42
Appendix 3
Category Author Type of handover Intervention Factor 1 Factor 2 Factor 3
1 Dharmadasa et al., (2014) Shift handover in maternity unit (verbal) Proforma (paper-based) + 1 Graham et al., (2013) Patient handover (verbal & written) Electronic template (electronic standalone
tools)
+ +
1 Wayne et al., (2008) Shift handover (verbal & written) Template (paper based) + +
1 Tucker, Brandling & Fox (2009)
Nursing shift handover (record) Checklist (paper based) +
1 Poh, Parasuram
&Kannusamy (2013)
Shift handover (written) Electronic tool (electronic standalone tools) +
1 Stahl et al., (2009) Handover in intensive care unit (written) Checklist (paper based) + +
1 Cheah et al., (2005) Shift handover in surgical (written) MSD embedded in electronic handover system (electronic standalone tools)
1 Abraham et al., (2012) Resident shift handover in medical intensive care unit (written)
Checklist (paper-based) + + +
1 Govier&Medcalf (2012) Handover from the week to weekend teams for medical inpatients (written)
Spreadsheet (electronic standalone tools). +
1 Ferran, Metcalfe
&O’Doherty, (2008)
Shift handover in Orthopedic Unit (verbal & written)
Proforma (paper based) + +
1 Blower et al., (2015) Surgical handover (written) Electronic template (electronic standalone tools)
43 1 Gibbons et al., (2015) Surgical handover (verbal & written) System-based standardized checklists
(electronic standalone tools)
+
1 Johnson, Sanchez &Zheng, (2016)
Nursing shift-to-shift handover (written) Electronic MDS (electronic standalone tools) + － +
1 Oroviogoicoechea et al.,
(2013)
Shift handover (written) Computerized tool for shift report (electronic standalone tools)
+ + +
2 Burton et al., (2010) Morning handover (verbal & written) Standardized procedure and Electronic template (EMR-integrated)
+
2 Malekzadeh et al., (2013) Shift handover in intensive care unit (written) Standardized protocol & minimal dataset (paper based)
+ +
2 Clark, Sindell& Koehler, (2011)
Shift handover in a general surgery residency program (verbal & written)
Standardized protocol and electronic template (EMR-integrated)
+ +
2 O’Horo et al., (2012) Shift handover (written) Electronic Clinical Sign-out system
(EMR-integrated)
+
2 Van Eaton et al., (2010) Shift handover (written) Electronic tool (EMR-integrated) － － +
3 Agarwal et al., (2012) Handover from operating room to intensive care unit (verbal)
Standardized protocol, proforma& checklist (paper based)
+ +
3 Catchpole, (2007) Handover from surgery to intensive care (verbal & written)
Standardized protocol & checklist (paper based)
+ －
3 Chen et al., (2011) Handover from the operating room to the intensive care unit (written & verbal)
Standardized protocol & checklist (paper based)
－
44 intensive care unit (verbal & written) (EMR-integrated)
3 Petrovic et al., (2012) Handover from the operating room to the intensive care unit (verbal & written)
Protocol & checklist (paper based) + －
3 Aasa, Soyland & Hansen, (2011)
Handover between ambulance personnel and emergency department (verbal & written)
Protocol & MSD (paper based) － －
3 Graan et al., (2015) Handover from the intensive care unit (ICU) to the cardiac ward (verbal & written)
Protocol & checklist (paper based) + －
3 Joy, (2011) Handover from the operating room to the
intensive care unit (verbal)
Protocol & an oral presentation script template (paper based)
+ + －
4 Degennaro et al., (2013) Between-unit handover, institution-wide (written) Electronic sign out system (EMR-integrated) + + 4 Karakaya et al., (2013) Handover from the operating room to the
intensive care unit (verbal & written)
Checklist (paper based) + +
4 Michael, Janelle & Neil (2012)
Handovers in an ambulatory care organization (written)
Standardized tool (paper based) + +
4 Bradley, (2014) Handover from the intensive care unit to the cardiac ward (written)
MDS (paper based) + +
4 Chenault et al., (2016) Handover from the operating room to the intensive care unit (verbal & written)
Electronic template (paper based) + + +
4 Ho, (2016) Handover from ICU to general ward (verbal & written)
Electronic sign-out system (electronic standalone tool)
+
4 Salzwedel et al., (2013) Handover from the operating room to the intensive care unit (verbal & written)
Checklist (paper based) + + －
4 Roberts, Putnam & Raup, (2012)
Handover between medical-surgical and progressive care nursing unit (written)
45 4 Salzwedel et al., (2015) Handover between anesthesiologist and
post-anesthesia care unit (verbal & written)
Checklist (paper based) + －
4 Randmaa et al., (2016) Handover from the operating theatre to the post-anesthesia care unit (verbal & written)
