• No results found

Verblijftijd in de bodem en grondwateraanvulling van water uit het Landelijk (LMG) en de Provinciale Meetnetten Grondwaterkwaliteit (PMG)

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "Verblijftijd in de bodem en grondwateraanvulling van water uit het Landelijk (LMG) en de Provinciale Meetnetten Grondwaterkwaliteit (PMG)"

Copied!
43
0
0

Bezig met laden.... (Bekijk nu de volledige tekst)

Hele tekst

(1)

'LWRQGHU]RHNZHUGYHUULFKWLQRSGUDFKWHQWHQODVWHYDQKHW'LUHFWRUDDW*HQHUDDO0LOLHXEHKHHUYDQKHW 0LQLVWHULHYDQ9RONVKXLVYHVWLQJ5XLPWHOLMNH2UGHQLQJHQ0LOLHXEHKHHU'LUHFWLH%RGHP:DWHUHQ/DQGHOLMN *HELHG SURMHFWQXPPHU0RQLWRULQJHQ'LDJQRVHJURQGZDWHU0$30,/,(8 5LMNVLQVWLWXXWYRRU9RONVJH]RQGKHLGHQ0LOLHX 5,90 3RVWEXV%$%LOWKRYHQ WHOHIRRQID[ 5,90UDSSRUW 5HLVWLMGHQLQGHERGHPHQDDQYXOOLQJYDQKHW JURQGZDWHUXLWKHW/DQGHOLMN0HHWQHW /0* HQGH 3URYLQFLDOH0HHWQHWWHQ*URQGZDWHUNZDOLWHLW 30* &50HLQDUGL

(2)

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

(3)

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

(4)

SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW

,

1+28'  ,1/(,',1*   75,7,80,11((56/$*(1*521':$7(59$11('(5/$1'   '(3529,1&,(6'5(17+(*521,1*(1(1)5,(6/$1'  ,1'(/,1*,1'((/*(%,('(1922530*'5(17+(  1225''5(17+(  =8,':(67'5(17+(  =8,'2267'5(17+(  29(5=,&+79$1'(5(68/7$7(1922530*'5(17+(  2267*521,1*(1  '()5,(6(:28'(1  '(3529,1&,(6*(/'(5/$1'29(5,-66(/(1875(&+7   ,1'(/,1*,1'((/*(%,('(1922530**(/'(5/$1'  '($&+7(5+2(.  +(72267*(/'(563/$7($8  '(,-66(/9$//(,  '(9(/8:(  '(*(/'(56(9$//(,  20*(9,1*9$11,-0(*(1  29(5=,&+79$1'(5(68/7$7(1922530**(/'(5/$1'  1225'29(5,-66(/  6$//$1'  &(175$$/29(5,-66(/  7:(17(  2267875(&+7(1+(7*22,  '(3529,1&,(61225'%5$%$17(1/,0%85*   ,1'(/,1*,1'((/*(%,('(1922530*1225'%5$%$17  +(7=$1'*(%,('9$11225':(67%5$%$17  '(0(,(5(,9$1'(1%26&+  '(.(03(1  '(1225'(/,-.(3((/  '(5(68/7$7(19$1+(730*1225'%5$%$17  1225'(10,''(1/,0%85*=8,'(/,-.(3((/  '8,1(1*((67*521'(1(1:$''(1(,/$1'(1  '(30*3877(1,1'(3529,1&,(=8,'+2//$1'  /0**(*(9(169$1'(+2//$1'6('8,1(1  '(=((8:6('8,1(1  /0**(*(9(169$1'(:$''(1(,/$1'(1  29(5=,&+79$1'(5(68/7$7(192259,(53529,1&,(6 

(5)

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

 ,QOHLGLQJ

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œ :DDUJHQRPHQFRQFHQWUDWLHVYDQGLYHUVHVWRIIHQLQKHWJURQGZDWHU œ 0RJHOLMNHSURFHVVHQLQGHERGHPGLHQDDVWGHUHLVWLMGHQHHQUROKHEEHQJHVSHHOG œ &RQFHQWUDWLHVYDQVWRIIHQLQRQEHODVWJURQGZDWHU +HWGRHOYDQKHWRQGHU]RHNZDVRPGHUHLVWLMGHQYDQKHWJURQGZDWHULQGHERGHPYDQGH ]DQGJHELHGHQYDQ1HGHUODQGYDVWWHVWHOOHQ(HQPHWKRGHGDDUYRRULVGHLQWHUSUHWDWLHYDQGH WULWLXP + FRQFHQWUDWLHVLQKHWJURQGZDWHUGLHJHPHWHQ]LMQLQGHSXWWHQYDQKHWODQGHOLMN PHHWQHWJURQGZDWHUNZDOLWHLW /0* HQYDQGHSURYLQFLDOHPHHWQHWWHQ 30* 'LHJHJHYHQV ]LMQJHEUXLNWYRRUHHQEHSDOLQJYDQGHUHLVWLMGHQLQGHERGHPYDQKHWEHPRQVWHUGHZDWHU 'HUHLVWLMGHQYDQKHWJURQGZDWHUXLWGHILOWHUV YDQKHW/0*]LMQHHUGHUJHw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

(6)

SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW 'HDDQYXOOLQJYDQKHWJURQGZDWHUGLHXLWGHEHSDOLQJYDQGHUHLVWLMGHQYROJWLVRS]LFK]HOI YDQEHODQJRPGDWKHWGHPRWRULVYRRUGHYHUGHUHVWURPLQJYDQKHWZDWHUHQGHHULQRSJHORVWH VWRIIHQ'H]HHLJHQVFKDSYRUPWHFKWHUWHYHQVHHQFRQWUROHRSGHXLWNRPVWHQRPGDWGLHRRN RSDQGHUHPDQLHUHQNXQQHQZRUGHQEHQDGHUG'HDDQYXOOLQJYDQKHWYHU]DGLJGHJURQGZDWHU ,LQPPD PDJQDPHOLMNQLHWJURWHU]LMQGDQKHWQHHUVODJRYHUVFKRW+HWQHHUVODJRYHUVFKRW LVJHOLMNDDQQHHUVODJ 3 PLQGHZHUNHOLMNHHYDSRWUDQVSLUDWLH(D PPD ZDDUELM(DYROJWXLW GHSRWHQWLsOHYHUGDPSLQJ(SPLQGHYHUGDPSLQJVUHGXFWLH'HYHUGHOLQJYDQ3HQ(SRYHU 1HGHUODQGLVEHNHQGXLWPHWLQJHQ .10, HQXLWK\GURORJLVFKHVWXGLHV 0HLQDUGL  5HGXFWLHVYDQGHYHUGDPSLQJWUHGHQRSLQGURJHSHULRGHQDOVGHERGHPKHWEHQRGLJGHZDWHU QLHWNDQOHYHUHQ'HODQJMDULJJHPLGGHOGHDDQYXOOLQJYDQKHWJURQGZDWHUZRUGWGDDUGRRU JURWHU'HJURRWWHYDQGHUHGXFWLHYDQGHSRWHQWLsOHHYDSRWUDQVSLUDWLH 5(' NDQZRUGHQ JHVFKDWPHWEHKXOSYDQGH+(/37DEHOOHQ :HUNJURHS+(/3 'HUHGHQZDDURPGH DDQYXOOLQJYDQKHWJURQGZDWHUVRPVNOHLQHULVGDQKHWQHHUVODJRYHUVFKRWLVGDWHHQGHHOYDQ GHQHHUVODJ $) RYHURIGLUHFWRQGHUKHWPDDLYHOGNDQDIVWURPHQQDDUGHVORWHQ'H]H RSSHUYODNNLJHGUDLQDJHYDQKHWQHHUVODJRYHUVFKRWGUDDJWQLHWELMDDQGHDDQYXOOLQJYDQKHW GLHSHUHJURQGZDWHU9RRUGHJURQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJSHUSXWJHOGWGDDURPVWHHGV , 3(S5('±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

(7)

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

 7ULWLXPLQQHHUVODJHQJURQGZDWHUYDQ1HGHUODQG

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œ 1HHUVODJJHZRJHQMDDUJHPLGGHOGHFRQFHQWUDWLHVYHUWRQHQHHQUHJHOPDWLJYHUORRS œ 'HFRQFHQWUDWLHVQHPHQWRHYDQDIGHNXVWQDDUKHWELQQHQODQG UHJLRQDOHWUHQG  œ ,QGHPDDQGJHPLGGHOGHFRQFHQWUDWLHVLVHHQVHL]RHQVIOXFWXDWLHZDDUWHQHPHQ WULWLXPLQQHHUVODJWH*URQLQJHQUHIHUHQWLHGDWXP           MDUHQ 7 8 )LJ1HHUVODJJHZRJHQMDDUJHPLGGHOGHWULWLXPFRQFHQWUDWLHVLQQHHUVODJWH*URQLQJHQ

(8)

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s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

(9)

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ WULWLXPLQQHHUVODJWH:HVW1RRUGEUDEDQWUHIHUHQWLHGDWXP                                                            MDDU 78 )LJ 1HHUVODJJHZRJHQHQMDDUJHPLGGHOGHWULWLXPFRQFHQWUDWLHVLQGHQHHUVODJYDQ :HVW1RRUGEUDEDQWYRRUHHQJHJHYHQUHIHUHQWLHGDWXP 8LWJDQJVSXQWHQYRRUGHLQWHUSUHWDWLHYDQGHPHWLQJHQLQGHPRQVWHUVXLWGH30*]LMQ œ 1HHUVODJJHZRJHQMDDUJHPLGGHOGHFRQFHQWUDWLHVLQGHQHHUVODJYRUPHQGHEDVLV œ (ULVJHHQUHNHQLQJJHKRXGHQPHWDDQULMNLQJGRRURSHQZDWHUYHUGDPSLQJ LQWHUFHSWLH  œ 'HUHJLRQDOHWUHQGLVJHOLMNDDQGHWUHQG]RDOVDDQJHJHYHQLQ 0HLQDUGL  œ 'HUHLVWLMGYDQKHWZDWHULQGHRQYHU]DGLJGH]RQHEHGUDDJWRQJHYHHUMDDU œ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ppQEHSDDOGHSXWEHUHNHQGHZDDUGHQPRHWHQRYHUHHQNRPHQ

(10)

SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW

(11)

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

 'HSURYLQFLHV'UHQWKH*URQLQJHQHQ)ULHVODQG

,QGHOLQJLQGHHOJHELHGHQYRRU30*'UHQWKH

+HWJURRWVWHGHHOYDQGHSXWWHQYDQKHWSURYLQFLDOHPHHWQHWLQ'UHQWKH )LJ LVLQKHWQDMDDU YDQEHPRQVWHUGYRRUHHQEHSDOLQJYDQGH+FRQFHQWUDWLHPDDUHQNHOHSXWWHQRRNLQ KHWPLGGHQYDQ+HWJHELHGLVRSJHGHHOGLQ1RRUG=XLGZHVWHQ=XLGRRVW'UHQWKHRS EDVLVYDQYHUVFKLOOHQLQGHVLWXDWLH%RGHPRSERXZQHHUVODJHQYHUGDPSLQJNXQQHQLQGLH JHELHGHQYHUVFKLOOHQ6WRUHQGHODJHQLQGHRQGLHSHERGHPNXQQHQRSSHUYODNNLJHDIVWURPLQJ YHURRU]DNHQGLHQLHWELMGUDDJWDDQGHDDQYXOOLQJYDQKHWJURQGZDWHU,QJURWHGHOHQYDQ 'UHQWKHNRPWNHLOHHPYRRULQGHRQGLHSHERGHP'DDUQDDVWNRPWLQGHRQGLHSHERGHPYDQ GHJHKHOHSURYLQFLHYULMYDDNEHHNOHHPYRRUZDWHHQ]HOIGHHIIHFWNDQYHURRU]DNHQ'HVRPV KHU]LHQHLQWHUSUHWDWLHYDQGHZDDUQHPLQJHQLQGH/0*SXWWHQ 0HLQDUGL LVVWHHGV HHUVWJHJHYHQHQGDDUQDYROJWGHLQWHUSUHWDWLHYDQGHWULWLXPFRQFHQWUDWLHVXLW30*'UHQWKH

1RRUG'UHQWKH

+HWGHHOJHELHG1RRUG'UHQWKHRPYDWUXZZHJKHWGHHOYDQGHSURYLQFLHGDWWHQQRRUGHQYDQ $VVHQOLJW )LJ ,QKHWJHELHGNRPWYHHONHLOHHPYRRURSHHQGLHSWHYDQFDWRWP RQGHUPDDLYHOG,QKHWJHELHGZRUGWODQGERXZEHGUHYHQHQRRN]LMQJHELHGHQPHWQDWXXUOLMNH YHJHWDWLHDDQZH]LJ ERXZODQGJUDV JUDVODQGERV QDWXXUOLMNHYHJHWDWLHLQGHWDEHOOHQ  9RRUGHLQWHUSUHWDWLHJHJHYHQLQGH7DEHOOHQHQHQLQ)LJLVDDQJHKRXGHQ JHPLGGHOGHQHHUVODJRYHU 3 PPD

JHPLGGHOGHUHIHUHQWLHJHZDVYHUGDPSLQJ (U PPD GLHSWHYDQGHK\GURORJLVFKHEDVLV ' P

7DEHO7ULWLXPZDDUQHPLQJHQLQ/0*SXWWHQ1RRUG'UHQWKHPHWLQJHQLQ I ERYHQVWHILOWHU I PLGGHOVWHILOWHUI RQGHUVWHILOWHU

/0* SODDWV ODQGJHEUXLN I I ,S , I I

QU 78 78 PD PPD UHLVWLMG D

 ODQJHOR ERV  I     I

 VFKLSERUJ JUDV        DPHQ JUDV        ]HLMHQ RQEHNHQG        VPLOGH JUDV    GHJURHYH JUDV        GHSXQW JUDV       'HLQWHUSUHWDWLHYDQ30*LVJHJHYHQLQ7DEHO'HGLNWHYDQGHGRRUVWURRPGHODDJ ] LV JHOLMNDDQGHJHPLGGHOGHGLHSWHYDQKHWILOWHURQGHUPDDLYHOGPLQP RQYHU]DGLJGH]RQH  'HJURQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJYROJWXLWGHYHUJHOLMNLQJYDQ+RRIGVWXNZDDULQ]GH GRRUVWURRPGHGLHSWHHQWGHWRWDOHUHLVWLMGPLQMDDULV'HJURQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJLVJHJHYHQ LQ)LJ$OVGHPHWLQJKHWGLHSVWHILOWHUEHWUHIWNDQGHZDDUGHYDQGHDDQYXOOLQJGLHYRRUKHW RQGLHSHILOWHULVEHSDDOGZRUGHQJHEUXLNWRPGHUHLVWLMGYRRUKHWGLHSVWHILOWHUWHEHUHNHQHQ ,Q1RRUG'UHQWKHLVGHJURQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJYDDNNOHLQHUGDQKHWQHHUVODJRYHUVFKRW]RDOV EOLMNWXLWGHZDDUGHQYDQGHJHPLGGHOGHDDQYXOOLQJHQKHWSRWHQWLsOHQHHUVODJRYHUVFKRW(HQ GHHOYDQGHQHHUVODJ]DOGXVRSSHUYODNNLJDIVWURPHQ

(12)

SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW

7DEHO ,QWHUSUHWDWLHWULWLXPFRQFHQWUDWLHV30*1RRUG'UHQWKHQDMDDU

] GLNWHGRRUVWURRPGHODDJ, JURQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJS SRURVLWHLW

30* ODQGJHEUXLN I I I I ,S , I I QU ] P ] P 78 78 PD PPD UHLVWLMG D  ERXZODQG          JUDV      JUDV    ERXZODQG          ERXZODQG         JUDV          ERXZODQG          JUDV    ERXZODQG      ERXZODQG          JUDV      ERXZODQG      JUDV       JUDV          ERV          ERXZODQG          ERV          ERXZODQG          ERXZODQG         *HPLGGHOGHZDDUGHQEHUHNHQGXLW7DEHO]LMQ ERVHQQDWXXU 3(S PPD ,JHP PPD 3(S,JHP PPD ERXZODQG 3(S PPD ,JHP PPD 3(S,JHP PPD JUDVODQG 3(S PPD ,JHP PPD 3(S,JHP PPD *URQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJLQ'UHQWKHQRRUG                                                                                  ERVHQQDWXXUDNNHUERXZJUDV QXP PHUYDQGH30*SXW P P D  )LJ*URQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJELMGH30*SXWWHQLQ1RRUG'UHQWKH

=XLGZHVW'UHQWKH

'HERGHPYDQ=XLGZHVW'UHQWKHYHUWRRQWYHHOJHOLMNHQLVPHW1RRUG'UHQWKHEHKDOYHGDWGH EDVLVYDQGHDTXLIHUGLHSHUOLJW9RRUGHLQWHUSUHWDWLH)LJLVDDQJHKRXGHQ JHPLGGHOGHQHHUVODJRYHU 3 PPD JHPLGGHOGHUHIHUHQWLHJHZDVYHUGDPSLQJ (U PPD GLHSWHYDQGHK\GURORJLVFKHEDVLV ' P

(13)

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ %LMGHZDDUQHPLQJHQLQ=XLGZHVW'UHQWKH]LMQGH]HOIGHSURFHGXUHVJHYROJGDOVYRRU1RRUG 'UHQWKH(HQYHUVFKLOLVGDWLQ=XLGZHVW'UHQWKHHHQDDQWDOSXWWHQLQEHERXZGJHELHG ³EHERXZG´LQ7DEHO LVJHSODDWVW9RRUORSLJPDJZRUGHQDDQJHQRPHQGDWKHWEHERXZGH JHELHGLQK\GURORJLVFKRS]LFKWQLHWYHHODI]DOZLMNHQYDQJUDVODQG9HUGHU]LMQLQ=XLGZHVW 'UHQWKHGHWULWLXPFRQFHQWUDWLHVLQEHLGHILOWHUVHHQDDQWDOPDOHQ]RODDJGDWJHHQEHSDOLQJ YDQGHUHLVWLMGHQPRJHOLMNLV'H]HSXWWHQVWDDQZHOOLFKWLQHHQNZHO]RQHZDDUKHWJURQGZDWHU QLHWZRUGWDDQJHYXOG ]LHRRN)LJ  7DEHO7ULWLXPZDDUQHPLQJHQLQ/0*SXWWHQ=XLGZHVW'UHQWKHPHWLQJHQLQ I ERYHQVWHILOWHU I PLGGHOVWHILOWHU I RQGHUVWHILOWHU

/0* SODDWV ODQGJHEUXLN I I ,S , I I QU 78 78 PD PPD UHLVWLMG D  GROGHUVXP ERV        YHOGKXL]HQ JUDV        HHPVWHU JUDV        KRRJHYHHQ RQEHNHQG        EHQGHUVH JUDV        ZHHUZLOOH JUDV    DOWHYHHU JUDV        GDUS JUDV       7DEHO ,QWHUSUHWDWLHWULWLXPFRQFHQWUDWLHV30*=XLGZHVW'UHQWKHQDMDDU

] GLNWHGRRUVWURRPGHODDJ, JURQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJS SRURVLWHLW

30* ODQGJHEUXLN I I I I ,S , I I QU ] P ] P 78 78 PD PPD UHLVWLMG D  ERXZODQG          EHERXZG          EHERXZG          JUDV     JUDV          JUDV    JUDV          ERV        EHERXZG          JUDV          JUDV         JUDV          JUDV          JUDV          JUDV          ERXZODQG          ERXZODQG          ERV          ERV          ERV          ERV          JUDV         JUDV  

(14)

SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW *URQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJLQ'UHQWKHZHVW          EHERXZGERVHQQDWXXUDNNHUERXZJUDV QXPPHUYDQGH30*SXW P P D  )LJ*URQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJELMGH30*SXWWHQLQ=XLGZHVW'UHQWKH ,Q=XLGZHVW'UHQWKHLVGHJURQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJYDDN YHHO NOHLQHUGDQGHZDDUGHYDQ3(S GRRUGDWVRPVHHQGHHOYDQGHQHHUVODJRSSHUYODNNLJDIVWURRPW8LW7DEHOYROJW EHERXZG 3(S PPD ,JHP PPD 3(S,JHP PPD ERVHQQDWXXU 3(S PPD ,JHP PPD 3(S,JHP PPD ERXZODQG 3(S PPD ,JHP PPD 3(S,JHP PPD JUDVODQG 3(S PPD ,JHP PPD 3(S,JHP PPD

=XLGRRVW'UHQWKH

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

/0* SODDWV  ODQG I I ,S , I I QU JHEUXLN 78 78 PD PPD UHLVWLMG D  JLHWHUYHHQ JUDVODQG    VFKRRQORR ERV        H[ORR ERXZODQG        GUPRQG ERXZODQG        EDUJHU C ERXZODQG    QZDPVW ERXZODQG        ZHVWHQHV JUDVODQG    NOLMQGLMN JUDVODQG        ]ZHHORR JUDVODQG        ZLMVWHU JUDVODQG    GDOHQ JUDVODQG        ]ZDUWHPHHU ERV  

(15)

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sOHYHUGDPSLQJGRRUGDWHHQUHGXFWLHYDQ GHYHUGDPSLQJRSWUHHGWGLHYROJHQVGH+(/3WDEHOOHQRQJHYHHUPPDNDQEHGUDJHQ+HW YHUVFKLOOLMNWJURRWWH]LMQYRRUERXZODQGPDDUGDWLVPLVVFKLHQVFKLMQRPGDWGHJHPLGGHOGH EHJURHLLQJYDQKHWDOVERXZODQGDDQJHJHYHQODQGYHUPRHGHOLMNRYHUZHJHQGJUDVODQGLV 7DEHO ,QWHUSUHWDWLHWULWLXPFRQFHQWUDWLHV30*=XLGRRVW'UHQWKHQDMDDU

] GLNWHGRRUVWURRPGHODDJ, JURQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJS SRURVLWHLW

30* ODQGJHEUXLN I I I I ,S , I I QU ] P ] P 78 78 PD PPD UHLVWLMG D  ERXZODQG          ERXZODQG     ERXZODQG          ERV          ERXZODQG          ERXZODQG        ERXZODQG          ERXZODQG     ERXZODQG          EHERXZG          JUDV          ERXZODQG      JUDV    JUDV          JUDV          EHERXZG          ERXZODQG          ERXZODQG          ERXZODQG         JUDV         'HJHPLGGHOGHZDDUGHQYRRU=XLGRRVW'UHQWKHYDQDDQYXOOLQJHQQHHUVODJRYHUVFKRW]LMQ EHERXZG 3(S PPD ,JHP PPD 3(S,JHP PPD ERVHQQDWXXU 3(S PPD ,JHP PPD 3(S,JHP PPD ERXZODQG 3(S PPD ,JHP PPD 3(S,JHP PPD JUDVODQG 3(S PPD ,JHP PPD 3(S,JHP PPD

(16)

SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW *URQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJLQ'UHQWKHRRVW                                                                                          EHERXZGERVDNNHUERXZJUDV QXP PHUYDQGH30*SXW P P D  )LJ*URQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJELMGH30*SXWWHQLQ=XLGRRVW'UHQWKH

2YHU]LFKWYDQGHUHVXOWDWHQYRRU30*'UHQWKH

9RRUGHKHOHSURYLQFLH]LMQJHJHYHQVEHVFKLNEDDUXLWILOWHUVLQSXWWHQYDQKHW30* 9RRUSXWWHQZDVJHHQLQWHUSUHWDWLHPRJHOLMN9HUPRHGHOLMN]LMQGH]HSXWWHQJHSODDWVWLQ JURQGZDWHUZDDULQRSZDDUWVHVWURPLQJRSWUHHGW]RGDWKHWHHQ YHHO ODQJHUHUHLVWLMGGDQ MDDULQGHERGHPKHHIWJHKDG9RRUGHILOWHUVLQ1RRUGHQ=XLGZHVW'UHQWKHZDDUHHQ EHSDOLQJYDQGHUHLVWLMGPRJHOLMNZDVEOHHNGDWGHJHVFKDWWHDDQYXOOLQJYDQKHWJURQGZDWHU LQYHHOJHYDOOHQODJHUZDVGDQGHSRWHQWLsOHDDQYXOOLQJ'HSRWHQWLsOHDDQYXOOLQJLVJHOLMNDDQ KHWYHUVFKLOWXVVHQGHJHPLGGHOGHQHHUVODJHQGHSRWHQWLsOHJHZDVYHUGDPSLQJ]RDOVEHSDDOG XLWJHJHYHQVYDQKHW.10,HQKHWODQGJHEUXLN 0HLQDUGL 'HZHUNHOLMNHDDQYXOOLQJLV YDDNJURWHUDOVJHHQRSSHUYODNNLJHDIYRHURSWUHHGWRPGDWLQGURJHMDUHQGHYHUGDPSLQJZRUGW JHUHGXFHHUGGRRUYRFKWWHNRUWHQLQGHERGHP :HUNJURHS+(/3 'LWYHUVFKLMQVHO EOLMNWXLWGHUHVXOWDWHQYRRU=XLGRRVW'UHQWKHZDDUGHXLW+PHWLQJHQJHVFKDWWHDDQYXOOLQJ YDDNHQLJHWLHQWDOOHQPPDJURWHULVGDQGHSRWHQWLs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wVODQGLVGDWLQDQGHUH YHHOODQJHUH WLMGHQDOVJUDVODQGZRUGWJHEUXLNW'HJHPLGGHOGHDDQYXOOLQJYDQKHWJURQGZDWHUGLHXLWGH PHWLQJHQNDQZRUGHQDIJHOHLGLVRSGHODQJMDULJJHPLGGHOGHEHJURHLLQJJHEDVHHUG'H JHFRQVWDWHHUGHYHUVFKLOOHQ]LMQQLHWYHURQWUXVWHQGDDQJH]LHQKHWDOJHPHQHEHHOGYDQ DDQYXOOLQJHQVWURPLQJYDQKHWJURQGZDWHULQ'UHQWKHEOLMIWJHOGHQ

(17)

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

2RVW*URQLQJHQ

9RRUGH30*SXWWHQLQGHSURYLQFLH*URQLQJHQ]LMQJHHQWULWLXPPHWLQJHQEHVFKLNEDDUPDDU ZHOYDQ/0* 7DEHO 'HYROJHQGHJHPLGGHOGHZDDUGHQ]LMQDDQJHKRXGHQ JHPLGGHOGHQHHUVODJRYHU 3 PPD JHPLGGHOGHUHIHUHQWLHJHZDVYHUGDPSLQJ (U PPD GLHSWHYDQGHK\GURORJLVFKHEDVLV ' P 7DEHO7ULWLXPZDDUQHPLQJHQLQ/0*SXWWHQ2RVW*URQLQJHQPHWLQJHQLQ I ERYHQVWHILOWHU I PLGGHOVWHILOWHUI RQGHUVWHILOWHU

/0* SODDWV  ODQG I I ,S , I I

QU JHEUXLN 78 78 PD PPD UHLVWLMG D

 WHUDSHO ERXZODQG      

 VHOOLQJHQ ERXZODQG      

 PXVVHONDQDDO ERXZODQG      

 VWDGVNDQDDO ERXZODQG   I     I

 RPPHOZLMN ERXZODQG    RXGHSHNHOD ERXZODQG        YHHOHUYHHQ ERXZODQG        IURRPERVFK ERXZODQG        RQQHQ JUDVODQG        JURQLQJHQ JUDVODQG        KHLQHEXUHQ ERXZODQG"        RXGH]LMO RQEHNHQG    VFKDUPHU ERXZODQG  

'H)ULHVH:RXGHQ

2RNYRRUGH30*SXWWHQLQGHSURYLQFLH)ULHVODQG]LMQJHHQWULWLXPPHWLQJHQEHVFKLNEDDU :DDUGHQDDQJHKRXGHQELMGHLQWHUSUHWDWLHYDQGH/0*PHWLQJHQ 7DEHO ]LMQ JHPLGGHOGHQHHUVODJRYHU 3 PPD JHPLGGHOGHUHIHUHQWLHJHZDVYHUGDPSLQJ (U PPD GLHSWHYDQGHK\GURORJLVFKHEDVLV ' P 7DEHO7ULWLXPZDDUQHPLQJHQLQ/0*SXWWHQ)ULHVH:RXGHQPHWLQJHQLQ I ERYHQVWHILOWHU I PLGGHOVWHILOWHUI RQGHUVWHILOWHU

/0* SODDWV ODQG I I ,S , I I I QU JHEUXLN 78 78 PD PPD UHLVWLMG D  PXUPHUZRXGH JUDVODQG    KHHUHQYHHQ EHERXZG        EHUJXP JUDVODQG        EXLWHQSRVW JUDVODQG        KRRJ]DQG JUDVODQG        RUDQMHZRXG ERV        EHHWVWHU]ZDDJ ERV        EDNNHYHHQ JUDVODQG        RXGHKRUQH JUDVODQG        DSSHOVFKD ERV        RXGHPLUGXP JUDVODQG        VSDQQHQEXUJ JUDVODQG    QLMHKROWSDGH JUDVODQG      

(18)

SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW

(19)

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

 'HSURYLQFLHV*HOGHUODQG2YHULMVVHOHQ8WUHFKW

,QGHOLQJLQGHHOJHELHGHQYRRU30**HOGHUODQG

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

'H$FKWHUKRHN

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

/0* SODDWV  ODQG I I ,S , I I

QU JHEUXLN 78 78 PD PPD UHLVWLMG D

 JRUVVHO ERV      

 KDUIVHQ JUDVODQG   I     I

 ODUHQ ERV        ZDUQVYHOG JUDVODQG        NH\HQE ERXZODQG        YHOGKRHN ERV        YRUGHQ ERV        UXXUOR EHERXZG        HLEHUJHQ JUDVODQG        OLHYHOGH JUDVODQG        LM]HUOR JUDVODQG        KHHOZHJ JUDVODQG        JDDQGHUHQ JUDVODQG        OHQJHO ERXZODQG        KXPPHOR ERXZODQG        GLGDP EHERXZG        DQJHUOR RQEHNHQG        QRRUGGLMN JUDVODQG      

(20)

SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW

7DEHO ,QWHUSUHWDWLHWULWLXPFRQFHQWUDWLHV30*'H$FKWHUKRHNPHGLR

] GLNWHGRRUVWURRPGHODDJ, JURQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJS SRURVLWHLW

30* ODQG I I I I I I ,S , I I I QU JHEU ] P ] P ] P 78 78 78 PD PPD UHLVWLMG D  EHE             EHE             EHE             ERV             ERV             ERV          ERV          EZO             EZO             EZO             JUDV           JUDV             JUDV           ,QGH$FKWHUKRHNLVGHDDQYXOOLQJYDQKHWJURQGZDWHUPHHVWDOJURWHUGDQ3(SGRRUGDWHHQ UHGXFWLHYDQGHHYDSRWUDQVSLUDWLHRSWUHHGWLQGURJHSHULRGHQ9ROJHQVGH+(/3WDEHOOHQ]DO GHJHPLGGHOGHUHGXFWLHYDQGHYHUGDPSLQJRQJHYHHUPPDEHGUDJHQHQGDWNRPWJRHG RYHUHHQPHWGHJHFRQVWDWHHUGHYHUVFKLOOHQ )LJ 'HRSSHUYODNNLJHDIYRHU]DOGDDURP JHULQJ]LMQ'HDIZLMNHQGHZDDUGHQYRRUEZO]LMQPLVVFKLHQVFKLMQGRRUGDWKHWGDDUELMYDDN RPWLMGHOLMNPDLVODQGJDDWGDWJHPLGGHOGRYHUZHJHQGXLWJUDVODQGEHVWDDW*HPLGGHOGH ZDDUGHQYRRUGH$FKWHUKRHNYDQGHDDQYXOOLQJHQKHWQHHUVODJRYHUVFKRW]LMQ EHERXZG 3(S PPD ,JHP PPD 3(S,JHP PPD ERVHQQDWXXU 3(S PPD ,JHP PPD 3(S,JHP PPD ERXZODQG 3(S PPD ,JHP PPD 3(S,JHP PPD JUDVODQG 3(S PPD ,JHP PPD 3(S,JHP PPD *URQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJLQGH$FKWHUKRHN                                                                                    EHERXZGERVHQQDWXXUDNNHUERXZJUDV QXPPHUYDQGH30*SXW P P D  )LJ*URQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJELMGH30*SXWWHQLQGH$FKWHUKRHN

+HW2RVW*HOGHUV3ODWHDX

'HGLNWHYDQGHGRRUVWURRPGHERGHPLV]HHUZLVVHOHQGYRRUKHW2RVW*HOGHUV3ODWHDXPDDU RYHUKHWDOJHPHHQNOHLQHUGDQP+LHUGRRU]LMQGHGLHSWHQYDQGHILOWHUVYDQGH30* SXWWHQDIZLMNHQGWHQRS]LFKWHYDQRYHULJ*HOGHUODQG'HGLHSVWHILOWHUVRQWEUHNHQPHHVWDO,Q

(21)

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ GH]HERGHPLVVRPVHHQVWRUHQGHODDJDDQZH]LJ NHLOHHP ZDDUPHHYHUGHUJHHQUHNHQLQJLV JHKRXGHQ9RRUGHLQWHUSUHWDWLHYDQGHJHJHYHQV 7DEHO LVDDQJHKRXGHQ JHPLGGHOGHMDDUQHHUVODJRYHU PPD JHPLGGHOGHUHIHUHQWLHJHZDVYHUGDPSLQJ PPD GLHSWHYDQGHK\GURORJLVFKHEDVLV P 7DEHO ,QWHUSUHWDWLHWULWLXPFRQFHQWUDWLHV30*2RVW*HOGHUV3ODWHDXPHGLR

] GLNWHGRRUVWURRPGHODDJ, JURQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJS SRURVLWHLW

SXW ODQG ] + , 7 SXW ODQG ] + , 7 QU JHEU P 78 PPD D QU JHEU P 78 PPD D  EHE      JUDV      ERV      JUDV      EZO      JUDV      EZO     'HEHUHNHQGHZDDUGHQYRRUGHDDQYXOOLQJYDQKHW JURQGZDWHU )LJ ]LMQPHHVWDO YHHO ODJHUGDQ RYHUHHQNRPWPHWKHWYHUVFKLOWXVVHQQHHUVODJHQ SRWHQWLsOHJHZDVYHUGDPSLQJ%OLMNEDDUNRPWGDW GRRUGDWHHQUHODWLHIJURRWGHHOYDQGHQHHUVODJ RSSHUYODNNLJZRUGWDIJHYRHUGHQGXVQLHWKHW JURQGZDWHUDDQYXOW9HHOODQGERXZJURQGHQLQKHW JHELHG]LMQLQGHUGDDGYRRU]LHQYDQGUDLQEXL]HQ 'DDUQDDVW]DOZHOOLFKWHHQGHHOYDQGHQHHUVODJ GRRUJUHSSHOVQDDUGHVORWHQZRUGHQJHYRHUG 2YHULJHQVLVGHSUHFLH]HJURQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJQLHW QDXZNHXULJWHEHSDOHQRSGH]HPDQLHUGDDUYRRU ]LMQGHRQ]HNHUKHGHQLQGHEHUHNHQLQJWHJURRW )LJ*URQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJ30*SXWWHQ LQGHERGHPYDQKHW2RVW*HOGHUV3ODWHDX

'H,-VVHOYDOOHL

'HEDVLVYDQGHERYHQVWHDTXLIHULQGH,-VVHOYDOOHLEHVWDDWXLWHHQGLNNHHQVOHFKWGRRUODWHQGH JODFLDOHNOHLODDJ0HWGHVWURPLQJYDQKHWJURQGZDWHURQGHUGLHODDJKRHIWJHHQUHNHQLQJWH ZRUGHQJHKRXGHQELMGHDIYRHUYDQKHWQHHUVODJRYHUVFKRW'HWRSYDQGHNOHLODDJOLJWYDDNRS HHQGLHSWHYDQFDPRQGHUPDDLYHOG 7DEHO7ULWLXPZDDUQHPLQJHQLQ/0*SXWWHQ,-VVHOYDOOHLPHWLQJHQLQ I ERYHQVWHILOWHU I PLGGHOVWHILOWHUI RQGHUVWHILOWHU

/0* SODDWV  ODQG I I ,S , I I QU JHEUXLN 78 78 PD PPD UHLVWLMG D  EXVVOR RQEHNHQG        DSHOGRRUQ EHERXZG        OLHUHQ ERXZODQG        WHUZROGH JUDVODQG        KDWWHP JUDVODQG       *URQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJLQGH $FKWHUKRHN3ODWHDX                        QXPPHUYDQGH30*SXW P P D 

(22)

SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW 9RRUGHLQWHUSUHWDWLH 7DEHOHQ LVDDQJHKRXGHQ JHPLGGHOGHMDDUQHHUVODJRYHU PPD JHPLGGHOGHUHIHUHQWLHJHZDVYHUGDPSLQJ PPD GLHSWHYDQGHK\GURORJLVFKHEDVLV P 7DEHO ,QWHUSUHWDWLHYDQGHWULWLXPFRQFHQWUDWLHV30*LQGH,-VVHOYDOOHLPHGLR

] GLNWHGRRUVWURRPGHODDJ, JURQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJS SRURVLWHLW

30* ODQG I I I I I I ,S , I I I QU JHEU ] P ] P ] P 78 78 78 PD PPD UHLVWLMG D  ERV          ERV          JUDV          EZO             EZO          EZO         *HPLGGHOGHZDDUGHQYRRUGH,-VVHOYDOOHLYDQGHDDQYXOOLQJHQKHWQHHUVODJRYHUVFKRW]LMQ ERVHQQDWXXU 3(S PPD ,JHP PPD 3(S,JHP PPD ERXZODQG 3(S PPD ,JHP PPD 3(S,JHP PPD JUDVODQG 3(S PPD ,JHP PPD 3(S,JHP PPD 'HLQWHUSUHWDWLHOHYHUWLQGLWJHYDORSGDWGHDDQYXOOLQJYDQKHWJURQGZDWHUNOHLQHULVGDQKHW YHUVFKLOWXVVHQQHHUVODJHQGHSRWHQWLsOHYHUGDPSLQJ:HOOLFKWLVGDWZHHUHHQJHYROJYDQKHW RSWUHGHQYDQRSSHUYODNNLJHDIYRHU$DQGH]HFRQFOXVLHPRHWHFKWHUQLHWWHYHHOZDDUGH ZRUGHQJHKHFKWDDQJH]LHQPHWQDPHGHQHHUVODJQLHWQDXZNHXULJNDQZRUGHQEHSDDOG 2RNYRRUGH,-VVHOYDOOHLJHOGWZDDUVFKLMQOLMNGDWYHHOODQGGDWDOVERXZODQGZRUGW DDQJHPHUNWRYHUZHJHQGJUDVODQGLVGDWWLMGHOLMNDOVERXZODQG PDLV ZRUGWJHEUXLNW9HUGHU LVKHWDDQWDOZDDUQHPLQJHQLQGHRQGHUVFKHLGHQFDWHJRULHsQVWHHGVEHWUHNNHOLMNODDJZDWDDQ GHEHWURXZEDDUKHLGYDQXLWVSUDNHQJHHQJRHGGRHW )LJ *URQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJ30*SXWWHQ,-VVHOYDOOHL *URQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJLQGH,-VVHOYDOOHL                                        ERVHQQDWXXUDNNHUERXZJUDV QXPPHUYDQGH30*SXW P P D 

(23)

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

'H9HOXZH

'HZDDUGHQYRRUQHHUVODJHQZHUNHOLMNHYHUGDPSLQJYDULsUHQVWHUNYRRUGH9HOXZVHKHXYHOV HQGHVWDQGYDQKHWJURQGZDWHUOLJWGLHSRQGHUPDDLYHOG'HEHSDOLQJYDQGHDDQYXOOLQJLV QLHWHUJEHWURXZEDDUYRRUGHGLYHUVHPHHWQHWSXWWHQ'HUHLVWLMGHQYDQKHWJURQGZDWHULQGH ERGHPNXQQHQHFKWHUZHOHHQYRXGLJZRUGHQEHSDDOG 7DEHOOHQHQ  7DEHO 7ULWLXPZDDUQHPLQJHQLQ/0*SXWWHQ9HOXZHPHWLQJHQLQ

I ERYHQVWHILOWHU I PLGGHOVWHILOWHUI RQGHUVWHILOWHU

/0* SODDWV  ODQG I I ,S , I I QU JHEUXLN 78 78 PD PPD UHLVWLMG D  KDUGHUZLMN ERV        QXQVSHHW ERV        RXZHQGRUS ERXZODQG        HUPHOR ERV        NWZEURHN RQEHNHQG        HGH ERXZODQG      

 UHQNXP ERV   I     I

 RXGUHHPVW ERV        ODDJVRHUHQ ERV        DUQKHP LQGXVWULH        DUQKHP EHERXZG       7DEHO ,QWHUSUHWDWLHYDQGHWULWLXPFRQFHQWUDWLHV30*,QGH9HOXZHPHGLR 30* ODQG I I I I I I ,S , I I I QU JHEU ] P ] P ] P 78 78 78 PD PPD UHLVWLMG D  ERV             EHE             ERV       ERV    ERV       ERV     

'H*HOGHUVH9DOOHL

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

(24)

SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW

7DEHO ,QWHUSUHWDWLHYDQGHWULWLXPFRQFHQWUDWLHV30**HOGHUVH9DOOHLPHGLR

] GLNWHGRRUVWURRPGHODDJ, JURQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJS SRURVLWHLW

30* ODQG I I I I I I ,S , I I I QU JHEU ] P ] P ] P 78 78 78 PD PPD UHLVWLMG D  EHE             EHE      EHE          EHE          ERV       EZO          EZO       EZO             EZO             EZO             JUDV           JUDV           JUDV          /0*  (PKEHUJ         8LW)LJEOLMNWGDWGHZDDUGHQYDQGHDDQYXOOLQJLQHHQDDQWDOJHYDOOHQNOHLQHU]LMQGDQ RYHUHHQNRPWPHWKHWJHPLGGHOGHYHUVFKLOYDQQHHUVODJHQGHSRWHQWLsOHJHZDVYHUGDPSLQJ 2RNYRRUGLWJHELHGJHOGWGDWKHWODQGGDWDOVEZOZRUGWJHEUXLNWYRRUHHQJURRWGHHOHLJHQOLMN JUDVODQGLVGDWWLMGHOLMNPHWPDLVLVEHERXZG'LWEHWHNHQWGDWVRPVHHQGHHOYDQGHQHHUVODJ RSSHUYODNNLJ]DOZRUGHQDIJHYRHUG]RDOVRSEDVLVYDQGHDDUGYDQGHGUDLQDJHDOZDV YHURQGHUVWHOG*HPLGGHOGHZDDUGHQYDQDDQYXOOLQJHQQHHUVODJRYHUVFKRW]LMQ EHERXZG 3(S PPD ,JHP PPD 3(S,JHP PPD ERVHQQDWXXU 3(S PPD ,JHP RQEHSDDOG 3(S,JHP RQEHSDDOG ERXZODQG 3(S PPD ,JHP PPD 3(S,JHP PPD JUDVODQG 3(S PPD ,JHP PPD 3(S,JHP PPD )LJ*URQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJ30*SXWWHQLQKHWRRVWHQYDQGH*HOGHUVH9DOOHL *URQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJLQGH*HOGHUVH9DOOHL                                                                EHERXZGERVDNNHUERXZ JUDV QXPPHUYDQGH30*SXW P P D 

(25)

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

2PJHYLQJYDQ1LMPHJHQ

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



2YHU]LFKWYDQGHUHVXOWDWHQYRRU30**HOGHUODQG

9RRUGH]DQGJHELHGHQLQGHSURYLQFLH*HOGHUODQG]LMQJHJHYHQVEHVFKLNEDDUXLWILOWHUVLQ SXWWHQYDQKHW30*'HFRQFHQWUDWLHVGLHYRRUILOWHUV]LMQEHSDDOG]LMQ]RODDJGDWJHHQ LQWHUSUHWDWLHPRJHOLMNLV9HUPRHGHOLMN]LMQGH]HILOWHUVJHSODDWVWLQHHQVLWXDWLHZDDUKHW JURQGZDWHUHHQ YHHO ODQJHUHUHLVWLMGGDQMDDULQGHERGHPKHHIWJHKDGGRRUGDWNZHO RSWUHHGWRIGRRUGDWGHYHUWLNDOHVQHOKHGHQYDQGHVWURPLQJ]HHUJHULQJ]LMQ'HDDQYXOOLQJ YDQKHWJURQGZDWHULQGH$FKWHUKRHNLVYULMZHOJHOLMNDDQKHWJHPLGGHOGHRYHUVFKRWDDQ QHHUVODJDOVUHNHQLQJZRUGWJHKRXGHQPHWGHSRWHQWLs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

(26)

SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW RQGHUJUDVODQGDOVRQGHUERXZODQG'LWKHHIWZDDUVFKLMQOLMNGH]HOIGHUHGHQDOVLQGHSURYLQFLH 'UHQWKHQDPHOLMNGDWYHHOERXZODQGHHQWLMGHOLMNNDUDNWHUKHHIWHQODQJHWLMGRRNJUDVODQGLV

1RRUG2YHULMVVHO

9RRUGH30*SXWWHQLQGHSURYLQFLH2YHULMVVHO]LMQJHHQWULWLXPPHWLQJHQEHVFKLNEDDU'H PHWLQJHQLQGH/0*SXWWHQ]LMQRSJHQRPHQLQGH7DEHOOHQWRWHQPHW%LMGH LQWHUSUHWDWLHYRRU1RRUG2YHULMVVHO]LMQGHYROJHQGHJHPLGGHOGHZDDUGHQDDQJHKRXGHQ JHPLGGHOGHQHHUVODJRYHU 3 PPD JHPLGGHOGHUHIHUHQWLHJHZDVYHUGDPSLQJ (U PPD GLHSWHYDQGHK\GURORJLVFKHEDVLV ' P 7DEHO7ULWLXPZDDUQHPLQJHQLQ/0*SXWWHQ1RRUG2YHULMVVHOPHWLQJHQLQ I ERYHQVWHILOWHU I PLGGHOVWHILOWHUI RQGHUVWHILOWHU

/0* SODDWV  ODQG I I ,S , I I QU JHEUXLN 78 78 PD PPD UHLVWLMG D  NDPSHQ EHERXZG        HQJHOVHZHUN RQEHNHQG        ]ZROOH EHERXZG        VWMDQVNORRVWHU RQEHNHQG        URXYHHQ JUDVODQG        VWDSKRUVW EHERXZG        SXQWKRUVW ERV        GDOIVHQ JUDVODQG        ZLWKDUHQ ERV        GHGHPVYDDUW JUDVODQG      

6DOODQG

%LMGHLQWHUSUHWDWLHYRRU6DOODQG]LMQDOVJHPLGGHOGHZDDUGHQDDQJHKRXGHQ JHPLGGHOGHQHHUVODJRYHU 3 PPD JHPLGGHOGHUHIHUHQWLHJHZDVYHUGDPSLQJ (U PPD GLHSWHYDQGHK\GURORJLVFKHEDVLV ' P 7DEHO7ULWLXPZDDUQHPLQJHQLQ/0*SXWWHQ6DOODQGPHWLQJHQLQ /0* SODDWV  ODQG I I ,S , I I QU JHEUXLN 78 78 PD PPD UHLVWLMG D  ZLQGHVKHLP JUDVODQG        ZLMKH EHERXZG        UHFKWHUHQ ERV        UDDOWH JUDVODQG        HLNHOKRI JUDVODQG        GHYHQWHU EHERXZG        GLMNHUK JUDVODQG        OHPHOH ERV      

&HQWUDDO2YHULMVVHO

%LMGHLQWHUSUHWDWLHYRRU&HQWUDDO2YHULMVVHO]LMQDOVJHPLGGHOGHZDDUGHQDDQJHKRXGHQ JHPLGGHOGHQHHUVODJRYHU 3 PPD JHPLGGHOGHUHIHUHQWLHJHZDVYHUGDPSLQJ (U PPD GLHSWHYDQGHK\GURORJLVFKHEDVLV ' P

(27)

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

7DEHO7ULWLXPZDDUQHPLQJHQLQ/0*SXWWHQ&HQWUDDO2YHULMVVHOPHWLQJHQLQ I ERYHQVWHILOWHU I PLGGHOVWHILOWHUI RQGHUVWHILOWHU

/0* SODDWV  ODQG I I ,S , I I QU JHEUXLN 78 78 PD PPD UHLVWLMG D  GHQKDP JUDVODQG    NORRVWHUKDP ERXZODQG    QLMYHUGDO ERV        KHOOHQGDDO JUDVODQG        PDUNHOR JUDVODQG      

7ZHQWH

%LMGHLQWHUSUHWDWLHYRRU7ZHQWH]LMQDOVJHPLGGHOGHZDDUGHQDDQJHKRXGHQ JHPLGGHOGHQHHUVODJRYHU 3 PPD JHPLGGHOGHUHIHUHQWLHJHZDVYHUGDPSLQJ (U PPD GLHSWHYDQGHK\GURORJLVFKHEDVLV ' P 7DEHO7ULWLXPZDDUQHPLQJHQLQ/0*SXWWHQ7ZHQWHPHWLQJHQLQ I ERYHQVWHILOWHU I PLGGHOVWHILOWHUI RQGHUVWHILOWHU

/0* SODDWV  ODQG I I ,S , I I QU JHEUXLN 78 78 PD PPD UHLVWLMG D  YDVVH JUDVODQG        DOPHOR EHERXZG        ZHHUVHOR JUDVODQG        KHQJHOR ERXZODQG      

 HQVFKHGH ERV   I     I

 GHQHNDPS EHERXZG        GHOXWWH ERV      

2RVW8WUHFKWHQKHW*RRL

9RRUGH30*SXWWHQLQGHSURYLQFLH8WUHFKW]LMQJHHQWULWLXPPHWLQJHQEHVFKLNEDDU'H PHWLQJHQLQGH/0*SXWWHQ]LMQRSJHQRPHQLQ7DEHO%LMGHLQWHUSUHWDWLHYRRUGH PHWLQJHQLQ2RVW8WUHFKWHQKHW*RRL]LMQGHYROJHQGHZDDUGHQDDQJHKRXGHQ JHPLGGHOGHQHHUVODJRYHU 3 PPD JHPLGGHOGHUHIHUHQWLHJHZDVYHUGDPSLQJ (U PPD GLHSWHYDQGHK\GURORJLVFKHEDVLV ' P 7DEHO7ULWLXPZDDUQHPLQJHQLQ/0*SXWWHQ2RVW8WUHFKWPHWLQJHQLQ I ERYHQVWHILOWHU I PLGGHOVWHILOWHU I RQGHUVWHILOWHU

/0* SODDWV  ODQG I I ,S , I I QU JHEUXLN 78 78 PD PPD UHLVWLMG D  KLOYHUVXP ERV        KLOYHUVXP RQEHNHQG        ODUHQ EHERXZG        JURHQHNDQ JUDVODQG        VRHVWHUYHHQ JUDVODQG        DPHUVIRRUW RQEHNHQG        ELOWKRYHQ EHERXZG        GRRUQ ERV      

(28)

SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW

(29)

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

 'HSURYLQFLHV1RRUG%UDEDQWHQ/LPEXUJ

,QGHOLQJLQGHHOJHELHGHQYRRU30*1RRUG%UDEDQW

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

+HW]DQGJHELHGYDQ1RRUGZHVW%UDEDQW

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

/0* SODDWV  ODQG I I ,S , I I QU JHEUXLN 78 78 PD PPD UHLVWLMG D  RRVWHUKRXW ERXZODQG        GRUVW ERV        RRVWHLQG JUDVODQG    ULMHQ JUDVODQG        KDOVWHUHQ ERXZODQG    ZRXZ ERXZODQG    EHUJHQRS]RRPERV  VFKLMI ERV        DFKWPDDO JUDVODQG        ULMVEHUJHQ JUDVODQG        HWWHQOHXU RQEHNHQG        EUHGD RQEHNHQG        EDDUOHQDVVDX JUDVODQG       JLO]H ERXZODQG      

(30)

SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW

7DEHO ,QWHUSUHWDWLHYDQWULWLXPFRQFHQWUDWLHVLQ30*1RRUGZHVW%UDEDQW

] GLNWHGRRUVWURRPGHODDJ, JURQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJS SRURVLWHLW

30* ODQGJHEUXLN I I I I ,S , I I QU ] P ] P 78 78 PD PPD UHLVWLMG D  EHERXZG       EHERXZG       ERV       ERV       ERV          ERV       ERXZODQG       ERXZODQG          JUDV          JUDV       JUDV       JUDV    JUDV       LQWHQVYHHK       LQWHQVYHHK          LQWHQVYHHK          LQWHQVYHHK      LQWHQVYHHK          LQWHQVYHHK          LQWHQVYHHK      WXLQ          WXLQ         (HQUHODWLHIJURRWGHHOYDQ1RRUGZHVW%UDEDQWLVLQJHULFKWYRRUGHLQWHQVLHYHYHHKRXGHULM ³LQWHQVYHHK´LQ7DEHO YHUPRHGHOLMNPHWJUDVDOVRYHUKHHUVHQGHYHJHWDWLH,QKHWJHELHG ZRUGWYHHOWXLQERXZWRHJHSDVW ³WXLQ´ +HWSRWHQWLsOHRYHUVFKRWDDQQHHUVODJLVEHWUHNNHOLMN ODDJPDDUGHDDQYXOOLQJYDQKHWJURQGZDWHUEOLMNWQRJODJHUWH]LMQ )LJ YHUPRHGHOLMN GRRUGDWHHQGHHOYDQKHWZDWHURSSHUYODNNLJZRUGWDIJHYRHUG'HJHPLGGHOGHZDDUGHQ]LMQ ERVHQQDWXXU 3(S PPD ,JHP PPD 3(S,JHP PPD ERXZODQG 3(S PPD ,JHP PPD 3(S,JHP PPD JUDVODQG 3(S PPD ,JHP PPD 3(S,JHP PPD WXLQERXZ 3(S PPD ,JHP PPD 3(S,JHP PPD *URQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJLQ1RRUGZHVW%UDEDQW                                                                          EHEERVDNNHUEJUDVWXLQ QXPPHUYDQGH30*SXW P P D  )LJ*URQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJ30*SXWWHQLQ1RRUGZHVW%UDEDQW

(31)

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

'H0HLHUHLYDQ'HQ%RVFK

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

/0* SODDWV  ODQG I I ,S , I I QU JHEUXLN 78 78 PD PPD UHLVWLMG D  NDDWVKHXYHO ERV        QXODQG JUDVODQG        OLWK JUDVODQG        KDDUHQ ERXZODQG        YHQNDQW JUDVODQG    GHQERVFK EHERXZG        YHJKHO JUDVODQG        ELHVW ERXZODQG        WLOEXUJ EHERXZG        VSRRUGRQN JUDVODQG    ROODQG JUDVODQG   7DEHO,QWHUSUHWDWLHYDQ+FRQFHQWUDWLHV30*0HLHUHLYDQ'HQ%RVFKPHGLR

] GLNWHGRRUVWURRPGHODDJ, JURQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJS SRURVLWHLW

30* ODQGJHEUXLN I I I I ,S , I I QU ] P ] P 78 78 PD PPD UHLVWLMG D  EHERXZG         ERV          ERV          JUDV          JUDV          JUDV          JUDV          LQWHQVYHHK          LQWHQVYHHK         'HDDQYXOOLQJYDQKHWJURQGZDWHULVZLVVHOHQGYDQJURRWWHLQKHWJHELHGYDQGH0HLHUHLYDQ 'HQ%RVFK )LJ +HWLVRSYDOOHQGGDWGH]XLGHOLMNHSXWWHQZDDUGHDI]HWWLQJHQYDQGH 1XHQHQJURHSKHWGLNVW]LMQGHODDJVWHZDDUGHQYHUWRQHQ,QKHWQRRUGHOLMNGHHOYLQGW EOLMNEDDUQDXZHOLMNVRSSHUYODNNLJHDIVWURPLQJSODDWVPDDULQKHW]XLGHQZHO+HWYHUPHOGHQ YDQJHPLGGHOGHZDDUGHQLVGDDURPQLHW]LQYRO

(32)

SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW )LJ *URQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJ30*SXWWHQLQGH0HLHUHL



'H.HPSHQ

,QGH.HPSHQODJHQMDDUJHOHGHQQRJYHHOZRHVWH]DQGJURQGHQPHWHHQKHLGHYHJHWDWLH (HQGHHOYDQKHWODQGLVGDDUQDPHWERVEHGHNWHQHHQDQGHUGHHOYDQKHWODQGLVRQWJRQQHQ YRRUGHODQGERXZ5RQG(LQGKRYHQYRQGHHQVWHUNHLQGXVWULsOHRQWZLNNHOLQJSODDWV]RGDWKHW JHELHGQXUHODWLHIGLFKWEHYRONWLV,QKHWQRRUGHOLMNGHHO]LMQGHDI]HWWLQJHQYDQGH1XHQHQ *URHSSURPLQHQWDDQZH]LJLQGHRQGLHSHERGHP%DVLVJHJHYHQV]LMQ 7DEHO  JHPLGGHOGHMDDUQHHUVODJRYHU PPD JHPLGGHOGHUHIHUHQWLHJHZDVYHUGDPSLQJ PPD GLHSWHYDQGHK\GURORJLVFKHEDVLV P 7DEHO7ULWLXPZDDUQHPLQJHQLQ/0*SXWWHQ'H.HPSHQPHWLQJHQLQ I ERYHQVWHILOWHU I PLGGHOVWHILOWHUI RQGHUVWHILOWHU

/0* SODDWV  ODQG I I ,S , I I QU JHEUXLN 78 78 PD PPD UHLVWLMG D  VRQ JUDVODQG        EODGHO ERXZODQG        YHVVHP ERV        OLHVKRXW JUDVODQG  KHOPRQG EHERXZG        HLQGKRYHQ EHERXZG        DDOVW ERV        PLHUOR ERV        YOLHUGHQ ERV        ZHHERVFK ERXZODQG        ZHVWHUK ERXZODQG        OHHQGH ERV        EXGHO EHERXZG        VRPHUHQ RQEHNHQG  EVFKRRW ERV       *URQGZDWHUDDQYXOOLQJLQGH0HLHUHL                                            EHEERVJUDV QXPPHUYDQGH30*SXW P P D

Referenties

GERELATEERDE DOCUMENTEN

'H]H RSPHWLQJ JHEHXUGH DDQ GH KDQG YDQ WUDQVHFWHQ GLH ORRGUHFKW RS GH RHYHU YDQ GH ZDWHUORRS VWDDQ 'H DIVWDQG WXVVHQ WZHH RSHHQYROJHQGH WUDQVHFWHQ EHGURHJ

The SSGs’ poor knowledge of sugarcane pests and their control also indicate that pests are not considered an important constraint, particularly when compared to

Most of the applied GM vectors in oncolytic virotherapy (at least the HAdV, HSV-1, VV based viruses) are however conditionally replicating vectors containing deletions of viral

Middellange termijn effecten zoals allergische reacties, ontstekingsreacties en het ontstaan van granuloma’s kunnen gerelateerd zijn aan een reactie van het lichaam op onzuiverheden

COMPETES wordt naast verschillende nationale analyses, zoals Flexnet (Sijm et al., 2017) en meer Europees gerichte analyses (bijv. Van Hout et al., 2017) ingezet voor de

7HQVORWWHJDDWKHWNDELQHWLQRSKHWYRRUVWHOYDQGH&*%RPGHZHUNLQJVVIHHUYDQ GH:JEKF] VSRHGLJ XLW WH EUHLGHQ PHW KHW JRHGHUHQ HQ GLHQVWHQYHUNHHU ,Q

Voor het natuurbeleid heeft dat de volgende consequenties: • een structurele beschikbaarheid van een grote diversiteit aan natuur is niet alleen van belang voor de natuur

‘behapbaar’ en men vindt de huidige situatie in het belang van de discussie, de eigen verantwoordelijkheid van de ministers en het primaat van de politiek bij het maken van