Judicial review of legislation : constitutionalism personified in the United Kingdom, the Netherlands and South Africa
6
0
0
Hele tekst
(2) JUDICIAL REVIEW OF LEGISLATION Constitutionalism Personified in the United Kingdom, the Netherlands and South Africa. Gerhard van der Schyff.
(3)
(4) .
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
(11)
(12)
(13)
(14)
(15)
(16)
(17)
(18) ! "
(19) # $ %
(20) &$ '( '''
(21) #
(22) )
(23) *
(24) (
(25) $ +,( +,-, -.'-/ . 0 *
(26) *1 . ) 2 $3 $)
(27) 456 7 -899.
(28) Promotiecommissie: Promotor: prof. dr. P.B. Cliteur Overige leden: prof. dr. A. Ellian prof. dr. WJ.M. Voermans prof. dr. T. Zwart (Universiteit Utrecht). This thesis has been reproduced with the kind permission of Springer SBM. Springer SBM will publish the thesis under the title Judicial Review of Legislation: A Study of the United Kingdom, the Netherlands and South Africa..
(29) Judicial Review of Legislation: A Comparative Study of the United Kingdom, the Netherlands and South Africa CHAPTER 1 Setting the scene (§§ 1-17) 1 Emerging bipolar constitutionalism 2 Selecting comparative material 3 Delineating the function of judicial review 3.1 National courts applying higher law 3.2 Reviewing legislation 3.3 Public law relationships 4 Outline of study CHAPTER 2 Three systems of judicial review (§§ 18-75) 1 Pursuing constitutionalism 2 United Kingdom 2.1 An unwritten constitution and the Mother of All Parliaments 2.2 Bringing rights home 3 The Netherlands 3.1 Consensus democracy and an internationalised constitution 3.2 Revitalising the Constitution by calling on the judiciary? 4 South Africa 4.1 Parliamentary sovereignty and restricted democracy 4.2 Constitutional supremacy and full democracy 5 Identifying trends CHAPTER 3 Judicial review and democracy (§§ 76-121) 1 Counter-majoritarianism 2 Democratic participation 3 Democratic legitimacy of laws 4 Legitimacy of judicial decisions 5 Trias politica re-configurated 6 Fora of principle 7 Benefit to democracy 8 Charting the middle ground CHAPTER 4 Fora of review (§§ 122-169) 1 Introduction 2 United Kingdom: Following tradition 3 The Netherlands: Pragmatism first 4 South Africa: A new beginning 5 Concluding remarks CHAPTER 5 Modalities of review (§§ 170-219) 1 Introduction 2 United Kingdom: Respecting parliamentary sovereignty 2.1 Abstract review of bills 2.2 Abstract or concrete review of legislation 3 The Netherlands: Emphasising the review of posited norms.
(30) 4. 5. 3.1 Abstract review of bills 3.2 Abstract or concrete review of legislation South Africa: Protecting political minorities 4.1 Abstract review of bills 4.2 Abstract or concrete review of legislation Concluding remarks. CHAPTER 6 Content of review (§§ 220-294) 1 Introduction 2 United Kingdom: Discovering proportionality 2.1 Legality 2.2 Legitimacy 3 The Netherlands: Which way forward? 3.1 Legality 3.2 Legitimacy 4 South Africa: Wide-ranging scrutiny 4.1 Legality 4.2 Legitimacy 5 Concluding remarks CHAPTER 7 Consequences of review (§§ 295-335) 1 Introduction 2 United Kingdom: Preferring weak review 3 The Netherlands: Non-application of legislation 4 South Africa: Exploring strong review 5 Concluding remarks CHAPTER 8 Constitutionalism personified (§§ 336-347) BIBLIOGRAPHY SUMMARY SAMENVATTING CURRICULUM VITAE.
(31)
GERELATEERDE DOCUMENTEN
We also described the uncertainty matrix in relation to the Deltamodel (see Appendix A). This matrix can aid in classifying the uncertainties and describing how uncertainty can be
This process of emancipation of the established religious leadership seemed to lay the foundation that was necessary to examine the possibility and the na- ture of a cultural,
The following topics will be addressed: the specific nature of the political process in these countries, corruption for political purposes, ethnicity, instrumentalization of
Op oude plannen van die tijd is er ook sprake van een keuken die precies op deze locatie werd opgetrokken, maar die was geen lang leven gegund, daar er midden-eind 18de
en m ontwikkelde zich een duidelijk geartikuleerde svarabhakti- vokaal : de z66 tot stand gekomen nieuwe eindlettergreep is_niet beklemtoond, en daarom kunnen deze
instinctively label 'democracy'. One of the most pressing reasons for the decline of the one-party state in Africa was, as is well known, the change in the
Als kanttekening moet wel geplaatst worden dat de supervisor dit niet in alle gevallen direct tegen de eerstejaars assistent zelf zegt, maar dat deze boodschap ook via een
All African Convention African National Congress African National Congress Youth League Azanian People’s Organisation Bantu Affairs Department Border Rural Committee Cala
