The Shareholder Settlement Program: A Pragmatic Resolution to confront a Systemic Banking Crises in view of the Dysfunctional Legal System and Tradition of the Republic of Indonesia

Hele tekst

(1)The Shareholder Settlement Program: A Pragmatic Resolution to confront a Systemic Banking Crises in view of the Dysfunctional Legal System and Tradition of the Republic of Indonesia Maroef, T.M.. Citation Maroef, T. M. (2010, March 25). The Shareholder Settlement Program: A Pragmatic Resolution to confront a Systemic Banking Crises in view of the Dysfunctional Legal System and Tradition of the Republic of Indonesia. Retrieved from https://hdl.handle.net/1887/15127 Version:. Not Applicable (or Unknown). License:. Licence agreement concerning inclusion of doctoral thesis in the Institutional Repository of the University of Leiden. Downloaded from:. https://hdl.handle.net/1887/15127. Note: To cite this publication please use the final published version (if applicable)..

(2) . . .

(3)

(4) . .

(5) . . . . . . &,@J6 ,;;,09=0 ,=:01 %41$4->14;801>$1@@8191:@">;3>-9 . ">-39-@5/#1?;8A@5;:@;/;:2>;:@-$E?@195/-:75:3>5?1? 5:B51C;2@41E?2A:/@5;:-813-8$E?@19-:0%>-05@5;: ;2@41#1<A.85/;2:0;:1?5-. 5:/8A01.5.85;3>-<45/-8>1221>1:/1?-:05:01D

(6) 978-602-96367-0-3 05??1>@-@5;:/;<E V

(7)

(8) -5I_?&5DD59BF9&5FC9: -88>534@?>1?1>B10.

(9) . . . . &%$"$%&& !&#$"$ )F5;A5H=7+9GC@IH=CBHC7CB:FCBH5,MGH9A=75B?=B;F=G9G =BJ=9KC:H<9MG:IB7H=CB5@%9;5@,MGH9A5B8-F58=H=CB C:H<9+9DI6@=7C:"B8CB9G=5. )+(,!+"-. H9FJ9F?F=>;=B;J5B 89;F558J5BC7HCF55B89.B=J9FG=H9=H%9=89B CD;9N5;J5B89+97HCF&5;B=_7IGDFC: AF ) J5B89F!9=>89B JC@;9BG69G@I=HJ5B<9HC@@9;9JCCF)FCACH=9G H9J9F898=;9BCD8CB89F85;A55FH

(10)

(11) ?@C??9 IIF. 8CCF. &,@J6 ,;;,09=0 ,=:01 ;96CF9BH9&5?5GG5F"B8CB9G=5 .

(12) . . . . . . #$" "&". . . %%. )FCACHCF9G . )FC:9GGCFF ! F5B?9B )FC:9GGCFF # $I=>@ )FC:9GGCFF / -=AA9FA5BF5GAIG.B=J9FG=HM+CHH9F85A. (J9F=;9@989B . )FC:9GGCFF 09GG9@G )FC:9GGCFF + J5BG7< )FC:9GGCFF # & (HHC )FC:9GGCF +58>5;I?;I?, ! %% & )< .B=J9FG=HMC:"B8CB9G=5 "B8CB9G=5 )FC:9GGCFF &5B5B, ! &% .B=J9FG=HMC:)58>58>5F5B"B8CB9G=5.

(13) . . . . . 5?9588-45>#-49--:5>#-4559 "5A;F5H9:I@HC69;=J9BH<9CDDCFHIB=HMHCH5?9D5FH=BH<9IBDF97989BH98<=GHCF=75@AC A9BH8IF=B;K<=7<H<9"B8CB9G=5B5B?=B;+9GHFI7HIF=B;;9B7M["+\5B8H<9,<5F9<C@8 9F,9HH@9A9BH)FC;F5AK9F99GH56@=G<985B8=BHFC8I798HC7CB:FCBH5B8CJ9F7CA9H<9GMGH9A=7 65B?=B;7F=G=G5B897CBCA=7A9@H8CKB5GC77IFF98=B"B8CB9G=58IF=B;

(14)

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

(16)

(17) -5I_?&5DD59BF9&5FC9:.

(18) . . . . . . L%41>1->1?1B1:?5:?5:@41C;>80C1-8@4C5@4;A@C;>7<81-?A>1C5@4;A@/;:?/51:/1 7:;C81031C5@4;A@/4->-/@1>/;991>/1C5@4;A@9;>-85@E?/51:/1C5@4;A@4A9-:5@EC;> 1'(/5(2'.321 "0(;"$ -#/.+(2("15(2'.32/0(-"(/+$9 . . . . . . &5<5HA5 5B8<= .

(19) %-.81!2;:@1:@. . . . . #=01,.0 --=0A4,?4:9>,9/..=:9D8> #&$. . . . . L=. . . . . . . . 57?;FCIB8 ,H5H9A9BHC:)FC6@9AG -<9-<9CF9H=75@F5A9KCF? -<9)IFDCG9C:+9G95F7<,HI8M -<9+9G95F7<&9H<C8C@C;M (F;5B=N5H=CBC:=GG9FH5H=CB . . .

(20) . . . . A. -<9'5H=CB5@7CBCAM 1. -<9,HFI7HIF5@"A65@5B79B(J9FJ=9K 2. -<9=B5B7=5@,97HCF 3. 0<5HCI@8 C0FCB; . . . B. -<9G=5B=B5B7=5@F=G=G 1. -<9CBH5;=CB::97H 2. -<95G9C:"B8CB9G=5%CGH=BCB_89B79 3. ,C7=5@5B8)C@=H=75@"AD@=75H=CB!=;<@=;<H 4. @9GG=B;=B=G;I=G9-<9LD9BG=J9%9GGCB. .

(21) . C. -<9"&+9G7I9)57?5;9 1. "B,95F7<:CF0<=H9$B=;<H 2. -<9,HFI7HIF5@8>IGHA9BHG)FC;F5A 3. +9J=H5@=N5H=CBC:H<95B?=B;,MGH9A. . . !"! A. B. C. D. E. F.. #&$. . !!. !. . D. -<9"B8CB9G=55B?+9GHFI7HIF=B;;9B7M["+\ 1. +9;I@5HCFM5B8(D9F5H=CB5@F5A9KCF? 2. -<9!CGD=H5@:CF-FCI6@985B?G 3. -<9 CJ9FBA9BH I5F5BH99)FC;F5A 4. (H<9FIH=9G 5. "+^G(J9F5@@)9F:CFA5B79 #&$ . !. !!!. A. -<9-FCI6@985B?=B;,97HCF 1. @5KGC:H<95B?=B;,MGH9A 2. 5B?"B8CB9G=5%=EI=8=HM,IDDCFH. . . . .

(22) . . . . . . %41$4->14;801>$1@@8191:@">;3>-9. 3. 57HI5@CB8=H=CBC:"+5B?G 4. "B*I9GHC:5=FB9GG . #&$( . . .

(23)

(24) . B. "BGH=HIH=CB5@"AD98=A9BHG 1. -<95B?=B;%5K%=A=HCB"+^G)CK9FG 2. -<9CAD5BM%5K,<5F9<C@89F^G%=A=H98%=56=@=HM 3. (H<9FJ5=@56@9/9BI9G 4. -<9#I8=7=5@,MGH9AB"ADCGG=6@9/9BI9 5. -<9'998:CF)F5;A5H=7+9GC@IH=CB .

(25) . C. @H9FB5H=J9DDFC57<!A@;2;A>@$1@@8191:@ 1. -<9"B=H=5@9G=;B 2. CJ9FBA9BH^G-5G?CF79-<9<FCBC@C;M 3. -<9CAA9F7=5@GD97H 4. @5KGC:H<9"B=H=5@9G=;B . .

(26)

(27) . D. -<95F?D=GC89 1. -<9)C@=H=75@-K=GH%9589FG<=D=B)9F=@ 2. '9K8A=B=GHF5H=CB&95BG'9K,HM@9 3. .BK=HH=B;C@@5H9F5@5A5;9G . .

(28)

(29) . E. -<9)C=BHC:'C+9HIFB%9GGCB%95FBH 1. -<9,IDF9A9 I=89@=B9G 2. -<9)5F@=5A9BH,H5B8DC=BH 3. -<9&9;5K5H=^G+9GC@IH=CB 4. -<9"AD@9A9BH=B;F5A9KCF?. .

(30) . . . . ! !!!!

(31) :9?=,.?,>#=:84>0. A. -<9CBHF57HG 1. -<9BHFM)5F5A9H9F 2. -<95G=7)FC_@9G 3. -<9CF;CHH9B(B9G&CF9,9HH@9A9BHCBHF57HG 4. -<9'CB CCD9F5H=J9(6@=;CFG . . B. CBHF57H/5@=8=HM5B8B:CF7956=@=HM 1. )F=B7=D@9G5B8+I@9G 2. /5@=8=HMC:H<9,9HH@9A9BH;F99A9BHG 3. 88=H=CB5@'CH9GCBH<9,9HH@9A9BH;F99A9BHG 4. CB7@IG=CBCB/5@=8=HM5B8B:CF7956=@=HM .

(32)

(33) . C. -<9+9@95G95B8=G7<5F;9@5IG9 1. +9@9J5BHCBBCH5H=CB 2. CB`=7H=B;,7<CC@C:-<CI;<HG 3. -<9)F9G=89BH=5@"BGHFI7H=CB'C C:

(34)

(35) ["')+,'C \ 4. "AD@9A9BH5H=CB,HF5H9;M 5. )FCA=G=B;,=;B5@C:CBHF57HI5@CAD@=5B79. .

(36)

(37) . . .

(38) %-.81!2;:@1:@. #&$(. . . . #&$( % % . . D. -<9CAD@9H=CBC:-<9)FC;F5A 1. -<9@CGIF9C:"+ 2. -<9@CG=B;;F99A9BH 3. )I6@=7@M,5B7H=CB98#181-?15?/4->31 4. '9K)5F58=;A=B%5KB:CF79A9BH.B89FH5?=B;.

(39) . E. "BH9F=A@CG=B;+9A5F?G 1. -<9=B5@+9GI@H 2. 9FH5=B.B_B=G<98!CA9KCF?. . . . . . . A. -<9#I8=7=5@,MGH9A 1. "B*I9GHC:#I8=7=5@"B89D9B89B79 2. -<9#I8=7=5@)9FGCBB9@ 3. -<9CIFH&5B5;9A9BH 4. -<9#I8=7=5@+9:CFAB(B ;C=B;=G7CIFG9.

(40)

(41) . B. -<9CBGHFI7H=J9,=;B5@ 5. %9;=H=A57MC:)C@=7M97=G=CB 6. -<9/5@=8=HMC:[)) [ 7. -<9/5@=8=HMC:["')+,'C \ 8. "B,IAA5FM . . . . C. -<9AD=F=75@"ADF97=G=CB 9. -<9(IH C: CIFHBCA5@M 10. -<9C@@5H9F5@5A5;9G 11. -<9.BK=HH=B;%9;5@7H=CBG 12. M9G0=H<CIH579 . . .

(42) . . . !#"& . " . . . . . 88=H=CB5@'CH9GCB"+ F9@5H98%9;5@5G9G

(43) 990C.BC:_7=5@HF5BG@5H=CBC:)F9G=89BH=5@"BGHFI7H=CB'C 295F

(44)

(45) 7CB79FB=B;-<905FF5BHMC:%9;5@9FH5=BHM:CF96HCF0<C!5GI@_@@98H<9 (6@=;5H=CBGCF%9;5@7H=CB;5=BGH96HCF0<C5=@GHCI@_@@H<9(6@=;5 H=CBG5G,H=DI@5H98=BH<9,<5F9<C@89F,9HH@9A9BH;F99A9BHG["')+,'C \. 990C .BC::=7=5@ HF5BG@5H=CB C: 97=G=CB C: ,IDF9A9 CIFH 'C

(46) !.&

(47)

(48) &5M

(49)

(50) 7CB79FB=B;%9;5@@5=AHCIB89FH5?9#I8=7=5@+9 J=9K5;5=BGH)F9G=89BH=5@"BGHFI7H=CB'C 295F

(51)

(52) 5 ? 5 \"')+,'C \. 990C .BC:_7=5@ HF5BG@5H=CB C: 97=G=CB C: 56=B9H &99H=B; 7CB 79FB=B; H<9 ,9HH@9A9BH C: 5B? ,<5F9<C@89FG^ (6@=;5H=CBG )$), 5G 75FF=98 CIH IB89F H<9 IGD=79G C: "B8CB9G=5B 5B?=B; +9GHFI7HIF=B; ;9B7M"+85H98&5F7<

(53)

(54) .

(55) =L. . . . . . %41$4->14;801>$1@@8191:@">;3>-9. 990C ( .BC:_7=5@ HF5BG@5H=CB C: KCF?=B; D5D9F [-<9 +9@95G9 =G 7<5F;9+@5IG9 %9HH9F=B%=;<HC:H<9+97CJ9FMC:,H5H9IB8G6MA95BG C:H<9,9HH@9A9BHC:,<5F9<C@89FG^(6@=;5H=CBG)$),\5GDF9D5F986M H<9,H99F=B;CAA=HH99:CF@9;5@ =8H<9=B5B7=5@,97HCF)C@=7MCAA=HH99 ,). 4-74:2=,;3D C0.@?4A0%@88,=D#$,**$ @==4.@7@8(4?,0 9/0C . . . . . . .

(56) ..>1B5-@5;:?:0//>;:E9?. . L=.

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

(58)

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

(61) C: .

(62)

No results found