Christiansen, S.C.
Citation
Christiansen, S. C. (2010, September 28). Clinical and biochemical risk factors for first and recurrent episodes of venous thrombosis. Retrieved from https://hdl.handle.net/1887/15992
Version: Corrected Publisher’s Version License:
Licence agreement concerning inclusion of doctoral thesis in the Institutional Repository of the University of Leiden
Downloaded from: https://hdl.handle.net/1887/15992
Note: To cite this publication please use the final published version (if applicable).
&KDSWHU
7KURPERSKLOLDFOLQLFDOIDFWRUVDQG
UHFXUUHQWYHQRXVWKURPERWLFHYHQWV
6&&KULVWLDQVHQ6&&DQQHJLHWHU7.RVWHU-39DQGHQEURXFNH)55RVHQGDDO
7KH-RXUQDORIWKH$PHULFDQ0HGLFDO$VVRFLDWLRQ0D\
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
6XPPDU\
&RQWH[W 'DWDRQWKHUHFXUUHQFHUDWHRIYHQRXVWKURPERWLFHYHQWVDQGWKHHIIHFWRIVHYHUDO
ULVNIDFWRUVLQFOXGLQJWKURPERSKLOLDUHPDLQFRQWURYHUVLDO7KHSRWHQWLDOEHQH¿WRIVFUHHQLQJ
IRU WKURPERSKLOLD ZLWK UHVSHFW WR SURSK\ODFWLF VWUDWHJLHV DQG GXUDWLRQ RI DQWLFRDJXODQW
WUHDWPHQWLVQRW\HWNQRZQ
2EMHFWLYH 7R HVWLPDWH WKH UHFXUUHQFH UDWH RI WKURPERWLF HYHQWV LQ SDWLHQWV DIWHU D ¿UVW
WKURPERWLFHYHQWDQGLWVGHWHUPLQDQWVLQFOXGLQJWKURPERSKLOLFDEQRUPDOLWLHV
'HVLJQ 6HWWLQJ 3DWLHQWV 3URVSHFWLYH IROORZXS VWXG\ RI FRQVHFXWLYH SDWLHQWV DJHG
\HDUVZLWKRXWDNQRZQPDOLJQDQF\WUHDWHGIRUD¿UVWREMHFWLYHO\FRQ¿UPHGWKURPERWLF
HYHQWDWDQWLFRDJXODWLRQFOLQLFVLQWKH1HWKHUODQGV7KH/HLGHQ7KURPERSKLOLD6WXG\ /(76 ZDVFRQGXFWHGIURP WKURXJK DQGSDWLHQWVZHUHIROORZHGXSWKURXJK
0DLQRXWFRPHPHDVXUHV 5HFXUUHQWWKURPERWLFHYHQWEDVHGRQWKURPERSKLOLFULVNIDFWRUV
VH[W\SHRILQLWLDOWKURPERWLFHYHQW LGLRSDWKLFSURYRNHG RUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYHXVHHOHYDWHG
OHYHOVRIIDFWRUV9,,,,;;,¿EULQRJHQKRPRF\VWHLQHDQGDQWLFRDJXODQWGH¿FLHQFLHV
5HVXOWV $ WRWDO RI SDWLHQWV ZHUH IROORZHG XS IRU PHDQ 6' RI \HDUV DQG
FRPSOHWHIROORZXSZDVDFKLHYHGLQ 5HFXUUHQFHRIWKURPERWLFHYHQWVRFFXUUHGLQ
SDWLHQWVGXULQJDWRWDORISDWLHQW\HDUV7KHUDWHRIWKURPERWLFHYHQWUHFXUUHQFHZDV
SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV FRQ¿GHQFHLQWHUYDO>&,@SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV
7KHLQFLGHQFHUDWHRIUHFXUUHQFHZDVKLJKHVWGXULQJWKH¿UVW\HDUV SHUSDWLHQW
\HDUV &,SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV 7KHULVNRIWKURPERWLFHYHQWUHFXUUHQFH
ZDVWLPHV &,WLPHV KLJKHULQPHQWKDQLQZRPHQ3DWLHQWVZKRVHLQLWLDO
WKURPERWLF HYHQW ZDV LGLRSDWKLF KDG D KLJKHU ULVN RI D WKURPERWLF HYHQW UHFXUUHQFH WKDQ
SDWLHQWVZKRVHLQLWLDOHYHQWZDVSURYRNHG KD]DUGUDWLR>+5@ &, :RPHQ
ZKRXVHGRUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYHVGXULQJIROORZXSKDGDKLJKHUWKURPERWLFHYHQWUHFXUUHQFHUDWH
SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV &, SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV WKDQWKRVHZKRGLG
QRW SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV &, SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV 5HFXUUHQFHULVNV
RIDWKURPERWLFHYHQWE\ODERUDWRU\DEQRUPDOLW\UDQJHGIURPDQ+5RI &, LQSDWLHQWVZLWKHOHYDWHGOHYHOVRIIDFWRU;,WRDQ+5RI &, IRUSDWLHQWV
ZLWKDQWLFRDJXODQWGH¿FLHQFLHV
&RQFOXVLRQ 3URWKURPERWLFDEQRUPDOLWLHVGRQRWDSSHDUWRSOD\DQLPSRUWDQWUROHLQWKHULVN
RI D UHFXUUHQW WKURPERWLF HYHQW7HVWLQJ IRU SURWKURPERWLF GHIHFWV KDV OLWWOH FRQVHTXHQFH
ZLWKUHVSHFWWRSURSK\ODFWLFVWUDWHJLHV&OLQLFDOIDFWRUVDUHSUREDEO\PRUHLPSRUWDQWWKDQ
ODERUDWRU\DEQRUPDOLWLHVLQGHWHUPLQLQJWKHGXUDWLRQRIDQWLFRDJXODWLRQWKHUDS\
55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55
,QWURGXFWLRQ
7KHLQFLGHQFHUDWHRID¿UVWYHQRXVWKURPERVLVLVWRHYHQWVSHUSDWLHQW\HDUV 9HQRXV WKURPERVLV PDQLIHVWV PDLQO\ DV GHHS YHQRXV WKURPERVLV '97 DQG SXOPRQDU\
HPEROLVP (QYLURQPHQWDO ULVN IDFWRUV LQFOXGH LPPRELOL]DWLRQ VXUJHU\ PDOLJQDQFLHV
SUHJQDQF\SXHUSHULXPDQGH[RJHQRXVIHPDOHKRUPRQHV*HQHWLFDEQRUPDOLWLHVLQFUHDVLQJ
WKHULVNRIDWKURPERWLFHYHQWKDYHEHHQNQRZQIRUVHYHUDOGHFDGHVDQGLQFOXGHGH¿FLHQFLHV
RIWKHQDWXUDODQWLFRDJXODQWVDQWLWKURPELQSURWHLQ&DQGSURWHLQ6$GGLWLRQDOELRFKHPLFDO
ULVNIDFWRUVIRUDWKURPERWLFHYHQWDUHIDFWRU9/HLGHQSURWKURPELQ*$KLJKOHYHOV
RI IDFWRU 9,,, ,; RU ;, KRPRF\VWHLQH DQG ¿EULQRJHQ .QRZOHGJH RI WKH ULVN RI D
WKURPERWLF HYHQW UHFXUUHQFH DQG LWV GHWHUPLQDQWV LV UHOHYDQW IRU FOLQLFDO SROLF\ UHJDUGLQJ
VFUHHQLQJIRUWKURPERSKLOLDGXUDWLRQRIDQWLFRDJXODQWWUHDWPHQWDQGSURSK\ODFWLFVWUDWHJLHV
LQFLUFXPVWDQFHVRILQFUHDVHGULVN
(VWLPDWHV RI WKH \HDU FXPXODWLYH LQFLGHQFH RI UHFXUUHQW WKURPERWLF HYHQWV DUH DURXQG
2QHVWXG\UHSRUWHGDKLJKUHFXUUHQFHUDWHRI FDVHV LQDWRWDORISDWLHQWV
GXULQJ D PRQWKV IROORZXS:KLOH HVWLPDWHV RI WKH RYHUDOO ULVN RI D WKURPERWLF HYHQW
UHFXUUHQFHYDU\UHSRUWVRQFRQWULEXWLQJIDFWRUVDUHFRQWUDGLFWRU\6HYHUDOVWXGLHVKDYHEHHQ
SXEOLVKHGOLQNLQJIDFWRU9/HLGHQWKHSURWKURPELQ*$PXWDWLRQDQGWKHUHFXUUHQFH
RIDWKURPERWLFHYHQW0RVWVWXGLHVVKRZHGOLWWOHHIIHFWRIFDUULHUVKLSRIWKHVHPXWDWLRQV
RQ WKH ULVN RI UHFXUUHQFH +RZHYHU LQ VRPH VWXGLHV D WR IROG KLJKHU ULVN RI D
WKURPERWLFHYHQWUHFXUUHQFHKDVEHHQQRWHGLQFDUULHUVFRPSDUHGZLWKQRQFDUULHUV$
UHFHQWFULWLFDOUHYLHZRIVWXGLHVKLJKOLJKWHGKD]DUGUDWLRV +5V UDQJLQJIURPWR
LQFDUULHUVRIIDFWRU9/HLGHQFRPSDUHGZLWKQRQFDUULHUV,QVWXGLHVFRPSDULQJFDUULHUVRI
SURWKURPELQ*$ZLWKQRQFDUULHUV+56RIDWKURPERWLFHYHQWUHFXUUHQFHYDULHGIURP
WR
$IROGLQFUHDVHGULVNRIDWKURPERWLFHYHQWUHFXUUHQFHZDVUHSRUWHGIRUSDWLHQWVZLWKKLJK
SODVPDOHYHOVRIIDFWRU9,,,$VOLJKWO\LQFUHDVHGULVNRIDWKURPERWLFHYHQWUHFXUUHQFHZDV
UHSRUWHGIRUSDWLHQWVZLWKKLJKOHYHOVRIIDFWRU,;1RUHFXUUHQFHGDWDDUHDYDLODEOHIRU
HOHYDWHGOHYHOVRIIDFWRU;,RU¿EULQRJHQZKLFKKDYHEHHQVKRZQWRLQFUHDVHWKHULVNIRUD
¿UVWHYHQW +\SHUKRPRF\VWHLQHPLDLQFUHDVHVWKHULVNRIDWKURPERWLFHYHQW,WZDVDOVR
IRXQGWREHSUHYDOHQWLQSDWLHQWVZLWKDUHFXUUHQWWKURPERWLFHYHQW
7ZRUHYLHZVSRLQWHGRXWWKDWWKHFRQWUDGLFWRU\UHVXOWVRQFRQWULEXWLQJIDFWRUVRIWKURPERWLF
HYHQWUHFXUUHQFHPD\KDYHUHVXOWHGIURP GLIIHUHQFHVLQVWXG\GHVLJQ ODFNRISURSHU
LQFHSWLRQFRKRUWV LQFRPSDUDELOLW\RIDQWLFRDJXODWLRQSUR¿OHV GLIIHUHQFHVLQTXDOLW\
RIGRFXPHQWDWLRQRIHYHQWVRU GLIIHUHQFHVLQWKHLQWHUSUHWDWLRQRIFOLQLFDORXWFRPHVDQG
ODERUDWRU\WHVWV$SDUWLFXODULVVXHPD\EHWKDWVHOHFWHGVXEJURXSVRISDWLHQWVZHUHVWXGLHGLH
WKRVHUHIHUUHGWRVSHFLDOL]HGFHQWHUVIRUWKURPERSKLOLDZRUNXSZKRPD\ZHOOKDYHKDUERUHG
DGGLWLRQDO\HWXQNQRZQGHIHFWVWKDWFRXOGKDYHDIIHFWHGULVNV0RVWVWXG\FRKRUWVZHUHVPDOO
DQGIROORZHGXSIRURQO\DVKRUWSHULRG
:HVHWRXWWRGHWHUPLQHWKHULVNRIDUHFXUUHQWWKURPERWLFHYHQWLQSDWLHQWVZKRKDG
SDUWLFLSDWHGLQDODUJHSRSXODWLRQEDVHGFDVHFRQWUROVWXG\RIULVNIDFWRUVIRUD¿UVW'97
0DQ\ULVNIDFWRUVIRUDWKURPERWLFHYHQWZHUHLQYHVWLJDWHGDQGWKHVHSDWLHQWVZHUHIROORZHG
XSIRUXSWR\HDUV,QSDUWLFXODUZHH[DPLQHGWKHHIIHFWRIVHYHUDOWKURPERSKLOLFULVN
IDFWRUVRQWKHULVNRIUHFXUUHQFHDVZHOODVWKHHIIHFWRIVH[RUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYHXVHDQG
ZKHWKHUWKH¿UVWHYHQWZDVLGLRSDWKLFRUSURYRNHG
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
0HWKRGV
:HLQFOXGHGFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZLWKD¿UVWREMHFWLYHO\FRQ¿UPHGHSLVRGHRI'97
3DWLHQWV ZHUH GLDJQRVHG EHWZHHQ -DQXDU\ DQG 'HFHPEHU DQG ZHUH
SDUWLFLSDQWVLQWKH/HLGHQ7KURPERSKLOLD6WXG\ /(76 ZKLFKZDVDFDVHFRQWUROVWXG\
RIWKHHWLRORJ\RI'97,QWKH1HWKHUODQGVSDWLHQWVZLWKDWKURPERWLFHYHQWDUHWUHDWHGLQ
DQWLFRDJXODWLRQFOLQLFVZKLFKDUHUHJLRQDOO\RUJDQL]HG7KHUHIRUHDOOSDWLHQWVOLYLQJLQD
FHUWDLQDUHDDUHPRQLWRUHGE\WKHVDPHFOLQLFLUUHVSHFWLYHRIWKHKRVSLWDOWKH\ZHUHDGPLWWHG
WRRUWKHSK\VLFLDQZKRVWDUWHGWKHWUHDWPHQW3DWLHQWVSDUWLFLSDWLQJLQ/(76ZHUHLGHQWL¿HG
IURPWKH¿OHVDWWKHDQWLFRDJXODWLRQFOLQLFVLQ/HLGHQ$PVWHUGDPDQG5RWWHUGDP1LQHW\
SHUFHQWRIHOLJLEOHSDWLHQWVZHUHZLOOLQJWRSDUWLFLSDWHLQ/(763DWLHQWVROGHUWKDQ\HDUV
DQGWKRVHZLWKPDOLJQDQFLHVZHUHH[FOXGHG7KHUHZHUHQRPDMRUGLIIHUHQFHVDWEDVHOLQHLQ
FKDUDFWHULVWLFVEHWZHHQWKHSDWLHQWJURXSVIURPWKHFOLQLFV SDWLHQWVKDGD'97DQG
KDGDWKURPERVLVLQWKHDUP/(76ZDVDSSURYHGE\WKHPHGLFDOHWKLFVFRPPLWWHHRIWKH
/HLGHQ8QLYHUVLW\0HGLFDO&HQWHUDQGKDVEHHQGHVFULEHGHOVHZKHUH
3DWLHQWVZHUHLQLWLDOO\VHHQDWOHDVWPRQWKVDIWHUWKHGLVFRQWLQXDWLRQRIRUDODQWLFRDJXODQW
WUHDWPHQWH[FHSWLQFDVHVZKHQWKLVWUHDWPHQWFRXOGQRWEHVWRSSHG Q 3DWLHQWVZHUH
VHHQLQSHUVRQE\RQHRIXV 7. EHWZHHQ2FWREHU DQG-DQXDU\ 7KHPHGLDQ
WLPHEHWZHHQDWKURPERWLFHYHQWDQGYHQLSXQFWXUHZDV PRQWKV UDQJHPRQWKV
$WWKHH[DPLQDWLRQLQIRUPDWLRQRQDFTXLUHGULVNIDFWRUVZDVFROOHFWHGDQGDYHQRXVEORRG
GUDZZDVSHUIRUPHG,QIRUPDWLRQZDVDOVRFROOHFWHGRQVXUJHU\WUDXPDLPPRELOL]DWLRQXVH
RIRUDOFRQWUDFHSWLRQVKRUWO\EHIRUHWKHGLDJQRVLVRIDWKURPERWLFHYHQWIDPLO\KLVWRU\DQG
UHSURGXFWLYHKLVWRU\
%ORRGZDVFROOHFWHGIURPWKHDQWHFXELWDOYHLQDQGSODFHGLQ0RIWULVRGLXPFLWUDWH
3ODVPDZDVSUHSDUHGE\FHQWULIXJDWLRQIRUPLQXWHVDWJDWURRPWHPSHUDWXUHDQG
VWRUHGDW±&LQP/FRQWDLQHU'1$ZDVH[WUDFWHGE\VWDQGDUGVDOWLQJRXWPHWKRGV
:KHQDGH¿FLHQF\RISURWHLQ&SURWHLQ6RUDQWLWKURPELQZDVVXVSHFWHGSDWLHQWVZHUHDVNHG
WRKDYHEORRGUHGUDZQWRFRQ¿UPWKHGLDJQRVLVDQGWKHQZHUHLQIRUPHGRIWKHLUGH¿FLHQF\
,QVXEVHTXHQW\HDUVZHLQYHVWLJDWHGUHVLVWDQFHWRDFWLYDWHGSURWHLQ&ZLWKIDFWRU9/HLGHQ
DQGSURWKURPELQ*$ LQDOOSDUWLFLSDQWVDQGLQIRUPHGWKHSDWLHQWVLIWKH\
KDGDQDEQRUPDOUHVXOW1RQHRIWKHRWKHUWHVWUHVXOWV RQOHYHOVRIIDFWRUV9,,,,;RU;,
KRPRF\VWHLQH¿EULQRJHQ ZHUHFRPPXQLFDWHGWRWKHSDWLHQWV
/DERUDWRU\0HDVXUHPHQWV
'HWDLOVUHJDUGLQJWKHPHWKRGVRIPHDVXULQJOHYHOVRIWKHFRDJXODWLRQIDFWRUVZHUHGHVFULEHG
LQGHWDLOLQ/(767KHIDFWRU9,,,DFWLYLW\ZDVPHDVXUHGE\DVWDJHFRDJXODWLRQDVVD\
)DFWRU,;DQWLJHQOHYHOVZHUHPHDVXUHGE\VDQGZLFKHQ]\PHOLQNHGLPPXQRVRUEHQWDVVD\V
XVLQJFRPPHUFLDOSRO\FORQDODQWLERGLHV 'DNR$6*ORVWUXS'HQPDUN )DFWRU;,DQWLJHQ
OHYHOVZHUHPHDVXUHGE\XVLQJDPRQRFORQDODQWLIDFWRU;,FDSWXUHDQWLERG\DQGSRO\FORQDO
DQWLIDFWRU;,DVWDJJLQJDQWLERG\ 7KH¿EULQRJHQFRQFHQWUDWLRQZDVPHDVXUHGDFFRUGLQJ
WR WKH &ODXVV PHWKRG XVLQJ 'DGH UHDJHQW %D[WHU 0LDPL )OD 3URWHLQ & DFWLYLW\ DQG
DQWLWKURPELQDFWLYLW\ZHUHPHDVXUHGZLWK&RDPDWH &KURPRJHQL[0|OQGDO6ZHGHQ RQ
DQ$&/ ,QVWUXPHQWDWLRQ/DERUDWRU\0LODQ,WDO\ 7RWDOSURWHLQ6ZDVPHDVXUHGE\
DSRO\FORQDOHQ]\PHOLQNHGLPPXQRVRUEHQWDVVD\$OOFRDJXODWLRQIDFWRUVZHUHH[SUHVVHG
55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 DV XQLWV SHU GHFLOLWHU LQ ZKLFK 8 LV WKH DPRXQW RI FRDJXODWLRQ IDFWRU SUHVHQW LQ P/
RISRROHGSODVPD)LEULQRJHQOHYHOVZHUHH[SUHVVHGDVJUDPVSHUOLWHU7RWDOKRPRF\VWHLQH
FRQFHQWUDWLRQZDVPHDVXUHGLQDQRQIDVWLQJVWDWHE\DPRGL¿HGPHWKRGRIDXWRPDWHGKLJK
SHUIRUPDQFHOLTXLGFKURPDWRJUDSK\ZLWKUHYHUVHSKDVHVHSDUDWLRQDQGÀXRUHVFHQWGHWHFWLRQ
ZLWKDVDPSOHSURFHVVRU *LOVRQ,QF0LGGOHWRQ:LV DQVROYHQWGHOLYHU\
V\VWHP 6SHFWUD3K\VLFV 0RXQWDLQ 9LHZ &DOLI DQG DQ /& ÀXRURPHWHU 6SHFWUD
3K\VLFV 3URWKURPELQ *$ DQG IDFWRU 9 /HLGHQ )9 * $ JHQRW\SHV ZHUH
DVVHVVHGE\VWDQGDUGSRO\PHUDVHFKDLQUHDFWLRQ
)ROORZXS
$OOSDWLHQWVJDYHLQIRUPHGFRQVHQWIRUIROORZXSDQGIRUWKHFROOHFWLRQRILQIRUPDWLRQ
IURPKRVSLWDOVGXULQJDVXVSHFWHGWKURPERWLFHYHQWUHFXUUHQFH)ROORZXSVWDUWHG GD\V
DIWHUWKHGDWHRIWKHLQLWLDOWKURPERWLFHYHQWWKDWRFFXUUHGLQ WKLV GD\SHULRG
ZDVGH¿QHGDVWKHSHULRGRILQLWLDODQWLFRDJXODWLRQ DQGHQGHGRQ-DQXDU\,QIRUPDWLRQ
UHOHYDQWWRWKHIROORZXSDIWHUWKHWKURPERWLFHYHQWZDV¿UVWJDWKHUHGDWWKHLQWHUYLHZDW
EDVHOLQHDQGVXEVHTXHQWO\E\UHSHDWHGPDLOHGTXHVWLRQQDLUHV7KHTXHVWLRQQDLUHVZHUHXVHG
DVDVFUHHQLQJWRROIRUWKHRFFXUUHQFHRIULVNVLWXDWLRQVDQGUHFXUUHQWWKURPERWLFHYHQWVDQG
DOVRLQFOXGHGLWHPVRQUHOHYDQWFOLQLFDOFLUFXPVWDQFHVVXFKDVDQWLFRDJXODWLRQ W\SHGXUDWLRQ
LQGLFDWLRQ VXUJHU\WUDXPDLPPRELOLW\XVHRIRUDOFRQWUDFHSWLRQDQGSUHJQDQFLHVGXULQJ
WKHSHULRGFRYHUHGE\HDFKTXHVWLRQQDLUH3DWLHQWVZHUHIXUWKHULQWHUYLHZHGE\WHOHSKRQHLI
WKH\UHVSRQGHGSRVLWLYHO\RQDQ\LWHPIURPWKHTXHVWLRQQDLUHRULIWKH\GLGQRWUHVSRQGWR
DTXHVWLRQQDLUH6XEVHTXHQWO\FRQ¿UPDWLRQRIDOOUHOHYDQWFOLQLFDOLQIRUPDWLRQSHUWDLQLQJ
WRUHFXUUHQWWKURPERWLFHYHQWVRUULVNVLWXDWLRQVZDVREWDLQHGIURPWKHWUHDWLQJSK\VLFLDQV
5HFXUUHQW WKURPERWLF HYHQWV ZHUH FRQ¿UPHG DQG UHSRUWV RQ GLDJQRVWLF PHWKRGV ZHUH
REWDLQHGE\FROOHFWLQJWKHGLVFKDUJHOHWWHUVIURPWKHWUHDWLQJKRVSLWDOV5HFXUUHQWWKURPERWLF
HYHQWV ZHUH DGMXGLFDWHG ZKHQ WKH\ ZHUH REMHFWLYHO\ FRQ¿UPHG ZLWK 'RSSOHU XOWUDVRXQG
YHQRJUDSK\RULPSHGDQFHSOHWK\VPRJUDSK\5HFXUUHQFHVRISXOPRQDU\HPEROLVPUHTXLUHG
DSRVLWLYHSHUIXVLRQOXQJVFDQ DWOHDVWVHJPHQWDOSHUIXVLRQGHIHFW DYHQWLODWLRQSHUIXVLRQ
OXQJVFDQ LQWHUPHGLDWHRUKLJKSUREDELOLW\ RUDFRPSXWHULVHGWRPRJUDSKLFVFDQ
'HHSYHLQWKURPERVHVRUSXOPRQDU\HPEROLVPVWKDWRFFXUUHGZLWKLQWKHLQLWLDODQWLFRDJXODWLRQ
SHULRG GD\V ZHUHQRWFRQVLGHUHGWKURPERWLFHYHQWUHFXUUHQFHVEXWZHUHFRQVLGHUHGD
SURJUHVVLRQRIWKHLQLWLDOHYHQW WKLVRFFXUUHGLQSDWLHQWV
,GLRSDWKLF ZDV GH¿QHG DV DQ LQLWLDO WKURPERWLF HYHQW WKDW RFFXUUHG LQ WKH DEVHQFH RI SUHJQDQF\ SXHUSHULXP RUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYHXVHZLWKLQGD\V WUDXPDVXUJHU\
LPPRELOL]DWLRQRUXVHRIDSODVWHUFDVWZLWKLQPRQWKVEHIRUHWKHHYHQW$OORWKHUVZHUH
FODVVL¿HGDVSURYRNHG
6WDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLV
(QGRIIROORZXSZDVDWWKH¿UVWWKURPERWLFHYHQWUHFXUUHQFHGDWHRIGHDWKGDWHRIHPLJUDWLRQ
RUWKHHQGRIWKHVWXG\ZKLFKHYHURFFXUUHG¿UVW2EVHUYDWLRQWLPHZDVFDOFXODWHGDVWKHWLPH
DWULVNIURPWKHHQGRIWKHDQWLFRDJXODWLRQWUHDWPHQWIRUWKH¿UVWWKURPERWLFHYHQWWRWKHHQG
RIIROORZXS,QFLGHQFHUDWHVRIUHFXUUHQWWKURPERWLFHYHQWVZHUHFDOFXODWHGDVWKHQXPEHURI
HYHQWVRYHUWKHDFFXPXODWHGSDWLHQWWLPH&XPXODWLYHLQFLGHQFHZDVFDOFXODWHGE\.DSODQ
0HLHUVXUYLYDODQDO\VLV
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
7KH&R[SURSRUWLRQDOKD]DUGVPRGHOZDVXVHGWRHYDOXDWHULVNVEHWZHHQJURXSVDQGZDV
DGMXVWHGIRUDJHDQGVH[$QWLFRDJXODQWWKHUDS\ZDVHQWHUHGLQWKHPRGHODVDWLPHGHSHQGHQW
FRYDULDWH6HSDUDWHDQDO\VHVZHUHSHUIRUPHGWRDVVHVVWKHHIIHFWRISURWKURPERWLFDEQRUPDOLWLHV
RQWKHULVNRIUHFXUUHQFH IDFWRU9/HLGHQSURWKURPELQ*$K\SHUKRPRF\VWHLQHPLD
KLJKOHYHOVRIIDFWRU9,,,,;RU;,RURI¿EULQRJHQDQGGH¿FLHQFLHVRISURWHLQ&SURWHLQ6RU
DQWLWKURPELQ :HDVVHVVHGWKHULVNRIWKURPERWLFHYHQWUHFXUUHQFHE\VH[DQGE\LGLRSDWKLF
RUSURYRNHGFODVVL¿FDWLRQRILQLWLDOWKURPERWLFHYHQW7KHHIIHFWRIRUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYHXVH
ZDVGHWHUPLQHGE\FDOFXODWLQJWKURPERWLFHYHQWUHFXUUHQFHUDWHVIRUZRPHQZKRXVHGDQ
RUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYHDWDQ\WLPH HLWKHUFRQWLQXHGXVHRUUHVWDUWHGXVH GXULQJWKHIROORZXS
SHULRG VWUDWL¿HG E\ XVH DW WKH WLPH RI WKH ¿UVW HYHQW ,Q DGGLWLRQ ZH HVWLPDWHG WKH ULVN
VHSDUDWHO\IRUDVHFRQGFRQWUDODWHUDOFRPSDUHGZLWKDVHFRQGLSVLODWHUDOWKURPERWLFHYHQW
'XULQJWKHIROORZXSSHULRGVRPHSDWLHQWVH[SHULHQFHGSHULRGVZLWKDQLQFUHDVHGULVNRID
WKURPERWLFHYHQW WUDXPDLPPRELOL]DWLRQRSHUDWLRQVRUDOFRQWUDFHSWLRQSUHJQDQF\ RUD
GHFUHDVHGULVN RUDODQWLFRDJXODWLRQWUHDWPHQW 7RGHWHUPLQHWKHHIIHFWRIEORRGDEQRUPDOLWLHV
RQULVNRIWKURPERWLFHYHQWUHFXUUHQFHZLWKRXWWKHLQWHUIHUHQFHRIWKHVHHSLVRGHVZHUHSHDWHG
WKHDQDO\VLVZKLOHH[FOXGLQJDOOVXFKSHULRGV
)RUFRQWLQXRXVSKHQRW\SHVZHXVHGWKHIROORZLQJFXWRIIYDOXHV ,8G/IRUIDFWRU9,,,
,8G/IRUIDFWRU,; ,8G/IRUIDFWRU;, J/IRU¿EULQRJHQ DQG RU
PPRO/IRUKRPRF\VWHLQH GLIIHUHQWFXWRIIOHYHOVZHUHXVHGDVDFRQVHTXHQFHRI
GLIIHUHQWSURFHVVLQJWLPHVLQWKHFOLQLFV 3DWLHQWVZHUHFRQVLGHUHGGH¿FLHQWIRUSURWHLQ&RU
SURWHLQ6ZKHQOHYHOVZHUHEHORZWKHORZHUOLPLWRIQRUPDO 8G/RU8G/ZKHQXVLQJ
RUDODQWLFRDJXODWLRQDWWKHEORRGGUDZ 3DWLHQWVZHUHFRQVLGHUHGGH¿FLHQWRIDQWLWKURPELQ
ZKHQOHYHOVZHUHUHSHDWHGO\EHORZ8G/$OODQDO\VHVZHUHSHUIRUPHGZLWK6366
6366,QF&KLFDJR,OO
5HVXOWV
$WRWDORISDWLHQWVZHUHIROORZHGXSIRUDPHDQ 6' RI \HDUVDQGFRPSOHWH
IROORZXSZDVDFKLHYHGIRUSDWLHQWV IRUDWRWDOREVHUYDWLRQWLPHRISDWLHQW
\HDUV ),*85( 7ZHQW\VHYHQ SDWLHQWV ZHUH ORVW IURP REVHUYDWLRQ XQWUDFHDEOH
UHIXVDOVGLVDEOHG DQGZHUHLQFOXGHGXQWLOWKHLUODVWREVHUYDWLRQ2IWKHUHPDLQLQJ
SDWLHQWVSDWLHQWVHPLJUDWHGDQGSDWLHQWVGLHGGXULQJIROORZXS)ROORZXSZDVFRPSOHWH
XQWLOGHDWKIRUSDWLHQWV7KHRWKHUVSDWLHQWVGLHGEHIRUHWKHVXEVHTXHQWTXHVWLRQQDLUHZDV
GXHDQGIROORZXSIRUDWKURPERWLFHYHQWZDVFRQVLGHUHGFRPSOHWHXSXQWLOWKHGDWHRIWKHLU
ODVWTXHVWLRQQDLUH7KHUHVSRQVHUDWHVDIWHUHDFKTXHVWLRQQDLUHYDULHGEHWZHHQ DQG
7KHJHQHUDOFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRIWKHFRKRUWDUHOLVWHGLQ7$%/(7KHUHZHUHPRUHZRPHQ
Q WKDQPHQ Q LQFOXGHGLQWKLVIROORZXSVWXG\7KHPHDQ 6' DJHRIWKH
FRKRUWZDV \HDUV7KHRYHUDOOPHDQDJHZDV\HDUVKLJKHULQPHQZKLFKGLIIHUHG
PDUNHGO\DFFRUGLQJWRWKHW\SHRILQLWLDOWKURPERWLFHYHQW,GLRSDWKLF¿UVWHYHQWVZHUHPRUH
FRPPRQLQPHQZKRZHUHRQDYHUDJH\HDUV\RXQJHUWKDQZRPHQZLWKDQLGLRSDWKLF¿UVW
HYHQW0RVWSURYRNHG¿UVWHYHQWVRFFXUUHGLQZRPHQ,QWKHSDWLHQWVZLWKSURYRNHGHYHQWV
PHQ ZHUH RQ DYHUDJH \HDUV ROGHU WKDQ ZRPHQ LQ ZKRP RUDO FRQWUDFHSWLYH XVH ZDV D
FRPPRQGHWHUPLQDQW$SDUWIURPHOHYDWHGOHYHOVRIIDFWRU,; PRUHIUHTXHQWLQZRPHQ DQG K\SHUKRPRF\VWHLQHPLD PRUH IUHTXHQW LQ PHQ SURWKURPERWLF IDFWRUV ZHUH HTXDOO\
GLVWULEXWHGEHWZHHQWKHVH[HV 7DEOH
55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 'XULQJIROORZXS SDWLHQWVKDGDUHFXUUHQWWKURPERWLFHYHQW2IWKHVHSDWLHQWVKDG
D'97LQWKHOHJKDGDWKURPERVLVLQWKHDUPKDGDSXOPRQDU\HPEROLVPDQGKDG
%XGG&KLDULV\QGURPHZLWKDQH[WHQVLRQLQWRWKHYHQDFDYD7ZRSDWLHQWVZKRLQLWLDOO\KDG
D'97ODWHUKDGDQDUPWKURPERVLV2QHSDWLHQWZKRLQLWLDOO\KDGDQDUPWKURPERVLVODWHU
KDGD'977ZRRWKHUSDWLHQWVZLWKDQLQLWLDODUPWKURPERVLVODWHUKDGDWKURPERVLVLQWKH
RSSRVLWHDUPDVWKHLUUHFXUUHQWWKURPERWLFHYHQW2IWKHSDWLHQWVZKRKDGD'97DVWKHLU
UHFXUUHQWHYHQWZHUHLSVLODWHUDODQGZHUHFRQWUDODWHUDO
7DEOH 3DWLHQWFKDUDFWHULVWLFV
0HQ :RPHQ $OO
Q Q Q
$JHPHDQ 6' \
)LUVWWKURPERWLFHYHQW
,GLRSDWKLF
0HDQ 6' DJH\
3URYRNHGÁ
0HDQ 6' DJH\
3URWKURPERWLFULVNIDFWRUV
)DFWRU9/HLGHQ
3URWKURPELQ*$
$QWLFRDJXODQWGH¿FLHQF\
+LJKOHYHORIIDFWRU
9,,, !,8G/
,; ! ,8G/
;, !,8G/
+\SHU¿EULQRJHQHPLD !J/
+\SHUKRPRF\VWHLQHPLD\
9DOXHV DUH H[SUHVVHG DV QXPEHU SHUFHQWDJH XQOHVV RWKHUZLVH LQGLFDWHG &XWRII SRLQWV DUH LQ
SDUHQWKHVHVXQOHVVRWKHUZLVHLQGLFDWHG
$WVWDUWRIIROORZXS
Á'H¿QHGDVSUHJQDQF\SXHUSHULXPRUXVHRIRUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYHVZLWKLQGD\VRUWUDXPDVXUJHU\
LPPRELOL]DWLRQRUXVHRIDSODVWHUFDVWZLWKLQPRQWKVEHIRUHWKHHYHQW
'H¿FLHQF\RISURWHLQ& >@,8P/ SURWHLQ6 >@,8P/@RUDQWLWKURPELQ
8P/
\&XWRIISRLQWV PRUHWKDQPRO/ /HLGHQ PRO/ $PVWHUGDP PRO/ 5RWWHUGDP
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
)LJXUH)ORZRI3DWLHQWV'XULQJ)ROORZXS
$WRWDORI LQGLYLGXDOVZHUHORVWGXULQJWKHVWXG\EXWODWHUIRXQG7KXVWKHVHLQGLYLGXDOVGLGQRW
UHFHLYHDOOTXHVWLRQQDLUHVEXWLQIRUPDWLRQZDVFRPSOHWHGXULQJIROORZXS
3DWLHQWV:LWKD)LUVW7KURPERWLF(YHQW
&RPSOHWHG)RXUWK4XHVWLRQQDLUH
(QGRI6WXG\
(PLJUDWHG
/RVWWR)ROORZXSRU8QDEOHWR3DUWLFLSDWH
5HDFKHG(QGRI6WXG\
5HFXUUHQW7KURPERWLF(YHQW
&RPSOHWHG6HFRQG4XHVWLRQQDLUH
&RPSOHWHG)LUVW4XHVWLRQQDLUH
([FOXGHG
(PLJUDWHG
/RVWWR)ROORZXSRU8QDEOHWR3DUWLFLSDWH
'LHG
5HDFKHG(QGRI6WXG\
5HFXUUHQW7KURPERWLF(YHQW
([FOXGHG
5HIXVHG
/RVWWR)ROORZXSRU8QDEOHWR3DUWLFLSDWH
'LHG
5HDFKHG(QGRI6WXG\
5HFXUUHQW7KURPERWLF(YHQW
([FOXGHG
(PLJUDWHG
5HIXVHG
/RVWWR)ROORZXSRU8QDEOHWR3DUWLFLSDWH
'LHG
5HDFKHG(QGRI6WXG\
55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55
$QWLFRDJXODQW8VH'XULQJ)ROORZXS
)ROORZXSVWDUWHG GD\VDIWHUWKH¿UVWHYHQW$WWKLVWLPHSRLQW LQGLYLGXDOVKDG¿QLVKHG
WKHLULQLWLDODQWLFRDJXODQWWUHDWPHQW2IWKHRWKHU SDWLHQWVKDGDSURORQJHGSHULRG
RILQLWLDODQWLFRDJXODWLRQWUHDWPHQWZKLFKZDVOHVVWKDQPRQWKVIRUWKHPDMRULW\ Q
7$%/( $OORWKHUVKDGDGGLWLRQDOSHULRGVRIRUDODQWLFRDJXODQWXVHGXULQJIROORZXS)RU
SDWLHQWV WKHWRWDOGXUDWLRQRIRUDODQWLFRDJXODQWXVHZDVOHVVWKDQPRQWKV
7KH PDLQ UHDVRQV IRU DQWLFRDJXODQW XVH ZHUH SURSK\OD[LV RI '97 GXULQJ ULVN VLWXDWLRQV
VXFKDVVXUJHU\RUSUHJQDQF\)LIW\VHYHQSDWLHQWVWRRNDQRUDODQWLFRDJXODQWIRUPRUHWKDQ
PRQWKVLQWRWDOZKLFKZDVIRUFDUGLDFUHDVRQVRUDUWHULDOSURSK\OD[LVLQSDWLHQWV7KH
H[DFWUHDVRQVIRURUDODQWLFRDJXODQWXVHZHUHQRWNQRZQLQSDWLHQWV
2IWKHSDWLHQWVZKRWRRNDQRUDODQWLFRDJXODQWIRUPRUHWKDQPRQWKVLQWRWDO KDGRUPRUHSURWKURPERWLFDEQRUPDOLWLHV7KHPHDQ 6' GXUDWLRQRIRUDODQWLFRDJXODQW
XVHGXULQJIROORZXSRISDWLHQWVZDV \HDUVSHUSDWLHQWFRPSDUHGZLWK
\HDUVLQWKHSDWLHQWVZLWKRXWDQ\DEQRUPDOLW\7KLVGLIIHUHQFHZDVGXHPRVWO\WRSDWLHQWV
ZLWK DQWLFRDJXODQW GH¿FLHQFLHV SURWHLQV & SURWHLQ 6 DQG DQWLWKURPELQ ZKR UHFHLYHG
DQWLFRDJXODWLRQ IRU D PHDQ 6' RI \HDUV SHU SDWLHQW 1R PDMRU GLIIHUHQFHV LQ
SUHVFULSWLRQ RI DQWLFRDJXODWLRQ ZHUH REVHUYHG DPRQJ FDUULHUV RI WKH RWKHU SURWKURPERWLF
ULVNIDFWRUVLQFOXGLQJIDFWRU9/HLGHQDQGSURWKURPELQ*$FDUULHUVFRPSDUHGZLWK
QRQFDUULHUV
7DEOH 2UDO$QWLFRDJXODQW8VH'XULQJ)ROORZXS 8VH'XULQJ
)ROORZXS
2UDO$QWLFRDJXODQW 1RQH 0RQWKV 0RQWKV !0RQWKV 7RWDO
,QLWLDOXVH
G
G
&RQWLQXRXVXVHDIWHU¿UVWHYHQW
5HVWDUW
7RWDO
1LQHW\GD\VDIWHU¿UVWHYHQW
5LVNRIUHFXUUHQWYHQRXVWKURPERVLV
7KHRYHUDOOLQFLGHQFHUDWHRIUHFXUUHQWWKURPERWLFHYHQWZDV SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV
&, SHU SDWLHQW\HDUV FRUUHVSRQGLQJ WR DQ DQQXDO ULVN RI
),*85(VKRZVWKHFXPXODWLYHLQFLGHQFHRIUHFXUUHQFHRYHUWKH\HDUIROORZXSSHULRG
7KHULVNRIUHFXUUHQFHZDVDIWHU\HDUVRIIROORZXS &, DQG
&, DIWHU\HDUVRIIROORZXS'XULQJWKH¿UVW\HDUVDIWHUWKH
GLVFRQWLQXDWLRQRIWKHLQLWLDODQWLFRDJXODQWWUHDWPHQWWKHLQFLGHQFHUDWHZDVKLJKHVW SHU
SDWLHQW\HDUV &,WRSHUSDWLHQW\HDUV 6XEVHTXHQWO\WKHLQFLGHQFH
UDWHGHFUHDVHGVORZO\ZLWKWLPH ),*85(
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
)LJXUH&XPXODWLYH,QFLGHQFHRI5HFXUUHQW7KURPERWLF(YHQWV
3DWLHQWVZLWKDQGZLWKRXWWKURPERSKLOLDGXULQJWKHSHULRGIURPWKHHQGRIWKHLQLWLDODQWLFRDJXODWLRQ
SHULRG GD\V XQWLO-DQXDU\7KHFUXGHKD]DUGUDWLRRIWKURPERSKLOLDFRPSDUHGZLWKQR
WKURPERSKLOLDZDV FRQ¿GHQFHLQWHUYDO WKHKD]DUGUDWLRDGMXVWHGIRUDJHVH[DQGRUDO
DQWLFRDJXODWLRQDVDWLPHGHSHQGHQWFRYDULDWHZDV FRQ¿GHQFHLQWHUYDO (IIHFWRIVH[
0HQKDGD\HDUFXPXODWLYHLQFLGHQFHRIWKURPERWLFHYHQWUHFXUUHQFHRI &,
FRPSDUHG ZLWK &, LQ ZRPHQ 7KH FXPXODWLYH
LQFLGHQFHDIWHU\HDUVZDV &, LQPHQFRPSDUHGZLWK
&, LQZRPHQ7KHRYHUDOODJHFRUUHFWHG+5IRUULVNRIWKURPERWLFHYHQW
UHFXUUHQFHLQPHQFRPSDUHGZLWKZRPHQZDV &,
:LWK 7URPERSKLOLD
:LWKRXW WURPERSKLOLD
7RWDO
:LWK WKURPERSKLOLD
:LWKRXW WKURPERSKLOLD
:LWK 7URPERSKLOLD
:LWKRXW WURPERSKLOLD
7RWDO
:LWK 7URPERSKLOLD
:LWKRXW WURPERSKLOLD
7RWDO
:LWK WKURPERSKLOLD
:LWKRXW WKURPERSKLOLD
55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55
)LJXUH,QFLGHQFH5DWHRI5HFXUUHQW7KURPERWLF(YHQW /DERUDWRU\$EQRUPDOLWLHV
2IDOOSDWLHQWV KDGDWOHDVWODERUDWRU\DEQRUPDOLW\DWWKHLU¿UVWH[DPLQDWLRQ
$IWHUDGMXVWPHQWIRUDJHVH[DQGDQWLFRDJXODWLRQQRFOHDUH[FHVVULVNRIUHFXUUHQFHZDV
REVHUYHGZKHQZHFRQWUDVWHG SDWLHQWVZLWKRUPRUHSURWKURPERWLFDEQRUPDOLWLHVWRWKRVH
ZLWKQRQH +5 &, 7$%/( :HGLGQRWREVHUYHDQLQFUHDVHGULVNRI
UHFXUUHQFHIRUDQ\RIWKHIROORZLQJSURWKURPERWLFULVNIDFWRUV XVLQJWKRVHZLWKRXWWKHVSHFL¿F
DEQRUPDOLW\DVUHIHUHQFHJURXS IDFWRU9/HLGHQSURWKURPELQ*$HOHYDWHGOHYHOVRI
IDFWRU9,,,HOHYDWHGOHYHOVRIIDFWRU,;HOHYDWHGOHYHOVRIIDFWRU;,DQGK\SHUKRPRF\VWHLQHPLD
7$%/( $GMXVWPHQWIRUDJHVH[DQGSHULRGVRIDQWLFRDJXODWLRQGLGQRWFKDQJHWKHVHULVN
HVWLPDWHV 7DEOH ,QWKHSDWLHQWVZLWKDGH¿FLHQF\RIRIWKHQDWXUDODQWLFRDJXODQWVSURWHLQ
&SURWHLQ6RUDQWLWKURPELQDPLOGO\LQFUHDVHGULVNRIDUHFXUUHQWWKURPERWLFHYHQWZDV
REVHUYHG +5 &, )LEULQRJHQOHYHOVH[FHHGLQJJ/ZHUHDOVRIRXQGWR
EHDVVRFLDWHGZLWKDVOLJKWO\LQFUHDVHGULVNRIWKURPERWLFHYHQWUHFXUUHQFH +5 &,
DIWHUDGMXVWPHQWIRUDJHVH[DQGDQWLFRDJXODWLRQWKH+5ZDV> &,@
2QO\RIWKHSDWLHQWVZLWKKRPR]\JRXVIRUIDFWRU9/HLGHQH[SHULHQFHGDUHFXUUHQFHGXULQJ
DPHDQ 6' IROORZXSRI \HDUV7KHLU\HDUFXPXODWLYHLQFLGHQFHRIGLGQRW
GLIIHUIURPDOOSDWLHQWVZKLOHQRQHRIWKHUHFHLYHGORQJWHUPDQWLFRDJXODQWWUHDWPHQW
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
7DEOH 5HFXUUHQFH5DWHIRU1XPEHURI3URWKURPERWLF/DERUDWRU\$EQRUPDOLWLHVLQ
3DWLHQWV
$EQRUPDOLW\
1RQH ! $Q\
,QFLGHQFHUDWH &,
+D]DUGUDWLR &, 5HIHUUHQW
+D]DUGUDWLR &, Á 5HIHUUHQW
$EEUHYLDWLRQ &,FRQ¿GHQFHLQWHUYDO
3HUSDWLHQW\HDUV
5HODWLYHWRWKRVHZLWKRXWDQDEQRUPDOLW\ FUXGHUDWLR
Á5HODWLYHWRWKRVHZLWKRXWDQDEQRUPDOLW\DQGDGMXVWHGIRUDJHVH[DQGDQWLFRDJXODWLRQDVDWLPH
GHSHQGHQWFRYDULDWH
&RPELQDWLRQVRI7KURPERSKLOLF)DFWRUV
6HYHUDOSDWLHQWVKDGPRUHWKDQRIWKHDEQRUPDOLWLHVVWXGLHG3DWLHQWVZLWKDEQRUPDOLW\
KDGDIROGLQFUHDVHGULVNRIDWKURPERWLFHYHQWUHFXUUHQFHFRPSDUHGZLWKWKHSDWLHQWV
ZLWKRXWDQDEQRUPDOLW\,QWKRVHZLWKPRUHWKDQDEQRUPDOLW\WKHUHFXUUHQFHUDWHLQFUHDVHG
IROG FRPSDUHG ZLWK WKRVH ZLWKRXW DQ DEQRUPDOLW\$IWHU FRUUHFWLRQ IRU DJH VH[ DQG
SHULRGV RI DQWLFRDJXODWLRQ 7DEOH WKH +5 LQFUHDVHG WR LQ WKRVH ZLWK PRUH WKDQ
DEQRUPDOLW\ZKLOHLWVWD\HGWKHVDPHLQWKRVHZLWKRQO\DEQRUPDOLW\
%HFDXVHIDFWRU9/HLGHQLVWKHPRVWFRPPRQJHQHWLFDEQRUPDOLW\ZHVWXGLHGLWVFRPELQDWLRQV
ZLWKRWKHUSURWKURPERWLFGHIHFWVLQPRUHGHWDLO6L[W\WKUHHSDWLHQWVKDGIDFWRU9/HLGHQ
DQG RI WKH RWKHU SURWKURPERWLF ULVN IDFWRUV SURWKURPELQ *$ HOHYDWHG OHYHOV RI
IDFWRUV9,,,,;RU;,¿EULQRJHQKRPRF\VWHLQHRUGH¿FLHQFLHVRISURWHLQ&SURWHLQ6RU
DQWLWKURPELQ ZKLOH SDWLHQWVFDUULHGIDFWRU9/HLGHQZLWKRXWDQ\DGGLWLRQDODEQRUPDOLW\
7KHWKURPERWLFHYHQWUHFXUUHQFHUDWHZDV SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV &,
SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV LQWKRVHZLWKIDFWRU9/HLGHQDQGDQ\RWKHUDEQRUPDOLW\DQG SHU
SDWLHQW\HDUV &, SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV LQWKRVHZLWKIDFWRU9/HLGHQ
ZLWKRXWDQ\RWKHUDEQRUPDOLW\
,QSDWLHQWVZLWKDFRPELQDWLRQRIIDFWRU9/HLGHQDQGHOHYDWHGOHYHOVRI¿EULQRJHQDKLJK
UHFXUUHQFHUDWHRI SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV &,SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV ZDVIRXQG2WKHUFRPELQDWLRQVRIELRFKHPLFDOULVNIDFWRUV SURWKURPELQ*$HOHYDWHG
OHYHOVRIIDFWRUV9,,,,;RU;,RUKRPRF\VWHLQHGH¿FLHQFLHVRISURWHLQ&SURWHLQ6RU
DQWLWKURPELQ ZLWKIDFWRU9/HLGHQGLGQRWVKRZDQDGGLWLRQDOLQFUHDVHGULVN
,SVLODWHUDOYV&RQWUDODWHUDO5HFXUUHQW'97V
7KHLQFLGHQFHUDWHRIDQLSVLODWHUDOVHFRQG'97 Q ZDVSHUSDWLHQW\HDUV
&, SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV ZKLOHWKHLQFLGHQFHUDWHRIDFRQWUDODWHUDOVHFRQG
'97 Q ZDVRQO\VOLJKWO\ORZHUDW SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV &,SHU
SDWLHQW\HDUV
7KH LQFLGHQFH UDWH RI DQ LSVLODWHUDO UHFXUUHQW '97 LQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK D SURWKURPERWLF ULVN
IDFWRUZDVSHUSDWLHQW\HDUV &,SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV ZKLOHWKH
LQFLGHQFHUDWHRIDFRQWUDODWHUDOUHFXUUHQW'97ZDV SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV &,
SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV ,QSDWLHQWVZLWKRXWSURWKURPERWLFULVNIDFWRUVWKHLQFLGHQFH
UDWHRIDQLSVLODWHUDOUHFXUUHQW'97ZDVSHUSDWLHQW\HDUV &, SHU
55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55
SDWLHQW\HDUV ZKLOHWKHLQFLGHQFHRIDFRQWUDODWHUDOUHFXUUHQW'97ZDV SHU
SDWLHQW\HDUV &,SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV
7DEOH 5HFXUUHQFH5DWHVIRU3URWKURPERWLF/DERUDWRU\$EQRUPDOLWLHVLQ3DWLHQWV
$EQRUPDOLW\ 1RRI
5HFXUUHQFHV ,QFLGHQFH5DWH
&, +D]DUG5DWLR
&, +D]DUG5DWLR
&, Á
)DFWRU9/HLGHQ ±
3URWKURPELQ*$ ±
$QWLFRDJXODQWGH¿FLHQF\\ ±
+LJKIDFWRU
9,,, !,8G/ ±
,; ! 8G/ ±
;, !8G/ ±
+\SHU¿EULQRJHQHPLD\ ±
+\SHUKRPRF\VWHLQHPLD ±
$EEUHYLDWLRQ &,FRQ¿GHQFHLQWHUYDO
3HUSDWLHQW\HDUV
5HODWLYHWRWKRVHZLWKRXWWKHDEQRUPDOLW\ FUXGHUDWLR
Á5HODWLYHWRWKRVHZLWKRXWWKHDEQRUPDOLW\DQGDGMXVWHGIRUDJHVH[DQGDQWLFRDJXODWLRQDVDWLPH
GHSHQGHQWFRYDULDWH
'H¿FLHQF\RISURWHLQ&SURWHLQ6RUDQWLWKURPELQ
\&XWRIISRLQWV SURWHLQ& ,8P/ SURWHLQ6 ,8P/ DQWLWKURPELQ
8P/ ¿EULQRJHQ !J/
&XWRIISRLQWVDUHLQSDUHQWKHVHV
&XWRII SRLQWV KRPRF\VWHLQH ! PRO/ /HLGHQ PRO/ $PVWHUGDP PRO/
5RWWHUGDP
,QLWLDO,GLRSDWKLFDQG3URYRNHG7KURPERWLF(YHQWV
7KHUHFXUUHQFHUDWHZDVKLJKHVWLQWKRVHZLWKDQLGLRSDWKLF¿UVWWKURPERWLFHYHQWDWSHU
SDWLHQW\HDUV &,SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV FRPSDUHGZLWKSDWLHQWVZLWKD
SURYRNHG¿UVWWKURPERWLFHYHQWLQZKRPWKHUHFXUUHQFHUDWHZDVSHUSDWLHQW\HDUV
&, SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV +5 &, ,QERWKPHQDQG
ZRPHQWKHULVNRIWKURPERWLFHYHQWUHFXUUHQFHZDVKLJKHULQWKRVHZKRKDGKDGDQLGLRSDWKLF
¿UVWWKURPERWLFHYHQWEXWWKHHIIHFWZDVVOLJKWO\KLJKHULQZRPHQ 7$%/( /LNHZLVHWKH
HIIHFWRIVH[RQWKHULVNRIWKURPERWLFHYHQWUHFXUUHQFHZDVWKHVDPHLUUHVSHFWLYHRIW\SH
LGLRSDWKLFRUSURYRNHG RIWKURPERWLFHYHQWZLWKDKLJKHUULVNLQPHQWKDQLQZRPHQ WDEOH
,Q SDWLHQWV ZLWK DQ LGLRSDWKLF ¿UVW HYHQW WKH UHFXUUHQFH UDWHV ZHUH HTXDO LQ WKRVH ZLWK
SURWKURPERWLF DEQRUPDOLWLHV SHU SDWLHQW\HDUV &, SHU
SDWLHQW\HDUV DQGZLWKRXWDEQRUPDOLW\ SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV &, SHU
SDWLHQW\HDUV IRUD+5DGMXVWHGIRUVH[DJHDQGDQWLFRDJXODWLRQRI &,
,QSDWLHQWVZLWKDQRQLGLRSDWKLF¿UVWWKURPERWLFHYHQWWKHUHFXUUHQFHUDWHZDVVRPHZKDW
KLJKHUDPRQJWKRVHZLWKSURWKURPERWLFDEQRUPDOLWLHV SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV &,
SHU SDWLHQW\HDUV FRPSDUHG ZLWK WKRVH ZLWKRXW DQ DEQRUPDOLW\ SHU
SDWLHQW\HDUV &,SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV IRUD+5DGMXVWHGIRUVH[DJH
DQGDQWLFRDJXODWLRQRI &,
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
7DEOH 5HFXUUHQFH5DWHVE\6H[DQG7\SHRI)LUVW7KURPERWLF(YHQW
0HQ :RPHQ
3URYRNHG ,GLRSDWKLF 3URYRNHG ,GLRSDWKLF
1RRISDWLHQWV
1RRIUHFXUUHQFHV
,QFLGHQFHUDWH &,
+D]DUGUDWLR &, Á 5HIHUUHQW 5HIHUUHQW
+D]DUGUDWLR &, Á 5HIHUUHQW
+D]DUGUDWLR &, Á 5HIHUUHQW
$EEUHYLDWLRQ &,FRQ¿GHQFHLQWHUYDO
'H¿QHGDVSUHJQDQF\SXHUSHULXPRUXVHRIRUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYHVZLWKLQGD\VRUWUDXPDVXUJHU\
LPPRELOL]DWLRQRUXVHRISODVWHUFDVWZLWKLQPRQWKVEHIRUHWKHHYHQW
3HUSDWLHQW\HDUV
Á&RUUHFWHG IRU \HDU DJH FDWHJRULHV GXUDWLRQ RI DQWLFRDJXODWLRQ GXULQJ WKH IROORZXS DV D WLPH
GHSHQGHQWFRYDULDWHDQGWKURPERSKLOLD
2UDO$QWLFRQFHSWLYH8VH
$VXEVWDQWLDOQXPEHURIZRPHQ Q XVHGRUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYHVDWWKHWLPHRIWKH
¿UVWWKURPERWLFHYHQWPRVWRIZKRPGLVFRQWLQXHGXVHDIWHUWKHHYHQW+RZHYHUZRPHQ
FRQWLQXHGRUUHVWDUWHGXVHRIRUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYHGXULQJIROORZXS(OHYHQWKURPERWLFHYHQW
UHFXUUHQFHV RFFXUUHG GXULQJ XVH RI RUDO FRQWUDFHSWLRQ RU ZLWKLQ PRQWK DIWHU FHVVDWLRQ
7KHUHFXUUHQFHUDWHLQZRPHQZKRGLGQRWXVHRUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYHVGXULQJIROORZXSZDV
SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV &, SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV ZKLOHLWZDV
SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV &, SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV LQZRPHQZKRXVHGRUDO
FRQWUDFHSWLYHVDWVRPHSRLQWGXULQJWKHIROORZXSSHULRG HLWKHUFRQWLQXLQJRUUHVWDUWLQJ
$PRQJZRPHQZKRGLGQRWXVHRUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYHVGXULQJIROORZXSUHFXUUHQFHUDWHZDV
VOLJKWO\KLJKHULQZRPHQZKRKDGQHYHUXVHGDQRUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYH SHUSDWLHQW
\HDUV &, SHU SDWLHQW\HDUV FRPSDUHG ZLWK ZRPHQ ZKR XVHG RUDO
FRQWUDFHSWLYHVDWWKHWLPHRIWKH¿UVWWKURPERWLFHYHQWEXWGLVFRQWLQXHGXVH SHU
SDWLHQW\HDUV &,SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV 7$%/( $PRQJZRPHQZKR
XVHGRUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYHVGXULQJIROORZXSWKHULVNRIWKURPERWLFUHFXUUHQFHZDVPRUHRUOHVV
HTXDOLQZRPHQZKRKDGDOVRXVHGDQRUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYHDWWKHWLPHRIWKH¿UVWWKURPERWLF
HYHQW SHU SDWLHQW\HDUV &, SHU SDWLHQW\HDUV FRPSDUHG
ZLWKWKRVHZKRKDGQRWXVHGRUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYHVDWWKHWLPHRIWKHLU¿UVWHYHQW SHU
SDWLHQW\HDUV &,SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV 7KHVHUDWHVZHUHKLJKHUZKHQRQO\
WKH\HDUVWKDWWKHRUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYHVZHUHDFWXDOO\XVHGZHUHWDNHQLQWRDFFRXQW 7DEOH
7ZRRIWKHWKURPERWLFHYHQWVWKDWDURVHGXULQJRUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYHXVHRFFXUUHGZLWKLQ
ZHHNVDIWHUVWDUWLQJXVH7ZRHYHQWVRFFXUUHGDIWHU\HDURIXVHDQGWKHRWKHUHYHQWV
KDSSHQHGDIWHUDORQJHUSHULRGRIXVHYDU\LQJEHWZHHQDQG \HDUV2IWKHZRPHQZKR
XVHGRUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYHVGXULQJIROORZXSKDGIDFWRU9/HLGHQ2QO\WKURPERWLFHYHQW
UHFXUUHQFHRFFXUUHGLQWKLVJURXS SHUSDWLHQW\HDUV &,SHU
SDWLHQW\HDUV
55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 7DEOH 5HFXUUHQFH5DWHVE\2UDO&RQWUDFHSWLYH8VHLQ:RPHQ%HWZHHQDQG
<HDUV
7DNLQJ2UDO&RQWUDFHSWLYHDW)LUVW
(YHQW 1RW7DNLQJ2UDO&RQWUDFHSWLYH
DW)LUVW(YHQW 8VHG'XULQJ
)ROORZXS 'LVFRQWLQXHG8VH 8VHG'XULQJ
)ROORZXS 1R8VH
Q Q Q Q
1RRIUHFXUUHQFHV
1RRISDWLHQW\HDUV
2YHUDOOLQFLGHQFH
&,
1RRIUHFXUUHQFHVZKLOH
WDNLQJRUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYH
1RRIRUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYH
XVHSDWLHQW\HDUV
,QFLGHQFH &, ZKLOH
WDNLQJRUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYH
$EEUHYLDWLRQ &,FRQ¿GHQFHLQWHUYDO
3HUSDWLHQW\HDUV
5DWHRI6SRQWDQHRXV5HFXUUHQFHV
7R GHWHUPLQH WKH HIIHFW RI SURWKURPERWLF DEQRUPDOLWLHV RQ UHFXUUHQFH ULVN ZLWKRXW WKH
LQWHUIHUHQFHRIHSLVRGHVZLWKDQLQFUHDVHGRUGHFUHDVHGULVNRIWKURPERVLVZHUHSHDWHGWKH
DQDO\VLVZKLOHH[FOXGLQJDOOSRVWRSHUDWLYHSHULRGV ZHHNVIROORZLQJVXUJLFDOLQWHUYHQWLRQV
SUHJQDQF\DQGSXHUSHULXP ZHHNVIROORZLQJGHOLYHU\ SHULRGVRIRUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYHXVH
DQG DOO SHULRGV RI DQWLFRDJXODWLRQ WUHDWPHQW7KLV OHIW HYHQWV RYHU SDWLHQW\HDUV
IRUDQLQFLGHQFHUDWHRISHUSDWLHQW\HDUV &, SHUSDWLHQW
\HDUV )RUWKRVHZLWKSURWKURPERWLFDEQRUPDOLWLHV IDFWRU9/HLGHQSURWKURPELQ*$
K\SHUKRPRF\VWHLQHPLD GH¿FLHQFLHV RI WKH SURWHLQV & 6 RU DQWLWKURPELQ HOHYDWHG OHYHOV
RIWKHIDFWRU9,,,IDFWRU,;IDFWRU;,RU¿EULQRJHQ WKHLQFLGHQFHUDWHZDVSHU
SDWLHQW\HDUV &, SHU SDWLHQW\HDUV )RU WKRVH SDWLHQWV ZLWKRXW D
SURWKURPERWLF DEQRUPDOLW\ WKH LQFLGHQFH UDWH ZDV SHU SDWLHQW\HDUV &,
SHU SDWLHQW\HDUV +5 &, 7KH HIIHFWV RI HDFK RI WKH
SURWKURPERWLFGHIHFWVVHSDUDWHO\RQWKHULVNRIVSRQWDQHRXVUHFXUUHQFHZHUHDJDLQHTXDOWR
WKRVHIRXQGLQWKHRYHUDOODQDO\VLV 7DEOH
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
'LVFXVVLRQ
,QDODUJHFRKRUWRISDWLHQWVIROORZHGXSIRUDSURORQJHGWLPHDIWHUD¿UVWYHQRXVWKURPERWLF
HYHQW ZH IRXQG DQ DQQXDO ULVN RI WKURPERWLF HYHQW UHFXUUHQFH RI 7KH FXPXODWLYH
ULVNRIUHFXUUHQFHZDVDIWHU\HDUVDQGDIWHU\HDUVRIIROORZXS$OWKRXJK
WKHLQFLGHQFHZDVVOLJKWO\KLJKHULQWKH¿UVW\HDUVDWDQDQQXDOUDWHRIWKHULVNRI
WKURPERWLFHYHQWUHFXUUHQFHSHUVLVWHGDWDKLJKOHYHORIPRUHWKDQGXULQJWKHIROORZLQJ
\HDUV2WKHUVKDYHUHSRUWHGKLJKHUUHFXUUHQFHUDWHVRIDSSUR[LPDWHO\DIWHU\HDUVRI
IROORZXS$QLPSRUWDQWGLIIHUHQFHRIWKHVHVWXGLHVZDVWKHLULQFOXVLRQRIHOGHUO\DQG
FDQFHUSDWLHQWV˹JURXSVOLNHO\WRKDYHUHFXUUHQWWKURPERWLFHYHQWV7KHUHIRUHRXUUHVXOWV
DSSO\WRSDWLHQWVZKRDUH\RXQJHUWKDQ\HDUVDWWKHLU¿UVWWKURPERWLFHYHQWZKRGRQRW
KDYHPDOLJQDQF\EXWZKRDUHRWKHUZLVHXQVHOHFWHG
:HIRXQGDIHZFOLQLFDOIDFWRUVWKDWDIIHFWWKHULVNRIUHFXUUHQFH LHPDOHVH[DQLGLRSDWKLF
¿UVWWKURPERWLFHYHQWDQGRUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYHXVH 6H[DQGWKHW\SHRIHYHQWZHUHUHODWHG
LGLRSDWKLF¿UVWWKURPERWLFHYHQWVZHUHPRUHFRPPRQLQPHQZKLOHSURYRNHG¿UVWWKURPERWLF
HYHQWVZHUHVHHQDOPRVWWLPHVPRUHIUHTXHQWO\LQZRPHQEHFDXVHRIRUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYHXVH
0HQKDGDIROGKLJKHUULVNRIWKURPERWLFHYHQWUHFXUUHQFHWKDQZRPHQ7KLVHIIHFWRI
VH[ZDVWKHVDPHLQSDWLHQWVZLWKD¿UVWLGLRSDWKLFWKURPERWLFHYHQWDVLQWKRVHZLWKD¿UVW
SURYRNHGWKURPERWLFHYHQW6LPLODUO\WKHULVNRIWKURPERWLFHYHQWUHFXUUHQFHLQERWKPHQ
DQGZRPHQZDVKLJKHULQWKRVHZKRKDGKDGDQLGLRSDWKLFHYHQW$OWKRXJKVH[DQGW\SHRI
¿UVWWKURPERWLFHYHQWZHUHVWURQJO\UHODWHGWKHLUHIIHFWVRQUHFXUUHQFHZHUHQRWFRQQHFWHG
7KH HIIHFW RI SURWKURPERWLF DEQRUPDOLWLHV ZDV VPDOO ERWK LQ PHQ DQG ZRPHQ DQG FRXOG
WKHUHIRUHQRWH[SODLQWKHGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHVH[HV7KHVH¿QGLQJVFRQ¿UPUHFHQWUHVXOWV
IURPD%ULWLVKDQGDQ$XVWULDQVWXG\ 8VHRIRUDOFRQWUDFHSWLRQDOVRLQFUHDVHGWKHULVNRI
WKURPERWLFHYHQWUHFXUUHQFH$GYLFHWRUHIUDLQIURPIXUWKHURUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYHXVHZRXOGEH
DVLPSOHDQGHIIHFWLYHZD\WRUHGXFHWKHULVNRIDVHFRQGWKURPERWLFHYHQWLQZRPHQ:H
GLGQRWVHHDPDMRUHIIHFWRISRVWWKURPERWLFGDPDJHRQWKHULVNRIUHFXUUHQFH:HIRXQG
VLPLODU UDWHV RI WKURPERWLF HYHQW UHFXUUHQFHV LQ WKH LSVLODWHUDO DQG FRQWUDODWHUDO OHJ7KLV
PDNHVLWWHPSWLQJWRK\SRWKHVL]HWKDWDV\VWHPLFHIIHFWLVDVOLNHO\WRFRQWULEXWHWRWKHRYHUDOO
UHFXUUHQFHULVNDVSHUVLVWLQJUHPQDQWVRIWKHLQLWLDOFORW
6L[W\VHYHQSHUFHQWRIWKHSDWLHQWVKDGDWOHDVWSURWKURPERWLFDEQRUPDOLW\,QWKHVHSDWLHQWV
WKHUHFXUUHQFHULVNZDVRQO\VOLJKWO\LQFUHDVHG IROG FRPSDUHGZLWKWKRVHZLWKRXWVXFK
DEQRUPDOLWLHV,QSDWLHQWVZLWKPRUHWKDQDEQRUPDOLW\WKHUHFXUUHQFHUDWHZDVKLJKHUWKDQ
LQWKRVHZLWKRQO\DEQRUPDOLW\ IROGYVIROG 7KHHIIHFWRIWKHSURWKURPERWLFULVN
IDFWRUVVHSDUDWHO\YDULHGVRPHZKDWEXWRQWKHZKROHWKH\VHHPHGWREHDZHDNGHWHUPLQDQWRI
UHFXUUHQFHV:HIRXQGQRHYLGHQFHRIDQLQFUHDVHGULVNRIUHFXUUHQFHIRUFDUULHUVRIIDFWRU9
/HLGHQRUWKHSURWKURPELQ*$PXWDWLRQ6LPLODUO\ZHFRXOGQRW¿QGDQH[FHVVUHFXUUHQFH
ULVNIRULQGLYLGXDOVZLWKKLJKOHYHOVRIIDFWRUV9,,,,;RU;,+\SHUKRPRF\VWHLQHPLDGLG
QRW VKRZ DQ\ HIIHFW RQ UHFXUUHQFH ULVN HLWKHU ,W VKRXOG EH QRWHG WKDW LQ WKH 1HWKHUODQGV
YLWDPLQVXSSOHPHQWDWLRQLVQRWFXUUHQWO\DGYLVHGWRSDWLHQWVZLWKK\SHUKRPRF\VWHLQHPLD
7KHUHIRUHWKHVHUHVXOWVUHSUHVHQWWKHQDWXUDOFRXUVHRIWKLVFRQGLWLRQ$PLOGO\LQFUHDVHGULVN
IROG ZDVREVHUYHGLQWKRVHZLWKWKHVWURQJHVWULVNIDFWRUVIRU¿UVWWKURPERWLFHYHQWV
GH¿FLHQFLHVRISURWHLQ&SURWHLQ6DQGDQWLWKURPELQ+LJK¿EULQRJHQOHYHOVDOVRFRQIHUUHG
DVOLJKWO\LQFUHDVHGULVNRIUHFXUUHQFH IROG 7KHVHUHVXOWVDUHDWYDULDQFHZLWKVRPH
55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 RWKHUVWXGLHVLQZKLFKLQFUHDVHGUHFXUUHQFHULVNVZHUHIRXQGIRUSURWHLQ&SURWHLQ6DQG
DQWLWKURPELQIRUK\SHUKRPRF\VWHLQHPLD IRULQFUHDVHGOHYHOVRIIDFWRU9,,,DQGIDFWRU
,;DQGIRUIDFWRU9/HLGHQDQGSURWKURPELQ*$7KHVHVWXGLHVGLIIHUHG
FRQVLGHUDEO\ZLWKUHVSHFWWRGHVLJQDQGVWXG\SRSXODWLRQPHWKRGVVDPSOHVL]HDQGGXUDWLRQ
RI IROORZXS ZKLFK FRXOG H[SODLQ WKH GLVFUHSDQFLHV ,Q D SURVSHFWLYH FRKRUW VWXG\ RI
XQVHOHFWHGSDWLHQWVZLWKDVLPLODUGHVLJQDVRXUVWXG\QRHIIHFWRIWKURPERSKLODZDVIRXQG
HLWKHU,QVXPPDU\ZHVDZQRPDMRUHIIHFWIRUDQ\RIWKHVHIDFWRUVZKLFKLVLQWHUQDOO\
FRQVLVWHQWEHFDXVHLWLVGLI¿FXOWWRXQGHUVWDQGZK\VRPHSURWKURPERWLFDEQRUPDOLWLHVZRXOG
LQFUHDVHWKHULVNRIUHFXUUHQFHDQGRWKHUVZRXOGQRW
9HQRXV WKURPERVLV LV D PXOWLFDXVDO GLVHDVH ,QGLYLGXDOV QHHG D FHUWDLQ FRPELQDWLRQ RI
ULVNIDFWRUVHDFKDGGLQJWRWKHWKURPERWLFHYHQWSRWHQWLDOZKLFKH[FHHGVWKHWKURPERVLV
WKUHVKROG:KHQSDWLHQWVKDYHVLPLODUWKURPERWLFHYHQWSRWHQWLDOVUHFXUUHQFHULVNVPD\EH
VLPLODUWRR7KLVH[SODLQVWKHHTXDOULVNVZHIRXQGIRUDOOWKURPERSKLOLFGHIHFWV,QSDWLHQWV
ZKRVH¿UVWWKURPERWLFHYHQWZDVLGLRSDWKLFWKHUHFXUUHQFHUDWHZDVHTXDOLQWKRVHZLWKDQG
ZLWKRXWDSURWKURPERWLFDEQRUPDOLW\7KLVFDQEHH[SODLQHGIURPWKHH[LVWHQFHRIDQRW\HW
LGHQWL¿HGSURWKURPERWLFDEQRUPDOLWLHVZKLFKKROGWKHVDPHWKURPERWLFHYHQWSRWHQWLDODV
WKH NQRZQ SURWKURPERWLF DEQRUPDOLWLHV7KH UHFXUUHQFH ULVN ZDV DFWXDOO\ RQO\ LQFUHDVHG
LQ WKRVH SDWLHQWV ZKR KDG RU PRUH DEQRUPDOLWLHV RU LQ RWKHU ZRUGV RQO\ WKRVH ZLWK D
VRPHZKDWKLJKHUWKURPERWLFHYHQWSRWHQWLDOVWRRGRXW
$PRQJSDWLHQWVZLWKWKURPERSKLOLDWKRVHZKRKDGDSURYRNHG¿UVWWKURPERWLFHYHQWKDGD
UHFXUUHQFHULVNWKDWZDVVWLOOORZHUWKDQSDWLHQWVZKRKDGDQLGLRSDWKLF¿UVWWKURPERWLFHYHQW
7KLVLVUHPDUNDEOHEHFDXVHRQHZRXOGH[SHFWWKHVHUDWHVWREHHTXDODIWHUWKHHQYLURQPHQWDO
IDFWRU VXUJHU\ SXHUSHULXP WKDW FRQWULEXWHG WR WKH LQLWLDO WKURPERWLF HYHQW KDV EHHQ
UHPRYHG7KLVFDQRQO\EHH[SODLQHGZKHQSDWLHQWVZLWKWKURPERSKLOLDDQGDQLGLRSDWKLF¿UVW
WKURPERWLFHYHQWKDYHDKLJKHUWKURPERWLFHYHQWSRWHQWLDOWKDQSDWLHQWVZLWKWKURPERSKLOLD
DQGDSURYRNHG¿UVWWKURPERWLFHYHQW˹WKLVFRXOGEHDQH[WUD DQRW\HWLGHQWL¿HG ODERUDWRU\
ULVNIDFWRURUDORFDOIDFWRUVXFKDVDQDQDWRPLFDODEQRUPDOLW\
7KHVH¿QGLQJVKDYHLPSRUWDQWLPSOLFDWLRQVIRUFOLQLFDOVWUDWHJLHV3DWLHQWVZLWKDQLGLRSDWKLF
¿UVW WKURPERWLF HYHQW DUH RIWHQ H[WHQVLYHO\ WHVWHG IRU SURWKURPERWLF GHIHFWV +RZHYHU
DSRVLWLYHUHVXOWRIDGHIHFWGRHVQRWSUHGLFWWKHULVNRIWKURPERWLFHYHQWUHFXUUHQFHDQG
WKHUHIRUHKDVQRFOLQLFDOFRQVHTXHQFH
2XUVWXG\PD\EHOLPLWHGZLWKUHVSHFWWRWKHJHQHUDOL]DELOLW\RIWKH¿QGLQJVEHFDXVHZH
H[FOXGHGSDWLHQWVROGHUWKDQ\HDUVDQGFDQFHUSDWLHQWV2XUPDLQ¿QGLQJVPD\WKHUHIRUH
QRW EH DSSOLFDEOH WR WKHVH JURXSV$OVR LQ RXU VWXG\ SRSXODWLRQ WKH XVH RI SURSK\ODFWLF
DQWLFRDJXODWLRQIRUVKRUWSHULRGVZDVTXLWHKLJK7KLVPD\KDYHDIIHFWHGWKHRYHUDOOUHODWLYHO\
ORZUDWHRIUHFXUUHQFHV+RZHYHUZHGRQRWH[SHFWWKDWWKLVKDVKDGDQLQÀXHQFHRQWKHODFN
RIHIIHFWZHIRXQGIRUWKHVHSDUDWHSURWKURPERWLFDEQRUPDOLWLHV,QDOODQDO\VHVWKHXVHRI
DQWLFRDJXODWLRQZDVDGMXVWHGIRUDQGHYHQZKHQZHH[FOXGHGDOOULVNHQKDQFLQJ VXUJHU\
RUDOFRQWUDFHSWLRQ XVH SUHJQDQF\SXHUSHULXP DQG ULVNGHFUHDVLQJ RUDO DQWLFRDJXODWLRQ VLWXDWLRQV ZH GLG QRW ¿QG DQ HIIHFW RI WKURPERSKLOLD$QRWKHU LVVXH LV WKH GLDJQRVLV RI
WKURPERWLF HYHQW UHFXUUHQFH EHFDXVH D QHZ HYHQW LV RIWHQ GLI¿FXOW WR GLVWLQJXLVK IURP
SRVWWKURPERWLFV\QGURPH$QLQFRUUHFWFODVVL¿FDWLRQRIDWKURPERWLFHYHQWUHFXUUHQFHFRXOG
KDYHDIIHFWHGWKHWRWDOUDWHRIUHFXUUHQWHYHQWV+RZHYHUWKHLQFLGHQFHUDWHRIDFRQWUDODWHUDO
VHFRQG'97ZDVRQO\VOLJKWO\ORZHUWKDQWKDWRIDQLSVLODWHUDO'97,WLVWKHUHIRUHXQOLNHO\
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
WKDWWKHORZUDWHRIUHFXUUHQWHYHQWVZDVRYHUHVWLPDWHG7KHGLVWULEXWLRQRIWKHSURWKURPERWLF
ULVN IDFWRUV ZDV DOVR HTXDO EHWZHHQ LSVLODWHUDO DQG FRQWUDODWHUDO '97V 7KHUHIRUH RXU
FRQFOXVLRQZLWKUHVSHFWWRWKHHIIHFWRIWKURPERSKLOLDZRXOGUHPDLQXQFKDQJHG
,QFRQFOXVLRQSDWLHQWVZKRKDGD¿UVWWKURPERWLFHYHQWKDGDKLJKULVNRIUHFXUUHQFH7KLV
ULVNLVKLJKHULQPHQLQSDWLHQWVZKRVH¿UVWWKURPERWLFHYHQWZDVLGLRSDWKLFLQZRPHQ
ZKR XVH RUDO FRQWUDFHSWLYHV DQG LQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK RU PRUH SURWKURPERWLF ULVN IDFWRUV
6ROLWDU\ ODERUDWRU\ DEQRUPDOLWLHV DSSHDU QRW WR SUHGLFW WKH ULVN RI UHFXUUHQFH 7KHUHIRUH
H[WHQVLYHLIDQ\WKURPERSKLOLFZRUNXSDIWHUD¿UVWWKURPERWLFHYHQWLVQRWOLNHO\WRFRQIHU
DFOLQLFDOEHQH¿WWRWKHSDWLHQW6LPLODUO\DGLIIHUHQWLDOWUHDWPHQWZLWKUHJDUGWRGXUDWLRQ
RI RUDO DQWLFRDJXODWLRQ LQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK SURWKURPERWLF DEQRUPDOLWLHV GRHV QRW VHHP WR EH
UDWLRQDOEDVHGRQWKHVHGDWD$GHTXDWHSURSK\ODFWLFDQWLFRDJXODWLRQGXULQJULVNVLWXDWLRQV
IRUDOOSDWLHQWVZLWKDKLVWRU\RIWKURPERWLFHYHQWPD\EHWKHPRVWLPSRUWDQWPHDVXUHWR
UHGXFHWKHULVNRIDUHFXUUHQWHYHQW:RPHQXVLQJRUDOFRQWUDFHSWLYHVVKRXOGEHDGYLVHGWR
UHIUDLQIURPIXUWKHUXVH7KHGHFLVLRQRQRSWLPDOGXUDWLRQRIDQWLFRDJXODWLRQWKHUDS\DIWHU
D¿UVWWKURPERWLFHYHQWZLOOSUREDEO\QHHGWREHEDVHGRQFOLQLFDOIDFWRUV PDOHVH[RUDO
FRQWUDFHSWLYHVXVHDQGLGLRSDWKLF¿UVWWKURPERWLFHYHQW UDWKHUWKDQODERUDWRU\DEQRUPDOLWLHV
$FNQRZOHGJHPHQWV
:HDUHJUDWHIXOWRWKHSHUVRQQHORIWKH$QWLFRDJXODWLRQ&OLQLFVRI/HLGHQ5RWWHUGDPDQG
$PVWHUGDPZKRIDFLOLWDWHGWKHLQFOXVLRQRIWKHSDWLHQWV:HWKDQN$QN6FKUHLMHU,QJHERUJ
GH-RQJHDQG,QJH1RRUGHUPHHUIRUGDWDPDQDJHPHQWDQGDOOSDUWLFLSDWLQJSDWLHQWVIRUWKHLU
FRRSHUDWLRQ
55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55 55 5 5 55 55 55
5HIHUHQFHV
$QGHUVRQ)$-U%URZQHOO:KHHOHU+*ROGEHUJ5-HWDO$SRSXODWLRQEDVHGSHUVSHFWLYHRI
WKHKRVSLWDOLQFLGHQFHDQGFDVHIDWDOLW\UDWHVRIGHHSYHLQWKURPERVLVDQGSXOPRQDU\HPEROLVP
WKH:RUFHVWHU'976WXG\$UFK,QWHUQ0HG
1RUGVWU|P0/LQGEODG%%HUJTYLVW'.MHOOVWU|P7$SURVSHFWLYHVWXG\RIWKHLQFLGHQFHRI
GHHSYHLQWKURPERVLVZLWKLQDGH¿QHGXUEDQSRSXODWLRQ-,QWHUQ0HG
2JHU( (3,*(7%36WXG\*URXS,QFLGHQFHRIYHQRXVWKURPERHPEROLVP DFRPPXQLW\EDVHG
VWXG\LQ:HVWHUQ)UDQFH7KURPE+DHPRVW
5RVHQGDDO)55LVNIDFWRUVIRUYHQRXVWKURPERWLFGLVHDVH7KURPE+DHPRVW
%HUWLQD50.RHOHPDQ%3.RVWHU7HWDO0XWDWLRQLQEORRGFRDJXODWLRQIDFWRU9DVVRFLDWHG
ZLWKUHVLVWDQFHWRDFWLYDWHGSURWHLQ&1DWXUH
3RRUW 65 5RVHQGDDO )5 5HLWVPD 3+ %HUWLQD 50 $ FRPPRQ JHQHWLF YDULDWLRQ LQ WKH
¶XQWUDQVODWHGUHJLRQRIWKHSURWKURPELQJHQHLVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKHOHYDWHGSODVPDSURWKURPELQ
OHYHOVDQGDQLQFUHDVHLQYHQRXVWKURPERVLV%ORRG
.RVWHU7%ODQQ$'%ULsW(9DQGHQEURXFNH-35RVHQGDDO)55ROHRIFORWWLQJIDFWRU9,,,LQ
HIIHFWRIYRQ:LOOHEUDQGIDFWRURQRFFXUUHQFHRIGHHSYHLQWKURPERVLV/DQFHW
YDQ+\OFNDPD9OLHJ$YDQGHU/LQGHQ,.%HUWLQD505RVHQGDDO)5+LJKOHYHOVRIIDFWRU,;
LQFUHDVHWKHULVNRIYHQRXVWKURPERVLV%ORRG
0HLMHUV -&0 7HNHOHQEXUJ :/+ %RXPD %1 %HUWLQD 50 5RVHQGDDO )5 +LJK OHYHOV RI
FRDJXODWLRQIDFWRU;,DVDULVNIDFWRUIRUYHQRXVWKURPERVLV1(QJO-0HG
GHQ+HLMHU0.RVWHU7%ORP+-HWDO+\SHUKRPRF\VWHLQHPLDDVDULVNIDFWRUIRUGHHSYHLQ
WKURPERVLV1(QJO-0HG
.RVWHU75RVHQGDDO)55HLWVPD3+YDQGHU9HOGHQ3$%ULsW(9DQGHQEURXFNH-3)DFWRU
9,,DQG¿EULQRJHQOHYHOVDVULVNIDFWRUVIRUYHQRXVWKURPERVLV DFDVHFRQWUROVWXG\RISODVPD
OHYHOVDQG'1$SRO\PRUSKLVPVWKH/HLGHQ7KURPERSKLOLD6WXG\ /(76 7KURPE+DHPRVW
+DQVVRQ 32 6|UER - (ULNVVRQ + 5HFXUUHQW YHQRXV WKURPERHPEROLVP DIWHU GHHS YHLQ
WKURPERVLV LQFLGHQFHDQGULVNIDFWRUV$UFK,QWHUQ0HG
3UDQGRQL3/HQVLQJ$:$&RJR$HWDO7KHORQJWHUPFOLQLFDOFRXUVHRIDFXWHGHHSYHQRXV
WKURPERVLV$QQ,QWHUQ0HG
.HDURQ & *HQW 0 +LUVK - HW DO $ FRPSDULVRQ RI WKUHH PRQWKV RI DQWLFRDJXODWLRQ ZLWK
H[WHQGHGDQWLFRDJXODWLRQIRUD¿UVWHSLVRGHRILGLRSDWKLFYHQRXVWKURPERHPEROLVP1(QJO-
0HG
'H6WHIDQR90DUWLQHOOL,0DQQXFFL30HWDO7KHULVNRIUHFXUUHQWGHHSYHQRXVWKURPERVLV
DPRQJKHWHUR]\JRXVFDUULHUVRIERWKIDFWRU9/HLGHQDQGWKH*$SURWKURPELQPXWDWLRQ
1(QJO-0HG
'H6WHIDQR90DUWLQHOOL,0DQQXFFL30HWDO7KHULVNRIUHFXUUHQWYHQRXVWKURPERHPEROLVP
DPRQJ KHWHUR]\JRXV FDUULHUV RI WKH *$ SURWKURPELQ JHQH PXWDWLRQ %U - +DHPDWRO
(LFKLQJHU63DELQJHU,6WPSÀHQ$HWDO7KHULVNRIUHFXUUHQWYHQRXVWKURPERHPEROLVPLQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKDQGZLWKRXWIDFWRU9/HLGHQ7KURPE+DHPRVW
(LFKLQJHU60LQDU(+LUVFKO0HWDO7KHULVNRIHDUO\UHFXUUHQWYHQRXVWKURPERHPEROLVP
DIWHU RUDO DQWLFRDJXODQW WKHUDS\ LQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK WKH *$ WUDQVLWLRQ LQ WKH SURWKURPELQ
JHQH7KURPE+DHPRVW
(LFKLQJHU6:HOWHUPDQQ$0DQQKDOWHU&HWDO7KHULVNRIUHFXUUHQWYHQRXVWKURPERHPEROLVP
LQKHWHUR]\JRXVFDUULHUVRIIDFWRU9/HLGHQDQGD¿UVWVSRQWDQHRXVYHQRXVWKURPERHPEROLVP
$UFK,QWHUQ0HG
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
55
5 5
55
55
55
/LQGPDUNHU36FKXOPDQ66WHQ/LQGHU0:LPDQ%(JEHUJ1-RKQVVRQ+'85$&7ULDO
6WXG\*URXS7KHULVNRIUHFXUUHQWYHQRXVWKURPERHPEROLVPLQFDUULHUVDQGQRQFDUULHUVRI
WKH* $DOOHOHLQWKHFRDJXODWLRQIDFWRU9JHQHDQGWKH*$DOOHOHLQWKHSURWKURPELQ
JHQH7KURPE+DHPRVW
0LOHV-60LOHWLFK-3*ROGKDEHU6=+HQQHNHQV&+5LGNHU30*$PXWDWLRQLQWKH
SURWKURPELQ JHQH DQG WKH ULVN RI UHFXUUHQW YHQRXV WKURPERHPEROLVP - $P &ROO &DUGLRO
5LGNHU300LOHWLFK-36WDPSIHU0-*ROGKDEHU6=/LQGSDLQWQHU.+HQQHNHQV&+)DFWRU9
/HLGHQDQGULVNVRIUHFXUUHQWLGLRSDWKLFYHQRXVWKURPERHPEROLVP&LUFXODWLRQ
5LQWHOHQ & 3DELQJHU , .Q|EO 3 /HFKQHU . 0DQQKDOWHU & 3UREDELOLW\ RI UHFXUUHQFH RI
WKURPERVLVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKDQGZLWKRXWIDFWRU9/HLGHQ7KURPE+DHPRVW
6LPLRQL33UDQGRQL3/HQVLQJ$:$HWDO7KHULVNRIUHFXUUHQWYHQRXVWKURPERHPEROLVPLQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKDQ$UJ!*OQPXWDWLRQLQWKHJHQHIRUIDFWRU9 IDFWRU9/HLGHQ 1(QJO-
0HG
6LPLRQL 3 3UDQGRQL 3 /HQVLQJ $:$ HW DO 5LVN IRU VXEVHTXHQW YHQRXV WKURPERHPEROLF
FRPSOLFDWLRQVLQFDUULHUVRIWKHSURWKURPELQRUWKHIDFWRU9JHQHPXWDWLRQZLWKD¿UVWHSLVRGH
RIGHHSYHLQWKURPERVLV%ORRG
'RFXPHQWRQFOLQLFDOYDOLGLW\$YDLODEOHDW KWWS ZZZFGFJRYJHQRPLFVDFWLYLWLHV¿OHVSULQW
97(B&OLQLFDO9DOLGLW\SGI$FFHVVLELOLW\YHUL¿HG$SULO
.\UOH3$0LQDU(+LUVFKO0HWDO+LJKSODVPDOHYHOVRIIDFWRU9,,,DQGWKHULVNRIUHFXUUHQW
YHQRXVWKURPERHPEROLVP1(QJO-0HG
:HOWHUPDQQ$(LFKLQJHU6%LDORQF]\N&HWDO7KHULVNRIUHFXUUHQWYHQRXVWKURPERHPEROLVP
DPRQJSDWLHQWVZLWKKLJKIDFWRU,;OHYHOV-7KURPE+DHPRVW
GHQ+HLMHU0%ORP+-*HUULWV:%-HWDO,VK\SHUKRPRF\VWHLQDHPLDDULVNIDFWRUIRUUHFXUUHQW
YHQRXVWKURPERVLV"/DQFHW
(LFKLQJHU66WPSÀHQ$+LUVFKO0HWDO+\SHUKRPRF\VWHLQHPLDLVDULVNIDFWRURIUHFXUUHQW
YHQRXVWKURPERHPEROLVP7KURPE+DHPRVW
/HQVLQJ$:$ 3ULQV 0+ 5HFXUUHQW GHHS YHLQ WKURPERVLV DQG WZR FRDJXODWLRQ IDFWRU JHQH
PXWDWLRQV TXRYDGLV"7KURPE+DHPRVW
6LPLRQL35LVNRIUHFXUUHQWYHQRXVWKURPERHPEROLVPDQGWKURPERSKLOLD GRHVGLVFUHSDQF\
PDNHFRPSOH[LW\RUYLFHYHUVD"-7KURPE+DHPRVW
YDQ GHU 0HHU )-0 .RVWHU 7 9DQGHQEURXFNH -3 %ULsW ( 5RVHQGDDO )5 7KH /HLGHQ
7KURPERSKLOLD6WXG\ /(76 7KURPE+DHPRVW
.RVWHU75RVHQGDDO)5%ULsW(HWDO3URWHLQ&GH¿FLHQF\LQDFRQWUROOHGVHULHVRIXQVHOHFWHG
RXWSDWLHQWV DQLQIUHTXHQWEXWFOHDUULVNIDFWRUIRUYHQRXVWKURPERVLV /HLGHQ7KURPERSKLOLD
6WXG\ %ORRG
.RVWHU 7 5RVHQGDDO )5 GH 5RQGH + %ULsW ( 9DQGHQEURXFNH -3 %HUWLQD 50 9HQRXV
WKURPERVLVGXHWRSRRUDQWLFRDJXODQWUHVSRQVHWRDFWLYDWHGSURWHLQ& /HLGHQ7KURPERSKLOLD
6WXG\/DQFHW
5RVHQGDDO)5.RVWHU79DQGHQEURXFNH-35HLWVPD3++LJKULVNRIWKURPERVLVLQSDWLHQWV
KRPR]\JRXVIRUIDFWRU9/HLGHQ DFWLYDWHGSURWHLQ&UHVLVWDQFH %ORRG
%DJOLQ7/XGGLQJWRQ5%URZQ.%DJOLQ&,QFLGHQFHRIUHFXUUHQWYHQRXVWKURPERHPEROLVP
LQ UHODWLRQ WR FOLQLFDO DQG WKURPERSKLOLF ULVN IDFWRUV SURVSHFWLYH FRKRUW VWXG\ /DQFHW
.\UOH3$0LQDU(%LDORQF]\N&+LUVFKO0:HOWHUPDQQ$(LFKLQJHU67KHULVNRIUHFXUUHQW
YHQRXVWKURPERHPEROLVPLQPHQDQGZRPHQ1(QJO-0HG
%DJOLQ7/XGGLQJWRQ5%URZQ.%DJOLQ&+LJKULVNRIUHFXUUHQWYHQRXVWKURPERHPEROLVP
LQPHQ-7KURPE+DHPRVW
3UDQGRQL3/HQVLQJ$:$3ULQV0+HWDO5HVLGXDOYHQRXVWKURPERVLVDVDSUHGLFWLYHIDFWRU
RIUHFXUUHQWYHQRXVWKURPERHPEROLVP$QQ,QWHUQ0HG
+XOO5'&DUWHU&--D\50HWDO7KHGLDJQRVLVRIDFXWHU $WRWDORI LQGLYLGXDOVZHUHORVW
GXULQJWKHVWXG\EXWODWHUIRXQG7KXVWKHVHLQGLYLGXDOVGLGQRWUHFHLYHDOOTXHVWLRQQDLUHVEXW
LQIRUPDWLRQZDVFRPSOHWHGXULQJIROORZXS
