VU Research Portal

Hele tekst

(1)VU Research Portal. Ook zonder het lef om de Grondwet te herzien, is bijsturing levensbeschouwelijke vakken mogelijk Franken, Leni; Lievens, J.. published in Knack.be 2019. document version Publisher's PDF, also known as Version of record. Link to publication in VU Research Portal. citation for published version (APA) Franken, L., & Lievens, J. (2019). Ook zonder het lef om de Grondwet te herzien, is bijsturing levensbeschouwelijke vakken mogelijk. Knack.be, 2019(Mei 2). https://www.knack.be/nieuws/belgie/ook-zonderhet-lef-om-de-grondwet-te-herzien-is-bijsturing-levensbeschouwelijke-vakken-mogelijk/article-opinion1459303.html. General rights Copyright and moral rights for the publications made accessible in the public portal are retained by the authors and/or other copyright owners and it is a condition of accessing publications that users recognise and abide by the legal requirements associated with these rights. • Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the public portal for the purpose of private study or research. • You may not further distribute the material or use it for any profit-making activity or commercial gain • You may freely distribute the URL identifying the publication in the public portal ? Take down policy If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim. E-mail address: vuresearchportal.ub@vu.nl. Download date: 13. Oct. 2021.

(2) 01213456. 789 ÿ

(3) 9 ÿÿÿ9ÿÿ9 ÿÿ

(4) ÿÿ ÿ 9 ÿ!. ÿ9 7ÿ"ÿ#$ÿ"ÿ% !. +,-.-/. 0123ÿ526789ÿ:8;ÿ<8=ÿ2>ÿ78ÿ?9267@8;ÿ;8ÿ:895A86BÿACÿDAEC;F9A6G <8H86CD8CI:2F@8<AE38ÿHJ3386ÿ>2G8<AE30 KLMKNMOPÿRSÿONTKK UVWXYZY[\]ÿRSÿO^TL_. `86Aÿa9J6386ÿ86ÿb2:J6ÿÀ8H86Cÿcdd@@@e36JI3eD8d6A8F@CdJF;8F9Cd<86Af=9J6386f86fE2:J6f<A8H86Cfghije:;><k. 0l8;ÿACÿ6A8;ÿ2>7J;ÿ78ÿ?9267@8;ÿ6A8;ÿG8@AE5AG7ÿ@297;Bÿ7J;ÿ@8ÿ6A8;ÿH89789ÿ@893ÿ3F6686ÿ>J386ÿHJ6ÿ886ÿHJ3 `8H86CD8CI:2F@A6GBÿm;:A83ÿ86ÿaA<2C2n8ÿc`mak0BÿCI:9AEH86ÿ`86Aÿa9J6386ÿcop6;@89q86kÿ86ÿb2:J6ÿÀ8H86Cÿcroÿ`8FH86ke. sR[VXYÿZYY\ÿt]YSuYÿuYÿvYwxx]ÿRyY[ÿYYwÿSRXYzVW\Yÿ{Y[|VYwVwXÿyxwÿYYwÿxxw]xzÿX[RwuZY]tx[]V\Yzt}ÿZxx[RwuY[ÿx[]V\YzÿL~}ÿux]ÿ|RZYz uYÿy[VW{YVuÿyxwÿRwuY[ZVWt}ÿxztÿuYÿR[XxwVtx]VYÿyxwÿuYÿzYyYwtYt{RZYzVW\Yÿyx\\Ywÿyxt]zYX]ÿV zYÿt{RzYwÿ|VWwÿVwÿUYzXV X[RwuZY]]YzVW\ÿyY[zV{]ÿRSÿzYyYwtYt{RZYzVW\ÿRwuY[ZVWtÿVwÿuYÿY[\YwuYÿY[YuVYwt]YwÿYwÿVwÿÿ|YuYwzYY[ÿxxwÿ]YÿVYuYwÿO xx[wxxt]ÿt]Yz]ÿuYÿX[RwuZY]ÿux]ÿYz\YÿzYY[zV{]VXYÿzYY[zVwXÿ{Y]ÿ[Y{]ÿ{YY]ÿRÿYYwÿSR[YzYÿRÿ[YzVXVY|YÿRyRYuVwXÿ]Ywÿzxt]Yÿyxw uYÿXYSYYwt{xÿÿV]ÿY]Y\Yw]ÿux]ÿRR\ÿVwÿ{Y]ÿy[VWÿRwuY[ZVWt}ÿux]ÿRyY[ZYXYwuÿSxx[ÿwVY]ÿV]tzV]Ywuÿ\x]{RzVY\ÿVt}ÿuY zYyYwtYt{RZYzVW\Yÿyx\\YwÿuRR[ÿuYÿRyY[{YVuÿZR[uYwÿXYwxwVY[u Sux]ÿuYÿSYYt]YÿSxx[ÿwVY]ÿxzzYÿy[VWYÿt{RzYwÿ\x]{RzVY\ÿ|VWw}ÿZR[u]ÿY[ÿVwÿ{Y]ÿy[VWYÿRwuY[ZVWtÿ{RRu|x\YzVW\ÿRRSt\x]{RzVY\Y XRutuVYwt]ÿxxwXYRuYw}ÿYYwÿyx\ÿux]ÿuRR[ÿVWwxÿ_KÿyxwÿxzzYÿzYY[zVwXYwÿVwÿszxxwuY[YwÿZR[u]ÿXYyRzXuÿwÿ{Y]ÿRVYYzÿRwuY[ZVWt {YY]ÿSYwÿSRSYw]YYzÿuYÿ\Y|Yÿ]ttYwÿÿ|YuYwzYY[ÿYwÿRwuY[ZVWtÿVwÿwÿyxwÿuYÿY[\YwuYÿ[YzVXVYtTÿRRSt\x]{RzVY\}ÿxwXzVxxwt} R[]{RuR{[Vt]YzVW\}ÿ[R]Yt]xw]tYyxwXYzVt{}ÿVtzxSV]Vt{ÿYwÿVt[x zV]Vt{ÿzÿuY|Yÿyx\\Yw}ÿVwztVYÿÿ|YuYwzYY[}ÿZR[uYwÿuRR[ÿuY Y[\YwuYÿzYyYwtYt{RZYzVW\YÿVwt]xw]VYtÿXYR[XxwVtYY[uÿVWÿ|VWwÿyY[xw]ZRR[uYzVW\ÿyRR[ÿuYÿVwtY]VY}ÿSxx[ÿRR\ÿyRR[ zY[x[YwRzYVuVwXYw}ÿzYY[zxwwYwÿYwÿ{xwuRY\Yw . ÿ ¡¢ÿ£¡¤ÿ¥¡¦ÿ§ÿ ¡ÿ¨¢ ©¡¤ÿ¤¡ÿ£¡¢ª¡«ÿª¬ÿª®¬¤¯¢ª°ÿ¥¡±¡¬¡¬²£¯©¡¥ª®¡ÿ±³¡ÿ§°¡¥ª®´. µY]ÿzYyYwtYt{RZYzVW\ÿRwuY[ZVWtÿZR[u]ÿ|RÿwVY]ÿxzzYYwÿuRR[ÿuYÿRyY[{YVuÿV]Yt]YYu¶ÿ{Y]ÿZR[u]ÿÿ{VY[SYYÿtxSYw{xwXYwuÿÿRR\ zR]Y[ÿ·¸¹º»¼¼½¸¹»»¾ÿVwXY\zY[uTÿ{Y]ÿZVzÿzYY[zVwXYwÿtRVxzVtY[YwÿVwÿYYwÿYxxzuYÿzYyYwtYt{RZYzVW\Yÿ][xuV]VYÿYwÿXxx]ÿY[yxwÿV] ux]ÿzYY[\[x{]YwÿwVY]ÿYw\YzÿYY[]tÿYwÿSRuY[x]R[t}ÿSxx[ÿRR\ÿ¿»ÀÁ½¿»¹ÿyxwÿYYwÿtYVY\YÿzYyYwtYt{RZVwXÿ|VWwÿÃYwÿyx\ÿ¸Ä»Å zYyYwtYt{RZVwXYw}ÿux]ÿXYxtYY[uÿVtÿRÿuYÿxxuYSVt{Yÿt]uVYÿyxwÿ[YzVXVYÿxztÿtRVxxz}ÿ{Vt]R[Vt{ÿYwÿz][YYzÿYwRSYYwÿYw utÿwVY]ÿRÿ]{YRzRXVYÿRÿSR[xxzZY]Ywt{xYwÿVtÿ]R]ÿwRXÿ]RYÿRwYt]xxwuYÿVwÿszxxwuY[Yw µY]ÿVuYYÿRSÿ|RÿYYwÿyx\ÿÿY]Y[ÿXY\YwuÿRwuY[ÿuYÿwRYSY[ÿÆÃÇTÿzYyYwtYt{RZVwX}ÿY]{VY\}ÿzRtRYÿÿVwÿ]Yÿ[V{]Yw}ÿZR[u]ÿwR{]xwt xzÿYw\YzYÿWx[YwÿuRR[ÿYYwÿxxw]xzÿRzV]VV}ÿxxuYSVVÿYwÿRwuY[ZVWtyY[][Y\\Y[tÿYzYV]ÿµY]ÿ|RÿwVY]ÿYw\YzÿYYwÿxxw]xzÿ[x\]Vt{Y [RzYSYwÿVwÿ{Y]ÿRVYYzÿRwuY[ZVWtÿ\wwYwÿRzRttYw¶ÿ{Y]ÿ\RS]ÿRR\ÿ]YXYSRY]ÿxxwÿ{Y]ÿXY[Y\ÿxxwÿzYyYwtYt{RZYzVW\Y XYzY]]Y[u{YVuÿYwÿxxwÿuYÿ]RYwYSYwuYÿtYzx[VtY[VwXÿYwÿuVyY[tV]YV]ÿVwÿ{Y]ÿRwuY[ZVWtÿv]YYutÿSYY[ÿRuY[tÿYwÿzYY[zVwXYw VuYw]VY[Ywÿ|V{ÿVSSY[tÿwVY]ÿSYY[ÿSY]ÿYYwÿYxxzuYÿzYyYwtYt{RZYzVW\Yÿ][xuV]VY}ÿSxx[ÿ{Y]ÿ{VuVXYÿtÈt]YYSÿXxx]ÿuxx[ÿZYz wRXÿt]YYutÿyxwÿV] &'11( ! (1 1199 "

(5) 9 """9""9 ""

(6) "" " 9 "!. "9 1!"9&) 51*.

(7) 01213456. 789 ÿ

(8) 9 ÿÿÿ9ÿÿ9 ÿÿ

(9) ÿÿ ÿ 9 ÿ!. ÿ9 7ÿ"ÿ#$ÿ"ÿ% !. +,,-ÿ/01-23,4536786/6-/. 9:;<ÿ<>?ÿ@AÿBCD:EFGÿHIÿBBJÿDFÿKB??FJLÿM@ÿAFFJ<Fÿ<FÿNBAFCÿ@KÿOÿBKC:GPÿQBBCÿ<FÿRFJBBDÿ@@C<FFG<FÿS:FCÿ@KÿHOÿBKC:GÿBJ<FC?ÿ@TFCL UBBC<@@CÿBCD:EFGÿHIÿ<FÿE@AFJ<FÿGFV:?GBD>>CÿJ:FDÿT@@CÿSFCM:FJ:JVÿTBDWBBCÿ:?PÿXFDFEFJDÿ<:Dÿ<BJÿ<BDÿYZ[ÿW:JJFJÿ<:FÿGFV:?GBD>>C @JA@VFG:;EÿU@C<D\ÿ]@@Cÿ<FÿAFF?Dÿ^@J?F_>FJDFÿT@CAÿTBJÿYZ[ÿ`ÿBG?ÿKG:^SDTBELÿBBJVFW@<FJÿ:JÿBGGFÿJFDDFJÿFJÿT@@CÿBGGFÿGFFCG:JVFJÿ` :?ÿSFDÿBJDU@@C<ÿ@Kÿ<FMFÿTCBBVÿ:J<FC<BB<ÿWFTF?D:VFJ<PÿQBBCÿ<BDÿWFDFEFJDÿJ:FDÿ<BDÿFCÿSFGFABBGÿVFFJÿABJ@F>TCFFCC>:ADFÿM@>ÿM:;J T@@CÿYZ[ÿabccdcÿ<FÿVC@J<UFDPÿf@ÿSFWWFJÿGFFCG:JVFJÿ:JÿSFDÿ@g^:FFGÿ@J<FCU:;?ÿSFDÿCF^SDÿ@KÿFFJÿTC:;?DFGG:JVÿTBJÿ<FÿBBJVFW@<FJ GFTFJ?WF?^S@>UFG:;EFÿTBEEFJLÿFFJÿCF^SDÿUBBCTBJÿhLijÿTBJÿ<FÿGFFCG:JVFJÿ:JÿSFDÿGBVFCÿFJÿkjÿ:JÿSFDÿ?F^>J<B:Cÿ@J<FCU:;?ÿ:JÿHhkl`km VFWC>:EÿABBEDFP nFÿDUFFÿ>CFJÿ<:Fÿ<BJÿTC:;E@AFJÿU@C<FJÿ<@@Cÿ<Fÿ@TFCSF:<ÿF^SDFCÿcbdoÿ:JVFT>G<pÿ@><FC?ÿA@FDFJÿS>JÿE:J<FCFJÿSFDÿJ@<:VFÿABDFC:BBG WFM@CVFJÿ@K<BDÿMFÿM:^Sÿ:Jÿ<FÿF:VFJÿGFTFJ?WF?^S@>U:JVÿq<:FÿMFÿTBBEÿJ:FDÿAFFCÿSFWWFJrÿE>JJFJÿTFC<:FKFJLÿABBCÿFFJÿT@GUBBC<:V :JS@><FG:;EÿFJÿ<@@Cÿ<Fÿ@TFCSF:<ÿBBJVFW@<FJÿBGDFCJBD:Fsÿ:?ÿFCÿJ:FDPÿnFMFÿCFVFGVFT:JVÿG:;EDÿJ:FDÿSFGFABBGÿDFÿ?DC@EFJÿAFDÿBCDPHIÿtip <@@CÿTC:;VF?DFG<FÿGFFCG:JVFJÿBBJÿS>JÿG@Dÿ@TFCÿDFÿGBDFJLÿU@C<DÿFCÿJ:FDÿBBJÿSFDÿVC@J<UFDDFG:;EFÿCF^SDÿ@KÿGFTFJ?WF?^S@>UFG:;EFÿFJ A@CFGFÿ@KT@F<:JVÿDFJÿGB?DFÿTBJÿ<FÿVFAFFJ?^SBKÿDFVFA@FDÿVFE@AFJPÿuAÿS:FCÿTFCBJ<FC:JVÿ:JÿDFÿWCFJVFJÿM@>ÿSFDÿ@g^:FFG @J<FCU:;?ÿYZ[ÿBG?ÿFFJÿFvDCBÿEF>MFA@VFG:;ESF:<ÿE>JJFJÿBBJW:F<FJLÿM@J<FCÿ<BDÿS:FCT@@CÿFFJÿVC@J<UFD?U:;M:V:JVÿJ@<:Vÿ:?PÿZFJ BJ<FCFÿ@KD:Fÿ:?ÿ<FÿTC:;?DFGG:JV?A@VFG:;ESF:<ÿAFFCÿWFEFJ<SF:<ÿVFTFJÿFJÿBG?ÿ?^S@@Gÿ`ÿTC:;U:GG:VÿFJÿ@Kÿ<FÿCBJ<ÿTBJÿSFDÿUFDDFG:;E EB<FCÿ`ÿ:JÿFFJÿYZ[`BBJW@<ÿT@@CÿTC:;VF?DFG<FÿGFFCG:JVFJÿT@@CM:FJLÿM@BG?ÿFJEFGFÿwux`[CF:JFD?^S@GFJÿTBJ<BBVÿBGÿ<@FJP. yz{ÿ6-ÿ|,4ÿ}067ÿ1-2,03675. n:Dÿ?^FJBC:@ÿVFG<DÿF^SDFCÿFJEFGÿT@@CÿSFDÿ@g^:~GFÿJFDÿ`ÿFJÿ<>?ÿ?GF^SD?ÿT@@CÿM@JÿihjÿTBJÿBGGFÿ]GBBA?Fÿ?^S@GFJPÿX:;JBÿlhjÿTBJÿ<F ?^S@GFJÿ:Jÿ]GBBJ<FCFJÿWFS@@CDÿJ:FDÿD@Dÿ<:DÿJFDLÿABBCÿD@DÿSFDÿTC:;ÿEBDS@G:FEÿ@J<FCU:;?PÿuA<BDÿ<FÿTC:;SF:<ÿTBJÿ@J<FCU:;?ÿ<FMF ?^S@GFJÿD@FGBBDÿS>JÿF:VFJÿKF<BV@V:?^SÿKC@;F^Dÿ:JÿDFÿEGF>CFJLÿE>JJFJÿMFÿFCÿT@@CÿE:FMFJÿ@AÿFFJÿF:VFJÿGFTFJ?WF?^S@>UFG:;EÿTBEÿq:J <FÿKCBED:;Eÿ:?ÿ<BDÿS@@s<MBEFG:;Eÿ@@A?ÈBDS@G:FEFÿV@<?<:FJ?DrÿBBJÿDFÿW:F<FJPÿ]C:;Fÿ?^S@GFJÿTFCKG:^SDFJÿ<:DÿTBEÿ@KD:@JFFGÿDF ABEFJÿFJÿFFJÿTBEÿYZ[ÿT@@Cÿ:F<FCFFJÿBBJÿDFÿW:F<FJÿ:?LÿTBJ>:Dÿ<:DÿKFC?KF^D:FsÿTBJÿ<Fÿ@J<FCU:;?TC:;SF:<Lÿ@JVC@J<UFDD:VP . ,ÿ1},0|,62ÿ1,4ÿ4,0/|12,-2ÿ867-ÿ 67ÿ|,4ÿ10,0,-ÿ}-ÿ302,-/,2,-ÿ,6-24,0,-ÿyz{ÿ124ÿ26,ÿ|,4 ,2/1/65|ÿ017,4ÿ}-ÿ}067,ÿ1-2,03675},0540,,05ÿ--,-ÿ2110065,-. 9@^Sÿ:?ÿFCÿ@@EÿS:FCÿFJ:VFÿ?KFFGC>:ADFPÿf@ÿUFC<ÿ:JÿHhkOÿqJ@DBÿWFJFÿJBÿFFJÿBCCF?DÿTBJÿ<FÿBB<ÿTBJÿRDBDFÿC@J<ÿTC:;?DFGG:JVrÿFFJ ÿdÿbbdÿdoÿdÿbodccdoÿqrÿ:JVFC:^SDÿ:Jÿ<Fÿ[CBJ?FÿwFAFFJ?^SBKPÿJÿSFDÿ@g^:FFGÿ@J<FCU:;?ÿTFCTBJVDÿ<:DÿTBEÿJ >>CÿTBJÿ<FÿGFTFJ?WF?^S@>UFG:;EFÿTBEEFJpÿSFDÿBBJDBGÿS:FCTBJÿUFC<ÿJBÿFFJÿ<F^CFFD?U:;M:V:JVÿDFC>VVF?^SC@Fs<ÿTBJÿHÿJBBCÿkPÿJÿSFD TC:;ÿ@J<FCU:;?ÿ:?ÿSFDÿBBJDBGÿ>CFJÿGFTFJ?WF?^S@>UFG:;Eÿ@J<FCU:;?ÿ:Jÿ<FÿAFF?DFÿ?^S@GFJÿ@JVFU:;M:V<ÿVFWGFTFJLÿABBCÿM:;Jÿ?^S@GFJ UFGÿTFCKG:^SDÿ@Aÿ@@Eÿ<FÿF:J<DFCAFJÿÿDFÿWFSBGFJPÿn:DÿVFWF>CDÿW:;T@@CWFFG<ÿ<@@CÿFCÿ:Jÿ<FÿGF??FJÿDBBGLÿBBC<C:;E?E>J<FL VF?^S:F<FJ:?Lÿ@sÿNÿV@<?<:FJ?DLÿBBJ<B^SDÿBBJÿDFÿWF?DF<FJPÿ]FCDBBG<ÿJBBCÿ]GBBJ<FCFJÿM@>ÿ<:Dÿ?^FJBC:@ÿWFDFEFJFJÿ<BDÿFCÿT@@C BGGFÿJFDDFJÿ<@@Cÿ<Fÿ@TFCSF:<ÿ@KVF?DFG<FÿF:J<DFCAFJÿYZ[ÿ@sÿGFTFJ?WF?^S@>UFG:;EFÿVFGFDDFC<SF:<ÿE@AFJP JÿSFDÿ@g^:~GFÿJFDÿE>JJFJÿ<FMFÿ<BJLÿA:D?ÿ<F^CFFD?U:;M:V:JVLÿT@CAÿEC:;VFJÿ:JÿFFJÿBKBCDÿTBEÿYZ[ÿ<BDÿkÿ>>CÿKFCÿUFFEÿU@C<D BBJVFW@<FJÿDFCÿTFCTBJV:JVÿTBJÿkÿTBJÿ<FÿHÿGF?>CFJÿ:Jÿ<FÿFCEFJ<FÿGFTFJ?WF?^S@>U:JVFJPÿ]C:;Fÿ?^S@GFJÿ?DBBDÿSFDÿ:Jÿ<:Dÿ?^FJBC:@ TC:;ÿ<:Dÿ@@EÿDFÿ<@FJLÿABBCÿE>JJFJÿFCÿ`ÿM@BG?ÿ:Jÿ<Fÿ[CBJ?FÿwFAFFJ?^SBKÿ`ÿ@@EÿT@@CÿE:FMFJÿ@Aÿ<FÿF:J<DFCAFJÿYZ[ÿDFÿ:JDFVCFCFJÿ:J FFJÿBBJDBGÿWF?DBBJ<FÿTBEEFJPÿXFGBJVC:;EÿT@@CWFS@><pÿ<Fÿ@TFCSF:<ÿA@FDÿDFC>VS@><FJ<ÿM:;JÿW:;ÿSFDÿs@CA>GFCFJÿTBJ UBBC<FJVFGB<FJÿF:J<DFCAFJÿYZ[ÿ@A<BDÿ<:FÿSFDÿKF<BV@V:?^SÿKC@;F^DÿTBJÿTC:;Fÿ@J<FCU:;?TFC?DCFEEFC?ÿE>JJFJÿ<@@CEC>:?FJP JS@><FG:;EÿEBJÿMFÿF^SDFCÿUFGÿTB?DGFVVFJÿUFGEFÿEFJJ:?ÿdÿGFTFJ?WF?^S@>U:JVFJÿBGGFÿ?^S@GFJLÿ@JVFB^SDÿSFDÿKF<BV@V:?^S KC@;F^DLÿA:J:A>AÿA@FDFJÿTFC?DCFEEFJP :FÿT@@CÿYZ[ÿ:;TFCDÿMBGÿJ:FDÿAFDFFJÿFFJÿTCF>V<F<BJ?ÿABEFJÿJ>ÿ:?ÿVFWGFEFJÿ<BDÿBCD:EFGÿHIÿTBJÿ<FÿVC@J<UFDÿJ:FDÿT@@CÿSFCM:FJ:JV U@C<Dÿ@KFJVF?DFG<PÿQBBCÿFFJÿ<@<FJ<BJ?ÿ:?LÿAFDÿFJ:VFÿVC@J<UFDDFG:;EFÿFJÿ<F^CFDBGFÿ^CFBD:T:DF:DLÿFTFJA:JÿJ@<:VP y,-6ÿ{0-,-ÿ65ÿ},0 1-2,-ÿ-ÿ2,ÿ-6},0564,64ÿ-43,0,-ÿ,-ÿ 1|-ÿy6,},-5ÿ65ÿ},0 1-2,-ÿ-ÿ2,ÿ¡ÿ54,02ÿ,-ÿ2,ÿ¢ y,},- YFF?ÿ@@Ep `ÿ?ÿSFDÿUFGÿVFM@J<ÿ@Aÿ@J<FCU:;?ÿDFÿ@CVBJ:?FCFJÿT@GVFJ?ÿGFTFJ?WF?^S@>U:JVÿ@sÿCFG:V:F\ÿq£J:F>U?£WFGV:F£:?`SFDÙFG`VFM@J<`@A` @J<FCU:;?`DF`@CVBJ:?FCFJ`T@GVFJ?`GFTFJ?WF?^S@>U:JV`@s`CFG:V:F£BCD:^GF`@K:J:@J`kIkO¤HiPSDAGr. &'11( ! (1 1199 "

(10) 9 """9""9 ""

(11) "" " 9 "!. "9 1!"9&) 31*.

(12)

No results found