$OES THE
UIFXIPMFCPEZWJCSBUJPONBHOJUVEF
*OUFSOBUJPOBM0SHBOJ[BUJPOGPS4UBOEBSEJ[BUJPO*40 .FDIBOJDBMWJCSBUJPOBOE
TIPDL FWBMVBUJPOPGIVNBOFYQPTVSFUPXIPMFCPEZWJCSBUJPOJOUIFXPSLJOH
FOWJSPONFOU QBSUHFOFSBMSFRVJSFNFOUT(FOFWB
#VSEPSG" -BBO+$PNQBSJTPOPGNFUIPETGPSUIFBTTFTTNFOUPGQPTUVSBMMPBEPOUIF
CBDL4DBOEJOBWJBO+PVSOBMPG8PSL&OWJSPONFOUBOE)FBMUI
)PPGUNBO8& WBOEFS#FFL"+ #POHFST1. WBO.FDIFMFO8(FOEFSEJĊFSFODFT
JOTFMGSFQPSUFEQIZTJDBMBOEQTZDIPTPDJBMFYQPTVSFTJOKPCTXJUICPUIGFNBMFBOENBMF
XPSLFST+PVSOBMPG0DDVQBUJPOBMBOE&OWJSPONFOUBM.FEJDJOF
)BOTTPO(" #BMPHI* #ZTUSPN+6 0IMTTPO, /PSEBOEFS$ "TUFSMBOE1 4KPMBOEFS 4
3ZMBOEFS4- 8JOLFM+ 4LFSGWJOH42VFTUJPOOBJSFWFSTVTEJSFDUUFDIOJDBM
NFBTVSFNFOUTJOBTTFTTJOHQPTUVSFTBOENPWFNFOUTPGUIFIFBE VQQFSCBDL BSNTBOE
IBOET4DBOEJOBWJBO+PVSOBMPG8PSL&OWJSPONFOUBOE)FBMUI
3FGFSFODFTDIBQUFS5XPXBZBTTFTTNFOUPGPUIFSQIZTJDBMXPSLEFNBOETXIJMFNFBTVSJOH
UIFXIPMFCPEZWJCSBUJPONBHOJUVEF
+PIBOOJOH&8IPMF#PEZWJCSBUJPO$BMMGPSPDDVQBUJPOBMNFEJDBMTVSWFJMMBODFBOE
QSFWFOUJPO+PVSOBMPG0DDVQBUJPOBMBOE&OWJSPONFOUBM.FEJDJOF
1BMNFS,5 (SJċO.+ #FOEBMM) 1BOOFUU# $PHHPO%1SFWBMFODFBOEQBUUFSOPG
PDDVQBUJPOBMFYQPTVSFUPXIPMFCPEZWJCSBUJPOJO(SFBU#SJUBJO mOEJOHTGSPNB
OBUJPOBMTVSWFZ0DDVQBUJPOBMBOE&OWJSPONFOUBM.FEJDJOF
#VSEPSG" 4PSPDL(1PTJUJWFBOEOFHBUJWFFWJEFODFPGSJTLGBDUPSTGPSCBDLEJTPSEFST
4DBOEJOBWJBO+PVSOBMPG8PSL&OWJSPONFOUBOE)FBMUI
#PWFO[J. )VMTIPG$5+"OVQEBUFESFWJFXPGFQJEFNJPMPHJDTUVEJFTPOUIF
SFMBUJPOTIJQCFUXFFOFYQPTVSFUPXIPMFCPEZWJCSBUJPOBOEMPXCBDLQBJO
*OUFSOBUJPOBM"SDIJWFTPG0DDVQBUJPOBMBOE&OWJSPONFOUBM)FBMUI
)PPHFOEPPSO8& WBO1PQQFM./ #POHFST1. ,PFT#8 #PVUFS-.1IZTJDBM
MPBEEVSJOHXPSLBOEMFJTVSFUJNFBTSJTLGBDUPSTGPSCBDLQBJO4DBOEJOBWJBO+PVSOBMPG
8PSL&OWJSPONFOUBOE)FBMUI
2EFERENCES
-JOHT4 -FCPFVG:EF$8IPMFCPEZWJCSBUJPOBOEMPXCBDLQBJOBTZTUFNBUJD
DSJUJDBMSFWJFXPGUIFFQJEFNJPMPHJDBMMJUFSBUVSF*OUFSOBUJPOBM"SDIJWFTPG
0DDVQBUJPOBMBOE&OWJSPONFOUBM)FBMUI
8BEEFMM( #VSUPO",0DDVQBUJPOBMIFBMUIHVJEFMJOFTGPSUIFNBOBHFNFOUPGMPX
#PWFO[J. 1JOUP* 4UBDDIJOF/-PXCBDLQBJOJOQPSUNBDIJOFSZPQFSBUPST+PVSOBM
PG4PVOEBOE7JCSBUJPO
)VMTIPG$5+ WBOEFS-BBO( #SBBN*5 7FSCFFL+ɨFGBUFPG.ST3PCJOTPO$SJUFSJB
GPSSFDPHOJUJPOPG8IPMFCPEZWJCSBUJPOJOKVSZBTBOPDDVQBUJPOBMEJTFBTF+PVSOBMPG
4PVOEBOE7JCSBUJPO
#PWFO[J. 3VJ' /FHSP$ %"HPTUJO' "OHPU[J( #JBODIJ4 #SBNBOUJ- 'FTUB(
(BUUJ4 1JOUP* 3POEJOB- 4UBDDIJOJ/"OFQJEFNJPMPHJDBMTUVEZPGMPXCBDL
QBJOJOQSPGFTTJPOBMESJWFST+PVSOBMPG4PVOEBOE7JCSBUJPO
#VSEPSG" -BBO+$PNQBSJTPOPGNFUIPETGPSUIFBTTFTTNFOUPGQPTUVSBMMPBEPOUIF
CBDL4DBOEJOBWJBO+PVSOBMPG8PSL&OWJSPONFOUBOE)FBMUI
WBOEFS#FFL"+ WBO(BBMFO-$ 'SJOHT%SFTFO.)88PSLJOHQPTUVSFTBOE
BDUJWJUJFTPGMPSSZESJWFSTBSFMJBCJMJUZTUVEZPGPOTJUFPCTFSWBUJPOBOESFDPSEJOHPOB
QPDLFUDPNQVUFS"QQMJFE&SHPOPNJDT
8JLUPSJO$ ,BSMRWJTU- 8JOLFM+7BMJEJUZPGTFMGSFQPSUFEFYQPTVSFTUPXPSLQPTUVSFT
BOENBOVBMNBUFSJBMTIBOEMJOH4UPDLIPMN.64*$*4UVEZ(SPVQ4DBOEJOBWJBO
+PVSOBMPG8PSL&OWJSPONFOUBOE)FBMUI
WBOEFS#FFL"+ #SBBN*5 %PVXFT. #POHFST1. 'SJOHT%SFTFO.)8 7FSCFFL
+) -VZUT 47BMJEJUZPGBEJBSZFTUJNBUJOHFYQPTVSFUPUBTLT BDUJWJUJFT BOEQPTUVSFTPG
UIFUSVOL*OUFSOBUJPOBM"SDIJWFTPG0DDVQBUJPOBMBOE&OWJSPONFOUBM)FBMUI
)PPGUNBO8& WBOEFS#FFL"+ #POHFST1. WBO.FDIFMFO8(FOEFSEJĊFSFODFT
JOTFMGSFQPSUFEQIZTJDBMBOEQTZDIPTPDJBMFYQPTVSFTJOKPCTXJUICPUIGFNBMFBOENBMF
XPSLFST+PVSOBMPG0DDVQBUJPOBMBOE&OWJSPONFOUBM.FEJDJOF
2EFERENCES
)BOTTPO(" #BMPHI* #ZTUSPN+6 0IMTTPO, /PSEBOEFS$ "TUFSMBOE1 4KPMBOEFS4
3ZMBOEFS- 8JOLFM+ 4LFSGWJOH42VFTUJPOOBJSFWFSTVTEJSFDUUFDIOJDBMNFBTVSFNFOUT
JOBTTFTTJOHQPTUVSFTBOENPWFNFOUTPGUIFIFBE VQQFSCBDL BSNTBOEIBOET
4DBOEJOBWJBO+PVSOBMPG8PSL&OWJSPONFOUBOE)FBMUI
'SBOTTPO)BMM$ (MPSJB3 ,JMCPN" 8JOLFM+ ,BSMRWJTU- 8JLUPSJO$"QPSUBCMF
FSHPOPNJDPCTFSWBUJPONFUIPE 1&0GPSDPNQVUFSJ[FEPOMJOFSFDPSEJOHPGQPTUVSFT
BOENBOVBMIBOEMJOH"QQMJFE&SHPOPNJDT
'SJOHT%SFTFO.)8 ,VJKFS11'.ɨF53"$TZTUFN"OPCTFSWBUJPONFUIPEGPS
BOBMZ[JOHXPSLEFNBOETBUUIFXPSLQMBDF4BGFUZ4DJFODF
%PVXFT. %VM+1SFWFOUJFCFSPFQTHFCPOEFOQSPCMFNBUJFLWBOIFUCFXFHJOHTBQQBSBBU
*OWFOUBSJTBUJFFOCFPPSEFMJOHWBOJOIFUWFMECSVJLCBSFNFUIPEFOWPPSIFUSFHJTUSFSFO
WBOIPVEJOHFOFOCFXFHJOHFO 1SFWFOUJPOPGXPSLSFMBUFENVTDVMPTLFMFUBMEJTPSEFST
3FWJFXPGQSBDUJDBMNFUIPETGPSUIFSFHJTUSBUJPOPGQPTUVSFTBOENPWFNFOUT-BCPS
*OTQFDUJPO%FO)BBH UIF/FUIFSMBOET
EF-PP[F.1 5PVTTBJOU). &OTJOL+ .BHOVT$ WBOEFS#FFL"+ɨFWBMJEJUZPG
WJTVBMPCTFSWBUJPOUPBTTFTTQPTUVSFJOBMBCPSBUPSZTJNVMBUFENBUFSJBMIBOEMJOHUBTL
&SHPOPNJDT
*OUFSOBUJPOBM0SHBOJ[BUJPOGPS4UBOEBSEJ[BUJPO*40 .FDIBOJDBMWJCSBUJPOBOE
TIPDL FWBMVBUJPOPGIVNBOFYQPTVSFUPXIPMFCPEZWJCSBUJPOJOUIFXPSLJOH
FOWJSPONFOU QBSUHFOFSBMSFRVJSFNFOUT(FOFWB
-VOETUSÚN3 )VMTIPG$5+ #PWFO[J.1SPUPDPMGPSFQJEFNJPMPHJDBMTUVEJFTPO
XIPMFCPEZWJCSBUJPO7*#3*4,48PSL1BDLBHF% mOBMSFQPSU GFC
<XXXIVNBOWJCSBUJPODPN>
1PQF.) .BHOVTTPO.- -POETUSVN3 #PWFO[J. )VMTIPG$5+ 7FSCFFL+
(VJEFMJOFTGPSXIPMFCPEZWJCSBUJPOIFBMUITVSWFJMMBODF+PVSOBMPG4PVOEBOE
7JCSBUJPO
1PQF.) (PI,- .BHOVTTPO.-4QJOFFSHPOPNJDT"OOVBM3FWJFXPG#JPNFEJDBM
&OHJOFFSJOH
2EFERENCES
-PUUFST' #VSEPSG" ,VJQFS+ .JFEFNB).PEFMGPSUIFXPSLSFMBUFEOFTTPGMPX
CBDLQBJO4DBOEJOBWJBO+PVSOBMPG8PSL&OWJSPONFOUBOE)FBMUI
#BUZ% #VDLMF1/ 4UVCCT%"1PTUVSFSFDPSEJOHCZEJSFDUPCTFSWBUJPO RVFTUJPOOBJSF
BTTFTTNFOUBOEJOTUSVNFOUBUJPOBDPNQBSJTPOCBTFEPOBSFDFOUmFMETUVEZɨF&SHP
OPNJDTPGXPSLJOHQPTUVSFT-POEPO5BZMPSBOE'SBODJT
6OHF+ )BOTTPO(" 0IMTTPO, /PSEBOEFS$ "YNPO" 8JOLFM+ 4LFSGWJOH4
7BMJEJUZPGTFMGBTTFTTFESFQPSUTPGPDDVSSFODFBOEEVSBUJPOPGPDDVQBUJPOBMUBTLT
&SHPOPNJDT
WBOEFS#FFL"+ 'SJOHT%SFTFO.)8"TTFTTNFOUPGNFDIBOJDBMFYQPTVSFJOFSHP
OPNJDFQJEFNJPMPHZ+PVSOBMPG0DDVQBUJPOBMBOE&OWJSPONFOUBM.FEJDJOF
IUUQVNFUFDIOJXMTF iEBUBBDDFTTFE+BOVBSZw
IUUQXXXJTQFTMJU iEBUBBDDFTTFE+BOVBSZw
1JOUP* 4UBDDIJOJ/6ODFSUBJOUZJOUIFFWBMVBUJPOPGPDDVQBUJPOBMFYQPTVSFUPXIPMF
CPEZWJCSBUJPO+PVSOBMPG4PVOEBOE7JCSBUJPO
)PP[FNBOT.+ #VSEPSG" WBOEFS#FFL"+ 'SJOHT%SFTFO.)8 .BUIJBTTFO4&
(SPVQCBTFENFBTVSFNFOUTUSBUFHJFTJOFYQPTVSFBTTFTTNFOUFYQMPSFECZCPPUTUSBQQJOH
4DBOEJOBWJBO+PVSOBMPG8PSL&OWJSPONFOUBOE)FBMUI
3FGFSFODFTDIBQUFS-PXCBDLQBJOJOESJWFSTFYQPTFEUPXIPMFCPEZWJCSBUJPOBOBMZTJTPG