Potassium as a tracer for residential woord combustion
Citation for published version (APA):Zeedijk, H., & Bubbert, M. (1986). Potassium as a tracer for residential woord combustion. In J. N. Lester, R. Perry, & R. M. Sterritt (Eds.), Proceedings of the International Conference Chemicals in the environment, 1-07-1986 (pp. 138-143). Selper Ltd.
Document status and date: Published: 01/01/1986
Document Version:
Accepted manuscript including changes made at the peer-review stage
Please check the document version of this publication:
• A submitted manuscript is the version of the article upon submission and before peer-review. There can be important differences between the submitted version and the official published version of record. People interested in the research are advised to contact the author for the final version of the publication, or visit the DOI to the publisher's website.
• The final author version and the galley proof are versions of the publication after peer review.
• The final published version features the final layout of the paper including the volume, issue and page numbers.
Link to publication
General rights
Copyright and moral rights for the publications made accessible in the public portal are retained by the authors and/or other copyright owners and it is a condition of accessing publications that users recognise and abide by the legal requirements associated with these rights. • Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the public portal for the purpose of private study or research. • You may not further distribute the material or use it for any profit-making activity or commercial gain
• You may freely distribute the URL identifying the publication in the public portal.
If the publication is distributed under the terms of Article 25fa of the Dutch Copyright Act, indicated by the “Taverne” license above, please follow below link for the End User Agreement:
www.tue.nl/taverne Take down policy
If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us at: openaccess@tue.nl
providing details and we will investigate your claim.
POTASSIUК AS А TRACER FOR RESIDENTIAL WOOD COKBUSTION
Н. Zeedijk, К. Bubbert
Laboratory of Instrumental Analysis,
Eindhoven University of Technology, Р.О. Вох 513, 5600 КВ Eindhoven, The Netherlands
ABSTRACT
The atmospheric potassium content has been changed strongly in The Netherlands during the last 15 years, wi th а minimum value in 1980. The winddirection has по noticeaЫe effect оп the concentra-tion and the small sodium/potassium ratio shows а low sea-salt con-tribution. The variation in potassium content of the atmosphere can
possiЫy Ье explained Ьу the changing use of residential fuels. The rise of the last years сап Ье the result of an increasing use of firewood for which the element potassium can Ье used as an atmos-pheric tracer compound.
INTRODUCTION
In many regions firewood is an attractive fuel for residential heating and the consumption is rising, for instance in the USA with
а 10,- per year (1). Combustion of firewood in airtight stoves pro-duces а consideraЫe emission of air pollutants, of which smoke par-ticulates, gaseous organics and carbon monoxide cause the most im-portant environmental impact (2). The particulate matter contains relatively high concentratio.ns of toxic compounds and the submicron sizes of the particulates make them well inhalaЫe. So one wants to
know the contribution of wood combustion emissions in the atmos-pheric aerosol content.
TRACER COKPOUNDS FOR WOOD COКВUSTION
The normal method for selecting the contribution of one source in the total air pollution is Ьу analysis of one specific emitted component, the so-called tracer. For the case of firewood combustion some methods are based оп the determination of the carbon-14/ carbon-12 ratio in atmospheric compounds, because this ratio is higher in wood in comparison with fossil fuels. So it was found Ьу
determination of the 14с112с ratio in carbon dioxide that in Portland, Oregon, wood combustion could contribute for 50,- to the atmospheric particulate matter (3). Also the ratio in carbon monoxide is used for this purpose (4).
for selection of the wood combustion contribution (5). The obtained results wеге unceгtain owing t.o the relatively high background
con-centгation of this component. caused Ьу oceanic emissions, but in spite of that, it could Ье estaЬlished tt1at backyard burning and firewood use contribute consideraЫy to the mass of fine particu-lates in the atmosphere.
An other suitaЫe tracer component for combustion of solid fuels and especially firewood could Ье the element potassium, because the ash of wood combustion consists for а consideraЫe part of potassium caгbonate and so does the fly ash that leaves the chimney. Thi s study had the aim to perfoгm а primary survey of atmospheric potassium concentrations in relation to the possiЫe
sources, that are except wood combustion sea-salt, windborne soil particles with clay composition and possiЫy industrial sources.
POTASSIUK IN ТНЕ ATKOSPHERE
In spite of the fact that potassium can hardly Ье considered to
Ье а harmful air pollution, it is possiЫe to find some measured atmospheric concentrations in the li terature. ТаЫе 1 i s deri ved frorn (6) and gives а survey:
ТаЫе 1: Atmospheric potassium concentrations (µg.m-3)
1974 1974 1974 1974 1974 1974 1974 1971 1972 1971 1970 Country Belgium Belgium Belgium Belgium Belgium Belgium Norway Norway Switz.erland U.S.A. Canada Canal of Gent Gent city Dourbes Antwerp Liege Charleroi Lakselv Skoganvarra Jungfraujoch Nw. Indiana TG Concentration Na
!
1.93 1.64 1.45 1.11 0.47 0.085 2.54 1.39 З.16 2.90 0.55 0.44 0.024 0.285 0.018 З.28 2.97 0.048 0.048 0.045 1.25 0.054 Ratio Na/K 1.18 1.30 5.53 1.83 0.96 0.98 11.5 9.15 0.56 0.23 0.33In urban areas the potassium concentration can exceed 1 µg .m-3 at а Na/K ratio lower than 1 and the background concen-tration of potassium is more than 25 times lower.
Since 1971 potassium in the atmosphere has been determined in Eindhoven, The Netherlands, at irregular intervals. ТаЫе 2 gives а
survey of the measurements.
ТаЫе 2: Atmospheric potass i um content in Eindhoven
Year Season Kean Conc. (µg .m-3) Stand.dev. Number 1971/1972 winter 2.53 0.17 86 1981 spring 0.044 0.044 10 1981 surnmer 0.025 0.017 9 1983 0.12 0.076 14 1985/1986 winter 0.46 0.26 28 - 2
-The potassium content of the atmosphere shows а large variation during these periods. It decreased from more than 2 µg.m-3 to а minimum lower than 0.1 µg .m-3 in 1981 and thereafter i t was in-creasing again. It looks strange, but the values f i t in the range found in the literature.
The relation between potassium concentration of the air and wind direction has already been studied for measurements in 1971/ 1972. No wind direction influence could Ье detected. Then for the most recent measurements again the relation has been examined. The wind direction was divided into 8 separate classes (Fig. 1) and for each class the availaЫe measurements have been averaged. ТаЫе 3 gi ves these mean values together wi th the averages for the atmos-pheric sodium, nitrate and sulphate concentrations.
Fig. 1: Definition of the windclasses
0-360
270
215
180
As а matter of fact the wind direction could have fluctuations during the sampling period of particulates that was usually one full day. The mentioned wind direction is the prevailing one. The dif-ferences in potassium concentrations are not statistically signifi-cant. The same holds for the other components.
ТаЫе З: Influence of wind direction on the potassiurn concentratior1
Wind class Hean concentration (µg.m-3) Ratio Na/K Nitrate ~y_l~hate Sodium Potassium
2 2 .16 0.86 2.5 з 8.3 13.5 0.38 0.32 1.2 4 13.1 22.З 1.55 0.95 1.6 5 6.1 7.8 1.66 0.40 4.2 6 8.9 11.8 2.44 0.43 5.7 7 3.78 0.42 9.0 8 8.2 13.9 1.61 0.60 2.7 all 8.2 11.4 2.20 0.46 4.8
When the potassium concentrations are related to windspeed values, there exists а small tendency to elevated concentrations at low windspeeds. It could Ье estaЫished that all high Na/K ratio' s were occurring in condi tions wi th а combination of high windspeed and wind originating from the North Sea (classes 6, 7 ,8), but under t.he same condi t ions also low Na/K ratio' s were observed. Some sea-sal t influence (sea-sea-salt has а Na/K ratio of 28), however, cannot Ье excluded, but. it is unlikely that the contribution to the potassium concentration will Ье very important.
Except determinations of the atmospheric potassium content also the emission of а woodstove wa.s determined. ТаЫе 4 gives these results.
ТаЫе 4: Emission factor in mg potassium/kg firewood
Hean value Standard deviation Number Potassium 11.2 5.7 7 Sodium 7.1 1.6 4 Nitrate 1.З 0.2 4 Sulphate 12.5 З.1
From the values in ТаЫе 4 the relative importance of the po-tassium emission is clear. Striking is the high standard deviation in the potassium value compared to the other components.
DISCUSSION
Sampling was performed in such а way that the efficiency for large dust particles should Ье as low as possiЫe: the filter had an inverted inlet and the high volume sampler was placed at а height of 15 m above soil level. The linear suction velocity was 0.5 m/sec. At
such conditions the filter efficiency for 5 micron particles is al-ready lower than some 20% (7). Smoke particles in srnoke of wood and coal are very small. Hore than 90~ of them is of submicron sizes and for this aerosol the filter efficiency of the used sampling method will Ье nearly 100~.
An eventual sea-salt effect on the potassium concentration can Ье estimated from the Na/K-ratio that amounts to 28 for sea-salt. In average the sodium concentration in Eindhoven air has not changed over the last 15 years and at the moment tt1e mean Na/K-rat io amounts to 5.5 (stand.dev.= 3.9, n=20). This ratio shows that the atmosphe
-ric potassium content only for а small part can Ье of sea-or1g1n. However, it appeared that the highest ratio's occurred during periods with wind directions that transported air from the seaside to the sampling station wi th high windspeeds. But in these condi-tions also low ratio's have been found.
The slight influence of sea-salt can also Ье seen from the bad correlation between sodium and potassium concentrations: Сна= 0.73 Ск + 1.84, correlation coefficient = 0.19, n=20. On the con-trary, there exists а better correlation wi th ni trate and sulphate: Cnitrate= 7.13 Ск + 4.95, corr.coeff.= 0.67, n=l6; and Csulphate= 17.5 Ск + 3.44, corr.coeff.= 0.80, n=16. These higher correlations can Ье explained Ьу taking into account that for all of these three components high concentrations are favoured Ьу the same meteorological conditions.
It is not clear, if the measured potassium concentrations are the result of emissions in the town of Eindhoven or the result of sources further away. Some control measurements in an agricultural background area showed an atmospheric potassium content of 0.194 microgram/mЗ (stand.dev.=0.026, n=4) in average. This is about half of the Eindhoven value. Dispers ion model calculations resulted in the same conclusion, that not only wood stove sources in the city itself contribute to the potassium content, but that there also must exist а consideraЫe contribution from further away sources.
Fig. 2: Residential fuel usage 1960-1985 in The Netherlands
100 %
80
60 40 20\
'
'
\
'
1.
•\/
'i ~!\
: \'
'
! \
:
\ 1 '.
...
,i
, ...
...
·
.... ~i
i
.
.
i
YEAR60
65
70
75
80
85
•---- COAL - O I LА likely explanation for the observed changes in the potassium
concentration in the Eindhoven atmosphere can possiЫy Ье found in
the typical tendencies in the Dutch fuel use. Figure 2 shows the percentual usage of the three fossil fuels: coal, oil and natural gas. The high potassium concentration in 1972 could Ье caused Ьу the residential burning of coal in the Netherlands and in the surrounding
countries. Ву replacing coal at first Ьу oil and later Ьу natural
gas, the atmospheric potassium concentration could reach а minimum.
Since 1978 the combustion of firewood became popular. There are no
data of the firewood usage availaЫe, but the sales of woodstoves
show this (ТаЫе 5).
ТаЫе 5: Sales of fireplaces, woodstoves and woodstove inserts in The Netherlands. Year 1978 1979 1980 1981 1982 1983 Fireplaces 64.000 40.000 20.000 15.000 12.000 ~10.000 Woodstoves Inserts 7.000 о 23.000 о 35.000 о 45.000 2.000 27.000 8.000 ~25 .ООО ~11.000
At this moment in about 7-8~ of the residences а woodstove сап
Ье found. The use of them possiЫy explains the rise of the
atmos-pheric potassium content, that started around 1980 and that today
amounts to а factor 4.
Literature
1. К. Becker, S.G. Barnett, J.W. Cowden, L.B.P. Graham, Н. v.d.
Bossche, К. Hannan, Great Lakes Regional Biomass Energy
Program, Jan. 1985: Residential wood combustion emissions and safety guidebook.
2. D.G. De Angelis, J.S. Ruffin, J.A. Peters, R.B. Reznik,
EPA-Technical Report 600/2-80-042Ь ( 1980): Source assessment:
Residential combustion of wood.
3. J.A. Cooper, L.A. Currie, L.A. Currie: 73rd Annual Keeting
АРСА, Kontreal, Canada, 1980: Impact of res idential wood com-bustion on urban air quality: first ambient measurements.
4. D.C. Duker, D.A. Levaggi, Т. Umeda, R.E. DeKandel, Т.Е.
Perardi, 77th Annual Keeting АРСА, San Francisco, USA, 1984:
Keasurement of а carbon monoxide cloud in San Jose, California.
5. S.A. Edgerton, К.А.К. Khalil, R.A. Rasmussen, J.A.P.C.A., 34,
661/3 (1984): Estimates of air pollution from backyard burning.
6. R. Dams, Thesis University of Gent, Belgium (1969): Studie van
de anorganische samenstelling van atmosferische aerosolen.
7. В.У.И. Liu, D.Y.H. Pui, Atm.Envir., 15, 589-600 (1981): Aerosol
sampling inlets and inhalaЫe particles.
