• No results found

The Shareholder Settlement Program: A Pragmatic Resolution to confront a Systemic Banking Crises in view of the Dysfunctional Legal System and Tradition of the Republic of Indonesia

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "The Shareholder Settlement Program: A Pragmatic Resolution to confront a Systemic Banking Crises in view of the Dysfunctional Legal System and Tradition of the Republic of Indonesia"

Copied!
77
0
0

Bezig met laden.... (Bekijk nu de volledige tekst)

Hele tekst

(1)The Shareholder Settlement Program: A Pragmatic Resolution to confront a Systemic Banking Crises in view of the Dysfunctional Legal System and Tradition of the Republic of Indonesia Maroef, T.M.. Citation Maroef, T. M. (2010, March 25). The Shareholder Settlement Program: A Pragmatic Resolution to confront a Systemic Banking Crises in view of the Dysfunctional Legal System and Tradition of the Republic of Indonesia. Retrieved from https://hdl.handle.net/1887/15127 Version:. Not Applicable (or Unknown). License:. Licence agreement concerning inclusion of doctoral thesis in the Institutional Repository of the University of Leiden. Downloaded from:. https://hdl.handle.net/1887/15127. Note: To cite this publication please use the final published version (if applicable)..

(2) %41$4->14;801>$1@@8191:@">;3>-9. . . .   .

(3) . . . . . . %41$4->14;801>$1@@8191:@">;3>-9.

(4) 65;9(*;: 9640:, . . .      

(5)  

(6)  

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

(11) @5B35>DG?E<4253<1CC9Q54 .@0.A24<?FKL/.;8@.;1/.;8@D6A5.'<392@@A5.;

(12) =2?02;AD2?20.A24<?FKL/.;8@.A24<?FKL/.;8@0<:=?6@21<3/.;8@A5.AD2?229646/92A< =.?A606=.A26;'<?A524<C2?;:2;AM@?20.=6A.96G.A6<;=?<4?.:12=2;16;4<;A52?2@B9A<3.;.;.9F@6@.@A<A52/.;8@M/B@6;2@@=?<@=20A@"2.;D56920.A24<?F KL/.;8@0<;@6@A21<3/.;8@A5.AD2?246C2;A52<==<?AB;6AFA<6;0?2.@2A526?'.AA5292.@AB=A<:6;B@

(13) =2?02;AD6A56;.02?A.6;=2?6<1<3A6:2.;163A52F 3.6921A<1<@<A52FD<B91/2=BAB;12??2026C2?@56=.;19.A2?/296>B61.A212=2;16;4<;A52=.?.:2A2?@<;9F0.A24<?FKL.;1KL/.;8@D<B91/2?2>B6?21 A<=.?A.826;A52%?<4?.:;<A52?6:=<?A.;A292:2;A6;A56@=.?.:2A2?D.@A523.0AA5.A<;2D.F<?.;<A52?A52@2/.;8@5.1?2026C21@A.A23B;1@D52A52?6;A52 3<?:<3A5202;A?.9/.;8M@96>B616AF@B==<?A@A52=.F:2;A<3/.;8@M</964.A6<;@/FA524<C2?;:2;A4B.?.;A22@052:2<?<A52?:<;2A.?F.1C.;02@A<822=A52: 6;<=2?.A6<;   B?6;4A52=2.8<3A52Q>1>391<3B9C9C9>  =1>I(21>;CP16Q<91D54452D?BCG5B5E>12<5D?=55DD859B452DC5BF935?2<971D9?>C?> A6:299A52@.:2:.;F;1<;2@6.;0<?=<?.A6<;@A5.A5.1<;2D.F<?.;<A52??2026C21/.;8@M9<.;@D2?25.?156A/FA5220<;<:60:29A1<D;.;156456;A2?2@A B1D5CG8938=145D85=75>5B1<<IE>12<5D?C5BF935D859B452DCD?D8521>;CC1B5CE<DD8521>;CG5B5E>12<5D?B53?F5BD859B1CC5DC1>4D??2D19>@B?QDC1>4 2C2;AB.99FA52F3.6921A<:22AA526?</964.A6<;@A<A5212=<@6A<?.;1<A52?A56?1=.?AF0?216A<?@)52F@B332?215B429<@@2@.;16;2C6A./9F/20.:26;@<9C2;A,.@ A56@6??24B9.?=?.0A602.

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

(15) /.;8@D6A5.(70;(3+,8<(*@!(;06<3 =2?02;A<?92@@)52@2/.;8@D2?202?A.6;9F;<A52.9A5F3?<:A52/.;86;46;1B@A?F=<6;A<3C62D.;1:B@A26A52?/2?20.=6A.96G21<?96>B61.A21)56@2E09B121A52 /.;8@A5.AD2?296>B61.A216;#<C2:/2? <BA<3A52@2

(16) /.;8@1610<:2B;12?A524<C2?;:2;A?20.=6A.96G.A6<;=?<4?.:/BAD2?2;2C2?.0AB.99F;B?@21 /F';A<A.9/.;8@D2?25.;192116?20A9F/F'   #2C2?A5292@@A52/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@161;<A7B@A.002=AA52?2@B9A@<3A521B2169642;02.;16;@A2.1A52F@B/:6AA21A526?<D;2C612;02A<A520<; A?.?F(<:2A6:2@A52F0<B91=<6;A<BA6;0<;@6@A2;062@6;A521B2169642;02.9A5<B45:<@A<3A52A6:2A52F0<B91;<A)56@/.AA92<32C612;02@0.:2.@;<@B?=?6@2 1B2A<A523.0AA5.AA524E549<975>353?E<481B4<I@B?F9451>I3?>3<EC9F5?@9>9?>B571B49>7D85Q>49>7C2531EC5D85B5<5F1>D4?3E=5>DCG5B59>3?=@<5D51>4 1<C?2531EC5D85I9>F?<F54=1>IC?@89CD931D54Q>1>391<DB1>C13D9?>C.

(17) . . . . . . #/,"/(9,/63+,9",;;3,4,5; 96.9(4. 2ID857?F5B>=5>D>1449D9?>9DG1C1<C?9>RE5>3542I5HD5B>1<613D?BCCE381C@<06<=<96A60.9 .;1@20B?6AF?2.@<;6;4

(18) @/20.:22C612;A6; A52;24<A6.A6<;@/2AD22;A524<C2?;:2;AM@ A.@83<?02.;1C.?6<B@:.7<?'/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@9.@A21<;9F.0<B=92<3:<;A5@.;1A52 @2AA92:2;A.4?22:2;A@A5.AD2?2@64;21/FA520<;A?.0A6;4=.?A62@;22121A</2.17B@A21.0<B=92 <3A6:2@C2?FA56;4.;12C2?F/<1F@22:21A</26;./64?B@5  ; 

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

(20)   .@21<;A52?2@B9A@<3A52;24<A6.A6<;@.;1A52.3<?2@.61=.?.:2A2?@A52?2D2?2/.@6 0.99FAD<0.A24<?62@<3'/.;8@6;A52(5.?25<912?(2AA92:2;A%?<4?.:  . . *85QBCD7B?E@3?=@B9C54?6 (/.;8@A5.AD2?2;<A?2>B6?21A<=.?A606=.A26;A52 %?<4?.:/20.B@2;<C6<9.A6<;<3=?B12;A6.9/.;86;4?24B9.A6<;@.;1 <?6??24B9.?/.;86;4 @B13D935C814255>6?E>4

(21)

(22) )52@20<;14?<B=0<;@6@A21<3'/.;8@A5.AD2?2?2>B6?21A<=.?A.826;A52%?<4?.: 21C54 ?> Q>49>7C D81D D85 21>;C 814 F9?<1D54 /.;86;4 =?B12;A6.9 ?24B9.A6<;@ .;1 <? 5.1 /22;6;C<9C216; 6??24B9.?/.;86;4 @B13D935CD81D25>5QD54D8521>;CP C81B58?<45BC*89C 4?<B=<3/.;8@D.@3B?A52?16C61216;A<A523<99<D6;4A5?220.A24<?62@ i) @5.?25<912?@3?<:

(23) '/.;8@D2?20<;@612?21A</20<<=2?.A6C2.A92.@A.AA52 6;6A6.9@A.42.@A52F.4?221A<@64;@2AA92:2;A.4?22:2;A@D6A5'(2C2;<3A52 21>;CPC81B58?<45BC6E<Q<<54D859B?2<971D9?>C9>31C8 ii) )52@5.?25<912?@<3'/.;8@D2?20<;@612?21A</2B;0<<=2?.A6C2.@A52F?2 6EC54D?C97>C5DD<5=5>D17B55=5>DCG9D8(1>4 iii) )52?2 D2?2  ' /.;8@ <3 D5605 ;<A <;2 <3 A52 @5.?25<912?@ @64;21 @2AA92:2;A .4?22:2;A@D6A5'6;=.?A/20.B@2<3<;4<6;4924.916@=BA2@.;16;=.?A1B2A< B;092.??2.@<;@ )52=.?.:2A2?@D2?2A52:<@A6:=<?A.;A2;A?F=<6;A6;A<KA52;2D924.9/<;1L/2AD22;. 

(24)  <?6;@A.;021B?6;4./6/62M@.1:6;6@A?.A6<;'5.1;<2E=2?62;02D5.A@<2C2?6;.1:6;6@A2?6;4.;12E20BA6;4A52/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@2AA92 :2;A@ .;1 12=2;121 C2?F :B05 <; A52 .1C602@ 3?<: .;1 B;12?A.86;4@ /F 2EA2?;.9 .1C6@<?@ D5692 A52 =<96A60.9 .;1 ;.A6<;.9 @20B?6AF 0<;16A6<;@ D2?2 =?2AAF 1F;.:60.;15.142;2?.A215645=?2@@B?2B=<;A52/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@A<0<<=2?.A2D6A5A524<C2?;:2;A#<A.1.FD2;A/FD6A5<BA@A?22A12:<;@A?.A6<;@ 3<99<D6;4A522A5;60?6<A@.;1A5286996;4<3@AB12;A12:<;@A?.A<?@6;:61 .;1/64/B@6;2@@0<;49<:2?.A2@.;1A526?.9924210<??B=A21D2.9A5D.@<;2<3A52 :<@A=<=B9.?A<=60@<316@0B@@6<;@ 

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

(26)

(27)  A6@6;A2?2@A6;4A<;<A2A5.A<;2<3A52/.;8@6;A56@4?<B=62 #(52$50)(52D.@;<A?2>B6?21A<=.?A.826;A52(5.?25<912?(2AA92:2;A%?<4?.: @6:=9F/20.B@2A52?2D.@;<0<;A?<996;4@5.?25<912?.;1;<A/20.B@2A52?2D.@;<C6<9.A6<;<3/.;86;4=?B12;A6.9?24B9.A6<;@.;1 <?6??24B9.?=?.0A602@)52 <1DD5B9CCE5G1C9>3?>3<EC9F52531EC5>?<571<1>4Q>1>391<1B2169642;025.12C2?/22;0<;1B0A216;?24.?1A<A56@/.;8.@21<;A52=?2C.696;4.;8;1<;2@6. B57E<1D9?>1C81B58?<45BG?E<4251CCE=54D?81F53?>DB?<<9>79>RE5>35?>D8521>;9685?G>54

(28) @5B35>D?B=?B5?6D8521>;PCC81B58?<49>7-85>D85?@5B1 A6<;<3A52/.;8D.@3?<G2;/F.;8;1<;2@6.6A5.1:<?2A5.;

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

(30) 65;9(*;: 9640:, . . . '/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@.;1A524<C2?;:2;A62A52@5.?25<912?@2AA92:2;A.4?22:2;A@D5605 D<B91 /20<:2 A52 B9A6:.A2 4?<B;1 D<?8 3<? A52 .3<?2@.61 0<;A?.0AB.9 /B?12;@5.?6;4@052:2 =0:B=0:A52;221A<0<=2D6A5A520<@A@6;0B??213?<:A52/.;86;40?6@6@

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

(32)   2=2;16;4<;A52;B:/2?.;1A52@6G2<3A52@2AA92:2;A.@@2A@A52/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@ .;1'.4?221A<2@A./96@5.5<916;40<:=.;F3<?2.05<3A52@2AA92:2;A.4?22:2;A@D6A5A52 :.6;.;1<;9F=B?=<@2A<=<<9:.;.42.;116@=<@2<3A52@2AA92:2;A.@@2A@

(33) )52.@@2A@D2?2 D?25F1<E542IB5@ED12<59>D5B>1D9?>1<Q>1>391<14F9C?BCEC9>7D8549C3?E>D5431C8R?G=5D8?4 <3C.9B.A6<;/.@21<;1.A..;16;3<?:.A6<;:.6;9F=?<C6121/FA52/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@<?<A52? 1F19<12<5C?EB35C9>D85=1B;5D$?D8?B?E78Q>1>391<?B<571<4E5169642;025.1/22;0.??621 <BA6;?24.?1A<A52@2AA92:2;A.@@2A@/20.B@2A524<C2?;:2;A.;1A52"5.1.99<0.A21<;9F <;2:<;A5A<B;12?A.82@B05.@@2AC.9B.A6<;/23<?2A52@64;6;4<32.05<3A52@2AA92:2;A.4?22 

(34)  ,52;A52/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@@64;21A52@2AA92:2;A.4?22:2;AD6A5(D85I?2<9754D85=C5<F5CD?1C5D?6?2<971D9?>CD81DD85I814D?6E<Q<< #51>G89<5D85IG5B51<C?79F5>1C5D?6B978DC1>4@B?D53D9?>6B?=D857?F5B>=5>D96D85I=1>1754D?6E<Q<<D859B3?>DB13DE1<?2<971D9?>CC1D9C613D?B9<I%>D85 <A52?5.;1A524<C2?;:2;A.;1(G5B51<C?D85=C5<F5C2?E>4D?1C5D?6?2<971D9?>CD81D=ECD256E<Q<<54133?B49>7<I*85<?G<5F5<?63?>DB13DE1<5>6?B35 ./696AF6;;1<;2@6.D.@<3A2;A52:.6;0.B@2<3:.;F924.916@=BA2@?24.?192@@<3A52;.AB?2<3A520<;A?.0A6;4=.?A62@D5692A527B1606.?FD.@B;./92A<=?<C612 .;23320A6C216@=BA2?2@<9BA6<;A?6/B;.9)52@20<;16A6<;@D2?2.99;<A20<;<:60.99F12@6?./9292A.9<;2@<06.99F.002=A./92 

(35)  ==.?2;A9F=.?A<3A52@2AA92:2;A.:<B;A5.1A</2=.616;0.@5)52?2D.@;<0<::<;3<?:B9.<;A52:.AA2?/20.B@2:<@A<3A52A6:2A52.:<B;A A</2=.616;0.@5D.@A52?2@B9A<3;24<A6.A6<;@/2AD22;A524<C2?;:2;AM@A.@83<?02.;1A52/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@!.A2?<;A56@/20.:2.@<B?02<316@=BA2/2 AD22;'.;1@2C2?.9<3A52/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@.@A52@5.?25<912?@/2962C21A5.AA52F5.1/22;05.?421B;3.6?9F56452?A5.;<A52?@5.?25<912?@)52.?4B:2;A @<B;121?2.@<;./92/BAD.@6;3.0A/.@292@@.05<3A52/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@D.@46C2;A52@.:2<==<?AB;6AFA<;24<A6.A2A52A2?:@<30<;16A6<;@/23<?2A52F @64;21A52@2AA92:2;A.4?22:2;A@.;1A52FD2?23B99F.D.?2<3.99A523.0A@@B??<B;16;4A52=?<02@@#<A56;4D.@.99<D21A</282=A@20?2A3?<:A52:1B?6;4A5.A A6:2.;1F2AA52FB9A6:.A29F.4?221A</6;1A52:@29C2@A<16332?2;A0<;A?.0AB.9</964.A6<;@$;A52.C2?.42A52B=3?<;A0.@5=.F:2;AD.@92@@A5.;  =2?02;A<3 A52A<A.9</964.A6<;  @.3<?2:2;A6<;21A52.:<B;AA</2@2AA921/FA52@5.?25<912?@<3'A.82<C2?/.;8@D.@16332?2;A3?<:A5.A<3'3?<G2;/.;8@",, <C2?;:2;A;;<B;02:2;A6;#<C2:/2? ",,(3:6<6;A20?22<3A52"6;6@A2?<36;.;02.;1A52<C2?;<?<3.;8;1<;2@6.@3.?.@';B?@21 D1;5?F5B21>;CG5B53?>35B>54D85C5DD<5=5>D1=?E>DG1C5AE1<D?D85D?D1<1=?E>D?6D8521>;CP16Q<91D549<.;@;A56@0.@26AD.@1206121A5.AA52/.;8@D2?2 A</282=A6;<=2?.A6<;.;1.99<3A52/.;8@M9<@@2@D<B91/2./@<?/21/FA524<C2?;:2;AM@6;720A6;4?20.=6A.96G.A6<;3B;1@.;10<;C2?A6;4.99<3A524<C2?;:2;AM@ 09.6:@6;A<A52/.;8M@2>B6AF2=2;16;4<;A52.0AB.906?0B:@A.;02@A524<C2?;:2;AM@09.6:@D<B91/26;A523<?:<302;A?.9/.;8M@96>B616AF@B==<?A:<;2A.?F .1C.;02@A5.A5.1/22;6;720A216;A<A52/.;8@6;<?12?A<822=A52:<=2?.A6;4.;1<A52?.@@<06.A216;A2?2@A.@:.F/26:=<@21;?24.?1A<'3?<G2;/.;8@ A52.:<B;AA</2@2AA921/FA52/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@D.@2>B.9A<A52/.;8@MA<A.9</964.A6<;A<A56?1=.?A62@:6;B@A52/.;8@M;2A.@@2AC.9B2*;9682A52@2AA92:2;A .:<B;A<3';B?@21 A.82<C2?/.;8@A52@2AA92:2;A.:<B;AA</2@2AA921/F@5.?25<912?@<3'3?<G2;/.;8@D.@6;A2;121A<0<C2?.9@<.99A52@A.A23B;1@ A5.A5.1/22;6;720A216;A<A52/.;8@6;09B16;4A5202;A?.9/.;896>B616AF@B==<?A@ 

(36)  ;6A6.99FA526;A2;A6<;D.@A5.AA525<916;40<:=.;62@D2?2A</2<D;21/<A5/F'.;1A52/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@D52?2'D<B915<91A52 ./@<9BA2:.7<?6AF<3A52@5.?2@6@@B21<D2C2?9.A2?<;.99<3A52@5.?2@D2?2<D;21/FA52/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@AD.@B;092.?.@A<A52?2.@<;6;4/256;1A56@ <1CD=9>ED5381>75#1>I5H@<19>54E>?6Q391<<ID81DD854539C9?>G1C=1452ID85819B=1>?6'6;0<;@B9A.A6<;D6A5A52"6;6@A2?<36;.;02.@A<=?2C2;A A525<916;40<:=.;62@A</20.A24<?6G21.@@A.A2<D;212;A2?=?6@2@26;4@A.A2<D;212;A2?=?6@2@A52?2D2?2.@2?62@<3/B?2.B0?.A60?B92@A5.A:B@A/20<:=9621 /FA525<916;40<:=.;62@D5605:645A5.:=2?A52@:<<A5<=2?.A6<;.;1.@@2A@16@=<@.9<3A52@.610<:=.;62@.

(37) . . . . . . #/,"/(9,/63+,9",;;3,4,5; 96.9(4. :2;A@

(38)   )52/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@D2?2</96421A<A?.;@32?.99<3A52@2AA92:2;A.@@2A@A<A525<91 6;40<:=.;62@.;1A<=2?320A@B05A?.;@32?6;.00<?1.;02D6A5A52=?2C.696;49.D@.;1?24B9.A6<;@ )56@D.@=?</./9F<;2<3A52A?60862@A=.?A@<3A52@2AA92:2;A.4?22:2;A.@6AD<B9112A2?:6;2 D52A52?<?;<A.@2AA92:2;A.4?22:2;A0<B91/20<;@612?21.@K09<@6;4L;?2.96AFA52@2AA92:2;A .@@2A@D2?2:<@A9F6;A523<?:<3@5.?2@<30<:=.;62@A52A?.;@32?<3D56056;C<9C21:.;F924.9 B;12?A.86;4@C.?6<B@0<?=<?.A2.0A6<;@.;1;B:2?<B@924.9.1:6;6@A?.A6C2=?<02216;4@D5605 5.1:.12A52A.@82C2;:<?21.B;A6;4.;1A6:20<;@B:6;4

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

(40)  . 

(41)  )52C.9B.A6<;<3A52@2AA92:2;A.@@2A@D.@A</2/.@21<;;<?:.96G2120<;<:60.;1=<96A60.90<;16A6<;@D5605D.@.0<;@612?./9F<=A6:6@A60.@ @B:=A6<;A5.A6;2C6A./9FD<B915.C22;<?:<B@0<;@2>B2;02@6;A522;1?2@B9A<3A52.@@2AC.9B.A6<;.@D299.@6;A524<C2?;:2;AM@1206@6<;A<.99<DA522E20BA6<; <3A52.@@2A@2AA92:2;A:2A5<1<3=.F:2;A 

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

(43)  )526@@B.;02<3=?<:6@@<?F;<A2@/FA525<916;40<:=.;62@A<'.;1A523.0AA5.AA52@25<916;40<:=.;62@D2?2<D;21/FA52/.;8@M@5.?2 5<912?@B;1<B/A219F0<;3B@21A52/.@60=?6;06=92.;1.0AB.96:=92:2;A.A6<;<3A52.@@2A@2AA92:2;A:2A5<1<3=.F:2;A*;12?A52@052:2A52C.9B2<3A52 =?<:6@@<?F;<A2@D.@/.@60.99FB;05.;421D5692A52C.9B2<3A52C5DD<5=5>D1CC5DCRE3DE1D5445@5>49>7?>=1>I613D?BC#?CD?6D85D9=5D85@B?3554C?2D19>54 3?<:A5216@=<@.9<3A52@2AA92:2;A.@@2A@D.@:B059<D2?A5.;A526;6A6.9C.9B2<3A52.@@2A@.@.4?221/F'.;1A52/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@.;1A52?23<?2A52 =?<:6@@<?F;<A2@D<B91;2C2?/2?2=.616;3B99A.9.A2?@A.42A524.=/2AD22;A52@2AA92:2;AC.9B2.;1A5216@=<@.9C.9B2?.6@210<;02?;@./<BAA5223320A6C2;2@@ <3A52@052:2.;142;2?.A21=<92:60@.:<;4A52=B/960.@A<D52A52?A52/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@5.10<:=92A21A526?</964.A6<;@A<A52@A.A2)56@/20.:2:<?2 0<:=960.A211B2A<A523.0AA5.A6;:.;F6;@A.;02@A526@@B.;02<3=?<:6@@<?F;<A2@/FA525<916;40<:=.;62@A<<8=9.02/23<?2.99A52@2AA92:2;A.@@2A@D2?2 924.99FA?.;@32??21<?=2?320A21  )52</964.A6<;@<3A52/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@D<B91/20<;@612?210<:=92A263A52/.;8@M@5.?25<912?5.1A?.;@32??21.99A52@2AA92:2;A.@@2A@A<A52 5<916;40<:=.;62@.;1A525<916;40<:=.;62@5.16@@B21=?<:6@@<?F;<A2@A<'3A522E6@A2;02<3.5<916;40<:=.;FD.@;<A?2>B6?21A52</964.A6<;D<B91 /20<;@612?210<:=92A21D52;.99A52@2AA92:2;A.@@2A@5.1/22;A?.;@32??21A<';?2.96AFA52?2D2?2:.;F6;@A.;02@D52?2A52A?.;@32?<3A52@2AA92:2;A .@@2A@5.1;<A/22;1<;2A52D.FA52FD2?2?2>B6?21A</2.;1A525<916;40<:=.;62@D2?26@@B6;4A<<:.;F=?<:6@@<?F;<A2@A<<@<<;;A56@0.@2A5209<@6;4 <3A52"(@5<B915.C2/22;0<;16A6<;.9B=<;A52=2?320A6<;<3@B05.@@2AA?.;@32?$;02.;"(D.@0<;@612?21.@09<@6;4A52<;9F?20<B?@2A5.A'5.1 .4.6;@AA52/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@D.@=?6:.?69F/.@21<;A5205+,450G*(;06509.B@2.00<?16;4A<D5605A52/.;8@@5.?25<912?@.4?221A<?26:/B?@26;12:;63F.;1 5<91'5.?:92@@3?<:.;1.4.6;@A.;F.;1.9909.6:@?29.A6;4A<<?.?6@6;4<BA<3<?6;0<;;20A6<;D6A5<?6;0612;A.9A<.;F/?2.05<3?2=?2@2;A.A6<;<?D.??.;AF .@@A6=B9.A216;A52@2AA92:2;A.4?22:2;A)56@D.@.C2?F/?<.1</964.A6<;<;A52=.?A<3A52/.;8@@5.?25<912?@/BA6;=?.0A6026AD.@?292C.;A:.6;9FA<.;F /?2.05<3K?2=?2@2;A.A6<;<?D.??.;AFL?24.?16;41.A..;16;3<?:.A6<;.@=?<C6121/FA52@5.?25<912?@A5.AD2?2B@21.@A52/.@6@A<12A2?:6;2A52C.9B2<3A52 @2AA92:2;A.@@2A@.@0<;A?.0A21/2AD22;'.;1A52/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@$A52??2=?2@2;A.A6<;.;1D.??.;AFD2?2?292C.;A<;9FA<A52B;12?A.86;4@0<;1B0A21 256?B5D853<?C9>741D51>4D8516?B5C1949>45=>9Q31D9?>3<1EC5G1CD85?><I3?>DB13DE1<3<1EC5D81DCEBF9F54CE3813<?C9>741D5*857?F5B>=5>D1>4D85# 4.C2'.C2?F@5<?AA6:2A<.==?.6@2A52@2AA92:2;A.@@2A@6;=.?A60B9.?A<:22AA521.A296;2.@D.@@2A3<?A56;A52"@B==<?A21=?<4?.:.;16;2C6A./9F (1>49DCQ>1>391<14F9C?BC814D?B5<I@B9=1B9<I?>D8541D11>4D851CC5DF1<E51C@B5@1B542ID8521>;CPC81B58?<45BC*89CG1C35BD19><I>?D1F5BIC=1BD G1ID?E>45BD1;5CE381>9=@?BD1>DD1C;#51>G89<5>?D?><ID8516?B5C1949>45=>9Q31D9?>3<1EC5G1C9>145AE1D5D??F5B3?=5D85<13;9>71C9>CD9DED544EB9>7 A52C.9B.A6<;<3A52C5DD<5=5>D1CC5DC2ED9DG1C1<C?E>25<95F12<I496Q3E<DD?9=@<5=5>D.

(44) 65;9(*;: 9640:, . . . )./92  '. &#. '&+)'$$"&  !)!'$). " &"& +. ++$%&+$, %"$$"'&(. +85/8=;+6<3+. %9/.989%+637;9>:. %/:=/7,/;  .   . +85+1+81!+<398+6 8.98/<3+. %A+7<>6!>;<+637. %/:=/7,/;  .   .

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

(49) .

(50). +85 9./;8. %+7+.35>8+;=989. /-/7,/;  . 

(51) 

(52). +859538.9. 93+;=993+8=9. :;36

(53)   '+$. 

(54)  . .  

(55).  ;A<A.9A52?2D2?23<B?"'#@0<C2?6;4<;2'A.82<C2?/.;8.;1A5?22' 6B?J5>21>;C1>4D85B5G5B5QF5/.;8@M0<;A?<996;4@5.?25<912?@D5<@64;21A52.4?22:2;A@ )5?<B45A52@2"'#@A524<C2?;:2;A5.1.A<A.909.6:<3'=

(56) 

(57)  :6996<;*;9682A52 "(A52=?2=.?.A<?FB;12?A.86;4@92.16;4A<A526@@B.;02<3=?<:6@@<?F;<A2@/FA525<916;4 0<:=.;62@D2?2;<A1<;2.@169642;A9F.@A52F<B45AA<5.C2/22;1<;2.;15.1;<AA.82;=9.02 C=??D8<IC1B5CE<D>?D?><IG1C9D496Q3E<D6?BD858?<49>70<:=.;62@.;12C2;AB.99F3<?' A<0<;A?<9A52<=2?.A6<;<3A52C5DD<5=5>D3?=@1>95C2ED9DG1C1<C?496Q3E<DD?49C@?C5?6D85=

(58)   &/ )"&0)/)"56 )522;( ,5.(2<(5$;(5.<?%*D.@A529.@A42;2?.A6<;<3@5.?25<912?@2AA92:2;A.4?22:2;A /FD5605A520<;A?<996;4@5.?25<912?@<3A52'/.;8@.4?221A<=.F'6;0.@5.02?A.6; .:<B;A<36;12/A21;2@@<C2?.=2?6<1<33<B?F2.?@.;1@6:B9A.;2<B@9F.4?221A<=?<C6120<9 9.A2?.9.A.:6;6:B:C.9B2<3  =2?02;A<3A52A<A.912/A.@60.99F6AD.@.9<.;.4?22:2;A /2AD22;A524<C2?;:2;A?2=?2@2;A21/F'.;1A52'/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@.9A5<B45A52 /.;8@M@5.?25<912?@5.1;2C2??2026C21.;F9<.;16?20A9F3?<:A524<C2?;:2;A)52@A?B0AB?.912 @64;<3%*D.@6;A?<1B0216;

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

(60)  %.?A<3A52=?</92:@D2?26;3.0A<?052@A?.A21/FA52/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@A52:@29C2@D5<32.?21A52=<A2;A6.92E=<@B?2@A5.AA52F:B@A./@<?/.@ =2?@<;.94B.?.;A<?@A<A525<916;40<:=.;62@.AA522;1<3A521.F/20.B@26A5.1/22;.;A606=.A21A5.AA5216@=<@.9C.9B2<3A52@2AA92:2;A.@@2A@D<B91/2:B05 9<D2?A5.;A526;6A6.9C.9B2.@.4?221B=<;/2AD22;'.;1A52/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@@.:.AA2?<33.0AA52=?<4?2@@<3A5216@=<@.9=?<4?.:<3A52@2AA92:2;A .@@2A@B;12?A52"'#/23<?2

(61). 5.1/22;C2?F16@.==<6;A6;49A5<B45<;=.=2?A52"'#D.@0<;02=AB.99F/2AA2?A5.;A52"(6;A2?:@<3A52=<A2;A6.9 ?20<C2?F<3A52@A.A23B;1@A522E20BA6<;<3A52"'#D.@:<?26;12A2?:6;.A2.;1A52.0AB.90<;A?6/BA6<;3?<:A52.@@2A16@=<@.9D.@3.?92@@A5.;@.A6@3.0A<?F.

(62) 65;9(*;: 9640:, . . . @5.?25<912?@.;1A524?<B=0<:=.;62@/20.:2'12/A<?@.;1.;F=.F:2;A/F26A52?=.?AF D<B91?21B02A52</964.A6<;@<3A52<A52?=.?AF.00<?16;49F)52@052:2D.@12@64;21<;A52 /.@6@<3.*6+,);69*65*,7;0651<D8?E789>1=?49Q546?B= @3.?.@'A.82<C2?/.;8@ D2?20<;02?;21A52.:<B;A<3</964.A6<;@A</2@2AA921/FA52/.;8M@0<;A?<996;4@5.?25<912?@ D.@/.@60.99F2>B6C.92;AA<A52.:<B;A<3</964.A6<;@A5.AA526?4?<B=0<:=.;62@<D21A<A52 /.;8@"2.;D5692A523<?:B9.B@21A<12A2?:6;2A52.:<B;A<3A52</964.A6<;@A</2@2AA921/F A52@5.?25<912?@<3'3?<G2;/.;8@D.@8;<D;.@A529<@@.99<0.A6<;0<;02=A   @@5<D;6;)./92 6;A<A.9A52?2D2?2A56?AF%*@@64;21/FA56?AFAD<0<;A?<996;4 @5.?25<912?@<3AD2;AF@6E'/.;8@<3D5605AD<D2?2'A.82<C2?/.;8@*;9682A52 "(.;1A52"'#A52;B:/2?<3@2AA92:2;A.4?22:2;A@B;12?A52%*@052:23.?2E0221 21A5<@2<3A52"(.;1A52"'#0<:/6;21/BAA52A<A.94<C2?;:2;AM@09.6:A52?2<3D.@ <;9F =2?02;A<3A52A<A.94<C2?;:2;A09.6:@B;12?A52"(.;1A52"'#@D.@2C612;A A52.1:6;6@A?.A6<;<3%*D.@:B05:<?2/B?12;@<:2A5<B4592@@0<:=960.A216;;.AB?2A5.; A5<@2<3"(.;1A52"'#AD.@.;612.912@64;<3@5.?25<912?@2AA92:2;A.4?22:2;A.;1 A52?25.1/22;56452E=20A.A6<;@A5.A6AD<B91D<?8/2AA2?A5.;A52"(.;1A52"'#  #2C2?A5292@@/23<?2:61

(63).

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

(65) 

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

(68) =2?02;A<3A52A<A.9/.;8M@.@@2A@  )56@3<?:B9.D.@6;A?<1B021A</?<.12;A52=.?A606=.A6<;<3A52(21>;CPC81B58?<45BCG8?814>?DC97>54D85#)?BD85#($?BD85QBCD /.A05<3%*A5B@6;0?2.@6;4A52=?</./696AF<3@A.A23B;1@?20<C2?F.@21<;A56@3<?:B9.6AD.@6??292C.;AD52A52?./.;8M@@5.?25<912?D.@0<;A?<996;4<?;<A .@2C2?F@5.?25<912?<3A52?2:.6;6;4'/.;8@D.@<332?21A52<==<?AB;6AFA<@5.?2A52</964.A6<;.@5.1/22;12A2?:6;21/F'6;=?<=<?A6<;D6A52.05<3 A526?@5.?25<916;4@6;A52/.;8'24.?192@@A52;2D3<?:B9.D.@B;./92A<6;A2?2@A:.;F<3A52?2:.6;6;4'/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@A<=.?A606=.A2)52?2D.@<;9F <;2/.;8@5.?25<912?D5<:.;.421A<0<:=92A2A52@2AA92:2;A.4?22:2;A.@@64;21)52?2D2?2AD<'/.;8@5.?25<912?@D5<@64;21@2AA92:2;A.4?22:2;A@ D6A5(21C54?>D85C1946?B=E<1?D8G5B5C81B58?<45BC6B?=B5C@53D9F5<I1>;&5<9D11>41>;CD9C=1B1D*85QBCDG1C1C:9=):?:?8149;ECE=?D?D1< </964.A6<;'=   :6996<;.;1A52@20<;1D.@4B@;D.?A<A.9</964.A6<;'= :6996<;*;96824B@;D.?.@76:(7<7<5.168B@B:<D.@ ./92A<0<:=92A256@</964.A6<;@6;3B99.

(69) 

(70) . . . . . . #/,"/(9,/63+,9",;;3,4,5; 96.9(4. )./92  '. &#. '&+)'$$"& !)!'$). 7366398$:. 

(71) . >.38=/;8+<398+6. +8+2>=+7+. &2//!38381. "-=9,/;  .

(72). *+538 +57>;. %3=3$>57+8+. %/:=/7,/;  .

(73)  . +4+8=/;8+<398+6. &2//!382981. %/:=/7,/;  . 

(74) . 8.3+;=+@+8%+;43=9. %/:=/7,/;  .  . . >73$+A+'=+7+. %>:+;89.34+8=9. %/:=/7,/;  .   . . %+829. +8.+5++8.;3+. "-=9,/; .  . #2363:%)34+A+. "-=9,/; . . . . +<2366'=+7+ 8.9=;+./. &+7+;+. #+:+8%/4+2=/;+. %/:=/7,/;  . %/==6/7/8=(+6>/. . /8.;+3/7. " &"& +. 

(75) . "-=9,/;  . . @+8%>2+;.37+8. !9?/7,/;  . 

(76)  . "7+;#>=32;+3. !9?/7,/;  .

(77) . 3.A+ >-2=+;. !9?/7,/;  .

(78)  . >63+8=9&+8+1+. 98119)/8.;+=79. "-=9,/;

(79)  .  . !499953981. "-=9,/;

(80)  .  . +<437%49492+.35><>79. "-=9,/;

(81)  . 

(82). +<=388=/;8+<398+6. &2/&4/ 38. "-=9,/; .  . %/@>8=/;8+<398+6. ><9.98159<>,;9=9. "-=9,/;  .  .

(83). +85!><+!+<398+6. !3;@+8+5;3/. !9?/7,/;  . +>=+8/;63+8. '6>81>;<+. "-=9,/; .  . . $. =+81+=3/0. "-=9,/;  .  . *+<98=+;9>: :/;<98<. "-=9,/;  . 

(84). +.>7+;9>: :/;<98<. "-=9,/;.  . 

(85)

(86). +;37>=>%383?+<+8. "-=9,/;

(87)  . 

(88) .   . . !+7>;+8=/;8><+. . #>=;+ >6=35+;<+. . #>=;+%>;A+#/;5+<+. &;3498998.95><>79. "-=9,/; .

(89) 

(90) . . '7>7%/;?3=3+. +?3.!><+)34+A+&+;>89.4949. "-=9,/;  .

(91) 

(92)

(93)  . . /=;9:963=+8. %+8=9<9%>7+63. "-=9,/;  .   . 5/8.  +./%>.3+;=+./+;7+@+8. "-=9,/;  . . 8=+8. +./6 >2+77+.. "-=9,/; .  .

(94). &+=+8=/;8+<398+6. /815A)34+A+. "-=9,/; .  . . +2+;3. %+8=9<9%>7+63. "-=9,/;  .  . . #/63=+. . <=3<7+;+=. +<437%49492+.35><>79. "-=9,/;

(95) 

(96). . 1><8@+;. !9?/7,/; 

(97).

(98) 

(99). +<437%49492+.35><979. "-=9,/;

(100) 

(101). 1><8@+;. !9?/7,/; 

(102) '+$. .

(103) 

(104)    . #<A2@   <?2.05/.;8A52?2D.@:<?2A5.;<;2@2AA92:2;A.4?22:2;A)52.:<B;A<3</964.A6<;3<?2.05<3A52@2AA92:2;A.4?22:2;A@D.@ 31<3E<1D54@B9=1B9<I?>D8521C9C?6D851=?E>D?67B?E@25>5QDCB5359F542I5138C97>1D?BI   <?2.05@2AA92:2;A.4?22:2;AA52?2D2?2:<?2A5.;<;2@64;.A<?FD5<D2?2@2C2?.99F.;17<6;A9F96./92   $?646;.9=?6;06=.9@2AA92:2;A.:<B;A   <?2.05<3A52/.;8M@@5.?25<912?A52?2D.@<;2@2AA92:2;A.4?22:2;AA5.A0<C2?21</964.A6<;@3?<:/<A5/.;8@;<A52?D<?1@ 2.05@5.?25<912?@64;21.@2AA92:2;A.4?22:2;AA5.A0<C2?21</964.A6<;@3?<:A52AD</.;8@.

(105) 65;9(*;: 9640:, . . . . 

(106)  . @29./<?.A21./<C2A52@2AA92:2;A.4?22:2;A@A5.AD2?2.1:6;6@A2?21B;12?A52(5.?25<912? )5DD<5=5>D&B?7B1=21C931<<I3?=@B9C54?6QF5#)C6?EB#($C1>4D89BDI&+C*85C5 .?2A52:.6;@A?2.:.;1A523<0.9=<6;A@<3A52@AB1F#2C2?A5292@@A52;<A6<;<3K/B?12;@5.?6;4 @052:2LD.@;<A:2.;AA</296:6A21A<A52@2AA92:2;A.4?22:2;A@A5.A0.:2B;12?A52%?<4?.: <;9F)52/.@60612.D.@5<DA<:.82'/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@D6996;4A<@5.?2A52/B?12;A5.A A524<C2?;:2;A5.1A</2.?/20.B@2<3A52/.;86;4@F@A2:600?6@6@.;16;=.?A60B9.?A<?20<C2? A52@A.A23B;1@A5.A5.1/22;6;720A216;A<A52/.;86;4@F@A2:.;1 <?A<:6;6:6G2A520<@A@<3A52 0?6@6@  @ . :.AA2? <3 3.0A A52?2 D2?2 @2AA92:2;A .00<?1@ /2AD22; ' .;1 @2C2?.9 /.;8@M @5.?25<912?@A5.A0.;;<A253<1CC9Q541C?>5?6D8512?F5=5>D9?>54C5DD<5=5>D17B55=5>DCE>45B A52)81B58?<45B)5DD<5=5>D&B?7B1=C1B5CE<DD85C5133?B4C3?E<4>?D25>5QD6B?=D85<571< .;1.1:6;6@A?.A6C2A?2.A:2;A=?<C61213<?A52:.6;@A?2.:@2AA92:2;A.4?22:2;A@.;1@A699A52F .?2D<?A5:2;A6<;6;46;<?12?A<:.82A56@(AB1F0<:=92A2  # .# //' ( )/"-. ( )/.. 2AD22; .;12.?9F

(107). .3A2?A52@A?B0AB?.912@64;<3A52"(.;1A52"'#D2?2 @B13D931<<I121>4?>542ID857?F5B>=5>D2ED256?B5D85?6Q391<9=@<5=5>D1D9?>?6&+9>@B9<

(108). @2C2?.90<;A?<996;4@5.?25<912?@<3'3?<G2;/.;8@.4?221A<@2AA9202?A.6;:<;2A.?F </964.A6<;@?29.A21A<A52/.;8@A52F<D;219A5<B45A523<?:B9.B@216;0.90B9.A6;4A52.:<B;A <3</964.A6<;A</2@2AA921/FA52/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@D.@A52@.:2.@A5.A<3%*;.:29FA5.A<3 A529<@@.99<0.A6<;0<;02=AA52@2.4?22:2;A@/2AD22;'.;1A52/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@5.1;<A /22;@A6=B9.A216;<;2<3A52:.6;@A?2.:@2AA92:2;A.4?22:2;A@  ;@A2.1A52.4?22:2;AD.@0<;A.6;216;A523<?:<3.:B05@6:=92?06C699.D0<;A?.0A A52@<0.9921"(3,(5+ <9*/(:,.9,,4,5;(5+::0.54,5;6-!,*,0=()3,:6;D5605A52/.;8@ @5.?25<912?@.4?221A<=.F'A520<;A?.0A21</964.A6<;@.;16;?2AB?;'.4?221A<@B??2; 12?A52.00<B;A?2026C./92@9D@?CC5CC541719>CDD8521>;CP16Q<91D54452D?BC*89CG1C=?B5<9;5 '0<9920A6;43B99=.F:2;A3?<:'/.;8@M12/A<?@<??2026C6;4=?<0221@3?<:A5216@=<@.9 <3'/.;8@M9<.;@.AA52/<<8C.9B2/BAD6A5.;.116A6<;.9.:<B;AA<0<C2?.99<0.A21/.;8@M 9<@@2@ )./92

(109). '. &#. +8560+.

(110). '&+)'$$"& !)!'$). ++$%&+$, +!',*&(. +7,+81&;32+=79.49. . . +85%389. %>;A+.3%>,+8.3&+8>@3.4+4+.   . +853:>=;+. 3:>=;++736A. . 

(111). +85";3/8=. 6.9;+<+63. . +85+8+2>=+7+. %90A+8)+8+8.3 '+$. 

(112)

(113).     

(114)  .  @@5<D;6;)./92

(115) A52?2D2?2@6E3?>DB?<<9>7C81B58?<45BC?6QF5(/.;8@D5< @64;21 @2AA92:2;A .4?22:2;A@ <3 D89C DI@5 *85 1=?E>D ?6 C5DD<5=5>D F1<E5 G1C 9>C97>9Q31>D .@ 0<:=.?21 A< A52 :.6;@A?2.: @2AA92:2;A .4?22:2;A@ .;1 A52?23<?2 A52 /.;8@M @5.?25<912?@ C55=54D?81F5>?@B?2<5=9>6E<Q<<9>7D85?2<971D9?>C9>31C8G9D89>1C8?BD@5B9?4?6D9=5>.

(116) . . . . . . #/,"/(9,/63+,9",;;3,4,5; 96.9(4. .116A6<;A52Q>1>391<3?>49D9?>?61<<?6D8521>;CPC81B58?<45BCG1C=E3825DD5BD81>D81D?6 :<@A%*@64;.A<?62@.@A<.99<D0.@5=.F:2;A*;@B?=?6@6;49FA52?2D.@.9@<;<?2>B6?2:2;A 6:=<@21B=<;A52/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@A<=?<C612A52;202@@.?F0<99.A2?.9@AD.@.@A?.645A3<? D.?10.@5@2AA92:2;A.??.;42:2;A.;1:<@A<3A52/.;8@M@5.?25<912?@D2?2./92A<0<:=92A2.99 A526?</964.A6<;@/FA522;1<3

(117).   #  //' ( )/*!

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

(119) '.  . )" "&''&. &#.*!)!'$). ++$%&+$, %"$$"'&(. +85*+538 +57>;+858=/; 8+=398+68.98/<3++85/8=;+6 <3++85>73+A++85 #/7,+81>8+88.98/<3++85 &+,>81+8!/1+;++8.+85 *+538 +57>;. %3=3$>57+8+-98=;966381<2+;/ 296./;90+85*+538 +57>;.

(120)

(121)  

(122). +85/8=;+6<3++8. +85+8+798. +7,+81&;32+=79.49-98=;966381 <2+;/296./;90+8560+.

(123)  . &9=+6.  

(124) . @@5<D;6;)./92

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

(127) =2?02;A6;D5605A52/.;8@M0<;A?<996;4 @5.?25<912?@D2?2D6996;4A<056=6;A<.:6;6:B:<3

Referenties

GERELATEERDE DOCUMENTEN

The Shareholder Settlement Program: A Pragmatic Resolution to confront a Systemic Banking Crises in view of the Dysfunctional Legal System and Tradition of the Republic of

The Shareholder Settlement Program: A Pragmatic Resolution to confront a Systemic Banking Crises in view of the Dysfunctional Legal System and Tradition of the Republic of

The Shareholder Settlement Program: A Pragmatic Resolution to confront a Systemic Banking Crises in view of the Dysfunctional Legal System and Tradition of the Republic of

The Shareholder Settlement Program: A Pragmatic Resolution to confront a Systemic Banking Crises in view of the Dysfunctional Legal System and Tradition of the Republic of

The Shareholder Settlement Program: A Pragmatic Resolution to confront a Systemic Banking Crises in view of the Dysfunctional Legal System and Tradition of the Republic of

The Shareholder Settlement Program: A Pragmatic Resolution to confront a Systemic Banking Crises in view of the Dysfunctional Legal System and Tradition of the Republic of

The Shareholder Settlement Program: A Pragmatic Resolution to confront a Systemic Banking Crises in view of the Dysfunctional Legal System and Tradition of the Republic of

In 1972 the social anthropologist Anthony Forge suggested from ethnographic studies that villages tend to fission at a size of circa 150 people to sustain a face-to-face form of