Multimodality imaging of coronary artery bypass grafts Salm, L.P.

Multimodality imaging of coronary artery bypass grafts

Salm, L.P.

Citation

Salm, L. P. (2006, November 7). Multimodality imaging of coronary artery bypass grafts.

Retrieved from https://hdl.handle.net/1887/4978

Version:

Corrected Publisher’s Version

License:

Licence agreement concerning inclusion of doctoral thesis in the

_{Institutional Repository of the University of Leiden}

Downloaded from:

https://hdl.handle.net/1887/4978



$

%675$&7 )RUW\QLQHSDWLHQWVZLWKSUHYLRXVE\SDVVVXUJHU\XQGHUZHQWFRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\DQG FDUGLRYDVFXODUPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH05LPDJLQJRIVLQJOHYHLQE\SDVVJUDIWV9ROXPH ÁRZDQGYHORFLW\DQDO\VHVZHUHSHUIRUPHGDQGFRPSDUHGRQ05YHORFLW\PDSV%ODQG $OWPDQDQDO\VLVVKRZHGFORVHDJUHHPHQWEHWZHHQWKHWZRW\SHVRIDQDO\VLV&RPSDULVRQ RI DUHDV XQGHU WKH UHFHLYHU RSHUDWLQJ FKDUDFWHULVWLF FXUYH UHYHDOHG QR VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQWKHDQDO\VHVIRUGHWHFWLRQRIVWHQRVHVRIRUJUHDWHU'LDJQRVWLF DFFXUDF\ IRU YROXPH ÁRZ DQG YHORFLW\ SDUDPHWHUV ZDV  DQG  UHVSHFWLYHO\ 9HORFLW\DQDO\VLVDSSHDUVWREHWKHSUHIHUUHGPHWKRGEHFDXVHLWLVOHVVWLPHFRQVXPLQJ DQGKDVDVLPLODUGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\WRYROXPHÁRZDQDO\VLV





,

1752'8&7,21

9ROXPHÁRZDQGSHDNYHORFLW\PHDVXUHPHQWVKDYHEHHQXVHGDVSK\VLRORJLFPDUNHUV RIVWHQRVLVVHYHULW\LQFRURQDU\DUWHULHV9ROXPHÁRZLVRIGLUHFWFOLQLFDOYDOXHVLQFHWKH TXDQWLW\RIEORRGÁRZLQJWKURXJKDYHVVHOZLWKLQPLQXWHLVPHDVXUHGDQGFRURQDU\ ÁRZ UHVHUYH &)5 LV FRUUHODWHG ZLWK VWHQRVLV VHYHULW\  KRZHYHU GLUHFW LQYDVLYH PHDVXUHPHQW LV UHVWULFWHG WR ´RSHQ FKHVWµ SURFHGXUHV 3HDN YHORFLW\ PHDVXUHG E\ XVLQJ D 'RSSOHU JXLGHZLUH KDV EHHQ SURYHQ WR FRUUHODWH ZHOO ZLWK YROXPH ÁRZ ERWK LQ YLWUR DQG LQ YLYR  DQG KDV HYROYHG LQWR D ZHOOHVWDEOLVKHG PHWKRG WR HYDOXDWH VWHQRVHV LQ FRURQDU\ DUWHULHV DQG E\SDVV JUDIWV LQ WKH FDWKHWHUL]DWLRQ ODERUDWRU\  &DUGLRYDVFXODUPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH05YHORFLW\PDSSLQJLVDQRQLQYDVLYHWHFKQLTXH XVHGWRPHDVXUHFRURQDU\ÁRZDQGYHORFLW\LQQDWLYHFRURQDU\DUWHULHVDQGE\SDVV JUDIWV%RWKYROXPHÁRZDQGYHORFLW\FDQEHDQDO\]HGRQD05YHORFLW\PDS05 YROXPHÁRZDQDO\VLVKDVEHHQYDOLGDWHGDVEHLQJDQDFFXUDWHQRQLQYDVLYHPHWKRGRI PHDVXULQJ YROXPH ÁRZ  :LWK WKLV DSSURDFK WKH PHDQ YHORFLW\ IRU WKH ZKROH OXPLQDODUHDRIWKHYHVVHOLVPXOWLSOLHGE\WKHOXPLQDODUHD$OOSL[HOVDUHLQFOXGHGLQ WKHDQDO\VLVKRZHYHUSDUWLDOYROXPHHIIHFWVPD\RFFXUDWWKHHGJHVRIWKHOXPHQ 0RUHRYHUWKLVDQDO\WLFDODSSURDFKLVWLPHFRQVXPLQJ,QYHORFLW\DQDO\VLVWKHYHORFLW\ LQWKHFHQWHURIWKHYHVVHOLVPHDVXUHG7KLVDSSURDFKLVOHVVWLPHFRQVXPLQJDQGKDV EHHQ XVHG VXFFHVVIXOO\ LQ VHYHUDO FOLQLFDO VWXGLHV  7KH SUHVHQW VWXG\ ZDV SHUIRUPHGWRHYDOXDWHZKHWKHU05YROXPHÁRZDQDO\VLVDQG05YHORFLW\DQDO\VLVKDYH FRPSDUDEOHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDFLHVIRUWKHGHWHFWLRQRIVLJQLÀFDQW•VWHQRVLVLQVLQJOH YHLQFRURQDU\DUWHU\E\SDVVJUDIWV

0

$7(5,$/6



$1'



0(7+2'6 3DWLHQWV $WRWDORISDWLHQWVZKRKDGSUHYLRXVO\XQGHUJRQHE\SDVVJUDIWVXUJHU\XQGHUZHQW FRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\EHFDXVHRIUHFXUUHQWFKHVWSDLQDQGLQDGGLWLRQXQGHUZHQW05 LPDJLQJDFFRUGLQJWRWKHVWXG\SURWRFRO$SSURYDORIWKHORFDOPHGLFDOHWKLFVFRPPLWWHH ZDV REWDLQHG DQG DOO SDWLHQWV JDYH LQIRUPHG FRQVHQW 7KLV VWXG\ ZDV SURVSHFWLYH DQG ZDV SHUIRUPHG LQ D XQLYHUVLW\ KRVSLWDO /HLGHQ 8QLYHUVLW\ 0HGLFDO &HQWHU 05 UHODWHGH[FOXVLRQFULWHULDLQFOXGHGLPSODQWHGPHWDOOLFGHYLFHVXQVWDEOHDQJLQDLUUHJXODU KHDUWUK\WKPFODXVWURSKRELDDQGWKHLQDELOLW\WROLHÁDW$GHQRVLQHUHODWHGH[FOXVLRQ FULWHULD LQFOXGHG FKURQLF REVWUXFWLYH SXOPRQDU\ GLVHDVH DQG VHFRQG RU WKLUGGHJUHH DWULRYHQWULFXODUEORFN0HDQDJH“VWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQLQSDWLHQWVZDV\HDUV“ UDQJH\HDUV7KHUHZHUHPHQDQGZRPHQZLWKPHDQDJHVRI\HDUV“ UDQJH\HDUVDQG\HDUV“UDQJH\HDUVUHVSHFWLYHO\7DEOHJLYHV SHUWLQHQWLQIRUPDWLRQUHJDUGLQJWKHSDWLHQWV

,

0$*,1*



$1'

$

1$/<6,6 &RURQDU\$QJLRJUDSK\

&RURQDU\ DQJLRJUDSK\ ZDV SHUIRUPHG DFFRUGLQJ WR D VWDQGDUG SURWRFRO E\ XVLQJ WKH 6HOGLQJHU WHFKQLTXH 6LQJOH YHLQ JUDIWV DQG UHFLSLHQW YHVVHOV Q   ZHUH VWXGLHG LQ  SDWLHQWV 7R REMHFWLYHO\ GHWHUPLQH WKH VHYHULW\ RI VWHQRVLV TXDQWLWDWLYH FRURQDU\ DUWHULRJUDSK\ZDVSHUIRUPHGE\PHPEHUVRIDQLQGHSHQGHQWFRUHODERUDWRU\+HDUW&RUH

 1XPEHURISDWLHQWVQ  0DOHIHPDOH  $JH\HDUV “ 7LPHDIWHUE\SDVVVXUJHU\\HDUV “ 1XPEHURIJUDIWVVWXGLHG  +\SHUFKROHVWHUROHPLD  +\SHUWHQVLRQ  &XUUHQWVPRNHUV  'LDEHWHVPHOOLWXV  )DPLO\KLVWRU\IRUFDUGLRYDVFXODUGLVHDVH  7DEOH  3DWLHQW&KDUDFWHULVWLFV

/HLGHQ WKH 1HWKHUODQGV $Q H[SHULHQFHG DQDO\VW IURP +HDUW &RUH ZKR ZDV EOLQGHG WR WKH UHVXOWV RI WKH 05 LPDJLQJ SHUIRUPHG WKH TXDQWLWDWLYH FRURQDU\ DUWHULRJUDSK\ DQDO\VHV 4XDQWLWDWLYH FRURQDU\ DUWHULRJUDSK\ HQDEOHG GLJLWDO PHDVXUHPHQW RI WKH GLDPHWHURIWKHVWHQRVLVLQPLOOLPHWHUVDQGRIDQRQVWHQRWLFVHJPHQWRIWKHVDPHYHVVHO UHIHUHQFHGLDPHWHU7KHSHUFHQWDJHRIVWHQRVLVZDVFDOFXODWHGDVWKHUDWLREHWZHHQWKH GLDPHWHURIWKHVWHQRVHGVHJPHQWDQGWKHUHIHUHQFHGLDPHWHU7KLVPHWKRGRITXDQWLWDWLYH FRURQDU\ DUWHULRJUDSK\ ZDV VWDQGDUGL]HG DQG H[WHQVLYHO\ YDOLGDWHG E\ 5HLEHU HW DO $UHGXFWLRQLQYHVVHOGLDPHWHURIRUJUHDWHUZDVFRQVLGHUHGDVLJQLÀFDQW VWHQRVLV

05,PDJLQJ



SDFNDJH)/2:0HGLV/HLGHQWKH1HWKHUODQGVE\WKHVDPHLQYHVWLJDWRU6(/DQG WKHÁRZDQGYHORFLW\DQDO\VHVRIWKHVDPHYHORFLW\PDSZHUHVHSDUDWHGE\DPLQLPXPRI ZHHNVWRDYRLGELDV7KHGXUDWLRQLQPLQXWHVRIWKHYROXPHÁRZDQGYHORFLW\DQDO\VHV SHUSDWLHQWZDVUHJLVWHUHGIURPWKHVWDUWRIWKHLPDJHDQDO\VLVWRUHSRUWJHQHUDWLRQ )RU WKH YROXPH ÁRZ DQDO\VLV WKH OXPLQDO DUHD ZDV WUDFHG PDQXDOO\ RQ WKH PRGXOXV LPDJH DQG WUDQVIHUUHG WR WKH SKDVH LPDJH )LJXUH  7KH SRVLWLRQ DQG VL]H RI HDFK FRQWRXUZHUHDGMXVWHGDFFRUGLQJWRWKHFDUGLDFSKDVH7KHÁRZUDWHLQPLOOLOLWHUVSHU VHFRQGZDVFDOFXODWHGE\PXOWLSO\LQJWKHDYHUDJHYHORFLW\RYHUWKHOXPLQDODUHDZLWK WKHOXPLQDODUHDIRUHDFKFDUGLDFSKDVH)ORZUDWHYHUVXVWLPHFXUYHVZHUHUHFRQVWUXFWHG DQG WKH YROXPH ÁRZ UDWH LQ PLOOLOLWHUV SHU PLQXWH ZDV REWDLQHG E\ PXOWLSO\LQJ WKH LQWHJUDWHG YROXPHWULF ÁRZ UDWH SHU KHDUWEHDW ZLWK WKH KHDUW UDWH )LJXUH  6\VWROLF SHDNÁRZUDWHDQGGLDVWROLFSHDNÁRZUDWHZHUHGHÀQHGDVPD[LPDOÁRZUDWHGXULQJ V\VWROH DQG GLDVWROH UHVSHFWLYHO\ ERWK PHDVXUHG LQ PLOOLOLWHUV SHU VHFRQG &)5 ZDV FDOFXODWHGDVWKHUDWLRRIYROXPHÁRZGXULQJDGHQRVLQHLQGXFHGVWUHVVDQGYROXPHÁRZ DW UHVW 7KH UDWLR EHWZHHQ GLDVWROLF DQG V\VWROLF SHDN ÁRZ UDWHV ZDV UHJDUGHG DV WKH GLDVWROLFWRV\VWROLFÁRZUDWLR 9HORFLW\LPDJHVFRQVLVWHGRISDLUHGPRGXOXVDQGSKDVHLPDJHV)RUWKHYHORFLW\DQDO\VLV DUHJLRQRILQWHUHVWRI[SL[HOVZDVSODFHGLQWKHFHQWHURIWKHYHVVHOLQHDFKSKDVH LPDJH)LJXUH7KHPHDQYHORFLW\RIWKHSL[HOVZDVGHÀQHGDVWKHFHQWUDOYHORFLW\ IRUWKDWFDUGLDFSKDVH9HORFLW\YHUVXVWLPHFXUYHVZHUHGUDZQ)LJXUHZKLFKZHUH VLPLODUWRÁRZUDWHFXUYHV6\VWROLFSHDNYHORFLW\DQGGLDVWROLFSHDNYHORFLW\ZHUHGHÀQHG DVWKHPD[LPDOFHQWUDOYHORFLW\GXULQJV\VWROHDQGGLDVWROHUHVSHFWLYHO\PHDVXUHGLQ FHQWLPHWHUV SHU VHFRQG 7KH PHDQ FHQWUDO YHORFLW\ ZDV UHJDUGHG DV WKH DYHUDJH SHDN YHORFLW\ &RURQDU\ ÁRZ YHORFLW\ UHVHUYH &)95 ZDV FDOFXODWHG DV WKH UDWLR EHWZHHQ DYHUDJHSHDNYHORFLWLHVGXULQJDGHQRVLQHLQGXFHGVWUHVVDQGDWUHVW'LDVWROLFWRV\VWROLF YHORFLW\UDWLRZDVWKHUDWLREHWZHHQGLDVWROLFDQGV\VWROLFSHDNYHORFLWLHV )LJXUH  6DJLWWDOREOLTXHLPDJHVIURPDW\SLFDOSKDVHFRQWUDVW05H[DPLQDWLRQ0RGXOXVWRSDQGSKDVH ERWWRPLPDJHVREWDLQHGZLWKDEUHDWKKROGWXUERÀHOGHFKRSODQDUVHTXHQFHVKRZ WKHFURVVVHFWLRQRIDYHLQJUDIWDUURZWRWKHOHIWDQWHULRUGHVFHQGLQJFRURQDU\DUWHU\DQGDQ DUWHULDOE\SDVVJUDIWDUURZKHDGWRWKHÀUVWGLDJRQDOEUDQFKGXULQJODWHGLDVWROH(QODUJHPHQWV RI WKH YHLQ JUDIW FURVV VHFWLRQ ULJKW DUH VKRZQ WR LOOXVWUDWH WKH YROXPH ÁRZ DQG YHORFLW\ DQDO\VHV3$ SXOPRQDU\DUWHU\ DUWHIDFWGHULYHGIURPVWHUQDOZLUHVRQWKHFKHVWZDOO

 )LJXUH  7RS)ORZUDWHYHUVXVWLPHFXUYH7KHLQWHJUDORIWKHFXUYHKDWFKHGDUHDLQGLFDWHVWKHYROXPH ÁRZSHUKHDUWEHDW7KHYROXPHÁRZSHUKHDUWEHDWPXOWLSOLHGZLWKWKHKHDUWUDWHUHVXOWVLQWKH YROXPHÁRZSHUPLQXWH%RWWRP9HORFLW\YHUVXVWLPHFXUYHIURPWKHVDPHE\SDVVJUDIWGLVSOD\V WKHYHORFLW\SDUDPHWHUVWKDWZHUHGLVWUDFWHGIURPWKHFXUYH)ORZUDWHDQGYHORFLW\YHUVXVWLPH FXUYHVZHUHXVHGWRTXDQWLI\YROXPHÁRZDQGYHORFLW\SDUDPHWHUV63) V\VWROLFSHDNÁRZ '3) GLDVWROLFSHDNÁRZ639 V\VWROLFSHDNYHORFLW\'39 GLDVWROLFSHDNYHORFLW\$39  DYHUDJHSHDNYHORFLW\

6WDWLVWLFDO$QDO\VLV

3DLUHGFRUUHODWLRQVRIWKHÁRZDQGYHORFLW\SDUDPHWHUVZHUHGHWHUPLQHGE\FDOFXODWLQJ WKH3HDUVRQFRUUHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQW/LPLWVRIDJUHHPHQWEHWZHHQWKHYROXPHÁRZDQG YHORFLW\ DQDO\VHV ZHUH HYDOXDWHG E\ PHDQV RI %ODQG$OWPDQ DQDO\VLV  5HFHLYHU RSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLF52&FXUYHDQDO\VLVZDVHPSOR\HGWRGHWHUPLQHWKHGLDJQRVWLF SHUIRUPDQFHRIHDFKÁRZDQGYHORFLW\SDUDPHWHUIRUGHPRQVWUDWLQJDVLJQLÀFDQWVWHQRVLV XVLQJWKH6LPSVRQUXOHXQLYDULDWHDQDO\VLV

6LJQLÀFDQWSDUDPHWHUVIURPWKHXQLYDULDWHDQDO\VLVZHUHVXEVHTXHQWO\XVHGWRSHUIRUP VWHSZLVH PXOWLYDULDWH ORJLVWLF UHJUHVVLRQ DQG 52& FXUYH DQDO\VHV WR GHWHUPLQH WKH GLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRIWKHFRPELQHGVHWRIÁRZRUYHORFLW\SDUDPHWHUVUHVSHFWLYHO\ LQ WKH GHWHFWLRQ RI D VLJQLÀFDQW VWHQRVLV PXOWLYDULDWH DQDO\VLV 0XOWLSOH VLQJOH YHLQ JUDIWVLQWKHVDPHSDWLHQWZHUHSRVVLEO\FRUUHODWHGIRULQVWDQFHEHFDXVHWKH\VKDUH WKHVDPHULVNRIVWHQRVLVGXHWRV\VWHPLFIDFWRUV7KLVFRUUHODWLRQZDVLQYHVWLJDWHGIRU WKH FDOFXODWLRQ RI WKH FRUUHODWLRQV EHWZHHQ WKH ÁRZ DQG YHORFLW\ SDUDPHWHUV DQG IRU WKHORJLVWLFUHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VLVE\XVLQJDUREXVWHVWLPDWRURIWKHVWDQGDUGHUURUVDQG E\WKHVXEVHTXHQWFDOFXODWLRQRIWKHSYDOXHV5HVXOWVLQGLFDWHGQRFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ PXOWLSOH JUDIWV ZLWKLQ D SDWLHQW 7KHUHIRUH DOO JUDIWV ZHUH WUHDWHG LQGHSHQGHQWO\ IRU FDOFXODWLQJFRUUHODWLRQVDQGDUHDVXQGHUWKHFXUYHLQ52&DQDO\VLVDQGIRUFRPSDULQJ 52& FXUYHV 7KH RSWLPDO FXWRII YDOXHV IRU ÁRZ DQG YHORFLW\ SDUDPHWHUV QHHGHG WR



SUHGLFW VWHQRVLV ZHUH GHÀQHG DV WKRVH SURYLGLQJ WKH PD[LPDO VXP RI VHQVLWLYLW\ DQG VSHFLÀFLW\6HQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DQGGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\ZHUHEDVHGRQWKHLUVWDQGDUG GHÀQLWLRQVDQGDUHSUHVHQWHGZLWKFRQÀGHQFHLQWHUYDOV )RUDOOWHVWVSZDVFRQVLGHUHGWRLQGLFDWHDVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH

5

(68/76 $WRWDORIVLQJOHYHLQJUDIWVZHUHDQDO\]HG6L[WHHQJUDIWVVXSSOLHGWKHOHIWDQWHULRU GHVFHQGLQJDUWHU\WHUULWRU\JUDIWVWKHOHIWFLUFXPÁH[DUWHU\WHUULWRU\DQGJUDIWV WKH ULJKW FRURQDU\ DUWHU\ WHUULWRU\ %\ PHDQV RI TXDQWLWDWLYH FRURQDU\ DUWHULRJUDSK\ VHYHULW\RIVWHQRVLVZDVGHWHUPLQHGWRUDQJHIURPWRZLWKDPHDQRI“ 6WHQRVLVRIRUJUHDWHUZDVGHWHFWHGLQJUDIWV

$W05LPDJLQJRIJUDIWVZHUHQRWYLVLEOHLQWKHLUH[SHFWHGFRXUVHDQGWKHVHJUDIWV ZHUH UHJDUGHG DV RFFOXGHG 05 YHORFLW\ PDSSLQJ ZDV SHUIRUPHG LQ WKH UHPDLQLQJ  JUDIWV %DVHOLQH YHORFLW\ PDSSLQJ ZDV XQVXFFHVVIXO LQ  JUDIW EHFDXVH RI DUWLIDFWV $GHQRVLQHLQGXFHGVWUHVVYHORFLW\PDSSLQJZDVQRWSRVVLEOHLQJUDIWVEHFDXVHRIVLGH HIIHFWVIURPDGHQRVLQH

&RUUHODWLRQVIRUWKHYROXPHÁRZDQGYHORFLW\SDUDPHWHUVDUHVKRZQLQ7DEOH+LJKO\ VLJQLÀFDQW FRUUHODWLRQV ZHUH IRXQG IRU DOO SDLUHG SDUDPHWHUV ERWK DW UHVW DQG GXULQJ VWUHVVSIRUDOOFRUUHODWLRQV

$JUHHPHQW EHWZHHQ &)5 DQG &)95 DQG EHWZHHQ GLDVWROLFWRV\VWROLF ÁRZ UDWLR DQG GLDVWROLFWRV\VWROLF YHORFLW\ UDWLR ZDV TXDQWLÀHG E\ PHDQV RI %ODQG$OWPDQ DQDO\VLV )LJXUH  GLVSOD\V WKH %ODQG$OWPDQ SORW IRU WKH &)5 DQG &)95 7KHUH ZDV D FORVH DJUHHPHQWEHWZHHQWKHWZRPHWKRGVRIDQDO\VLV7KHPHDQGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKH&)95 DQG&)5ZDVQRWVLJQLÀFDQW6LPLODUUHVXOWVZHUHIRXQGIRUGLDVWROLFWRV\VWROLFÁRZUDWLR DQG GLDVWROLFWRV\VWROLF YHORFLW\ UDWLR E\ XVLQJ EDVHOLQH DQG VWUHVV SDUDPHWHUV 'LUHFW FRPSDULVRQRIWKHUHPDLQLQJSDUDPHWHUVZDVQRWSRVVLEOHEHFDXVHXQLWVRIPHDVXUHZHUH QRWHTXLYDOHQWYROXPHÁRZSDUDPHWHUVZHUHPHDVXUHGLQPLOOLOLWHUVSHUVHFRQGZKLOH YHORFLW\SDUDPHWHUVZHUHPHDVXUHGLQFHQWLPHWHUVSHUVHFRQG $WXQLYDULDWHDQDO\VLVDOOSDUDPHWHUVIRUERWKYROXPHÁRZDQGYHORFLW\PHWKRGVZHUH VLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQWEHWZHHQJUDIWVZLWKDQGWKRVHZLWKRXWVWHQRVHV•VWHQRVLV S$WPXOWLYDULDWHDQDO\VLVWKHGLDJQRVWLFYDOXHRIDOOVLJQLÀFDQWXQLYDULDWHÁRZ SDUDPHWHUVYROXPHÁRZV\VWROLFDQGGLDVWROLFSHDNÁRZUDWHVGLDVWROLFWRV\VWROLFÁRZ UDWLRDWEDVHOLQHDQGGXULQJVWUHVV&)5ZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKDOOVLJQLÀFDQWXQLYDULDWH YHORFLW\SDUDPHWHUVDYHUDJHV\VWROLFDQGGLDVWROLFSHDNYHORFLWLHVGLDVWROLFWRV\VWROLF YHORFLW\UDWLRDWEDVHOLQHDQGGXULQJVWUHVV&)95LQWKHGHWHFWLRQRIDJUDIWVWHQRVLVRI RUPRUH7KHHVWLPDWHGUHJUHVVLRQSDUDPHWHUVVHOHFWHGLQWKHPRGHODUHJLYHQLQ 7DEOH7KHDUHDXQGHUWKH52&FXUYHZDVFRQÀGHQFHLQWHUYDO IRU WKH ÁRZ SDUDPHWHUV DQG   FRQÀGHQFH LQWHUYDO   IRU WKH YHORFLW\ SDUDPHWHUV%RWK52&DUHDVZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\ODUJHUWKDQS:KHQWKH52& DUHDVZHUHFRPSDUHGWKHUHVXOWVVKRZHGQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHS 2SWLPDO FXWRIISRLQWVIRUWKH52&FXUYHVDUHGLVSOD\HGLQ)LJXUH7KHRSWLPDOVHQVLWLYLW\ VSHFLÀFLW\ DQG DFFXUDF\ IRU WKH YROXPH ÁRZ SDUDPHWHUV ZHUH   FRQÀGHQFH LQWHUYDOFRQÀGHQFHLQWHUYDODQGFRQÀGHQFH LQWHUYDOUHVSHFWLYHO\7KHRSWLPDOVHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DQGDFFXUDF\IRUWKH



YHORFLW\SDUDPHWHUVZHUHFRQÀGHQFHLQWHUYDOFRQÀGHQFH LQWHUYDO   DQG   FRQÀGHQFH LQWHUYDO   UHVSHFWLYHO\ 1R VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFHV LQ VHQVLWLYLW\ VSHFLÀFLW\ RU DFFXUDF\ ZHUH IRXQG EHWZHHQ WKH PHWKRGVRIDQDO\VLVIRUGHPRQVWUDWLQJDE\SDVVJUDIWVWHQRVLVRIRUJUHDWHU

7KH PHDQ GXUDWLRQ IRU SHUIRUPLQJ D YROXPH ÁRZ DQDO\VLV ZDV  PLQXWHV “  ZKHUHDVDYHORFLW\DQDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHGLQPLQXWHV“S

)LJXUH

 3DLUHGSDUDPHWHUV &RUUHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQW &)5DQG&)95  %DVHOLQH  9ROXPHÁRZDQGDYHUDJHSHDNYHORFLW\   6\VWROLFSHDNÁRZDQGYHORFLW\   'LDVWROLFSHDNÁRZDQGYHORFLW\   'LDVWROLFWRV\VWROLFÁRZDQGYHORFLW\UDWLRV  $GHQRVLQHLQGXFHGVWUHVV  9ROXPHÁRZDQGDYHUDJHSHDNYHORFLW\   6\VWROLFSHDNÁRZDQGYHORFLW\   'LDVWROLFSHDNÁRZDQGYHORFLW\   'LDVWROLFWRV\VWROLFÁRZDQGYHORFLW\UDWLRV  7DEOH  &RUUHODWLRQVIRUSDLUHGÁRZDQGYHORFLW\SDUDPHWHUV  )RUDOOFRUUHODWLRQVS)ORZDQGYHORFLW\SDUDPHWHUVDUHGHULYHGIURPWKHYROXPHÁRZDQG YHORFLW\DQDO\VLVRIWKH05YHORFLW\PDSVRIVLQJOHYHLQE\SDVVJUDIWV  9ROXPHÁRZ 9HORFLW\ 3DUDPHWHU E 6(( E 6(( $YHUDJHSHDN     %DVHOLQH      6WUHVV     5HVHUYH      6\VWROLFSHDN     %DVHOLQH      6WUHVV     'LDVWROLFSHDN     %DVHOLQH      6WUHVV     'LDVWROLFWRV\VWROLFUDWLR     %DVHOLQH     6WUHVV     &RQVWDQW     7DEOH  (VWLPDWHGUHJUHVVLRQSDUDPHWHUVRIWKHIRUZDUGVWHSZLVHPXOWLYDULDWHORJLVWLFUHJUHVVLRQPRGHO

 5HIHUVWRWKH&)5RU&)95E UHJUHVVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW6(( VWDQGDUGHUURURIWKHHVWLPDWH



'

,6&866,21

,QWKHSUHVHQWVWXG\WZRDSSURDFKHVXVHGWRDQDO\]H05YHORFLW\PDSV05YROXPH ÁRZ DQDO\VLV DQG 05 YHORFLW\ DQDO\VLV ZHUH FRPSDUHG LQ D KHDGWRKHDG IDVKLRQ LQ VLQJOH YHLQ E\SDVV JUDIWV &ORVH DJUHHPHQW ZDV VKRZQ EHWZHHQ WKH YROXPH ÁRZ DQG YHORFLW\ PHWKRGV ZKHQ FRPSDULQJ &)5 &)95 GLDVWROLFWRV\VWROLF ÁRZ UDWLR DQG GLDVWROLFWRV\VWROLF YHORFLW\ UDWLR )DLU VHQVLWLYLW\ VSHFLÀFLW\ DQG GLDJQRVWLF DFFXUDF\ ZHUHVKRZQIRUERWKDSSURDFKHVLQGHSLFWLQJVLJQLÀFDQW•VWHQRVLV7KHUHIRUHD VLQJOHDSSURDFKZRXOGEHVXIÀFLHQWZKHQDQDO\]LQJ05YHORFLW\PDSV

7KHFRQFHSWRI&)5ZDVSURSRVHGE\*RXOGHWDOLQWKHHDUO\VZKHQWKHQHFHVVLW\ DURVHIRUDKHPRG\QDPLFDVVHVVPHQWRIFRURQDU\VWHQRVHVYLVXDOL]HGRQWKHFRURQDU\ DQJLRJUDP$EVROXWHFRURQDU\EORRGÁRZFRXOGEHPHDVXUHGRQO\E\XVLQJSHULYDVFXODU ÁRZ WUDQVGXFHUV LQ ´RSHQ FKHVWµ SURFHGXUHV &)5 ZDV WKHUHIRUH YDOLGDWHG LQ DQLPDO PRGHOVRULQSDWLHQWVXQGHUJRLQJE\SDVVJUDIWVXUJHU\KRZHYHUH[WHQVLYHXVH LQ WKH FOLQLFDO VHWWLQJ ZDV QRW SRVVLEOH :KHQ WKH GLDPHWHU RI LQWUDYDVFXODU FDWKHWHU EDVHG 'RSSOHU XOWUDVRQRJUDSKLF GHYLFHV FRXOG EH UHGXFHG WR DQ LQFK GLDPHWHU LW EHFDPH IHDVLEOH WR PHDVXUH DEVROXWH YHORFLW\ RI EORRG ÁRZ DQG FDOFXODWH &)95 LQ FRURQDU\ DUWHULHV LQ SDWLHQWV GXULQJ FDWKHWHUL]DWLRQ $EVROXWH EORRG ÁRZ FRUUHODWHG ZHOO ZLWK 'RSSOHUGHULYHG DEVROXWH YHORFLW\ DQG YROXPH ÁRZ ERWK LQ YLWUR DQG LQ YLYR'RSSOHUGHULYHGYHORFLW\DQG&)95SURYHGWKHLUSRWHQWLDOLQQXPHURXV FOLQLFDODSSOLFDWLRQVVXFKDVLQLGHQWLÀFDWLRQRIKHPRG\QDPLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWVWHQRVHV LQQDWLYHFRURQDU\DUWHULHVDQGYHLQJUDIWVLQWKHIXQFWLRQDODVVHVVPHQWRIVWHQRVHV RILQWHUPHGLDWHVHYHULW\LQWKHGHWHUPLQDWLRQRIWKHQHHGIRUDQGWKHRXWFRPHDIWHU FRURQDU\LQWHUYHQWLRQDQGLQWKHSUHGLFWLRQRIUHVWHQRVLV

:LWK 05 LPDJLQJ DQG D YHORFLW\ PDSSLQJ VHTXHQFH ERWK &)5 DQG &)95 FDQ EH FDOFXODWHGDVZDVGHVFULEHGLQ0DWHULDOVDQG0HWKRGV,QFOLQLFDOVWXGLHVERWKWKHYROXPH ÁRZDQDO\VLVDQGWKHYHORFLW\DQDO\VLVKDYHEHHQXVHGVXFFHVVIXOO\,Q RXU VWXG\ WKH DFFXUDFLHV RI YROXPH ÁRZ DQG YHORFLW\ DQDO\VHV ZHUH QRW VLJQLÀFDQWO\ GLIIHUHQW ZKHQ HYDOXDWLQJ 05 YHORFLW\ PDSV 2WKHU IDFWRUV VXFK DV HUURUV LQ SKDVH FRQWUDVW05LPDJLQJDQGWKHWLPHQHFHVVDU\WRDQDO\]HWKH05YHORFLW\PDSVEHFRPH LPSRUWDQWLQFKRRVLQJDPHWKRGIRUDQDO\VLV

:KHQREWDLQLQJÁRZPHDVXUHPHQWVDWSKDVHFRQWUDVW05LPDJLQJVHYHUDOHUURUVPLJKW RFFXU6RPHHUURUVDUHGHSHQGHQWRQWKHSUHVFULSWLRQRIWKH05YHORFLW\PDSSLQJ VHTXHQFHHJLQDGHTXDWHVSDWLDODQGWHPSRUDOUHVROXWLRQPLVPDWFKHGHQFRGLQJYHORFLW\ GHYLDWLRQ RI WKH SHUSHQGLFXODU LPDJLQJ SODQH IURP WKH ÁRZ GLUHFWLRQ ,Q WKH SUHVHQW VWXG\DQHIIRUWZDVPDGHWRNHHSWKHHIIHFWVRIHUURUVPLQLPDO(QFRGLQJYHORFLW\ZDV DGHTXDWHO\PDWFKHGWRDYRLGDOLDVLQJDQGWZRVXUYH\LPDJHVREWDLQHGDWGLIIHUHQWDQJOHV ZHUHXVHGWRSODQWKHLPDJLQJSODQHSHUSHQGLFXODUWRWKHJUDIW3KDVHRIIVHWHUURUVDUH GHSHQGHQWRQORFDOPDJQHWLFÀHOGLQKRPRJHQHLWLHVDQGDUHXVXDOO\VPDOO,QWKHDQDO\VLV RI05YHORFLW\PDSVDOORIWKHVHHUURUVDIIHFWERWKYROXPHÁRZDQGYHORFLW\DQDO\VHV ,Q YROXPH ÁRZ DQDO\VLV DOO SL[HOV LQ WKH FURVVVHFWLRQDO DUHD RI WKH JUDIW OXPHQ DUH LQFOXGHG3L[HOVRQWKHYHVVHOHGJHPD\DYHUDJHVLJQDOVERWKIURPWKHYHVVHOOXPHQDQG IURPVXUURXQGLQJWLVVXH7KLVW\SHRIHUURUNQRZQDVSDUWLDOYROXPHHIIHFWFRXOGHLWKHU LQFUHDVHRUGHFUHDVHDSSDUHQWÁRZ7KHH[WHQWRISDUWLDOYROXPHHIIHFWGHSHQGV SUHGRPLQDQWO\RQVSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQDQGUHODWLYHVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\RIVWDWLRQDU\WLVVXH



:LWKWKHFXUUHQW05LPDJLQJWHFKQLTXHVVSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQIRUÁRZPHDVXUHPHQWVLQ VPDOOYHVVHOVLVOLPLWHGDQGGXHWREDFNJURXQGQRLVHYHORFLW\LVQRW]HURLQVWDWLRQDU\ WLVVXH HQKDQFLQJ SDUWLDO YROXPH HIIHFWV +RZHYHU YHORFLWLHV DW WKH YHVVHO HGJH DUH H[SHFWHGWREHORZDVWKHUHLVDSXOVDWLOHODPLQDUÁRZSDWWHUQLQE\SDVVJUDIWVZLWKWKH KLJKHVWYHORFLW\LQWKHFHQWHURIWKHYHVVHO6LQFHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIWKHYROXPH ÁRZDQGYHORFLW\DQDO\VHVGLGQRWGLIIHUVLJQLÀFDQWO\LQRXUVWXG\WKLVPLJKWLQGLFDWH WKDWWKLVW\SHRIHUURUKDVDUHODWLYHO\PLQRUUROHZKHQ05LPDJLQJLVXVHGWRPHDVXUH ÁRZLQVLQJOHYHLQE\SDVVJUDIWV ,QRXUVWXG\DYROXPHÁRZDQDO\VLVUHTXLUHGPLQXWHV“WRFRPSOHWHZKHUHDVD YHORFLW\DQDO\VLVUHTXLUHGRQO\PLQXWHV“,IFOLQLFDODFFHSWDQFHRIDGLDJQRVWLFWHVW LVWREHDFKLHYHGSHUIRUPDQFHDQGDQDO\VLVRIWKHWHVWVKRXOGEHIDVWDQGVWUDLJKWIRUZDUG 6LQFHWKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\IURPERWKDQDO\VHVZDVVLPLODUYHORFLW\DQDO\VLVDSSHDUV WREHWKHSUHIHUDEOHPHWKRG

2XU VWXG\ KDG OLPLWDWLRQV LQ WKDW RWKHU LVVXHV DVVRFLDWHG ZLWK 05 YHORFLW\ PDSSLQJ VXFKDVUHIHUHQFHYDOXHVRIWKH05ÁRZDQGYHORFLW\SDUDPHWHUVVSDWLDODQGWHPSRUDO UHVROXWLRQ RI WKH DFTXLUHG 05 LPDJHV DQG SUR[LPDO ORFDWLRQ RI WKH LPDJLQJ SODQH LQ WKHYHVVHOZHUHQRWDGGUHVVHGWKLVLVEHFDXVHRXUSXUSRVHZDVWRFRPSDUHYROXPHÁRZ DQG YHORFLW\ DQDO\VHV RI 05 YHORFLW\ PDSV ,Q DGGLWLRQ WKH VDPSOH VL]H RI RXU VWXG\ ZDVVPDOO7KHVWXG\ZDVQRWGHVLJQHGWRWHVWHTXLYDOHQFHRIWKHDQDO\VLVPHWKRGV7R GHPRQVWUDWHHTXLYDOHQFHDODUJHUGDWDVHWZRXOGEHQHFHVVDU\

&

21&/86,21

,QWKHHYDOXDWLRQRI05YHORFLW\PDSVRIVLQJOHYHLQFRURQDU\DUWHU\E\SDVVJUDIWVWKHUH LVFORVHDJUHHPHQWEHWZHHQYROXPHÁRZDQGYHORFLW\DQDO\VHV)RUGHWHFWLRQRIDVWHQRVLV  RU JUHDWHU YHORFLW\ DQDO\VLV KDV D GLDJQRVWLF DFFXUDF\ VLPLODU WR WKDW RI YROXPH ÁRZDQDO\VLVDQGLVOHVVWLPHFRQVXPLQJ7KHUHIRUHYHORFLW\DQDO\VLVDSSHDUVWREHWKH PHWKRGRISUHIHUHQFHLQWKHDQDO\VLVRI05YHORFLW\PDSVRIE\SDVVJUDIWV





5

()(5(1&(6  *RXOG.//LSVFRPE.+DPLOWRQ*:3K\VLRORJLFEDVLVIRUDVVHVVLQJFULWLFDOFRURQDU\VWHQRVLV,QVWDQWDQHRXV ÁRZUHVSRQVHDQGUHJLRQDOGLVWULEXWLRQGXULQJFRURQDU\K\SHUHPLDDVPHDVXUHVRIFRURQDU\ÁRZUHVHUYH $P-&DUGLRO  'RXFHWWH-:&RUO3'3D\QH+0HWDO9DOLGDWLRQRID'RSSOHUJXLGHZLUHIRULQWUDYDVFXODUPHDVXUHPHQW RIFRURQDU\DUWHU\ÁRZYHORFLW\&LUFXODWLRQ

 2ÀOL (2 /DERYLW] $- .HUQ 0- &RURQDU\ ÁRZ YHORFLW\ G\QDPLFV LQ QRUPDO DQG GLVHDVHG DUWHULHV $P - &DUGLROGG

 :KLWH&:&OLQLFDODSSOLFDWLRQVRI'RSSOHUFRURQDU\ÁRZUHVHUYHPHDVXUHPHQWV$P-&DUGLROGG  +XQGOH\ :* +DPLOWRQ &$ &ODUNH *' HW DO 9LVXDOL]DWLRQ DQG IXQFWLRQDO DVVHVVPHQW RI SUR[LPDO DQG

PLGGOHOHIWDQWHULRUGHVFHQGLQJFRURQDU\VWHQRVHVLQKXPDQVZLWKPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ&LUFXODWLRQ   6KLEDWD06DNXPD+,VDND17DNHGD.+LJJLQV&%1DNDQR7$VVHVVPHQWRIFRURQDU\ÁRZUHVHUYHZLWK IDVWFLQHSKDVHFRQWUDVWPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJFRPSDULVRQZLWKPHDVXUHPHQWE\'RSSOHUJXLGHZLUH -0DJQ5HVRQ,PDJLQJ  1DJHO(%RUQVWHGW$+XJ-6FKQDFNHQEXUJ%:HOOQKRIHU()OHFN(1RQLQYDVLYHGHWHUPLQDWLRQRIFRURQDU\ EORRGÁRZYHORFLW\ZLWKPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJFRPSDULVRQRIEUHDWKKROGDQGQDYLJDWRUWHFKQLTXHV ZLWKLQWUDYDVFXODUXOWUDVRXQG0DJQ5HVRQ0HG  .HVVOHU:0RVKDJH:*DOODQG$HWDO$VVHVVPHQWRIFRURQDU\EORRGÁRZLQKXPDQVXVLQJSKDVHGLIIHUHQFH 05LPDJLQJ&RPSDULVRQZLWKLQWUDFRURQDU\'RSSOHUÁRZPHDVXUHPHQW,QW-&DUG,PDJLQJ  /DQJHUDN 6( .XQ] 3 9OLHJHQ +: HW DO ,PSURYHG 05 ÁRZ PDSSLQJ LQ FRURQDU\ DUWHU\ E\SDVV JUDIWV

GXULQJDGHQRVLQHLQGXFHGVWUHVV5DGLRORJ\ /DQJHUDN6(.XQ]39OLHJHQ+:HWDO0DJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHÁRZPDSSLQJLQFRURQDU\DUWHU\E\SDVVJUDIWV DYDOLGDWLRQVWXG\ZLWK'RSSOHUÁRZPHDVXUHPHQWV5DGLRORJ\ ,VKLGD16DNXPD+&UX]%3HWDO0UÁRZPHDVXUHPHQWLQWKHLQWHUQDOPDPPDU\DUWHU\WRFRURQDU\DUWHU\ E\SDVVJUDIWFRPSDULVRQZLWKJUDIWVWHQRVLVDWUDGLRJUDSKLFDQJLRJUDSK\5DGLRORJ\ %HGDX[:/+RIPDQ0%9\W6/%URQ]ZDHU-*9LVVHU&$YDQ5RVVXP$&$VVHVVPHQWRIFRURQDU\DUWHU\

E\SDVV JUDIW GLVHDVH XVLQJ FDUGLRYDVFXODU PDJQHWLF UHVRQDQFH GHWHUPLQDWLRQ RI ÁRZ UHVHUYH - $P &ROO &DUGLRO +RIPDQ0%9LVVHU)&YDQ5RVVXP$&9LQN406SUHQJHU0:HVWHUKRI1,QYLYRYDOLGDWLRQRIPDJQHWLF UHVRQDQFHEORRGYROXPHÁRZPHDVXUHPHQWVZLWKOLPLWHGVSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQLQVPDOOYHVVHOV0DJQ5HVRQ 0HG 6DNXPD+6DHHG07DNHGD.HWDO4XDQWLÀFDWLRQRIFRURQDU\DUWHU\YROXPHÁRZUDWHXVLQJIDVWYHORFLW\ HQFRGHGFLQH05LPDJLQJ$-5$P-5RHQWJHQRO

/HH 96 6SULW]HU &( &DUUROO %$ HW DO )ORZ TXDQWLÀFDWLRQ XVLQJ IDVW FLQH SKDVHFRQWUDVW 05 LPDJLQJ FRQYHQWLRQDOFLQHSKDVHFRQWUDVW05LPDJLQJDQG'RSSOHUVRQRJUDSK\LQYLWURDQGLQYLYRYDOLGDWLRQ$-5 $P-5RHQWJHQRO 7DQJ&%ODWWHU''3DUNHU'/$FFXUDF\RISKDVHFRQWUDVWÁRZPHDVXUHPHQWVLQWKHSUHVHQFHRISDUWLDO YROXPHHIIHFWV-0DJQ5HVRQ,PDJLQJ 6DLWR<6DNXPD+6KLEDWD0HWDO$VVHVVPHQWRIFRURQDU\ÁRZYHORFLW\UHVHUYHXVLQJIDVWYHORFLW\HQFRGHG FLQH05,IRUQRQLQYDVLYHGHWHFWLRQRIUHVWHQRVLVDIWHUFRURQDU\VWHQWLPSODQWDWLRQ-&DUGLRYDVF0DJQ5HVRQ  /DQJHUDN6(9OLHJHQ+:-XNHPD-:HWDO9DOXHRIPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJIRUWKHQRQLQYDVLYHGHWHFWLRQ RIVWHQRVLVLQFRURQDU\DUWHU\E\SDVVJUDIWVDQGUHFLSLHQWFRURQDU\DUWHULHV&LUFXODWLRQ 5HLEHU -+ YDQ GHU =ZHW 30 .RQLQJ * HW DO $FFXUDF\ DQG SUHFLVLRQ RI TXDQWLWDWLYH GLJLWDO FRURQDU\

DUWHULRJUDSK\REVHUYHUVKRUWDQGPHGLXPWHUPYDULDELOLWLHV&DWKHW&DUGLRYDVF'LDJQ 5HLEHU-+-XNHPD:YDQ%RYHQ$YDQ+RXGW50/LH.,%UXVFKNH$9&DWKHWHUVL]HVIRUTXDQWLWDWLYH

FRURQDU\DUWHULRJUDSK\&DWKHW&DUGLRYDVF'LDJQ

%ODQG -0 $OWPDQ '* 6WDWLVWLFDO PHWKRGV IRU DVVHVVLQJ DJUHHPHQW EHWZHHQ WZR PHWKRGV RI FOLQLFDO PHDVXUHPHQW/DQFHW

 6XGKLU.+DUJUDYH9.-RKQVRQ(/HWDO0HDVXUHPHQWRIYROXPHWULFFRURQDU\EORRGÁRZZLWKD'RSSOHU

FDWKHWHUYDOLGDWLRQLQDQDQLPDOPRGHO$P+HDUW-

/DERYLW]$-$QWKRQLV'0&UDYHQV7/.HUQ0-9DOLGDWLRQRIYROXPHWULFÁRZPHDVXUHPHQWVE\PHDQVRI D'RSSOHUWLSSHGFRURQDU\DQJLRSODVW\JXLGHZLUH$P+HDUW-

.HUQ 0- 'RQRKXH 7- $JXLUUH )9 HW DO $VVHVVPHQW RI DQJLRJUDSKLFDOO\ LQWHUPHGLDWH FRURQDU\ DUWHU\ VWHQRVLVXVLQJWKH'RSSOHUÁRZLUH$P-&DUGLROGG

6HJDO - $SSOLFDWLRQV RI FRURQDU\ ÁRZ YHORFLW\ GXULQJ DQJLRSODVW\ DQG RWKHU FRURQDU\ LQWHUYHQWLRQDO SURFHGXUHV$P-&DUGLROGG

6HUUX\V 3: 'H %UX\QH % &DUOLHU 6 HW DO 5DQGRPL]HG FRPSDULVRQ RI SULPDU\ VWHQWLQJ DQG SURYLVLRQDO EDOORRQ DQJLRSODVW\ JXLGHG E\ ÁRZ YHORFLW\ PHDVXUHPHQW 'RSSOHU (QGSRLQWV %DOORRQ $QJLRSODVW\ 7ULDO (XURSH'(%$7(,,6WXG\*URXS&LUFXODWLRQ

1LVKLGD7'L0DULR&.HUQ0-HWDO,PSDFWRIÀQDOFRURQDU\ÁRZYHORFLW\UHVHUYHRQODWHRXWFRPHIROORZLQJ VWHQWLPSODQWDWLRQ(XU+HDUW-