• No results found

Fisheries co-management, the role of local institutions and decentralisation in Southeast Asia : with specific reference to marine sasi in Central Maluku, Indonesia

N/A
N/A
Info
Downloaden
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "Fisheries co-management, the role of local institutions and decentralisation in Southeast Asia : with specific reference to marine sasi in Central Maluku, Indonesia"

Copied!
17
0
0

Bezig met laden.... (Bekijk nu de volledige tekst)

Download het nu ( 17 pagina )

Hele tekst

(1)Fisheries co-management, the role of local institutions and decentralisation in Southeast Asia : with specific reference to marine sasi in Central Maluku, Indonesia Harkes, I.H.T.. Citation Harkes, I. H. T. (2006, May 15). Fisheries co-management, the role of local institutions and decentralisation in Southeast Asia : with specific reference to marine sasi in Central Maluku, Indonesia. Retrieved from https://hdl.handle.net/1887/4385 Version:. Not Applicable (or Unknown). License:. Licence agreement concerning inclusion of doctoral thesis in the Institutional Repository of the University of Leiden. Downloaded from:. https://hdl.handle.net/1887/4385. Note: To cite this publication please use the final published version (if applicable)..

(2) . . . . K I=J=CAIAJP. 5PQEPXO DFOUSBMJ[FEBQQSPBDIFTUPmTIFSJFTNBOBHFNFOUIBWFMFBEUP PWFSFYQMPJUBUJPO NJTNBOBHFNFOUBOEDSJTFTJOmTIFSJFTXPSMEXJEF ,FBS  OFZ+FOUPGU1JOLFSUPO.D(PPEXJO)BOOFTTPO #FSLFTBOE'PMLF'JOMBZTPOBOE.D$BZ)BSBBOE3BBLKS /JFMTFO 5IFMBDLPG MPDBM QSPQFSUZSJHIUTJTBOJODFOUJWFGPSmTIFSTUP PWFSIBSWFTUBOEDPNQFUFPWFSSFTPVSDFT $IBSMFT 5IFJOBCJMJUZPGUIF OBUJPOBMHPWFSONFOUUPFOGPSDFUIFSVMFTIBTCFFOVOEFSNJOJOHDPNQMJBODF GVSUIFS*OTPNFDPVOUSJFT TVDIBT*OEPOFTJBXJUIBDPBTUMJOFPG LN MPOH FGGFDUJWFNBOBHFNFOUCZUIFOBUJPOBMHPWFSONFOUJTQIZTJDBMMZJNQPT TJCMF5IFJOGBNPVTDBTFPGUIFDPMMBQTFUIF$BOBEJBODPEmTIFSZXBTBUVSO JOHQPJOUCPUIJOSFDPHOJTJOHUIFWVMOFSBCJMJUZPGmTITUPDLTBOEUIFOFFEUP NBOBHFUIFN BTXFMMJOBDLOPXMFEHJOHUIFJOBCJMJUZPGUIFHPWFSONFOUUP EPTP 'JOMBZTPO)BOOFTTPO4ZNFT'JOMBZTPOBOE.D$BZ )BFESJDIBOE)BNJMUPO *OTFBSDIGPSTPMVUJPOTBOECFUUFSXBZT PGHPWFSOJOHSFTPVSDFVTF JUIBTCFDPNFDMFBSUIBUPOFTJOHMFCFTUTUSBUFHZ EPFTOPUFYJTU(JWFOUIFXJEFEJWFSTJUZPGUISFBUFOFESFTPVSDFTJUJTBHSFFE UIBUNVMUJQMFJOTUJUVUJPOBMTUSBUFHJFTBSFOFFEFE %JFU[ FUBM $PNBO BHFNFOUJTTVDIBTUSBUFHZ. 

(3)  K I=J=CAIAJP@ABEJA@ $PNBOBHFNFOU PSDPMMBCPSBUJWFNBOBHFNFOU XBTJOUSPEVDFEJOUIFFBSMZ TBTUIFXBZGPSXBSE 1PNFSPZ.D$BZBOE+FOUPGU4FOBOE 3BBLKS/JFMTFO $PNBOBHFNFOUJTDPNNPOMZEFmOFEBTBQBSUOFS  TIJQJOTIBSJOHNBOBHFNFOUBVUIPSJUZBOESFTQPOTJCJMJUZ BOEUIFCFOFm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mDJFOUBOEFRVJUBCMFHPWFSOBODFTZTUFN ,VQFSBOFUBM  0WFSUIFZFBST UIFDPODFQUPGDPNBOBHFNFOUIBTCFFOVTFEGPSBXJEFWB  SJFUZPGBSSBOHFNFOUTJOWBSJPVTDPOUFYUT*OJUTCSPBEFTUTFOTF DPNBOBHF .

(4) . $0  ."/"(&.&/5. . NFOUJTTFFOBTBOFWPMWJOHQSPDFTTHVJEFECZBTFUPGJOTUJUVUJPOBMQSJODJQMFT XIJDINVTUCFBMMPXFEUPBEBQUBOECFnFYJCMF*UDBOBMTPCFWJFXFEBTB TFUPGJOTUJUVUJPOBMBSSBOHFNFOUT SJHIUTBOESVMFT UIBUEFmOFUIFDPPQFSB  UJPOBNPOHUIFmTIFSJFTBENJOJTUSBUJPOBOESFMFWBOUm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nZEFBMXJUITPNFPGUIF DVSSFOUJTTVFT. 

(5) 1DAL=NPEAOEJ?K I=J=CAIAJP "DDPSEJOHUPUIFEFmOJUJPO UIFUXPNBJOQBSUJFTJODPNBOBHFNFOUBSFUIF MPDBMDPNNVOJUZBOEUIFHPWFSONFOU PSHPWFSONFOUJOTUJUVUJPO *OSFBM  JUZ IPXFWFS UIFQSPDFTTJTPGUFOTVQQPSUFECZ/(0TPSFYUFSOBMBHFOUTBOE DBOJOWPMWFTDJFOUJTUT UIFQSJWBUFTFDUPS BOEPUIFSTUBLFIPMEFST /BUVSBMMZ  UIFNPSFQBSUJFTCFDPNFJOWPMWFE UIFNPSFEJGm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mOJUJPOPGBDPNNVOJUZ  UIFMPDVTBOETDBMF. -BSHFJOUFSOBUJPOBMPSHBOJTBUJPOTBOEEPOPSTTVDIBTUIF8PSME#BOL 64"*%BOEUIF"TJBO %FWFMPQNFOU#BOLBSFJNQPSUBOUBTUIFZBSFQMBZJOHBLFZSPMFJOUIFNPWFUPXBSETEFDFOUSBMJTB UJPO 1FSTPPOBOEWBO&TU "MTPQSJWBUFPSHBOJTBUJPOT UIFUPVSJTUJOEVTUSZ TDJFOUJTUTBOE SFTFBSDIFSTIBWFBQPUFOUJBMMZJNQPSUBOUSPMFJODPNBOBHFNFOU'PSUIFTBLFPGTJNQMJDJUZ UIFZ BSFOPUGVSUIFSEJTDVTTFEIFSF.

(6) . 5)&  1"35 *&4  */  $0  ."/"(&.&/5. . . PGBDPNNVOJUZ  UIFSFQSFTFOUBUJPOPGTVCHSPVQTBOE QSPQFSUZSJHIUT "OPUIFSJOUFSFTUJOHBOEIFMQGVMDBUFHPSJTBUJPOJTQSFTFOUFECZ.D$BZ  JO1JOLFSUPO XIPUBMLTBCPVUUFSSJUPSJBMDPNNVOJUJFT PSDPNNVOJ  UJFTPGQMBDF BOEGVODUJPOBMDPNNVOJUJFT PSDPNNVOJUJFTPGJOUFSFTU  " DPNNVOJUZPGQMBDFDBOCFTFFOBTBXFCPGTPDJBMJOUFSBDUJPOTUJFEUPQMBDF  IJTUPSZBOEJEFOUJUZ XIFSFBTBDPNNVOJUZPGJOUFSFTUVTVBMMZDPOTJTUTPGB HSPVQXJUIBTIBSFESFMJBODFPOBQBSUJDVMBSHFBSUZQFPSTQFDJFT +FOUPGUFUBM  *UJTJNQPSUBOUUPSFBMJTFUIBUDPNNVOJUJFTPGJOUFSFTUHFOFSBMMZIBWF BXFBLFSJODFOUJWFUPQSPUFDUMPDBMm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mTIFSJFTNBOBHFNFOUBOEDPNQMJBODFPOUIFMPOHFSUFSN UIFZBMTPDSF  BUFUIFNFDIBOJTNTUIBUFOIBODFTPDJBMTUBCJMJUZBOEJOTUJUVUJPOBMSFTJMJFODF TFF$IBQUFS *UJTUIVTJNQPSUBOUUPJEFOUJGZUIFUZQFPGDPNNVOJUZXIFO FTUBCMJTIJOHBDPNBOBHFNFOUTZTUFN *UJTBMTPJNQPSUBOUUPJEFOUJGZUIFMPDVTBOETDBMFPGBDPNNVOJUZJOSFMB  UJPOUPUIFSFTPVSDFTUPCFNBOBHFE4FEFOUBSZTQFDJFTPSNBSJOFSFTFSWFT DBOCFSFHVMBUFEMPDBMMZ CVUGPSSFTPVSDFTUIBUDPWFSNPSFUIBOPOFWJMMBHF UFSSJUPSZBMPDBMDPNNVOJUZNBZOPUCFUIFBQQSPQSJBUFTUSVDUVSF5PNBOBHF QFMBHJDm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mFEJOJOUFSOBUJPOBMFOWJSPONFOUBMQPMJUJDTBOEUIBUPGHSPXJOH JNQPSUBODFJODPNBOBHFNFOUBSFTPDBMMFEAFQJTUFNJDDPNNVOJUJFT5IFTFBSFDPNNVOJUJFTUIBU DFOUSFPOTQFDJmDNBOBHFNFOUJTTVFTPSNBOBHFNFOUCPEJFTBOEDBOCFNBEFVQPGJOEVTUSZ NFNCFST MPCCZJTUT CVSFBVDSBUT KPVSOBMJTUTBOETDJFOUJTUT *OBEEJUJPOUPQSPWJEJOHFOBCMJOHMFHJTMBUJPO UIFHPWFSONFOUNBZQSPWJEFBTTJTUBODFBOETFSW  JDFT BENJOJTUSBUJWF UFDIOJDBMBOEmOBODJBM UPTVQQPSUUIFTVTUBJOBCJMJUZPGUIFMPDBMPSHBOJTBUJPOT BOEJOTUJUVUJPOBMBSSBOHFNFOUT 1PNFSPZ .

(7) . $0  ."/"(&.&/5. . "HSBXBMBOE3JCPU .BOZDBTFTTIPXJOBEFRVBUFUSBOTGFSPGQPXFSTPS BMBDLPGHPWFSONFOUTVQQPSU "HSBXBMBOE3JCPU8JMTPO FUBM  4PNFUJNFTJUJTTIFFSHSFFEUIBULFFQTIJHIFSHPWFSONFOUMFWFMTGSPNHJWJOH VQDPOUSPM CVUPGUFOJUJTBMTPUIFJOBEFRVBDZPGUIFPSHBOJTBUJPOBMTUSVDUVSFT PGHPWFSONFOUEFQBSUNFOUTUPDPQFXJUIUIFOFXNBOBHFNFOUDPODFQUTBOE BQQSPBDI#FTJEFT HPWFSONFOUJOTUJUVUJPOTBSFPGUFOSJEEFOXJUIJOUFSOBM DPOnJDUT WFTUFEJOUFSFTUTBOE JOTPNFDBTFT DPSSVQUJPO"UUIFTBNFUJNF  UIFDFOUSBMHPWFSONFOUJTVOEFSQSFTTVSFGSPNMPCCZJTUTBOENVMUJOBUJPOBMT UPCBMBODFTVTUBJOBCMFSFTPVSDFVTFBOEFDPOPNJDEFWFMPQNFOU5IJTDBO MFBEUPBTJUVBUJPOXIFSFUIFHPWFSONFOUVTFTDPNBOBHFNFOUBTBOJOTUSV  NFOUUPSFBDIJUTPXONBOBHFNFOUPCKFDUJWFTNPSFFGmDJFOUMZ )BSBBOE 3BBLKS/JFMTFO"INFE FUBM3BBLKS/JFMTFO FUBM   *OTUFBEPGCFJOHQBSUPGBDPMMBCPSBUJWFQSPDFTT mTIJOHDPNNVOJUJFTBSFPOMZ BMMPXFEUPCFJOWPMWFEJOUIFJNQMFNFOUBUJPOQSPDFTT"TBSFTVMU JOTPNF QMBDFT MPDBMDPNNVOJUJFTGFMUVTFEBOEIBWFEFWFMPQFEBTVTQJDJPVTBUUJUVEF UPXBSETUIFTUBUF "OPUIFSPCTUBDMFUPFGGFDUJWFDPMMBCPSBUJPOJTUIFGBDUUIBUNPTUEFQBSUNFOUT BSFTUBGGFEXJUICJPMPHJTUTXIPBSFDPODFSOFEPWFSSFTPVSDFDPOTFSWBUJPO  SBUIFSUIBOXJUIUIFTPDJBMBTQFDUTPGDPMMBCPSBUJPOBOENBOBHFNFOU )BSB BOE3BBLKS/JFMTFO3BBLK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S/JFMTFO FUBM4FJYBTBOE#FSLFT 5PFTUBC  MJTINFBOJOHGVMDPMMBCPSBUJPO UIFHPWFSONFOUBOEUIFJSTUBGGOFFEUPVOEFS TUBOEUIFJNQPSUBOUDPOUSJCVUJPOTUBLFIPMEFSTNBZIBWFJOBMMTUBHFTPGUIF NBOBHFNFOUQSPDFTT EFTJHO JNQMFNFOUBUJPO NPOJUPSJOH FWBMVBUJPO BOE BEBQUBUJPO "TFDPOETUFQDBOCFUPTUVEZTUBLFIPMEFSDPODFSOTBOEVTFS LOPXMFEHF UPMFBSOUIFUPPMTBOEUFDIOJRVFTUPDPOEVDUXPSLTIPQT BOEUP MFBSOUIFTLJMMTUPNBOBHFDPOnJDUTBNPOHVTFSHSPVQT 4FJYBTBOE#FSLFT  5IFDPNNVOJDBUJPOHBQDBOCFCSJEHFEEVSJOHUIFQSPDFTTPGJOTUJUV UJPOCVJMEJOHBOEOFHPUJBUJPO%VSJOHUIJTTUBHFPCKFDUJWFTDBOTFUUIBUBSFJO MJOFXJUIUIFXJTIFTPGCPUIUIFOBUJPOBMHPWFSONFOUBOEUIFMPDBMDPNNV  OJUZ UBLJOHJOUPBDDPVOUmTIFSTLOPXMFEHFBOEQSBDUJTFT5IJTXJMMFOIBODF . 'PSEFUBJMTPOUIFQSPDFTTPGDPNBOBHFNFOUTFF1PNFSPZ  .

(8) . *.1035"/5.  *446&4  */  $0  ."/"(&.&/5 . . USVTUoBOFDFTTBSZJOHSFEJFOUJODPMMBCPSBUJPO 1JOLFSUPO+FOUPGU 8JMTPOB3BBLKS/JFMTFOFUBM  5IFHPWFSONFOUDBOGVSUIFSJODSFBTFMFHJUJNBDZPGUIFOFXTUSVDUVSFTBOE EPXOXBSEBDDPVOUBCJMJUZ UISPVHI PWFSTFFJOHMPDBMBSSBOHFNFOUTBOE EFBMJOHXJUIBCVTFPGMPDBMBVUIPSJUZ  DPOn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S/JFMTFO FUBM  'PSZFBST  JOUFSOBUJPOBM /(0TIBWFQMBZFEBQSPNJOFOUSPMFJOMPDBM JOTUJUVUJPOCVJMEJOH3FHBSEMFTTPGIPXXFMMUIFZBDUVBMMZmUUFEXJUIUIFMPDBM DJSDVNTUBODFTBOEUSBEJUJPOBMTUSVDUVSFT mTIFSJFTPSHBOJTBUJPOTPSDPPQFSB UJWFTXFSFFTUBCMJTIFEUPEFBMXJUImTIFSJFTQSPCMFNT5IFDMBTIXJUIFYJTUJOH JOTUJUVUJPOTDBVTFEUIFTFJOJUJBUJWFTNPSFPGUFOUIBOOPUUPGBJM +FOUPGU JO+FOUPGU . 

(9) &ILKNP=JPEOOQAOEJ?K I=J=CAIAJP (VJEJOHQSJODJQMFTJODPNBOBHFNFOUBSFQBSUJDJQBUJPOPGUIPTFBGGFDUFE FR VJUZBOEFGmFODZPGNBOBHFNFOUTUSVDUVSFT QPXFSTIBSJOH BOESFTQFDUGPS UIFMPDBMDVMUVSF JODMVEJOHUSBEJUJPOBMJOTUJUVUJPOTBOEMPDBMLOPXMFEHF$PO nJDUSFTPMVUJPOJTBMTPBOJNQPSUBOUDPNQPOFOUPGUIFDPNBOBHFNFOUQSPD  FTT&YQFDUFEPVUDPNFTEFQFOEMBSHFMZPOUIFEFHSFFUPXIJDIUIFTFNFDIB  OJTNTBSFBUXPSL CVUJNQMFNFOUBUJPOPSFYFDVUJPOPGUIFTFBTQFDUTJTOPU BMXBZTDMFBSDVUBOEIJHIMZEFQFOEFOUPOUIFDPOUFYU5IJTTFDUJPOIJHIMJHIUT TPNFPGUIFBTQFDUTBOEJOTUSVNFOUTUIBUBSFPGJNQPSUBODFJODPNBOBHF  NFOU. -FHJUJNBDZBOEEPXOXBSEBDDPVOUBCJMJUZBSFUIFUXPNBJOQJMMBSTPGEFDFOUSBMJTFETZTUFNT "HSBXBMBOE3JCPU3BBLKBFS/JFMTFOFUBM .

(10) . $0  ."/"(&.&/5. . 1SPQFSUZSJHIUT *OTUVEZJOHSFTPVSDFNBOBHFNFOUJUNBLFTTFOTFUPTFQBSBUFUIFDPODFQUPG UIFSFTPVSDFJUTFMG GSPNUIFSVMFTUIBUHPWFSOUIFSFTPVSDF %JFU[FUBM  $PNNPOTSFTFBSDI TFF$IBQUFS EFBMTQSJNBSJMZXJUIDPNNPOQPPMSF  TPVSDFT$PNNPOQPPMSFTPVSDFTBSFPOFTGPSXIJDIFYDMVTJPOJTDPTUMZBOE XIFSFPOFQFSTPOTVTFTVCUSBDUTGSPNXIBUJTBWBJMBCMFUPPUIFST 0TUSPN FUBM%JFU[ FUBM 8IFOOPQSPQFSUZSJHIUTEFm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mUT GSPNUIFDPOUSJCVUJPOTQSPWJEFECZPUIFSTXJUIPVUQBZJOHUIFDPTUT#ZTUSFTT  JOHUIFTFMGJOUFSFTUPGQFPQMFUIJTNFUBQIPSSFnFDUTBOFHBUJWFWJFXPOVTFS JOWPMWFNFOU CVUXIBUJUNFSFMZEFTDSJCFTJTIVNBOCFIBWJPVSBTBSFTQPOTF UPBQBSUJDVMBSJOTUJUVUJPOBMDPOUFYU TVDIBTBOPQFOBDDFTTSFHJNF"OPQFO BDDFTTSFHJNFDBOIBWFDFSUBJOBEWBOUBHFTJUJTJOQSJODJQBMNPSFFRVJUBCMF BOEMFTTEJWJTJWFUIBOPUIFSTZTUFNT#VUJOHFOFSBM PQFOBDDFTTNBLFTJU NPSFEJGmDVMUUPFOGPSDFDPPQFSBUJPOBOEBHSFFEVQPOSVMFTCFDBVTFPGUIF GSFFSJEFSQSPCMFNBOEJUUIVTDPOUSJCVUFTUPDPNQFUJUJPOBOEPWFSFYQMPJUB  UJPO +FOUPGUFUBM 'PSUIJTSFBTPO UPNBOBHFDPNNPOQPPMSFTPVSDFT  QSJWBUFQSPQFSUZIBTCFFOQSPNPUFE 5IFBEWBOUBHFPGFTUBCMJTIJOHMPDBMQSPQFSUZSJHIUTJTUIBUJUDSFBUFTBOJODFO UJWFUPJOWFTUJOUIFTVTUFOBODFPGUIFSFTPVSDF 3PTFJO+FOUPGU FUBM +FOUPGU $MFBSMZEFmOFEQSPQFSUZSJHIUTBSFBMTPBOJNQPSUBOU UPPMGPSmTIFSTUPFYDMVEFPUIFST 3BBLKS/JFMTFOFUBM 5IFFTUBCMJTI NFOUPGBTFMGHPWFSOJOHSFHJNFJTFBTJFTUXIFSFUIFSFBSFDMFBSMZEFmOFE TFUTPGQSPQFSUZSJHIUT 4DPUUJO+FOUPGU FUBM+FOUPGU BOE MPDBMSJHIUTUPNBOBHFDBOCFTUSFOHUIFOFEJGCBDLFEVQCZSJHIUTPGPXOFS  TIJQ +FOUPGU FUBM  5IFSFGPSFDPNBOBHFNFOUJOHFOFSBMBSHVFTGPS. "DPNNPOQPPMSFTPVSDFJTBWBMVFEOBUVSBMPSIVNBONBEFSFTPVSDFUIBUJTBWBJMBCMFUPNPSF UIBOPOFQFSTPOBOETVCKFDUUPEFHSBEBUJPOBTBSFTVMUPGPWFSVTF 3FOFXBCJMJUZSFGFSTUPUIFSBUFBUXIJDISFTPVSDFVOJUTUIBUBSFFYUSBDUFE SFQMBDFUIFNTFMWFT PWFSUJNF.

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mDVMUUIBOBUmSTUTJHIU0GUFOUIFSFJTOPBVUIFOUJD QBSUJDJQBUJPO JFUSVFQPXFSTIBSJOHJOUIFTFOTFUIBUUIFSFJTMPDBMJOQVU JOBMMPDBUJPOEFDJTJPOTBOEBVUIPSJUZPWFSDPNNFSDJBMMZJOUFSFTUJOHQSPEVDUT 1JOLFSUPO"HSBXBMBOE3JCPU)JMEFCSBOEJO+FOUPGU 1JOLFSUPO 8IFSFQPXFSGVMQMBZFSTBSFJOWPMWFE UIFWPJDFTPGMPDBM TUBLFIPMEFSTBSFPGUFOOPUIFBSE #FSLFT  5IFPCTUBDMFTJOBDIJFWJOHBVUIFOUJDQBSUJDJQBUJPOBSFGVOEBNFOUBMBOEDPN QMFY5IFSFBSFEJGGFSFODFTJOQFSTQFDUJWFT JOUFSFTUT BOEFYQFDUBUJPOTPGUIF WBSJPVTQBSUJFTUIBUBSFEJGm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oBOEQBSUJDVMBSMZUIPTFJOQPXFSoJOPSEFS UPBDIJFWFUIFJSPXOPCKFDUJWFT5IFPVUTJEFFMJUFTEFTDSJCFEJO$IBQUFS BSFBOFYBNQMFPGUIJT$PNBOBHFNFOUUIVTXJMMOPUHPXJUIPVUCFJOHDPO  UFTUFECZUIFNBOZJOUFSFTUFEQBSUJFTJOWPMWFEJOTFDVSJOHCFOFmUTGSPNUIF SFTPVSDFTJORVFTUJPO 3BBLKS/JFMTFO FUBM *OTUBSUJOHUIFQSPDFTT PGDPMMBCPSBUJPO JUJTUIFSFGPSFJNQPSUBOUUPBOBMZTFUIPTFUSZJOHUPHFUBTFBU BUUIFUBCMF -PDBMLOPXMFEHF 8FMMGVODUJPOJOHDPNNVOJUJFTDPOUBJOVOUBQQFEIVNBOBOEDBQJUBMSF  TPVSDFTUIBUTIPVMECFQVUUPVTF +FOUPGUFUBM 5SBEJUJPOBMLOPXMFEHF  HFOFSBUJPOTPMEBEBQUBUJPOT BOETFMGSFHVMBUJOHQSJODJQMFTIBWFIFMQFEWBSJ  PVTHSPVQTUPTVSWJWFJOUIFMPOHUFSNBOEIBWFUIFQPUFOUJBMUPJNQSPWFTVT UBJOBCJMJUZPOCPUIUIFTPDJBMBOEUIFFOWJSPONFOUBMMFWFM +PIBOOFT  'PSBXJEFSEFmOJUJPOPGQBSUJDJQBUJPO JODMVEJOHUIFEJNFOTJPOTBOEUZQFTPGQBSUJDJQBUJPO * XPVMEMJLFUPSFGFSUP6QIPGG%SJKWFS1SFUUZBOE)BSLFT.

(12) . $0  ."/"(&.&/5. . 5IFTFDVMUVSBMBOETPDJBMRVBMJUJFTPGIVNBOTPDJFUJFTBSFBTTFUTPSATPDJBM DBQJUBM +FOUPGUFUBM *ODPSQPSBUJPOPGUIJTTPDJBMDBQJUBMJOUPmTIFSJFT NBOBHFNFOUJTUIPVHIUJNQPSUBOUJOSFWFSTJOHOFHBUJWFTPDJBMBOEFOWJSPO  NFOUBMJNQBDUTBOEJOCVJMEJOHNPSFTPDJBMMZBOEFOWJSPONFOUBMMZTUBCMF TZTUFNTUIBUBSFFGmDJFOUBOEMFHJUJNBUF .D$BZBOE+FOUPGU.JMUPO 1PNFSPZBOE#FSLFT3JCPU3BBLKS/JFMTFOFUBM  5IFVTFPGMPDBMFOWJSPONFOUBMLOPXMFEHFIPXFWFSIBTUPCFEFBMUXJUIDSJUJ DBMMZBOEMJNJUBUJPOTOFFEUPCFBDLOPXMFEHFE4PNFLOPXMFEHF GPSFYBN  QMF JTTFDSFUBOEUIFSFGPSFJOBDDFTTJCMFUPPVUTJEFSTPSDFSUBJOHSPVQTJOUIF DPNNVOJUZ"MTPUIFGBDUUIBUQFPQMFTWJFXJTCBTFEPOBMJNJUFEHFPHSBQIJ DBMMPDBMJUZDBODBVTFCMJOETQPUTPSXPSTFA-PDBMJHOPSBODFDBOGPSNBTFSJ  PVTPCTUSVDUJPOJOOFHPUJBUJPOTPSUIFFTUBCMJTINFOUPGBmTIFSJFTNBOBHF  NFOUTDIFNF*ONBOZQMBDFTQFPQMFBSFTJNQMZJOEFOJBMPGFOWJSPONFOUBM QSPCMFNTBOECMBNFJUPO(PEPSPUIFSFYUFSOBMJUJFT5IJTJTBMTPNZQFSTPOBM FYQFSJFODFA$FTUB%JFVJTSFQFBUFEMZIFBSEJOOPSUI$BNFSPPOXIFOQFP  QMFBSFBTLFEXIZUIFJSmTIDBUDIFTBSFJOEFDMJOF )BSLFT  4DFQUJDJTNJOUIFVTFPGMPDBMLOPXMFEHFJOFOWJSPONFOUBMNBOBHFNFOUJT BMTPFYQSFTTFECZ&MMFOBOE)BSSJT  XIPTUBUFA5IFDMBJNTGPSUIF FOWJSPONFOUBMXJTEPNPGMPDBMQFPQMFIBWFTPNFUJNFTCFFONJTKVEHFEBOE OB«WF5IFFTUBCMJTINFOUPGBQSPQFSUZSJHIUTSFHJNFNBZCFEJGmDVMUJOB DVMUVSFXIFSFQFPQMFCFMJFWFUIBUOBUVSFJTOPUBDPNNPEJUZUPCFCPVHIU  TPMEPSQSFTFSWFE 1PTFZ *OQSJODJQMF UIFTFVOEFSTUBOEJOHTPGUIF XPSMEBSFBTWBMJEBTBOZPUIFSFYQSFTTJPOPGMPDBMLOPXMFEHF XFSFJUOPUUIBU QBSUJDVMBSJEFBTPSQFSDFQUJPOTJOGBDUSFGSBJOQFPQMFGSPNFOWJSPONFOUBMMZ TVTUBJOBCMFCFIBWJPVS5IFXBZWBSJPVTHSPVQTUBDLMFFOWJSPONFOUBMQSPC  MFNTUIVTJTBSFnFDUJPOPGEJWFSTJUZ CPUIDVMUVSBMMZBTXFMMBTJOUFSNTPG CJPEJWFSTJUZ 4MJLLFSWFFS 5IFVTFPGMPDBMLOPXMFEHFJOFOWJSPONFOUBM NBOBHFNFOUJTUIVTDPOUFYUTQFDJmDBOESFRVJSFTDBSFGVMDPOTJEFSBUJPO 0OFPGUIFNBJODVSSFOUDIBMMFOHFTFYQSFTTFEJOUIFTFBSDIGPSTPMVUJPOTUP FOWJSPONFOUBMQSPCMFNT JTUPDPNCJOFPSJOUFHSBUFMPDBMLOPXMFEHFBOETP DBMMFEAHMPCBMLOPXMFEHF%FTQJUFJODSFBTJOHXJMMJOHOFTTPOUIFQBSUPGmTI  FSJFTNBOBHFSTUPNBLFVTFPGMPDBMLOPXMFEHFGPVOEJOUIFDPNNVOJUJFT  UIFJOUFHSBUJPOPGMPDBMFDPMPHJDBMLOPXMFEHFBOESFTFBSDICBTFETDJFOUJmD LOPXMFEHFJOUPBDPNNPOCBTJTGPSNBOBHFNFOUEFDJTJPOTSFNBJOTBEJGm  DVMUUBTL )PCBSU3BBLKS/JFMTFOFUBM *OmTIFSJFT UIFSFTFFNT UPCFBGVOEBNFOUBMHBQJOUIFQFSDFQUJPOPGUIFDPOEJUJPOPGUIFTUPDLTCF . *UBMTPSFGFSTUPAJHOPSBODFJOSFMBUJPOUPTDJFOUJmDLOPXMFEHFGPSTPDJBMBOEFDPOPNJDEFWFMPQ  NFOU*HOPSBODFJTOPUBTJNQMFBOUJUIFTJTPGLOPXMFEHF XSJUFT)PCBSU  *UJTBTUBUFXIJDI QFPQMFBUUSJCVUFUPPUIFSTBOEJTMBEFOXJUINPSBMKVEHFNFOU5IFSFMBUJPOTIJQPGEFWFMPQFSTBOE UIPTFUPCFEFWFMPQFEJTDPOTUJUVUFECZUIFEFWFMPQFSTLOPXMFEHFBOEDBUFHPSJFT,OPXMFEHFPG QFPQMFCFJOHEFWFMPQFEJTJHOPSFEPSUSFBUFEBTBNFSFPCTUBDMFUPEFWFMPQNFOU.

(13) . *.1035"/5.  *446&4  */  $0  ."/"(&.&/5 . . UXFFOmTIJOHDPNNVOJUJFT TDJFOUJTUT BOEmTIFSJFTBHFOUT5IFEBUBHFOFS  BUFEUISPVHIDPOWFOUJPOBMTDJFOUJmDNFUIPETBSFPGUFORVJUFEJTUJODUGSPN UIFLOPXMFEHFMPDBMQFPQMFCSJOHJO BOEXIJDIJTCZEFGBVMUDPOUFYUTQFDJmD BOERVBMJUBUJWFJOOBUVSF5PNBLFVTFPGUIJTLOPXMFEHF JUJTPGUFOSFEFmOFE BOEFYUSBDUFEGSPNJUTDPOUFYU "HSBXBMBOE8BSSFOFUBMJO&MMFO BOE)BSSJT &MMFOBOE)BSSJT  XBSOGPSUIJTTPDBMMFEAEFDPOUFY UVBMJTBUJPOPGLOPXMFEHF 5PQSFWFOUEFDPOUFYUVBMJTBUJPO JUNBZQSPWFVTFGVMUPJEFOUJGZUIFEJGGFSFOU QVSQPTFTGPSXIJDILOPXMFEHFJTVTFEBOEFYUSBDUFEBOENBLFUIFQSPDFTT FYQMJDJUBT4FJYBTBOE#FSLFT  EPJOUIFJSEFTDSJQUJPOPGUIF*CJSBRVFSB MBHPPOmTIFSZJO#SB[JM5IFZQSFTFOUNFDIBOJTNTUPEFBMXJUIEJGGFSFOU UZQFTPGLOPXMFEHFJOUIFJOUFSBDUJPOTBNPOHNBOBHFNFOUJOTUJUVUJPOT BDSPTTQPMJUJDBMTDBMFTBOEBENJOJTUSBUJWFTFDUPST'PSUIJT UIFZEJTUJOHVJTI UISFFQVSQPTFTGPSBDPNNPOLOPXMFEHFCBTF  UPQSPWJEFJOGPSNBUJPOGPS EFDJTJPONBLJOH   UPNJOJNJTFEJGGFSFODFTJOTUBLFIPMEFSTVOEFSTUBOE  JOHPGQSPCMFNT BOE  UPQSPWJEFJOQVUUPNBOBHFNFOUDPPSEJOBUJPOBUB MBSHFSTDBMF*OUIFTFBSDIGPSmTIFSJFTNBOBHFNFOUQMBOTUIBUBMMPXCPUI USBEJUJPOBMBOETDJFOUJmDLOPXMFEHFUPGFFEJO UIFBCPWFDBUFHPSJTBUJPONBZ CFVTFGVMBTJUIFMQTUPEFmOF XIBUUZQFPGLOPXMFEHFJTVTFEGPS XIBUQVS QPTF*UJTBMTPJNQPSUBOUUPMPPLBUIPXMPDBMQFSTQFDUJWFTBSFJODMVEFEJOUIF EFDJTJPONBLJOHQSPDFTT#ZNBLJOHUIFQSPDFTTPGFYQMJDJUBOEQMBDJOHJU UIFDPOUFYU MPDBMLOPXMFEHF FWFOUIPVHIPOMZQBSUJBMMZVTFEBOEFYUSBDUFE  JTBDLOPXMFEHFE DSFEJUFEBOEoJOJUTMJNJUFEGPSNoVTFGVMJODPNCJOBUJPO XJUITDJFOUJmDLOPXMFEHFJONBOBHFNFOU $POºJDUSFTPMVUJPO 5IFSFBSFWBSJPVTSFBTPOTXIZQBSUJFTEFDJEFUPDPPQFSBUFJOmTIFSJFTNBO  BHFNFOUZFU QSPCMFNTPMWJOHQSPWJEFTPOFPGUIFLFZJODFOUJWFT 1JOLFSUPO  *OmTIFSJFTUISPVHIPVUUIFXPSMEJOUFSOBMDPOnJDUTBSJTFPWFSBDDFTT UPSFTPVSDFT QSPQFSUZSJHIUT HFBSUZQFT TQBDF BOENBSLFUT +FOUPGU FUBM  4FJYBTBOE#FSLFT 3FHVMBUPSZTZTUFNTBMXBZTJNQPTFSFTUSJD  UJPOTPOVTFSTBOEJUJTIBSEMZQPTTJCMFUPmOEBNFBTVSFGPSDPOTFSWJOHmTI TUPDLTUIBUEPFTOPUCFOFmUPOFSFTPVSDFVTFSNPSFUIBOPUIFST4PUIFSF BSFBMXBZTUIPTFXIPXJOBOEUIPTFXIPMPTF 3BBLKS/JFMTFO FUBM  5IFTFSFTUSJDUJPOTPOmTIFSTBOEVOFRVBMEJWJTJPOPGSFTPVSDFCFOFmUTFWJ  EFOUMZPGGFSHSFBUQPUFOUJBMGPSDPOnJDUT *OUFSFTUJOHMZ DPOnJDUJTOPUPOMZBEFTUSVDUJWF CVUDBOBMTPCFBDSFBUJWFGPSDF GPSSFTPVSDFNBOBHFNFOU 8JMTPOC 5IJTJTCFBVUJGVMMZJMMVTUSBUFE UISPVHIBDPNQBSBUJWFDBTFTUVEZCZ%POEB  JO.BMBXJ"U-BLF$IJVUB %FDPOUFYUVBMJTBUJPOSFGFSTUPUIFTFQBSBUJPOPGLOPXMFEHFGSPNJUTIVNBOBHFOUTBOEGSPNUIF TJUVBUJPOTJOXIJDIJUJTQSPEVDFE SFQSPEVDFE USBOTGPSNFEBOEQSFTVNBCMZBUJUTNPTUFGGFDUJWF &MMFOBOE)BSSJT 4FFBMTP)PCBSU  .

(14) . $0  ."/"(&.&/5. . DPOnJDUPWFSSFTPVSDFTNPUJWBUFEMPDBMDPNNVOJUJFTUPSFRVFTUUIFHPWFSO  NFOUGPSBTTJTUBODFJOTFUUJOHVQDPNBOBHFNFOUBSSBOHFNFOUT5ISPVHI UIFTFBSSBOHFNFOUT mTIFSTGPVOEBKVEJDJBMMZTPMJECBTFUPFYDMVEFPVUTJEFST GSPNUIFJSmTIJOHHSPVOET XIJDISFEVDFEDPOnJDUBOEJNQSPWFENBOBHF  NFOU $PNBOBHFNFOUBDDPNNPEBUFTGPSMPDBMDPOnJDUTUPCFSFTPMWFE$POnJDU SFTPMVUJPONFDIBOJTNTDBOIFMQUPGBDJMJUBUFOFHPUJBUJPOT GPSFYBNQMF PO BDDFTTSFHVMBUJPOTPSUIFEJWJTJPOPGCFOFmUT PSUIFJEFOUJmDBUJPOPGUIF NPTUBQQSPQSJBUFNFBTVSFT*GDPOnJDUT IPXFWFS JOWPMWFHSPVQTPVUTJEFUIF DPNNVOJUZ TUSVDUVSFTGPSDPPSEJOBUJPOBOEDPPSEJOBUJPOPOBIJHIFSMFWFM BSFVTVBMMZSFRVJSFE5IFDVSSFOUDIBMMFOHF BT)BOOB  QVUTJU JTUP EFWFMPQDPOnJDUSFTPMVUJPOQSPDFTTFTUIBUBDDPNNPEBUFIFUFSPHFOFPVTQBS  UJDJQBOUTBOENVMUJEJNFOTJPOBMDIBOHFXIJMFNBJOUBJOJOHUIFMFHJUJNBDZPG NBOBHFNFOU $PNQMJBODFBOEFOGPSDFNFOU $PNQMJBODFBOEFOGPSDFNFOUJOmTIFSJFTNBOBHFNFOUBSFPGUFOVOEFSTUPPE GSPNBOFDPOPNJDWJFXQPJOU JFUIFSBUJPOBMFUIBUmTIFSTBSFDBMDVMBUJOH UIFSJTLPGCFJOHDBVHIUXJUIUIFQPUFOUJBMCFOFmUTPGCZQBTTJOHUIFSVMFT 3BBLKS/JFMTFO *OUIJTTPDBMMFEJOTUSVNFOUBMQFSTQFDUJWF UIFBQ  QSPBDIUPSVMFDPNQMJBODFJTPGUFOHFBSFEUPXBSETNPOJUPSJOH DPOUSPMBOE FOGPSDFNFOU .$&BQQSPBDI *ODPOUSBTUUPUIJT TPDJBMTDJFOUJTUTMPPLBUJU GSPNBNPSFOPSNBUJWFQFSTQFDUJWFXIJDIQVUTTQFDJBMFNQIBTJTPOmTIFST JOUFSOBMJODFOUJWFTGPSDPNQMJBODFCFIBWJPVS TVDIBTOPSNT/PSNTGPSN UIFBUUJUVEFTBOEFYQFDUBUJPOTUPXBSETPUIFSTBOEUIFZDSFBUFTPDJBMQSFT  TVSF0OFPGUIFBTTVNQUJPOTJTUIBUJOEJWJEVBMEFDJTJPOTUPDPNQMZXJUI UIFSVMFTBSFMBSHFMZCBTFEPONPSBMPCMJHBUJPOPSQFFSHSPVQQSFTTVSF"D  UJWFQBSUJDJQBUJPOPGmTIFSTUIVTIFMQTUPDSFBUFBTUSPOHFSNPSBMPCMJHBUJPO PGJOEJWJEVBMTUPDPNQMZXJUIUIFSVMFTBOESFHVMBUJPOT +FOUPGU FUBM ,VQFSBOFUBM'PMLFFUBM  -FHJUJNBDZPGSVMFT SFHVMBUJPOTBOEUIFMBXFOGPSDFNFOUBVUIPSJUJFTJTBMTP BLFZJODFOUJWFGPSDPNQMJBODF5IFEJTUSJCVUJPOPGmTIJOHSJHIUTOFFETUPCF MFHJUJNBUF EJTUSJCVUJWFGBJSOFTT CVUBMTPUIFSFHVMBUPSZTZTUFN QSPDFEVSBM GBJSOFTT  5ZMFS3BBLKS/JFMTFO 5IFTUVEZPG TBTJJO.BMVLV TFF$IBQUFSBOE/PWBD[FL FUBM TIPXTUIBUWJMMBHFMFBEFSTPSNBO  BHFNFOUBVUIPSJUJFTXIPMPTFMFHJUJNBDZBTBDPOTFRVFODFPGQPMJUJDBMTUSJGF PSVOGBJSFMFDUJPOT PQFOUIFXBZGPSEJTPCFEJFODF(PWFSONFOUNBOBHFST PGUFOEPOPUSFBMJTFIPXJNQPSUBOUMFHJUJNBDZJTBOEIPXJNQPSUBOUJUJTUIBU UIFmTIFSTGFFMIFBSEBCPVUXIBUUIFZUIJOLOFFETUPCFEPOFBUUIFMPDBM MFWFM5IFTUSBUFHZUIVTJTUPFTUBCMJTIBMBSHFSEFHSFFPGDPOWFSHFODFCFUXFFO /PSNTDSFBUFTPDJBMQSFTTVSF.PSBMJTFTUBCMJTIFEJOJOUFSBDUJPOXJUIPUIFST CVUEJGGFSTGSPN OPSNTCZSFQSFTFOUJOHJOEJWJEVBMWBMVFTCBTFEPOQFSTPOBMSFnFDUJPOT (JEEFOT .

(15) . 4)035$0.*/(4.  0'  $0  ."/"(&.&/5 . QPMJUJDBMMZEFDJEFENBOBHFNFOUPCKFDUJWFTBOEXIBUmTIFSTQFSDFJWFBTMF HJUJNBUF. . . 5SBOTBDUJPODPTUT 5SBOTBDUJPODPTUTBSFEFmOFECZ8JMMJBNTPO  BTUIFDPNQBSBUJWFDPTUT PGQMBOOJOH BEBQUJOH BOENPOJUPSJOHVOEFSBMUFSOBUJWFHPWFSOBODFTUSVD  UVSFT*ODPNBOBHFNFOUUSBOTBDUJPODPTUTDBOCFEJWJEFEJOUPB JOGPSNB  UJPODPTUT C EFDJTJPONBLJOHDPTUT D PQFSBUJPOBMDPTUT BOEE UIFDPTUTGPS NPOJUPSJOH DPOUSPMBOEFOGPSDFNFOU ,VQFSBO FUBM  "DFOUSBMJTFE BQQSPBDIUPm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mTIFSTDBOQSPWJEFBEJSFDU TPVSDFPGSFMFWBOUJOGPSNBUJPOPOmTIJOHQBUUFSOT UIFTUBUFPGUIFSFTPVSDF BOEmTIDBUDIFT )BOOB 5IFPQFSBUJPOBMDPTUT UIFDPTUTGPSVOEFSUBL JOHUIFmTIJOHBDUJWJUJFT DBOCFSFEVDFEUISPVHINPSFFRVBMBDDFTTBOEB GBJSEJWJTJPOPGCFOFmUT5ISPVHIJUTQBSUJDJQBUPSZQSPDFTTDPNBOBHFNFOU JTBMTPFYQFDUFEUPJODSFBTFMFHJUJNBDZBOESVMFDPNQMJBODF XIJDI JOUVSO  GVSUIFSSFEVDFFOGPSDFNFOUDPTUT&OGPSDFNFOUDPTUTDBOCFGVSUIFSSFEVDFE XIFOWJPMBUJPOTPGSVMFTDBOCFIBOEMFEFGGFDUJWFMZBUMPDBMMFWFM +FOUPGUFUBM  . 

(16) 0DKNP?KIEJCOKB?K I=J=CAIAJP $PNBOBHFNFOUBTBTUSBUFHZPGGFSTBWJBCMFTPMVUJPOGPSEZTGVODUJPOBMSF  TPVSDFNBOBHFNFOUBOEPWFSFYQMPJUBUJPO#VUFWFOUIPVHIDPNBOBHFNFOU EPFTIBWFHSFBUQPUFOUJBMBOEIBTHBJOFEJODSFBTJOHBDDFQUBODFBNPOHTUHPW FSONFOU EFWFMPQNFOUBHFODJFTBOESFTFBSDIFST JODSFBTJOHFYQFSJFODFBOE XJEFSBQQMJDBUJPOIBWFCSPVHIUDFSUBJOTIPSUDPNJOHTBOEQJUGBMMTUPUIFMJHIU 5IFmSTU XIJDIJTBMSFBEZNFOUJPOFEJOBUUIFCFHJOOJOHPGUIJTDIBQUFS JT UIBUUIFDPODFQUPGDPNBOBHFNFOUJTOPUDMFBSMZEFmOFEBOENFBOTBEJGGFS FOUUIJOHUPEJGGFSFOUQFPQMF 0TTFXJKFS+FOUPGU3BBLKS/JFMTFO FUBM 5IFTFDPOETIPSUDPNJOHJTUIBU JONBOZDBTFT DPNBOBHFNFOU IBTCFDPNFMBSHFMZJOTUSVNFOUBM JFUIFJOWPMWFNFOUPGmTIJOHDPNNV  OJUJFTIBTCFFOMJNJUFEUPUIFJNQMFNFOUBUJPOQIBTFXJUIPVUIBWJOHCFFO JOWPMWFEJOEFWFMPQNFOUBOEQMBOOJOH 3BBLKS/JFMTFO FUBM  'PS.

(17) . $0  ."/"(&.&/5. . FYBNQMF UIF#FBDI7JMMBHF$PNNJUUFFTBU-BLF.BMPNCF BMTPJO.BMBXJ  GFMUUIFZXFSFEPJOHUIFAEJSUZXPSLGPSUIF'JTIFSJFT%FQBSUNFOUSBUIFSUIBO CFJOHJOWPMWFEBTQBSUOFST %POEB 5IJTUSFOENJHIUFWFOUVBMMZMFBEUP BTJUVBUJPOXPSTFUIBOCFGPSFCFDBVTFUIFGSVTUSBUJPOBNPOHUIFm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mUUJOHBOFYJTUJOH88'QSPKFDUJOUPBADPNBOBHFNFOUKBDLFUIBT OPUPOMZEJTUPSUFEUIFDPODFQUPGDPNBOBHFNFOUJOUIFSFHJPO CVUXIJMTU UIJTBQQSPBDINBZIBWFCFFOQPTTJCMFEVSJOHUIFDFOUSBMJTUJD4VIBSUPZFBST  JUIBTNPTUQSPCBCMZSVMFEPVUBOZTVQQPSUGPSAQSPQFSDPNBOBHFNFOU JO UIFGVUVSF. 

(18)  K I=J=CAIAJPPK@=U (MPCBMJTBUJPOJTBQSPDFTTUIBUJTJODSFBTJOHMZBGGFDUJOHNBOBHFNFOUPG OBUVSBMSFTPVSDFT.BSLFUTBSFPQFOJOHVQBOEMPDBMQSPDFTTFTBSFCFDPN  JOHNPSFBOENPSFUJFEUPHMPCBMJTTVFT"TUIFTDBMFJODSFBTFT mTIFSJFT NBOBHFNFOUTUSVDUVSFTIBWFUPBEBQU-PDBMDPNNVOJUJFTBOETPDJPQPMJUJDBM QSPDFTTFTBSFCFDPNJOHMJOLFEUPEJTUBOUMPDBMJUJFT BOEJOUFSOBUJPOBMFDP  OPNJDGPSDFT (JEEFOT 5IFQSFTFSWBUJPOPGCJPEJWFSTJUZBOEOBUVSBM SFTPVSDFTPOBHMPCBMTDBMFJTJNQPSUBOU CVUJUJTJNQPSUBOUUPSFBMJTFUIBUCJP EJWFSTJUZDPOTFSWBUJPOHFOFSBMMZDPODFSOTFDPTZTUFNTSBUIFSUIBOMPDBMDPN . *OIJTUIFTJT %POEB  DPNQBSFTUXPEJGGFSFOUQSPDFTTFTPGUIFFTUBCMJTINFOUPGDPNBO  BHFNFOU5IFmSTU JO-BLF$IJVUBXBTJOJUJBUFECZUIFMPDBMm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mTIFSJFT.

(19) . $0  ."/"(&.&/5.  50%": . . NVOJUJFT XIPDBOCFDPNFNBSHJOBMJ[FEJOUIFQSPDFTT #FSLFT+FOUPGU  "MTPJODPBTUBMmTIFSJFT MPDBMDPNNVOJUJFTDBOFODPVOUFSBMPTTPG DPOUSPMBOEBVUIPSJUZBTUIFTDBMFJODSFBTFT*OEVTUSJBMJTFEIJHIUFDImTIFS  JFTSFRVJSFTVCTUBOUJBMmOBODJBMBOEPSHBOJTBUJPOBMSFTPVSDFTBOEMPOHUFSN BDDFTTUPmTIFSJFT"TMPDBMDPNNVOJUJFTSBSFMZIBWFUIFNFBOTPSQPXFSUP DPVOUFSUIFTFQPXFSGVMEJTUBOUTUBLFIPMEFST UIFZBSFMJLFMZUPCFDPNFEJTFN QPXFSFE 3BBLKS/JFMTFOFUBM  "TUIFTDBMFPGSFTPVSDFNBOBHFNFOUJODSFBTFT BSBOHFPGOFXJTTVFTBSJTFT BTXFMMBTUIFOVNCFSBOEIFUFSPHFOFJUZPGSFTPVSDFVTFST5IJTNBLFTEFDJ TJPONBLJOHBOEDPPQFSBUJPONPSFDPNQMFY*UBMTPJODSFBTFTUIFDPTUTPG NPOJUPSJOHBOEFOGPSDFNFOU5IFRVFTUJPOBSJTFTXIFUIFSUIFmOEJOHTBOE FYQFSJFODFTPGDPNBOBHFNFOUPOUIFMPDBMMFWFMDBOCFTDBMFEVQ $PTUBO  [BFUBM &YQFSJFODFTGSPNUIF1IJMJQQJOFTBOE#BOHMBEFTI 3BBLKS /JFMTFO FUBM  TIPXUIBUMBSHFTDBMFSFTPVSDFTZTUFNTJOGBDUDBOCF IBOEMFECZDPNBOBHFNFOUJOTUJUVUJPOT CVUJUJTBMTPCFDPNJOHDMFBSUIBU EJGGFSFOUQSJODJQMFTDPNFJOUPQMBZBUEJGGFSFOUTDBMFT :PVOH $VSSFOU EFCBUFTGPDVTPOXIJDIUZQFTPGJOTUJUVUJPOBMBSSBOHFNFOUTBSFSFRVJSFEBOE POXIFUIFSUIFTUBOEBSEEFTJHOQSJODJQMFT 0TUSPN DBOCFTDBMFEVQ UPIJHIFSMFWFMTPGTPDJBMPSHBOJTBUJPO0OFXBZUPEFBMXJUIUIJTJTUPDSFBUF AOFTUFEJOTUJUVUJPOTBOEUISPVHIJOTUJUVUJPOBMJOUFSQMBZ5IJTMBTUTUSVDUVSFJT BMTPJNQPSUBOUJOEFBMJOHXJUIVODFSUBJOUZ BOPUIFSSFDVSSFOUJTTVFJOmTIFS JFTNBOBHFNFOU $IBSMFT  6ODFSUBJOUZSFGFSTUPTPDJBMBOEOBUVSBMTZTUFNTUIBUBSFIJHIMZEZOBNJDBOE XJUIMJNJUFEQSFEJDUBCJMJUZ5IFDIBMMFOHFJOmTIFSJFTNBOBHFNFOUJTUPNBLF EFDJTJPOTJOSFMBUJPOUPUIJTVODFSUBJOUZ 8JMTPO 0WFSUIFZFBST UIF QSPCMFNTIBWFCFDPNFQSPHSFTTJWFMZNPSFDPNQMFYBOEEJGmDVMUUPNBOBHF 0WFSmTIJOH PDFBOEJTQPTBMBOETQJMMT UIFEFTUSVDUJPOPGDPBTUBMFDPTZTUFNT  MBOECBTFEDPOUBNJOBUJPOBOEDMJNBUFDIBOHFBGGFDUNBSJOFFDPTZTUFNTBOE DPOWFOUJPOBMNBOBHFNFOUBQQSPBDIFTCBTFEPOQSFEJDUBCJMJUZIBWFCFDPNF JODSFBTJOHMZVOXPSLBCMF $PTUBO[B 0OFTPMVUJPOUPEFBMXJUIVODFS  UBJOUZJTTPVHIUJOBEBQUJWFmTIFSJFTNBOBHFNFOUXIJDIJTACBTFEPOJOTUJUV UJPOBMTUSVDUVSFTXIJDIDBOFWBMVBUFPVUDPNFT EFWFMPQOFXVOEFSTUBOEJOHT PGUIFTJUVBUJPO BOEUBLFDPSSFDUJWFBDUJPOCPUIJOUFSNTPGNBOBHFNFOU NFBTVSFTBOEUIFJOTUJUVUJPOBMGSBNFXPSLGPSNBOBHFNFOUEFDJTJPOT %FH OCPMBOE3BBLKS/JFMTFO -FBSOJOHGSPNQBTUFYQFSJFODFTBOENPEJ mDBUJPOGPSGVUVSFBDUJPOJTBOJNQPSUBOUQSPDFTTUPCFJODMVEFEJODPNBO  BHFNFOU.

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nVFODFECZIJHIFSMFWFMSVMFTBOESFHVMBUJPOTBOEWJDFWFSTB BOEUIFTVD  DFTTGVMFYFSDJTFPGSJHIUTPOPOFMFWFMUIVTEFQFOETTUSPOHMZPOUIFFYFSDJTF PGSJHIUTPGUIFPUIFS -JOLJOHJOTUJUVUJPOT IPXFWFS JTNPSFUIBOKVTUEFMJWFSJOHEFDJTJPOTVQBOE EPXOXSJUF%FHOCPMFUBM  %FDJTJPONBLFSTIBWFSFTQPOTJCJMJUJFTWJT ¹WJTUIPTFUIFZSFQSFTFOU)FODF BDDPVOUBCJMJUZBOEUSBOTQBSFODZBSFJNQPS UBOUBOEEFQFOENVDIPOUIFQSPDFEVSFTBOEDPNNVOJDBUJPO%FNPDSBUJD TFMFDUJPOBOEUIFQPTTJCJMJUZUPSFNPWFBSFQSFTFOUBUJWFBSFLFZTJODSFBUJOH BDDPVOUBCJMJUZ*UJTGVSUIFSNPSFJNQPSUBOUIPXJOGPSNBUJPOJTFYDIBOHFE  IPXDPOnJDUTBSFTPMWFEBOEIPXBHSFFNFOUTPSDPNQSPNJTFTBSFSFBDIFE "DIBMMFOHFGPSNBOBHFNFOUJOTUJUVUJPOTJTUPAUSBOTMBUFDFSUBJOUZQFTPGJO  GPSNBUJPOGSPNPOFMFWFMUPBOPUIFS5IFUSBOTGFSPGJOGPSNBUJPOPOSFTPVSDF NBOBHFNFOUUPEJGGFSFOUKVSJTEJDUJPOBMTDBMFT JTBQSPDFTTJOXIJDIBMPUPG JOGPSNBUJPOGSFRVFOUMZHFUTMPTU %FHOCPMFUBM  5IFSFJTBMTPPGUFOBAMBOHVBHFCBSSJFSCFUXFFOMFWFMTPGJOTUJUVUJPOT5PUBDLMF UIJTQSPCMFN EJGGFSFOUTFUTPGTLJMMTBUEJGGFSFOUMFWFMTBSFOFFEFEUPFOIBODF DPNNVOJDBUJPOBOEVOEFSTUBOEJOH %FHOCPMBOE3BBLKS/JFMTFO  "OFXQIFOPNFOPONFOUJPOFEUPEFBMXJUIDPNNVOJDBUJPOQSPCMFNTBU WBSJPVTMFWFMTBSFXIBU%FHOCPMFUBM  DBMMAQSBDUJUJPOFSTPSADJSDVJUFST XIPNPWFBNPOHUIFOFTUFENBOBHFNFOUJOTUJUVUJPOT TVQQPSUJOHOFHPUJB  UJPOTBOEQSPWJEJOHJOGPSNBUJPO5IFTFQSBDUJUJPOFSTOFFEBWBSJFUZPGTLJMMT GSPNEFDJTJPONBLJOHQSPDFTTFTBOEDPOnJDUNBOBHFNFOU UPFYQFSUJTFJO TPDJPDVMUVSBMBOECJPMPHZSFMBUFEmFMET*ONZWJFX UIJTSPMFJTUZQJDBMMZPOF PGBGBDJMJUBUPS BQFSTPOXIPCVJMETCSJEHFTCFUXFFOQBSUJFTXJUIPVUQFSTPOBM JOWPMWFNFOU"OUISPQPMPHJTUT VTFEUPAUSBOTMBUJOHDVMUVSBMBTQFDUTBOEFY  QSFTTJPOTUPBOPUIFS DPVMEGVMmMBOJNQPSUBOUSPMFIFSF. /FTUFETZTUFNTNBOBHFNFOUJOTUJUVUJPOTFYJTUXJUIJOBIJFSBSDIJDBMTUSVDUVSFJOXIJDIEFDJ  TJPOTBSFNBEFBUUIFMPXFTUQPTTJCMFBQQSPQSJBUFTDBMF TVCTJEJBSJUZQSJODJQMF  *XJMMOPUHPEFFQFSJOUPEFmOJUJPOTPGEFNPDSBDZ CVUJOUIJTDPOUFYUJUSFGFSTUPFMFDUJPOQSPDF EVSFTGPSSFQSFTFOUBUJWFT6OEFNPDSBUJDSFQSFTFOUBUJPO JFCZBQQPJOUNFOU DBOCFIJHIMZMFHJUJ  NBUFBTJTUIFDBTFJO*OEPOFTJB TFF$IBQUFS .

(21) . 5)&  30-&  0'  5)&  "/5)3010-0(*45. . . 

(22) 1DANKHAKBPDA=JPDNKLKHKCEOP 4JODFQFPQMFIBWFCFFOBDLOPXMFEHFEBTBDUJWFQBSUJDJQBOUTJOSFTPVSDFNBO BHFNFOU UIFDPOUSJCVUJPOPGTPDJBMTDJFODFToBOEBOUISPQPMPHZJOQBSUJDVMBS oJOUIFTUVEZBOEJNQMFNFOUBUJPOPGOBUVSBMSFTPVSDFNBOBHFNFOUIBTJO  DSFBTFE"TJTDMFBSGSPNUIFBCPWF UIFSFJTBHFOFSBMEFNBOEUPDPNQMFNFOU UIFTDJFOUJmDLOPXMFEHFPGCJPMPHJTUTBOEFDPOPNJTUTPOmTITUPDLTBOENBS LFUT XJUILOPXMFEHFPOUIFTPDJPDVMUVSBMBTQFDUTPGmTIFSTBOEmTIFSJFT NBOBHFNFOU #PXFOBOE3JMFZ+FOUPGU #VUXIBUFYBDUMZJTJU UIBUUIFBOUISPQPMPHJTUDBODPOUSJCVUF  "OUISPQPMPHZFOUBJMTBMBSHFSBOHFPGBDUJWJUJFTBOEBQQSPBDIFT.JMUPO   EJTUJOHVJTIFTUXPNBKPSSPMFTGPSBOUISPQPMPHJTUTJOFOWJSPONFOUBMJTN5IF m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mDJOQVU FHCJPMPHJDBMBOEFDPOPNJD JONBOBHFNFOUPGOBUVSBMSFTPVSDFTBOEFOWJSPONFOUBMJTTVFT*U DBO IPXFWFS BMTPCFBUUSJCVUFEUPBOUISPQPMPHJTUTUIFNTFMWFTXIPIBWFIJTUPSJDBMMZGPDVTFEPO JOEFQUIDBTFTUVEJFTXJUIPVUCFJOHBCMFPSXJMMJOHUPFYUFOEUIFJSGPDVTCFZPOEUIFMPDBMTJUVBUJPO VOEFSTUVEZ3FTVMUTXFSFOPUFYUSBQPMBUFEUPPUIFSTJUFTPSXJEFSEFCBUFT QBSUMZCFDBVTFPGUIF FUIJDBMDPEFTUIBULFQUBOUISPQPMPHJTUGSPNTIBSJOH TPNFUJNFTTFOTJUJWF JOGPSNBUJPO TFFBMTP 1FSTPPOBOE)PCCFT .

(24)

Referenties

Download het nu ( PDF - 17 pagina - 170.96 KB )

GERELATEERDE DOCUMENTEN

Fisheries co-management, the role of local institutions and decentralisation in Southeast Asia : with specific reference to marine sasi in Central Maluku, Indonesia

MPXT NPTUPGUIFMBSHFTIFMMTXFSFHPOF7JMMBHFSTCFMJFWFUIFUPQTIFMMTXFSF QSPCBCMZTUPMFOEVSJOHUIF$ISJTUNBTBDUJWJUJFTJOUIFWJMMBHF5IFDBUDIXBT TPMEGPS3Q LHGPSUIFIJHIRVBMJUZTIFMMT LH BOE3Q

Fisheries co-management, the role of local institutions and decentralisation in Southeast Asia : with specific reference to marine sasi in Central Maluku, Indonesia

8SJUUFOSVMFT TBODUJPOTBOEDFSFNPOJFT 8SJUUFOSVMFTXFSFGPVOEJOPGTBTJWJMMBHFTBOEFYJTUFEJOWJMMBHFTPGBMM TJ[FT

Fisheries co-management, the role of local institutions and decentralisation in Southeast Asia : with specific reference to marine sasi in Central Maluku, Indonesia

Fisheries co-management, the role of local institutions and decentralisation in Southeast Asia : with specific reference to marine sasi in Central Maluku, Indonesia.. Not Applicable

Fisheries co-management, the role of local institutions and decentralisation in Southeast Asia : with specific reference to marine sasi in Central Maluku, Indonesia

Fisheries co-management, the role of local institutions and decentralisation in Southeast Asia : with specific reference to marine sasi in Central Maluku, Indonesia.. Not Applicable

Fisheries co-management, the role of local institutions and decentralisation in Southeast Asia : with specific reference to marine sasi in Central Maluku, Indonesia

0DKNP?KIEJCOEJPDA?QNNAJPOUOPAI "TNVDIPGUIFJODPNFJTEFSJWFEGSPNOBUVSBMSFTPVSDFVTF SFWFOVFEJTUSJ CVUJPOXJMMWBSZFOPSNPVTMZGSPNSFHJPOUPSFHJPO #SPXOJO1BUMJT FU BM

Fisheries co-management, the role of local institutions and decentralisation in Southeast Asia : with specific reference to marine sasi in Central Maluku, Indonesia

NVOJUZBOEFDPOPNJDEFWFMPQNFOU 1PNFSPZ "OPUIFSBTTVNQUJPO

Fisheries co-management, the role of local institutions and decentralisation in Southeast Asia : with specific reference to marine sasi in Central Maluku, Indonesia

Fisheries co-management, the role of local institutions and decentralisation in Southeast Asia : with specific reference to marine sasi in Central Maluku, Indonesia.. Not Applicable

Fisheries co-management, the role of local institutions and decentralisation in Southeast Asia : with specific reference to marine sasi in Central Maluku, Indonesia

Fisheries co-management, the role of local institutions and decentralisation in Southeast Asia : with specific reference to marine sasi in Central Maluku, Indonesia.. Not Applicable