UHVHDUFKIRU PDQDQGHQYLURQPHQW 5,-.6,167,7887922592/.6*(=21'+(,'(10,/,(8 1$7,21$/,167,787(2)38%/,&+($/7+$1'7+((19,5210(17 5,90UDSSRUW 8LWERXZHQRSWLPDOLVDWLHYDQKHW/DQGHOLMN%HHOG YDQ9HUVWRULQJ 3DUWLsOHYDOLGDWLHHQJHYRHOLJKHLGVDQDO\VH $*0'DVVHQ--DEEHQ3+0-DQVVHQ MXQL 'LWRQGHU]RHNZHUGYHUULFKWLQRSGUDFKWHQWHQODVWHYDQKHW'LUHFWRUDDW*HQHUDDO 0LOLHXEHKHHU'LUHFWLH/RNDOH0LOLHXNZDOLWHLWHQ9HUNHHULQKHWNDGHUYDQSURMHFWµ8LWERXZHQ RSWLPDOLVDWLH/DQGHOLMN%HHOGYDQ9HUVWRULQJSURMHFWQXPPHUPLMOSDDO µ%HWURXZEDDUKHLGVDQDO\VHHQYDOLGDWLH¶ 5,903RVWEXV%$%LOWKRYHQWHOHIRRQ ID[
SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW
$EVWUDFW
7KHUHSRUWJLYHVDQRYHUYLHZRIYDULRXVVWXGLHVFDUULHGRXWWRXQGHUVWDQGDQGLPSURYHWKH DFFXUDF\DQGUHOLDELOLW\RI(03$5$(03$5$LVWKH(QYLURQPHQWDO0RGHOIRU3RSXODWLRQ $QQR\DQFHDQG5LVN$QDO\VLVIRUPHUO\NQRZQDVWKHQDWLRQDOQRLVHQXLVDQFHRYHUYLHZ /%9LQ'XWFK7KHVWXGLHVFRYHUHGPRGHOFRPSDULVRQH[SHULPHQWDOYDOLGDWLRQDQG VHQVLWLYLW\DQDO\VHV$OOVWXGLHVZHUHFRQILQHGWRWKHSDUWVRIWKHPRGHODQGWKHOLPLWHG QXPEHURISDUDPHWHUVHVWLPDWHGWRKDYHDUHODWLYHO\ODUJHLQIOXHQFHRQWKHPRGHORXWFRPH ,QPRVWRIWKHFDVHVVWXGLHGWKHW\SLFDOXQFHUWDLQW\LQWKHµDYHUDJH¶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
,QKRXG
6DPHQYDWWLQJ ,QOHLGLQJ (PLVVLHHQRYHUGUDFKWVPRGHOOHULQJ 6WDQGDDUG0HHWHQ5HNHQYRRUVFKULIWHQ 7RHSDVVLQJHQQDXZNHXULJKHGHQ $DQSDVVLQJHQYDQKHWUHNHQYRRUVFKULIW *HEUXLNYDQGH650VLQ(03$5$ 0RGHOOHULQJYDQGHHPLVVLH 1LHWVSHFWUDOHPRGHOOHULQJ ([SOLFLHWHYHUJHOLMNLQJPHW650,, 0RGHOOHULQJYDQGHVFKHUPZHUNLQJ 0RGHOOHULQJYDQGHVFKHUPZHUNLQJLQFRPELQDWLHPHW=2$% 'HPRGHOOHULQJYDQGHJHOXLGRYHUGUDFKWLQEHERXZGHJHELHGHQ µ'KXLV¶ ([WHUQHLQYRHUJHJHYHQV 5HVXPp 9DOLGDWLH *HOXLGRYHUGUDFKWLQGHµYULMHYHOG¶VLWXDWLH *HOXLGRYHUGUDFKWLQGHEHERXZGH VWHGHOLMNH RPJHYLQJ 5HVXPp *HYRHOLJKHLGVDQDO\VH *HYRHOLJKHLGYRRUQDXZNHXULJKHLGYDQHPLVVLHHQRYHUGUDFKW 3DUDPHWHUVWXGLH 9HUJHOLMNLQJPHW85%,6 5HVXPp &RQFOXVLHVHQDDQEHYHOLQJHQ /LWHUDWXXU %LMODJH %HNQRSWHEHVFKULMYLQJPRGHOOHULQJJHOXLGEHODVWLQJLQ(03$5$ %LMODJH 9HUJHOLMNLQJYDQ(03$5$PHW650,,DDQGHKDQGYDQHHQDDQWDOWHVWFDVHV %LMODJH 9HU]HQGOLMVWSDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW
6DPHQYDWWLQJ
0HWKHWPRGHO(03$5$ (QYLURQPHQWDO0RGHOIRU3RSXODWLRQ$QQR\DQFHDQG5LVN $QDO\VLVHHUGHUµ/DQGHOLMN%HHOGYDQ9HUVWRULQJ¶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µJHPLGGHOGH¶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µEUHGH¶DDQGDFKWYRRUGH PRGHOEHWURXZEDDUKHLGQRGLJJHDFKW]HNHUJHOHWRSGHZHQVRP(03$5$WHRQWZLNNHOHQ WRWLQVWUXPHQWYRRUGHMDDUOLMNVHPRQLWRULQJYDQODQGHOLMNHHQUHJLRQDOHRQWZLNNHOLQJHQRS KHWJHELHGYDQJHOXLG5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ
,QOHLGLQJ
0HWKHWµ(QYLURQPHQWDO0RGHOIRU3HRSOH$QQR\DQFHDQG5LVN$QDO\VLV¶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µJHOXLGVGHHO¶YHUEHWHUGHQJHRSHUDWLRQDOLVHHUG7HQWLMGHYDQKHW VFKULMYHQYDQGLWUDSSRUWZHUG(03$5$JHEUXLNWYRRUEHUHNHQLQJHQDDQJHOXLGYDQ ZHJYHUNHHUUDLOYHUNHHUHQOXFKWYDDUW 9DQZHJHGHPRGXODLUHRS]HWYDQKHWPRGHOLVKHWYDQEHODQJRP]LFKWWHKRXGHQRSGH EHWHNHQLVYDQGHPRGHOXLWNRPVWHQ%LQQHQKHWSURMHFWµ8LWERXZUHNHQV\VWHHPJHOXLGHQ YHUVWRULQJ¶ 0 LVKLHUYRRUKHWGHHOSURMHFWµ%HWURXZEDDUKHLGVDQDO\VHHQYDOLGDWLH¶ 0%$ RSJHQRPHQ%LQQHQGLWGHHOSURMHFWLVPHWQDPHJHNHNHQQDDUGH EHWURXZEDDUKHLGYDQGHPRGHOOHULQJYDQGHJHOXLGEHODVWLQJGRRUKHWZHJHQUDLOYHUNHHU 2PGDWGHRQWZLNNHOLQJYDQHHQPRGXOHYRRUOXFKWYDDUWJHOXLGZRUGWXLWJHYRHUGLQHHQDSDUW GHHOSURMHFWLVGHEHWURXZEDDUKHLGYDQGHEHUHNHQLQJYDQKHWOXFKWYDDUWJHOXLGJHHQ RQGHUZHUSYDQKHWGHHOSURMHFWµ%HWURXZEDDUKHLGVDQDO\VHHQYDOLGDWLH¶9HUGHU]LMYHUPHOG GDWYULMZHOXLWVOXLWHQGLVJHNHNHQQDDUGHEHWURXZEDDUKHLGYDQGHUHNHQPHWKRGLHN1DDUKHW JHEUXLNHQGHYHUEHWHULQJYDQLQYRHUHQHPLVVLHJHJHYHQVZRUGWDSDUWDDQGDFKWEHVWHHGLQ KHWSURMHFWµ0RQLWRULQJVV\VWHHP*HOXLG¶ 0 2PWHNRPHQWRWHHQVFKDWWLQJYDQGHEHWURXZEDDUKHLGYDQGHPHWKRGLHNGLHLQ(03$5$ ZRUGWWRHJHSDVWYRRUGHEHUHNHQLQJYDQGHJHOXLGEHODVWLQJLVDOOHUHHUVWHHQYHUJHOLMNLQJ XLWJHYRHUGPHWGHQDWLRQDOH6WDQGDDUG5HNHQPHWKRGHVYRRUZHJHQUDLOYHUNHHUVJHOXLG,Q KRRIGVWXNZRUGWEHVFKUHYHQZHONHVFKDWWLQJYRRUGHQDXZNHXULJKHLGYDQGHEHUHNHQLQJ YDQGHJHOXLGHPLVVLHHQ±RYHUGUDFKWKLHUXLWYROJW 'HVLWXDWLHVGLHEXLWHQKHWWRHSDVVLQJVJHELHGYDQGHVWDQGDDUGPHWKRGHVYDOOHQ]LMQDSDUW EHVWXGHHUG,QKRRIGVWXNVWDDWHHQYHUJHOLMNLQJPHWHHQQXPHULHNPRGHOYDQ712 EHVFKUHYHQ,QGH]HYHUJHOLMNLQJLVJHNHNHQQDDUGHPRGHOOHULQJYDQGHJHOXLGRYHUGUDFKW RYHUJURWHDIVWDQGHQ WRWNP LQKHWµYULMHYHOG¶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
5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ
(PLVVLHHQRYHUGUDFKWVPRGHOOHULQJ
,QGLWKRRIGVWXNZRUGWLQJHJDDQRSGHPRGHOOHULQJYDQGHJHOXLGHPLVVLHHQ±RYHUGUDFKW'LW JHEHXUWGRRUHHQYHUJHOLMNLQJWHPDNHQPHWGH6WDQGDDUG0HHWHQ5HNHQYRRUVFKULIWHQ 605 ]RDOVGLH]LMQYDVWJHOHJGLQGHZHW*HOXLGKLQGHU1DDUGHWRHSDVVLQJHQGH QDXZNHXULJKHLGYDQGH]HPHWKRGHVLVXLWJHEUHLGRQGHU]RHNXLWJHYRHUG'LWKHHIWJHOHLGWRW HHQEHHOGYDQGHDIZLMNLQJHQGLHLQYHUVFKLOOHQGHVLWXDWLHVYHUZDFKWPRJHQZRUGHQPHWGH µZHUNHOLMNH¶JHOXLGEHODVWLQJ'H]HLQIRUPDWLHLVJHEUXLNWRPHHQVFKDWWLQJWHPDNHQYDQGH QDXZNHXULJKHLGYDQGH(03$5$EHUHNHQLQJHQHQWHYHQVHYHQWXHOHPRJHOLMNKHGHQWRW YHUEHWHULQJWHLGHQWLILFHUHQ6WDQGDDUG0HHWHQ5HNHQYRRUVFKULIWHQ
'HPHWLQJHQRIEHUHNHQLQJYDQGHHPLVVLHHQGHRYHUGUDFKWYDQZHJHQUDLOYHUNHHUVJHOXLG ZRUGWLQ1HGHUODQGYULMZHODOWLMGXLWJHYRHUGDDQGHKDQGYDQKHW6WDQGDDUG0HHWHQ 5HNHQYRRUVFKULIWYRRUZHJYHUNHHUVODZDDLUHVSHFWLHYHOLMNYRRUUDLOYHUNHHUVODZDDL 5HIVHQ 'H]HYRRUVFKULIWHQ]LMQHLQGMDUHQ]HYHQWLJRSJHVWHOGRPWHNRPHQWRW]RXQLIRUP PRJHOLMNHEHUHNHQLQJVZLM]HQELMGHWRHWVLQJYDQVSHFLILHNHVLWXDWLHVDDQULFKWHQ JUHQVZDDUGHQXLWGHZHW*HOXLGKLQGHU7RHSDVVLQJHQQDXZNHXULJKHGHQ
,QGHUHNHQYRRUVFKULIWHQ]LMQVHPLHPSLULVFKHIRUPXOHVRSJHQRPHQYRRUGHEHUHNHQLQJYDQ GHHPLVVLHHQGHRYHUGUDFKW=H]LMQJHEDVHHUGRSHHQYHUHHQYRXGLJGHYRRUVWHOOLQJYDQGH I\VLFDYDQGHEURQGHYRRUWSODQWLQJYDQJHOXLGVJROYHQLQGHDWPRVIHHUGHGLIIUDFWLHHUYDQ DDQERGHPHQREMHFWHQHQGHLQWHUIHUHQWLHVGLHKLHUELMNXQQHQRQWVWDDQ2SEDVLVYDQGH YHUHHQYRXGLJGHYRRUVWHOOLQJHQ]LMQKDQWHHUEDUHDQDO\WLVFKHXLWGUXNNLQJHQRSJHVWHOGGLH]LMQ JHYDOLGHHUGPHWHHQJURRWDDQWDOPHWLQJHQ'RRUGHVNXQGLJHQYDQ712LVGHVWLMGVLQGH 605JHVWUHHIGQDDUHHQQDXZNHXULJKHLGYDQG%LQYULMZHODOOHYRRUNRPHQGHVLWXDWLHV $IKDQNHOLMNYDQGHFRPSOH[LWHLWYDQGHVLWXDWLHZRUGWHHQHHQYRXGLJH µ0HWKRGH,¶ HQHHQ XLWJHEUHLGHEHUHNHQLQJVPHWKRGH µ0HWKRGH,,¶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pp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µ0HWKRGHDQGHUKDOI¶EHWURNNHQ9DQZHJHGHEHSHUNWHWRHSDVEDDUKHLGYDQ 0HWKRGH,HQGHEHZHUNHOLMNKHLGYDQ0HWKRGH,,LVGLWHHQDDQWUHNNHOLMNHGRFKQLHW JHVWDQGDDUGLVHHUGHWXVVHQYRUPZDDULQGHVFKHUPZHUNLQJZRUGWEHQDGHUGGRRUJHEUXLNWH PDNHQYDQVWDQGDDUGVSHFWUDYRRUZHJHQRIUDLOYHUNHHUVODZDDL 7DEHO ,QGLFDWLHYHRQ]HNHUKHGHQLQUHVXOWDWHQYDQEHUHNHQLQJHQDDQVSHFLILHNHVLWXDWLHVPHW µPHWKRGHDQGHUKDOI¶ EURQ '*05 6LWXDWLH 2Q]HNHUKHLG LQG% $ %HWHNHQLV 6FKHUPHQODQJV VSRRU ZHJHQ 2YHUGUDFKWELMYDULsUHQGERGHPW\SH 6LWXDWLHVPHWDIVFKHUPLQJZDDUELM GHUHIOHFWLHELMGUDJHPDDWJHYHQGLV =2$%LQFRPELQDWLHPHWVFKHUPHQ 6SUHLGLQJ G%VSUHLGLQJG%PD[LPDOHDIZLMNLQJ G%VSUHLGLQJG%PD[DIZLMNLQJ DIZLMNLQJ V\VWHPDWLVFKHRYHUVFKDWWLQJ RQGHUOLQJHDIZLMNLQJLQUHVXOWDWHQYDQYHUVFKLOOHQGHYHUVLHVYDQµPHWKRGHDQGHUKDOI¶ DIZLMNLQJWHQRS]LFKWHYDQUHVXOWDDW0HWKRGH,, ,Q7DEHOZRUGWHHQRYHU]LFKWJHJHYHQYDQGHRQ]HNHUKHLGZDDUPHHUHNHQLQJPRHW ZRUGHQJHKRXGHQELMWRHSDVVLQJYDQGHµ0HWKRGHDQGHUKDOI¶'HJURRWWHYDQGHRQ]HNHUKHLG LVKLHUELMEHSDDOGDDQGHKDQGYDQGHVSUHLGLQJGLHGHYHUVFKLOOHQGHYHUVLHVYDQGHµ0HWKRGH
5,90UDSSRUW SDJ YDQ DQGHUKDOI¶]RDOVGLHLQRPORRS]LMQRQGHUOLQJJHYHQGDQZHODDQGHKDQGYDQGHDIZLMNLQJ WHQRS]LFKWHYDQ0HWKRGH,,2PGDW]RZHOGHVSUHLGLQJDOVGHDIZLMNLQJHQGLUHFW VDPHQKDQJHQPHWGHJHNR]HQEHQDGHULQJHQOHLGHQ]HRRNELMPLGGHOLQJRYHUHHQJURRW DDQWDOµYHUJHOLMNEDUH¶VLWXDWLHVWRWV\VWHPDWLVFKHDIZLMNLQJHQYDQGHZHUNHOLMNHZDDUGHQ
$DQSDVVLQJHQYDQKHWUHNHQYRRUVFKULIW
9RRUKHWYRRUMDDUYDQZRUGWHHQKHU]LHQLQJYDQKHWUHNHQYRRUVFKULIWYRRU ZHJYHUNHHUVODZDDLYRRU]LHQ 5HI 'H]HKHU]LHQLQJULFKW]LFKYULMZHOXLWVOXLWHQGRSGH EHUHNHQLQJYDQGHHPLVVLHVGRRUKHWZHJYHUNHHU'HEHUHNHQLQJYDQGHRYHUGUDFKWEOLMIW YRRUORSLJRQYHUDQGHUGLQDIZDFKWLQJYDQ(XURSHVHKDUPRQLVDWLH 'HZLM]LQJHQLQGHEHUHNHQLQJYDQGHHPLVVLHV]LMQJHEDVHHUGRSHHQJURRWDDQWDOPHWLQJHQ 5HI 'H]HPHWLQJHQWRQHQDDQGDWGHHPLVVLHYDQSHUVRQHQDXWR¶VVLQGVGHMDUHQµ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¶VLVYRRUKHOOLQJHQHHQ PD[LPDDO HIIHFWYDQ G% $ YDVWJHVWHOG$DQNUXLVSXQWHQPLQLURWRQGHVHQGUHPSHOVLVYRRUSHUVRQHQDXWR¶VJHHQ HIIHFWWRHJHNHQG9RRUPLGGHO]ZDDUHQ]ZDDUYHUNHHU]LMQKLHUYRRUWRWG%JURWH FRUUHFWLHVRSJHQRPHQ 1DDUYHUZDFKWLQJZRUGWRRNKHWUHNHQYRRUVFKULIWYRRUUDLOYHUNHHUVODZDDLELQQHQNRUW DDQJHSDVW'H]HDDQSDVVLQJLVQRGLJLQYHUEDQGPHWGHLQYRHULQJYDQ(XURSHVHUHJHOJHYLQJ RSKHWWHUUHLQYDQJHOXLG'HYRULJHDDQSDVVLQJYDQKHWUHNHQYRRUVFKULIWYRRUUDLOYHUNHHUV JHOXLGZDVLQ 'HUDLOYRHUWXLJHQ]LMQWRHQRSEDVLVYDQPHWLQJHQRYHUHHQJURWHUDDQWDO JHOXLGHPLVVLHFDWHJRULHs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
5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ JHPHWHQHQEHUHNHQGHZDDUGHQ PD[LPDDOFLUFDG% *HPLGGHOGOHLGWGLWWRWPHHWZDDUGHQ GLHG% DIKDQNHOLMNYDQGHULMVQHOKHLG KRJHU]LMQGDQGHEHUHNHQGHZDDUGHQ'RRUGH JURWHPHHWVSUHLGLQJ]LMQGH]HYHUVFKLOOHQHFKWHUQLHWVLJQLILFDQW'LWJHOGWQLHWYRRUORFDWLHV PHWH[WUHPHVSRRUUXZKHLG JROIVOLMWDJH +LHUNXQQHQGHEHUHNHQLQJHQOHLGHQWRW RQGHUVFKDWWLQJYDQGHHPLVVLHVPHWHQNHOHG%¶V
*HEUXLNYDQGH650VLQ(03$5$
9RRUGHPRGHOOHULQJYDQGHHPLVVLHVHQGHRYHUGUDFKWLQ(03$5$LVXLWJHJDDQYDQGH PHWKRGLHNXLWGHUHNHQYRRUVFKULIWHQHQLV]RYHHOPRJHOLMNJHEUXLNJHPDDNWYDQGHHPLVVLH HQRYHUGUDFKWVIRUPXOHVXLWGH]HYRRUVFKULIWHQ'LWLPSOLFHHUWGDWUHNHQLQJPRHWZRUGHQ JHKRXGHQPHWGHDIZLMNLQJHQHQRQ]HNHUKHGHQGLHLQGHYRULJHSDUDJUDIHQ]LMQEHVFKUHYHQ 2PUHGHQYDQKDQWHHUEDDUKHLGLVELMGHLPSOHPHQWDWLHYDQGHPHWKRGLHNHQGHIRUPXOHVLQ (03$5$HHQDDQWDO]DNHQµYHUHHQYRXGLJG¶RIJHZLM]LJGWHQRS]LFKWHYDQKHW UHNHQYRRUVFKULIW'LWLVJHEHXUGPHWGHGRHOVWHOOLQJRPRSJURWH ODQGHOLMNH VFKDDOWHNXQQHQ UHNHQHQDDQGHJHOXLGEHODVWLQJ 9DQEHODQJYRRUGHPRGHORQ]HNHUKHLG]LMQPHWQDPHGHYROJHQGHDVSHFWHQYDQGH PRGHOOHULQJ GHPRGHOOHULQJYDQGHHPLVVLH GHQLHWVSHFWUDOHPRGHOOHULQJ GHPRGHOOHULQJYDQGHDIVFKHUPHQGHZHUNLQJYDQDOOHHQJHOXLGVFKHUPHQ GHPRGHOOHULQJYDQJHOXLGVFKHUPHQLQFRPELQDWLHPHW=2$% GHPRGHOOHULQJYDQGHRYHUGUDFKWYDQKHWJHOXLGLQEHERXZGHJHELHGHQ µ'KXLV¶ 'H]HDVSHFWHQ]XOOHQLQGHYROJHQGHSDUDJUDIHQPHWQDPHLQNZDOLWDWLHYH]LQQDGHUZRUGHQ EHVSURNHQ2RN]LMQUHFHQWGRRUJHYRHUGHYHUEHWHULQJHQEHVFKUHYHQ0RGHOOHULQJYDQGHHPLVVLH
9RRUGHHHUVWHYHUVLHYDQ(03$5$]LMQGHHPLVVLHIRUPXOHVJHEUXLNWXLWGH650¶V ,QYyyUGHEHUHNHQLQJHQYRRUGHYLMIGH0LOLHXYHUNHQQLQJ]LMQGHHPLVVLHIRUPXOHVYRRU ZHJYHUNHHUDDQJHSDVWRSEDVLVYDQHPLVVLHJHJHYHQVGLHPHGLRMDUHQQHJHQWLJEHVFKLNEDDU ]LMQJHNRPHQ 5HI $OVGH]HDDQSDVVLQJHQZRUGHQYHUJHOHNHQPHWGHIRUPXOHVGLHLQKHW NDGHUYDQGHKHU]LHQLQJZRUGHQYRRUJHVWHOGGDQEOLMNHQDIKDQNHOLMNYDQGH YRHUWXLJFDWHJRULHHQ±VQHOKHLGYHUVFKLOOHQRSWHWUHGHQWRWPD[LPDDOG% $ *HPLGGHOG RYHUDOOHVQHOKHGHQHQYRHUWXLJHQLVKHWYHUVFKLOPLQGHUGDQG% $ 2SKHWPRPHQWGDWGHKHU]LHQLQJYDQKHWUHNHQYRRUVFKULIWZRUGWJHsIIHFWXHHUG]XOOHQ GDDURPGHHPLVVLHIRUPXOHVYRRUZHJYHUNHHULQ(03$5$ZRUGHQDDQJHSDVWDDQGH HPLVVLHIRUPXOHVXLWGH]HKHU]LHQLQJ ,QGHRRUVSURQNHOLMNHPRGHOOHULQJZHUGHQ VSRRU ZHJHQJHPRGHOOHHUGDOVSXQWEURQQHQ 'LFKWELMGH VSRRU ZHJHQRQWVWRQGHQKLHUGRRUDIZLMNLQJHQ YDQPD[LPDDOG% WHQRS]LFKWH YDQGHOLMQEURQPRGHOOHULQJGLHLQGHUHNHQYRRUVFKULIWHQZRUGWJHKDQWHHUG,QPLGGHOVLVHHQSDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW OLMQEURQPRGHOOHULQJJHwPSOHPHQWHHUG 5HI ZDDUGRRUGH]HDIZLMNLQJHQQLHWPHHU RSWUHGHQ
1LHWVSHFWUDOHPRGHOOHULQJ
2PGHUHNHQWLMGYDQ(03$5$WHEHSHUNHQLVJHNR]HQYRRUHHQµIUHTXHQWLHOR]H¶ PRGHOOHULQJYDQGHHPLVVLHHQRYHUGUDFKW'LWLVJHEHXUGLQRYHUOHJPHWGHVNXQGLJHQYDQ 71273' 5HI 'HSDUDPHWULVDWLHLQ(03$5$LVKLHUELMDIJHVWHPGRSGHGHPSLQJYDQ KHWVWDQGDDUGVSHFWUDYRRUZHJHQUDLOYHUNHHUVJHOXLG )LJXXUJHHIWKHWDIVWDQGVYHUORRSYDQGHGHPSLQJVHQFRUUHFWLHWHUPHQ]RDOVGLHZRUGHQ JHEUXLNWYRRUGHEHUHNHQLQJYDQGHRYHUGUDFKWYDQZHJYHUNHHUVJHOXLG'HZDDUGHQYRRU UDLOYHUNHHUVJHOXLGNXQQHQRSJURWHUHDIVWDQGHQHQNHOHG%¶VDIZLMNHQ9RRUGHEHWHNHQLVYDQ GHYHUVFKLOOHQGHGHPSLQJVHQFRUUHFWLHWHUPHQZRUGWYHUZH]HQQDDUGHEHVFKULMYLQJYDQ (03$5$ 5HIVHQ %LMGHEHSDOLQJYDQGHWHUPHQLVXLWJHJDDQYDQHHQZHJKRRJWHYDQPHQHHQ ERGHPKDUGKHLGYDQYRRUKHWEXLWHQJHELHGHQYRRUKHWVWHGHOLMNHEHERXZGHJHELHG'H REMHFWGHPSLQJ µ'KXLV¶ LVJHEDVHHUGRSHHQYHUEHWHUGHPRGHOOHULQJ'H]H]DOLQSDUDJUDDI QDGHUZRUGHQWRHJHOLFKW )LJXXU $IVWDQGVDIKDQNHOLMNKHLGGHPSLQJVHQFRUUHFWLHWHUPHQZHJYHUNHHUVODZDDL 9DQZHJHKHWRQWEUHNHQYDQLQIRUPDWLHRYHUGHKRRJWHOLJJLQJYDQZHJHQZRUGWELMGH (03$5$EHUHNHQLQJDDQJHQRPHQGDWULMNVZHJHQVWDQGDDUGHHQKRRJWHYDQPWHQ RS]LFKWHYDQKHWPDDLYHOGKHEEHQ9RRUSURYLQFLDOHHQJHPHHQWHOLMNHZHJHQZRUGW DDQJHQRPHQGDWGHKRRJWHJHOLMNLVDDQGLHYDQKHWPDDLYHOG'HKDUGKHLGYDQGHERGHP ZRUGWJHVFKDWDDQGHKDQGYDQKHWODQGJHEUXLNVEHVWDQGµKHWGHUGH/DQGJHEUXLN1HGHUODQG /*1 ¶=RNULMJHQGH/*1FDWHJRULHsQµJODVWXLQERXZ¶HQµRSHQZDWHU¶GHERGHPIDFWRUµ¶ $IVWDQGWRWZHJ P 7U DQ VP LV VL H G% $ JHRPHWULVFKHXLWEUHLGLQJ OXFKWGHPSLQJ ERGHPFRUUHFWLH PHWHRFRUUHFWLH REMHFWGHPSLQJ YHUEHWHUGH'KXLV5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ DNRHVWLVFKKDUG GHFDWHJRULHsQµJUDV¶HQµERV¶ YHUVFKLOOHQGHRQGHUYHUGHOLQJHQ NULMJHQGH ERGHPIDFWRUµ¶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µPDWLJVWHGHOLMN¶YDQKHWEHERXZGHJHELHG PHWHHQ FRsIILFLsQWYRRUGHWUDQVPLVVLHYDQKHWJHOXLGGRRUGHHHUVWHOLMQVEHERXZLQJYDQHHQ JHPLGGHOGHEHERXZLQJVKRRJWHYDQPHHQYULMHZHJOHQJWHYDQELMQDPHHQJHPLGGHOGH DEVRUSWLHFRsIILFLsQWYDQKHWJHOXLGGRRUEHERXZLQJYDQ 8LW)LJXXUEOLMNWGDWGHLQYORHGYDQKHWJHEUXLNYDQJHVWDQGDDUGLVHHUGHZHJKRRJWHVHQ ERGHPIDFWRUHQRSGHJHOXLGEHODVWLQJRYHUKHWDOJHPHHQEHSHUNWLVWRWHQNHOHG%¶V$OOHHQ HHQYHUKRJLQJYDQGHZHJKRRJWHPHWPLQKHWVWHGHOLMNHJHELHGOHLGWRSJURWHDIVWDQGHQ YDQPWRWNP WRWHHQYHUVFKLOPHWGHQRPLQDOHZDDUGHYDQUXLPG%'LWZRUGWPHW QDPHYHURRU]DDNWGRRUGHYHUPLQGHUGHVFKHUPZHUNLQJYDQGHHHUVWHOLMQVEHERXZLQJ 9RRUDOVQRJOLMNWGH XQLIRUPH KRRJWHVFKDWWLQJYDQGHZHJHQUHDOLVWLVFKHQ]DORRNGH ERGHPIDFWRUUHGHOLMNQDXZNHXULJHQEHWURXZEDDUZRUGHQEHSDDOG'HLQYORHGYDQGH]H SDUDPHWHUVRSGHµJHPLGGHOGH¶JHOXLGEHODVWLQJLVQDDUYHUZDFKWLQJGDQRRNUHODWLHIJHULQJ /RNDDOZDDUZHJHQYHUGLHSWGDQZHOYHUKRRJG]LMQDDQJHOHJG]LMQDIZLMNLQJHQWH YHUZDFKWHQ]RDOVJHWRRQGLQ)LJXXU'LWVWHPWRYHUHHQPHWGHRQ]HNHUKHLGYRRU EHUHNHQLQJHQDDQµRYHUGUDFKWELMYDULsUHQGERGHPW\SH¶]RDOVJHQRHPGLQ7DEHO )LJXXU 9HUORRSJHOXLGWUDQVPLVVLHELMYHUVFKLOOHQGHZHJKRRJWHVHQKDUGKHLGEHSDDOGWHQ RS]LFKWHYDQQRPLQDOHWUDQVPLVVLHLQVWHGHOLMNJHELHG ,ERGHPIDFWRUZHJKRRJWHP HQQLHW VWHGHOLMNJHELHG ERGHPIDFWRUZHJKRRJWHP 'HZDDUQHHPKRRJWHLVP $IVWDQGWRWZHJ P 7U DQ VP LV VL HY HU VF KL O G% $ DIZLMNHQGHZHJKRRJWH P DIZLMNHQGHZHJKRRJWH P DIZLMNHQGHZHJKRRJWH P DIZLMNHQGHZHJKRRJWH P ERGHPIDFWRU
SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW
([SOLFLHWHYHUJHOLMNLQJPHW650,,
,QKHWNDGHUYDQHHQVWXGLHQDDUGHLPSOLFDWLHVYDQGHYRRUJHQRPHQLQYRHULQJYDQHHQ(8 ULFKWOLMQYRRUJHOXLGYRRUJHOXLGNDUWHULQJLVUHFHQWHOLMNHHQH[SOLFLHWHYHUJHOLMNLQJXLWJHYRHUG WXVVHQ(03$5$HQGH KHU]LHQH 650,,YRRUZHJYHUNHHUVJHOXLG2PGDWGH]HVWXGLH DDQYXOOHQGLVRSKHWJHHQLQLVXLWJHYRHUGRSKHWJHELHGYDQPRGHOYHUJHOLMNLQJ]LMQGH UHVXOWDWHQHUYDQLQGLWUDSSRUWRSJHQRPHQ 9RRUGH650,,IRUPXOHVLVJHEUXLNJHPDDNWYDQKHWFRQFHSWYDQKHWKHU]LHQH5HNHQHQ 0HHWYRRUVFKULIWYRRUZHJYHUNHHUVODZDDL 5HI 'H(03$5$EHUHNHQLQJHQ]LMQ XLWJHYRHUGPHWHHQDDQJHSDVWHYHUEHWHUGHPRGHOOHULQJYDQVFKHUPZHUNLQJ ]LHYROJHQGH SDUDJUDDI HQREMHFWGHPSLQJ GRRUEHERXZLQJ (HQEHVFKULMYLQJYDQGHJHEUXLNWH PRGHOOHULQJYDQHPLVVLHHQRYHUGUDFKWZRUGWJHJHYHQLQ%LMODJH ,QGHYHUJHOLMNLQJLVHQNHOJHNHNHQQDDUGHLQYORHGYDQGHPRGHOOHULQJYDQGHRYHUGUDFKWHQ QLHWQDDUGHLQYORHGYDQGHUXLPWHOLMNHGLVFUHWLVDWLHHQVFKHPDWLVHULQJYDQGHRPJHYLQJ 2RNLVGHYHUJHOLMNLQJEHSHUNWWRWKHWODQGHOLMNHJHELHG JHHQEHERXZLQJ 'LWKHHIWDOVUHGHQ GDWHHQEHUHNHQLQJYDQGHJHOXLGRYHUGUDFKWRYHUJURWHUHDIVWDQGHQLQEHERXZGHRPJHYLQJ PHW650,,QLHWPRJHOLMNLV 'HYHUJHOLMNLQJLVXLWJHYRHUGDDQGHKDQGYDQppQVLWXDWLHZDDULQpp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±VQHOKHLG6DPHQVWHOOLQJHQVQHOKHLG]LMQYDQ LQYORHGRSGHHPLVVLH2PWHNRPHQWRWUHDOLVWLVFKHYHUGHOLQJHQLVJHEUXLNJHPDDNWYDQ JHJHYHQVYRRUKHWYHUNHHURSULMNVZHJHQSURYLQFLDOHZHJHQHQµPLGGHOJURWH¶ ELQQHQVWHGHOLMNHZHJHQXLWGHYLMIGH0LOLHXYHUNHQQLQJ ]LH7DEHO 7DEHO %HVFKRXZGHµW\SLVFKH¶YHUGHOLQJHQYHUNHHU QDDU09 $DQWDOOHQ YRHUWXLJHQXXU 6QHOKHLG NPX :HJW\SH OY PY ]Y PU OY PY ]Y PU 5LMNVZHJHQ 3URYLQFLDDO %LQQHQVWHGHOLMNOY OLFKWYHUNHHUPY PLGGHO]ZDDUYHUNHHU]Y ]ZDDUYHUNHHUPU PRWRUHQ
'HUHVXOWDWHQYDQGHEHUHNHQLQJHQ]LMQZHHUJHJHYHQLQELMODJH8LWGHUHVXOWDWHQEOLMNWGDW GHYHUVFKLOOHQEHSHUNWEOLMYHQWRWjG% $ ]RZHOPHWDOV]RQGHUDDQZH]LJKHLGYDQ VFKHUPHQ$OOHHQYRRUGHVLWXDWLHYDQHHQULMNVZHJZDDULQRYHUKHWJHKHOHRYHUGUDFKWVSDG
5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ VSUDNHLVYDQHHQKDUGHERGHPJHVWHOGKHLGHQLQDDQZH]LJKHLGYDQVFKHUPHQJHHIWGH PHWKRGH/%9HHQWRWG% $ KRJHUHXLWNRPVW
0RGHOOHULQJYDQGHVFKHUPZHUNLQJ
'HZLM]HZDDURSGHVFKHUPZHUNLQJDORIQLHWLQFRPELQDWLHPHWGHZHUNLQJYDQ=2$%LQ (03$5$LVJHPRGHOOHHUGLVJH]LHQGHYHUHHQYRXGLJLQJWHQRS]LFKWHYDQGH650,,HHQ SRWHQWLsOHEURQYDQRQ]HNHUKHLG'H]HRQ]HNHUKHLGKRXGWQLHWDOOHHQYHUEDQGPHWKHWIHLWGDW GHVFKHUPZHUNLQJIUHTXHQWLHDIKDQNHOLMNLVPDDU]HNHURRNPHWKHWIHLWGDWGHVFKHUPZHUNLQJ LQ(03$5$LVYHUGLVFRQWHHUGLQGHHPLVVLH'LWOHLGWWRWHHQXQLIRUPHYHUODJLQJLQGH JHOXLGEHODVWLQJDDQEHLGH]LMGHQYDQHHQ VSRRU ZHJZDDUVFKHUPHQDDQppQ]LMGHGDQZHO DDQWZHH]LMGHQ]LMQJHSODDWVW+LHUGRRUZRUGWPHWQDPHKHWDDQWDOKRRJEHODVWHZRQLQJHQ RQGHUVFKDW+HWYHUODJHQYDQGHHPLVVLHKRXGWWHYHQVLQGDWGHVFKHUPZHUNLQJQLHW DIKDQNHOLMNZRUGWJHVWHOGYDQGHDIVWDQGYDQZHJWRWVFKHUPHQHU]LMGVHQYDQRQWYDQJHUSXQW WRWKHWVFKHUPDQGHU]LMGV'HPDWHZDDULQGH]HDIVWDQGHQHHQUROVSHOHQELMGH VFKHUPZHUNLQJZRUGWJHWRRQGLQ)LJXXUHQ)LJXXU,QGH]HILJXUHQLVKHWYHUVFKLO JHQRPHQWXVVHQGHµRXGH¶HPLVVLHYHUODJLQJHQHHQRYHUGUDFKWVPRGHOOHULQJGLHGHI\VLVFKH ZHUNHOLMNKHLGEHWHUEHQDGHUW 5HI ,Q)LJXXULVHHQDIVWDQGWXVVHQZHJPLGGHQHQ VFKHUPYDQPDDQJHKRXGHQ,Q)LJXXULVGH]HDIVWDQGP,Q(03$5$ZRUGW JHUHNHQGPHWDIVWDQGHQGLHYDULsUHQYDQPWRWPDIKDQNHOLMNYDQKHWDDQWDOULMVWURNHQ YDQGHZHJ0HWDIVWDQGHQYDQUHVSHFWLHYHOLMNPZRUGWJHUHNHQGLQKHWJHYDOYDQHQ ULMVWURNHQ 8LWGHILJXUHQEOLMNWGDWELMHHQDIVWDQGWXVVHQZHJHQVFKHUPYDQPHQVFKHUPKRRJWHV YDQHQPGHJHOXLGGHPSLQJGRRUGHHPLVVLHYHUODJLQJPHWWRWG% $ ZRUGW RYHUVFKDW%LMKRJHUHVFKHUPHQEHGUDDJWGH]HRYHUVFKDWWLQJj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j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
0RGHOOHULQJYDQGHVFKHUPZHUNLQJLQFRPELQDWLHPHW=2$%
'RRUGDWGHZHUNLQJYDQVFKHUPHQHQ=2$%QLHWELMDOOHIUHTXHQWLHVHYHQJURRWLV]LMQ UHGXFWLHVLQGHJHOXLGEHODVWLQJWHQJHYROJHYDQVFKHUPHQHQ=2$%QLHWDGGLWLHI=HNHURS $IVWDQGWRWZHJ P YH UV FK LO LQ J HO XL GQ LY HD X G % $ KRRJWHVFKHUP P KRRJWHVFKHUP P KRRJWHVFKHUP P KRRJWHVFKHUP P $IVWDQGWRWZHJ P YH UV FK LO LQ J HO XL GQ LY HD X G % $ KRRJWHVFKHUP P KRRJWHVFKHUP P KRRJWHVFKHUP P KRRJWHVFKHUP P5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ JURWHUHDIVWDQGHQYDQGHZHJJHOGWGDWGHWRWDOH G% $ UHGXFWLHGRRUGHFRPELQDWLHYDQ VFKHUPHQHQ=2$%NOHLQHULVGDQGHµVRP¶YDQGHDI]RQGHUOLMNHUHGXFWLHV ,QGHPRGHOOHULQJZRUGWKLHUPHHJHHQUHNHQLQJJHKRXGHQZDDUGRRURSGLHSOHNNHQZDDU ]RZHOVFKHUPHQ]LMQJHSODDWVWDOV=2$%LVDDQJHOHJGHHQRQGHUVFKDWWLQJRSWUHHGWYDQGH JHOXLGEHODVWLQJYDQjG% $ *HOHWRSKHWUHODWLHIJHULQJHDDQWDONLORPHWHUVZHJPHW VFKHUPHQpQ=2$% FLUFDYDQGHUXLPNPULMNVZHJHQ OHLGWGH]HRQGHUVFKDWWLQJ QLHWWRWHHQVXEVWDQWLsOHRQQDXZNHXULJKHLGLQKHWDDQWDOJHOXLGEHODVWHZRQLQJHQ8LWHHQ EHUHNHQLQJDDQGLWHIIHFWEOLMNWGDWKHWWRWDOHDDQWDOJHOXLGEHODVWHZRQLQJHQ !G% $ GRRUKHWZHJYHUNHHURSULMNVZHJHQKLHUGRRUPHWFLUFDZRUGWRQGHUVFKDW2SKHWWRWDOH DDQWDOZRQLQJHQGDWEHODVWLVGRRUKHWJHOXLGYDQKHWZHJYHUNHHUVFKHHOWGLWFLUFDppQSURFHQW 8LWHUDDUGJHOGWGDWELMVWXGLHVZDDULQVSHFLILHNZRUGWJHNHNHQQDDUGHHIIHFWLYLWHLWYDQ VFKHUPHQpQ=2$%UHNHQLQJPRHWZRUGHQJHKRXGHQPHWGLWHIIHFW
'HPRGHOOHULQJYDQGHJHOXLGRYHUGUDFKWLQEHERXZGHJHELHGHQ
µ'
KXLV¶
9RRUGHEHSDOLQJYDQGHJHOXLGRYHUGUDFKWDFKWHUGHHHUVWHOLMQVEHERXZLQJEHVWDDWJHHQ ZHWWHOLMNYRRUJHVFKUHYHQPHWKRGH,QGHSUDNWLMNZRUGWYRRUUHODWLHINOHLQHJHELHGHQRS µHQLJH¶DIVWDQGDFKWHUGHHHUVWHOLMQVEHERXZLQJJHUHNHQGPHW650,,'H]HPHWKRGHVWHOW KRJHHLVHQDDQGHUXLPWHOLMNHQDXZNHXULJKHLGYDQGHRPJHYLQJVNHQPHUNHQ9RRUJURWHUH JHELHGHQZRUGWHHQPHWKRGHJHEUXLNWGLHLVDIJHOHLGYDQKHW'XLWVH9',YRRUVFKULIW 5HI ,QGH]HPHWKRGHZRUGW]RZHOGHDIVFKHUPHQGHZHUNLQJYDQGHHHUVWHOLMQVEHERXZLQJDOV GHJHOXLGVWUDQVPLVVLHGRRUGH]HEHERXZLQJJHPRGHOOHHUG'HDIVFKHUPHQGHZHUNLQJZRUGW KLHUELMEHUHNHQGDDQGHKDQGYDQGH]RJHQDDPGHµDNRHVWLVFKHRPZHJ¶GLHHHQJHOXLGVWUDDO PDDNWµRYHUGHEHERXZLQJKHHQ¶'HWUDQVPLVVLHZRUGWDIKDQNHOLMNJHVWHOGYDQGHPDWHYDQ RSHQKHLGYDQGHEHERXZLQJ]RDOVGH]HµZRUGWJH]LHQ¶GRRUGHUHFKWVWUHHNVHJHOXLGVWUDDO'H WRWDOHGHPSLQJZRUGWYHUYROJHQVEHSDDOGGRRUGHµNOHLQVWH¶YDQGH]HWZHHGHPSLQJVWHUPHQ +HWWRWDDOYDQGHGHPSLQJGRRUGHDDQZH]LJKHLGYDQGHEHERXZLQJZRUGWRRNZHODDQJHGXLG PHWµ'KXLV¶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tHQGHDIVWDQGWRWGHHHUVWHOLMQVEHERXZLQJ'HOESDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW
)LJXXU 2RUVSURQNHOLMNH HQYHUEHWHUGH'KXLV ELMYHUVFKLOOHQGHEHERXZLQJVGLFKWKHGHQ
OY P ]HHUVWHGHOLMNOY P PDWLJVWHGHOLMNOY ZHLQLJVWHGHOLMN
)LJXXU 2RUVSURQNHOLMNH HQYHUEHWHUGH'KXLV ELMYHUVFKLOOHQGHWUDQVPLVVLHGRRUGH
HHUVWHOLMQVEHERXZLQJ WDX YULMZHOYROOHGLJDDQHHQJHVORWHQEHERXZLQJWDX KDOIRSHQ EHERXZLQJWDX RSHQEHERXZLQJ )LJXXU 2RUVSURQNHOLMNH HQYHUEHWHUGH'KXLV ELMYHUVFKLOOHQGHDIVWDQGHQWRWGH HHUVWHOLMQVEHERXZLQJ $IVWDQGWRWZHJ P ' KX LV G % $ 'HEE P 'HEE P 'HEE P $IVWDQGWRWZHJ P ' KX LV G % $ OY P OY P OY P $IVWDQGWRWZHJ P ' KX LV G % $ WDX WDX WDX
5,90UDSSRUW SDJ YDQ ,QDOOHJHYDOOHQEOLMNHQELMYULMZHODOOHDIVWDQGHQWXVVHQZHJHQRQWYDQJHUSXQWJURWH YHUVFKLOOHQPHWGHµRXGH¶PRGHOOHULQJRSWHWUHGHQ ,QKRRIGVWXN]DOZRUGHQDDQJHWRRQGGDWGHYHUEHWHUGHPRGHOOHULQJYDQ'KXLVOHLGWWRW YHUJURWLQJYDQGHEHWURXZEDDUKHLGYDQGHEHUHNHQLQJHQ'LWJHEHXUWDDQGHKDQGYDQHHQ YHUJHOLMNLQJPHWPHWLQJHQGLHVSHFLDDOYRRUGHYDOLGDWLHYDQGH'KXLVPRGHOOHULQJ]LMQ XLWJHYRHUG
([WHUQHLQYRHUJHJHYHQV
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µ2QWZLNNHOLQJPRQLWRULQJVV\VWHHPJHOXLG¶ 5HI ,QPLGGHOV]LMQQLHXZHJHXSGDWHEHVWDQGHQPHWGHLQIRUPDWLHRYHUGHYHUNHHUVLQWHQVLWHLWHQ RSSURYLQFLDOHZHJHQGHORFDWLHVYDQVFKHUPHQHQ=2$%EHVFKLNEDDU1DDUYHUZDFKWLQJ NRPWELQQHQNRUWRRNHHQEHVWDQGPHWGHKRRJWHOLJJLQJYDQZHJHQEHVFKLNEDDU'H]H LQIRUPDWLH]DOLQGHORRSYDQZRUGHQEHZHUNWWRWEUXLNEDUHEHVWDQGHQELQQHQKHW (03$5$V\VWHHP5HVXPp
2SEDVLVYDQUHFHQWHOLWHUDWXXURYHUGHQDXZNHXULJKHLGYDQGHZHWWHOLMNHUHNHQPHWKRGHVYRRU KHWJHOXLGYDQKHWZHJHQUDLOYHUNHHUHQHHQYHUJHOLMNLQJYDQGHJHOXLGPRGHOOHULQJGLHLQ (03$5$ZRUGWWRHJHSDVWRSEDVLVYDQGH]HPHWKRGHVNDQZRUGHQDIJHVFKDWGDWGH RQ]HNHUKHLGLQGH(03$5$UHVXOWDWHQYRRUGHJHOXLGEHODVWLQJRSHHQEHUHNHQLQJVORFDWLH RYHUKHWDOJHPHHQQLHWJURWHULVGDQHQNHOHGHFLEHOOHQ*HPLGGHOGRYHUHHQJHELHGWHUJURWH YDQHHQPLGGHOJURWHVWDGEHGUDDJWGHRQQDXZNHXULJKHLGLQGHµJHPLGGHOGH¶JHOXLGEHODVWLQJ QDDUVFKDWWLQJPD[LPDDOG% $ %LMJHEUXLNYDQKHWPRGHOYRRUORNDOHVWXGLHVHQELMGHGRRUUHNHQLQJYDQVSHFLILHNH PDDWUHJHOHQPHWQDPHGHWRHSDVVLQJYDQVFKHUPHQPRH V W ]LHSDJ UHNHQLQJ JHKRXGHQZRUGHQPHWJURWHUHHQV\VWHPDWLVFKHDIZLMNLQJHQ'LWNDQYRRUKHWDDQWDO ZRQLQJHQPHWHHQKRJHJHOXLGEHODVWLQJ !G% $ GRRUULMNVZHJHQUHVXOWHUHQLQHHQ RQ]HNHUKHLGVPDUJHGLHEHGXLGHQGJURWHULVGDQGHEHUHNHQGHZDDUGHYRRUGLWDDQWDOSDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW
9DOLGDWLH
,QGLWKRRIGVWXNZRUGWHHQWZHHWDOVWXGLHVEHVFKUHYHQGLHVSHFLILHN]LMQXLWJHYRHUGWHU YDOLGDWLHYDQGHRYHUGUDFKWVPRGHOOHULQJ]RDOVGLHLVJHwPSOHPHQWHHUGLQ(03$5$+HW EHWUHIWHQHU]LMGVHHQYHUJHOLMNLQJPHWHHQQXPHULHNPRGHOYDQ712YRRUGHEHUHNHQLQJYDQ GHJHOXLGRYHUGUDFKWRYHUJURWHDIVWDQGHQHQDQGHU]LMGVGHYDOLGDWLHYDQGHGHPSLQJGRRU EHERXZLQJGRRUGHXLWYRHULQJYDQHHQVHULHPHWLQJHQLQHHQWZHHWDOZRRQZLMNHQ*HOXLGRYHUGUDFKWLQGHµYULMHYHOG¶VLWXDWLH
9RRUGHEHUHNHQLQJYDQGHRYHUVFKULMGLQJYDQGHQRUPLQVWLOWHJHELHGHQLVKHWQRRG]DNHOLMN GDWZRUGWJHUHNHQGYRRUJURWHDIVWDQGHQWXVVHQEURQHQµRQWYDQJHU¶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µJUDV¶YHURQGHUVWHOG%LM GHEHUHNHQLQJPHWKHW3(PRGHONDQELQQHQGH]HµNODVVH¶QRJZRUGHQJHYDULHHUGPHWGH DNRHVWLVFKHLPSHGDQWLHYDQGHERGHP+LHUELM]LMQYDULDWLHVEHNHNHQ2RNNDQPHWKHW3( PRGHODDQHHQµZLOOHNHXULJ¶PHHZLQGSURILHOZRUGHQJHUHNHQG+LHULVJHNR]HQYRRUKHW SURILHOGDWKHWPHHVWSDVWELMGHPHHZLQGVLWXDWLHYDQGHVWDQGDDUGUHNHQPHWKRGH %LMGHYHUJHOLMNLQJLVRRN6WDQGDDUG5HNHQPHWKRGH 650,, EHWURNNHQ+LHULPSOLFHHUWGH NHX]HYRRUHHQµ]DFKWH¶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
*HOXLGRYHUGUDFKWLQGHEHERXZGH VWHGHOLMNH RPJHYLQJ
2PGHQLHXZHYHUEHWHUGHPRGHOOHULQJYDQGHGHPSLQJYDQKHWJHOXLGGRRUEHERXZLQJLQGH VWHGHOLMNHRPJHYLQJWHNXQQHQYDOLGHUHQLVLQRSGUDFKWYDQKHW5,90GRRUKHWDNRHVWLVFK DGYLHVEXUHDX'*05HHQVHULHPHWLQJHQXLWJHYRHUGLQHHQWZHHWDOZRRQZLMNHQ9RRUHHQ XLWJHEUHLGHEHVFKULMYLQJYDQGHXLWYRHULQJYDQGHPHWLQJHQHQGHUHVXOWDWHQZRUGWYHUZH]HQ QDDUHHQDSDUWUDSSRUW 5HI %LMGHNHX]HYDQGHZRRQZLMNHQLVJHOHWRSGHYHUNHHUVVLWXDWLH ppQGRPLQDQWHµUHFKWH¶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t GHWUDQVPLVVLHGRRUHHUVWHOLMQVEHERXZLQJ /Y GHYULMHZHJOHQJWHDFKWHU GHHHUVWHOLMQVEHERXZLQJ HQ+ GHEHERXZLQJVKRRJWH RSEDVLVYDQYLVXHOHZDDUQHPLQJ ZDDUGHQWRHWHNHQQHQ+HWYHUORRSLVRRNEHUHNHQGRSEDVLVYDQGHVFKHPDWLVHULQJ]RDOVGLH ZRUGWWRHJHSDVWELMGHEHUHNHQLQJHQ+LHUELMZRUGWXLWJHJDDQYDQGHVWHGHOLMNKHLGVJUDDG ]RDOVGLHYROJWXLWHHQFRPELQDWLHYDQGHEHVWDQGHQµKHWGHUGH/DQGJHEUXLN1HGHUODQG¶ /*1 HQKHWµ:LMNHQ%XXUWUHJLVWHU¶2SEDVLVYDQGH]HEHVWDQGHQZRUGWDDQGHZHVWHOLMNH ZLMNRYHUDOGHVWHGHOLMNKHLGVJUDDGµZHLQLJVWHGHOLMN¶WRHJHNHQG+HWZHVWHOLMNHGHHOYDQGH ZHVWHOLMNHZLMNNULMJWHYHQHHQVGH]HNDUDNWHULVHULQJ$DQKHWRRVWHOLMNHGHHOYDQGH]HZLMN ZRUGWGHVWHGHOLMNKHLGVJUDDGµPDWLJVWHGHOLMN¶WRHJHNHQG%RYHQGLHQYHUVFKLOWGHDIVWDQGWRW GHHHUVWHOLMQVEHERXZLQJ,QGH(03$5$EHUHNHQLQJLVYRRUGHZHVWHOLMNHZLMNHHQDIVWDQG YDQPDDQJHKRXGHQ YRRUGHRRVWHOLMNHZLMNJHOGWHHQDIVWDQGYDQUXLPP%LMGH XLWYRHULQJYDQHHQJULGEHUHNHQLQJLVGH]HDIVWDQGDIKDQNHOLMNYDQGHOLJJLQJYDQGHZHJHQ GHEHERXZLQJLQGHJULGFHOOHQ ,QRQGHUVWDDQGHWDEHOZRUGWHHQRYHU]LFKWJHJHYHQYDQGHZDDUGHQGLHYROJHQXLWGHYLVXHOH HQGHQRPLQDOHWRHNHQQLQJHQDDQGHSDUDPHWHUVt/YHQGHEHERXZLQJVKRRJWH+ 7DEHO 3DUDPHWHUZDDUGHQYRRUEHUHNHQLQJYDQ'KXLVELMYLVXHOHHQQRPLQDOHWRHNHQQLQJ 9LVXHHO 1RPLQDDO
:HVWHOLMNHZLMN 2RVWHOLMNHZLMN :HLQLJVWHGHOLMN 0DWLJVWHGHOLMN
t /Y + t /Y + t /Y + t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
SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW JHFRQVWDWHHUGGDWHHQQDXZNHXULJHUHQ LQKHWVWHGHOLMNJHELHG YHUGHUJHGLIIHUHQWLHHUG EHVWDQGPHWEHERXZLQJVLQIRUPDWLHJHZHQVWLV 'H]HFRQVWDWHULQJVOXLWDDQELMGHRSPHUNLQJYDQ'*05RYHUKHWJHEUXLNYDQ JHVWDQGDDUGLVHHUGHZDDUGHQ µ'RRUKHWJHEUXLNYDQJHVWDQGDDUGLVHHUGHZDDUGHQNXQQHQ DIZLMNLQJHQYDQHQNHOHG%¶VRSWUHGHQ+HWLVHFKWHURRNPRJHOLMNGDWGHGRRUYHUVFKLOOHQGH SDUDPHWHUVYHURRU]DDNWHDIZLMNLQJHQHONDDUFRPSHQVHUHQ'LWNDQEHWHNHQHQGDWKHW XLWHLQGHOLMNHHIIHFWEHSHUNWEOLMIW2PKLHUQDGHUHXLWVSUDNHQRYHUWHNXQQHQGRHQGLHQHQ YRRUPHHUGHUHZRRQZLMNHQEHUHNHQLQJHQWHZRUGHQXLWJHYRHUGPHWGHYRRUGHEHWUHIIHQGH ZRRQZLMNHQJHOGHQGHZDDUGHQYRRUGHJHQRHPGHSDUDPHWHUV RSEDVLVYDQNDDUWPDWHULDDO HQPHWGHVWDQGDDUGZDDUGHQ¶
5HVXPp
'HPRGHOOHULQJYDQGHJHOXLGRYHUGUDFKWLQGHµYULMHYHOGVLWXDWLH¶HQLQEHERXZGJHELHGLV JHYDOLGHHUGDDQGHKDQGYDQHHQYHUJHOLMNLQJPHWUHVXOWDWHQYHUNUHJHQPHWHHQµH[DFW¶ QXPHULHNPRGHOUHVSHFWLHYHOLMNDDQGHKDQGYDQPHWLQJHQ=RZHOGHPRGHOEHUHNHQLQJHQDOV GHPHWLQJHQ]LMQVSHFLDDOYRRUGH]HYDOLGDWLHXLWJHYRHUG 2SEDVLVYDQGHUHVXOWDWHQYDQGHYDOLGDWLHVLVEHVORWHQRPGHPRGHOOHULQJ OHHV VFKHPDWLVHULQJ YDQGHJHOXLGRYHUGUDFKWQLHW YHUGHU]LHSDJ DDQWHSDVVHQ=RZHO EHUHNHQGHDOVJHPHWHQZDDUGHQYHUVFKLOOHQµJHPLGGHOG¶PLQGHUGDQjG% $ YDQGH (03$5$UHVXOWDWHQ7XVVHQJHPHWHQHQEHUHNHQGH (03$5$ ZDDUGHQOLMNWJHHQ V\VWHPDWLVFKHDIZLMNLQJRSWHWUHGHQPLWVGHEHQRGLJGHEHERXZLQJVSDUDPHWHUVµYLVXHHO¶ ZRUGHQEHSDDOG*HPLGGHOGHYHUVFKLOOHQLQGHRUGHYDQG%WUHGHQRSDOVGHKXLGLJH VWDQGDDUGSDUDPHWULVDWLHRSEDVLVYDQGHFODVVLILFDWLHYDQVWHGHOLMNHEHERXZLQJZRUGW WRHJHSDVW(HQDGHTXDWHUHPHWQDPHPHHUJHGLIIHUHQWLHHUGHFODVVLILFDWLHYDQGHEHERXZLQJ LVGDQRRNJHZHQVW 'HVLWXDWLHVZDDUPHWKHWQXPHULHNHPRGHODDQLVJHUHNHQG]DOHHQJURRWGHHOYDQGH SUDNWLMNVLWXDWLHVRPYDWWHQ(HQXLW]RQGHULQJLVGHVLWXDWLHZDDUELMGHJHOXLGRYHUGUDFKW SODDWVYLQGWRYHUJURWHZDWHURSSHUYODNNHQ'HµZHLQLJVWHGHOLMNH¶HQµPDWLJVWHGHOLMNH¶ ZRRQZLMNHQZDDUGHPHWLQJHQ]LMQXLWJHYRHUG]LMQUHSUHVHQWDWLHIYRRUHHQEHGXLGHQGNOHLQHU GHHOYDQGH VWHGHOLMNH SUDNWLMNVLWXDWLHV*HOHWRSGHJURWH PRGHO JHYRHOLJKHLGYRRUGH SDUDPHWHUVGLHHHQUROVSHOHQELMGHPRGHOOHULQJYDQGHRYHUGUDFKWLQGHVWHGHOLMNHRPJHYLQJ NXQQHQGHJHYRQGHQµQDXZNHXULJKHGHQ¶QLHW]RQGHUPHHUYHUWDDOGZRUGHQQDDUGHRYHULJH VLWXDWLHV5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ
*HYRHOLJKHLGVDQDO\VH
,QGLWKRRIGVWXNZRUGHQGHUHVXOWDWHQYDQHHQJHYRHOLJKHLGVDQDO\VHEHVFKUHYHQ+LHUELM ZRUGWRQGHUVFKHLGJHPDDNWWXVVHQGHGRRUZHUNLQJYDQPRGHORQQDXZNHXULJKHLG RQDIKDQNHOLMNYDQGHLPSOHPHQWDWLHLQHHQ*HRJUDILVFK,QIRUPDWLH6\VWHHP *,6 HQGH LQYORHGYDQGHGLVFUHWLVDWLHLQ(03$5$ 9RRUGHPRGHORQQDXZNHXULJKHLGZRUGWJHEUXLNJHPDDNWYDQGHLQKRRIGVWXNHQ EHVFKUHYHQEHYLQGLQJHQGDWGHJHOXLGHPLVVLHHQRYHUGUDFKWLQYHHOVLWXDWLHVPHWHHQ QDXZNHXULJKHLGYDQµHQNHOH¶G%¶VZRUGWEHUHNHQG9RRUGHEHSDOLQJYDQGHLQYORHGYDQGH GLVFUHWLVDWLHHQGHGDDUPHHVDPHQKDQJHQGHVFKHPDWLVHULQJ]LMQGHPHHVWJHYRHOLJH SDUDPHWHUVJHYDULHHUGWHQRS]LFKWHYDQGHQRPLQDOHZDDUGHQ 'HUHVXOWDWHQYDQGHDQDO\VHVZRUGHQJHwQWHUSUHWHHUGYDQXLWGHRQWZHUSGRHOVWHOOLQJRPGH RPYDQJHQGHHIIHFWHQYDQJHOXLGRSHHQJURRWJHELHG PLQLPDDOGHRPYDQJYDQHHQJURWH VWDG WHNXQQHQEHUHNHQHQ,QGHVWXGLHVLVGDDURPJHNHNHQQDDUJHDJJUHJHHUGH HLQGUHVXOWDWHQ LQGLFDWRUZDDUGHQ 'HYHUZDFKWLQJLVGDWLQGH]HUHVXOWDWHQGHµORNDOH¶IRXWHQ GLHVDPHQKDQJHQPHWGHUXLPWHOLMNHGLVFUHWLVDWLHYRRUHHQEHODQJULMNGHHOZRUGHQ XLWJHPLGGHOG*HYRHOLJKHLGYRRUQDXZNHXULJKHLGYDQHPLVVLHHQ
RYHUGUDFKW
,QGHYRULJHKRRIGVWXNNHQLVEHVFKUHYHQGDWGHRQQDXZNHXULJKHLGLQGHEHUHNHQLQJYDQGH HPLVVLHZDDUGHQQDDUVFKDWWLQJµJHPLGGHOG¶PLQGHUGDQG%EHGUDDJW9RRUGH RYHUGUDFKWVEHUHNHQLQJJHOGWLQYHHOVLWXDWLHVHHQRQQDXZNHXULJKHLGYDQjG% 'HJHYRHOLJKHLGYDQGHLQGLFDWRUHQYRRUGH]HRQQDXZNHXULJKHGHQLVKLHURQGHU]RFKWRS EDVLVYDQHHQDDQWDOEHUHNHQLQJHQZDDUELMGHJHOXLGEHODVWLQJJHQHULHNLVJHYDULHHUG 8LWHUDDUGJHOGWGDWGH]HJHQHULHNHYDULDWLHVJH]LHQNXQQHQZRUGHQDOVµZRUVWFDVHV¶ DDQJH]LHQRSDOOHORFDWLHVGHJHOXLGEHODVWLQJXQLIRUPPHWGH ELMQD PD[LPDOHLVYHUDQGHUG (ULVJHEUXLNJHPDDNWYDQHHUGHUHEHUHNHQLQJHQDDQKHWJHOXLGYDQZHJYHUNHHUVJHOXLG]RDOV GLHLQKHWNDGHUYDQGH0LOLHXEDODQVHQGHYLMIGH0LOLHXYHUNHQQLQJ 5HI ]LMQ XLWJHYRHUG'HJHOXLGEHODVWLQJGLHLVEHUHNHQGLQKHWNDGHUYDQGH0%LVLQGH]HVWXGLH µODQGVGHNNHQG¶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
'HWRWDOHJHOXLGEHODVWLQJGRRUDOOHZHJYHUNHHULQGHJHOXLGPDDW/HWPDDO]RDOVGLHLVEHUHNHQG
LQKHWNDGHUYDQGH0%LV]RZHOYHUODDJGDOVYHUKRRJGPHWHQPHWG% $ 'H JHOXLGEHODVWLQJ]RDOVEHUHNHQGLQKHWNDGHUYDQGH09LQ/HWPDDOLVRSKHWVWXGLHJHELHGYDQ
/HLGHQHQNHOYHUKRRJGPHWG% $ 'HJHOXLGEHODVWLQJLQGHJHOXLGPDDW/$HTXXU 09 LV
RSKHWVWXGLHJHELHGLQ*HOGHUODQG]RZHOYHUKRRJGPHWDOVPHWG% $
)LJXXU 6WXGLHJHELHG/HLGHQ
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
SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW ,Q7DEHOLVGHUHODWLHYHJHYRHOLJKHLGYDQGHLQGLFDWRUZDDUGHQYRRUJHQHULHNH YHUDQGHULQJHQLQGHJHOXLGEHODVWLQJZHHUJHJHYHQ'HUHODWLHYHJHYRHOLJKHLG6DYDQGH LQGLFDWRUHQYRRUHHQJHQHULHNHYHUDQGHULQJLQGHJHOXLGEHODVWLQJDSHUG%YHUDQGHULQJLV JHGHILQLHHUGDOV D ¼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¶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µHQNHOHSURFHQWHQ¶WRWµHQNHOH WLHQWDOOHQSURFHQWHQ¶SHUG%+HWDDQWDOLQZRQHUVPHWHHQJHOXLGEHODVWLQJGLHOLJWWXVVHQ
5,90UDSSRUW SDJ YDQ HQG% $ LVKHWRQJHYRHOLJVWYRRURQQDXZNHXULJKHGHQLQGHEHUHNHQLQJYDQGH JHOXLGEHODVWLQJ PD[LPDDOG% 2YHULJHQVEOLMNWXLWGHWDEHOGDWGHJHYRHOLJKHGHQQLHWOLQHDLUVDPHQKDQJHQPHWGHJHQHULHNH JHOXLGEHODVWLQJVYDULDWLH'LWEOLMNWXLWKHWIHLWGDWGHJHYRHOLJKHGHQDIKDQNHOLMN]LMQYDQGH PDWHHQKHWWHNHQYDQGHJHQHULHNHDDQSDVVLQJ'LWKRXGWLQGDWGHQDXZNHXULJKHLGQLHW DOOHHQYDQLQYORHGLVRSGHRQ]HNHUKHLGLQGHDEVROXWHLQGLFDWRUZDDUGHQPDDURRNRS UHODWLHYHµWUHQG¶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¶QKHEEHQEHGUDJHQYDQGHQXEHUHNHQGHZDDUGH%LMHHQ WRHQDPHYDQGHJHOXLGEHODVWLQJPHWG%]RXGHJHOXLGEHODVWLQJYHUYROJHQVPHWELMQD WRHQHPHQ WRWYDQGHQXEHUHNHQGHZDDUGHYRRUKHWUHIHUHQWLHMDDU ,QGLWYRRUEHHOGLV GHJHYRHOLJKHLGYDQGHWUHQGZDDUGHQYRRURQQDXZNHXULJKHLGLQGHEHUHNHQGH JHOXLGEHODVWLQJGXVYULMZHOJHOLMNDDQGHJHYRHOLJKHLGYDQGHDEVROXWHZDDUGHQ HYHQHHQV ELMHHQV\VWHPDWLVFKHIRXWYDQG% ,QYHHOJHYDOOHQLVGHJHYRHOLJKHLGYDQGHWUHQGV HFKWHUNOHLQHUGDQGLHYDQGHDEVROXWHZDDUGHQ
3DUDPHWHUVWXGLH
1DDVWGHQDXZNHXULJKHLGYDQGHEHUHNHQLQJYDQGHJHOXLGEHODVWLQJ]DOGHUXLPWHOLMNH GLVFUHWLVDWLHHQGHGDDUPHHVDPHQKDQJHQGHVFKHPDWLVHULQJYDQLQYORHG]LMQRSGH PRGHOUHVXOWDWHQ'HUXLPWHOLMNHGLVFUHWLVDWLHµKHWUHNHQHQRSHHQURRVWHU JULG ¶KHHIWDOV FRQVHTXHQWLHGDWDOOHHQRSGHEURQHQRQWYDQJHUSXQWHQZDDUGHQNXQQHQZRUGHQWRHJHNHQG DDQGHPRGHOSDUDPHWHUV'HNHX]HYDQGHZDDUGHQLVGDQRRNDIJHVWHPGRSµGHJHPLGGHOGH VLWXDWLH¶LQGHFHOYDQKHWEHWUHIIHQGHJULGSXQW2RNGHEHUHNHQGHJHOXLGEHODVWLQJGLHQWWH ZRUGHQJHwQWHUSUHWHHUGDOVHHQJHPLGGHOGHZDDUGHYRRUGHJHKHOHFHOHQQLHWDOVGH JHOXLGEHODVWLQJWHUSOHNNHYDQKHWFHOPLGGHQ 8LWHHUGHUHEHUHNHQLQJHQLVEHNHQGGDWGHLQGLFDWRUZDDUGHQJHYRHOLJ]LMQYRRUGHUHVROXWLH YDQKHWUHNHQURRVWHUNRUWZHJGHµJULGJURRWWH¶GHPD[LPDOHDIVWDQGWXVVHQEURQHQ RQWYDQJHU SXQW ZDDUYRRUGHRYHUGUDFKWZRUGWEHUHNHQG 'PD[ HQGHDDQQDPHRYHUGHDIVWDQGYDQGH VSRRU ZHJWRWGHHHUVWHOLMQVEHERXZLQJ 'HOE $IKDQNHOLMNYDQGHEURQ
VSRRURIZHJYHUNHHU HQKHWW\SHZHJZRUGHQYHUVFKLOOHQGHZDDUGHQYRRU'PD[HQ'HOE
SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW 7DEHO 1RPLQDOHZDDUGHQYRRUJULGJURRWWHDIVWDQGWRWHHUVWHOLMQVEHERXZLQJHQPD[LPDOH UHNHQDIVWDQG LQPHWHUV
*ULGJURRWWH 6SRRUZHJHQ 5LMNVZHJHQ 3URYLQFLDOHZHJHQ *HPHHQWHOLMNHZHJHQ
'PD[ 'HOE 'PD[ 'HOE 'PD[ 'HOE 'PD[ 'HOE
,Q12,672/GDWLVKHWGHHOYDQGH(03$5$SURJUDPPDWXXUZDDUGHRYHUGUDFKWZRUGW EHUHNHQGZRUGWRQGHUVFKHLGJHPDDNWWXVVHQGHDIVWDQGWRWGHHHUVWHOLMQVEHERXZLQJ KLHU 'HOELQ12,672/;OEEVRXUFH LQHHQEHERXZGHEURQFHOHQGHYHURQGHUVWHOGHPLQLPDOH
DIVWDQGGLHHHQRQWYDQJHUSXQWWRWHHQµEURQSXQW¶ IHLWHOLMNVQLMSXQWYDQELVVHFWULFHPHW ZHJVWXN PRHWKHEEHQ LQ12,672/5IRUELG 'HOEZRUGWJHEUXLNWLQGHEHUHNHQLQJYDQ
'KXLV'HJHJHYHQJHVWDQGDDUGLVHHUGHZDDUGHQYRRU'HOEZRUGHQELMGHEHUHNHQLQJHQNHO
JHEUXLNWLQGLHQHHQEURQFHO GLHHQFHOZDDUGRRUHHQZHJVWXNORRSW DOVµEHERXZG¶LV DDQJHPHUNW,QDOOHDQGHUHJHYDOOHQZRUGWGH]HEHSDDOGDDQGHKDQGYDQGHELVVHFWULFHYDQXLW GHKRHNGLHZRUGWRSJHVSDQQHQGRRUKHWUHFHSWRUSXQWHQGHHLQGSXQWHQYDQKHWOLMQVWXN2S KHWJHOXLGQLYHDXLQGHEURQFHOKHHIW'HOEJHHQLQYORHG'H12,672/SDUDPHWHU5IRUELGLV
RSJHQRPHQRPWHYHUPLMGHQGDWGHJHOXLGVQLYHDXVLQGHEURQFHOOHQRQUHDOLVWLVFKKRRJ ZRUGHQRSKHWPRPHQWGDWKHWPLGGHQYDQHHQJULGFHORSRIYODNELMHHQZHJOLJW'DDUWRH ZRUGWGHZHUNHOLMNHDIVWDQGWXVVHQµEURQSXQW¶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
5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ 'PD[YRRUSURYLQFLDOHZHJHQRSJHKRRJGPHWPHQPWRWUHVSHFWLHYHOLMN P 'PD[YRRUULMNVZHJHQRSJHKRRJGPHWPHQPWRWUHVSHFWLHYHOLMNP 'HOEYRRUELQQHQVWHGHOLMNHZHJHQ]RZHOYHUODDJGDOVYHUKRRJGPHWPWRW UHVSHFWLHYHOLMNP 'HOEYRRUULMNZHJHQ]RZHOYHUODDJGPHWPWRWPDOVYHUKRRJGPHWPWRWP
'HJHQRHPGHYDULDWLHVYDQ'HOEYRRUELQQHQVWHGHOLMNHZHJHQHQULMNVZHJHQ]LMQ]RZHORS
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
VWXGLHJHELHGYDQ*HOGHUODQG )LJXXU 9HUGHOLQJJHOXLGEHODVWLQJ/HLGHQQDDUNODVVHQYDQG% $ ELMYDULDWLHYDQ'PD['HOE HQJULGJURRWWH ! JHOXLGVNODVVH>G% $ @ LQ Z RQ HU V > @ QRPLQDDO 'PD[ELQVWZJQP 'HOEELQVWZJQP JULGJURRWWH P
SDJYDQ 5,90UDSSRUW )LJXXU 9HUGHOLQJJHOXLGEHODVWLQJRSVWLOWHJHELHGHQ*HOGHUODQGQDDUNODVVHQYDQG% $ ELM YDULDWLHYDQ'PD[HQJULGJURRWWH ,Q7DEHOHQ7DEHOZRUGHQGHJHYRHOLJKHGHQJHWRRQGYRRUGHYDULDWLHVLQ'PD[ 'HOEHQGHJULGJURRWWH+LHUELMLVWHYHQVGHJHYRHOLJKHLGJHJHYHQQDJHQHULHNHYHUKRJLQJYDQ GHEHUHNHQGHJHOXLGEHODVWLQJ 7DEHO 5HODWLHYHJHYRHOLJKHLGYDQLQGLFDWRUHQYRRUJULGJURRWWHDIVWDQGWRWHHUVWHOLMQV EHERXZLQJ 'HOE HQPD[LPDOHUHNHQDIVWDQG 'PD[ YRRUVWXGLHJHELHG/HLGHQ
,QZG% $ ,QZ!G% $ $!G% $ 3DUDPHWHU 09 D G% 09 D G% 09 D G% *ULGJURRWWH 'PD[ELQVWZJQ 'PD[ULMNVZJQ 'HOEELQVWZJQ 'HOEULMNVZJQ 7DEHO 5HODWLHYHJHYRHOLJKHLGYDQLQGLFDWRUHQYRRUJULGJURRWWHDIVWDQGWRWHHUVWHOLMQV EHERXZLQJ 'HOE HQPD[LPDOHUHNHQDIVWDQG 'PD[ DKYVWXGLHJHELHG*HOGHUODQG
$!G% $ $UHDDOQRUPRYHUVFKULMGLQJVWLOWHJHELHGHQ 3DUDPHWHU 09 D G% D G% 09 D G% D G% *ULGJURRWWH 'PD[ELQVWZJQ 'PD[ULMNVZJQ 'HOEULMNVZJQ JHOXLGVNODVVH>G% $ @ RS SH UY OD NW H VW LOW HJ HE LH G + D QRPLQDDO 'PD[P 'PD[P JULGJURRWWH P
