Physiotherapy in Parkinson's disease. towards evidence- based practice. Keus, S.H.J.

Physiotherapy in Parkinson's disease. towards evidence- based practice.

Keus, S.H.J.

Citation

Keus, S. H. J. (2010, April 29). Physiotherapy in Parkinson's disease. towards evidence-based practice. Retrieved from https://hdl.handle.net/1887/15341

Version: Corrected Publisher’s Version

License: Licence agreement concerning inclusion of doctoral thesis in the Institutional Repository of the University of Leiden

Downloaded from: https://hdl.handle.net/1887/15341

Note: To cite this publication please use the final published version (if applicable).



7KHHIIHFWVRISK\VLRWKHUDS\LQ

3DUNLQVRQ·VGLVHDVHDUHVHDUFK

V\QWKHVLV



$UFK3K\V0HG5HKDELO

6XPPDU\

2XUDLPZDVWRSUHVHQWDFULWLFDOUHYLHZDQGPHWDDQDO\VLVRIVWXGLHVHYDOXDWLQJWKHHI

IHFWVRISK\VLRWKHUDS\LQSDWLHQWVVXIIHULQJIURP3DUNLQVRQ·VGLVHDVH3'LQWHUPVRI  QHXURORJLFDOVLJQVDFWLYLWLHVRIGDLO\OLYLQJDQGZDONLQJDELOLW\$UWLFOHVSXEOLVKHGIURP

XSWR0D\ZHUHFRPSLOHGE\PHDQVRI0('/,1(&RFKUDQHUHJLVWHURI FRQ

WUROOHGWULDOVDQG&,1$+/XVLQJFRPELQDWLRQVRI WKHNH\ZRUGV¶3DUNLQVRQ·VGLVHDVH·¶H[

HUFLVH·¶H[HUFLVHWKHUDS\·¶SK\VLFDOWKHUDS\·DQG¶JURXSWUDLQLQJ·5HIHUHQFHVSUHVHQWHGLQ

UHOHYDQWSXEOLFDWLRQVZHUHDOVRH[DPLQHG$UWLFOHVZULWWHQLQ(QJOLVK*HUPDQRU'XWFK

ZHUHLQFOXGHG6WXGLHVKDGWRPHHWWKHIROORZLQJVHOHFWLRQFULWHULDSDWLHQWVZLWK3'

ZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWKHLQWHUYHQWLRQVWXG\WKHHIIHFWVRISK\VLRWKHUDS\ZHUHHYDOXDWHG

WKHVWXG\FRXOGEHFODVVLÀHGDVWUXHRUTXDVLH[SHULPHQWDQGWKHVWXG\ZDVSXE

OLVKHGLQDMRXUQDORUERRN7ZRUHYLHZHUVDVVHVVHGLQGHSHQGHQWO\WKHPHWKRGRORJLFDO

TXDOLW\RI WKHGDWDRIHDFKLQFOXGHGVWXG\2QHUHYLHZHUH[WUDFWHGUHOHYDQWPHWDDQDO\VLV

GDWD)RUHDFKRXWFRPHPHDVXUHWKHHVWLPDWHGHIIHFWVL]HDQGWKHVXPPDU\HIIHFWVL]H

6(6ZHUHFDOFXODWHGXVLQJÀ[HGLH+HGJHV·VJDQGUDQGRPHIIHFWVPRGHOV7KHPHWD

DQDO\VLVUHVXOWHGLQDVLJQLÀFDQWKRPRJHQHRXV6(6ZLWKUHJDUGWR$'/DQGVWULGH

OHQJWK7KH6(6ZLWKUHJDUGWRZDONLQJVSHHGVKRZHGDVLJQLÀFDQWKHWHURJHQHRXV

6(6ZKLFKUHPDLQHGVLJQLÀFDQWDIWHUDSSO\LQJDUDQGRPHIIHFWVPRGHO7KH6(6

ZLWKUHJDUGWRQHXURORJLFDOVLJQVZDVQRWVLJQLÀFDQW7KHVPDOOQXPEHURI VWXGLHV

LQFOXGHGDQGWKHVKRUWFRPLQJVRIWKHPHWKRGRORJLFDOTXDOLW\RIWKHVHVWXGLHVKRZHYHU

ELDVWKHUHVXOWVRIWKHSUHVHQWVWXG\7KHUHVXOWVRIWKHSUHVHQWUHVHDUFKV\QWKHVLVVXS

SRUWWKHK\SRWKHVLVWKDW3DUNLQVRQSDWLHQWVEHQHÀWIURPSK\VLRWKHUDS\DGGHGWRWKHLU

VWDQGDUGPHGLFDWLRQ





,QWURGXFWLRQ

,QWKHDJLQJSRSXODWLRQWKHSUHYDOHQFHRI3DUNLQVRQ·VGLVHDVH3'LVLQFUHDVLQJ5H

FHQWO\LWKDVEHHQUHSRUWHGWKDWLQDSRSXODWLRQROGHUWKDQ\HDUVVXIIHUVIURP3'

ZLWKDSUHYDOHQFHRI WRSHUDQGDQDQQXDOLQFLGHQFHRISHU

LQWKH86$^7KHFOLQLFDOKDOOPDUNVRUQHXURORJLFDOV\PSWRPVRI WKHGLVHDVHLQFOXGH

GLIÀFXOW\LQLQLWLDWLQJPRYHPHQWDNLQHVLDVORZQHVVDQGGLIÀFXOW\LQPDLQWDLQLQJPRYH

PHQWEUDG\NLQHVLDWKHUHGXFHGDELOLW\WRVZLWFKEHWZHHQGLIIHUHQWFRRUGLQDWLRQSDW

WHUQVVHWVKLIWLQJEHLQJVWLIILQDUPVOHJVDQGWUXQNULJLGLW\DQGDSDWKRORJLFDOWUHPRU

DWDSSUR[LPDWHO\+]^

3'LVFKDUDFWHULVHGE\LQVLGLRXVRQVHW7KHÀUVWFOLQLFDOVLJQVDSSHDUZKHQDERXWWR

RIWKHGRSDPLQHSURGXFLQJFHOOVRIWKHVXEVWDQWLDQLJUDKDYHGHJHQHUDWHG^ 'HVSLWHGRSDPLQHUJLFPHGLFDWLRQDIWHUVRPHWLPHSDWLHQWVIDFHDUHOHQWOHVVGHWHULRUDWLRQ

LQPRELOLW\DQGDFWLYLWLHVRIGDLO\OLYLQJ$'/ZKLFKFDQUHVXOWLQQHHGIRUFXVWRGLDO

FDUH7KHPHGLFDOWUHDWPHQWRI3'LVPDLQO\FRPSULVHGRIGRSDPLQHUHSODFHPHQWWKHUD

S\OHYRSRGDSOXVFDUELGH>6LQHPHW@OHYRGRSDSOXVEHQVHUD]LGH>0DGRSDU@RUGRSDPLQH

DJRQLVWVSHUJROLGH>3HUPD[@EURPRFULSWLQH>3DUORGHO@DQGVXUJHU\

$QXPEHURI LQWHUYHQWLRQVWXGLHVKDYHEHHQFDUULHGRXWWRLQYHVWLJDWHWKHHIÀFDF\

RI SK\VLRWKHUDS\LQDGGLWLRQWRWKHDQWL3DUNLQVRQSKDUPDFRORJLFDOWUHDWPHQW2IWHQ

SK\VLRWKHUDS\ERWKLQGLYLGXDODQGJURXSWUHDWPHQWIRFXVHVRQWKHLPSDLUPHQWVHJ

QHXURORJLFDOV\PSWRPVIXQFWLRQDOOLPLWDWLRQVHJZDONLQJVWDLUFOLPELQJUHDFKLQJDQG

JUDVSLQJDQGGLVDELOLWLHVHJKREELHVVSRUWDQGVRFLDODFWLYLWLHVDQGLVFRPSULVHGRI

PRELOLW\H[HUFLVHV^JDLWWUDLQLQJZLWKDQGZLWKRXWWKHDSSOLFDWLRQRIH[WHUQDOFXHV^ WUDLQLQJRI GDLO\DFWLYLWLHV^UHOD[DWLRQWKHUDS\DQGEUHDWKLQJH[HUFLVHV^$QRWKHU

JRDOLVWRHGXFDWHWKHLQGLYLGXDODVZHOODVSDUWQHUDQGIDPLO\DERXWWKHGLVHDVHSURFHVV

DQGWKHEHQHÀWVRIH[HUFLVHWKHUDS\^

,WKDVEHHQVXJJHVWHGLQSUHYLRXVUHYLHZVWKDWSK\VLRWKHUDS\LVDQLPSRUWDQWDGMXQFWWR

WKHDQWL3DUNLQVRQPHGLFDWLRQ0RVWUHYLHZHUVDJUHHWKDWRQO\DIHZVWXGLHV

KDYHULJRURXVO\DVVHVVHGWKHFOLQLFDOEHQHÀWRISK\VLRWKHUDS\LQZHOOFRQWUROOHGWULDOV

ZLWKUHJDUGWRQHXURORJLFDOV\PSWRPV^ZDONLQJDELOLW\^$'/TXDOLW\RIOLIH

42/^DQGSV\FKRVRFLDOLQWHJUDWLRQ^$FFRUGLQJWRUHYLHZHUVJURXSWUHDWPHQWPD\

LQFUHDVHWKHSV\FKRVRFLDOHIIHFWRISK\VLRWKHUDS\IRUSDWLHQWVWKHLUUHODWLYHVDQGFRP

SDQLRQV^

$OWKRXJKLQWKHLUUHYLHZ9DQ(PPHULNHWDO^PHQWLRQHGPHWKRGRORJLFDOVKRUWFR

PLQJVLQDQXPEHURI VWXGLHVQRQHRI WKHUHYLHZHUVSXEOLVKHGVRIDUKDYHDVVHVVHG

WKHPHWKRGRORJLFDOTXDOLW\RIWKHLQWHUYHQWLRQVWXGLHVRUKDYHEXQGOHGWKHHIIHFWVL]HV

RI WKHLQGLYLGXDOVWXGLHV2XUVWXG\LQYROYHVDUHVHDUFKV\QWKHVLVRIWKHUHVXOWVRI

ZHOOFRQWUROOHGH[SHULPHQWVRQWKHHIÀFDF\RISK\VLRWKHUDS\LQSDWLHQWVZLWK3'7KH

PHWKRGRORJLFDOTXDOLW\RIWKHLQGLYLGXDOVWXGLHVZLOOEHHYDOXDWHGERWKWKHLQGLYLGXDODQG

VXPPDU\HIIHFWVL]HV6(6VZLOOEHSUHVHQWHGDQGWKHLQÁXHQFHRIWKHPHWKRGRORJLFDO



TXDOLW\RI WKHVWXGLHVRQWKH6(6VZLOOEHDVVHVVHG7KHPRVWGHWDLOHGV\VWHPDWLFUHYLHZ

RQWKHHIIHFWVRISK\VLRWKHUDS\LQ3'ZDVSXEOLVKHGLQHYDOXDWLQJDUWLFOHV^6L[

VWXGLHVZHUHFODVVLÀHGDVSUHH[SHULPHQWVWXGLHVDVTXDVLH[SHULPHQWDQGDVWUXH

H[SHULPHQW6LQFHWKHQDQXPEHURI LQWHUYHQWLRQVWXGLHVKDYHEHHQSXEOLVKHGLQWKH

OLWHUDWXUH

2QWKHEDVLVRI WKHSDWWHUQVGLVFHUQHGLQSUHYLRXVUHYLHZVLWLVK\SRWKHVLVHGWKDWSDWLHQWV

ZLWK3'EHQHÀWIURPSK\VLRWKHUDS\DGGHGWRWKHLUVWDQGDUGPHGLFDOFDUHRUPHGLFDO

WUHDWPHQWZLWKUHJDUGWRQHXURORJLFDOV\PSWRPVZDONLQJDELOLW\$'/DQG42/

0HWKRGV

/LWHUDWXUHVHDUFK

7KHGDWDEDVHRIDUWLFOHVSXEOLVKHGIURPXSWR0D\ZDVFRPSLOHGE\PHDQV

RI 0('/,1(&,1$+/DQG&RFKUDQHUHJLVWHURI FRQWUROOHGWULDOVXVLQJFRPELQDWLRQV

RI WKHNH\ZRUGV¶3DUNLQVRQ·VGLVHDVH·¶H[HUFLVH·¶H[HUFLVHWKHUDS\·¶SK\VLFDOWKHUDS\·DQG

¶JURXSWUDLQLQJ·5HIHUHQFHVSUHVHQWHGLQUHOHYDQWSXEOLFDWLRQVZHUHDOVRH[DPLQHG2QO\

DUWLFOHVZULWWHQLQ(QJOLVK*HUPDQRU'XWFKZHUHLQFOXGHG

6WXGLHVKDGWRPHHWWKHIROORZLQJVHOHFWLRQFULWHULDSDWLHQWVZLWK3'ZHUHLQFOXGHGLQ

WKHVWXG\WKHHIIHFWVRISK\VLRWKHUDS\ZHUHHYDOXDWHGWKHVWXG\FRXOGEHFODVVL

ÀHGDVDWUXHRUTXDVLH[SHULPHQWDQGWKHVWXG\ZDVSXEOLVKHGLQDMRXUQDORUERRN

&ULWLFDO5HYLHZ

7KHPHWKRGRORJLFDOTXDOLW\RIWKHVWXG\ZDVDVVHVVHGE\WZRUHYLHZHUV&-GH*DQG

6+.LQGHSHQGHQWO\E\DSSO\LQJDPHWKRGRORJLFDOVFRULQJOLVWXVHGE\.ZDNNHOHWDO

^DQG&DPEDFKHWDO^FRQWDLQLQJQLQHLWHPV$SSHQGL[ZLWKDPD[LPXP

SRVVLEOHVFRUHRISRLQWV7KHPHWKRGRORJLFDOVFUHHQLQJOLVWKDGDJRRGLQWHUUDWHU

UHOLDELOLW\.DSSD,QDPHHWLQJWKHUHYLHZHUVWULHGWRDFFRPSOLVKDJUHHPHQWRQGLI

IHUHQFHVLQVFRULQJ:KHQGLVDJUHHPHQWSHUVLVWHGDWKLUGUHYLHZHU5&:PDGHWKHÀQDO

GHFLVLRQ5HYLHZHUVZHUHQRWEOLQGWRDXWKRUVLQVWLWXWLRQVDQGMRXUQDO2QHUHYLHZHU

6+-.H[WUDFWHGUHOHYDQWGDWD

7KHIROORZLQJLWHPVZHUHHYDOXDWHGDUDQGRPLVDWLRQSURFHGXUHVEPDWFKLQJSUR

FHGXUHVFEOLQGLQJSURFHGXUHVGDQDO\VLVRIGURSRXWVHUHOLDELOLW\DQGYDOLGLW\RI  DVVHVVPHQWLQVWUXPHQWVIFRQWUROIRUFRLQWHUYHQWLRQVJFRPSDUDELOLW\RIEDVHOLQH

SDWLHQWFKDUDFWHULVWLFVKFRQWUROIRUDPRXQWRI WKHUDS\DQGLDSSOLHGVWDWLVWLFV

0HWDDQDO\VLV

7KHTXDQWLWDWLYHDQDO\VLVRUPHWDDQDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHGFDOFXODWLQJWKHHVWLPDWHG

XQELDVHGHIIHFWVL]HIRUHDFKVWXG\VHSDUDWHO\DQGWKH6(6FRPELQLQJWKHLQGLYLGXDO



XQELDVHGHIIHFWVL]HVXVLQJWKHPRGHORI+HGJHV·VJ7KHHIIHFWVL]H+HGJHV·VJ_LRI  HDFKLQGLYLGXDOVWXG\ZDVFDOFXODWHGE\GLYLGLQJWKHGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHJDLQVRI WKH

H[SHULPHQWDODQGFRQWUROJURXSWKURXJKWKHHVWLPDWHGSRROHGVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQVG_L RI WKHH[SHULPHQWDODQGFRQWUROJURXSDWEDVHOLQH)RUHDFKRXWFRPH+HGJHV·VJ_LDQGWKH

FRQÀGHQFHLQWHUYDO&,ZHUHUHSRUWHGLQVGXQLWV0RVWVWXGLHVUHSRUWHGVXIÀFLHQW

VWDWLVWLFVWRFDOFXODWHWKHHIIHFWVL]H

7KH6(6LVDZHLJKWHGPHDQRIWKHXQELDVHGLQGLYLGXDOHIIHFWVL]HVFDOFXODWHGDFFRU

GLQJWRWKHÀ[HGHIIHFWVPRGHO7KHZHLJKWRIHDFKVWXG\ZDVUHFLSURFDOWRLWVVG&RRSHU

DQG+HGJHVGHVFULEHWKHPHWKRGVXVHGWRFDOFXODWHXQELDVHGHIIHFWVL]HVWRFRPELQH

HIIHFWVL]HVDQGWRWHVWIRUVWDWLVWLFDOVLJQLÀFDQFHDQGKRPRJHQHLW\^7KHKRPRJHQHLW\

RUKHWHURJHQHLW\WHVWVWDWLVWLF4VWDWLVWLFRIHDFKVHWRI HIIHFWVL]HVZDVH[DPLQHGWR

GHWHUPLQHZKHWKHUVWXGLHVVKDUHGDFRPPRQHIIHFWVL]HRIZKLFKWKHYDULDQFHFRXOGEH

H[SODLQHGE\VDPSOLQJHUURUDORQH7KHÀ[HGHIIHFWVPRGHOZDVXVHGWRGHFLGHZKHWKHU

DQ6(6ZDVVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW,IKRZHYHUDVLJQLÀFDQWKHWHURJHQHLW\LQ6(6VZDV

IRXQGDUDQGRPHIIHFWVPRGHOZDVDSSOLHG)RUHDFKRXWFRPHWKHZHLJKWHG6(6DQGWKH

&,DUHUHSRUWHGLQVGXQLWV

5HVXOWV

$WRWDORI VWXGLHVZHUHLQLWLDOO\IRXQG6HYHQVWXGLHVZHUHFODVVLÀHGDVSUHH[SHUL

PHQWV^7KHVHVWXGLHVZHUHH[FOXGHGIURPIXUWKHUDQDO\VLVEHFDXVHRIDODFNRI  H[SHULPHQWDOFRQWURO7KHUHPDLQLQJWZHOYHVWXGLHVZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWKHPHWDDQDO\VLV

*URXSSDWLHQWDQGWUHDWPHQWFKDUDFWHULVWLFVDUHVKRZQLQ7DEOH

&ULWLFDO5HYLHZ

(LJKWVWXGLHVZHUHFODVVLÀHGDVWUXHH[SHULPHQWVDQGIRXUZHUHFODVVLÀHGDVTXDVL

H[SHULPHQWV7DEOH7KHVFRUHVRIWKHPHWKRGRORJLFDOTXDOLW\RIWKHWZHOYHLQFOXGHG

VWXGLHVVKRZDUDQJHIURPHLJKWWRIRXUWHHQSRLQWVWRRIWKHPD[LPXPVFRUH

RI SRLQWV2QHRXWRIHLJKWWUXHH[SHULPHQWVVSHFLÀHGWKHPHWKRGRIUDQGRPLVD

WLRQ^,QDOOEXWRQHRI WKHWUXHH[SHULPHQWV^DQGWZRRI WKHTXDVLH[SHULPHQWV^

WKHEOLQGLQJRI WKHREVHUYHUVZDVUHSRUWHG,QDOOEXWWZRWUXHH[SHULPHQWVGURSRXWV

IRUH[SHULPHQWDODQGFRQWUROJURXSZHUHGHVFULEHGVHSDUDWHO\^DQGLQWKUHH^ WKHWHPSRUDULO\GURSRXWVZHUHDOVRUHSRUWHG1RQHRIWKHVHVWXGLHVKRZHYHUDSSOLHG

LQWHQWLRQWRWUHDWDQDO\VLV,QRXWRITXDVLH[SHULPHQWVGURSRXWVLQERWKH[SHULPHQ

WDODQGFRQWUROJURXSZHUHGHVFULEHG^ZKHUHDVWKHVWXGLHVGLGQRWPHQWLRQWKHWHPSR

UDULO\GURSRXWVRUSHUIRUPDQLQWHQWLRQWRWUHDWDQDO\VLV2QHTXDVLH[SHULPHQWDSSOLHGD

ZRUVWFDVHDQDO\VLVIRUGURSRXWV^2QO\WZRWUXHH[SHULPHQWVDQGWZRTXDVLH[SHULPHQWV

UHSRUWHGWKHLQWHUDQGLQWUDUDWHUUHOLDELOLW\RI WKHXVHGRXWFRPHPHDVXUHVRUUHIHUUHGWR

VWXGLHVLQZKLFKWKHUHOLDELOLW\ZDVGHPRQVWUDWHG,QDOOEXWRQHRI WKHWUXH



7DEOH6WXG\FKDUDFWHULVWLFVRI WUXHDQGTXDVLH[SHULPHQWV

7WRWDO(H[SHULPHQWDOJURXS&FRQWUROJURXSQDQRWDSSOLFDEOH37 SK\VLRWKHUDS\*JURXS16QRWVLJQLÀFDQW27RFFXSDWLRQDO

WKHUDS\%7EHKDYLRXUDOWUHDWPHQWHJFXHVYLGHRIHHGEDFNDQGUHOD[DWLRQ1637QRQVSHFLÀFSV\FKRORJLFWUHDWPHQW637VSHHFKWKHUDS\

5$6UK\WKPLFDXGLWRU\VWLPXODWLRQ6,37VHOI LQWHUQDOO\SDFHGWUDLQLQJ17QRWUHDWPHQW FRQWUROJURXSGLYLGHGLQ6371 DQG

171 ‚0HDQLQWHUYHQWLRQWLPHRYHU&LQFDVHLQWHUYHQWLRQZDVJLYHQ

 ^{1 ,QGLY}

,RU

*URXS

*

0HDQDJH

\U“6'

'XUDWLRQ

RI3'\U

(W\SHRI

LQWHU

YHQWLRQ

(ZHHNV

ZHHNO\

IUHTXHQF\

PLQXWHV

(™

WLPHKU

&ZHHNV

ZHHNO\

IUHTXHQF\

PLQXWHV

&W\SHRI

LQWHUYHQWLRQ

&RPHOOD^  7 

( 

& 



( ,

& QD

“

“ “

“ SK\VLFDO

H[HUFLVHV   

QD QR

LQWHUYHQWLRQ

'DP^ 7 

( 

& 

( ,& , “

“ “

“ VHQVRU\

HQKDQFHG

37



 

 " FRQYHQWLRQDO

37 )RUPLVDQR^ 7  

( 

& 



( ,& , 

 

 37

H[HUFLVHV    DVVHVVPHQWV



*DXWKLHU^ 7 

( 

& 

( *& QD “

“ 16

16 37

H[HUFLVHV

27HGXF



  QD QR

LQWHUYHQWLRQ

 .DPVPD^ 7 

( 

& 



( ,& * “

“ “

“ VNLOOV

WUDLQLQJ YDULDEOH YDULDEOH  UHJXODU

H[HUFLVHV

 0RKU^ 7 

( 

& 



( *& * “

“ “

“ %7 " " " 1637

0OOHU^ 7 

( 

& 



( "

& " “

“ “

“ %7    1637DQG

37

1LHXZERHU^ 7 

( 

& 

( ,& QD 

 

 37

H[HUFLVHV

VNLOOV

WUDLQLQJ

  QD QR

LQWHUYHQWLRQ

 3DOPHU^ 7 

( 

& 



( *& * “

“ "

" 37

H[HUFLVHV    NDUDWHDUP

WUDLQLQJ

 3DWWL^ 7 

( 

& 



( ,& QD “

“ “

“ 3727

637 "" " QD QR

LQWHUYHQWLRQ

 6FKHQNPDQ^ 7 

( 

& 

( ,& QD “

“ "

" VNLOOVDQG

PRELOLW\

WUDLQLQJ





  QD ZDLWOLVWHG

7KDXW^{ } 7 

( 

& 



( ,& ,



“

“

“

“

“

“

5$6    6,3717



7RWDO 7 

( 

& 

 ( 

& ^‚ ( 

&  KU KU





H[SHULPHQWVDQGWZRRXWRI IRXUTXDVLH[SHULPHQWVFRLQWHUYHQWLRQVWKDWFRXOGOHDGWR

V\VWHPDWLFGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQFRQWURODQGH[SHULPHQWDOJURXSZHUHDYRLGHG^,Q

DOOWUXHH[SHULPHQWVDQGTXDVLH[SHULPHQWVEHWZHHQJURXSGLIIHUHQFHVLQUHOHYDQWSDWLHQW

FKDUDFWHULVWLFVHJDJHLQLWLDOQHXURORJLFDQG$'/VFRUHZHUHQRWVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀ

FDQW,QDOOEXWWZRVWXGLHVERWKSODQQHGGXUDWLRQDQGIUHTXHQF\RI WUHDWPHQWZHUH

UHSRUWHG)LQDOO\RQO\RQHWUXHH[SHULPHQW^DQGRQHRI WKHTXDVLH[SHUL

PHQWVUHSRUWHGWKHUHDOGXUDWLRQDQGIUHTXHQF\RIWUHDWPHQWRIDOOSDWLHQWV

7DEOH7KHPHWKRGRORJLFDOTXDOLW\RI VWXGLHVLQFOXGHGLQWKHPHWDDQDO\VLV

$UDQGRPLVDWLRQSURFHGXUH%PDWFKLQJSURFHGXUH&EOLQGLQJ'GURSRXWVDQDO\VLV(PHDVXUHLQVWUXPHQWV)FRQWUROFRLQWHUYHQWLRQV

(SDWLHQWFKDUDFWHULVWLFV+GRVHRI WKHUDS\,VWDWLVWLFVTXDVLTXDVLH[SHULPHQWDO\HVQRQRWPHQWLRQHGQDQRWDSSOLFDEOH

 VWXG\

GHVLJQ $

 %

 &

 '

 (

 )

 *

 +

 ,

 WRWDO

VFRUH UHSRUWHG

RXWFRPH

&RPHOOD^ 

WUXH 

 

QD       

 

 SRVLWLYH

'DP^ TXDVL QD          SRVLWLYH

)RUPLVDQR^ TXDVL QD          SRVLWLYH

*DXWKLHU^ WUXH  QD         SRVLWLYH

.DPVPD^ TXDVL  QD         SRVLWLYH

0RKU^ WUXH  QD         SRVLWLYH

0OOHU^ WUXH  QD         SRVLWLYH

1LHXZERHU^ TXDVL  QD         SRVLWLYH 3DOPHU^ WUXH  QD QD        SRVLWLYH 3DWWL^ WUXH  QD         SRVLWLYH 6FKHQNPDQ^ WUXH  QD   QD       SRVLWLYH 7KDXW^ WUXH  QD   QD      SRVLWLYH



6  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  



0HWDDQDO\VLV

)RUWKHIROORZLQJDQDO\VHVWKHPHDQJDLQEHWZHHQSUHDQGSRVWWHVWPHDVXUHPHQWVDQG

WKHVGRIWKHEDVHOLQHPHDVXUHPHQWVZHUHUHSRUWHGRUFRXOGEHFDOFXODWHG

$FWLYLWLHVRI GDLO\OLYLQJ

,QIRXUWUXHH[SHULPHQWVDQGWKUHHTXDVLH[SHULPHQWV^WKHHIIHFWVL]HVRI

WKHVWXGLHVZHUHSRROHGZKLFKUHVXOWHGLQDVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW6(6RI)LJXUH

,QGLYLGXDOHIIHFWVL]HVZHUHKRPRJHQHRXVDFURVVWKHVWXGLHV7ZR^RI VHYHQHIIHFW

VL]HVRIWKHLQGLYLGXDOVWXGLHVFRQFHUQLQJ$'/ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQW7DEOH^

7DEOH,QGLYLGXDOHIIHFWVL]HVZLWKUHJDUGWRDFWLYLWLHVRI GDLO\OLYLQJ

*DXWKLHU1 

&RPHOOD1 

.DPVPD1 

'DP1 

1LHXZERHU1 

6XPPDU\(6$'/

   

0XOOHU1 

0RKU1 

)LJXUH(IIHFWVL]HDQG&,

ZLWKUHJDUGWR$'/

3RVLWLYH VXPPDU\ HIIHFW VL]H LQ VWDQGDUG

GHYLDWLRQXQLWVLQGLFDWHVEHWWHURXWFRPHIRU

WKH H[SHULPHQWDO JURXS FRPSDUHG ZLWK WKH

FRQWUROJURXS

  6WXG\

$XWKRU 1 W\SH (6 VG ,&ORZ ,&KLJK

*DXWKLHU^  7     

&RPHOOD^  7     

.DPVPD^  4     

'DP^  4     

0RKU^  7     

0OOHU^  7     

1LHXZERHU^  4     

7RWDO        

(6HIIHFWVL]H7WUXHH[SHULPHQW4TXDVLH[SHULPHQW 4V QRWVLJQLÀFDQWKRPRJHQRXV



:DONLQJVSHHG

,QWKUHHWUXHH[SHULPHQWV^DQGWKUHHTXDVLH[SHULPHQWV^WKHHIIHFWVL]HVRI

WKHVL[VWXGLHVZHUHSRROHG)LJXUH%HFDXVHLQGLYLGXDOHIIHFWVL]HVZHUHKHWHURJHQH

RXVDFURVVWKHVWXGLHVDUDQGRPHIIHFWVPRGHOZDVDSSOLHGUHVXOWLQJLQDVLJQLÀFDQW6(6

RI 7KUHHRXWRI VL[HIIHFWVL]HVRIWKHLQGLYLGXDOVWXGLHVFRQFHUQLQJZDONLQJVSHHG

ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQW7DEOH^

  6WXG\

$XWKRU 1 W\SH (6 VG ,&ORZ ,&KLJK

)RUPLVDQR^  4    

.DPVPD^  4    

3DWWL^  7    

7KDXW^  7    

6FKHQNPDQ^  7    

1LHXZERHU^  4    

7RWDO      

(6HIIHFWVL]H7WUXHH[SHULPHQW4TXDVLH[SHULPHQW

7DEOH,QGLYLGXDOHIIHFWVL]HVZLWKUHJDUGWRZDONLQJVSHHG

 

6XPPDU\(6ZDONLQJVSHHG 1LHXZERHU1 

6FKHQNPDQ1 

7KDXW1 

3DWWL1 

.DPVPD1 

)RUPLVDQR1 

  

)LJXUH(IIHFWVL]HDQG

&,ZLWKUHJDUGWRZDONLQJVSHHG 3RVLWLYH VXPPDU\ HIIHFW VL]H LQ VWDQGDUG

GHYLDWLRQXQLWVLQGLFDWHVEHWWHURXWFRPHIRU

WKH H[SHULPHQWDO JURXS FRPSDUHG ZLWK WKH

FRQWUROJURXS



6WULGHOHQJWK

,QWZRWUXHH[SHULPHQWV^DQGWZRTXDVLH[SHULPHQWV^WKHHIIHFWVL]HVRIWKHIRXU

VWXGLHVZHUHSRROHGZKLFKUHVXOWHGLQDVLJQLÀFDQW6(6RI)LJXUH,QGLYLGXDO

HIIHFWVL]HVZHUHKRPRJHQHRXVDFURVVWKHVWXGLHV7ZRRXWRI IRXUHIIHFWVL]HVRIWKH

LQGLYLGXDOVWXGLHVFRQFHUQLQJVWULGHOHQJWKZHUHVLJQLÀFDQW7DEOH^

  6WXG\

$XWKRU 1 W\SH (6 VG ,&ORZ ,&KLJK

.DPVPD^  4    

3DWWL^  7    

7KDXW^  7    

1LHZERHU^  4    

7RWDO       

(6HIIHFWVL]H7WUXHH[SHULPHQW4TXDVLH[SHULPHQW 4V QRWVLJQLÀFDQWKRPRJHQHRXV

7DEOH,QGLYLGXDOHIIHFWVL]HVZLWKUHJDUGWRVWULGHOHQJWK 3DWWL1 

7KDXW1 

1LHXZERHU1 

6XPPDU\(6VWULGHOHQJWK

   

.DPVPD1 

)LJXUH(IIHFWVL]HDQG

&,ZLWKUHJDUGWR

VWULGHOHQJWK

3RVLWLYH VXPPDU\ HIIHFW VL]H LQ

VWDQGDUG GHYLDWLRQ XQLWV LQGLFDWHV

EHWWHU RXWFRPH IRU WKH H[SHULPHQWDO

JURXS FRPSDUHG ZLWK WKH FRQWURO

JURXS



1HXURORJLFDOVLJQV

,QWKUHHWUXHH[SHULPHQWV^DQGWZRTXDVLH[SHULPHQWV^WKHHIIHFWVL]HVRIWKH

WKUHHVWXGLHVZHUHSRROHGZKLFKUHVXOWHGLQDQRQVLJQLÀFDQW6(6RI)LJXUH

,QGLYLGXDOHIIHFWVL]HVZHUHKRPRJHQHRXVDFURVVWKHVWXGLHV1RQHRI WKHHIIHFWVL]HVRI

WKHLQGLYLGXDOVWXGLHVFRQFHUQLQJQHXURORJLFDOVLJQVZHUHVLJQLÀFDQW7DEOH

)RUPLVDQR1 

&RPHOOD1 

.DPVPD1 

6XPPDU\(6

QHXURORJLFDOVLJQV

   

0XOOHU1 

0RKU1 

)LJXUH(IIHFWVL]HDQG

&,ZLWKUHJDUGWRQHXURORJL

FDOVLJQV

3RVLWLYH VXPPDU\ HIIHFW VL]H LQ

VWDQGDUG GHYLDWLRQ XQLWV LQGLFDWHV

EHWWHU RXWFRPH IRU WKH H[SHULPHQWDO

JURXS FRPSDUHG ZLWK WKH FRQWURO

JURXS

  6WXG\

$XWKRU 1 W\SH (6 VG ,&ORZ ,&KLJK

)RUPLVDQR^  4    

&RPHOOD^  7    

.DPVPD^  4    

0RKU^  7    

0OOHU^  7    

7RWDO       

(6HIIHFWVL]H7WUXHH[SHULPHQW4TXDVLH[SHULPHQW 4V QRWVLJQLÀFDQWKRPRJHQHRXV

7DEOH,QGLYLGXDOHIIHFWVL]HVZLWKUHJDUGWRQHXURORJLFDOVLJQV



'LVFXVVLRQ

2QWKHEDVLVRI SUHYLRXVUHYLHZVLWZDVK\SRWKHVLVHGWKDWSK\VLRWKHUDS\LVDQLPSRUWDQW

DGMXQFWWRSKDUPDFRORJLFDOWUHDWPHQWLQSDWLHQWVZLWK3'ZLWKUHJDUGWRQHXURORJLFDO

V\PSWRPVHJWUHPRUEUDG\NLQHVLDDQGULJLGLW\ZDONLQJDELOLW\$'/DQG42/

7KHUHVXOWVRIRXUUHVHDUFKV\QWKHVLVVXSSRUWWKHK\SRWKHVLVWKDWSDWLHQWVZLWK3'EH

QHÀWIURPSK\VLRWKHUDS\LQWHUPVRI DFWLYLWLHVRIGDLO\OLYLQJDQGZDONLQJDELOLW\ZDONLQJ

VSHHGDQGVWULGHOHQJWKEXWQRWLQWHUPVRI QHXURORJLFDOVLJQV,QRQO\RQHRXWRI 

VWXGLHVWKHHIIHFWRISK\VLRWKHUDS\RQWKH42/ZDVDVVHVVHG^7KHVHÀQGLQJVVXJ

JHVWWKDWPRELOLW\FDQEHPRUHHDVLO\LQÁXHQFHGE\SK\VLRWKHUDS\WKDQE\QHXURORJLFDO

V\PSWRPV,WVKRXOGEHQRWLFHGKRZHYHUWKDWSK\VLRWKHUDS\LVPDLQO\IRFXVHGRQPRELO

LW\UDWKHUWKDQQHXURORJLFDOV\PSWRPVVXFKDVULJLGLW\DQGWUHPRU7KHQRQVLJQLÀFDQW

ÀQGLQJZLWKUHJDUGWRQHXURORJLFV\PSWRPVPHQWLRQHGSUHYLRXVO\PD\DOVREHFDXVHG

E\WKHOLPLWHGQXPEHURI VWXGLHVLQFOXGHGLQWKHPHWDDQDO\VLVÀYHRXWRI  7KUHHPRUHVWXGLHVLQFOXGHGQHXURORJLFV\PSWRPVDVDQRXWFRPHSDUDPHWHUEXWSUR

GXFHGLQVXIÀFLHQWGDWDWRLQFRUSRUDWHWKHÀQGLQJVLQWKHPHWDDQDO\VLV7KHKH

WHURJHQHRXV6(6ZLWKUHJDUGWRZDONLQJVSHHGLVFDXVHGE\WKHODUJHHIIHFWVL]HVUHSRUWHG

E\)RUPLVDQRHWDO^([FOXGLQJWKH)RUPLVDQRVWXG\IURPWKHPHWDDQDO\VLVUHVXOWHGLQ

DKRPRJHQHRXVDQGMXVWVLJQLÀFDQW6(6RI&,

,QJHQHUDOWKHPHWKRGRORJLFDOTXDOLW\RIWKHLQFOXGHGVWXGLHVZDVORZDQGUDQJHGIURP

WRWUXHH[SHULPHQWDOTXDVLH[SHULPHQWDO3RVWKRFDQDO\VLV

VKRZHGQRVLJQLÀFDQWHIIHFWRIWKHRYHUDOOPHWKRGRORJLFDOTXDOLW\VFRUHRQWKH6(6V,Q

DGGLWLRQQRVLJQLÀFDQWLQÁXHQFHRIEOLQGLQJWKHREVHUYHUZDVIRXQG

:HKDYHWUDQVIRUPHGWKHHIIHFWVL]HVUHSRUWHGLQVGXQLWVWRSHUFHQWDJHVRULQLWLDOO\XVHG

PHDVXUHPHQWXQLWVLQFOXGLQJDFRUUHFWLRQIRUQQXPEHURI SDWLHQWVLQHDFKVWXG\7KLV

UHVXOWHGLQDVPDOOEXWVXEVWDQWLDOLPSURYHPHQWLQ$'/RI DSSUR[LPDWHO\LQZDO

NLQJVSHHGRI DSSUR[LPDWHO\PVNPKDQGLQVWULGHOHQJWKRIDSSUR[LPDWHO\

P$OWKRXJKWKHVPDOO6(6VZLWKUHJDUGWR$'/DQGZDONLQJDELOLW\DUHVWDWLVWLFDOO\

VLJQLÀFDQWLWUHPDLQVRSHQWRIXUWKHUGLVFXVVLRQZKHWKHUWKHHIIHFWVL]HVDUHFOLQLFDOO\

UHOHYDQW

)XWXUHZHOOFRQWUROOHGWULDOVZLWKVXIÀFLHQWSRZHUVKRXOGIRFXVRQWKHFOLQLFDOUHOHYDQFH

RI HIIHFWVL]HVLQDGGLWLRQWRWKHLQÁXHQFHRIGLIIHUHQWIUHTXHQFLHVDQGGXUDWLRQRI

WUHDWPHQWVHVVLRQVDVWKHLQWHQVLW\RIWUHDWPHQWFDQEHRIFRQVLGHUDEOHLQÁXHQFHRQWKH

HIIHFWVRIWUHDWPHQW^



,WDOVRUHPDLQVXQFOHDUZKLFKFRPSRQHQWRI WKHDSSOLHGSK\VLRWKHUDS\UHJLPHFDXVHV

WKHVLJQLÀFDQWHIIHFWVL]HVUHSRUWHG$QLPSRUWDQWFRPSRQHQWRISK\VLRWKHUDS\LQWKH

LQFOXGHGVWXGLHVLVWKHDSSOLFDWLRQRIH[WHUQDODXGLWRU\DQGYLVXDOUK\WKPVGXULQJJDLW

WUDLQLQJ7KHUHVXOWVRIDUDQGRPLVHGFRQWUROOHGWULDOE\7KDXWHWDOVKRZWKDWWKHDS

SOLFDWLRQRI UK\WKPLFDXGLWRU\VWLPXODWLRQLQWKHKRPHVLWXDWLRQUHVXOWHGLQVLJQLÀFDQW

LPSURYHPHQWLQZDONLQJVSHHGVWULGHOHQJWKDQGHOHFWURP\RJUDSKLFDFWLYLW\RI UHOHYDQW

ORZHUH[WUHPLW\PXVFOHVFRPSDUHGZLWKDFRQWUROJURXS^)XWXUHVWXGLHVVKRXOGIRFXVRQ

WKHJHQHUDOLVDELOLW\RI WKHVHUHVXOWVWR$'/42/DQGQHXURORJLFV\PSWRPV

6RPHVWXGLHVVWXGLHGWKHHIIHFWRIDSK\VLRWKHUDS\JURXSWUHDWPHQWSURJUDP^

*DXWKLHU^DQG3DOPHU^UHSRUWHGLPSURYHPHQWRI SV\FKRORJLFDOZHOOEHLQJ*DXWKLHU

DOVRUHSRUWHGIDFLOLWDWLRQRIVHYHUDOSRVLWLYHEHKDYLRXUDOFKDQJHVDVDGGLWLRQDOHIIHFWV

RI JURXSWUHDWPHQW7KH¶WUXH·HIIHFWRIWUHDWLQJ3'SDWLHQWVLQDJURXSFRPSDUHGZLWK

LQGLYLGXDOVWLOOQHHGVWREHVRUWHGRXW

$OOVWXGLHVXVHGIRUWKHPHWDDQDO\VLVUHSRUWHGDVWDEOH3'PHGLFDWLRQUHJLPHWKURXJK

RXWWKHLQWHUYHQWLRQSHULRG2QO\WKUHHVWXGLHVVWDQGDUGLVHGWKHDVVHVVPHQWWLPHVEDVHG

RQWKHWLPHRIPHGLFDWLRQLQWDNH^,QIXWXUHVWXGLHVDVWDEOH3'PHGLFDWLRQUHJLPH

DQGDVWDQGDUGLVDWLRQRI WKHDVVHVVPHQWWLPHVDUHVWURQJO\UHFRPPHQGHGWRDYRLGWKH

FRQIRXQGLQJE\PHGLFDWLRQ

)LQDOO\DFKDOOHQJLQJTXHVWLRQIRUWKHQHDUIXWXUHLVZKHWKHURYHUWKHORQJWHUPWKHDSSOL

FDWLRQRI SK\VLRWKHUDS\RUH[HUFLVHWKHUDS\FDQUHVXOWLQDUHGXFHGXVDJHRI PHGLFDWLRQ

DQGVORZGRZQWKHGHJHQHUDWLRQRI WKHGRSDPLQHUJLFV\VWHP

&RQFOXVLRQ

,PSRUWDQWOLPLWDWLRQVRI WKHSUHVHQWUHVHDUFKV\QWKHVLVDUHWKHVPDOODPRXQWRIFRQ

WUROOHGLQWHUYHQWLRQVWXGLHVLQFOXGHGWKHSRRUPHWKRGRORJLFDOTXDOLW\RIPRVWRI WKH

LQWHUYHQWLRQVWXGLHVSXEOLFDWLRQELDVE\XQSXEOLVKHGSDSHUVDQGVWXGLHVSXEOLVKHGLQ

IRUHLJQODQJXDJHV+RZHYHUWKHLQFUHDVLQJQXPEHURI ZHOOFRQWUROOHGLQWHUYHQWLRQVWX

GLHVSXEOLVKHGLQWKHODVWÀYH\HDUVKROGVDQLPSRUWDQWSURPLVHIRUWKHIXWXUHZLWKUHJDUG

WRHYLGHQFHEDVHGSK\VLRWKHUDS\

$FNQRZOHGJHPHQW

:HWKDQNWKH3DUNLQVRQ3DWLsQWHQ9HUHQLJLQJ>'XWFK3DUNLQVRQVGLVHDVHVRFLHW\@DQG

3ULQVHV%HDWUL[)RQGV>3ULQFHVV%HDWUL[)RXQGDWLRQ@UHI3IRUWKHLUJUDQWV



$SSHQGL[0HWKRGRORJLFDOVFRULQJOLVW



0HWKRGRORJLFDODVSHFW



$5DQGRPLVDWLRQ

SURFHGXUHLVDGHTXDWHLI



%0DWFKLQJSURFHGXUHLV

DGHTXDWHLI



&%OLQGLQJSURFHGXUHLV

DGHTXDWHLI





''URSRXWVDQGLQWHQWLRQ

WRWUHDWDQDO\VLVDUHDGHTXDWH

LI



(0HDVXUHPHQW

LQVWUXPHQWVDUHDGHTXDWHLI









)&RQWURORIFR

LQWHUYHQWLRQVLVDGHTXDWH

LI

*&RPSDUDELOLW\RISDWLHQW

FKDUDFWHULVWLFVLVDGHTXDWHLI



+&RQWUROIRUGRVHRI

WKHUDS\LVDGHTXDWHLI



,$SSOLHGVWDWLVWLFVDUH

FRPSOHWHLI





2SHUDWLRQDOLVDWLRQRIYDOLGLW\FULWHULD



 5DQGRPLVHGDOORFDWLRQRYHUH[SHULPHQWDODQGFRQWUROJURXSVLVDSSOLHG

 5DQGRPVHTXHQFHJHQHUDWLRQLVDSSOLHGHJUDQGRPQXPEHUWDEOHFRLQ

WRVVLQJFRPSXWHUUDQGRPQXPEHUVRUVKXIIOLQJ

3DWLHQWVDUHPDWFKHGDFFRUGLQJWRUHOHYDQWSDWLHQWFKDUDFWHULVWLFV

 $JH

 $'/VFRUH

 2EVHUYHUVDUHNHSWXQDZDUHRIWKHJURXSVWRZKLFKSDWLHQWVKDYHEHHQ

DVVLJQHG

 7KRVHSHUIRUPLQJVWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVDUHNHSWXQDZDUHRIWKHJURXSVWR

ZKLFKSDWLHQWVKDYHEHHQDVVLJQHG

 3DWLHQWVDUHNHSWXQDZDUHZLWKUHVSHFWWRWKHFRQGLWLRQWRZKLFKWKH\KDYH

EHHQDVVLJQHG

 7KHQXPEHURIGURSRXWVDUHGHVFULEHGIRUHDFKJURXSVHSDUDWHO\

 7KHQXPEHURILQWHUFXUUHQWGURSRXWVDUHGHVFULEHGIRUHDFKJURXS

VHSDUDWHO\

 ,QWHQWLRQWRWUHDWDQDO\VLVRUZRUVWFDVHDQDO\VLVKDVEHHQDSSOLHG

 6WDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLILFDQWWHVWUHWHVWFRUUHODWLRQFRHIILFLHQWVDQGRULQWUD

LQWHUREVHUYHUUHOLDELOLW\RIUHOHYDQWPHDVXUHPHQWLQVWUXPHQWVKDYHEHHQ

UHSRUWHGE\WKHDXWKRUVRUKDYHEHHQHVWDEOLVKHGLQVWXGLHVZKLFKDUHFLWHG

E\WKHDXWKRUV

 7KHUHOHYDQW$'/PHDVXUHPHQWLQVWUXPHQWVDUHFRPSDUHGVWDWLVWLFDOO\ZLWK

RWKHULQVWUXPHQWVPHDVXULQJWKHVDPHPRGDOLW\E\WKHDXWKRUVRULQVWXGLHV

UHSRUWHGE\WKHDXWKRUV

 7KHUHOHYDQWQHXURORJLFDOPHDVXUHPHQWLQVWUXPHQWVDUHFRPSDUHG

VWDWLVWLFDOO\ZLWKRWKHULQVWUXPHQWVPHDVXULQJWKHVDPHPRGDOLW\E\WKH

DXWKRUVRULQVWXGLHVUHSRUWHGE\WKHDXWKRUV

 2WKHUFRLQWHUYHQWLRQVOHDGLQJWRV\VWHPDWLFGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQJURXSVDUH

DYRLGHG

 $GMXQFWLYHPHGLFDOLQWHUYHQWLRQVDUHUHSRUWHG

 5HOHYDQWSDWLHQWFKDUDFWHULVWLFVHJDJHLQLWLDOQHXURORJLFDODQG$'/

VFRUHDUHQRWVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLILFDQWGLIIHUHQWEHWZHHQH[SHULPHQWDODQG

FRQWUROJURXSV

 3UHGHWHUPLQHGUHKDELOLWDWLRQWLPHLQKRXUVPLQXWHVDQGIUHTXHQF\KDYH

EHHQUHSRUWHGIRUH[SHULPHQWDODQGFRQWUROJURXSV

 $FWXDOVSHQGUHKDELOLWDWLRQWLPHLQKRXUVPLQXWHVDQGIUHTXHQF\KDYH

EHHQUHSRUWHGIRUH[SHULPHQWDODQGFRQWUROJURXSV

 7KHJDLQRIERWKH[SHULPHQWDODQGFRQWUROJURXSVKDVEHHQUHSRUWHG

 6GRIWKHJDLQKDVEHHQUHSRUWHGIRUH[SHULPHQWDODQGFRQWUROJURXSV

 1XPEHURISDWLHQWVSHUJURXSKDVEHHQUHSRUWHGIRUH[SHULPHQWDODQG

FRQWUROVJURXSV

6FRUH

QR 

\HV