Ecological compensation of highway impacts; negotiated trade-off or no-net-loss?
Cuperus, R.
Citation
Cuperus, R. (2005, January 13). Ecological compensation of highway impacts; negotiated trade-off or no-net-loss?. Retrieved from https://hdl.handle.net/1887/581
Version: Not Applicable (or Unknown)
License: Licence agreement concerning inclusion of doctoral thesis in the Institutional Repository of the University of Leiden
Downloaded from: https://hdl.handle.net/1887/581
Note: To cite this publication please use the final published version (if applicable).
E cological compensation of highway impacts :
N egotiated trade - off or no - net - loss ?
"7 "$'&'& &'*+/78*)&2 "344 "89.:,:34;=<
>?@BAADCE%F1GF4HIAGJ?@BKLNMOF1GFQPR-KLNST1ADUAWV4F4CX
E cological compensation of highway impacts :
N egotiated trade - off or no - net - loss ?
Z [-\ ]_^a`b_c)[d^ae
fg+h1i1g+h:jh-klnm4k'o)mi1p5o
q
gm4h:p4p
q
i7p4osrutv+fthp4p5o
q
gwxo)ki1g+h-y:k'fg+kf7z7g+k
q
g+o{
t|m5g}p5m~i1p4o
q
gxxgv+fthp4m5o)k'k'vyruh0 rQ rQ #h-gk'gh'{
t)tm4'gh:p4p5hko q
g8p4v'fg+kf q
g+h)ky:jo
q
g8go
p4f)h0"gfgoy:v
p4||)gougo
q
k'g
q
gh1ug+o)gg+y-j)o
q
g+{
i1tm4g+oygy:')k'fBi7p4o
g+fxt'gm5g1i1tthh:tstfk'gy
fg1i1gh q g q
k'm4got|
q
t)o
q
gh
q
p4m7lnp4o)p4h:k)
j)t)jj)g!+) J))h
q
t5t5h
8 h
q
8)| g_h y
m4gth:g+oufgy:Qh-pi1go
p4m4g
ko+ ))¡
¬ ®)¯°® ±a® -² ¬):®)³W´ µ0´ ¶´'·´)¸xµ®°µ¹¶º4¹»
¼ ® ½¿¾ ®¯°® ±¿® D² Àu'´Á´ÂB´ ¼ º4ñ¹:»
Ä8¹³a¹-¹_Ã)±a² ¬):®)³W´Åµ'´Ä´Æ´Æ´ÅÇ®-¯º4Ãȶº40É1º5-µ¸ÃÊÉ1¹:»:Ê'±Ë5È
¼ ºB¯sÌ-ʵ)Í4¹Îa¸Ï4·#Ð
Ñ É1¹:Ê'Í4¹Ò'¹+µ)¹+ò ¬-®³´µ'´¬´Ó7º4º4»
¬):®³´5µ'´5¬_´5ÔuÒ'º4»:̹ÕÍ4¹ÃÈ5¸xÃÊÉ1¹:»:Ê'±¹+ʱŸx±-¹+Ö×±
¬):®³´µ´Ø#´É1º4õ)¹+Ù¹+ÊÚnµ¹Ã
¬):®³´ µ)0´¬_´Ç´Ù´ Ñ ¾)µº4¯ÈÛܺ4Í4¹+ÃÊÃÍ4¹+øxÃÊÉ7¹:»:ʱW¹Ê'±
Ý
Ĺ»-¹º4-Ö× ¼ ¹Ã)±-Þ)¯
¬):®³´µ'´ÔQ´Äx´µ¹~Ï4Ã)®®
Æ ×)Ê'»ß:¹»:¹+º4:Ö×8à"º4»ßÖ+®)õÞÖ±W¹µÊñ׹~á¹±×¹:Ò'º4õ»ß®+É7¹ß±à"®¾¹:Ê'®µ»#º5±²
½â±×¹ãWÃ)»:±Ê'±Þ±¹®³)Ø#ÃÉ1Ê:®Ã¯¹Ã±º4Ò4Ï4Ö+ʹ+ÃÖ¹+»7®³)ä7¹+ʵ¹+Ãu¸ÃÊÉ1¹+-»:Ê'±ËsÎ-åæDçèéBê+ëì5í)íé
îðïñ'ïæ+êòuæèæDçónôDõö4÷)÷æDç ø æWï-ùæWçú+³®:¯s¹+:ÒË1² åxæWçèéBêëûì4ííé1îðï'ñ'ïæêüêçùæø æDïùæWç5Ð
ÎÕý+þ þ ÿ ½ýþ þ+ÐÕȺnà µ
½â±×¹ÀuÞ±Ö×QÙÊÃÊ'»:±0Ë°®³Æ-º5Ã)»:¾®:±È4¬ÞÌ)Ò'Ê'ÖÅÛÜ®)»#º4õÛܺ4±¹#Ùº4ú4Í4¹¯¹Ã±
Îïnü)óBò~ö1èæDé-óBèö4ö1èÐ_ÈÄ®º4µº5Ã)µ¶!Ë7µ):º4ÞÒ'ÊÖ~Ø#Ã)Í5Êù¹+:ÊÃÍJÀuÊÉ1Ê»:Ê'®ÃÎïæDç)óBè ðæ ÅæWç
söÅèaæé í)ê òüßê+çßù)æ0Ð7Îýþ)þ)½+ÐÈ+À ¹_Ò³a±¿´
¼ Þ¾¹:Þ»:È5Äx´5ÎÐ_´5Ø#Ö®Ò'®)Í4Ê'Ö+º4Ò5Ö®¯¾¹Ã»:º4±Ê'®)î³×Ê'Í4×à"ºÕËʯ¾º4Ö±W»-²5á¹+Í4®±Ê'º4±¹µ
±a-ºBµ)¹½a®)³³®)Ã)®)½aÃ)¹±a½Ò®)»-»
ã¿ÏnÓ1áþ ½ þ)½¿ÿ ÿßý½
ÀÛ Û ½½
Àu¹»:Ê'Í4ð³:®)ñ¾º4Í4¹+²Ï4±:º4¾º4±+ÈÀu¹+Ò'³±È_Æ ×¹~á¹±W×)¹+:Òº5Ã)µ»
¬):Ê'ñ¹+µÌËÏ4±:º5¾)º5±ÈÀQ¹Ò'³±È_Æ ×¹~á¹±×¹+:Òº4õ»
Contents
!#"$%$%&(') *
!#&+$%,.-0/p-3 44
56#78:9<;>=?87@ABC.8D@?E8@F8GHIH.C.@J@0KLDC<6#J(C<@MONH<?P6#8D@?EN7D?C.DNJHQ6#?A
8@E8GHIRBH.P8D@?P6#?AEDPPBH<P6#AA7H.PPH<AED?E8GDPSADPPH.786#8D@? T 4
U<VXW-1'ZY["\]12Y- T^
U]VU _ 2`1Y')%Ya1b,c,<\.YdY3#2\<&#d+\<Y$%e,<-`Y-fe'2-\<2ed,
2-E1b,Qg%,.1b,.'d&#-[` T(h
U]Vi j ,k/L,.dYe$%,<-1L&#-[O`23#-2a2\<&#-\.,lYaL1b,l,.\<YdY3#2\.&+d
\.Y$Oe,.-`Y-me'2-\.2ed, ^(n
U]V4 o\<YdY3#2\<&#d(\.Y$%e,.-`Y-p(1b,Q2-1,.'-&+12Y-&#d(\<Y-1,kq:1 ^ 4
U]VT r '&#\.12\.&+d2``",<`:&#'2`2-3m["'2-3m2$Oed,.$%,<-1Y-f2-s1b,tg%,<1b,.'d&#-[` ^u
U]V^ v b,Iw",.`12Y-`S&#-[x2``",.`S&#[[',.``,<`S2-x1b2`S[2``,<'1Y- ^(y
U]Vu v b,I2``",<`-Y1&#[[',.``,.[x2-x1b2`S[2``,<'1Y- ^ *
U]Vh z ,<&#[,.'`{3#"2[, un
56#78|;~}O78DC.JH.P6#?AxPBMOM%6#7%@7H<PBJ8P u^
iV o\<YdY3#2\.&#d\.Y$%e,.-`Y-sYa1b,2$Oe&#\<1`QYaL&F'Y&#[e',<d2$%2-&#')
$O,<1bY[FaY'L1b,Q ^n 'Y&#[Fd2-Fo2-[bY</L,<-%``(1b,Qg%,.1b,.'d&#-[` uh
sF0:k0(O.k#(#:tQ.s% ¡Q¢£¤¤¥Z¦
§F¨.©0ª©<«+¡Z¨k#ª§I«#¡:<¡«¬¤®<¯m°0±®²¤
4 VX³ "2[,<d2-,.`aY',<\.YdY3#2\<&#d\.Y$%e,.-`Y-f&#``Y\<2&+1,.[´µ21bfb23#b0´µ&¶)L` U n U
sf0Q(0(]s<#Qk.·¸kª¡#:s¹x©sL·%Lk
º».¼0l½L¾¡Z<<¿%#µ¢£¤¤¤Z¦
ÀI¡Z©0ª©<«+¡Z¨k#ª©<((Á¶L¡©0¤Ã(²£±Ä£
T V o\<YdY3#2\.&#d\.Y$%e,<-`&+12Y-s2- j "1\<bfb23#b<´Å&¶)¬ed&#--2-3 U¶i *
ss0:k(<(.ÆX#(¨<©lÆÇ%.ÀI#ÈQ¿%#(.·»ª¡+:s¹E©s·%L
O.k+#S#Qk¢¯QÃãk¦
§QQÁ¡©<¿¸:
ÒÓÕÔÖ×<ØÙ#ÖÙ#ÚÛÜÝsÙ#ÝÞfÛß%Øà×<ßO×<ÝÚÙ#ÚÛÜÝfÜáâ×ãL×<Ýf×<ä.ÜàÜå#Ûä.Ù+à
ä.ÜßOØ×.ÝâÙ(ÚÛÜÝFØàÙ#ÝâLáÜÖLæEçÚä.èFèÛå#è0éµÙ¶êLâ ë¶ì#í
îsïïðfñï<òQókô(ï<õ(ö]÷Xø#ôùó.ókúfûlø+ùõ(üó.ókýQö]þ¸ókùÿø#õEðfðóLþ%øLóõ
ûOó.ókõ (ñø#ú ókôõ ö
Qú¶ÿô<ú¸óúø(ù÷Xø(úøLó»óú !"#$ %&#'
ìÓ)(lÜß%Ø×.ÝâÙ#ÚÛÝåÉáÜÖ×.ä<ÜàÜå#Ûä.Ù#àÛß%ØÙ+ä.ÚâÜáÖÜÙ#ÞfÞ×kãL×.àÜØß%×<ÝÚ+*
â×ãL×<ÝêL×.Ù+Öâ-,×!.QØ×<ÖÛ×.Ýä.×LéµÛÚè0/%Ûå#è0éµÙ ê21Ò3546ÛÝÞèÜ0ãL×<Ý78%ââ:9
;O×]Úè×.ÖàÙ(ÝÞâ=< ë?>#í
îsïïðxñlï0òQóô(ï0õ(ö?@#ÿ=A0ú:óCBED 0ùóúQö þ¸ókúýF ø#úµðóCGA0ùHõ:Dø#ø#ô
lúú:ó%÷Xø(ôÿZóIôø#øJ +ö
÷»ÿùÿZó.ïLK #$!"#%KLM»ïN+DO ï0ôúø(ùöôø(úõùøPó.ðQ
R Ó)Sß%ØÖÜ0ãLÛÝåm×<ä.ÜàÜå#Ûä.Ù#àÛÝØçÚÛÝfæxçÚä.èsÖÜÙ#ÞsØàÙ#ÝÝÛÝå TLë¶Ò
îfïïðñlï.òóô0ï.õOJ$!#ö
ûsóú÷AIîlý:óúUK$!"V%KUM¸ïN+D Eï<ôúø#ùZöôø(úõùøó.ð!
WÓ)X#çßOß%Ù#Öê%ÜáÖ×<âçàÚâ T#í#í
WÓë Yl×<âçàÚâÜÝEØàÙ#ÝÝÛÝålÙ#ÝÞEÞ×<ä.ÛâÛÜÝ7ß%Ù[ZÛÝå T#í#ì
WÓT Yl×.âçàÚâLÜÝFÛßOØà×.ß%×.ÝÚÙ#ÚÛÜÝ T#í[W
WÓí Yl×.âçàÚâLÜÝFä.ÜßOØ×.ÝâÙ(ÚÛÜÝFä.ÜâÚâ T[\[3
WÓ\ Yl×<âçàÚâÜÝE×ãLÙ#àçÙ#ÚÛÜÝEÙ#ÝÞEß%ÜÝÛÚÜÖÛÝå T[\Lë
WÓÒ Yl×<âçàÚâ:ÜÝfà×<å#Ù#àÙ#âØ×.ä<Úâ T[\Lë
WÓì Yl×.âçàÚâLÜÝFØç]àÛä:âçØØÜÖÚ T[\[T
WÓR Yl×<âçàÚâÜÝxå#Ù#ØâÛÝ^ZÝÜ0éµà×<Þå#× T[\#í
_`[a-bcdfe^gh-ijh:h-g=klmiklinjh-gklh-ma-oikp2p2olq`[bg=klhP`[lqLroa-h-roibgsPoh T[\#Ò
>ÓÕæEÛâä.çââÛÜÝ*(Ù#Ýâéµ×.ÖÛÝåÚè× tç×.âÚÛÜÝâ T[\ R
>ÓëvuFè×lÖÜà×ÜáL×.ä<ÜàÜå#Ûä.Ù#àä<Üß%Ø×<ÝâÙ+ÚÛÜÝOÛÝOØàÙ#ÝÝÛÝåFÙ#ÝÞOÞ×<ä.ÛâÛÜÝ7
ßOÙZÛÝåÉÜÝfÝÙ#ÚÛÜÝÙ#àÖÜÙ#ÞfØÖÜQw0×<ä.Úâ T[\[>
>ÓT SßOØà×.ß%×.ÝÚÙ(ÚÛÜÝEÙ(âØ×.ä.ÚâLÜáä<Üß%Ø×.ÝâÙ#ÚÛÜÝEßO×.Ù#âçÖ×.â T#ÒLë
>Óí xÖÜÙ#Þ×.ÖQÙ#ØØàÛä.Ù[]ÛàÛÚêÂÜáL×.ä<ÜàÜå#Ûä.Ù#àä<Üß%Ø×<ÝâÙ+ÚÛÜÝ T#Ò#ì
>Ó\ 1lÞ0ãLÙ#ÝÚÙ#å#×<âSÙ#ÝÞEÞÖÙ¶éF]Ù#äZâSÜáÚè×Iß%Ù#ÛÝEÜØÚÛÜÝâSáÜÖSâä.Û×.Ýä.×7]Ù#â×.Þ
ä.ÜßOØ×.ÝâÙ(ÚÛÜÝFßO×.Ù(âçÖ×.â T#Ò[W
>ÓÒ ÔÖÜ]à×.ß%âL×<Ýä<ÜçÝÚ×.Ö×.ÞFÛÝFØÖÙ#ä.ÚÛä<× T#ìLë
&J& -[=:=-- 22 - -- +P {[
:2--=:= [
&+ :[: [[
& &J5 JJ [[
& -: [¡[
&¢£[2[--- [¡
¤{¥=¦-§J¨©ª-«©«ª-«¬«¦ [®[
¯±° ª-ª-¥= °²°³)´ ¥§+µ[« [[
¶5µQ·¸¨¨Jª!¹ [P