De LeefOmgevingsVerkenner. Technische Documentatie | RIVM

0HWPHGHZHUNLQJYDQ _{5HVHDUFK,QVWLWXWHRI.QRZOHGJH6\VWHPV} 0DDVWULFKW _{0HPRULDO8QLYHUVLW\} 6W-RKQ¶V1IOG &DQDGD 5,90UDSSRUW

'H/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHU

7HFKQLVFKH'RFXPHQWDWLH 7GH1LMV*(QJHOHQ_5:KLWH_+YDQ 'HOGHQ,8OMHH 'LWRQGHU]RHNZHUGYHUULFKWLQRSGUDFKWHQWHQODVWHYDQGHGLUHFWLHYDQKHW5,90LQKHW NDGHUYDQSURMHFW1DWLRQDOH/HHI2PJHYLQJV.ZDOLWHLW 5,903RVWEXV%$%LOWKRYHQWHOHIRRQID[ 5,903RVWEXV%$%LOWKRYHQWHOHIRRQID[

SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW

$EVWUDFW

7KLVUHSRUWIRUPVWKHWHFKQLFDOGRFXPHQWDWLRQRIWKH(QYLURQPHQW([SORUHUYHUVLRQ 7KH(QYLURQPHQW([SORUHULVEHLQJGHYHORSHGIRUUDSLGLQWHJUDWHGDVVHVVPHQWVRIWKHHIIHFWV RIGLIIHUHQWVSDWLDOSROLF\RSWLRQVEDVHGRQHFRQRPLFVRFLDODQGHFRORJLFDOYDOXHV,WZRUNV E\VNHWFKLQJWKHVSDWLDOGHYHORSPHQWVODQGXVHWUDQVIRUPDWLRQVDQGHIIHFWVIRUWKH 1HWKHUODQGVRQDVHWRILQGLFDWRUVXSWRXQGHUJLYHQGHPRJUDSKLFDQGHFRQRPLF SURJQRVHV

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

,QKRXG

6DPHQYDWWLQJ  ,QOHLGLQJ  2S]HWYDQGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHU  'RHOVWHOOLQJHQXLWJDQJVSXQWHQ  +HWH[SORUDWLHYHNDUDNWHU  +HWFRPSOH[HVRFLDDOHFRQRPLVFKHV\VWHHP  2S]HWYDQKHWPRGHO  +HW0DFURPRGHO  5XLPWHOLMNHLQWHUDFWLHRSUHJLRQDDOQLYHDX  $OJHPHQHRS]HWYDQKHW0DFURPRGHO  (FRQRPLH  'HPRJUDILH  /DQGJHEUXLN  9HUNHHU  *HGHWDLOOHHUGHEHVFKULMYLQJ  *URHL$FWLYLWHLW1HGHUODQG  $FWLYLWHLWORNDDO  /DQGSURGXFWLYLWHLW  /DQGJHEUXLN  +HWYHUVFKLOLQµZRQHQGXQ¶HQµZRQHQGLFKWEHYRONW¶  9UDDJQDDU$FWLYLWHLWHQ  3RWHQWLDOHQ  3URGXFWLHWRHJHYRHJGHZDDUGHHQZHUNJHOHJHQKHLG  9HUNHHUFRQJHVWLHHQLQWHQVLWHLW  +HW0LFURPRGHO  5XLPWHOLMNHG\QDPLHNRSKHWORNDDOQLYHDX  +HWµ&HOOXODLUH$XWRPDWD¶0LFURPRGHO  /DQGJHEUXLNIXQFWLHV  ,QYORHGYDQGHRPJHYLQJ  :LVVHOZHUNLQJWXVVHQODQGJHEUXLNIXQFWLHV  .HQPHUNHQYDQGH&HOOXODLUHUXLPWH  5XLPWHOLMNHG\QDPLHNGRRU&HOOXODLUH$XWRPDWD  *HGHWDLOOHHUGHEHVFKULMYLQJ  7UDQVLWLHSRWHQWLDDO  /DQGJHEUXLN  *HVFKLNWKHLG  %HOHLG  %HUHLNEDDUKHLG

SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW  ,QGLFDWRUHQ  ,QOHLGLQJ  (FRQRPLH  %UXWRUHJLRQDOHSURGXFWLH  %UXWRUHJLRQDDOSURGXFW  $JUDULVFKHJURQGSULMV*URQGSULMV  /RNDOHEHUHLNEDDUKHLG  5HJLRQDOHEHUHLNEDDUKHLG  9HVWLJLQJVNOLPDDW  :HUNGLFKWKHLG  :HUNJHOHJHQKHLG  %HUHLNEDDUKHLGYDQDUEHLGVSODDWVHQHQEHURHSVEHYRONLQJ  (FRORJLH  %HERXZGHHQRSHQUXLPWH  9HUVQLSSHULQJQDWXXU9HUVQLSSHULQJ  %HERXZLQJLQ«9HUVWRULQJ  (PLVVLHVYDQ12[30HQ%D3GRRUYHUNHHU  *HOXLGLQ6WLOWHJHELHGHQ  6RFLDDOFXOWXUHHO  1DELMKHLGYDQ%HUHLNEDDUKHLG  *HOXLGLQZRRQJHELHGHQ  5HFUHDWLHDDQERGHQGUXN  ,QZRQHUGLFKWKHLG:RRQGLFKWKHLG  9HUDQGHULQJSLHNDIYRHU:DWHURYHUODVW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

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

6DPHQYDWWLQJ

'H/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHUZRUGWRQWZLNNHOGLQRSGUDFKWYDQGHGLUHFWLHYDQKHW5,90 +HWEHRRJWHHQPRGHOV\VWHHPWH]LMQRPVQHOLQWHUDFWLHIGHHIIHFWHQYDQDOWHUQDWLHYH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EHOHLG]RDOVYDVWJHOHJGLQRPGH $F9,1(;9520HQKHW6WUXFWXXUVFKHPD*URHQH5XLPWH/19 +RHGH]HRQWZLNNHOLQJHQHONDDUGLUHFWRILQGLUHFWEHwQYORHGHQNDQDDQKDQGYDQVSHFLILHNH LQGLFDWRUHQYDQXLWHHQHFRQRPLVFKHFRORJLVFKRIVRFLDDOSHUVSHFWLHIEHRRUGHHOGZRUGHQ 0RPHQWHHOLVHHQHHUVWHVWHUNXLWHHQORSHQGHVHWLQGLFDWRUHQRSHUDWLRQHHOZDDURQGHU LQZRQHUGLFKWKHGHQZHUNJHOHJHQKHLGDDQWDVWLQJYDQODQGVFKDSSHQHQGHNDQVRS RYHUVWURPLQJ 'HNHUQYDQGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHUZRUGWJHYRUPGGRRUHHQG\QDPLVFKUXLPWHOLMN DOORFDWLHPRGHO,QKHWPDFURPRGHOZRUGWGHMDDUOLMNVHRQWZLNNHOLQJYDQKHWUXLPWHJHEUXLN YRRUYHUVFKLOOHQGHODQGJHEUXLNVIXQFWLHVLQGHWLMGEHUHNHQG(HQUXLPWHOLMNLQWHUDFWLHPRGHO YHUGHHOWGHQDWLRQDOHJURHLYDQGHEHYRONLQJHQGHHFRQRPLVFKHSURGXFWLHRYHUGH&2523 UHJLR¶V*HJHYHQRQGHUPHHUGHEHVFKLNEDUHUXLPWHZRUGWGH]HUHJLRQDOHRQWZLNNHOLQJYDQ KHWDDQWDOLQZRQHUVHQGHSURGXFWLHYHUWDDOGQDDUGHYHUDQGHULQJYDQGHYHUVFKLOOHQGH ODQGJHEUXLNIXQFWLHV+HWYHUDQGHUGHUXLPWHJHEUXLNZRUGWYHUYROJHQVLQKHWPLFURPRGHO JHSODDWVWRSGHNDDUWYDQ1HGHUODQGPHWHHQUXLPWHOLMNHUHVROXWLHYDQP'H JHVSHFLILFHHUGHLQGLFDWRUHQZRUGHQEHUHNHQGRSEDVLVYDQGH]HQLHXZHODQGJHEUXLNVNDDUW $IKDQNHOLMNYDQGHLQGLFDWRUZRUGHQVSHFLILHNHPRGHOOHQHQDDQYXOOHQGH*,6LQIRUPDWLH JHEUXLNW 'LWUDSSRUWYRUPWGHWHFKQLVFKHGRFXPHQWDWLHYDQGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHUYHUVLH +HWEHVFKULMIWGHEHODQJULMNVWHXLWJDQJVSXQWHQHQRYHUZHJLQJHQGLHLQGHRS]HWYDQKHW V\VWHHP]LMQPHHJHQRPHQGHZHUNLQJYDQKHWPDFURPRGHOKHWPLFURPRGHOGHKXLGLJHVHW PHWLQGLFDWRUHQDOVRRNGHRSHUDWLRQDOLVDWLHYDQKHWV\VWHHP]RDOVGLHLQKHWSURMHFW .DDUWEHHOGHQ5,90LVWRHJHSDVW,QGDWSURMHFWLVGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHULQ VDPHQZHUNLQJPHWGH5LMNVSODQRORJLVFKH'LHQVWWRHJHSDVWRPGHPRJHOLMNHHIIHFWHQYDQ YHUVFKLOOHQGHYDULDQWHQYDQKHWUXLPWHOLMNEHOHLGWHYHUNHQQHQ +HWUDSSRUWZRUGWDIJHVORWHQPHWHHQDDQWDODDQEHYHOLQJHQGLHPHWQDPHEHWUHNNLQJKHEEHQ RSFRQVLVWHQWLHYDQJHRLQIRUPDWLHYDOLGDWLHYDQKHWPRGHOHQYHUGHUHRQWZLNNHOLQJYDQGH PRGXOHVGLHGHYHUVFKLOOHQGHDFWRUHQEHVFKULMYHQWHZHWHQODQGERXZZRQHQZHUNHQHQ QDWXXU

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

 ,QOHLGLQJ

'HRQWZLNNHOLQJYDQGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHUYLQGWSODDWVLQRSGUDFKWYDQGHGLUHFWLH YDQKHW5,90HQLVJHVWDUWLQVDPHQKDQJPHWGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV%DODQV5,90 9DQXLWKHWFRQFHSWµOHHIRPJHYLQJ¶ZRUGWGHSUREOHPDWLHNLQHHQEHSDDOGHUHJLRLQRQGHUOLQJH VDPHQKDQJEHVFKRXZG=RVFKHWVWGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV%DODQVGHKLVWRULVFKHRQWZLNNHOLQJYDQ 1HGHUODQGYDQXLWSHUVSHFWLHYHQHFRQRPLVFKHFRORJLVFKHQVRFLDDORIWHZHOJHOGJURHQHQ JHYRHO(ONSHUVSHFWLHIXLWGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV%DODQVLQWHJUHHUWVWHUNXLWHHQORSHQGHDVSHFWHQ ,QDDQYXOOLQJKLHURSZLOOHQEHOHLGVPDNHUVZHWHQZDWGHSRWHQWLsOHHIIHFWHQRSGH OHHIRPJHYLQJ]LMQYDQPRJHOLMNHEHOHLGVPDDWUHJHOHQ:DDUGH%DODQVWHUXJNLMNWRYHUGH SHULRGH±ULFKWGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHU]LMQEOLNRSGHWRHNRPVW+RH]LHW 1HGHUODQGHULQXLW"9HUJHOLMNEDDUPHWGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV%DODQVLVKHWGDDUELMGH EHGRHOLQJGDWYHUVFKLOOHQGHUHOHYDQWHDVSHFWHQYDQGHI\VLHNHOHHIRPJHYLQJWHQDDQ]LHQYDQ UXLPWHQDWXXUPLOLHXJH]RQGKHLGPDDURRNµ]DFKWH¶VRFLDOHDVSHFWHQ]RDOVEHOHYLQJ ZDDUGHULQJHQSHUFHSWLHZRUGHQPHHJHQRPHQ 'H/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHUVFKHWVWDOOHUHHUVWGHUXLPWHOLMNHRQWZLNNHOLQJYDQ1HGHUODQG RSEDVLVYDQGHPRJUDILVFKHHQHFRQRPLVFKHRQWZLNNHOLQJHQ8LWJDDQGHYDQGH]HUXLPWHOLMNH RQWZLNNHOLQJHQEHRRJWGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHUHHQEHHOGWHVFKHWVHQYDQHFRQRPLVFKH HFRORJLVFKHHQVRFLDOHLQGLFDWRUHQ0RPHQWHHOLVHHQJURWHVHWDDQLQGLFDWRUHQRSHUDWLRQHHO YDULs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wQYORHGHQ:DDUQHHPWGHNDQVRSRYHUVWURPLQJHQWRH":DDURQWZLNNHOHQ]LFK ZRRQZLMNHQLQZDDUGHYROOHODQGVFKDSSHQ"+RHRQWZLNNHOWGHQDWXXUNZDOLWHLW]LFK":DDULV VSUDNHYDQWHJHQVWULMGLJHEHODQJHQ" 'HNHUQYDQGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHUZRUGWJHYRUPGGRRUHHQG\QDPLVFKUXLPWHOLMN DOORFDWLHPRGHO:KLWHHQ(QJHOHQ(QJHOHQHWDO'HMDDUOLMNVHRQWZLNNHOLQJ YDQKHWUXLPWHJHEUXLNZRUGWYRRUYHUVFKLOOHQGHODQGJHEUXLNVIXQFWLHVLQGHWLMGEHUHNHQGHQ JHSODDWVWRSGHNDDUWYDQ1HGHUODQG2SEDVLVYDQKHWWRHNRPVWLJHODQGJHEUXLNZRUGHQHHQ JURRWDDQWDOHIIHFWLQGLFDWRUHQXLWJHUHNHQG$IKDQNHOLMNYDQGHLQGLFDWRUZRUGHQVSHFLILHNH PRGHOOHQHQDDQYXOOHQGH*,6LQIRUPDWLHJHEUXLNW +HWPRGHOLVRSJH]HWDOVHHQUDDPZHUNZDDULQGHSURFHVVHQZRUGHQEHVFKUHYHQRS UXLPWHOLMNHVFKDDOQLYHDXVKHWQDWLRQDOHQLYHDXKHWUHJLRQDOH&2523QLYHDXHQKHWORNDOH QLYHDXEHVWDDQGHXLWJULGFHOOHQPHWHHQUHVROXWLHYDQPHWHU9DQXLWGHERYHQVWHODDJ ZRUGHQGHSURFHVVHQRSKHWUHJLRQDOHHQYHUYROJHQVRSKHWORNDOHQLYHDXDDQJHVWXXUGWHUZLMO YDQXLWKHWRQGHUVWHQLYHDXLQIRUPDWLHZRUGWGRRUJHJHYHQDDQKHWUHJLRQDOHVFKDDOQLYHDX ZDDUGRRUHUHHQVWHUNHWHUXJNRSSHOLQJRQWVWDDWWXVVHQGHSURFHVVHQRSGHYHUVFKLOOHQGH

SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW VFKDDOQLYHDXV'RRUKHWV\VWHHPRSWH]HWWHQDOVHHQUDDPZHUNNXQQHQWDOYDQDDQYXOOHQGHHQ VSHFLILHNHPRGXOHQLQJHEHGZRUGHQ 'H/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHUKHHIWHHQLQWHUIDFHZDDUPHHDOOHPRGHOLQSXWJHJHYHQV JHRJUDILVFKHLQIRUPDWLHHQSDUDPHWHUVELMJHVWHOGNXQQHQZRUGHQ8OMHHHWDO8VHU 0DQXDO'DDUQDDVW]LMQVRIWZDUHWRROVRQWZLNNHOGRPVQHOQLHXZHLQYRHUNDDUWHQWHNXQQHQ GHILQLsUHQHQGHRXWSXWYDQKHWPRGHOWHDQDO\VHUHQ 7LMGHQVGHRQWZLNNHOLQJYDQKHWLQVWUXPHQWLVJHWUDFKW]RYHHOPRJHOLMNVDPHQWHZHUNHQPHW DQGHUHSODQEXUHDXVHQLQVWLWXWHQYDQZHJHKHWGUDDJYODNHQGHRPYDQJYDQKHWSURMHFW 9DQXLWGH]HVWUDWHJLHZRUGWVDPHQJHZHUNWPHWGHRQGHU]RHNVGLHQVWHQYDQ5LMNVZDWHUVWDDW 5:6GHSURYLQFLHVYLDKHW,32HQLQGH]JQµ%UHHGWH6WUDWHJLH¶KHWRQGHU]RHNVSURJUDPPD YDQGHYDNJURHS*HRJUDILHYDQGH5LMNVXQLYHUVLWHLW8WUHFKW6FKRWHQ'LMVW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

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

 2S]HWYDQGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHU

$OYRUHQVGHRS]HWYDQGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHUWHVFKHWVHQZRUGWRQGHUVWDDQGKHWGRHO YDQKHWV\VWHHPWRHJHOLFKWGDWLQVDPHQZHUNLQJPHW5,=$HQ5,.=LVYHUWDDOGQDDUHHQ WLHQWDOXLWJDQJVSXQWHQ'HWZHHGDDURSYROJHQGHSDUDJUDIHQJDDQGLHSHULQRSKHWW\SLVFKH H[SORUDWLHYHNDUDNWHUHQGHFRPSOH[LWHLWYDQKHWVRFLDDOHFRQRPLVFKHV\VWHHPGDWPHWKHW V\VWHHPJHWUDFKWZRUGWWHEHQDGHUHQ

 'RHOVWHOOLQJHQXLWJDQJVSXQWHQ

+HWGRHOYDQGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHULV µKHWVQHOLQWHUDFWLHIVFKHWVHQYDQGHHIIHFWHQYDQYHUVFKLOOHQGHVFHQDULR¶VRIEHOHLGVRSWLHVRS GHUXLPWHOLMNHRQWZLNNHOLQJHQNZDOLWHLWYDQGHOHHIRPJHYLQJ¶ 'H/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHUEHRRJWHHQPRGHOV\VWHHPWH]LMQYRRUGHLQWHJUDOHDQDO\VHYDQ YLJHUHQGHQRSWLRQHHOEHOHLGGDWGHµOHHIRPJHYLQJ¶GLUHFWRILQGLUHFWEHwQYORHGW+HWV\VWHHP LVPHWQDPHEHGRHOGYRRUKHWDQDO\VHUHQYDQEHOHLGVYDULDQWHQRSGHPLGGHOODQJHWRWODQJH WHUPLMQ±MDDU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EHKRHIWHDDQPHHUHQEHWHUHZRRQUXLPWHPDDURRNKXQLQGLUHFWHEHKRHIWH DDQUXLPWHRPWHUHFUHsUHQJURHQHQQDWXXULQGHRPJHYLQJ +HWVDPHQVSHOWXVVHQGH]HYHUVFKLOOHQGHDFWRUHQHQKXQEHKRHIWHQEHSDDOWGHDXWRQRPH G\QDPLHNYDQKHWUXLPWHOLMNHV\VWHHPLQ1HGHUODQG+HWEHOHLGWUDFKWGRRUUHJHOJHYLQJGH]H HLJHQG\QDPLHNYDQKHWV\VWHHPWHEHwQYORHGHQHQLQJRHGHEDQHQWHOHLGHQ+HWLVKHWGRHO YDQGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHURPGH]HHLJHQG\QDPLHNYDQKHWUXLPWHOLMNV\VWHHPRSHHQ ]RUHDOLVWLVFKPRJHOLMNHZLM]HZHHUWHJHYHQHQGHGLUHFWHHQLQGLUHFWHHIIHFWHQYDQKHWEHOHLG LQ]LFKWHOLMNWHPDNHQ'H/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHULVJHEDVHHUGRSHHQJHwQWHJUHHUG UXLPWHOLMNV\VWHHPG\QDPLVFKPRGHOGDWRSYHUVFKLOOHQGHUXLPWHOLMNHQLYHDXVKHWVDPHQVSHO YDQGH]HDFWRUHQRQGHULQYORHGYDQKHWEHOHLGWUDFKWWHEHVFKULMYHQRPHHQDQWZRRUGWH NULMJHQRSGHYUDDJµ:LHGRHWZDWZDDUHQZDQQHHU"¶ ,QKHWPRGHO]LMQYDULDEHOHQHQSDUDPHWHUVYRRUKDQGHQZDDUPHHGHUXLPWHOLMNHDOORFDWLHWHQ JHYROJHYDQDXWRQRPHRIEHOHLGVPDWLJHRQWZLNNHOLQJHQELMJHVWHOGNDQZRUGHQ7HYHQV]LMQ UHOHYDQWHLQGLFDWRUHQLQGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHURSJHQRPHQZRRQGLFKWKHGHQ JHOXLGRYHUODVWNDQVRSRYHUVWURPLQJHQGLHHHQEHRRUGHOLQJYDQGHHIIHFWHQYDQKHW UXLPWHOLMNEHOHLGPRJHOLMNPDNHQ'RRUGHUHVXOWDWHQYDQYHUVFKLOOHQGHVFHQDULR¶VRI EHOHLGVYDULDQWHQWHYHUJHOLMNHQNDQLQ]LFKWZRUGHQYHUNUHJHQLQGLHEHOHLGVRSWLHVRI PDDWUHJHOHQGLHGHNZDOLWHLWYDQGHOHHIRPJHYLQJJXQVWLJEHwQYORHGHQ

SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW ,QHHQJH]DPHQOLMNHRQWZLNNHOLQJVYLVLHYDQ5,=$5,.=HQ5,90LVGHGRHOVWHOOLQJYDQKHW V\VWHHPYHUWDDOGQDDURQGHUVWDDQGHVHWYDQLQKRXGHOLMNHWHFKQLVFKHHQVRIWZDUHPDWLJH XLWJDQJVSXQWHQ  'H/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHUJHHIWLQIRUPDWLHRSKHWKRRJVWHDJJUHJDWLHQLYHDXYRRU DIZHJLQJVYUDDJVWXNNHQRSEDVLVYDQGHSHUVSHFWLHYHQHFRQRPLHHFRORJLHHQVRFLDDO DOVRRNGZDUVGRRUVQHGHQQDDUWKHPD¶VDOVZDWHUQDWXXUPLOLHXHQUXLPWHOLMNHRUGHQLQJ  'H/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHUZRUGWQLHWRQWZLNNHOGYRRUKHWYHUNHQQHQYDQ EHOHLGVPDDWUHJHOHQYRRUGHNRUWHWHUPLMQMDDURIORNDOHSUREOHPHQJHPHHQWH QLYHDX  'HNHUQYDQGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHUGHUXLPWHOLMNHDOORFDWLHYDQGHYHUVFKLOOHQGH DFWLYLWHLWHQGLHQWJH]DPHQOLMNRQWZLNNHOGWHZRUGHQ'HLQGLFDWRUHQGLHQHQRQGHUOLQJ]R JRHGPRJHOLMNDIJHVWHPGWHZRUGHQPDDUPRJHQELMYHUVFKLOOHQLQLQ]LFKWHYHQWXHHO XLWHHQORSHQILJ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HQGH$FWLYH;&RPSRQHQWWHFKQRORJLHYDQ0LFURVRIW  *H]LHQGHFRPSOH[LWHLWYDQGHJHZHQVWHLQWHJUDOHDIZHJLQJHQZRUGWKHWV\VWHHPSULPDLU RQWZLNNHOGYRRUJHEUXLNGRRUHHQWHDPYDQVSHFLDOLVWHQ )LJXXU0RGXODLUHRS]HWYDQGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHU

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ  *H]LHQKHWGRHOYDQKHWV\VWHHPKHWVQHOHQLQWHUDFWLHIYHUNHQQHQYDQYHUVFKLOOHQGH EHOHLGVRSWLHVGLHQWGHWRWDOHUHNHQWLMGHQGHDIKDQGHOLQJVWLMGYDQKHWV\VWHHPEHSHUNWWH ]LMQ7HQDDQ]LHQYDQGHUHNHQWLMGYRRUHHQVLPXODWLHGLHQWJHVWUHHIGWHZRUGHQQDDUHHQ PD[LPDOHWLMGYDQFDPLQXWHQ9RRUGHDIKDQGHOLQJVWLMGGHWLMGQRGLJYRRUKHWLQVWHOOHQ GRRUUHNHQHQHQKHWYHUZHUNHQYDQGHUHVXOWDWHQZRUGWJHVWUHHIGQDDUHHQjXXU+HW LQVWUXPHQW]DOQLHWGLUHFWLQ]RJHQDDPGHµRSHQSODQSURFHVVHQ¶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sOHNDQVRSZDWHURYHUODVWGLHYHUYROJHQVLQGH /HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHUJHwPSOHPHQWHHUGNXQQHQZRUGHQ

 +HWH[SORUDWLHYHNDUDNWHU

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RQGDQNVGHWLMGHQ HQHUJLHGLHLQGHRQWZLNNHOLQJHQWRHSDVVLQJZRUGWJHVWRSW'LWLVPHWQDPHKHWJHYDOYRRU PRGHOOHQYDQVRFLDDOHFRQRPLVFKHV\VWHPHQGLHZRUGHQJHNHQPHUNWGRRUHHQELM]RQGHU KRJHJUDDGYDQRQ]HNHUKHLG 9ROJHQVGHFODVVLILFDWLHYDQ/RZU\GLHHHQRQGHUVFKHLGPDDNWWXVVHQGHVFULSWLHYH H[SORUDWLHYHSUHGLFWLHYHHQQRUPDWLHYHPRGHOOHQLVGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHUHHQ H[SORUDWLHIPRGHO 'HVFULSWLHYHRIEHVFKULMYHQGHPRGHOOHQ]LMQYDDNQLHWZLVNXQGLJHPRGHOOHQGLHRQWVWDDQLQ GHDDQORRSIDVHQDDUGHRQWZLNNHOLQJYDQHHQH[SORUDWLHIRISUHGLFWLHIPRGHO1RUPDWLHYH PRGHOOHQSRVWXOHUHQKHWEHVWDDQYDQHHQJHNHQGHHQVWDWLVFKHQRUPZDDUDDQPRHWHQNDQ ZRUGHQYROGDDQGRRUJHEUXLNWHPDNHQYDQHHQRIDQGHUHRSWLPDOLVDWLH3UHGLFWLHYHPRGHOOHQ GRHQH[SOLFLHWHXLWVSUDNHQRYHUGHWRHNRPVWLQNZDQWLWDWLHYHHQNZDOLWDWLHYH]LQ ([SORUDWLHYHPRGHOOHQZRUGHQJHEUXLNWPHWKHWGRHORPPRJHOLMNHHQORJLVFKHDOWHUQDWLHYHQ YRRUGHWRHNRPVWWHJHQHUHUHQ]RQGHUGDWGH]HKHOHPDDOUHDOLVWLVFKLQWXwWLHIRI YDQ]HOIVSUHNHQGKRHYHQWH]LMQ9ROJHQV6LPPRQGVZLQWHHQJRHGH[SORUDWLHIPRGHO DDQYRRUVSHOOHQGHZDDUGHDOVDDQRQGHUVWDDQGHGULHYRRUZDDUGHQLVYROGDDQ  GHMXLVWHG\QDPLVFKHPHFKDQLVPHQGLHLQGHZHUNHOLMNKHLGRRNYHUDQWZRRUGHOLMN]LMQ YRRUGHYHUDQGHULQJHQYDQKHWV\VWHHP]LMQRSJHQRPHQLQGHYHUJHOLMNLQJHQYDQKHW PRGHO  KHWPRGHOEOLMNWLQVWDDWRPHHQSHULRGHXLWKHWYHUOHGHQWHKHUFRQVWUXHUHQHQ

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sQHUJWLMGVJHERQGHQWH]LMQHQGDDUGRRU YDQEHSHUNWHZDDUGHYRRUYRRUVSHOOLQJHQRSGHODQJHWHUPLMQ+HWSUREOHHP]LWKHPYRRUDOLQ KHWIHLWGDWGHREMHFWHQYDQGHPRGHOOHHURHIHQLQJGHPHQVHOLMNHDFWRUHQ]HOIHUJVQHONXQQHQ YHUDQGHUHQLQGHWLMG+HW]LMQLQWHOOLJHQWHDFWRUHQGLHDOVUHDFWLHRSHONHQLHXZHVLWXDWLHLQ KXQRPJHYLQJHHQNHX]HPDNHQXLWHHQJURWHKRHYHHOKHLGPRJHOLMNHUHDFWLHV

 +HWFRPSOH[HVRFLDDOHFRQRPLVFKHV\VWHHP

'H/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHUWUDFKWHHQEHHOGWHVFKHWVHQYDQGHWRHNRPVWYDQGH 1HGHUODQGVHPDDWVFKDSSLM+HWVRFLDDOHFRQRPLVFKHV\VWHHPGDWGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV 9HUNHQQHUWUDFKWWHEHVFKULMYHQZRUGWJHNHQPHUNWGRRUHHQKRJHJUDDGYDQFRPSOH[LWHLW 'HUJHOLMNHFRPSOH[HV\VWHPHQPHWHHQVFDODDDQVRFLDOHHQUXLPWHOLMNHLQWHUDFWLH NHQPHUNHQ]LFKGRRUGDWNOHLQHYHUDQGHULQJHQWRHYDOOLJKHGHQRIHHQVDPHQORRSYDQ RPVWDQGLJKHGHQWRWRQYHUZDFKWHHIIHFWHQNDQOHLGHQ&RPSOH[HV\VWHPHQNXQQHQSORWVHOLQJ QDDUHHQDQGHUHYRUPYDQRUJDQLVDWLHRIZHUNLQJRPVODDQ3ULJRJLQH$OOHQHWDO 'HDDUGYDQGH]HWRHYDOOLJKHLGRIKHWRJHQEOLNZDDURS]LFKHHQVDPHQORRSYDQ RPVWDQGLJKHGHQYRRUGRHWHQGHPDQLHUZDDURSKHWV\VWHHPZRUGWEHwQYORHG]LMQPRHLOLMN YRRUVSHOEDDU (HQLQWHJUDDOVRFLDDOHFRQRPLVFKPRGHOPRHWYRRUDOJH]LHQZRUGHQDOVHHQLQVWUXPHQWRPGH YHUVFKLOOHQGHSRWHQWLsOHWRHVWDQGHQYDQKHWV\VWHHPWHYHUNHQQHQ'RRUGHWRHNRPVWLJH RQWZLNNHOLQJHQHQKHWHIIHFWYDQYHUVFKLOOHQGHEHOHLGVPDDWUHJHOHQHHUVWPHWHHQGHUJHOLMN H[SORUDWLHILQVWUXPHQWWHYHUNHQQHQ]RXGHQSRWHQWLHHORQJXQVWLJHRQWZLNNHOLQJHQNXQQHQ ZRUGHQYRRU]LHQ0HWQDPHYLHUDVSHFWHQWUHGHQGDDUELMRSGHYRRUJURQG  %HOHLGVPDDWUHJHOHQJULMSHQLQRSµYROOHGLJH¶V\VWHPHQ %HOHLGVPDDWUHJHOHQ]LMQLQSULQFLSHEHGRHOGRPKHWV\VWHHPWHEHwQYORHGHQ%HKDOYHKHW ERRJGHHIIHFWYDQGH]HPDDWUHJHOHQZRUGHQDXWRPDWLVFKRRNSURFHVVHQEHw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µQLHWHYHQZLFKWV¶WRHVWDQG3ULJRJLQH%HOHLGVPDDWUHJHOHQ EHwQYORHGHQGH]HG\QDPLVFKHZHUNHOLMNKHLG'H]HLQJUHSHQOHLGHQWRWRQRPNHHUEDUH HIIHFWHQHQ]HOIVNOHLQHLQJUHSHQLQKHWV\VWHHPNXQQHQRQYHUZDFKWHHQPDFURVFRSLVFKH JHYROJHQKHEEHQZDDUGRRUKHWV\VWHHPIXQGDPHQWHHONDQYHUDQGHUHQRSHHQPLQRIPHHU NRUWHWHUPLMQSDUDGLJPDYDQGH]HOIRUJDQLVDWLH2PGLWVRRUWHIIHFWHQWHNXQQHQ YRRUVSHOOHQ]LMQQLHWOLQHDLUHJHNRSSHOGHPRGHOOHQYHUHLVW]RGDWGHFRPSOH[LWHLWGLHGH

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ ZHUNHOLMNKHLGW\SHHUWJHSDVWNDQZRUGHQZHHUJHJHYHQ0HWFRPSOH[HPRGHOOHQZRUGHQ KLHUPRGHOOHQEHGRHOGGLHJHNHQPHUNWZRUGHQGRRUHHQYHHOKHLGDDQWHUXJNRSSHOLQJHQ ZDWQLHWKHW]HOIGHLVDOVJHFRPSOLFHHUGHPRGHOOHQGLHGRRUHHQKRJHPRHLOLMNKHLGVJUDDG ZRUGHQJHNHQPHUNW+HWPHHVWHHQYRXGLJHµFRPSOH[H¶PRGHOGDWKHWLQWHJUDOH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2PGHPLFURG\QDPLHNYDQGH]HV\VWHPHQJRHGWHEHVFKULMYHQPRHWHQUXLPWHOLMN G\QDPLVFKHPRGHOOHQZRUGHQJHEUXLNW  +HWJHGUDJYDQVRFLDDOHFRQRPLVFKHV\VWHPHQLVPRHLOLMNWHYRRUVSHOOHQ 2QGDQNVDOOHZHWHQVFKDSSHOLMNNHQQLVHQLQVSDQQLQJHQLVKHWWRWRSKHGHQXLWHUPDWHODVWLJ RPKHWJHGUDJYDQFRPSOH[HQDWXXUOLMNHHQDQWURSRJHQHSURFHVVHQQDXZNHXULJWH YRRUVSHOOHQ%LQQHQEHSDDOGHPDUJHVNXQQHQXLWVSUDNHQZRUGHQJHGDDQRYHUGH UREXXVWKHLGYDQKHWJHGUDJYDQKHWV\VWHHPZDQQHHUGLWZRUGWYHUVWRRUGGRRUHHQ EHSDDOGHLQJUHHS(HQH[SORUDWLHIJHEUXLNYDQPRGHOOHQGULQJW]LFKRS'LWKHOSWRPKHW ]RHNHQQDDUPRJHOLMNHLQJUHSHQEUHHGLQWH]HWWHQPHWKHWGRHOGH]RHNUXLPWHWH YHUQDXZHQWRWHHQUHHNVYDQKDDOEDUHYDULDQWHQ]RQGHUHHQYRRUVSHOOHQGHXLWVSUDDNWH GRHQRYHUGHµHQLJH¶RIGHµRSWLPDOH¶LQJUHHS

 2S]HWYDQKHWPRGHO

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EHVFKUHYHQGRRUHHQLQWHJUDDOG\QDPLVFKPDFURPRGHOHQHHQPLFURPRGHO GDWGHUXLPWHOLMNHDOORFDWLHYHU]RUJWGLHRQGHUOLQJVWHUNJHNRSSHOG]LMQ'DDUQDDVWRPYDWKHW PRGHOHHQUDVWHU*,6V\VWHHPYRRUGHSUHVHQWDWLHHQEHZHUNLQJYDQGHUXLPWHOLMNH LQIRUPDWLH +HWLQWHJUDOHG\QDPLVFKHPDFURPRGHOJHHIWRSUXLPWHOLMNHDEVWUDFWLHQLYHDXVKHW VWXGLHJHELHGZHHU2SKHWQDWLRQDOHQLYHDXZRUGWDDQGHKDQGYDQGH2PJHYLQJVVFHQDULR¶V /DQJH7HUPLMQ9HUNHQQLQJHQ&3%ZHHUJHJHYHQKRH1HGHUODQG]LFKHFRQRPLVFKHQ GHPRJUDILVFKRQWZLNNHOW2SKHWUHJLRQDOHQLYHDXJHEDVHHUGRSGH&2523JHELHGVLQGHOLQJ ZRUGHQGHRQWZLNNHOLQJHQLQGH&2523UHJLR¶VGRRUJHUHNHQGRSEDVLVYDQHHQµ6SDWLDO ,QWHUDFWLRQ%DVHG0RGHO¶'LWVWHUNJHNRSSHOGHV\VWHHPEHVFKULMIWRSHHQLQWHJUDOHPDQLHU GHGHPRJUDILVFKHHQHFRQRPLVFKHRQWZLNNHOLQJHQRSKHWQLYHDXYDQGH&2523JHELHGHQ 'HUHVXOWHUHQGHUHJLRQDOHRQWZLNNHOLQJHQZRUGHQYHUGHUYHUWDDOGQDDUYHUDQGHULQJHQLQ YUDDJQDDUUXLPWH

SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW ,QKHWPDFURPRGHOYDQGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHUZRUGHQQDDVWGHEHYRONLQJPRPHQWHHO GULHHFRQRPLVFKHDFWRUHQRQGHUVFKHLGHQEHYRONLQJLQGXVWULHGLHQVWHQHQVRFLDDOFXOWXUHOH DFWLYLWHLWHQ'H]HLQGHOLQJYDQDFWRUHQZRUGWLQEHODQJULMNHPDWHEHSDDOGGRRUGH EHVFKLNEDUHPDFURHFRQRPLVFKHJHJHYHQVHQJHRJUDILVFKHLQIRUPDWLHWHQDDQ]LHQYDQKHW ODQGJHEUXLN'DDUQDDVWVSHHOWKHWNHQPHUNHQGHUXLPWHOLMNHJHGUDJPHHHQGHPDWHZDDULQ HHQEHSDDOGHDFWRUSRWHQWLHHOEHOHLGVPDWLJVWXXUEDDULV )LJXXU'HVFKDDOQLYHDXVLQGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHUQDWLRQDDOUHJLRQDDOHQORNDDO +HWPLFURPRGHOLVJHEDVHHUGRSGHWKHRULHYDQµ&HOOXODLUH$XWRPDWD¶&$6WDQGDDUG JHRJUDILVFKHLQIRUPDWLHV\VWHPHQ*,6]LMQQLHWJHVFKLNWRPGHUXLPWHOLMNHG\QDPLVFKH RQWZLNNHOLQJHQWHEHVFKULMYHQ(QJHOHQHWDO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LVGLWPHWQDPHRPGDWµPLVVLQJDOPRVW HQWLUHO\>LQ*,6@DUHQRQORFDOLVHGVSDWLDOQRWLRQVVXFKDVVSDWLDORUJDQLVDWLRQ FRQILJXUDWLRQSDWWHUQVSDWLDOSURFHVVVSDWLDOG\QDPLFVUHVWUXFWXULQJWUDQVIRUPDWLRQDQG FKDQJH<HWWKHVHDUHDOOQRWLRQVWKDWDUHFHQWUDOLQXUEDQDQGUHJLRQDOVWXGLHVDQGWKH\ XQGHUOLHXUEDQDQGUHJLRQDOSODQQLQJHVSHFLDOO\DWWKHVWUDWHJLFOHYHO¶ ,QKHWPLFURPRGHOZRUGHQGHYHUVFKLOOHQGHDFWLYLWHLWHQLQGHUXLPWHJHSODDWVWRSEDVLVYDQGH ORNDOHG\QDPLHNLQKHWODQGJHEUXLN+HWVWXGLHJHELHGZRUGWGDDUWRHRSJHGHHOGLQFHOOHQYDQ ELMPHWHU'HUHJHOVYDQGH&HOOXODLUH$XWRPDWDGLHGHHVVHQWLHYDQGH]HG\QDPLHN EHYDWWHQYHUWDOHQKHWPLFURJHGUDJHQGHLQWHUDFWLHYDQUXLPWHOLMNHDFWRUHQHQKRXGHQYHUGHU UHNHQLQJPHWGHI\VLVFKHLQVWLWXWLRQHOHHQEHUHLNEDDUKHLGVNHQPHUNHQYDQGH1HGHUODQGVH UXLPWH 1DWLRQDDOQLYHDX 1HGHUODQGDOV 5HJLRQDDOQLYHDX &2523UHJLRV /RNDDOQLYHDX PUDVWHU

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ (HQLQJHERXZGHHQYRXGLJ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¶VRSKHWPDFURQLYHDXEHwQYORHGHQ+HWLVPHWQDPHGH]HG\QDPLVFKHZLVVHOZHUNLQJ WXVVHQPLFURHQPDFURGLHGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHURQGHUVFKHLGWYDQDQGHUHV\VWHPHQ ,QWHJHQVWHOOLQJWRWGHW\SLVFKHVWDWLVFKHHYHQZLFKWVPRGHOOHQJHEDVHHUGRSKHWJUDYLWHLWRI KHWµHQWURSLH¶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wQYORHGWRSGLHPDQLHUGHDQGHUH JHEUXLNHUVLQ]LMQQLHXZHRPJHYLQJ 9HUYROJHQV]DOHHQQLHXZHF\FOXVVWDUWHQGRRUGDW]LMQQDDVWHEXUHQRSKXQEHXUWKXQ ORFDWLHNHX]HWHUGLVFXVVLHNXQQHQVWHOOHQ2SGLHPDQLHUYHUNHHUWKHWV\VWHHPYRRUWGXUHQGLQ HHQQLHWHYHQZLFKWVLWXDWLH'H]HF\FOXVKHUKDDOW]LFKWRWKHWHLQGHYDQGHVLPXODWLH +HWEDVLVPHFKDQLVPHYDQG\QDPLVFKHWHUXJNRSSHOLQJYROGRHWKLHUPHHDDQHHQVWUHQJH GHILQLWLHYDQKHWEHJULSµUXLPWHOLMNHG\QDPLHN¶DDQJH]LHQ  ,HGHUHQLHXZHWRHVWDQGYDQKHWUXLPWHOLMNHV\VWHHPYROOHGLJDIKDQNHOLMNLVYDQGHYRULJH  µ5XLPWH¶HHQYDULDEHOHLVLQKHWPRGHOYHUJHOLMNEDDUPHWGHYDULDEHOHWLMG'HSODDWVLQJ YDQDFWLYLWHLWHQYRUPWGHDDQOHLGLQJWRWHHQRQRPNHHUEDUHHYROXWLHJHNHQPHUNWGRRUKHW RQWVWDDQJURHLHQRSEUHNHQRIYHUGZLMQHQYDQFOXVWHUVYDQDFWLYLWHLWHQGLHGHUXLPWHOLMNH LQGHOLQJGHILQLWLHIDIOLMQHQ  'HUXLPWHOLMNHLQYXOOLQJHHQVWDSVJHZLMVSURFHVLVZDDUELMGHUXLPWHEHHWMHELMEHHWMH ZRUGWLQJHQRPHQDOVDQWZRRUGRSGHWLMGHOLMNHHQYHUDQGHUHQGHEHKRHIWHQYDQEHSDDOGH UXLPWHJHEUXLNHUV'H]HUXLPWHOLMNHLQYXOOLQJLVYRRUDOKHWUHVXOWDDWYDQNHX]HQHQ EHVOLVVLQJHQRSKHWPLFURQLYHDX'HUHVXOWHUHQGHUXLPWHOLMNHVWUXFWXUHQPDQLIHVWHUHQ]LFK HFKWHURSHHQYHHOJURWHUHVFKDDOGDQKHWJHRJUDILVFKHJHELHGZDDUYRRUGHLQWHUDFWLH UHJHOVJHGHILQLHHUG]LMQZDWNHQPHUNHQGLVYRRUKHWµ]HOIRUJDQLVHUHQGH¶YHUPRJHQYDQ GLWW\SHPRGHOOHQ  ,QGH]HUXLPWHOLMNHV\VWHPHQNXQQHQFOXVWHUVPHWHHQKRJHGLFKWKHLGRQWVWDDQQDDVW JHELHGHQGLHUHODWLHIRQLQWHUHVVDQW]LMQHQOHHJEOLMYHQ(ULVHHQµRYHUORRS¶PRJHOLMNYDQ UHODWLHIµYROOH¶JHELHGHQQDDUPLQGHUµYROOH¶JHELHGHQZDDUGRRUFOXVWHUVNXQQHQJURHLHQ PDDUQDYHUORRSYDQWLMGRRNZHHUNXQQHQRSEUHNHQLQYHUVFKLOOHQGHGHOHQ'H]H ]RJHQDDPGHµV\PPHWU\EUHDNLQJ¶LVNHQPHUNHQGYRRUGLWW\SHPRGHOOHQ  'HUJHOLMNHUXLPWHOLMNHV\VWHPHQGRRULQWURGXFWLHYDQVWRFKDVWLVFKHHOHPHQWHQ YHUVFKLOOHQGHRQWZLNNHOLQJVULFKWLQJHQQDDUGHWRHNRPVWNXQQHQYRRUWEUHQJHQGLH JHOLMNZDDUGLJ]LMQRSHHQEHSDDOGDEVWUDFWLHQLYHDXPDDULQGHZHUNHOLMNKHLGQLHWHYHQ ZHQVHOLMN

SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW 6DPHQYDWWHQGYRUPWGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHUHHQUXLPWHOLMNG\QDPLVFKPRGHOZDDULQ VRFLDOHHFRQRPLVFKHHQQDWXXUOLMNHSURFHVVHQLQWHJUDDOZRUGHQZHHUJHJHYHQ+HWRPYDWHHQ H[SOLFLHWHZHHUJDYHYDQGHUXLPWHOLMNHG\QDPLHNYDQYHUVFKLOOHQGHUXLPWHJHEUXLNHUVGLH DFWLHI]LMQRSYHUVFKLOOHQGHJHRJUDILVFKHQLYHDXVHQGLHLQKXQUXLPWHOLMNJHGUDJPLQRIPHHU EHwQYORHGNXQQHQZRUGHQGRRUEHOHLGVLQJUHSHQ'HXLWYRHUYDQKHWPRGHOEHVWDDWXLW NDDUWHQYDQ1HGHUODQGGLHKHWUXLPWHJHEUXLNLQELMYRRUEHHOGZHHUJHYHQYRRUZRQHQ ZHUNHQQDWXXUHQODQGERXZ

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

 +HW0DFURPRGHO

 5XLPWHOLMNHLQWHUDFWLHRSUHJLRQDDOQLYHDX

+HWPDFURPRGHOGDWGHYHUGHOLQJYDQGHQDWLRQDOHZDDUGHQRYHUGHUHJLR¶VHQGHG\QDPLHN WXVVHQGHUHJLR¶VRQGHUOLQJUHJHOWLVYDQKHWW\SHµUXLPWHOLMNHLQWHUDFWLH¶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pp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ppQPRGHOHHQKHOHUHHNVYDQ UXLPWHOLMNHIXQFWLHVDDQNDQPHWHHQPLQLPXPDDQJHJHYHQV+HWWRHYRHJHQRIRSVSOLWVHQYDQ HFRQRPLVFKHVHFWRUHQYHUJWELMJHYROJVOHFKWVEHSHUNWHDDQSDVVLQJHQDDQKHWEDVLVLQVWUXPHQW ,QGHORRSYDQGHWLMGZDQQHHUGLWZHQVHOLMNZRUGWJHDFKWHQZDQQHHUPHHUVSHFLILHNH PRGHOOHQEHVFKLNEDDU]LMQNXQQHQGH]HLQKHWPRGHOZRUGHQJHKDQJHQWHUYHUEHWHULQJYDQGH JHQHULHNHUHSUHVHQWDWLH 'HHHUVWHQGLHRSUXLPWHOLMNHLQWHUDFWLHJHEDVHHUGHYHVWLJLQJVWKHRULHsQRQWZLNNHOGHQZDUHQ RQGHUPHHU$QGHUVRQ&DUURWKHUV,VDUG/DFKHQHHQ:DUQW] 7HUZLMOGHEHQDGHULQJppQYDQGHIXQGDPHQWHQYDQGHYHVWLJLQJVWKHRULHEOHHI]LH ELMYRRUEHHOG:LOVRQHQ%DWW\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HQ]LMQJURHS&ODUNHHQ :LOVRQ$OOHQHQ6DQJOLHU$OOHQHQ:KLWHGHHHUVWH G\QDPLVFKHYHUVLHVYDQRSUXLPWHOLMNHLQWHUDFWLHJHEDVHHUGHYHVWLJLQJVPRGHOOHQ'H]H EHYDWWHQKHWFXPXODWLHYHUHVXOWDDWYDQWHUXJNRSSHOLQJHQJURHLJHQHUHHUWDGGLWLRQHOHJURHL %RYHQGLHQEHYDWWHQGHPRGHOOHQYDQ$OOHQHQ]LMQFROOHJDGLH]LMQJHEDVHHUGRS YHUJHOLMNLQJHQPHWHHQORJLVWLHNHVWUXFWXXUHHQYHU]DGLJLQJVHIIHFWZDDUELMGHJURHLVWRSWDOV GHRPVWDQGLJKHGHQRIYRRUZDDUGHQYRRUJURHLXLWJHSXW]LMQ(QJHOHQHQ$OOHQ'H]H PRGHOOHQEHYDWWHQLPSOLFLHWQHJDWLHYHWHUXJNRSSHOLQJHQZDDUELMGHHFRQRPLVFKHJURHLZRUGW

SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW DIJHUHPGGRRUQHJDWLHYHHIIHFWHQ]RDOVWRHQHPHQGHNRVWHQWHQJHYROJHYDQFRQJHVWLHRS ZHJHQRIKRJHUHJURQGSULM]HQ :KLWHLQWURGXFHHUGHHHQZLQVWRIYHUOLHVEHUHNHQLQJJHEDVHHUGRSHHQUXLPWHOLMNLQWHUDFWLH PRGHOHQGHYHVWLJLQJVG\QDPLHNZHUGXLWJHGUXNWDOVHHQIXQFWLHYDQZLQVWLQSODDWVYDQGH UXLPWHOLMNHLQWHUDFWLH]HOI$DQJH]LHQGHZLQVWEHUHNHQLQJNRVWHQEHYDWNXQQHQQHJDWLHYH HIIHFWHQZRUGHQEHSDDOGGRRUGHNRVWHQYHUJHOLMNLQJ'H]HEHQDGHULQJZHUGYHUGHUJHWHVWLQ VWHGHOLMNH.RKHQUHJLRQDOHWRHSDVVLQJHQ5HQHQ:KLWHHQLVLQKHWKXLGLJH PRGHOYDQGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHURSJHQRPHQRPGHYHVWLJLQJVG\QDPLHNYDQGH FRPPHUFLsOHVHFWRUZHHUWHJHYHQ 'RRUGHNRSSHOLQJYDQKHWUXLPWHOLMNHLQWHUDFWLHPRGHOPHWHHQPRGHORSKHWFHOOXODLUQLYHDX EHVFKLNWGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHURYHUQLHXZHPRJHOLMNKHGHQ=RZRUGWKHW PDFURPRGHOEHwQYORHGWGRRURQWZLNNHOLQJYDQGHNZDOLWHLWHQGHEHVFKLNEDDUKHLGYDQUXLPWH RSKHWPLFURQLYHDX+HWEHODQJULMNVWHYRRUGHHOYDQGHLQWURGXFWLHYDQGH]HYDULDEHOHQRS PLFURVFKDDOLVGDWPHWGHUXLPWHVSHFLILHNHNHQPHUNHQRSKHWFHOOXODLUQLYHDXYDQHONHUHJLR ZRUGWUHNHQLQJJHKRXGHQLQGHLQWHUUHJLRQDOHG\QDPLHN%RYHQGLHQ]LMQGH]HNHQPHUNHQQLHW VWDWLVFKHQLVRRNKXQHYROXWLHDOVDQWZRRUGRSGHUHJLRQDOHG\QDPLHNRSJHQRPHQDDQJH]LHQ GHYHUELQGLQJPHWKHWFHOOXODLUHPRGHOZHGHUNHULJLV'LWLVEHODQJULMN,QKHWYHUOHGHQZDV KHWQLHWRQJHEUXLNHOLMNRPLQRSHUDWLRQHOHUHJLRQDOHYHUZDFKWLQJVPRGHOOHQFRUUHFWLHIDFWRUHQ IXGJLQJIDFWRUVLQWHYRHUHQYRRUVSHFLILHNHLQWULQVLHNHUHJLRQDOHNDUDNWHULVWLHNHQGLH RSWLRQHHOJHFDOLEUHHUGZHUGHQ$OOHQHQ(QJHOHQ,QGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHU NXQQHQYDULDEHOHQXLWKHWPLFURPRGHOJHEUXLNWZRUGHQRPGH]HFRUUHFWLHIDFWRUHQWH JHQHUHUHQGLHLQSODDWVYDQHHQPDOLJJHFDOLEUHHUGELMLHGHUHLWHUDWLHYDQKHWPRGHOZRUGHQ KHUEHUHNHQG'HYDULDEHOHQRSKHWFHOOXODLUHQLYHDXLQWURGXFHUHQQHJDWLHYH WHUXJNRSSHOLQJVHIIHFWHQRSHHQH[SOLFLHWHZLM]H'LFKWKHLGJHGHILQLHHUGRSKHWFHOOXODLUH QLYHDXLVppQYDQGHEHODQJULMNVWHUHJHOPHFKDQLVPHQYDQGHUHJLRQDOHG\QDPLHN$OVGH GLFKWKHLGWRHQHHPWJDDQGHGDDUPHHJHSDDUGJDDQGHNRVWHQLQKHWELM]RQGHUGHVWLMJHQGH NRVWHQYDQGHJURQGHQGHLQGLUHFWHNRVWHQYDQYHUNHHUVRSVWRSSLQJHQXLWHLQGHOLMNGH YRRUWGXUHQGHJURHLYDQ]HOIVKHWPHHVWDDQWUHNNHOLMNHJHELHGVWRSSHQ(HQUHJLRGLHQLHWPHHU JURHLW]DORRNJHHQQLHXZHJURHLPHHURSOHJJHQDDQKHWPLFURPRGHO'HGLFKWKHLG]DOGXV QLHWODQJHUYHUDQGHUHQZDDUGRRUGHUHJLRWHUXJFRPSHWLWLHINDQZRUGHQWHQRS]LFKWHYDQGH DQGHUHUHJLR¶V (QLJV]LQVYHUHHQYRXGLJGJHVWHOGSRQHHUWKHWPRGHOGDWGHKRHYHHOKHLGYDQHHQEHSDDOGW\SH DFWLYLWHLWEHYRONLQJLQGXVWULHNDQWRUHQHWFGLHPLJUHHUWYDQKHWHQHUHJLRQDDUKHWDQGHUH DIKDQNHOLMNLVYDQ  GHKRHYHHOKHLGDFWLYLWHLWLQEHLGHUHJLR¶V  GHKRHYHHOKHLGZHUNJHOHJHQKHLGLQEHLGHUHJLR¶V  GHKRHYHHOKHLGEHYRONLQJLQEHLGHUHJLR¶V  GHDIVWDQGWXVVHQEHLGHUHJLR¶V  GHJHPLGGHOGHGLFKWKHLGYDQGHDFWLYLWHLWLQEHLGHUHJLR¶VHQ  GHDIVWDQGVJHZRJHQDDQWUHNNLQJVNUDFKWYDQDOOHDQGHUHFRQFXUUHUHQGHUHJLR¶V 0DDUGHPLJUDWLHYDQHHQDFWLYLWHLWLVRRNDIKDQNHOLMNYDQNHQPHUNHQRSKHWFHOOXODLUH QLYHDX]RDOV  GHJHPLGGHOGHWUDQVLWLHSRWHQWLDDOYDQFHOOHQYRRUGHDFWLYLWHLWLQGHWZHHUHJLR¶V 'HWUDQVLWLHSRWHQWLDDOJHHIWGHNDQVGDWHHQFHOYDQODQGJHEUXLNVIXQFWLHYHUDQGHUWZHHU  GHJHPLGGHOGHJHVFKLNWKHLGYDQFHOOHQYRRUGHDFWLYLWHLWLQGHWZHHUHJLR¶VHQ  KHWGRRUKHWEHOHLGRSHQJHVWHOGHJHELHGLQGHWZHHUHJLR¶V

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

 $OJHPHQHRS]HWYDQKHW0DFURPRGHO

=RDOVUHHGVXLWYRHULJJHVWHOGLQ3DUDJUDDIEHVWDDWKHWPRGHOYDQGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV 9HUNHQQHUXLWHHQJHNRSSHOGPLFURHQPDFURPRGHO'H]HNRSSHOLQJLVYDQGRRUVODJJHYHQG EHODQJJHZHHVWLQGHNHX]HYDQHQHU]LMGVGH6HFWRUHQ_{JHPRGHOOHHUGLQKHWPDFURPRGHOHQ} DQGHU]LMGVGH/DQGJHEUXLNHQJHPRGHOOHHUGLQKHWPLFURPRGHO 'HNHX]HHQGHVDPHQVWHOOLQJYDQGH6HFWRUHQHQ/DQGJHEUXLNHQLVJHEHXUGRSEDVLVYDQ  GHEHVFKLNEDDUKHLGYDQODQGJHEUXLNJHJHYHQVRSKHWPLFURQLYHDX&%6ERGHPVWDWLVWLHN HQ/DQGJHEUXLN1HGHUODQG/*1NDDUWHQ  GHWLMGUHHNVHQHQSURJQRVHVPHWEHWUHNNLQJWRWGHRQWZLNNHOLQJYDQGHVHFWRUHQRS QDWLRQDDOQLYHDX  GHYHUVFKLOOHQLQUXLPWHOLMNHG\QDPLHNHQYHVWLJLQJVJHGUDJYDQDFWLYLWHLWHQ  GHRYHUODSWXVVHQODQGJHEUXLNNODVVHQHQGH&%6LQGHOLQJYDQGHHFRQRPLHHQGH EHYRONLQJ 'LWODDWVWHDUJXPHQWLVYDQJURRWEHODQJ(ULVQDPHOLMN]RYHHOPRJHOLMNJHVWUHHIGQDDUHHQ ppQRSpp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{'HWHUP6HFWRUZRUGWKLHUJHEUXLNWLQHHQEHWHNHQLVGLHUXLPHULVGDQGHORXWHUHFRQRPLVFKH=RLVHUQDDVW} HFRQRPLVFKHVHFWRUHQRRNVSUDNHYDQGHGHPRJUDILVFKHVHFWRUHQGHVHFWRUQDWXXU

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wQYORHGWKHWJHGUDJYDQGHVHPLG\QDPLVFKHIXQFWLHV +HWPDFURPRGHOEHVWDDWXLWVWHUNJHNRSSHOGHVXEV\VWHPHQILJYRRU(FRQRPLH 'HPRJUDILH/DQGJHEUXLNHQ9HUNHHU'H]HYLHUVXEV\VWHPHQZRUGHQLQRQGHUVWDDQGH SDUDJUDIHQDFKWHUHHQYROJHQVEHKDQGHOG )LJXXU+HWPDFURPRGHOYDQGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHU

 (FRQRPLH

+HWVXEV\VWHHP(FRQRPLHEHVFKULMIWGH1HGHUODQGVHHFRQRPLHRSHHQELM]RQGHUKRRJ DJJUHJDWLHQLYHDXVOHFKWV]HYHQHFRQRPLVFKHDFWLYLWHLWHQZRUGHQRQGHUVFKHLGHQ  ODQGERXZH[FOXVLHIJODVWXLQERXZ  YLVVHULM  UHFUHDWLH  JODVWXLQERXZ  LQGXVWULH  GLHQVWHQHQ  VRFLDDOFXOWXUHOHDFWLYLWHLWHQ 'HZLM]HZDDURSGHVHFWRUHQZRUGHQJHPRGHOOHHUGLVVWHUNDIKDQNHOLMNYDQGHDXWRQRPH G\QDPLHNYDQGHVHFWRUHQ1DDUPDWHGHUROYDQEHOHLGWRHQHHPWLQKHWJHGUDJYDQHHQVHFWRU ZRUGWHHQPHHUHHQYRXGLJHPRGHOIRUPXOHULQJJHKDQWHHUG'HPHHVWHHQYRXGLJHEHVWDDWHULQ KHWJHGUDJYDQGHVHFWRUYROOHGLJRSWHOHJJHQSHUUHJLR

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ 'HYLVVHULMVHFWRUZRUGWDI]RQGHUOLMNJHPRGHOOHHUGRPGDWKLMJURWHQGHHOVSODDWVKHHIWRSKHW ZDWHUHQGXVJHHQODQGJHEUXLNW+HWUXLPWHJHEUXLNRSKHWODQGYRRUDIVODJHQYHUZHUNLQJLV WHNOHLQRPHHQDSDUWHODQGJHEUXLNVIXQFWLHYRRUGHYLVVHULMWHPDNHQ'LWUXLPWHJHEUXLNYDOW QXRQGHULQGXVWULHHQKDYHQWHUUHLQHQ,QKHWPDFURPRGHOZRUGWGHWRWDOHSURGXFWLHKHWWRWDDO DDQWDOEDQHQHQGHWRHJHYRHJGHZDDUGHDDQGHUHJLR¶VWRHJHZH]HQRSEDVLVYDQGHJHPHWHQ ZDDUGHQ(UZRUGWYRRUKHWRYHULJHJHHQLQWHUDFWLHPHFKDQLVPHWRHJHSDVW 'HODQGERXZVHFWRUHQDNNHUERXZJUDVODQGHQRYHULJDJUDULVFKZRUGHQDOOHHQRSKHW PLFURQLYHDXJHPRGHOOHHUGHQOHYHUHQGHUXLPWHYRRUGHJURHLYDQGHDQGHUHVHFWRUHQ,QKHW PDFURPRGHOZRUGWRSEDVLVYDQGHJHPHWHQZDDUGHQHQGHYHUDQGHULQJHQLQGHLQJHQRPHQ UXLPWHGHWRWDOHSURGXFWLHKHWWRWDDODDQWDOEDQHQHQGHWRHYRHJGHZDDUGHDDQUHJLR¶V WRHJHZH]HQ(UZRUGWYHUGHUJHHQLQWHUDFWLHSULQFLSHWRHJHSDVW8LWDQDO\VHVYDQGH 1HGHUODQGVHODQGERXZEOLMNWQDPHOLMNGDWGHG\QDPLHNLQGHODQGERXZLQEHODQJULMNHPDWH ZRUGWEHSDDOGGRRUVSHFLILHNHNHQPHUNHQYDQGHLQGLYLGXHOHEHGULMYHQ]RDOVGHUHQWDELOLWHLW HQKHWDOGDQQLHWEHVFKLNEDDU]LMQYDQHHQRSYROJHURPKHWEHGULMIYRRUWWH]HWWHQ/(,  2RNYRRUGHVHFWRUHQJODVWXLQERXZHQUHFUHDWLHHQGHUXLPWHJHEUXLNHQERVQDWXXUHQ H[WHQVLHIJUDVODQGZRUGWHUJHHQHFKWLQWHUDFWLHSULQFLSHJHKDQWHHUG,QKHWYHUOHGHQJROGGDW JODVWXLQERXZHHQYROJ]DPHVHFWRUYDQGHEHYRONLQJZDVRPZLOOHYDQGHDI]HWPDUNW1X JHOGWPHHUHQPHHUGDWGHJODVWXLQERXZµIRRWORRVH¶LVJHZRUGHQ%RYHQGLHQLVKHW]RGDWLQ 1HGHUODQGKHWEHOHLGLQVWHUNHPDWHEHSDDOGZDDUGHJODVWXLQERXZ]LFK]DONXQQHQYHVWLJHQ =R]LMQHUVWXGLHVJHGDDQQDDUGHHFRQRPLVFKHHIIHFWHQDOVGHKXLGLJHORFDWLHVLQGH5DQGVWDG JHGHHOWHOLMNYHUSODDWVWZRUGHQQDDUDQGHUHUHJLR¶V/(,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ZRUGHQDOVYROJWZHHUJHJHYHQ2SKHW QDWLRQDOHQLYHDXZRUGWSHUVFHQDULRHHQJURHLSRVLWLHIRIQHJDWLHIYDQGHDFWLYLWHLWDDQKHW PRGHORSJHOHJGEORNMH*URHL$FWLYLWHLW1HGHUODQG+HWPRGHO]DOGDQXLWPDNHQZHONGHHO YDQGH]HJURHLDDQHONYDQGHUHJLR¶VZRUGWWRHJHZH]HQ'H]HKRHYHHOKHLGZRUGWEHSDDOG GRRUGHYUDDJGLHGRRUHONYDQGHUHJLR¶VZRUGWJHJHQHUHHUGUHODWLHIWHQRS]LFKWHYDQDOOH

SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW DQGHUHFRQFXUUHUHQGHUHJLR¶VEORNMH9UDDJQDDU$FWLYLWHLW'H]HYUDDJZRUGWJHJHQHUHHUG GRRU  GHEHYRONLQJYDQGHUHJLRHQGHQDEXULJHUHJLR¶VGLH]LFKEHYRRUUDGHQLQGHEHZXVWH UHJLR]RDOVEHSDDOGLQKHW%HYRONLQJVSRWHQWLDDO  GHZHUNJHOHJHQKHLGLQGHUHJLRHQGHRPOLJJHQGHUHJLR¶V]RDOVEHSDDOGLQGH %DQHQSRWHQWLDDOHQ  GHKRHYHHOKHLGYDQGHDFWLYLWHLWGLHUHHGVLQGHUHJLRHQGHQDEXULJHUHJLR¶VDDQZH]LJLV ]RDOVEHSDDOGLQGHHLJHQ3RWHQWLDDOYDQGH$FWLYLWHLW 'HLQYORHGYDQGHRPOLJJHQGHUHJLR¶VLQERYHQVWDDQGHSRWHQWLDOHQZRUGWJHZRJHQRSEDVLV YDQGHLQWHU&2523DIVWDQGHQ]RDOVEHUHNHQGLQKHWVXEV\VWHHPYHUNHHU 1DDVWGH]HUHJLRQDOHHOHPHQWHQ]LMQHUQRJHHQDDQWDOYDULDEHOHQRSKHWPLFURQLYHDXGLHGH UHJLRQDOHYUDDJQDDUHHQDFWLYLWHLWEHwQYORHGHQ'H]HKHEEHQPHWQDPHWHPDNHQPHWGH VSHFLILHNHNZDOLWHLWYDQGHUXLPWHYRRUHHQEHSDDOGHVHFWRU]RDOVGHI\VLVFKH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SODDWVLQJYDQGHVHFWRUGLHQVWHQJHOGWHHQOLFKWHOLMNDDQJHSDVWSULQFLSHILJ+LHU ZRUGWHHQUHODWLHIZLQVWSULQFLSHJHKDQWHHUG,QKHWDDQJHSDVWHVFKHPD]LHWPHQKRHGHYUDDJ QDDUGLHQVWHQDIKDQNHOLMNLVYDQGHKRHYHHOKHLGLQNRPVWHQGLHJHJHQHUHHUGNXQQHQZRUGHQ GRRUGHEHYRONLQJHQDFWLYLWHLWHQLQGHUHJLRHQGHQDEXULJHUHJLR¶V'H]HLQNRPVWHQZRUGHQ DIJHZRJHQWHJHQGHNRVWHQGLHJHSDDUGJDDQPHWKHWXLWRHIHQHQYDQGHDFWLYLWHLWLQGHUHJLR 'HUHJLRNULMJWXLWHLQGHOLMNKHWGHHOYDQGHJURHLWRHJHZH]HQGDWLQYHUKRXGLQJVWDDWWRWGH UHODWLHYHZLQVWGLHJHUHDOLVHHUGNDQZRUGHQ

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

 'HPRJUDILH

+HWVXEV\VWHHPGHPRJUDILHEHVFKULMIWGHORNDOLVDWLHHQPLJUDWLHYDQGH1HGHUODQGVH EHYRONLQJRSKHW&2523QLYHDX(UZRUGWHHQQDJHQRHJLGHQWLHNVFKHPDJHKDQWHHUG]RDOV YRRUGHVHFWRUHQLQGXVWULHHQVRFLDDOFXOWXUHOHDFWLYLWHLWHQILJ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 )LJXXU+HWV\VWHHPGLDJUDPYRRUGH%HYRONLQJ

 /DQGJHEUXLN

+HWVXEV\VWHHP/DQGJHEUXLNYHUWDDOWGHKRHYHHOKHLGDFWLYLWHLWXLWJHGUXNWLQSURGXFWLH HHQKHGHQJXOGHQVRIEHYRONLQJSHUVRQHQQDDUHHQKRHYHHOKHLGODQGGLHLQJHQRPHQZRUGW GRRUGHDFWLYLWHLWILJ'DDUELMZRUGWHHQ]RJHQDDPGHµ/DQGSURGXFWLYLWHLW¶EHSDDOG'H /DQGSURGXFWLYLWHLWLVHHQG\QDPLVFKDDQSDVEDUHPDDWYRRUGHGLFKWKHLGYDQHHQDFWLYLWHLWLQ HHQEHSDDOGH&2523HQJHHIWDDQKRHYHHORSSHUYODNWHZRUGWLQJHQRPHQGRRUGHDFWLYLWHLW DOVIXQFWLHYDQ  GHWRWDOHYUDDJQDDUUXLPWH  GHJHVFKLNWKHLGYDQKHWJHELHG  KHWEHOHLGHQ  GHKRHYHHOKHLGQRJYRRUXLWEUHLGLQJEHVFKLNEDUHUXLPWH )LJXXU+HWV\VWHHPGLDJUDPYRRUKHWVXEV\VWHHP/DQGJHEUXLN

SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW 1DGDWGHODQGSURGXFWLYLWHLWLVLQJHVWHOGZRUGWYRRUHONHDFWLYLWHLWLQHONH&2523EHSDDOG KRHYHHOUXLPWHGRRUGHDFWLYLWHLWZRUGWLQJHQRPHQ%LMGHEHUHNHQLQJZRUGWHUYRRUJH]RUJG GDWGHWRWDOHEUXLNEDUHRSSHUYODNWHYDQGHUHJLRQLHWZRUGWRYHUVFKUHGHQ,QGLHQDOOH EUXLNEDUHUXLPWHLQHHQ&2523LVEHQXWZRUGWHHQPHFKDQLVPHLQZHUNLQJJH]HWGDWHUYRRU ]RUJWGDWDFWLYLWHLWHQ]LFKNXQQHQYHUSODDWVHQQDDUQDEXULJHJHELHGHQ

 9HUNHHU

+HWVXEV\VWHHP9HUNHHUUHJHOWGHYHUNHHUVJHERQGHQDVSHFWHQYDQGHXLWZLVVHOLQJYDQ JRHGHUHQHQSHUVRQHQWXVVHQGHYHUVFKLOOHQGHUHJLR¶V'HDIVWDQGHQWXVVHQGHYHUVFKLOOHQGH UHJLR¶VZRUGHQPHWHHQNRUWVWHSDGDOJRULWPHEHUHNHQGRSEDVLVYDQKHWZHJHQQHWZHUNXLWKHW /DQGHOLMN0RGHO6\VWHHP/06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¶VRPDO]RGHG\QDPLHNYDQKHW UHJLRQDOHV\VWHHPWHEHwQYORHGHQ 'HLQWHUUHJLRQDOHG\QDPLHNYDQKHWPRGHONDQLQGLHQJHZHQVWXLWJHVFKDNHOGZRUGHQ'LWNDQ YRRUDOOHVHFWRUHQLQGXVWULHGLHQVWHQVRFLDDOFXOWXUHOHDFWLYLWHLWHQHQEHYRONLQJ$OV DOWHUQDWLHIPRHWHHQWLMGUHHNVPHWGHHYROXWLHYDQGHEHWUHIIHQGHDFWLYLWHLWSHUUHJLR DDQJHOHYHUGZRUGHQ'H]HRSWLHNDQJHEUXLNWZRUGHQDOVHUWLMGVUHHNVHQSHUUHJLR EHVFKLNEDDU]LMQYDQELMYRRUEHHOGGRPHLQVSHFLILHNHPRGHOOHQGLHLQJHEUXLN]LMQELMGH GDDUWRHJHsLJHQGHLQVWLWXWHQRIRUJDQLVDWLHV 'H/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHUEHKDQGHOWRSHHQH[SOLFLHWHZLM]HGHLQWHUUHJLRQDOHG\QDPLHN YDQYLMIDFWLYLWHLWVNODVVHQGLHRYHUHHQVWHPPHQPHWGHFHOOXODLUHODQGJHEUXLNFDWHJRULHsQ JODVWXLQERXZLQGXVWULHGLHQVWHQVRFLDDOFXOWXUHOHDFWLYLWHLWHQHQZRQHQ,QGH]HYHUVLH ZRUGHQGHODQGERXZVHFWRUHQRSXLW]RQGHULQJYDQGHJODVWXLQERXZSDVVLHIPHHJHQRPHQ 2RNGLHQWPHQWHVWHOOHQGDWGHFDWHJRULHZRQHQYDQKHWFHOOXODLUHPRGHORYHUHHQVWHPWPHW EHYRONLQJRSKHWPDFURQLYHDX,QKHWPDFURPRGHOZRUGWGHEHYRONLQJDOVppQDFWLYLWHLW EHKDQGHOGGLHYHUYROJHQVZRUGWRSJHGHHOGQDDUWZHHZRRQNODVVHQLQRYHUHHQVWHPPLQJPHW GHWZHHZRRQGLFKWKHGHQYDQKHWFHOOXODLUHPRGHO'H]HYHUGHOLQJZRUGWGRRUJHYRHUGRS EDVLVYDQGHYHUDQGHULQJLQGHGLFKWKHGHQYDQGH&2523EHYRONLQJ,QGLHQJHZHQVWNDQ PHQGHLQWHUUHJLRQDOHG\QDPLHNYDQKHWPRGHOXLWVFKDNHOHQHQYHUYDQJHQGRRUSURMHFWLHV YRRUEHYRONLQJHQDFWLYLWHLWSHUUHJLR2SGH]HODDWVWHZLM]HZRUGWGHG\QDPLHNYDQGH QDWXXUFDWHJRULHsQERVQDWXXUHQH[WHQVLHIJUDVODQGLQKHWPRGHORSJHQRPHQ'HRSPHUNLQJ GLHQWKLHUWHZRUGHQJHPDDNWGDWKHWSULQFLSHYDQGHUXLPWHOLMNHLQWHUDFWLHGDWGHYHUGHOLQJ YDQGHHFRQRPLVFKHDFWLYLWHLWHQHQGHEHYRONLQJRYHUGHUHJLR¶VUHJHOWZHLQLJYDQWRHSDVVLQJ LVYRRUGHSODDWVLQJYDQODQGERXZDFWLYLWHLWHQHQQRJPLQGHUYDQQDWXXUOLMNHV\VWHPHQ +HWPDFURPRGHOLVJHEDVHHUGRSHHQUXLPWHOLMNG\QDPLVFKLQWHUDFWLHPRGHO+HWYHU]RUJWGH YHUSODDWVLQJYDQDFWLYLWHLWHQDOVUHVXOWDDWYDQGHJURHLRSKHWQDWLRQDOHHQKHWUHJLRQDOH &2523QLYHDX+HWYHUSODDWVHQYDQEHVWDDQGHDFWLYLWHLWHQJHEHXUWRSWZHHYHUVFKLOOHQGH PDQLHUHQ9RRUGHDFWLYLWHLWHQZRQHQLQGXVWULHHQVRFLDDOFXOWXUHOHDFWLYLWHLWHQZRUGWHHQ VWDQGDDUGUHODWLHISRWHQWLDDOEHUHNHQLQJXLWJHYRHUG9RRUGHVHFWRUGLHQVWHQZDDUYRRU HFRQRPLVFKHRYHUZHJLQJHQLQGHSODDWVLQJVNHX]HYDQJURWHUEHODQJ]LMQZRUGWHHQUHODWLHI

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ ZLQVWFULWHULXPJHEUXLNW9RRUGHRYHULJHVHFWRUHQODQGERXZUHFUHDWLHHQQDWXXUZRUGHQ HHQYRXGLJHUHIRUPXOHULQJHQJHKDQWHHUG9RRUDOOHVHFWRUHQRSXLW]RQGHULQJYDQJUDVODQG DNNHUERXZHQRYHULJDJUDULVFKZRUGHQGHEHUHNHQGHDFWLYLWHLWHQLQHONHVHFWRUHQYRRUHONH UHJLRDDQKHWFHOOXODLUHPRGHORSJHOHJGRPRSKHWORNDOHQLYHDXJHSODDWVWWHZRUGHQ'H YHUDQGHUHQGHSDWURQHQYDQODQGJHEUXLNRSKHWPLFURQLYHDXEHwQYORHGHQRSKXQEHXUWGH DDQWUHNNHOLMNKHLGYDQHONHUHJLRHQGDDUGRRURRNGHG\QDPLHNRSKHWUHJLRQDOH&2523 QLYHDX

SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW

 *HGHWDLOOHHUGHEHVFKULMYLQJ

,QGH]HSDUDJUDDIZRUGWLQGHWDLOLQJHJDDQRSGHZLVNXQGLJHRSERXZYDQKHWPRGHO'H YHUJHOLMNLQJHQZRUGHQVWXNYRRUVWXNEHKDQGHOG'HJHEUXLNWHLQYRHUJHJHYHQVZRUGHQ EHVFKUHYHQLQKRRIGVWXN'HSDUDPHWULVHULQJYDQKHWPDFURPRGHOHQGHFDOLEUDWLHZRUGW EHVFKUHYHQLQELMODJH

 *URHL$FWLYLWHLW1HGHUODQG

$FWLYLWHLWLVLQKHWPDFURPRGHOJHGHILQLHHUGDOVKHWSURGXFWLHYROXPHLQJXOGHQVYRRUGH HFRQRPLVFKHVHFWRUHQDOVLQZRQHUVYRRUGHUHVLGHQWLHOHVHFWRUHQDOVKHWDDQWDOKDFHOOHQ YRRUGHQDWXXUNODVVHQ =RDOVLQGHSDUDJUDDIJHVWHOGYHU]RUJWGH/HHI2PJHYLQJV9HUNHQQHULQGULHVWDSSHQGH UXLPWHOLMNHDOORFDWLHYDQGHJURHLLQGHHFRQRPLHHQEHYRONLQJYDQ1HGHUODQGHHUVW 1DWLRQDDOGHJURHLYDVWVWHOOHQYHUYROJHQV5HJLRQDDOGHJURHLWRHZLM]HQDDQUHJLR¶VHQ WHQVORWWH/RNDDOGHJURHLSODDWVHQLQFHOOHQYDQKD 3HUDFWLYLWHLWZRUGWGHQDWLRQDOHRQWZLNNHOLQJDOVHHQWLMGUHHNVLQJHYRHUGLQKHWPRGHO'H]H WLMGUHHNVHQNXQQHQKHWUHVXOWDDW]LMQYDQHHQQLHWJHUHJLRQDOLVHHUGHFRQRPLVFKGHPRJUDILVFK RIDQGHUVRRUWLJPRGHORIPDNHQGHHOXLWYDQHHQVFHQDULRGDWGRRUGHJHEUXLNHUZRUGW RQGHU]RFKW9RRUHONHWLMGVWDSOHHVWKHWPRGHOGHQDWLRQDOHRQWZLNNHOLQJYDQHHQDFWLYLWHLWLQ HONHVHFWRU.³^EHYRONLQJPHWKHWVXEVFULSW3DDQJHJHYHQLQGXVWULHGLHQVWHQHQVRFLDDO FXOWXUHOHDFWLYLWHLWHQ`'H]HZDDUGHW9; ORRSWLQGHWLMGWLMGVWDSYRRURSGHVRPYDQGH. HIIHFWLHYHDFWLYLWHLWVZDDUGHQW; +HWLVPHWQDPHGHRQJHOLMNKHLGWXVVHQEHLGHGLHKHW.L PRGHOG\QDPLVFKGULMIW

Ê

₌ -= 5 L W .L W . W . 9; ; (   _ PHW .

W_{( %LMNRPHQGH QDWLRQDOH YUDDJ QDDU GH DFWLYLWHLW}_{ . >SHUVRQHQ  JXOGHQV  HHQKHGHQ}

QDWXXU@ . W_{9; 7RWDOHQDWLRQDOHYUDDJQDDUDFWLYLWHLW.>SHUVRQHQJXOGHQVHHQKHGHQQDWXXU@} . W_{; 7RWDOHDFWLYLWHLWLQVHFWRU.LQ&2523L>SHUVRQHQJXOGHQVHHQKHGHQQDWXXU@} 5 7RWDDODDQWDO&2523JHELHGHQ 

 $FWLYLWHLWORNDDO

'HHIIHFWLHYHKRHYHHOKHLGDFWLYLWHLWGLHXLWHLQGHOLMNLQHHQ&2523ZRUGWJHSODDWVWZRUGW EHSDDOGYRRUDOOHHFRQRPLVFKHDFWLYLWHLWHQ.GHUHVLGHQWLsOHDFWLYLWHLW3HQGH QDWXXUW\SHQ)LQHONH&2523LDOV]LMQGH .L W W .L  W .L W .L : 1 ;5 ; = - + _ PHW .L W_{: /DQGSURGXFWLYLWHLWYDQVHFWRU.LQ&2523L>SHUVRQHQJXOGHQVHHQKHGHQQDWXXUSHU} FHO@ W .L 1 'RRUKHWODQGJHEUXLN.DDQWDOLQJHQRPHQFHOOHQLQ&2523L>FHOOHQ@  _{'HLQYHWJHGUXNWHWHUPHQZRUGHQJHEUXLNWLQGHGLDORJHQYDQGHLQWHUIDFHYDQKHWPRGHORPGH]HYDULDEHOHQ} HQSDUDPHWHUVWHEHVFKULMYHQ

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

.L

W_{;5 1LHWWRHJHNHQGHDFWLYLWHLW.LQ&2523L>@}

'H MXLVWH EHWHNHQLV YDQ GH]H WHUP ZRUGW YHUNODDUG QDDU DDQOHLGLQJ YDQ YHUJHOLMNLQJ 

 /DQGSURGXFWLYLWHLW

'HODQGSURGXFWLYLWHLWLVHHQXLWGUXNNLQJYDQGHKRHYHHOKHLGDFWLYLWHLWGLHSHUFHOYDQKHW FHOOXODLUHPRGHONDQZRUGHQJHSODDWVW'H]HJURRWKHLGYHUYXOWHHQFUXFLDOHUROLQGH NRSSHOLQJYDQKHW&2523QLYHDXHQKHWFHOOXODLUHQLYHDXYDQKHWPRGHO(UZRUGWHHQ ODQGSURGXFWLYLWHLWEHUHNHQGYRRUDOOHHFRQRPLVFKHDFWLYLWHLWHQ.HYHQDOVGHUHVLGHQWLsOH DFWLYLWHLW3LQHONH&2523L9RRUGHQDWXXUW\SHV)LVGH/DQGSURGXFWLYLWHLWFRQVWDQWLQ GHWLMG9RRUDOOH&2523UHJLR¶VZRUGW]HRSJH]HW %LMKHWEHJLQYDQGHVLPXODWLHZRUGWGHODQGSURGXFWLYLWHLWEHUHNHQGDOV .L .L .L ₁ ; : _  ₌  ,QHONHYROJHQGHWLMVWDSZRUGWGHZDDUGHG\QDPLVFKELMJHVWHOGDOV .L W .L W .L W . .L W_{: = d} -_{:  :FRU  :FHO } PHWHHQWHUPGLHGHYHUGLFKWLQJRSKHW&2523QLYHDXLQUHNHQLQJEUHQJW . . L W . .L W . .L W .L W . .L W 4 1 ; ' :FRU     PD[   d d d d ß ß ß à Þ Ï Ï Ï Ð Î Ü Ü Ü Ý Û Ì Ì Ì Í Ë ß ß à Þ Ï Ï Ð Î ÜÜÝ Û ÌÌÍ Ë =

Ê

 HQPHWGHWHUPGLHGHYHUGLFKWLQJRSKHWFHOOXODLUHQLYHDXLQUHNHQLQJEUHQJW . . . L . W L . W . W . W . .L W .L W . .L W .L W . .L W %7 %P %7 %7P =P =P 3P 3P :FHO               d d d d d d ß ß ß ß ß à Þ Ï Ï Ï Ï Ï Ð Î Ü Ü Ý Û Ì Ì Í Ë + ÜÜÝ Û ÌÌÍ Ë + ß à Þ Ï Ð Î ß à Þ Ï Ð Î = --  PHW d_. DEVROXWHLQYORHGYDQGHDFWXHOHODQGSURGXFWLYLWHLW>@ d _. DEVROXWHLQYORHGYDQYUDDJQDDUDFWLYLWHLWRYHUKHWDDQERGDDQDFWLYLWHLW>@ d _. UHODWLHYHLQYORHGH[SRQHQWYDQYUDDJRYHUKHWDDQERGDDQDFWLYLWHLW>@ d _. DEVROXWHLQYORHGYDQKHWRYHUVFKRWDDQRSHQUXLPWH>@ d_. UHODWLHYHLQYORHGH[SRQHQWYDQKHWRYHUVFKRWDDQRSHQUXLPWH>@ d _. DEVROXWHLQYORHGYDQGHJURHLLQGH&$WUDQVLWLHSRWHQWLDOHQ>@ d _. UHODWLHYHLQYORHGH[SRQHQWYDQGHJURHLLQGH&$WUDQVLWLHSRWHQWLDOHQ>@ d_. DEVROXWHLQYORHGYDQGHYHUDQGHULQJLQGHJHVFKLNWKHLGYDQGHLQJHQRPHQUXLPWH>@

d _. UHODWLHYH LQYORHG H[SRQHQW YDQ GH YHUDQGHULQJ LQ GH JHVFKLNWKHLG YDQ GH LQJHQRPHQ UXLPWH>@

.



SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW

.



d UHODWLHYH LQYORHG H[SRQHQW YDQ GH YHUDQGHULQJ LQ GH GRRU KHW EHOHLG EHVFKLNEDDU JHVWHOGHUXLPWH>@ W L 4 %HVFKLNEDDUDDQWDOFHOOHQLQ&2523L>FHOOHQ@ L . W_3P

 5HJLRQDDO JHPLGGHOGH WUDQVLWLHSRWHQWLDDO YRRU ODQGJHEUXLN . YDQ GH FHOOHQ [\LQJHQRPHQGRRUODQGJHEUXLN.LQ&2523L>@ W . L =P _ 5HJLRQDDOJHPLGGHOGHJHVFKLNWKHLGYRRUODQGJHEUXLN.YDQGHFHOOHQ[\LQJHQRPHQ GRRUODQGJHEUXLN.LQ&2523L>@ L . W_%7  &2523WRWDDOEHOHLGYRRUODQGJHEUXLN.LQ&2523LRSWLMGVWLSW>@ W_{%7 1DWLRQDDOWRWDDOEHOHLGYRRUODQGJHEUXLN.RSWLMGVWLSW>@} W . [ \ % _{ } %HOHLGYRRUFHO[\YRRUODQGJHEUXLN.RSWLMGVWLSW>@ . W_%P

 5HJLRQDDO JHPLGGHOGH EHOHLG YRRU ODQGJHEUXLN . YDQ GH FHOOHQ LQJHQRPHQ GRRU

ODQGJHEUXLN.LQ&2523L>@ 9RRUUHVLGHQWLsOHDFWLYLWHLWJHOGWGDWGHEHLGHFDWHJRULHsQ/DJHGLFKWKHLGUHVLGHQWLHHO/HQ +RJHGLFKWKHLGUHVLGHQWLHHO+ZRUGHQJHFRPELQHHUGLQHHQJHZRJHQJHPLGGHOGH,QGH GHUGHWHUPYDQGHYHUJHOLMNLQJJHOGWGHYROJHQGHXLWGUXNNLQJ ß ß à Þ Ï Ï Ð Î ÜÜÝ Û ÌÌÍ Ë + ÜÜÝ Û ÌÌÍ Ë + = L + W L + W +L L / W L / W /L +L /L L W L W %7 %P 1 %7 %P 1 1 1 %7 %P        _ 'HH[SRQHQWHQd3K, d5K, d7K, d9K, d11KLQGHYHUJHOLMNLQJHQWRWHQPHWZRUGHQLQKHW PRGHOLQGHHHUVWHSODDWVDDQJHZHQGDOVELQDLUHVZLWFKHV]LMZRUGHQRSRIJH]HWDOQDDUJHODQJ PHQGHLQYORHGYDQGHEHWUHIIHQGHWHUPLQGHYHUJHOLMNLQJZLOPHHQHPHQRIQLHW'LWLVEHODQJULMN RPGDWHHQDDQWDOYDQGHEHWUHIIHQGHWHUPHQHUJYHUJHOLMNEDUHGLQJHQPHWHQHQGXVQLHWDOOHPDDOLQKHW PRGHO PRHWHQ ZRUGHQ RSJHQRPHQ =R LV ELMYRRUEHHOG EHOHLG d11K HHQ RQGHUGHHO YDQ KHW &$

WUDQVLWLHSRWHQWLDDO d7K 'RRU KHW LQVWHOOHQ YDQ GH H[SRQHQWHQ NDQ PHQ GH EHUHNHQLQJ YDQ GH

ODQGSURGXFWLYLWHLWPLQGHURIPHHUDIKDQNHOLMNPDNHQYDQGHHQHRIGHDQGHUHJURRWKHLG

 /DQGJHEUXLN

+HWGRRUODQGJHEUXLN.LQJHQRPHQDDQWDOFHOOHQGDWXLWHLQGHOLMNDDQKHWPLFURPRGHOZRUGW RSJHOHJGZRUGWEHSDDOGDOV L W L W L W : ' 1 =  ,QKHWJHYDOGDW . .L W_{' <:PLQ } ZRUGW  = .L W_{1 } PHW PLQ : W . 0LQLPXP/DQG3URGXFWLYLWHLW>SHUVRQHQJXOGHQVHHQKHGHQQDWXXUSHUFHO@ +HWJHYDOEHGRHOGLQYHUJHOLMNLQJGRHW]LFKYRRUZDQQHHUGHJHYUDDJGHKRHYHHOKHLG DFWLYLWHLWEHQHGHQGHPLQLPDOHODQGSURGXFWLYLWHLWYDOW'LWPLQLPXPZRUGWH[RJHHQRSJHOHJG HQJHOGWDOVHHQDEVROXWHEHQHGHQJUHQVYRRUKHWWRHNHQQHQYDQHHQGRPLQDQWODQGJHEUXLN

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ DDQHHQFHO=RODQJKHWPLQLPXPQLHWZRUGWJHKDDOGZRUGWDDQKHWEHWUHIIHQGHODQGJHEUXLN JppQFHOWRHJHZH]HQ 'RRUKHWLQYRHUHQYDQGH]HEHQHGHQJUHQVEHVWDDWGHPRJHOLMNGDWHUHHQ]HNHUHKRHYHHOKHLG DFWLYLWHLWQLHWZRUGWWRHJHNHQG'H]HZRUGWYHU]DPHOGHQZRUGWODWHUJHSODDWVWLQGH]HOIGH &2523RILQHHQQDEXULJH&2523 .L W .L W .L W .L W_{;5 =' -1 : } PHW .L W_{;5 1LHWWRHJHNHQGHDFWLYLWHLW.LQ&2523L>@} +HWDDQWDOFHOOHQGDWLQHHQUHJLRHHQDFWLYLWHLWWRHJHZH]HQNDQNULMJHQLVNOHLQHUGDQKHW WRWDDODDQWDOFHOOHQLQKHWJHELHG+HWYHUVFKLOEHVWDDWXLWGH]RJHQDDPGHµ)HDWXUH¶FHOOHQ RRN.HQPHUNHQJHQRHPGGLHZRUGHQLQJHQRPHQGRRUHHQODQGJHEUXLNGDWJHGXUHQGHGH VLPXODWLHQLHWYHUDQGHUWKRRIGVWXN+HWYRRUDOORFDWLHEHVFKLNEDDUDDQWDOFHOOHQEHGUDDJW L QDWXXU W L DJUDULVFK W . .L W L W_{4 1 1 1}  + + =

Ê

 PHW W L 4 %HVFKLNEDDUDDQWDOFHOOHQLQ&2523L>FHOOHQ@

 +HWYHUVFKLOLQµZRQHQGXQ¶HQµZRQHQGLFKWEHYRONW¶

,QKHWPDFURPRGHOZRUGWZRQHQDOVppQVHFWRUJHDVVRFLHHUGPHWGHEHYRONLQJ JHPRGHOOHHUG,QKHWPLFURPRGHOGDDUHQWHJHQZRUGWZRQHQJHPRGHOOHHUGDOVZRQHQKRJH GLFKWKHLGHQZRQHQODJHGLFKWKHLG0HWKHWGRHOKHWPLFURPRGHOWHNXQQHQYRHGHQZRUGWGH EHYRONLQJSHUWLMGVWDSRSJHGHHOGQDDUZRQHQKRJHHQZRQHQODJHGLFKWKHLG]RQGHUGHJUHQ]HQ YRRUKRJHHQODJHGLFKWKHLGIHLWHOLMNLQWHVWHOOHQ,PSOLFLHWHGLFKWKHGHQ]RXGHQEHUHNHQG NXQQHQZRUGHQLQGLHQGHYHUKRXGLQJYDQGHEHYRONLQJXLWEHLGHFDWHJRULHsQSHUUHJLREHNHQG LV'LWLVKHODDVQLHWKHWJHYDO ,QKHWPRGHOLVGHIUDFWLHFHOOHQZRQHQGLFKWJHUHODWHHUGDDQGHYHUDQGHULQJYDQGH EHYRONLQJVGLFKWKHLGSHUUHJLR+LHUWRHZRUGWSHUWLMGVWDSEHNHNHQKRHGHUHJLRQDOH EHYRONLQJVGLFKWKHLGYHUDQGHUWDW_: 3L'RRUGH]HYHUDQGHULQJWHYHUPHQLJYXOGLJHQPHWGH µWUDQVLWLHFRHIILFLHQW¶E+GLHGHYHUDQGHULQJLQGHIUDFWLHFHOOHQZRQHQGLFKWSHUHHQKHLG YHUDQGHULQJLQGHEHYRONLQJVGLFKWKHLGZHHUJHHIWZRUGWGHWRHRIDIQDPHYDQGHIUDFWLHFHOOHQ ZRQHQGLFKWWHQRS]LFKWHYDQGHYRULJHWLMGVWDSEHSDDOG 'HYHUDQGHULQJLQGHEHYRONLQJVGLFKWKHLGYDQHHQUHJLRZRUGWEHSDDOGDOV  OQ  OQ  3L W 3L W 3L W_{: = : -} -_: D  3L W + +L W +L W_{e =}-_{e +E D: } 3L W +L W +L W_{1 =e 1 } PHWDOVUDQGYRRUZDDUGH    ˆ W_e+Lˆ _

SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW PHW +L W_{e 5HODWLHIDDQGHHOFHOOHQZRQHQYDQKHWW\SHKRJHGLFKWKHLGLQ&2523UHJLRL>@} 3L W_{1 $DQWDOZRRQFHOOHQLQ&2523UHJLRL>FHOOHQ@} +L W_{1 $DQWDOZRRQFHOOHQYDQKHWW\SHKRJHGLFKWKHLGLQ&2523UHJLRL>FHOOHQ@} +

E 7UDQVLWLHFRHIILFLHQW GLH GH YHUDQGHULQJ LQ GH IUDFWLH FHOOHQ ZRQHQ GLFKW SHU HHQKHLG YHUDQGHULQJLQGHEHYRONLQJVGLFKWKHLGZHHUJHHIW>FHOSHUVRRQ@ 'HLQLWLHOHZDDUGHYDQGHµWUDQVLWLHFRHIILFLHQW¶E+LVHQJHEDVHHUGRSHHQUHJUHVVLH YDQGHIUDFWLHFHOOHQZRQHQGLFKWPHWGHZRRQGLFKWKHLGSHU&2523

 9UDDJQDDU$FWLYLWHLWHQ

9RRUKHWEHSDOHQYDQGHYUDDJQDDUDFWLYLWHLWHQLQHONHVHFWRUHQYRRUHON&2523JHELHG EHUHNHQWKHWPRGHOHQHU]LMGVGHYHUGHOLQJYDQGHELMNRPHQGHDFWLYLWHLW]RDOVEOLMNWXLWGH QDWLRQDOHJURHLFLMIHUVHQDQGHU]LMGVGHYHUSODDWVLQJYDQDFWLYLWHLWHQWXVVHQGH&2523 JHELHGHQRQGHUOLQJRSEDVLVYDQKXQUHODWLHYHDDQWUHNNLQJVNUDFKWYRRUGHVHFWRU(UZRUGW GDDUELMHHQOLFKWHOLMNYHUVFKLOOHQGPHFKDQLVPHJHEUXLNWDOQDDUJHODQJGHVHFWRUGLHZRUGW JHPRGHOOHHUG  YRRUGHVHFWRUHQ.³^EHYRONLQJLQGXVWULHHQVRFLDDOFXOWXUHOHDFWLYLWHLWHQ`ZRUGWHHQ VWDQGDDUGUHODWLHYHSRWHQWLDDOEHUHNHQLQJXLWJHYRHUG  YRRUGHVHFWRU&³^GLHQVWHQ`ZRUGWGHUHODWLHYHSRWHQWLDDOEHUHNHQLQJDDQJHYXOGPHWHHQ UHODWLHIZLQVWFULWHULXP %HLGHW\SHVHFWRUHQZRUGHQKLHUVDPHQEHKDQGHOGRPGDWGHPRGHOPDWLJHIRUPXOHULQJWRWRS JURWHKRRJWHYHUJHOLMNEDDULV'DDUELMJHOGWGDWKHWVXEVFULSW.YHUZLMVWQDDUGHVHFWRUHQ EHYRONLQJLQGXVWULHHQVRFLDDOFXOWXUHOHDFWLYLWHLWHQWHUZLMOKHWVXEVFULSW&YHUZLMVWQDDUGH VHFWRUGLHQVWHQ 'HYUDDJRPDFWLYLWHLWHQLQDOOHVHFWRUHQ.ZRUGWEHSDDOGDOV

(

)

(

)

{

}

{

'%Q '%[ ; ' ' '

}

' W 2.L W .L , . W (.L .L W .L .L W .L=PD[ PLQ  + + -j -  PHW (.L W_{' ([RJHQHYUDDJQDDUDFWLYLWHLW.LQ&2523L>SHUVRQHQJXOGHQV@} ' W ,.L 9UDDJNRPHQGHXLWDQGHUH&2523¶VYRRUDFWLYLWHLW.LQ&2523L>SHUVRQHQ.IO@ ' W

2.L 9HUOLHV DDQ DQGHUH &2523¶V YDQ YUDDJ QDDU DFWLYLWHLW . LQ &2523 L >SHUVRQHQ 

JXOGHQV@ .L '%Q (HQGRRUKHWEHOHLGRSJHOHJGPLQLPXPYRRUDFWLYLWHLW.LQ&2523L>SHUVRQHQ.IO@ .L '%[ (HQGRRUKHWEHOHLGRSJHOHJGPD[LPXPYRRUDFWLYLWHLW.LQ&2523L>SHUVRQHQ.IO@ j_. ,QHUWLHLQGHYHUSODDWVLQJYDQGHLQWHUQHYUDDJ>@ 'HEHLGHWLMGUHHNVHQ'%Q HQ_.L '%[ ODWHQWRHRPUHVSHFWLHYHOLMNHHQPLQLPDDOGHHOYDQGH_.L DFWLYLWHLWWRHWHZLM]HQDDQHHQ&2523UHJLRLHQGHDFWLYLWHLWWHEHSHUNHQWRWHHQYDVWJHVWHOG PD[LPXP,QGLHQYRRUKHWPLQLPXPHQKHWPD[LPXPGH]HOIGHWLMGUHHNVZRUGWJHKDQWHHUG ZRUGWGHHYROXWLHYDQGHDFWLYLWHLWKHOHPDDOH[RJHHQDDQKHWPRGHORSJHOHJG