Beyond ethnic differences in child sexual abuse: Comparative study into child sexual abuse of youth with a non-western ethnic and native Dutch background

(1)

Tilburg University

Beyond ethnic differences in child sexual abuse Okur, Pinar

Publication date:

2015

Document Version

Publisher's PDF, also known as Version of record

Link to publication in Tilburg University Research Portal

Citation for published version (APA):

Okur, P. (2015). Beyond ethnic differences in child sexual abuse: Comparative study into child sexual abuse of youth with a non-western ethnic and native Dutch background. Ridderprint BV.

General rights

Copyright and moral rights for the publications made accessible in the public portal are retained by the authors and/or other copyright owners and it is a condition of accessing publications that users recognise and abide by the legal requirements associated with these rights. • Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the public portal for the purpose of private study or research. • You may not further distribute the material or use it for any profit-making activity or commercial gain

• You may freely distribute the URL identifying the publication in the public portal

Take down policy

(2)

(3)

(4)

(5)

(6)

! !?@AB@AC+ + ! ! !2%$'*&+D+ U;5;76F!45=7A>9?=4A5+ a! !2%$'*&+E+ 37;K6F;5?;!65>!56=97;!AD!?:4F>!<;b96F!6@9<;!45!=:;! &;=:;7F65><T!#=:54?!>4DD;7;5?;<c! Wd! !2%$'*&+F+ '4DD;7;5?;<!45!?A5=;b=96F!D6?=A7<!45!?:4F>:AA>!<;b96F!6@9<;! @;=B;;5!K4?=4E<!B4=:!6!56=4K;!'9=?:!65>!5A5`P;<=;75!;=:54?! @6?8H7A95>! eZ! !2%$'*&+G+ #=:54?!>4DD;7;5?;<!45!:;FC`<;;845H!@;:6K4A7!DAFFAB45H!?:4F>! <;b96F!6@9<;T!2!E9F=4`E;=:A>!>;<4H5! [Y! !2%$'*&+H+ &A5`P;<=;75!;=:54?!E45A74=I!K4?=4E<!AD!?:4F>!<;b96F!6@9<;! O+.2Q!45!P;<=;75!<9CCA7=!<I<=;E<T!GŝĐƚŝŵƐ͛ŶĂƌƌĂƚŝǀĞƐŽŶ C;7?;C=4A5<!AD!+.2!65>!:;FC!<;;845H! \Y! !2%$'*&+I+ 2!f965=4=6=4K;!<=9>I!A5!H;5>;7!>4DD;7;5?;<!45!>4<?FA<45H!?:4F>! <;b96F!6@9<;!65>!7;6<A5<!DA7!5A5`>4<?FA<97;! YYd! !2%$'*&+J+ 2==74@9=4A5<!AD!@F6E;!6EA5H!K4?=4E<!AD!?:4F>!<;b96F!6@9<;T! ,45>45H<!D7AE!6!?AEE954=I!<6ECF;! YeZ!

!2%$'*&+K+ .9EE67I!65>!H;5;76F!>4<?9<<4A5! Yad!

+ &;>;7F65><;!<6E;5K6==45H! Y\\!

+ 2@A9=!=:;!69=:A7! WYY!

+ /4<=!AD!C9@F4?6=4A5<! WYZ!

(7)

! [!

!

(8)

! a!

+)23(#-!Y!

!

U;5;76F!45=7A>9?=4A5!

(9)

! ]!

(10)

! \!

L@AM?:N!AL?@+

(11)

! YX!

<;b96F!?A;7?4A5!65>!DA7?;!=:65!56=4K;!'9=?:!H47F<J!B:4F;!5A!C7;K6F;5?;!76=;!B6<!7;CA7=;>!DA7! .97456E;<;R'9=?:! 25=4FF;65! H47F<V! /6E;7<`tŝŶŬĞůŵĂŶ͕ ^ůŽƚ͕ ŝũů͕ ĂŶĚ sŝũůďƌŝĞĨ͛Ɛ ƐƚƵĚǇ ;WXXaQ! >4>!5A=!>4<=45H94<:!@;=B;;5!@AI<!65>!H47F<!@9=!7;CA7=;>!=:6=!E45A7<!O@;FAB!Ye!I;67<Q!D7AE! ;=:54?!E45A74=I!H7A9C<!:6>!65!6FEA<=!=BA!=4E;<!:4H:;7!74<8!AD!;bC;74;5?45H!?:4F>!6@9<;!O4V;VJ! 5A! >4<=45?=4A5! B6<! E6>;! @;=B;;5! +.2! 65>! A=:;7! DA7E<! AD! ?:4F>! 6@9<;Q! =:65! 56=4K;! '9=?:! 6>AF;<?;5=<V! *5! 6! <97K;I! A5! <;b96F! K4?=4E4N6=4A5! O';! )66<J! WXYWQJ! :AB;K;7J! 5A! >4DD;7;5?;<! B;7;! DA95>!@;=B;;5! BAE;5! AD! '9=?:! A74H45! 65>!(9784<:J! ^A7A??65J! .97456E;<;! A7! '9=?:! 25=4FF;65!BAE;5!O=:;!59E@;7!AD!E;5!B6<!=AA!<E6FF!=A!6FFAB!f965=4=6=4K;!656FI<4<QV!.4E4F67FIJ! G65! *_N;5>AA75! ;=! 6FV! OWXXaQ! ?A5?F9>;>! =:6=! =:;! C7;K6F;5?;! AD! +.2! AD! ?:4F>7;5! B4=:! 6!5A5` P;<=;75!;=:54?!@6?8H7A95>!>A;<!5A=!>4DD;7!<4H54D4?65=FI! D7AE!=:;!C7;K6F;5?;!76=;!AD!56=4K;! '9=?:!?:4F>7;5V!*5!=:;!DAFFAB`9C!<=9>I!AD!G65!*_N;5>AA75!;=!6FV!OWXXaQJ!?A5>9?=;>!@I!2F458J! G65!*_N;5>AA75J!"68;7E65<`M765;5@97HJ!3655;@688;7J!GAH;F<J!65>!#9<;7!OWXYWQ!6!D;B!I;67<! F6=;7J! :4H:;7! C7;K6F;5?;! 76=;<! AD! +.2! B;7;! 7;CA7=;>! 6EA5H! ;=:54?! E45A74=4;<J! @9=! =:;<;! >4DD;7;5?;<! >4<6CC;67;>! 6D=;7! ?A5=7AFF45H! DA7! <A?4A`>;EAH76C:4?! D6?=A7<! <9?:! 6<! FAB! <A?4A` ;?A5AE4?!<=6=9<!65>!;>9?6=4A56F!F;K;FV!';<C4=;!=:;!D45>45H<!D7AE!6@AK;!E;5=4A5;>!<=9>4;<J! =A! >6=;J! D45>45H<! 67;! 6E@4H9A9<! B4=:! 7;H67>! =A! =:;! C7;K6F;5?;! 76=;<! AD! +.2! 6EA5H! ;=:54?! E45A74=4;<V!

*5=;756=4A56F! 7;<;67?:! D64F;>! =A! ?F674DI! =:;! f9;<=4A5! B:;=:;7! ;=:54?! >4DD;7;5?;<! ;b4<=! 45! C7;K6F;5?;! 76=;<! AD! +.2! 6<! B;FFV! (:;7;! 67;! 6! D;B! <=9>4;<! 45>4?6=45H! =:6=! +.2! 4<! EA7;! C7;K6F;5=!6EA5H!;=:54?!E45A74=I!H7A9C<!O.;>F68J!^;==;5@97HJ!"6<;56J!3;==6J!^?3:;7<A5J!S! U7;;5;J! WXYXi! 1V.V! ';C67=E;5=! AD! );6F=:! 65>! )9E65! .;7K4?;<J! &6=4A56F! +;5=;7! A5! +:4F>! 2@9<;!65>!&;HF;?=J!Y\\aQJ!@9=!=:;7;!67;!6F<A!<=9>4;<!=:6=!?A5=;<=!=:;<;!>4DD;7;5?;<!O-9<<;FFJ! Y\][i!PI6==J!Y\]ZQV!

(A!?F674DI!=:;!C:;5AE;5A5!AD!+.2!45!E45A74=I!H7A9C<J!C7;K6F;5?;!76=;<J!@9=!6F<A!>6=6!A5!=:;! 56=97;! O4V;VJ! DA7E<! AD! 6@9<;QJ! ?A5=;b=! O4V;VJ! ?A5=;b=96F! D6?=A7<J! 45?F9>45H! K4?=4E`C;7C;=76=A7! 7;F6=4A5<:4CJ!6H;!AD!A5<;=J!D7;f9;5?I!AD!6@9<;Q!65>!O?9F=976FQ!6==4=9>;<!=AB67>!<;b96F4=I!65>! <;b96F!6@9<;!5;;>!=A!@;!45?F9>;>!45!6?6>;E4?!7;<;67?:V!(:;<;!>6=6!B4FF!@;!7;F;K65=!DA7!=:;! 45=;7C7;=6=4A5! AD! =:;! C7;K6F;5?;! 76=;<V! (A! D4FF! =:4<! H6C! 45! 7;<;67?:J! =:;! ?977;5=! <=9>I! ;b6E45;<! =:;! C7;K6F;5?;J! 56=97;! 65>! ?A5=;b=! AD! +.2! 6EA5H! ;=:54?! E45A74=4;<! 45! =:;! &;=:;7F65><V!

(12)

!YY!

O*3$8,**;(0<+%6'*&+!CP+

(13)

! YW!

P(#+"6+'2*+.(,,*&'%'("0+

(:;7;! 4<! F4E4=;>! 65>! E4b;>! ;EC474?6F! ;K4>;5?;! A5! B:;=:;7! ;=:54?! >4DD;7;5?;<! ;b4<=! 45! C7;K6F;5?;!76=;<!AD!+.2!45!=:;!&;=:;7F65><!65>!45!:;FC`<;;845H!@;:6K4A7!6D=;7!+.2V!*5!A7>;7! =A!95>;7<=65>!=:;!E6H54=9>;!AD!=:;!C7A@F;E!65>!=:;!5;;><!AD!;=:54?!E45A74=4;<!6D=;7!+.2J! 65>!B:;=:;7!=:;<;!5;;><!>4DD;7!45!?AEC674<A5!B4=:!56=4K;!'9=?:!K4?=4E<!AD!+.2J!?AEC676=4K;! 7;<;67?:!4<!7;f947;>V! (:;!64E!AD!=:;!?977;5=!<=9>I!4<!=:7;;DAF>T!O6Q!>;K;FAC45H!6!?AEC676=4K;!C;7<C;?=4K;!A5!=:;! C7;K6F;5?;J!56=97;!65>!?A5=;b=!AD!+.2!6EA5H!IA9=:!B4=:!6!5A5`P;<=;75!;=:54?!@6?8H7A95>! 65>! 56=4K;! '9=?:! @6?8H7A95>i! O@Q! 95>;7<=65>45H! B:;7;! ʹ! 45! ?AEC674<A5! B4=:! =:;47! 56=4K;! '9=?:!?A95=;7C67=<!`!5A5`P;<=;75!;=:54?!E45A74=I!K4?=4E<!AD!+.2!=975!=A!DA7!:;FC!6D=;7!+.2! 65>!B:6=!=:;47!;bC;74;5?;<!67;!B4=:!:;FC`<;;845H!@;:6K4A7i!65>!O?Q!H64545H!6>>4=4A56F!45<4H:=! 45! =:;! B6I! K4?=4E<! AD! +.2! ?AC;! B4=:! =:;! 6@9<;! 65>! =:;! 45DF9;5?;! AD! 6==4=9>;<! =AB67>! <;b96F4=I! 65>! H;5>;7! 7AF;<! A5! ?AC45Hi! 5A=! A5FI! D7AE! 65! ;=:54?! C;7<C;?=4K;J! @9=! 6F<A! 45! @7A6>;7! =;7E<J! 56E;FI! K4?=4E<! AD! +.2! 45! H;5;76F! 65>! E6F;! 65>! D;E6F;! K4?=4E<! AD! +.2! 45! C67=4?9F67V!!

';<C4=;!=:;!D6?=!=:6=!C7;K4A9<!<=9>4;<!67;!6E@4H9A9<!B4=:!7;H67>!=A!=:;!C7;K6F;5?;!76=;<!AD! ;=:54?! E45A74=4;<J! 4=! 4<! :ICA=:;<4N;>! ʹ@6<;>! A5! 45>4?6=4A5<! AD! '9=?:! <A?4;=I`! =:6=! ;=:54?! >4DD;7;5?;<!B4FF!@;!DA95>J!B4=:!;=:54?!E45A74=I!H7A9C<!7;CA7=45H!:4H:;7!C7;K6F;5?;!76=;<!AD! +.2! 45! ?AEC674<A5! B4=:! 56=4K;! '9=?:! IA9=:V! ,97=:;7J! 4=! 4<! 6<<9E;>! =:6=! ʹ! @6<;>! A5! =:;! 6K64F6@F;!F4=;76=97;!>;<?74@;>!6@AK;! ʹ!;=:54?!E45A74=I!H7A9C<!<;;8!F;<<!:;FC!6D=;7!+.2!=:65! =:;47! 56=4K;! '9=?:! ?A95=;7C67=<! 65>! =:6=! =:;47! :;FC`<;;845H! @;:6K4A7! 4<! 45DF9;5?;>! @I! O?9F=976FQ!6==4=9>;<!=AB67>!<;b96F4=I!65>!H;5>;7!7AF;<V!!

C'-./+.*,(<0+

(A! 6>;f96=;FI! 6>>7;<<! =:;! ?AECF;b4=I! AD! 6! +.2! <=9>I! 45! 6! :;=;7AH;5;A9<! 7;<;67?:! CAC9F6=4A5J! 6! E9F=4`E;=:A>J! E9F=4`45DA7E65=! 7;<;67?:! >;<4H5! B6<! >;<4H5;>V! (:4<! >;<4H5! ?A5<4<=;>! AD! =:7;;! C67=<! 65>! ?AE@45;>! 6! f965=4=6=4K;! 6CC7A6?:! 65>! =BA! f96F4=6=4K;! 6CC7A6?:;<V!,4H97;!YVYV!4FF9<=76=;<!=:;!<=9>I!>;<4H5V!

(14)

!Yd!

Q(<-&*+D=D=!';<4H5!AD!=:;!<=9>I!

(15)

! Ye!

Q(<-&*+D=E=!,FAB?:67=!AD!C67=4?4C6=45H!<?:AAF<!

! '6=6!B;7;!?AFF;?=;>!>9745H!<?:AAF!:A97<!6<!C67=!AD!=:;!7;H9F67!F;?=97;<V!*5!?A5<9F=6=4A5!B4=:! <?:AAF<! 65>! =;6?:;7<! A5! :AB! =A! 45=7A>9?;! =:;! =AC4?J! =:;! <97K;I! B6<! 45=7A>9?;>! >9745H! <?:AAF! F;<<A5<! 45! ?AEC9=;7! ?F6<<7AAE<J! B:;7;! <=9>;5=<! D4FF;>! 45! =:;! B;@`@6<;>! <97K;IV! .=9>;5=<!B;7;!6<8;>!DA7!=:;47!45DA7E;>!?A5<;5=!65>!=:A<;!B:A!>;?F45;>!=A!C67=4?4C6=;!45!=:;! <=9>I! ?AECF;=;>! 65! 6F=;756=4K;! <97K;I! A5! <=9>I! EA=4K6=4A5T! =:;! '9=?:`F65H96H;! !"#$%&%'#(

)*%'+&%'#(,#$%!O3^(Q!g3;7DA7E65?;!^A=4K6=4A5!(;<=hV!(:4<!<97K;I!B6<!C7;<;5=;>!45!=:;!<6E;!

F6IA9=! 6<! =:;! <97K;I! A5! +.2V! (:4<! B6IJ! <=9>;5=<! >4>! 5A=! :6K;! =A! F;6K;! =:;! ?F6<<7AAE! 65>! C74K6?I! DA7! 6FF! =:;! <=9>;5=<! B6<! <6D;H967>;>V! (:;! 7;<9F=<! AD! =:;! 6F=;756=4K;! <97K;I! B;7;! >;F;=;>! D7AE! =:;! >6=6<;=! 6D=;7! =:;! >6=6! ?AFF;?=4A5! B6<! D454<:;>V! '6=6! B;7;! ?AFF;?=;>! @;=B;;5! &AK;E@;7! WXYY! 65>! 2C74F! WXYWV! ! ,4H97;! YVdV! 4FF9<=76=;<! =:;! DFAB?:67=! AD!

(16)

!YZ!

Q(<-&*+D=F=!,FAB?:67=!AD!C67=4?4C65=<!

(17)

! Y[! 45?F9>;>!45!=:4<!=:;<4<V!(:;!>6=6!?AFF;?=4A5!DA7!=:;!45=;7K4;B<!=AA8!CF6?;!D7AE!29H9<=!WXYW!=A! ';?;E@;7!WXYW!65>!=:;!C67=4?4C65=<!?:A<;!=:;!<;==45HV!(:;!3<I?:AFAH4?6F!#=:4?<!+AEE4==;;! O3#(+Q!AD!(4F@97H!154K;7<4=I!6CC7AK;>!=:;!C7A?;>97;V!(:;!45=;7K4;B<!B;7;!?A5>9?=;>!@I!=:;! 69=:A7!65>!=:7;;!45=;7K4;B;7<!65>!F6<=;>!65!6K;76H;!AD!eZ!=A!\X!E459=;<V!! ! (:;!DA?9<!H7A9C<!DAFFAB;>!6D=;7!=:;!A5F45;!<97K;I!65>!45=;7K4;B<!45!A7>;7!=A!H645!6!>;;C;7! ŝŶƐŝŐŚƚ ĨƌŽŵ Ă ƉƌŽĨĞƐƐŝŽŶĂů͛Ɛ ƉĞƌƐƉĞĐƚŝǀĞ ŝŶƚŽ ƚŚĞ ƐƵƌǀĞǇ! 7;<9F=<! 65>! =:;! 45=;7K4;B<V! (:;! DA?9<! H7A9C<! ?A5<4<=;>! AD! C7AD;<<4A56F<! D7AE! DA97! >4DD;7;5=! 5A5`P;<=;75! ;=:54?! @6?8H7A95><T!'9=?:!25=4FF;65J!.97456E;<;J!^A7A??65!65>!(9784<:V!(A!f96F4DI!DA7!45?F9<4A5!45! =:;! DA?9<! H7A9C<J! =:;! C67=4?4C65=<! :6>! =A! BA78! B4=:! ;=:54?! E45A74=4;<J! C7;D;76@FI! :6K;! =:;! <6E;!;=:54?!@6?8H7A95>!6<!A5;!AD!=:;!;=:54?!E45A74=I!H7A9C<J!65>!@;!45KAFK;>!B4=:!=:;!=AC4?! AD!<;b96F4=I!65>RA7!+.2V!(:7A9H:!6!<5AB@6FF!<6ECF45H!6CC7A6?:J!6!F4<=!AD!;F4H4@F;!C;ACF;!B6<! H;5;76=;>V!#K;5=96FFI!=BA!=A!DA97!;bC;7=<!B;7;!C7;<;5=!45!;6?:!DA?9<!H7A9CV!^;;=45H<!B;7;! <?:;>9F;>!@;=B;;5!^6I!WXYW!65>!_95;!WXYW!65>!F6<=;>!DA7!65!6K;76H;!AD!A5;!=A!A5;!65>!6! :6FD!:A97<V!! :*6(0('("0,+ -%./'0(1'/*"'%2(3"*45$((

(18)

!Ya! *=!<:A9F>!@;!E;5=4A5;>!=:6=!>4DD;7;5=!=;7E<!:6K;!@;;5!9<;>!=:7A9H:A9=!=:4<!>4<<;7=6=4A5!=A! >;<?74@;! =:;! ;=:54?! E45A74=I! H7A9C<! 45! =:;! &;=:;7F65><V! *5=;7?:65H;6@FI! 9<;>! =;7E<! `! >;C;5>45H!A5!=:;!?A5=;b=!AD!=:;!<=9>I!65>!=:;!<=IF;!AD!=:;!LA9756F!=:;!<;C676=;!<=9>4;<!B;7;! C9@F4<:;>! `! 67;! ;=:54?! E45A74=I! H7A9C<J! E45A74=I! ;=:54?! H7A9C<J! =76>4=4A56F! 5A5`P;<=;75! E4H765=! H7A9C<J! IA9=:! B4=:! 6! 5A5`P;<=;75! ;=:54?! @6?8H7A95>J! IA95H! C;ACF;! AD! 5A5` P;<=;75!:;74=6H;!65>!5A5`P;<=;75!;=:54?!E45A74=4;<V!

6.'78($#94&7(&:4$#((

(:;!>4DD4?9F=I!B:;5!>;D4545H!+.2!4<!=:6=!4=!?AK;7<!6!@7A6>!<C;?=79E!AD!<;b96F!6@9<;!7;F6=;>! @;:6K4A7<V! (:4<! <C;?=79E! AD! @;:6K4A7<! 45?F9>;<! =:;! DA7E! AD! 6@9<;J! =:;! K4?=4E`C;7C;=76=A7! 7;F6=4A5<:4C!65>!=:;!6H;!765H;!AD!K4?=4E<!65>!C;7C;=76=A7<V!*5!A7>;7!=A!?AEC67;! H7A9C<!A5! =:;!56=97;!65>!?A5=;b=!AD!=:;!6@9<;J!@9=!6F<A!=A!@;!6@F;!=A!?F6<<4DI!=:;!6@9<;!45=A!>4DD;7;5=! ?6=;HA74;<J!B;!>4>!5A=!B65=!=A!7;<=74?=!A97<;FK;<!@I!9<45H!6!5677AB!>;D454=4A5V!(:;!>;D454=4A5! AD!+.2!45!=:4<!<=9>I!4<T!

!

;/2( $#94&7( #95#"'#/0#( *<( &( 5#"$*/( 45( %*( =>( 2#&"$?( '/+*7+'/3( :*8'72( *"(/*/@:*8'72( 0*/%&0%( '/( "#&7(7'<#?('<(%.&%(#95#"'#/0#('$($4:A#0%'+#72(B4&7'<'#8(&$('/+*74/%&"2(:2(%.#($4:A#0%?("#3&"87#$$(*<( %.#(&3#(8'<<#"#/0#(:#%C##/($4:A#0%(&/8(5#"5#%"&%*"D(

!

*5! =:;! DAFFAB45H! <;?=4A5J! =:;! 76=4A56F;! DA7! =:;! >;D454=4A5! AD! +.2! 45! =:;! ?977;5=! <=9>I! 4<! >;<?74@;>V!

!

!2(3.&*0=!/ŶƚŚŝƐƐƚƵĚǇ͕ĂĐŚŝůĚŝƐĚĞĨŝŶĞĚĂƐ͚&(5#"$*/(#/0*15&$$'/3(%.#(&3#("&/3#(45(%*(=>( 2#&"$͛ ;hE ŽŶǀĞŶƚŝŽŶ ŽŶ! =:;! -4H:=<! AD! =:;! +:4F>J! 1&+-+J! &AKV! WXJ! Y\]\QV! P4=:! =:4<!

>;D454=4A5J!6FF!<;b96FFI!6@9<4K;!;K;5=<!=:6=!:6K;!:6CC;5;>!=A!6!C;7<A5!@;DA7;!=:;!6H;!AD!Y]! I;67<! 67;! ?A5<4>;7;>! 6<! +.2V! P:6=! 4<! ?A5<4>;7;>! 6<! 6! <;b96FFI! 6@9<4K;! ;K;5=! 4<! >;D45;>! @;FABV!

!

R".(3/+%0.+0"085".(3/+1"0'%1'+*4$*&(*01*,=!.;b96FFI!6@9<4K;!;bC;74;5?;<!?65!45KAFK;!@A>4FI!

(19)

! Y]! F45;QV!(:;!D47<=!?6=;HA7I!45?F9>;<!;bC;74;5?;<!<9?:!6<!@;45H!DA7?;>!=A!B6=?:!<;b96F!6?=4K4=4;<! AD!A=:;7<!A7!K4<96F!4E6H;<!AD!6!<;b96F!56=97;J!A7!@;45H!DA7?;>!=A!C;7DA7E!<AF4=67I!<;b96F!6?=<! 45!=:;!C7;<;5?;!AD!A=:;7O<QJ!B:4F;!=:;!<;?A5>!?6=;HA7I!6CCF4;<!=A!45=;75;=!H7AAE45HV!,A7!=:;! <?AC;!AD!=:4<!<=9>IJ!B;!DA?9<;>!A5!@A>4FI!65>!5A5`@A>4FI!?A5=6?=!;bC;74;5?;<!45!7;6F!F4D;V! !

M*3%'("0,2($+ 7('2+ '2*+ $*&$*'&%'"&=! *5! A7>;7! =A! @;! 6<! 45?F9<4K;! 6<! CA<<4@F;J! =:;! DAFFAB45H!

?6=;HA74;<!AD!C;7C;=76=A7<!B;7;!>4<=45H94<:;>T!

! ,6E4FI!E;E@;7<!OC67;5=6F!D6E4FIJ!<=;C!C67;5=<R`<4@F45H<J!A=:;7!7;F6=4K;<Q! ! 367=5;7<R;b`C67=5;7<!

! ,74;5><RC;;7<!

! 37AD;<<4A56F<! OB:;7;! =:;! ?:4F>! 4<! 45! 6! C7AD;<<4A56F! 7;F6=4A5<:4C! AD! 95;f96F! CAB;7R>;C;5>;5?IT! =;6?:;7<J! <A?46F! BA78;7<J! =:;76C4<=<J! H967>465<J! 7;F4H4A9<! ADD4?46F<RC74;<=<!;=?VQ!

! .A?46F!6?f9645=65?;<!! ! .=765H;7<!

!

P<*+&%0<*=!.;b96F!;bC;74;5?;<!AD!6!?:4F>!9C!=A!YW!I;67!B4=:!6!C;7<A5!6=!F;6<=!Z!I;67<!AF>;7!

(20)

!Y\! ?-'3(0*+"6+'2*+.(,,*&'%'("0+ +:6C=;7! W! 65>! d! >;<?74@;! =:;! C7;K6F;5?;J! 56=97;! 65>! ?A5=;b=! AD! <;b96F! 6@9<;! 45! =:;! &;=:;7F65><i!?:6C=;7!e!6>>7;<<;<!=:;!>4DD;7;5?;<!45!:;FC`<;;845H!6D=;7!+.2!@;=B;;5!;=:54?! E45A74=4;<!65>!56=4K;!'9=?:!K4?=4E<V!+:6C=;7!Z!>;<?74@;<!=:;!C;7?;C=4A5<!AD!;=:54?!E45A74=4;<! 7;H67>45H!?A5?;C=<!AD!+.2!65>!:;FC`<;;845H!45!=:;!&;=:;7F65><V!+:6C=;7![!65>!a!C7;<;5=!=:;! 7;<9F=<! AD! =BA! <=9>4;<! A5! ?AC45H! @;:6K4A7! 6D=;7! +.2i! ?:6C=;7! [! >;<?74@;<! :;FC`<;;845H! @;:6K4A7! 6EA5H! @AI<! 65>! H47F<! 65>! ?:6C=;7! a! ;b6E45;<! =:;! C;7?;C=4A5<! AD! K4?=4E<! AD! +.2! 7;H67>45H!@F6E;! 6==74@9=4A5<V!(:;!D456F! ?:6C=;7! O]Q! C7;<;5=<! 6! <9EE67IJ!H;5;76F! >4<?9<<4A5! AD!=:;!D45>45H<!65>!4ECF4?6=4A5<!DA7!C76?=4?;V!

(21)

! WX!

MBQBMB@!BC+

2F6HH46J!-V!OWXXWQV!+9F=976F!65>!7;F4H4A9<!45DF9;5?;<!45!E6=;756F!7;<CA5<;!=A!45=76D6E4F46F!?:4F>! <;b96F!6@9<;T!+:67=45H!5;B!=;774=A7I!DA7!7;<;67?:!65>!=7;6=E;5=V!E*4"/&7(*<(6.'78(F#94&7( ;:4$#J!=GJ!eY`[XV! 2F458J!/V!-V!2VJ!3655;@688;7J!,V!'VJ!#9<;7J!#V!^VJ!"68;7E65<`M765;5@97HJ!^V!_VJ!GAH;F<J!(VJ!S! G65!*_N;5>AA75J!-V!OWXYWQV!H'/8#"1'$.&/8#7'/3('/(I#8#"7&/8(&//*(JG=G(K6.'78(&:4$#('/( %.#(I#%.#"7&/8$('/(JG=GLD!/;4>;5J!(:;!&;=:;7F65><T!+6<4E47!39@F4<:;7<V! ";FF667=J!)V!OWXXaQV!^A;4F4L8!@;7;48@67;!>A;FH7A;C;5!AD!EA;4F4L8!@;7;48@67;!45<=;FF45H;5c!g27;! =:;!=67H;=<!:67>!=A!7;6?:!A7!=:;!45<=4=9=4A5<chV!,'A8$0."'<%(E#438:#7#'8J(=J!YWZ`YdXV! "AA5J!2VJ!)665J!2VJ!S!"A;7J!.V!OWXYXQV!G;7<?:4FF;5!45!;=54<?:;!6?:=;7H7A5>!K65!DA7;5<4<?:;!;5! 7;H9F4;7;! L;9H>`HHN`?F4k5=;5! g'4DD;7;5?;<! 45! ;=:54?! @6?8H7A95>! AD! IA95H! DA7;5<4?! 65>! 7;H9F67!?F4;5=<!45!=:;!E;5=6F!:;6F=:!?67;hV!H'/8(#/(;8*7#$0#/%J!M=J!Y[`W]V!!

+69?;J!2V!^VJ!'AE;5;?:`!-A>74H9;NJ!^VJ!3676>4<;J!^VJ!+A?:765J!"V!&VJ! .:;6J!_V!^VJ!.7;@548J! 'VJ! S! "6I>67J! &V! OWXXWQV! +9F=976F! 65>! ?A5=;b=96F! 45DF9;5?;<! 45! E;5=6F! :;6F=:! :;FC! <;;845HT!2!DA?9<!A5!;=:54?!E45A74=I!IA9=:V!E*4"/&7(*<(6*/$47%'/3(&/8(67'/'0&7(!$20.*7*32J! NGJ!ee`ZZV! ';!U766DJ!)VJ!^;4L;7J!.VJ!3A;FE65J!_VJ!S!G65B;<;5@;;?8J!*V!OWXXZQV!F#O$(*/8#"(A#(JP#Q(F#O$4#7#( 3#R*/8.#'8(+&/(A*/3#"#/(+&/(=J(%*%(JP(A&&"('/(I#8#"7&/8(KF#9(4/8#"(JPD( F#94&7(.#&7%.( *<(2*4/3(5#*57#('/(%.#(I#%.#"7&/8$('/(JGGPLD(';FD=T!#@97A5V! ';!)66<J!.V!OWXYWQV!.;8<9;;F!H7;5<AK;7<?:74L>;5>!H;>76H!A5>;7!LA5H;7;5!;5!KAFB6<<;5;5!45! &;>;7F65>V!,'A8$0."'<%+S**"(F#O$4*7*3'#J!MTJ!Yd[`YeZV! '4;C;5E66=J!2V!+V!^VJ!P6FJ!^V!,VJ!+94LC;7<J!3VJ!S!)476<45HJ!-V!2V!OWXX[QV!#=54<?:;!K;7<?:4FF;5!45! A5H;B;5<=;!;7K6745H;5!@4L!&;>;7F65><;!6>AF;<?;5=;5V!g#=:54?!>4DD;7;5?;<!45!95B65=;>! ;bC;74;5?;<! 6EA5H! '9=?:! 6>AF;<?;5=<hV! ,'A8$0."'<%( +**"( U#R*/8.#'8$C#%#/$0.&55#/J!

>M?!ZYV!

,A5=;<J! /V! 2VJ! S! 3F9EE;7J! +V! OWXYXQV! +9F=976F! 4<<9;<! 45! >4<?FA<97;<! AD! ?:4F>! <;b96F! 6@9<;V!

(22)

!WY! U4FF4H65J! 3VJ! S! 28:=67J! .V! OWXX[QV! +9F=976F! @6774;7<! =A! =:;! >4<?FA<97;! AD! ?:4F>! <;b96F! 6@9<;! 45! 2<465! ?AEE954=4;<T! /4<=;545H! =A! B:6=! BAE;5! <6IV! W"'%'$.( E*4"/&7( *<( F*0'&7( X*"OJ! MTJ! Yd[Y`YdaaV!

U7A;5J!_V!OWXYYJ!^67J!WYQV!^4<@7948!@4L!6FFA?:=AA5!5AH!6F=4L>!=6@A;!g2@9<;!6EA5H!4EE4H765=<! 7;E645<! 6! =6@AAhV! -;=74;K;>! D7AE! :==CTRRBBBVKAF8<8765=V5FR>A<<4;7`E4<@7948`AC` ?7;?:;<RE4<@7948`@4L`6FFA?:=AA5`5AH`6F=4L>`=6@A;l6Y][WaeZR!

)6E@IJ!.V!OWXX]QV!(:;!C6=:!AD!:;FC<;;845HT!3;7?;C=4A5<!AD!F6B!;5DA7?;E;5=!6EA5H!K4?=4E<! AD!<;b96F!6<<69F=V!E*4"/&7(*<(!"#+#/%'*/(&/8(Y/%#"+#/%'*/('/(%.#(6*114/'%2J!MTJ!]\`YXeV!

_;L;;@:AIJ!.V!_VJ!.:6:J!*VJ!S!(:6C6J!.V!OWXXZQV!F#9(C'%.*4%(0*/$#/%V!2*4/3(5#*57#('/(8#+#7*5'/3(

0*4/%"'#$D!/A5>A5T!m;>!"AA8<V!

MAA4<=76J! %V! OWXX[QV! E*/3#/$( .4'7#/( /'#%D( F#O$4##7( 3#C#78( %#3#/( &77*0.%*/#( A*/3#/$V! g"AI<! ĚŽŶ͛ƚ ĐƌǇ͘ ^ĞǆƵĂů ǀŝŽůĞŶĐĞ ĂŐĂŝŶƐƚ ďŽǇƐ ǁŝƚŚ Ă ŶŽŶ`P;<=;75! ;=:54?! E45A74=I! @6?8H7A95>hV!2E<=;7>6ET!2E<=;7>6E<!+;5=79E!"94=;5F65>;7<V!

MA<<J!^V!3VJ!2@@;IJ!2VJ!+6EC@;FFJ!-VJ!+AA8J!.VJ!&A774<J!_VJ!dĞƐƚĂ͕D͙͘!P:4=;J!_V!OWXXaQV!-;K4<45H! =:;! .#.T! 2! ?AFF6@A76=4K;! C7A?;<<! =A! 4EC7AK;! 6<<;<<E;5=! AD! <;b96F! 6HH7;<<4A5! 65>! K4?=4E4N6=4A5V!!$20.*7*32(*<(X*1#/(Z4&"%#"72J!M=J!dZa`daXV!

/6E;7<`P458;FE65J! ,VJ! .FA=J! &V! PVJ! "4LFJ! "VJ! S! G4LF@74;DJ! 2V! +V! OWXXaQV! F0.*7'#"#/( *+#"(

1'$.&/8#7'/3D( [#$47%&%#/( +&/( ##/( 7&/8#7'AO( */8#"R*#O( /&&"( 8#( *1+&/3( +&/( O'/8#"1'$.&/8#7'/3(*/8#"(7##"7'/3#/(+&/(.#%(+**"%3#R#%(*/8#"C'A$D(K;$O'/3(545'7$(&:*4%( &:4$#D( ,.#( "#$47%$( *<( &( /&%'*/&7( $%482( */( %.#( 5"#+&7#/0#( *<( 0.'78( &:4$#( 0*/840%#8( '/( $#0*/8&"2(#840&%'*/LD!'94K;5>7;?:=T!3*!-;<;67?:V!

/;;J! ^V! $VJ! S! /6BJ! 3V! ,V! ^V! OWXXYQV! 3;7?;C=4A5! AD! <;b96F! K4AF;5?;! 6H645<=! BAE;5! 45! 2<465! 2E;74?65!?AEE954=4;<V!E*4"/&7(*<(-%./'0(&/8(647%4"&7(\'+#"$'%2('/(F*0'&7(X*"OJ!=GJ!d`WZV!

^?^6:A5J! .V! OWXYYQV! +:65H45H! C;7?;C=4A5<! AD! <;b96F! K4AF;5?;! AK;7! =4E;V! )6774<@97HJ! 32T!

G2P5;=V! -;=74;K;>! D7AE!

:==CTRRBBBVK6B5;=VA7HR2<<A?n,4F;<nG2P5;=R2-n+:65H45H3;7?;C=4A5<VC>D!

(23)

! WW!

<;8<9;;F!E4<@7948!45!>;!845>;7=4L>T!_A5H;7;5!665!:;=!BAA7>V!g+AC45H<=76=;H4;<!65>!=:;! 5;;>! DA7! <9CCA7=! 6D=;7! ?:4F>! <;b96F! 6@9<;! O+.2QT! 3;7<C;?=4K;<! AD! IA95H! 6>9F=<hV!

,'A8$0."'<%(+**"(F#O$4&7'%#'%?(M>J!YXZ`YYXV!

3;7;>6J!&VJ!U94F;76J!UVJ!,A75<J!^VJ!S!UAE;N`";54=AJ!_V!OWXX\QV!(:;!45=;756=4A56F!;C4>;E4AFAHI! AD! ?:4F>! <;b96F! 6@9<;T! 2! ?A5=4596=4A5! AD! ,458;F:A7! OY\\eQV! 6.'78( ;:4$#( ]( I#37#0%J! MMJ! ddY`deWV!

-9<<;FFJ! 'V! OY\][QV! ,.#( $#0"#%( %"&41&Q( %"&41&Q( Y/0#$%( '/( %.#( 7'+#$( *<( 3'"7$( &/8( C*1#/V! &;B! $A78T!"6<4?!"AA8<V!

.;>F68J! 2V! _VJ! ^;==;5@97HJ! _VJ! "6<;56J! ^VJ! 3;==6J! *VJ! ^?3:;7<A5J! MVJ! S! U7;;5;J! 2V! OWXYXQV!

^*4"%.(I&%'*/&7(Y/0'8#/0#(F%482(*<(0.'78(&:4$#(&/8(/#37#0%(_IYF@`aQ([#5*"%(%*(0*/3"#$$V!

P6<:45H=A5T! '+T! 1V.V! ';C67=E;5=! AD! );6F=:! 65>! )9E65! .;7K4?;<J! 2>E454<=76=4A5! DA7! +:4F>7;5!65>!,6E4F4;<V!

(B;;>;!M6E;7!g'9=?:!)A9<;!AD!-;C7;<;5=6=4K;<hJ!WXX]J!W\!WWXJ!57V!YWV!

1V.V!';C67=E;5=!AD!);6F=:!65>!)9E65!.;7K4?;<J!&6=4A56F!+;5=;7!A5!+:4F>!2@9<;!65>!&;HF;?=V! OY\\aQV! 6.'78( 1&7%"#&%1#/%( =VVPQ( [#5*"%$( <"*1( %.#( F%&%#$( %*( %.#( I&%'*/&7( 6#/%#"( */(

6.'78(;:4$#(&/8(I#37#0%V!P6<:45H=A5J!'+T!1V.V!UAK;75E;5=!3745=45H!%DD4?;V!

PI6==J! UV! OY\]ZQV! (:;! <;b96F! 6@9<;! AD! 2D7A`2E;74?65! 65>! P:4=;`2E;74?65! BAE;5! 45! ?:4F>:AA>V!6.'78(;:4$#(](I#37#0%J!VJ!ZXa`ZY\V!

G65!*_N;5>AA75J!^V!)VJ!3745N4;J!3VJ!#9<;7J!#V!^VJ!U7A;5;K;F>J!^V!UVJ!"74FF;<F4LC;7`M6=;7J!.V!&VJ!S! &AA7=`G65! >;7! /45>;5J! 2V! ^V! (V͕ ͙ .65! ^67=45! ";98J!^V! OWXXaQV! H'/8#"1'$.&/8#7'/3( '/(

I#8#"7&/8( &//*( JGGP( K6.'78( )&7%"#&%1#/%( '/( %.#( I#%.#"7&/8$( '/( JGGPLV! /;4>;5J! (:;!

&;=:;7F65><T!+6<4E47!39@F4<:;7<V!

(24)

(25)

! We!

PRCAMP!A+

*5! EA<=! ;C4>;E4AFAH4?6F! C7;K6F;5?;! <=9>4;<! AD! ?:4F>! <;b96F! 6@9<;J! =:;! 7AF;! AD! ;=:54?4=I! 7;E645<! 95?F;67V! (:4<! <=9>I! ;b6E45;>! =:;! C7;K6F;5?;! 65>! 56=97;! AD! ?:4F>! <;b96F! 6@9<;! 45! DA97!5A5`P;<=;75!;=:54?!E45A74=I!H7A9C<!65>!?AEC67;>!=:;E!B4=:!6!56=4K;!'9=?:!H7A9CV!2! <6ECF;! AD! dJeW[! IA95H! 6>9F=<! O6H;>! Y]ʹWZQ! ?AECF;=;>! 6! <=79?=97;>J! A5F45;! <97K;I! A5! ;bC;74;5?;<!AD!?:4F>!<;b96F!6@9<;V!2!=A=6F!AD!eWV\j!O/!o!YJe[\Q!C67=4?4C65=<!7;CA7=;>!6=!F;6<=! A5;!DA7E!AD!?:4F>!<;b96F!6@9<;!K4?=4E4N6=4A5!@;DA7;!=:;!6H;!AD!Y]V!.97456E;<;!65>!(9784<:! ƌĞƐƉŽŶĚĞŶƚƐ͛ ƉƌĞǀĂůĞŶĐĞ ƌĂƚĞƐ ĚŝĚ ŶŽƚ ĚŝĨĨĞƌ ĨƌŽŵ ƚŚĞ ŶĂƚŝǀĞ ƵƚĐŚ ǇŽƵƚŚ͘ ,Žǁ;K;7J! =:;! '9=?:! 25=4FF;65! 7;<CA5>;5=<! 7;CA7=;>! <4H54D4?65=FI! :4H:;7! 76=;<! AD! ?:4F>! <;b96F! 6@9<;! A5! <C;?4D4?!DA7E<!AD!6@9<;J!B:;7;6<!=:;!^A7A??65!7;<CA5>;5=<!7;CA7=;>!FAB;7!76=;<!?AEC67;>! B4=:!=:;47!56=4K;!'9=?:!C;;7<V!P4=:!=:4<!<=9>IJ!B;!:6K;!EA7;!45<4H:=! 45=A!=:;!>4DD;7;5?;<Ͷ :AB;K;7!<E6FF!=:;I!E6I!@;Ͷ@;=B;;5!;=:54?!H7A9C<!65>!56=4K;!'9=?:!IA9=:!7;H67>45H!?:4F>!

(26)

!WZ!

L@AM?:N!AL?@+

+:4F>! <;b96F! 6@9<;! O+.2Q! A??97<! 6=! 6FF! 6H;<V! 2! H7AB45H! @A>I! AD! 7;<;67?:! A5! +.2! <:AB<! =:;! C;7K6<4K;5;<<! AD! =:4<! C:;5AE;5AŶ ;Ğ͘Ő͕͘ DŽŽƌĞ Ğƚ Ăů͕͘ ϮϬϭϬ͖ WŝŶĞĚĂ͕ >ƵĐĂƚĞƌŽ͕ dƌƵũŝůůŽ` ,ĞƌŶĄŶĚĞǌ͕ DŝůůĄŶ`'ƵƌĞƌƌĞƌŽ͕ Θ sĄƐƋƵĞǌ͕ ϮϬϬϵ͖ ^ƚŽůƚĞŶďŽƌŐŚ͕ sĂŶ /:ǌĞŶĚŽŽƌŶ͕ ƵƐĞƌ͕ Θ "68;7E65<`M765;5@97HJ!WXYYQV!2!7;K4;B!AD!=:;!45=;756=4A56F!;C4>;E4AFAHI!AD!+.2!@;=B;;5! Y\aX!65>!Y\\e!?A5>9?=;>!@I!,458;F:A7!OY\\eQ!7;K;6F;>!=:6=!6=!F;6<=!aj!=A!dZj!AD!BAE;5! 65>!dj!=A!W[j!AD!E;5!;bC;74;5?;>!<;b96F!6@9<;!45!?:4F>:AA>V!3;7;>6J!U94F;76J!,A75<J!65>! UAE;N`ĞŶŝƚŽ ;ϮϬϬϵͿ ĞǆƚĞŶĚĞĚ &ŝŶŬĞůŚŽƌ͛Ɛ ;ϭϵϵϰͿ ƌĞǀŝĞǁ ĂŶĚ ĞǆĂŵŝŶĞĚ ƚŚĞ ƉƌĞǀĂůĞŶĐĞ ŽĨ +.2! D7AE! Y\\e! =A! WXXa! A5B67>! 45! WY! >4DD;7;5=! ?A95=74;<! 6<! 7;CA7=;>! 45! ;C4>;E4AFAH4?6F! <=9>4;<!=:6=!B;7;!C9@F4<:;>!45!=:6=!=4E;D76E;V!(:;47!7;<9F=<!<:AB;>!=:6=!Y\Vaj!AD!BAE;5! 65>!aV\j!AD!E;5!:6>!6!:4<=A7I!AD!+.2!@;DA7;!=:;!6H;!AD!Y]!I;67<V!

15DA7=956=;FIJ! =:;! 7AF;! AD! ;=:54?4=I! 4<! 5A=! =68;5! 45=A! 6??A95=! 45! E65I! ;C4>;E4AFAH4?6F! <=9>4;<V!(:4<!4<!EA<=!F48;FI!>9;!=A!E;=:A>AFAH4?6F!F4E4=6=4A5<!<9?:!6<!<E6FF!<6ECF;!<4N;<!65>! F6?8! AD! 7;C7;<;5=6=4K;5;<<V! 2<! 6! 7;<9F=J! ;K;5! @6<4?! >6=6! A5! C7;K6F;5?;! AD! +.2! 45! >4DD;7;5=! ;=:54?! E45A74=4;<! 4<! E454E6FV! ^;65B:4F;J! =:;7;! 4<! 7;6<A5! =A! @;F4;K;! =:6=! +.2! 4<! EA7;! C7;K6F;5=!6EA5H!;=:54?!E45A74=I!H7A9C<!O.;>F68!;=!6FVJ!WXYXi!1V.V!';C67=E;5=!AD!);6F=:!65>! )9E65!.;7K4?;<J!&6=4A56F!+;5=;7!A5!+:4F>!2@9<;!65>!&;HF;?=J!Y\\aQV!

(27)

! W[! LA@<V!*5!?A95=74;<!<9?:!6<!=:;!&;=:;7F65><J!=:4<!F;>!=A!=:;!7;?794=E;5=!AD!H9;<=!BA78;7<!D7AE! <A9=:;75!#97AC;J!(978;IJ!65>!^A7A??AV!2=!=:;!<6E;!=4E;J!4EE4H76=4A5!AD!C;ACF;!D7AE!=:;! DA7E;7!?AFA54;<!O<9?:!6<!=:;!'9=?:!25=4FF;65!4<F65><!65>!.97456EQ!45?7;6<;>!>9;!=A!6>K;7<;! ;?A5AE4?!>;K;FACE;5=<! 45!=:;47!?A95=74;<!O_;554<<;5J!WXYdQV!+977;5=FIJ!=:;<;!H7A9C<!E68;! 9C!YYVaj!AD!=:;!'9=?:!CAC9F6=4A5!O+;5=76F!"97;69!AD!.=6=4<=4?<!g+".hJ!WXYeQV!

*5! =:;! &;=:;7F65><J! F4==F;! 4<! 85AB5! 6@A9=! =:;! C7;K6F;5?;! 65>! 56=97;! AD! +.2! 6EA5H! ;=:54?! E45A74=4;<V!%5FI!6!D;B!'9=?:!<=9>4;<!:6K;!?A5<4>;7;>!;=:54?!>4DD;7;5?;<!45!C7;K6F;5?;!76=;<! AD!+.2V!%5;!AD!=:;!EA<=!7;?;5=!<=9>4;<!=:6=!=A9?:;>!A5!=:4<!=AC4?!DA95>!=:6=!Â7A??65!@AI<! 7;CA7=;>! :4H:;7! 76=;<! AD! +.2! O/6:F6:J! G65! >;7! M566CJ! S! "AH6;7=<J! WXYdQV! (:4<! <=9>IJ! :AB;K;7J! DA?9<;>! A5FI! A5! Â7A??65! @AI<! 65>! 9<;>! 6! 5677AB! >;D454=4A5! AD! +.2V! Â7;! ?AEC7;:;5<4K;! <=9>4;<! =:6=! <C;?4D4?6FFI! 45K;<=4H6=;>! >4DD;7;5?;<! 45! =:;! C7;K6F;5?;! AD! +.2! 6EA5H! <;K;76F! ;=:54?! H7A9C<! :6K;! DA95>! E4b;>! 7;<9F=<V! ,A7! ;b6ECF;J! ';! U766DJ! ^;4L;7J! 3A;FE65J! 65>! G65B;<;5@;;?8! OWXXZQ! ?A5?F9>;>! =:6=! @AI<! B4=:! 6! 5A5`P;<=;75! ;=:54?! @6?8H7A95>! 7;CA7=;>! EA7;! DA7?;>! <;b96FFI! 6@9<4K;! 6?=<! =:65! 56=4K;! '9=?:! @AI<V! (:;! ACCA<4=;!7;<9F=<!B;7;!DA95>!DA7!H47F<!B4=:!6!(9784<:!65>!Â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aQ!6F<A!?6E;!=A!=:;!?A5?F9<4A5!=:6=!<;b96F!6@9<;!AD!?:4F>7;5! AD! 5A5`P;<=;75! A74H45! >A;<! 5A=! A??97! EA7;! AD=;5! =:65! <;b96F! 6@9<;! AD! 56=4K;! '9=?:! ?:4F>7;5V! )AB;K;7J! =:;! DAFFAB`ƵƉ ƐƚƵĚǇ ŽĨ sĂŶ /:ǌĞŶĚŽŽƌŶ ĂŶĚ ĐŽůůĞĂŐƵĞƐ͛ ƐƚƵĚǇ ;ϮϬϬϳͿ͕ ?A5>9?=;>!@I!2F458!65>!?AFF;6H9;<!OWXYWQ!6!D;B!I;67<!F6=;7J!>4>!7;CA7=!;=:54?!>4DD;7;5?;<!45! <;b96F!6@9<;V!

(28)

!Wa! =:;! 6<<9EC=4A5! =:6=! ;=:54?! >4DD;7;5?;<! ;b4<=J! @9=! @A=:! <=9>4;<! >;EA5<=76=;! >4DD;7;5?;<! 45! =:;47!E;=:A><!O<;FD`ƌĞƉŽƌƚƐǀĞƌƐƵƐŝŶĨŽƌŵĂŶƚƐƚƵĚǇ͕͞ůŝĨĞƚŝŵĞ͟ƉƌĞǀĂůĞŶĐĞǀĞƌƐƵƐŝŶĐŝĚĞŶĐĞŝŶ =:;! C6<=! I;67QV! (:;7;DA7;J! 4=! 4<! >4DD4?9F=! =A! >76B! ?A5?F9<4A5<! A5! CA<<4@F;! ;=:54?! >4DD;7;5?;<! D7AE!=:;!6K64F6@F;!F4=;76=97;V!

(A!D4FF!=:4<!H6C!45!=:;!F4=;76=97;J!=:;!?977;5=!<=9>I!:6<!;b6E45;>!=:;!C7;K6F;5?;!65>!56=97;!AD! +.2! 45! DA97! ;=:54?! E45A74=I! H7A9C<! 65>! 6! 56=4K;! '9=?:! H7A9CV! (:;! ;=:54?! E45A74=4;<! 45! =:4<! <=9>I! ?A5<4<=! AD! =:;! DAFFAB45H! DA97! H7A9C<T! IA95H! 6>9F=<! B4=:! ;4=:;7! 6! '9=?:! 25=4FF;65J! .97456E;<;J! Â7A??65J! A7! (9784<:! @6?8H7A95>V! (A! 6?f947;! 6! ?AECF;=;! AK;7K4;B! A5! =:;! C7;K6F;5?;! 76=;<J! 6! @7A6>! >;D454=4A5! AD! +.2! 4<! ?:A<;5! =:6=! ?A5?;75<! @A=:! :65><ÀDD! 65>! :65><À5! DA7E<! AD! 6@9<;! 65>! B:;7;! 5A! <C;?4D4?! 6H;! >4<=45?=4A5! @;=B;;5! C;7C;=76=A7! 65>! K4?=4E!4<!6<<9E;>V!2=!=:;!<6E;!=4E;J!B;!:6K;!FAA8;>!45!>;=64F!6=!=:;!56=97;!AD!=:;!6@9<;!@I! 6<845H!6@A9=!;6?:!DA7E!AD!6@9<;!45!?A5?7;=;!=;7E<V!,97=:;7EA7;J!?A5<4>;745H!=:;!4ECA7=65=! >4DD;7;5?;<! @;=B;;5! +.2! C7;K6F;5?;! 76=;<! 6EA5H! @AI<! 65>! H47F<! 45! C7;K4A9<! <=9>4;<! O,458;F:A7! ;=! 6FVJ!Y\\ei!3;7;>6! ;=!6FVJ! WXX\i! .=AF=;5@A7H:! ;=! 6FVJ! WXYYQJ!B;! 656FIN;>! H;5>;7! >4DD;7;5?;<!@;=B;;5!;=:54?!H7A9C<!45!A97!<6ECF;!6<!B;FFV!

SBAO?:C+

T&"1*.-&*+

(29)

! W]!

C:A5;!=:7A9H:!65A=:;7!<=76=4D4;>!<;F;?=;>!<6ECF;V!.?:AAF<!45!?4=4;<!B4=:!=:;!:4H:;<=!59E@;7! AD! ;=:54?! E45A74=4;<! O+;5=76F! "97;69! AD! .=6=4<=4?<J! WXYe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f9;<=4A55647;!A5! <=9>I! EA=4K6=4A5T! =:;! '9=?:`F65H96H;! !"#$%&%'#( )*%'+&%'#( ,#$%! O3^(Q! g3;7DA7E65?;! ^A=4K6=4A5!(;<=hV!(:4<!=;<=!B6<!C7;<;5=;>!45!=:;!<6E;!F6IA9=!6<!=:;!<97K;I!A5!<;b96F!6@9<;! 45! A7>;7! =A! H96765=;;! C74K6?I! DA7! 6FF! =:;! <=9>;5=<V! (:;! 7;<9F=<! AD! =:;! 6F=;756=4K;! f9;<=4A55647;! B;7;! >;F;=;>! D7AE! =:;! >6=6! <;=! 6D=;7! =:;! >6=6! ?AFF;?=4A5! B6<! D454<:;>V! (:4<! B6I!5A5;!AD!=:;!<=9>;5=<!:6>!=A!F;6K;!=:;!?F6<<7AAEV!

M*,$"0,*+&%'*+

(30)

!W\! AD=;5!9<;>!6<!65!9E@7;FF6!=;7E!=A!?AK;7!6!B4>;!<C;?=79E!AD!<;b96F!6@9<;!7;F6=;>!@;:6K4A7<V! *5! =:4<! 67=4?F;J! 6! @7A6>! >;D454=4A5! AD! +.2! B6<! ?:A<;5! =:6=! 7;F6=;>! =A! @A=:! :65><ÀDD! 65>! :65><À5! 6@9<;! 65>! B4=:A9=! 65I! 6H;! F4E4=! @;=B;;5! =:;! C;7C;=76=A7! 65>! =:;! K4?=4EV! 2=!=:;! <6E;!=4E;J!>;=64F<!AD!=:;!56=97;!AD!=:;!6@9<;!B;7;!85AB5!@I!45f94745H!6@A9=!;K;7I!DA7E!AD! 6@9<;! 45! ?A5?7;=;! =;7E<V! ,A7! =:4<! <=9>IJ! +.2! B6<! >;D45;>! 6<! 65I! <;b96F! ;bC;74;5?;! =:6=! :6CC;5<!45!7;6F!F4D;!OADDF45;QJ!45KAFK;<!:65><À5!65>RA7!:65><ÀDD!?A5=6?=J!65>!4<!?AEE4==;>! 6H645<=!=:;!B4FF!AD!6!E45A7!O95>;7!6H;!Y]Q!@I!6!C;;7!A7!6>9F=V!

2!<;FD`7;CA7=!f9;<=4A55647;!B6<!>;K;FAC;>!45!?AFF6@A76=4A5!B4=:!6!'9=?:!?;5=;7!AD!;bC;7=4<;! A5! <;b96F! 65>! 7;C7A>9?=4K;! :;6F=:! O-9=H;7<QV! (:;! f9;<=4A55647;! B6<! @6<;>! A5! =:;! .;b96F! #bC;74;5?;<! .97K;I! OMA<<! ;=! 6FVJ! WXXaQ! 65>! E;6<97;<! >;EAH76C:4?! ?:676?=;74<=4?<! AD! =:;! 7;<CA5>;5=<J! C7;K6F;5?;! AD! +.2J! 6==4=9>;<! =AB67>! <;b96F4=I! 65>! H;5>;7! 7AF;<J! 65>! :;FC` <;;845H!@;:6K4A7V!(:;!+.2!f9;<=4A5<!B;7;!C7;?;>;>!@I!H;5;76F!f9;<=4A5<!6@A9=!<;b96F4=I!=A! ;5<97;!7;<CA5>;5=<!B;7;!6??9<=AE;>!B4=:!=:;!=AC4?V!,A7!=:4<!67=4?F;!B;!9<;>!>;EAH76C:4?! >6=6!6<!B;FF!6<!>6=6!A5!C7;K6F;5?;!76=;<V!

(31)

! dX!

C%#$3*+

2! 7;=7A<C;?=4K;! <=9>I! B6<! ?6774;>! A9=! 6EA5H! <=9>;5=<! 6H;>! Y]! =:7A9H:! WZ! I;67<V! *5! =A=6FJ! dJ[\a!<=9>;5=<!;5H6H;>!45!=:;!<=9>IT!\aVYj!O/!o!dJZ\XQ!C67=4?4C6=;>!45!=:;!<97K;I!A5!<;b96F! 6@9<;J!65>!WV\j!O/!o!YXaQ!7;D9<;>!=A!C67=4?4C6=;!65>!?AECF;=;>!=:;!6F=;756=4K;!<97K;I!6@A9=! <=9>I!EA=4K6=4A5V!2D=;7!;b?F9>45H!=:;!?6<;<!AD!7;<CA5>;5=<!B:A!>4>!5A=!E;;=!=:;!?A5>4=4A5<! AD!=:;!=67H;=!H7A9C!O6H;>!@;=B;;5!Y]!65>!WZ!I;67<QJ!dJeW[!?6<;<!B;7;!45?F9>;>!45!=:;!>6=6! 656FI<4<! O<;;! (6@F;! YQV! (BA`=:47><! AD! =:;! <6ECF;J! [[VejJ! B6<! D;E6F;! O/! o! WJWXeQJ! 65>! A5;` =:47>J! dYV[jJ! E6F;! O/! o!YJX]dQV! ^A7;! =:65! =:7;;`f967=;7<! OaaVdjQ! AD!=:;! 7;<CA5>;5=<! B;7;! <=9>I45H!6=!6!KA?6=4A56F!<?:AAF!6=!=:;!=4E;!AD!=:;!>6=6!?AFF;?=4A5J!B:4F;!WWVej!B;7;!;57AFF;>! 6=!6!954K;7<4=I!AD!6CCF4;>!<?4;5?;V!(:;!E;65!6H;!AD!=:;!C67=4?4C65=<!B6<!WX!I;67<!O)!o!Y\V\\J!

F\!o!YV]]QV!(:;!E6LA74=I!AD!=:;!7;<CA5>;5=<!B:A!C67=4?4C6=;>!45!=:;!<=9>I!B;7;!@A75!45!=:;!

&;=:;7F65><!O]]jQV!

(32)

!dY!

APRUB+ D=!';EAH76C:4?! ?:676?=;74<=4?<! AD! =:;! 7;<CA5>;5=<! OI! o! dJeW[Q! 45! =:;! <6ECF;! 65>!6??A7>45H!=A!+".!

! I! j! +".!OjQ! ^;65! F\!

U;5>;7! ! ! ! ! !

^6F;<! YJX]d! dYV[! ! ! !

,;E6F;<! WJWXe! [[Ve! ! ! !

&A!65<B;7! Yd\! WVX! ! ! !

! ! ! ! ! !

#=:54?4=I! ! ! ! ! !

'9=?:! WJW[\! [[VW! aeVX! ! !

'9=?:!25=4FF;65! ZX! YVZ! YVZ! ! !

.97456E;<;! Ydd! dV\! WVe! ! !

^A7A??65! WXa! [VX! WV\! ! !

(9784<:! WeX! aVX! dVe! ! !

͚KƚŚĞƌ͛! dZa! YYVX! ! ! !

&A!65<B;7! YaX! eV\! ! ! !

! ! ! ! ! !

2H;!OE;65Q! ! ! ! Y\V\\! YV]]!

! ! ! ! ! !

#>9?6=4A5! ! ! ! ! !

GA?6=4A56F!<?:AAF! WJa\a! aaVd! ! ! !

154K;7<4=I!AD!6CCF4;>!<?4;5?;! aeX! WWVe! ! ! !

!

(33)

! dW! ;b?;C=!DA7!=:;!Â7A??65!<6ECF;J!B:;7;!Â7A??65!@AI<!B;7;!95>;77;C7;<;5=;>!OWYVdjQ!45! =:;!=A=6F!<6ECF;!65>!Â7A??65!H47F<!B;7;!AK;77;C7;<;5=;>!Oa]VajQJ!?AEC67;>!B4=:!=:;!=A=6F! <6ECF;V!.;;!(6@F;!W!DA7!D97=:;7!>;=64F<V! ! APRUB+E=!'4<=74@9=4A5!@I!H;5>;7!@;=B;;5!;=:54?!H7A9C<!OI!o!WJ]\\Q! #=:54?4=I+ U47F<! "AI<! ɍW! 5! G! /! j! /! j!

(A=6F! Y\e]! [aVW! \ZY! dWV]! WXV]Xppp! VXX! VX\!

'9=?:! YZXe! [[Vd! a[Z! ddVa! ! ! !

'9=?:!25=4FF;65! W[! ZWVX! We! e]VX! ! ! !

.97456E;<;! \a! aWV\! d[! WaVY! ! ! !

^A7A??65! Y[eppp! a]Va! eeppp! WYVd! ! ! !

(9784<:! YZ]! [ZV]! ]W! deVW! ! ! !

&A=;T!E4<<45H!K6F9;<!67;!5A=!45?F9>;>!45!=:;!656FI<4<V!p5!b(DXZJ!pp!5!b(DXYJ!ppp5(b(DXXYV!

C'%'(,'(1%3+%0%3/,*,+

-6=;<!AD!+.2!B;7;!?6F?9F6=;>!DA7!6FF!H7A9C<!B4=:!6!5A5`P;<=;75!;=:54?!@6?8H7A95>!65>!=:;! 56=4K;! '9=?:! H7A9CV! +:4`<f967;! 656FI<;<! B;7;! ?A5>9?=;>! =A! 656FIN;! >4DD;7;5?;<! @;=B;;5! ŐƌŽƵƉƐ͘ dŚĞ ĞĨĨĞĐƚ ƐŝǌĞƐ ǁĞƌĞ ĐĂůĐƵůĂƚĞĚ ǁŝƚŚ ƌĂŵĞƌ͛Ɛ s͕ ĚŝƐƚŝŶŐƵŝƐŚŝŶH! @;=B;;5! E67H456F! ĚŝĨĨĞƌĞŶĐĞƐ;ƌĂŵĞƌ͛Ɛsф͘ϭϬͿĂŶĚĚŝĨĨĞƌĞŶĐĞƐǁŝƚŚĂƐŵĂůůĞĨĨĞĐƚ;ƌĂŵĞƌ͛Ɛsх͘ϭϬͿ͘!

MBCNUAC+

T&*)%3*01*+"6+")*&%33+12(3.2"".+,*4-%3+%5-,*+

(34)

!dd! APRUB+F=!37;K6F;5?;!AD!+.2!6EA5H!;=:54?!H7A9C<J!6H;>!Y]ʹWZ!I;67<!O;bC;74;5?;>!6=!F;6<=!A5;!DA7E!AD!6@9<;Q! ! (%(2/! '9=?:! O/!o!WJW[\Q! '9=?:! 25=4FF;65!O/!o! ZXQ! .974`56E;<;! O/!o!YddQ! ^A7A?`?65! O/!o!WXaQ! (9784<:! O/!o!WeXQ!

!CP+V(0+$*&1*0'%<*,W+ eWV\! eaVW! e]VX! e]VY! dWV[pp!! eZVX!

+.2`)65><`ADD! WWVX! WdVd! W]VX! dXVX! YaV[! WYV[!

+.2`)65><`A5! d[VW! eXV]! d]VX! daVX! WdVWpp!! daVe!

C$*1(6(1+6"&#+"6+!CP+ !! !! !! !! !! !!

.AE;A5;!DA7?;>!IA9!=A!95>7;<<! [VZ! [V\! YXVW! [Vd! ZV]! [VW!

.AE;A5;!E6>;!C4?=97;<!A7!7;?A7>45H<!AD!IA9!B:4F;!95>7;<<45H!65>RA7! @;45H!568;>V!!

WVd! WVe! [VX! dVY! YV[! XVe!

.AE;A5;!DA7?;>!IA9!=A!B6=?:!CA75AH76C:4?!4E6H;<! WV]! WVa! [VX! dVY! YVX! YVa!

.AE;A5;!<:AB;>!IA9J!6H645<=!IA97!B4FFJ!:4<R:;7!H;54=6F<! Y[VW! YaVa! WWVX! WdVY! YWV[! YeVd!

.AE;A5;!E6<=97@6=;>!45!D7A5=!AD!IA9J!6H645<=!IA97!B4FF! ZVa! ZVe! ]VX! YXV\! ZVa! [V[!

.AE;A5;!DA7?;>!IA9!=A!E6<=97@6=;! dVZ! dVd! YXVXp!! eVa! YV[! eV]!

.AE;A5;!84<<;>!IA9!6H645<=!IA97!B4FF! WdVe! WZV[! dXVX! WWVd! Y[VY! WeVW!

.AE;A5;!=A9?:;>!IA9!<;b96FFI!6H645<=!IA97!B4FF! WYV\! WZVW! Y]VX! WeVW! YdVXpp!! Y\V[!

.AE;A5;!DA7?;>!IA9!=A!=A9?:!:4<R:;7!H;54=6F<! ]VW! ]Va! Y]VXp!! ]Va! ZVW! YYVY!

.AE;A5;!DA7?;>!IA9!=A!E6<=97@6=;!:4E! ZVX! ZVW! ]VX! dV\! eVY! [VY!

.AE;A5;!DA7?;>!IA9!=A!:6K;!A76F!<;b! eVe! eV[! YWVX! [Vd! dVY! dVZ!

.AE;!DA7?;>!IA9!=A!:6K;!<;b96F!45=;7?A97<;!OK6H456FR656FQ! ZVZ! [VY! YXVX! aVa! YVZpp!! dVX!

(35)

! de!

O%0.,8"66+)*&,-,+2%0.,8"0+*4$*&(*01*,+

3;7?;5=6H;<! AD! +.2! B;7;! ?6F?9F6=;>! 65>! <CF4=! 45=A! :65><ÀDD! 65>! :65><À5! +.2V! 2! =A=6F! AD! WWj! O/! o! aZdQ! ;bC;74;5?;>! :65><ÀDD! +.2V! (:;7;! B6<! 5A! <4H54D4?65=! 7;F6=4A5<:4C!@;=B;;5!;=:54?4=I!65>!:65><ÀDD!+.2!O5!o!VYYXQV!

-;H67>45H!:65><`A5!+.2!;bC;74;5?;<J!d[VWj!O/!o!YJWeYQ!AD!=:;!7;<CA5>;5=<!7;CA7=;>! =A! :6K;! ;bC;74;5?;>! =:4<! 6=! F;6<=! A5?;! @;DA7;! =:;! 6H;! AD! Y]! I;67<V! (:;! EA<=! D7;f9;5=FI! 7;CA7=;>! =IC;<! AD! :65><`ŽŶ ĂďƵƐĞ ǁĞƌĞ ͞ďĞŝŶŐ ŬŝƐƐĞĚ ĂŐĂŝŶƐƚ ǇŽƵƌ ǁŝůů͟ ;Ϯϯ͘ϰйͿ ĂŶĚ ͞ďĞŝŶŐ ƚŽƵĐŚĞĚ ƐĞǆƵĂůůǇ ĂŐĂŝŶƐƚ ǇŽƵƌ ǁŝůů͟ ;Ϯϭ͘ϵйͿ͘ dŚĞ ĂƐƐŽĐŝĂƚŝŽŶ @;=B;;5! :65><`A5! +.2! 65>! ;=:54?4=I! ǁĂƐ ƐŝŐŶŝĨŝĐĂŶƚ ;ʖWOeQ! o! WdVZWJ! 5! o! VXXXJ! ƌĂŵĞƌ͛Ɛsс͘ϬϵͿ͕ǁŝƚŚƚŚĞDŽƌŽĐĐĂŶŐƌŽƵƉƌĞƉŽƌƚŝŶŐƐŝŐŶŝĨŝĐĂŶƚůǇůŽǁĞƌƌĂƚĞƐƚŚĂŶ =:;!56=4K;!'9=?:!H7A9CV!

2CC7Ab4E6=;FI! YZj! OYZVdjQ! AD! 6FF! =:;! 7;<CA5>;5=<! 7;CA7=;>! =A! :6K;! ;bC;74;5?;>! @A=:! :65><`ADD! 65>! :65><`A5! ;bC;74;5?;<! AD! <;b96F! 6@9<;J! @9=! =:;7;! B;7;! 5A! <4H54D4?65=!>4DD;7;5?;<!@;=B;;5!=:;!H7A9C<!O5!o!VeXQ!O5A=!45!(6@F;!dQV!

B'20(1+.(66*&*01*,+(0+)%&("-,+6"&#,+"6+,*4-%3+%5-,*+

(36)

!dZ! с ͘ϬϭϮ͕ ƌĂŵĞƌ͛Ɛ s с ͘ϬϳͿ͕ ŝŶ B:4?:! =:;! Â7A??65! H7A9C! <?A7;>! <4H54D4?65=FI! FAB;7! =:65!=:;!56=4K;!'9=?:!H7A9CV! X*0.*&+.(66*&*01*,+(0+'2*+$&*)%3*01*+"6+!CP+ -;<9F=<!45>4?6=;>!=:6=!=:;!+.2!C7;K6F;5?;!76=;<!B;7;!:4H:;7!DA7!H47F<!OZdjJ!/!o!YJYW[Q! =:65!DA7!@AI<!OdWV\jJ!/!o!dedQV!U47F<!B;7;!A5;!65>!6!:6FD!=4E;<!EA7;!F48;FI!=A!@;?AE;! ǀŝĐƚŝŵƐŽĨ^ƚŚĂŶďŽǇƐ;ʖWOYQ!o!YYWV\\J!5!с͘ϬϬϬ͕ƌĂŵĞƌ͛Ɛsс͘ϭϴͿ͘dŚĞƌĞƐƵůƚƐŽĨ =:;!'9=?:J!'9=?:!25=4FF;65J!65>!.97456E;<;!@AI<!65>!H47F<!;EC:6<4N;>!=:4<!D45>45HV! Â7A??65!@AI<J!:AB;K;7J!7;CA7=;>!65!;f96FFI!:4H:!C7;K6F;5?;!AD!+.2!6<!Â7A??65! H47F<!OdWV\j!65>!dYVaj!7;<C;?=4K;FIQV!(9784<:!@AI<!OZXVXjQ!7;CA7=;>!;K;5!EA7;!+.2! =:65! (9784<:! H47F<! OeWVZjQV! )AB;K;7J! =:;<;! H;5>;7! >4DD;7;5?;<! 45! =:;! (9784<:! H7A9C! B;7;!5A=!<4H54D4?65=!O5!o!VW]WQV!-;H67>45H!H;5>;7!>4DD;7;5?;<!45!:65><ÀDD!65>!:65><` A5! DA7E<! AD! 6@9<;J! =:;! 7;<9F=<! B;7;! <4E4F67V! U47F<! B;7;! A5;! 65>! 6! :6FD! =4E;<! EA7;! F48;FI! =A! @;?AE;! K4?=4E<! AD! :65><`ŽĨĨ ĨŽƌŵƐ ŽĨ ĂďƵƐĞ ƚŚĂŶ ďŽǇƐ ;ʖWOYQ! o! dZVXYJ! 5! o! ͘ϬϬϬ͕ ƌĂŵĞƌ͛Ɛ s с ͘ϭϭͿ ĂŶĚ ĂůŵŽƐƚ ƚǁŝĐĞ Ă<! F48;FI! =A! @;?AE;! 6! K4?=4E! AD! :65><À5! ĨŽƌŵƐŽĨĂďƵƐĞĐŽŵƉĂƌĞĚǁŝƚŚďŽǇƐ;ʖWOYQ!o!YdXVdaJ!5!с͘ϬϬϬ͕ƌĂŵĞƌ͛Ɛsс͘ϮϬͿ͘ƵĞ =A! <E6FF! <6ECF;! <4N;<J! 4=! B6<! 5A=! CA<<4@F;! =A! E68;! D97=:;7! H;5>;7! >4<=45?=4A5<! @;=B;;5!:65><ÀDD!65>!:65><À5!DA7E<!AD!6@9<;!6EA5H!=:;!;=:54?!E45A74=I!H7A9C<V! #=:54?!>4DD;7;5?;<!6EA5H!H47F<!<:AB;>!=:;!DAFFAB45H!7;<9F=<T!Â7A??65!65>!(9784<:! ŐŝƌůƐƌĞƉŽƌƚĞĚƐŝŐŶŝĨŝĐĂŶƚůǇůŽǁĞƌƉƌĞǀĂůĞŶĐĞƌĂƚĞƐƚŚĂŶƚŚĞŶĂƚŝǀĞƵƚĐŚŐŝƌůƐ;ʖWOYQ!o! WaVaWJ! 5! с ͘ϬϬϬ͕ ƌĂŵĞƌ͛Ɛ s с ͘ϭϴ ĂŶĚ ʖWOYQ! o! \VeYJ! 5! o! VXϬϮ͕ ƌĂŵĞƌ͛Ɛ s с ͘Ϭϴ 7;<C;?=4K;FIQV! -;<9F=<! DA7! ;=:54?! >4DD;7;5?;<! 6EA5H! @AI<! <:AB;>! =:6=! =:;! (9784<:! @AI<! 7;CA7=;>! <4H54D4?65=FI! :4H:;7! C7;K6F;5?;! 76=;<! ?AEC67;>! =A! =:;! 56=4K;! '9=?:! ďŽǇƐ;ʖWOYQ!o!YYVZ[J!5!с͘ϬϬϭ͕ƌĂŵĞƌ͛Ɛsс͘ϭϮͿ͘!

:LC!NCCL?@+

(37)

! d[!

'95?65J! Y\]Zi! ,458;F:A7J! )A=6F45HJ! /;B4<J! S! .E4=:J! Y\\Xi! 3;7;N`,9;5=;<J! %FD<A5J! G4FF;H6<J! ^A7?4FFAJ! P65HJ! S! "F65?AJ! WXYdQV! (:;! :4H:;7! C7;K6F;5?;! 76=;<! =:6=! 67;! 7;CA7=;>! 45! =:4<! <=9>I! E6I! @;! 7;F6=;>! =A! 65I! A5;! AD! =:7;;! D6?=A7<V! ,47<=J! E9F=4CF;! >;=64F;>!f9;<=4A5<!B;7;!6<8;>!6@A9=!=:;!<C;?4D4?!DA7E<!AD!6@9<4K;!<;b96F!@;:6K4A7J! 65>! =:;! ;bCF4?4=! f9;<=4A5<! B4=:! ?A5?7;=;! >;<?74C=4A5<! E4H:=! :6K;! E6>;! 4=! ;6<4;7! =A! 7;?6FF!65!;K;5=V!.;?A5>J!=:;!@7A6>!>;D454=4A5!AD!+.2!9<;>J!45!?AEC674<A5!B4=:!A=:;7! <=9>4;<J! E6I! :6K;! F;>! =A! =:;! ;5>A7<;E;5=! AD! 6! F67H;7! 59E@;7! AD! <;b96FFI! 6@9<4K;! ;K;5=<!6<!;C4<A>;<!AD!+.2V!,456FFIJ!=:;!:4H:!59E@;7!AD!H47F<!45!=:;!<6ECF;!E6I!:6K;! 6F<A!?A5=74@9=;>!=A!=:;!:4H:;7!C7;K6F;5?;!76=;V!(:4<!4<!<9CCA7=;>!@I!7;<;67?:J!B:4?:! <9HH;<=<! =:6=! @;45H! 6! H47F! 4<! 6! 74<8! D6?=A7! DA7! +.2! O,;7H9<<A5J! /I5<8;IJ! S! )A7BAA>J! Y\\[i! ,458;F:A7J! Y\\dQV! .;;! =:;! F4E4=6=4A5<! AD! =:4<! <=9>I! DA7! 6! >4<?9<<4A5! 6@A9=! =:;! :4H:;7!76=;<!AD!C67=4?4C6=45H!H47F<V!

%97! 7;<9F=<! <:AB;>! 76=:;7! <E6FF! >4DD;7;5?;<! 45! C7;K6F;5?;! 76=;<! 6EA5H! ;=:54?! E45A74=4;<! 45! =:;! &;=:;7F65><V! &A! >4DD;7;5?;<! A5! AK;76FF! C7;K6F;5?;! 76=;<! AD! +.2! B;7;! DA95>! @;=B;;5! =:;! 56=4K;! '9=?:! 65>! =:;! '9=?:! 25=4FF;65J! .97456E;<;J! 65>! (9784<:! H7A9C<V! %5FI! =:;! Â7A??65! H7A9C! 7;CA7=;>! FAB;7! 76=;<! 45! AK;76FF! +.2! C7;K6F;5?;!6<!B;FF!6<!:65><À5!+.2V!(:4<!4<!45!?A5=76<=!B4=:!7;?;5=!7;<;67?:!AD!/6:F6:! 65>! ?AFF;6H9;<! OWXYdQ! B:A! DA95>! E9?:! :4H:;7! C7;K6F;5?;! 76=;<! AD! +.2! 6EA5H! Â7A??65! @AI<! ?AEC67;>! B4=:! 56=4K;! '9=?:! @AI<V! 2H645J! E;=:A>AFAH4?6F! ŝŵƉůŝĐĂƚŝŽŶƐ ŵĂǇ ĂĐĐŽƵŶƚ ĨŽƌ ƚŚĞƐĞ ĚŝĨĨĞƌĞŶĐĞƐ͘ /Ŷ >ĂŚůĂŚ ĂŶĚ ĐŽůůĞĂŐƵĞƐ͛ ;ϮϬϭϯͿ <=9>IJ!A5FI!=BA!4=;E<!B;7;!45?F9>;>!A5!<;b96F!6@9<;J!65>!=:;<;!4=;E<!>4>!5A=!6<8!4D! =:;!6@9<;!B6ƐĂŐĂŝŶƐƚƚŚĞƌĞƐƉŽŶĚĞŶƚƐ͛ǁŝůů͕ǁŚŝĐŚŵĂǇůĞĂĚƚŽĐŽŶĨƵƐŝŽŶŝŶǁŚĞƚŚĞƌ 4=! B6<! ?A5<4>;7;>! <;b96F! 6@9<;V! Â7;AK;7J! A97! <6ECF;! OIA95H! 6>9F=<Q! >4>! 5A=! ĐŽƌƌĞƐƉŽŶĚǁŝƚŚƚŚĞƐĂŵƉůĞŽĨ>ĂŚůĂŚĂŶĚĐŽůůĞĂŐƵĞƐ͛ƐƚƵĚǇ;ĂĚŽůĞƐĐĞŶƚďŽǇƐͿ͕ǁŚŝĐŚ E6I! :6K;! 7;<9F=;>! 45!>4DD;7;5=!C;7?;C=4A5<! 7;H67>45H! B:6=! 4<! ?A5<4>;7;>!6! <;b96FFI! 6@9<4K;!;K;5=V!

(38)

!da! DA95>! =A! @;! <4H54D4?65=J! =:;! D6?=! =:6=! =:;7;! B;7;! 5A! H;5>;7! >4DD;7;5?;<! 45! =:;<;! H7A9C<!B67765=<!D97=:;7!7;<;67?:V!-;H67>45H!H;5>;7!>4DD;7;5?;<!?AEC67;>!B4=:!=:;! 56=4K;!'9=?:!H7A9CJ!=:4<!<=9>I!<:AB;>!=:6=!^A7A??65!65>!(9784<:!H47F<!7;CA7=;>!F;<<! +.2J! B:4F;! (9784<:! @AI<! 7;CA7=;>! :4H:;7! C7;K6F;5?;! 76=;<! AD! +.2! =:65! =:;47! 56=4K;! '9=?:!C;;7<V!

U(#('%'("0,+"6+'2*+$&*,*0'+,'-./+

/4D;=4E;! C7;K6F;5?;! AD! +.2! B6<! <=9>4;>! K46! 7;=7A<C;?=4K;! 7;<;67?:V! *5! 65I! ƌĞƚƌŽƐƉĞĐƚŝǀĞ ĚĞƐŝŐŶ͕ ŵĞŵŽƌǇ ĞĨĨĞĐƚƐ ŵŝŐŚƚ ŚĂŵƉĞƌ ĂĚƵůƚ ƌĞƐƉŽŶĚĞŶƚƐ͛ ĂďŝůŝƚǇ ƚŽ 7;CA7=V! (:4<! 4<! ;K;5! EA7;! F48;FI! =A! A??97! B:;5! <=9>I45H! 6! <;5<4=4K;! =AC4?! <9?:! 6<! <;b96F! 6@9<;V! )AB;K;7J!4D!@46<;>! E;EA7I! ;DD;?=<! A??977;>J!=:4<! BA9F>! 6CCFI!DA7! 6FF! 7;<CA5>;5=<V!(:;7;DA7;J!5A!>4DD;7;5?;<!B;7;!;bC;?=;>!6EA5H!=:;!<9@H7A9C<!45!=:4<! 7;<;67?:! <45?;! =:;! 6@4F4=I ƚŽ ƌĞŵĞŵďĞƌ ǁŚĞŶ ƐŽŵĞƚŚŝŶŐ ŚĂƐ ŚĂƉƉĞŶĞĚ ;ƐŽƵƌĐĞ ŵĞŵŽƌǇͿŝƐƚƌĂŶƐĐƵůƚƵƌĂů;'ƵƚĐŚĞƐƐΘ/ŶĚĞĐŬ͕ϮϬϬϵͿ͘,ŽǁĞǀĞƌ͕ǁĞŶĞĞĚƚŽƚĂŬĞŝŶƚŽ ĂĐĐŽƵŶƚƚŚĂƚǇŽƵŶŐĂĚƵůƚŚŽŽĚŵŝŐŚƚŝŶĐƌĞĂƐĞƵŶĚĞƌƌĞƉŽƌƚŝŶŐĚƵĞƚŽŝŶƚĞŶƐĞƐŚĂŵĞ ƚŚĂƚ ŵĂǇ ůĞĂĚ ƚŽ ƐĞĐƌĞĐǇ ;^ĐŚƂŶďƵĐŚĞƌ͕ DĂŝĞƌJ! ^A:F;7`M9AJ! .?:5I>;7J! S! /65>AF=J! WXYWQV! ^;6<97;<! =A! ?A95=;7! 95>;77;CA7=45H! 7;f947;! ?67;D9F! 6==;5=4A5V! P;! =74;>! =A! 6?:4;K;!=:4<!@I!?67;D9FFI!<=79?=9745H!=:;!f9;<=4A5<!<A!=:6=!=:A<;!7;H67>45H!+.2!B;7;! C7;?;>;>!@I!H;5;76F!f9;<=4A5<!6@A9=!<;b96F4=I!45<=;6>!AD!6<845H!>47;?=FI!6@A9=!+.2! ;bC;74;5?;<V!2<!6!7;<9F=J!C67=4?4C65=<!?A9F>!H;=!9<;>!=A!=:;!<;5<4=4K;!=AC4?V!

(39)

! d]!

E4H:=!:6K;!6DD;?=;>!=:;!+.2!C7;K6F;5?;!76=;<!B;!DA95>!DA7!@AI<J!4=!>A;<!>4E454<:!=:;! H;5;76F4N6@4F4=I!AD!=:;<;!7;<9F=<V!

,97=:;7EA7;J!DA7!=:4<!67=4?F;J!+.2!45?F9>;>!6FF!DA7E<!AD!<;b96F!6@9<;V!(:4<!E6I!:6K;! ?A5D9<;>!=:;! 7;<CA5>;5=<J! 6<!=:;7;! 67;! E65I! H76>6=4A5<! B4=:45!=:4<! 845>! AD! 6@9<;J! 45?F9>45H! <;b96F! 6<<69F=J! <;b96F! :676<<E;5=J! 65>! <;b96F! K4AF;5?;V! /6<=J! >;<C4=;! =:;! D6?=!=:6=!<AE;!;=:54?!>4DD;7;5?;<!B;7;!DA95>!45!=:;!C7;K6F;5?;!76=;<!AD!+.2J!?69=4A5! 4<! 7;f947;>! 45! 45=;7C7;=45H! =:;<;! >4DD;7;5?;<J! @;?69<;! =:;! A@<;7K;>! ;DD;?=! <4N;<! 67;! 7;F6=4K;FI!<E6FFV!

(40)

!d\! EA7;! A5! =:A<;! ?9F=976F! 6<C;?=<! =:6=! >4DD;7;5=46=;! H7A9C<! 76=:;7! =:65! FAA845H! 6=! ;=:54?4=I!6<!6!D6?=A7!45!4=<;FDV!

(41)

! eX!

MBQBMB@!BC+

2F458J! /VJ! G65! *_N;5>AA75J! ^V! )VJ! "68;7E65<`M765;5@97HJ! ^V_VJ! 3655;@688;7J! ,VJ! GAH;F<J! (VJ! S! #9<;7J!#V!^V! OWXYWQV! H'/8#"1'$.&/8#7'/3( '/( I#8#"7&/8( &//*( JG=G(

K6.'78(&:4$#('/(%.#(I#%.#"7&/8$('/(JG=GLV!%;H<=H;;<=T!+6<4E47V!

"68;7J! 2V! PVJ! S! '95?65J! .V! 3V! OY\]ZQV! +:4F>! <;b96F! 6@9<;T! 2! <=9>I! AD! C7;K6F;5?;! 45! U7;6=!"74=645V!6.'78(;:4$#(](I#37#0%J!VJ!eZa`e[aV!

"688;7J!,VJ!U766DJ!)VJ!S!)66<J!.VJ!M;>>;J!)VJ!M794L;7J!)VJ!S!P4L<;5J!+V!OWXX\QV!F#O$4#7#(

3#R*/8.#'8('/(I#8#"7&/8(JGGV(KF#94&7(.#&7%.('/(%.#(I#%.#"7&/8$(JGGVLV!1=7;?:=J!

=:;!&;=:;7F65><T!-9=H;7<!&4<<A!U7A;CV!

+6CC;FF;74J! _VJ! #?8;57A>;J! _VJ! S! 3AB;7<J! _V! OY\\dQV! (:;! ;C4>;E4AFAHI! AD! ?:4F>! 6@9<;T! D45>45H<! D7AE! =:;! .;?A5>! &6=4A56F! *5?4>;5?;! 65>! 37;K6F;5?;! .=9>I! AD! ?:4F>! 6@9<;!65>!5;HF;?=V!;1#"'0&/(E*4"/&7(*<(!4:7'0(c#&7%.J!>MJ!Y[WW`Y[WeV!

+;5=76F! "97;69! AD! .=6=4<=4?<V! OWXYeQV! )AH;7! A5>;7B4L<i! 45H;<?:7;K;5;5J!

A5>;7B4L<<AA7=J! <=9>4;74?:=45HV! -;=74;K;>! D7AE! :==CTRR<=6=F45;V?@<V5FR.=6=P;@RC9@F4?6=4A5R>;D69F=V6<Cbc'^o./&/S32oaYXda& #'S'YoXS'WoFS'doXS'eoXS'ZoX`YjW?ZS'[oX!! ';!U766DJ!)VJ!^;4L;7J!.VJ!3A;FE65J!_VJ!S!G65B;<;5@;;?8J!*V!OWXXZQV!.;8<!A5>;7!L;!WZ;T! .;8<9;F;!H;NA5>:;4>!K65!LA5H;7;5!K65!YW!=A=!WZ!L667!45!&;>;7F65>!g.;b!95>;7! WZV!.;b96F!:;6F=:!AD!IA95H!C;ACF;!45!=:;!&;=:;7F65><!45!WXXZhV!';FD=T!#@97A5V! '4;C;5E66=J! 2V! +V! ^VJ! G65! >;7! P6FJ! ^V! ,VJ! +94LC;7<J! 3VJ! S! )476<45HJ! -V! 2V! OWXX[QV! #=54<?:;! K;7<?:4FF;5! 45! A5H;B;5<=;! ;7K6745H;5! @4L! &;>;7F65><;! 6>AF;<?;5=;5! g#=:54?! >4DD;7;5?;<! 45! 95B65=;>! ;bC;74;5?;<! 6EA5H! '9=?:! 6>AF;<?;5=<hV!

,'A8$0."'<%(S**"(U#R*/8.#'8$C#%#/$0.&55#/J!>M?!ZYV!

,;7H9<<A5J! 'V! ^VJ! /I5<8;IJ! ^V! (VJ! S! )A7BAA>J! /V! _V! OY\\[QV! +:4F>:AA>! <;b96F! 6@9<;! 65>! C<I?:46=74?! >4<A7>;7! 45! IA95H! 6>9F=:AA>T! 37;K6F;5?;! AD! <;b96F! 6@9<;! 65>! D6?=A7<!6<<A?46=;>!B4=:!<;b96F!6@9<;V!E*4"/&7(*<(%.#(;1#"'0&/(;0&8#12(*<(6.'78(

(42)

!eY! ,458;F:A7J! 'V! OY\\dQV! #C4>;E4AFAH4?6F! D6?=A7<! 45! =:;! ?F454?6F! 4>;5=4D4?6=4A5! AD! ?:4F>!

<;b96F!6@9<;V!6.'78(;:4$#(](I#37#0%J!=NJ![a`aXV!

,458;F:A7J! 'V! OY\\eQV! (:;! 45=;756=4A56F! ;C4>;E4AFAHI! AD! ?:4F>! <;b96F! 6@9<;V! 6.'78(

;:4$#(](I#37#0%J!=>J!eX\`eYaV!

,458;F:A7J! 'VJ! )A=6F45HJ! UVJ! /;B4<J! *VJ! S! .E4=:J! +V! OY\\XQV! .;b96F! 6@9<;! 45! 6! 56=4A56F! <97K;I! AD! 6>9F=! E;5! 65>! BAE;5T! 37;K6F;5?;J! ?:676?=;74<=4?<J! 65>! 74<8! D6?=A7<V!

6.'78(;:4$#(](I#37#0%J!=`J!Y\`W]V!

U9=?:;<<J! 2V! )VJ! S! *5>;?8J! 2V! OWXX\QV! +9F=976F! 45DF9;5?;<! A5! E;EA7IV! !"*3"#$$( '/(

W"&'/([#$#&"0.J!=N>J!Yda`YZXV!

);6=:J!2V!,VJ!-A=:A5J!+VJ!S!M4FC4J!#V!OWXX]QV!(:;!<;?A5>!H;5;76=4A5!45!P;<=;75!#97AC;T! ;>9?6=4A5J! 95;ECFAIE;5=J! 65>! A??9C6=4A56F! 6==645E;5=V! ;//4&7( [#+'#C( *<(

F*0'*7*32J!M`J!WYY`WdZV!

)9<=A5J! -V! /VJ! 36776J! _V! ^VJ! 374:A>6J! (V! _VJ! S! ,A9F><J! 'V! ^V! OY\\ZQV! +:676?=;74<=4?<! AD! ?:4F>:AA>!<;b96F!6@9<;!45!6!C7;>AE4565=FI!^;b4?65`2E;74?65!CAC9F6=4A5V!6.'78(

;:4$#(](I#37#0%J!=VJ!Y[Z`Ya[V!

_;554<<;5J! -V! 3V! PV! OWXYdQV! ';! 45<=7AAE! K65! @94=;5F65><;! 67@;4>;7<! ;5! >;! E4H76=4;H;<?:4;>;54<!K65!&;>;7F65>!56!Y\eZ!g(:;!45DF9b!AD!DA7;4H5!BA78;7<!65>! =:;! E4H76=4A5! :4<=A7I! AD! =:;! &;=:;7F65><! 6D=;7! Y\eZhV! E4$%'%'d7#( S#"O#//'/3#/J!

MV?!\`dYV!

MA<<J!^V!3VJ!2@@;IJ!2VJ!+6EC@;FFJ!-VJ!+AA8J!.VJ!&A774<J!_VJ!dĞƐƚĂ͕D͙͘!P:4=;J!_V!OWXXaQV! 2! ?AFF6@A76=4K;! C7A?;<<! =A! 4EC7AK;! 6<<;<<E;5=! AD! <;b96F! 6HH7;<<4A5! 65>! K4?=4E4N6=4A5V!!$20.*7*32(*<(X*1#/(Z4&"%#"72J!M=J!dZa`daXV!

/6:F6:J! #VJ! G65! >;7! M566CJ! /V! ^VJ! S! "AH6;7=<J! .V! OWXYdQV! '65H;7A9<! @AI<! A7! @AI<! 45! >65H;7V! #=:54?! >4DD;7;5?;<! 45! =:;! C7;K6F;5?;! AD! ?:4F>! 6@9<;! 65>! 4=<! ;DD;?=! A5! L9K;54F;!K4AF;5=!>;F45f9;5?IV!-4"*5#&/(E*4"/&7(*<(6"'1'/*7*32J!=GJ![eY`[Z]V!

(43)

! eW!

^AA7;J!#V!#VJ!-AE65498J!)VJ!%F<<A5J!+V!2VJ!_6I6<45H:;J!$VJ!+67F45J!_V!"VJ!S!36==A5J!UV!+V! OWXYXQV! (:;! C7;K6F;5?;! AD! ?:4F>:AA>! <;b96F! 6@9<;! 65>! 6>AF;<?;5=! 95B65=;>! <;b96F!?A5=6?=!6EA5H!@AI<!65>!H47F<!F4K45H!45!G4?=A746J!29<=76F46V! 6.'78(;:4$#(](

I#37#0%J!M`J!da\`d]ZV!

3;7;>6J! &VJ! U94F;76J! UVJ! ,A75<J! ^VJ! S! UAE;N`";54=AJ! _V! OWXX\QV! (:;! 45=;756=4A56F! ;C4>;E4AFAHI! AD! ?:4F>! <;b96F! 6@9<;T! 2! ?A5=4596=4A5! AD! ,458;F:A7! OY\\eQV! 6.'78(

;:4$#(](I#37#0%J!MMJ!ddY`deWV!!

3;7;N`,9;5=;<J!UVJ!%FD<A5J!^VJ!G4FF;H6<J!/VJ!^A7?4FFAJ!+VJ!P65HJ!.VJ!S!"F65?AJ!+V!OWXYdQV! 37;K6F;5?;! 65>! ?A77;F6=;<! AD! ?:4F>! <;b96F! 6@9<;T! 6! 56=4A56F! <=9>IV!

6*15"#.#/$'+#(!$20.'&%"2J!P`J!Y[`WaV!

345;>6`/9?6=;7AJ! 2VJ! (79L4FFA`);7565>;NJ! "VJ! ^4FFq5`U9;77;7AJ! -VJ! S! G6<f9;NJ! +V! OWXX\QV! 37;K6F;5?;! AD! ?:4F>:AA>! <;b96F! 6@9<;! 6EA5H! ^;b4?65! 6>AF;<?;5=<V!

6.'78Q(6&"#?(c#&7%.(&/8(\#+#7*51#/%J!MPJ!Y]e`Y]\V!

.?:r5@9?:;7J! GVJ! ^64;7J! (VJ!^A:F;7`M9AJ! ^VJ! .?:5I>;7J! 1VJ! S! /65>AF=J! ^V! 2V! OWXYWQV! '4<?FA<97;! AD! ?:4F>! <;b96F! 6@9<;! @I! 6>AF;<?;5=<T! 2! f96F4=6=4K;! 45`>;C=:! <=9>IV!

E*4"/&7(*<(Y/%#"5#"$*/&7(S'*7#/0#J!JNJ!de][`dZYdV!

.;>F68J! 2V! _VJ! ^;==;5@97HJ! _VJ! "6<;56J! ^VJ! 3;==6J! *VJ! ^?3:;7<A5J! MVJ! S! U7;;5;J! 2V! OWXYXQV! ^*4"%.( I&%'*/&7( Y/0'8#/0#( F%482( *<( 6.'78( ;:4$#( &/8( I#37#0%( _IYF@`aQ(

[#5*"%( %*( 6*/3"#$$V! P6<:45H=A5T! '+T! 1V.V! ';C67=E;5=! AD! );6F=:! 65>! )9E65!

.;7K4?;<J!2>E454<=76=4A5!DA7!+:4F>7;5!65>!,6E4F4;<V!

.4;H;FJ!_VJ!.A7;5<A5J!.VJ!UAF>45HJ!_VJ!"9756EJ!_VJ!S!.=;45J!_V!OY\]aQV!(:;!C7;K6F;5?;!AD! ?:4F>:AA>!<;b96F!6<<69F=V!;1#"'0&/(E*4"/&7(*<(-5'8#1'*7*32J!YW[J!YYeY`YYZdV!

.=AF=;5@A7H:J!^VJ!G65!*_N;5>AA75J!^V!)VJ!#9<;7J!#V!^VJ!S!"68;7E65<`M765;5@97HJ!^V! _V! OWXYYQV! 2! HFA@6F! C;7<C;?=4K;! A5! ?:4F>! <;b96F! 6@9<;T! ^;=6`656FI<4<! AD! C7;K6F;5?;!67A95>!=:;!BA7F>V!6.'78()&7%"#&%1#/%J!=TJ!a\`YXYV!

1V.V!';C67=E;5=!AD!);6F=:!65>!)9E65!.;7K4?;<J!&6=4A56F!+;5=;7!A5!+:4F>!2@9<;!65>! &;HF;?=V! OY\\aQV! 6.'78( )&7%"#&%1#/%( =VVPQ( [#5*"%$( <"*1( %.#( F%&%#$( %*( %.#(

(44)

!ed! 3745=45H!%DD4?;V!

1FFE65J!.V!#VJ!S!,4F4C6<J!)V!)V!OWXXZQV!#=:54?4=I!65>!?:4F>!<;b96F!6@9<;!;bC;74;5?;<!AD! D;E6F;!?AFF;H;!<=9>;5=<V!E*4"/&7(*<(6.'78(F#94&7(;:4$#J!=`J![a`]\V!

G65!*_N;5>AA75J!^V!)VJ!3745N4;J!3VJ!#9<;7J!#V!^VJ!U7A;5;K;F>J!^V!UVJ!"74FF;<F4LC;7`M6=;7J! .V! &VJ! S! &AA7=`G65! >;7! /45>;5J! 2V! ^V! (V͕ ͙ ^ĂŶ DĂƌƚŝŶ ĞƵŬ͕ D͘ OWXXaQV!

(45)

! ee!

(46)

!eZ!

+)23(#-!d!

!

'4DD;7;5?;<!45!?A5=;b=96F!D6?=A7<!45!?:4F>:AA>!

<;b96F!6@9<;!@;=B;;5!K4?=4E<!B4=:!6!56=4K;!'9=?:!

65>!5A5`P;<=;75!;=:54?!@6?8H7A95>!

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

!

! ! ! ! ! ! (:4<! ?:6C=;7! 4<! 95>;7! 7;K4;B! 6<T! %897J! 3VJ! G65! >;7! M566CJ! /V! ^VJ! S! "AH6;7=<J! .V! '4DD;7;5?;<! 45! ?A5=;b=96F! D6?=A7<! 45! ?:4F>:AA>! <;b96F! 6@9<;!@;=B;;5! K4?=4E<! B4=:! 6!

(47)

! e[!

PRCAMP!A+

(:;! F4=;76=97;! A5! >4DD;7;5?;<! 45! ?A5=;b=96F! D6?=A7<! 45! ?:4F>:AA>! <;b96F! 6@9<;! O+.2Q! 6EA5H!;=:54?!E45A74=4;<!45!=:;!&;=:;7F65><!4<!F4E4=;>V!(:;!C97CA<;!AD!=:4<!<=9>I!B6<! =A!>A?9E;5=!>4DD;7;5?;<!45!=:;!?A5=;b=!AD!+.2!;bC;74;5?;<!65>!6<<;<<!B:;=:;7!=:;<;! >4DD;7;5?;<! E6I! @;! ;bCF645;>! @I! D6E4FI! ;5K47A5E;5=6F! D6?=A7<V! &6=4K;! '9=?:! 65>! 5A5`P;<=;75!;=:54?!E45A74=I!IA9=:!B4=:!6!:4<=A7I!AD!+.2!O&!o!YJe\[Q!C67=4?4C6=;>!45!6! 7;=7A<C;?=4K;! <=9>I! A5! <;b96FFI! 6@9<4K;! ;bC;74;5?;<V! %5! 6! 954K6746=;! F;K;FJ! K4?=4E` C;7C;=76=A7! 7;F6=4A5<:4C! B6<! =:;! A5FI! ?A5=;b=96F! D6?=A7! =:6=! B6<! <4H54D4?65=FI! 6<<A?46=;>! B4=:! ;=:54?4=IV! *5! ?AEC674<A5! B4=:! 56=4K;! '9=?:! K4?=4E<J! EA7;! '9=?:! 25=4FF;65!K4?=4E<!7;CA7=;>!=:6=!=:;!6@9<;!B6<!C;7C;=76=;>!@I!6!O<=;CQD6E4FI!E;E@;7J! B:4F;!EA7;!(9784<:!K4?=4E<!7;CA7=;>!=:6=!=:;!C;7C;=76=A7!B6<!6!C67=5;7R;b`C67=5;7V! #=:54?! H7A9C<! >4DD;7;>! <4H54D4?65=FI! A5! <;K;76F! D6E4FI! ;5K47A5E;5=6F! D6?=A7<! O4V;VJ! :A9<;:AF>!?AECA<4=4A5J!;>9?6=4A5!65>!;ECFAIE;5=!C67;5=<QV!+AEC67;>!B4=:!56=4K;! '9=?:! K4?=4E<! AD! +.2J! EA7;! '9=?:! 25=4FF;65! 65>! .97456E;<;! K4?=4E<! 7;CA7=;>! =:6=! =:;I! B;7;! 764<;>! 45! A5;`C67;5=! :A9<;:AF><! 65>i! EA7;! ^A7A??65! 65>! (9784<:! 7;<CA5>;5=<!7;CA7=;>!=A!:6K;!C67;5=<!B4=:!6!FAB!;>9?6=4A56F!@6?8H7A95>V!2FF!;=:54?! E45A74=I! H7A9C<! 7;CA7=;>! 95;ECFAIE;5=! AD! =:;47! C67;5=<! EA7;! AD=;5! =:65! =:;47! 56=4K;! '9=?:! C;;7<V! )AB;K;7J! 5A5;! AD! =:;! D6E4FI! ;5K47A5E;5=6F! D6?=A7<! B;7;! 6<<A?46=;>! B4=:! =:;! K4?=4E`C;7C;=76=A7! 7;F6=4A5<:4CV! #=:54?4=I! ?A5=459;>! =A! @;! =:;! <4H54D4?65=! C7;>4?=A7! AD! =:;! K4?=4E`C;7C;=76=A7! 7;F6=4A5<:4Ci! =:;! A>><! AD! (9784<:! ƌĞƐƉŽŶĚĞŶƚƐ ƌĞƉŽƌƚŝŶŐ Ă ͚ĐůŽƐĞ͛ ƌĞůĂƚŝŽŶƐŚŝƉ ǁŝƚŚ ƚŚĞ ƉĞƌƉĞƚƌĂƚŽƌ ;4V;VJ! D6E4FI! A7! C67=5;7Q!45<=;6>!AD!6!<=765H;7RA=:;7!B;7;!=B4?;!6<!:4H:!?AEC67;>!B4=:!56=4K;!'9=?:! K4?=4E<V!!

(48)

!ea!

L@AM?:N!AL?@+

2F=:A9H:!=:;7;!4<!65!45?7;6<45H!59E@;7!AD! <=9>4;<!DA?9<45H!A5!;=:54?!>4DD;7;5?;<!45! C7;K6F;5?;!76=;<!AD!?:4F>!<;b96F!6@9<;!O+.2Q!O%897J!G65!>;7!M566CJ!S!"AH6;7=<J!WXYZi! .;>F68!;=!6FVJ!WXYXQJ!45!E65I!;C4>;E4AFAH4?6F!<=9>4;<J!;=:54?4=I!4<!;b?F9>;>!D7AE!=:;! 656FI<;<!>9;!=A!E;=:A>AFAH4?6F!F4E4=6=4A5<J!<9?:!6<!<E6FF!<6ECF;!<4N;<V!)AB;K;7J!6! <E6FF!@A>I!AD!7;<;67?:!<9HH;<=<!=:6=!=:;!?A5=;b=96F!D6?=A7<!B4=:!7;H67>!=A!+.2!K67I! 6EA5H!;=:54?!E45A74=4;<!OM6=;75>6:FJ!"97H;J!M;FFAHHJ!S!36776J!WXXZi!.65>;7<`3:4F4C<! .65>;7<`3:4F4C<J! ^A4<65J! P6>F45H=A5J! ^A7H65J! S! #5HF4<:J! Y\\Zi! .:6BJ! /;B4<J! /A;@J! -A<6>AJ!S!-A>74H9;NJ!WXXYQV!.65>;7<`3:4F4C<!;=!6FV!OY\\ZQ!>;EA5<=76=;>!=:6=!<;b96FFI! 6@9<;>!)4<C654?!H47F<!B;7;!45!?AEC674<A5!=A!@F6?8!H47F<!EA7;!F48;FI!=A!@;!6@9<;>!6=!6! IA95H;7! 6H;! 65>! EA7;! AD=;5! 6@9<;>! @I! =:;! @4AFAH4?6F! ĨĂƚŚĞƌ͘ ^ŚĂǁ Ğƚ Ăů͛͘Ɛ ƐƚƵĚǇ OWXXYQ! ?AEC67;>! 2D74?65`2E;74?65! 65>! )4<C654?! H47F<! B:A! B;7;! <;b96FFI!K4?=4E4N;>! 65>!DA95>!=:6=!)4<C654?!H47F<!7;CA7=;>!6!H7;6=;7!59E@;7!AD!<;b96F!6@9<;!;bC;74;5?;<! 65>! =:6=! =:;47! 6@9<;7<! B;7;! AF>;7! =:65! =:;! 6@9<;7<! AD! =:;! 2D74?65`2E;74?65! H47F<V! M6=;75>6:F! ;=! 6FV! OWXXZQ! DA95>! =:6=! )4<C654?! K4?=4E<! B;7;! EA7;! F48;FI! =A! 7;CA7=! 6! D6E4FI!E;E@;7!6<!=:;!C;7C;=76=A7!65>!=A!;bC;74;5?;!EA7;!<;FD`@F6E;!6<!6!7;<9F=!AD! =:;!6@9<;V!

M6=;75>6:F! ;=! 6FV! OWXXZQ! 6F<A! 7;CA7=;>! =:6=! ;=:54?! >4DD;7;5?;<! 45! ?A5=;b=96F! D6?=A7<! ?A9F>!@;!C7;>4?=;>!@I!<A?4A`>;EAH76C:4?!K6746@F;<!A7!D6E4FI!;5K47A5E;5=6F!D6?=A7<V! M6=;75>6:F!;=!6FV!OWXXZQ!<=6=;>T!! ! ͚>ŽǁƐŽĐŝŽĞĐŽŶŽŵŝĐƐƚĂƚƵƐŵĂǇĞǆƉůĂŝŶĚŝĨĨĞƌĞŶĐĞƐŝŶŚŽƵƐĞŚŽůĚƐŝǌĞĂŶĚƚŚĞ ƉĞƌƉĞƚƌĂƚŽƌůŝǀŝŶŐŝŶƚŚĞǀŝĐƚŝŵ͛Ɛ!:AE;J!@;?69<;!<:67;>!F4K45H!<C6?;!E6I!@;!6! ƌĞĨůĞĐƚŝŽŶŽĨƚŚĂƚůŽǁƐŽĐŝŽĞĐŽŶŽŵŝĐƐƚĂƚƵƐ͛͘OCV!\YQV!! ! .65>;7<`3:4F4C<!;=!6FV!OY\\ZQ!6F<A!7;CA7=;>!;=:54?!>4DD;7;5?;<!45!D6E4FI!;5K47A5E;5=6F! D6?=A7<J! 56E;FI! FAB;7! E6=;756F! <9CCA7=! 6EA5H! )4<C654?! H47F<! 45! ?AEC674<A5! B4=:! @F6?8!H47F<J!@9=!=:4<!D6?=A7!B6<!5A=!<=9>4;>!45!7;F6=4A5!=A!=:;!>4DD;7;5?;<!45!?A5=;b=96F! D6?=A7<!AD!=:;!6@9<;V!

(49)

! e]!

;=:54?! E45A74=I! H7A9C<! O';7;NA=;<! S! .5AB>;5J! Y\\Xi! (N;5H! S! .?:B67N45J! Y\\XQV! (:;7;DA7;J!=:4<!<=9>I!45K;<=4H6=;>!B:;=:;7!>4DD;7;5?;<!;b4<=!45!?A5=;b=96F!D6?=A7<!AD! +.2! @;=B;;5! ;=:54?! E45A74=I! H7A9C<! 65>! 56=4K;! '9=?:! K4?=4E<! AD! +.2! 65>! 4D! <AJ! 4D! =:;<;! >4DD;7;5?;<! ?65! @;! ;bCF645;>! @I! D6E4FI! ;5K47A5E;5=6F! D6?=A7<! <9?:! 6<! :A9<;:AF>!?AECA<4=4A5!65>!<A?4A`;?A5AE4?!<=6=9<!O.#.QV!

SBAO?:+

C%#$3*+

Â7;! =:65! dJ[XX! C67=4?4C65=<! B4=:! 6! 5A5`P;<=;75! ;=:54?! 65>! 56=4K;! '9=?:! @6?8H7A95>! OI! o! dJ[\[QJ! 6H;>! Y]`WZJ! ?AECF;=;>! 6! B;@`@6<;>! <97K;I! 6@A9=! 95B65=;>! <;b96F! ;bC;74;5?;<V! Â7;! =:65! eXj! AD! =:;! C67=4?4C65=<! OI! o! YJe\[Q! 7;CA7=;>! =A! :6K;! ;bC;74;5?;>! 6=! F;6<=! A5;! DA7E! AD! +.2V! Â7;! >;=64F<! A5! =:;! C7;K6F;5?;! 76=;<! ?65! @;! DA95>! 45! %897J! G65! >;7! M566CJ! 65>! "AH6;7=<! OWXYZQV! (:;! ?977;5=! <=9>I! 9<;>! >6=6! D7AE! =:;! <9@<6ECF;! AD! C67=4?4C65=<! B4=:! 6! :4<=A7I! AD! +.2V! 2EA5H!=:;EJ!aYVYj!O/!o!YJXeeQ!:6>!6!'9=?:J!YV[j!O/!o!WeQ!6!'9=?:!25=4FF;65J!eVWj!O/! o! [WQ! 6! .97456E;<;J! eVWj! O/! o! [WQ! 6! Â7A??65J! 65>! aVXj! O/! o! YXdQ! 6! (9784<:! @6?8H7A95>V!,7AE!YYV]j!O/!o!YaeQ!AD!=:;!C67=4?4C65=<!45DA7E6=4A5!6@A9=!=:;47!;=:54?! @6?8H7A95>!B6<!E4<<45H!65>!=:;I!B;7;!<9@<;f9;5=FI!>;F;=;>!D7AE!=:;!656FI<;<V!(:;! >4<=74@9=4A5! @I! H;5>;7! B6<! a[Vaj! H47F<! 65>! WdVdj! @AI<V! 2! <4E4F67! >4<=74@9=4A5! @I! H;5>;7!A??977;>!45!=:;!<;C676=;!;=:54?!H7A9C<J!;b?;C=!DA7!=:;!(9784<:!<6ECF;J!B:;7;! (9784<:! @AI<! B;7;! AK;77;C7;<;5=;>! Od[V\jQ! 45! =:;! <6ECF;! 65>! (9784<:! H47F<! B;7;! 95>;77;C7;<;5=;>! O[dVYjQJ! ?AEC67;>! B4=:! =:;! =A=6F! <6ECF;! AD! 7;<CA5>;5=<! B4=:! 6! :4<=A7I!AD!^;ʖW!OeQ!o!YZVZaJ!5!с͘ϬϬ͕ƌĂŵĞƌ͛Ɛsс͘ϭϭͿ͘!

S*%,-&*,+

(50)

!e\! ƚŚĂƚ ĐŽǀĞƌ Ăůů ĂƐƉĞĐƚƐ ŽĨ ^͘ ^ ŝƐ ĚĞĨŝŶĞĚ ĂƐ ͚;/2( $#94&7( #95#"'#/0#( *<( &( 0.'78?(

'/+*7+'/3( :*8'72( *"( /*/@:*8'72( 0*/%&0%( '/( "#&7( 7'<#?( '<( %.&%( #95#"'#/0#( '$( $4:A#0%'+#72( B4&7'<'#8(&$('/+*74/%&"2(:2(%.#(0.'78?("#3&"87#$$(*<(%.#(&3#(8'<<#"#/0#(:#%C##/($4:A#0%( &/8(5#"5#%"&%*"D͛!

(:;! f9;<=4A55647;! ?A5<4<=;>! AD! Yd! 4=;E<! 45?F9>45H! 6FF! DA7E<! AD! 6@9<;! O:65><`ADDJ! :65><`A5!B4=:!65>!B4=:A9=!C;5;=76=4A5QJ!65>!=:;!7;<CA5<;<!B;7;!H4K;5!A5!6!d`CA45=! <?6F;T!5;K;7J!A5?;J!65>!EA7;!=:65!A5?;V!*D!=:;!65<B;7!A5?;!A7!EA7;!=:65!A5?;!B6<! H4K;5! A5! 65I! AD! =:;! Yd! 4=;E<J! =:4<! B6<! <?A7;>! 6<! +.2V! ,AFFAB`9C! f9;<=4A5<! B;7;! 6<8;>!=A!H6=:;7!45DA7E6=4A5!6@A9=!=:;!6@9<;!?:676?=;74<=4?<J!56E;FI!=:;!7;F6=4A5<:4C! ǁŝƚŚ ƚŚĞƉĞƌƉĞƚƌĂƚŽƌ ;ĨƌŽŵ ͚ĐůŽƐĞ͛ƚŽ ŵŽƌĞ ͚ĚŝƐƚĂŶƚ͛ƌĞůĂƚŝŽŶƐŚŝƉ͗ ĨĂŵŝůǇͬƐƚĞƉĨĂŵŝůǇ͖ C67=5;7R;b`C67=5;7J! D74;5>RC;;7i! <=765H;7RA=:;7QJ! =:;! 6H;! AD! =:;! 7;<CA5>;5=! B:;5! =:;!;bC;74;5?;!:6CC;5;>!O@;DA7;!YW!I;67<J!@;=B;;5!YW!65>!Y]!I;67<J!A7!@A=:QJ!=:;! D7;f9;5?I! AD! =:;! 6@9<;! OA5?;i! W`YX! =4E;<i! EA7;! =:65! YX! =4E;<QJ! 65>! D;;F45H<! AD! @F6E;!OOEA<=FIQ!=:;!C;7C;=76=A7i!@A=:i!OEA<=FIQ!E;QV!!

,6E4FI! ;5K47A5E;5=! ?:676?=;74<=4?<! B;7;! E;6<97;>! B4=:! =:;! DAFFAB45H! =:7;;! K6746@F;<T! :A9<;:AF>! ?AECA<4=4A5! OA5;`C67;5=! K;7<9<! =BA`C67;5=! :A9<;:AF><Qi! ;>9?6=4A5!F;K;F!AD!C67;5=<!OFABJ!E4>>F;J!:4H:!;>9?6=4A5J!45!B:4?:!=:;!:4H:;<=!>;H7;;! D7AE!@A=:!C67;5=<!:6<!@;;5!<;F;?=;>!6<!=:;!;>9?6=4A5!F;K;FQi!65>!;ECFAIE;5=!<=6=9<! AD! C67;5=<! O@A=:! 95;ECFAI;>i! D6=:;7! 95;ECFAI;>REA=:;7! BA7845Hi! EA=:;7! 95;ECFAI;>RD6=:;7!BA7845Hi!65>!@A=:!;ECFAI;>QV!!

P0%3/,(,+

2<! 6! D47<=! <=;CJ! @4K6746=;! 656FI<;<! O4V;VJ! ?:4`<f967;! 65>! =`=;<=Q! B;7;! C;7DA7E;>! =A! >;=;7E45;! B:;=:;7! ;=:54?! >4DD;7;5?;<! ;b4<=;>! 45! 6@9<;! ?:676?=;74<=4?<! 65>! D6E4FI! ;5K47A5E;5=! ?:676?=;74<=4?<V! .;?A5>J! =A! 6<<;<<! B:;=:;7! >4DD;7;5?;<! 45! ?:4F>:AA>! <;b96F! 6@9<;! ;bC;74;5?;<! B;7;! 7;F6=;>! =A! >4DD;7;5?;<! 45! D6E4FI! ;5K47A5E;5=J! <=;CB4<;!FAH4<=4?!65>!A7>456F!7;H7;<<4A5<!B;7;!C;7DA7E;>!DA7!;6?:!6@9<;!;bC;74;5?;! K6746@F;! =:6=! <:AB;>! <4H54D4?65=! ;=:54?! >4DD;7;5?;<! A5! =:;! @4K6746=;! 656FI<4<J! 9<45H! D6E4FI!;5K47A5E;5=!D6?=A7<!65>!;=:54?4=I!6<!45>;C;5>;5=!K6746@F;<V!!

(51)

! ZX!

(52)

!ZY! A%53*+D=!'4DD;7;5?;<!45!6@9<;!?:676?=;74<=4?<!6EA5H!K4?=4E<!AD!+.2!B4=:!6!56=4K;!'9=?:!65>!5A5`P;<=;75!;=:54?!@6?8H7A95>! OI!o!YJe\[Q! ! &6=4K;!'9=?:! '9=?:! 25=4FF;65! .97456E;<;! ^A7A??65! (9784<:! ! ! ! ! /! j! /! j! /! j! /! j! /! j! ʖW! 5! G! -;F6=4A5<:4C!B4=:!C;7C;=76=A7! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! deV\Xppp! VXX! VWX! ,6E4FIR.=;CD6E4FI! d]! ZVX! e! W]V[! d! YWVX! W! ]Vd! Y! WVX! ! ! !

367=5;7R;b`C67=5;7! YZW! WXVY! d! WYVe! Z! WXVX! ]! ddVd! Y\! d]V]! ! ! !

%=:;7!C;;7<! YXW! YdVZ! Y! aVY! e! Y[VX! [! WZVX! a! YeVd! ! ! !

!.=765H;7RA=:;7<! e[Z! [YVe! [! eWV\! Yd! ZWVX! ]! ddVd! WW! eeV\! ! ! !

2H;!AD!A5<;=! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! eV[[! Vdd! VX[!

";DA7;!YW!I;67<! ZX! ZVX! d! YeVd! W! dV[! e! aVd! [! [Va! ! ! !

2D=;7!YW!I;67<! \e\! \ZVX! Y]! ]ZVa! Ze! \[Ve! ZY! \WVa! ]d! \dVd! ! ! !

,7;f9;5?I!AD!6@9<;! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! YWVee! VYd! VYd!

%5?;! eee! [[Vd! a! ZdV]! Y[! ZaVY! WX! aeVY! W]! [dV[! ! ! !

W`YX!=4E;<! Y\W! W]Va! d! WdVY! \! dWVY! a! WZV\! YW! WaVd! ! ! !

^A7;!=:65!YX!=4E;<! de! !ZVY! d! WdVY! d! YXVa! X! XVX! !e! \VY! ! ! !

,;;F45H<!AD!@F6E;! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! YdVd\! VYX! VYW!

O^645FIQ!C;7C;=76=A7! [YY! ]YVY! YW! aZVX! WZ! ][VW! WY! aZVX! dZ! aWV\! ! ! !

"A=:! \[! YWVa! Y! [VW! W! [V\! W! aVY! a! YeV[! ! ! !

O^645FIQ!E;! e[! [VY! d! Y]V]! W! [V\! Z! YaV\! [! YWVZ! ! ! !

(53)

! ZW!

(6@F;! W! C7;<;5=<! =:;! >4DD;7;5?;<! 45! D6E4FI! ;5K47A5E;5=6F! D6?=A7<! @;=B;;5! 56=4K;! '9=?:!65>!5A5`P;<=;75!;=:54?!H7A9C<V!^A7;!'9=?:!25=4FF;65!65>!.97456E;<;!K4?=4E<! AD!+.2!=:65!56=4K;!'9=?:!+.2!K4?=4E<!7;CA7=;>!=:6=!=:;I!B;7;!764<;>!45!A5;`C67;5=! ŚŽƵƐĞŚŽůĚƐ;ʖW!OeQ!o!YX\VW\J!5!с͘ϬϬ͕ƌĂŵĞƌ͛Ɛsс͘ϮϵͿ͘tŝƚŚƌĞŐĂƌĚƚŽƚŚĞĞĚƵĐĂƚŝŽŶ F;K;F!AD!C67;5=<J!EA7;!^A7A??65!65>!(9784<:!K4?=4E<!AD!+.2! =:65!56=4K;!'9=?:! +.2! K4?=4E<!7;CA7=;>!=A!:6K;!C67;5=<!B4=:!6!FAB!;>9?6=4A56F!@6?8H7AƵŶĚ;ʖW!OeQ!o!YedVXXJ! 5! с͘ϬϬ͕ ƌĂŵĞƌ͛Ɛ s с ͘ϯϲͿ͘ /Ŷ ĂĚĚŝƚŝŽŶ͕ F;<<! (9784<:! 7;<CA5>;5=<! =:65! 56=4K;! '9=?:!

(54)

!Zd! A%53*+E=!,6E4FI!;5K47A5E;5=6F!?:676?=;74<=4?<!AD!=:;!C67=4?4C65=<!OI!o!YJe\[Q! ! &6=4K;!'9=?:! '9=?:! 25=4FF;65! .97456E;<;! ^A7A??65! (9784<:! ! ! ! ! /! j! /! j! /! j! /! j! /! j! ʖW!! 5! G! )A9<;:AF>!F;K;F! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! YX\VW\ppp! VXX! VW\!

(BA`C67;5=!:A9<;:AF>! ][e! ]dVa! YX! eaV[! Y\! dWVW! eY! aXVa! ]W! a\V[! ! ! !

%5;`C67;5=!:A9<;:AF>! Y[]! Y[Vd! YY! ZWVe! eX! [aV]! Ya! W\Vd! WY! WXVe! ! ! !

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

#>9?6=4A5!C67;5=<! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! YedVXXppp! VXX! Vd[!

/AB! Ya! YV]! X! XVX! W! eV]! [! YeV[! We! WaVZ! ! ! !

^A>;76=;! e\d! ZdV[! \! ZWV\! WZ! Z\VZ! WY! ZYVW! e[! ZWV\! ! ! !

)4H:! eYX! eeV[! ]! eaVY! YZ! dZVa! Ye! deVY! Ya! Y\VZ! ! ! !

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

#ECFAIE;5=!367;5=<! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! YY]VYZppp! VXX! VdY!

"A=:!C67;5=<!95;ECFAI;>! dY! dVY! e! Y]VW! [! YYV]! YY! WXVX! YW! YWV]! ! ! !

,6=:;7!95;ECFAI;>! e\! eV\! e! Y]VW! ]! YZVa! d! ZVZ! Z! ZVd! ! ! !

^A=:;7!95;ECFAI;>! Wde! WdVe! W! \VY! ]! YZVa! WZ! eZVZ! eX! eWV[! ! ! !

"A=:!C67;5=<!;ECFAI;>! [][! []V[! YW! ZeVZ! W\! Z[V\! Y[! W\VY! da! d\Ve! ! ! !