1
Silicon Solutions for the Real World Silicon Solutions for the Real World
AID-EMC
Automotive IC Design for Low EMC
AID-EMC
Automotive IC Design for Low EMC
Review Meeting 29 augustus 2006 VILVOORDE
KUL-ESAT-MICAS
Slide 2 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
Agenda Agenda
Structure of the IWT project Progress per workpackage
WP1:
WP2:
WP3:
WP4:
Status Deliverables Resources used
Cooperation
Conclusions
Slide 3 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
Structure of the project Structure of the project
WP2 Analog
specs Comparison
of results
Comparison of results specs
Improved design techniques
Improved design techniques
WP3 Digital
WP4 CAD WP1 Specs &
Measurements
WP2 Analog
specs Comparison
of results
Comparison of results specs
Improved design techniques
Improved design techniques
WP3 Digital
WP4 CAD WP1 Specs &
Measurements
4
Silicon Solutions for the Real World Silicon Solutions for the Real World
WP1: Specifications and measurements
WP1: Specifications and
measurements
Slide 5 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
WP1: Technical problems WP1: Technical problems
Nearly impossible to achieve
Slide 6 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
T1.1: Correlation between different test set-ups
T1.1: Correlation between different test set-ups
Target is to increase current handling
Slide 7 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
T1.2: Influence of PCB and attached cabling
T1.2: Influence of PCB and attached cabling
VDMOS is more stable and robust
Slide 8 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
T1.3: Validation of the ICEM model T1.3: Validation of the ICEM model
Need for additional
Selection
Slide 9 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
T1.4: Characterization of the coupling paths
T1.4: Characterization of the coupling paths
Need for additional
Selection
Slide 10 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
T1.5: Measurements T1.5: Measurements
Need for additional
Selection
Slide 11 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
Contributions by partners Contributions by partners
AMIS
Aa bb
KUL-ESAT
aa
KHBO
cc
Slide 12 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
WP1: Innovation Realised WP1: Innovation Realised
Improved
13
Silicon Solutions for the Real World Silicon Solutions for the Real World
WP2: EMC susceptibility of analogue circuits
WP2: EMC susceptibility of
analogue circuits
Slide 14 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
WP2: Technical problems WP2: Technical problems
LDMOS
Surface
Slide 15 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
T2.1: Finalization of the LIN driver T2.1: Finalization of the LIN driver
Design
Use
Slide 16 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
T2.2: Design DC current regulator with low EMS
T2.2: Design DC current regulator with low EMS
ESD
Slide 17 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
T2.3: Design input structure with low EMS
T2.3: Design input structure with low EMS
Optimize
Slide 18 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
T2.4: Design input structure with high common mode rejection
T2.4: Design input structure with high common mode rejection
Optimize
Slide 19 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
T2.3: Design guidelines for low EMS T2.3: Design guidelines for low EMS
Optimize
Slide 20 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
Contributions by partners Contributions by partners
AMIS
Aa bb
KUL-ESAT
aa
KHBO
cc
Slide 21 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
WP2: Innovation Realised WP2: Innovation Realised
New Better
Guidelines
Technical Risks
Protection Protection
22
Silicon Solutions for the Real World Silicon Solutions for the Real World
WP3: Digital techniques
WP3: Digital techniques
Slide 23 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
WP3: Technical problems WP3: Technical problems
Logic families with reduced current variation
how logic circuits can be designed in such a way that they generate less current variation (di/dt) in the supply lines
EMC-friendly clock strategy
how the electromagnetic radiation caused by digital circuits can be reduced by adapting the clock strategy.
Slide 24 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
T3.1: Design of EMC-friendly logic families - I
T3.1: Design of EMC-friendly logic families - I
Selection of EMC-friendly logic family:
6 different logic design techniques are compared,
The design goal is to reduce di/dt noise while still keep the compromise on the speed, power, area trade-off under control, Based on the simulations, we conclude that CSL logic is the best choice.
Comparison of CSL and SCMOS:
The CSL logic produces an amount of di/dt noise almost 36dB smaller than the SCMOS logic,
If controlled properly, we can keep the power of CSL circuit comparable to the SCMOS,
CSL show a smaller area per logic function for complex digital gates and systems.
Slide 25 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
T3.1: Design of EMC-friendly logic families - II
T3.1: Design of EMC-friendly logic families - II
Target : Mixed-Mode Automotive Electronics Design Key aspects : di/dt + Power + Area + Speed
Inv erter Power in different logic techniques
0.00E+00 5.00E+01 1.00E+02 1.50E+02 2.00E+02 2.50E+02
SCMOS PNMOS RSBMOS CSL MCML FSCL
Power [μW]
Inv erter area in different logic techniques
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4
SCMOS PNMOS RSBMOS CSL MCML FSCL
Area [μm2]
Ring Oscillator of 21-stages
(Static + Dynamic)
Current Steering Logic
But there is static power !!
di/dt Peak-Peak Power Area
Slide 26 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
T3.1: Design of EMC-friendly logic families - III
T3.1: Design of EMC-friendly logic families - III
Power spectrum density Power spectrum density of di/dt comparison
of di/dt comparison
SCMOS
CSL 36dB
Slide 27 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
T3.2: EMC-friendly clock strategies - I
T3.2: EMC-friendly clock strategies - I
Clock skew
Clock skew:
based on the introduction of different skews to the branches of a clock tree.Only 2-5dB reduction,
Need smart algorithm to control and optimize the skew.
Spread Spectrum Clock Generation(SSCG)
Spread Spectrum Clock Generation(SSCG):
based on an existing DLL idea.Spread the clock period by a programmable amount, Fully digital and simple implementation,
More than 12dB on the maximum di/dt power spectrum reduction.
2 different clock strategies are studied:
Slide 28 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
T3.2: EMC-friendly clock strategies - II
T3.2: EMC-friendly clock strategies - II
Spectrum from 300MHz to 800MHz
Spread Spectrum
Clock
Regular Clock
12dB reduction
Zoom in
A test chip for SSCG will be designed to prove the A test chip for SSCG will be designed to prove the
simulation(next project phase).
simulation(next project phase).
Problem remains: introduction into a standard Problem remains: introduction into a standard
design flow.
design flow.
Slide 29 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
T3.3: Test chip for the EMI Suppressing Regulator - I T3.3: Test chip for the EMI
Suppressing Regulator - I
The EMI suppressing regulator replaces the EMC-friendly logic:
Control the way the current delivered to the internal digital core, hence keep the EMI under control,
Compatible with conventional CMOS logic,
Large EMI reduction is ensured (40dB), comparable with low noise digital cells only,
More power efficient than low noise logic cells,
Can be adjusted to a wide range of chip size and power consumption level.
Slide 30 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
T3.3: Test chip for the EMI Suppressing Regulator - II T3.3: Test chip for the EMI
Suppressing Regulator - II
current of Vbat
di/dt p-p =8.5x104 [A/s]
load current of digital core
FFT FFT
di/dt p-p =1.8x109 [A/s]
di/dt of Vbat di/dt
of V3v3
40dB (EMI regulator) + 20dB (Serial regulator 40dB (EMI regulator) + 20dB (Serial regulator))
9x106
7x103
Slide 31 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
T3.3: Test chip for the EMI Suppressing Regulator - III T3.3: Test chip for the EMI Suppressing Regulator - III
Micrograph of the RD2E test chip and the EMI suppressing regulator
EMI
Suppressing regulator
Slide 32 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
T3.3: Test chip for the EMI Suppressing Regulator - IV T3.3: Test chip for the EMI Suppressing Regulator - IV
Measurements
di/dt@Vbat
di/dt@source
> 5x reduction
> 5x reduction
TBD:
• figure out low current capability problem,
• detailed measurements will be ready in 2nd phase
Slide 33 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
Contributions by partners Contributions by partners
AMIS
Deliver specifications for the chip, Deliver design kit,
Process the chip,
Evaluate the chip measurement results.
KUL-ESAT-MICAS
Scientific analysis, Chip design,
Chip measurements.
KHBO
Advice on the EMC measurements.
Slide 34 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
WP3: Innovation Realized WP3: Innovation Realized
Innovative characters:
It addresses the problem of electromagnetic radiation at its very source,
A systematic approach for radiation reduction is developed (includes a EMI suppressing
regulator).
A clever clock design strategy to guarantee low
EMI is designed.
35
Silicon Solutions for the Real World Silicon Solutions for the Real World
WP4: Computer-aided EMC analysis
WP4: Computer-aided EMC
analysis
Slide 36 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
WP4: Technical problems WP4: Technical problems
Technical problem
Slide 37 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
T4.1: Models for EMS simulation framework
T4.1: Models for EMS simulation framework
Improve
Slide 38 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
T4.2: Development of EMS simulation framework
T4.2: Development of EMS simulation framework
Design
Slide 39 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
T4.3: Automated generation of EM- inclusive behavioral models
T4.3: Automated generation of EM- inclusive behavioral models
The best
Slide 40 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
T4.4: Industrial EMC design flow T4.4: Industrial EMC design flow
The best
Slide 41 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
Contributions by partners Contributions by partners
AMIS
Aa bb
KUL-ESAT
aa
KHBO
cc
Slide 42 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
WP4: Innovation Realised WP4: Innovation Realised
Self-protecting Know-how
Design guidelines Technical risks
Conflicting aaa
Slide 43 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
Status Deliverables Status Deliverables
Main result:
Slide 44 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
Cooperation Cooperation
Flemish partners
KUL ESAT KHBO
AMIS
Slide 45 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
Resources (1)
Resources (1)
Slide 46 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
Resources (2)
Resources (2)
Slide 47 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
Conclusions Conclusions
38% basis funding percentage
Slide 48 AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
AID-EMC review meeting 29/08/2006 CONFIDENTIAL
Silicon Solutions for the Real World!
KUL-ESAT-MICAS