Wandering saints : Chan eccentrics in the art and culture of Song and Yuan China
Paul, P.
Citation
Paul, P. (2009, November 3). Wandering saints : Chan eccentrics in the art and culture of
Song and Yuan China. Retrieved from https://hdl.handle.net/1887/14321Version: Not Applicable (or Unknown)
License: Licence agreement concerning inclusion of doctoral thesis in the Institutional Repository of the University of Leiden
Downloaded from: https://hdl.handle.net/1887/14321
Note: To cite this publication please use the final published version (if applicable).
QQVQVFROOFLLQVLVROORLQR
LVRLVQRQLQLLXOVX F!
QLVLVRQR"
QVRRQQVRR#VLQ$
LQRVFXOLLORV
RXRLVVL
OQLQLQVF
XQLOQVV
VRXVQ%!
QRQ%
XVVOV&
VXQO%FL
LOOROFR
QRLQQF$V
R%RV'(()
*VOQFROLFQXRRXVOLQVFQVLRFO%VFLQVQ!LV
OOR FFQLFV Q L FLRQ LVRLV LQ O% RQ &LQ' *V
+FLRQO RQ$V Q QLQ VLQV LQQQ VRXOV! O R O
%RQRXQLVROLLRXVQVRFLOLLRQVLQRX!VFQFLRQ!
QXVOLQRQXQL%RRO'
Q ,RQ Q -XQ %QVLV! VLQV OR LQR OV R
OLLRXV FXOX! XV LQ &LQ .OOV LQLLRQ'((.OO XVV /OLLRXV
FXOX0 R VFL OLLRXV +LQF V RQ V%ROLF FLLLV! Q
VRQOLLRXVQVRFLORXV!VXFV/.XLVV0!/1RLVV0!/RXO0Q
/OL0'*&QFFQLFVQLVQLRQVLQ+VQ!QVLOO
! V%ROLF FLLLV! R FRQFV VX F R RFVVV R RXFLRQ!
LLQ Q XQVQLQFRVVLRXVRXVLQ LLRQOQ RQ VRFL%'
*VX%R VFRQFV QRFVVV XQVFRV QFVVL%RR %
R FRQFL QRLRQV LQLF LFXO OLLRXV LLRQV OL$
Q R % O R R LLRQV! R LRLL2 FLQ %V R R
RV'LOOXLQVFRO+LLVRROLLRXVOLQRO!
QLQ VLQV Q L VQLRQV LQ R LQ RO! LV
Q RV R LVLF +VVLRQ' 3LFXOO%! VX% R R &Q
FFQLFVFOOQVORQ4OFLRQVR/0!/&Q0Q/&Q0'
(()RVRQ567'
((.OO6878'
6
9 RXO Q FXLQ LQ LQLQV LQ LQ$ Q FRORX! Q RQ
Q VLO$! V OO V LQ QLQV! XLQV Q VRQ VFXOXV! LVLF
VQLRQV R QLQ VLQV FOO R FRQVLLRQ R XQQO
LVVXVLQLVR%':OFLQOQLVLFLRLLVVOOVFXOXO
ROVLQLFRVLRLLV+LV!VVQLRQVXQVFRQR
LVR% R LQ ORFOLLV Q RVLLRQV' *RX XQL;X LVXO
FFLVLFVLFVL2LVVXVRRQ!VFQOLOLQVV!QLQ
FRVRQQFLRVLLQVFROOFLQ&QFQRQ!VQLRQVR
QLQ VLQV FRQ% V LVXO OL% V RLV R LVRLFO
VRQOLLV' *V VQLRQV ;XVLRQ OLL% R LF$%! X LRQ
LVLQFLRQVLQLVR%QRLXQOLORLXO'
Q LQ LVLF L! LV R VLQV LQ L LVXO
FFLVLFV LO LVO%LQ L LVXOLLV! L OLLRXV! LVLF Q
VRFLRORLFO FV' *LV XQVFRV LF XQL% R VX F! Q L
LOLVQFVVL%RVX%VQLRQVLQLQLLQFRQ XQFLRQL
FR'*XV!LVVX%RFVRLVRFFQLFVQRVVXOR
RVRLFXORVQLVV!XLFOO%!VVX FLQ,RQQ-XQ
!LQVLVRQVRFLOVXFXVFRQQFLRXVVQLRQVR
VLQV! VXF V RXFLRQ Q LLQ R LV Q L +FQ!
QVORFLRQ Q FROOFLRQ' *V VXFXV QO XV R FR VFXOX R
.XL LQ Q LLO F VL R QLQ VFROO R V RQ$ L Q
LQVFLLRQ % Q R! R FFLVLFV R +FQ Q FROOFLRQ LQ
VQQ4FQX% O% R RV R LQ4FQX% Q2RX! R 9VL$
V<XQV!FRQLXLQRXOOXQVQLQRLQLRQVRLVLVLF!
RX LV LQFLRQ L LRXV OLLRXV Q VRFLO RXV' V R
FFQLFV % Q FL LQ VOO FLFOV R LV! V XF V %
R FVRFRQOLRQRLFLFOVRRV!LRQLOOXVLRQVLQ
1RLV O! R QLFLO LLV LQ .XLV OV RQ QLQV Q
VFXOXVRQ%OLLRXVVVRFLLRQV'QQLRQQR&QO!
LV R VLQV LQF L RQ$V Q O% LV! LO LQ -XQ
$QLQ=XRFL>Q!%FFROOFRVLV!QLQ+LLLRQVR
?QLQLQR%!%$OVVVFFO'*VVXOVQFRX
VX% R FRO LVLF +LQF R R V LQ &LQ! VXF V
RLVRLVRLFOVRQVQOQVFV'
*FRQFRFFQLFVQOQ%R&QRLVLQQLQV!
QLV+FLRQOLQVLQVLQV$QRVQRFLQQ%RLLRQ'*
,RQQ-XQ&QVOLVQQFQLQVLQVVLVVLLXOOL
LQ ! + Q FLF' * RVLLRQ R VLQV LQ &Q QRQ Q L
QLQ&Q+VQLVLQFRLVLLRQVLVLQFL;XOL%
R ;XVLRQLQ VRFLO QRV' @ FRXV! LV V R XQL;XO% &Q LLRQV
VXFVVFVV!QR&QVQFRLVFFQLFLFV!XLLVRV
RLQQLQVOLVQVQLRQRQLQVLQV!RVQVFQ
RXQRXRX&QFQRQ!QRVLVO!RXLLVXO
FFLVLFV!Q+FOXVLLQVLQLV$LQRVRQOL%'
Q RQ VFROVL! &Q ;XVLRQV RQ Q LQ V
RQRXQF XQV!VXOLQLQRXOLQLLRQRLVLLRQVRQ
LVFV+VQLV'&RQV;XQO%!,RQ&QQLRQR+VQV
QVVLQRQLRQR&QVOLVQ':FQVXLV
FRQLF LV % XLQ OLLRXV FLF LQ &Q VOLVQ
VQLFOO%LQRLQR.XLVOV'9OVR!VVXLV
FR R L ,RQ %QV% V &QV /AROQ 90' *LV VF
FRQLXVRORQ%RRVLQQLROLRQVLQ
Q &Q' RV VR QR % XROLQ FR% R /&Q 0! X RX
VL2LQ V R LQVLLQ FQLQ QX R OLRQVL
Q&QQ'
&Q RV QFRL! +V LQVFL RQ RLV R QLQ VLQV!
V$VRQVFOLVR&QVXQL;XXQVQLQR'*VVQV
VR L LV FRQFQ L QRLRQV R /L0 Q /OL$QVV0' BX!
XVV R R FV LQ &Q RQVLV! LQFOXLQ XVV R LV R FFQLFV! VR
LO% LQ LVXOLLV Q FRQFRLQ FLFV R LLQ! FROOFLRQ Q
QLRQ' BR LQVQF! LO RO% =RQ$ V RVL LQ R R
LQVV% V!RL R FFQLF1R L VQ Q
OO VVRFL L RQ R LV OQV LQ >LQFL O' *LV LV LQF R
&QVFLLFOQLRQRLVXO+LQF!QLVQLXOLRQRLVLRQ'
=RVLRQO%!VX%RR&QVOLVQVFLV&Q
VLFLORLVXOFLFLQFRQLQXRXVFRXQLFLRQLRROVR
LQ &LQ' * R QLQ VLQVFL% RLVV RF
RXLLVLQFLLQLQQF$RXQRLVLO'*LVQ
5
L! Q! FROOF Q LQ LQ RVVLO% L FLFOV R
RQVLFQO%LV'*LVLQLV+ORLRQR&QRQVLVVFQVR
FROOFLRQQFLFXOLRQ!QRFRQLXLRQVR&QVOLVQR
OLLRQQLQ&LQ'