2 /Bb+mbb2/ bBKBH ` Bbbm2b KQ`2 #`Q /HvX AM Qi?2` rQ`/b- deW Q7 `2+2Mi bim/B2b +Bi2 i?2 K2i @ M HvbBb b 2pB/2M+2 7Q` i?2 bbQ+B iBQM rBi?Qmi 2tT`2bbBM; +QM+2`M `2; `/BM; i?2 p HB/Biv Q7 i?Bb +QM+HmbBQMX
q?Q M/ r? i Bb +Bi2/ +QHQ`b i?2 +QKKQM T2`+2TiBQM Q7 M 2pB/2M+2 # b2X 6Q` i?2 bbQ+B@ iBQM Q7 8@>hhGS_ ;2MQivT2 rBi? Kv;/ H +iBp iBQM- r2 ? p2 b?QrM i? i `27mi iBQM bim/B2b `2 ivTB+ HHv B;MQ`2/ M/ K2i?Q/QHQ;B+ H +QM+2`Mb `2TQ`i2/ #v K2i @ M HvbBb `2 Q7i2M Qp2`HQQF2/X _2b2 `+?2`b b?QmH/ 7Q+mb QM i?2 Mm M+2 M/ + p2 ib bbQ+B i2/ rBi? Mv `2bmHi UBM+Hm/BM; i?Qb2 /2`Bp2/ 7`QK K2i @ M HvbBbV BM i?2B` `iB+H2b- M/ b?QmH/ #2 2M+Qm` ;2/ iQ Tm#HBb? M/ +Bi2 `27mi iBQM bim/B2bX `2+2Mi bim/v Tm#HBb?2/ BM/BpB/m H UMmHHV `2bmHib iQ;2i?2` rBi? M mT/ i2/ K2i @ M HvbBb- M TT`Q +? i? i KB;?i ?2HT BM@ +`2 b2 i?2 pBbB#BHBiv Q7 `27mi iBQM bim/B2b (kN3)X *Bi iBQM M HvbBb Q7 Qi?2` iQTB+b +QmH/
Within−network
Web of Science
Positive Claim Refutation Positive Claim Refutation 0 20 40 60 80 0 20 40 60 80 % of possible citations
Yearly citation rate
6B;m`2 8Xk, W Q7 TQbbB#H2 rBi?BM@M2irQ`F +Bi iBQMb UǬR a.V M/ v2 `Hv q2# Q7 a+B2M+2
+Bi iBQM ` i2 UǬR a.V 7Q` TQbBiBp2- +H BK- M/ `27mi iBQM bim/B2bX
?2HT +H `B7v r?v +2`i BM #2HB27b `2K BM /22THv `QQi2/ BM i?2 }2H/ M/ bmTTQ`i `2b2 `+?2`b BM /BbiBM;mBb?BM; 7 / 7`QK 7 +iX
*? Ti2` e
*Bi iBQM #B b M/ b2H2+iBp2 7Q+mb QM
TQbBiBp2 }M/BM;b BM i?2 HBi2` im`2 QM
i?2 b2`QiQMBM i` MbTQ`i2` ;2M2- HB72
bi`2bb M/ /2T`2bbBQM
uKFD2 MM /2 o`B2b- MM2HB2F2 JX _Q2bi- JBMBi 6` Mx2M-J `+mb _X JmM 7ǁ- CQD MM2F2 X " biB Mb2M Sbv+?QHQ;B+ H J2/B+BM2 UkyReV- 9e- kNdR @ kNdN
