Central European Constitutional Courts in the face of EU membership : the influence of the German model of integration in Hungary and Poland
Tatham, A.F.
Citation
Tatham, A. F. (2011, November 1). Central European Constitutional Courts in the face of EU membership : the influence of the German model of integration in Hungary and Poland.
Retrieved from https://hdl.handle.net/1887/18011
Version: Not Applicable (or Unknown)
License: Licence agreement concerning inclusion of doctoral thesis in the Institutional Repository of the University of Leiden
Downloaded from: https://hdl.handle.net/1887/18011
Note: To cite this publication please use the final published version (if applicable).
CASES CITED
EUROPEAN UNION
EUROPEAN COURT OF JUSTICE
26/62 NV Algemene Transport- en Expeditie Onderneming van Gend & Loos v. Tariefcommissie [1963] ECR 1 ... 22, 82
28-30/62 (Joined Cases) Da Costa en Schaake [1963] ECR 31 ... 259
6/64 Costa v. ENEL [1964] ECR 585 ... 22, 255 57/65 Alfons Lütticke GmbH v. Hauptzollamt Saarlouis [1966] ECR 205 ... 198
13/68 Salgoil (SpA) v. Italian Ministry for Foreign Trade [1968] ECR 453 ... 143, 149
26/69 Stauder v. City of Ulm [1969] ECR 419 ... 156 77/69 Commission v. Belgium [1970] ECR 237 ... 19 8/70 Commission v. Italy [1970] ECR 961 ... 19 9/70 Grad v. Finanzamt Traunstein [1970] ECR 825 ... 14, 81, 82
11/70 Internationale Handelsgesellschaft mbH v.
Einfuhr-und Vorratsstelle für Getriede und Futtermittel [1970] ECR 1125 ... 14, 156-157, 209, 255, 274
20/70 Transports Lesage & Cie SA v. Hauptzollamt Freiburg [1970] ECR 861 ... 82
23/70 Haselhorst v. Finanzamt Düsseldorf-Altstadt [1970] ECR 881 ... 82
25/70 EVGF v. Köster [1970] ECR 1161 ... 157, 274 33/70 SpA SACE v. Finance Minister of the Italian Republic [1970] ECR 1213 ... 82
6/71 Rheinmühlen Düsseldorf v. Einfuhr- und Vorratsstelle für Getreide und Futtermittel [1971]
ECR 823 ... 149
39/72 Commission v. Italy [1973] ECR 101 ... 167 4/73 Nold v. Commission [1974] ECR 491... 93, 157 167/73 Commission v. France [1974] ECR 359 ... 19 2/74 Reyners v. Belgian State [1974] ECR 631 ... 141
41/74 Van Duyn v. Home Office [1974] ECR 1337 ... 14
51/76 Verbond [1977] ECR 113 ... 14
78/76 Firma Steinike & Weinlig v. Federal Republic of Germany [1977] ECR 595 ... 83
107/76 Hoffmann-La Roche AG v. Centrafarm Vertriebsgesellschaft Pharmazeutischer Erzeugnisse mbH [1977] ECR 957 ... 259
106/77 Amministrazione delle Finanze dello Stato v.
Simmenthal SpA [1978] ECR 629 ... 14, 20, 22, 139, 157, 172, 197-198, 200, 203, 240
44/79 Hauer v. Land Rheinland-Pfalz [1979] ECR 3727 ... 93, 157, 274
98/79 Pecastaing v. Belgian State [1980] ECR 691 ... 274
100-103/80 (Joined Cases) SA Musique Diffusion française v. Commission [1983] ECR 1825 ... 274 244/80 Foglia v. Novello (No. 2) [1981] ECR 3045
… 20
8/81 Becker v. Finanzamt Münster-Innenstadt [1982] ECR 53 ... 81, 82
255/81 R.A. Grendel GmbH v. Finanzamt für Körperschaften in Hambourg [1982] ECR 2301 ...
82
283/81 Srl CILFIT v. Ministero della Sanità [1982]
ECR 3415 ... 145, 170, 207, 259-260, 267, 273, 275 14/83 von Colson v. Land Nordrhein-Westfalen [1984] ECR 1891 ... 19
63/83 R. v. Kent Kirk [1984] ECR 2689 ... 157, 168 70/83 Kloppenburg v. Finanzamt Leer [1984] ECR 1075 ... 81, 82
294/83 Parti Ecologiste Les Verts v. European Parliament [1986] ECR 1339 … 12
152/84 Marshall v. Southampton and South West Hampshire Area Health Authority (Teaching) [1986]
ECR 723 ... 113
EUROPEAN UNION (cont.)
EUROPEAN COURT OF JUSTICE (cont.) 222/84 Johnston v. Chief Constable of the Royal Ulster Constabulary [1986] ECR 1651 ... 93, 274 147/86 Commission v. Greece [1988] ECR 1637 ... 252
222/86 UNECTEF v. Heylens [1987] ECR 4097 ...
274
379/87 Groener [1989] ECR 3967 ... 252 C-2/88 Imm. Zwartfeld [1990] ECR I-3365 ... 20 5/88 Wachauf v. Germany [1989] ECR 2609 ... 157 103/88 Fratelli Costanzo v. Comune di Milano [1989]
ECR 1839 … 14
C-106/89 Marleasing SA v. La Comercial Internacional de Alimentacion SA [1990] ECR I- 4135 ... 168, 243
C-213/89 R. v. Secretary of State for Transport, ex parte Factortame Ltd. [1990] ECR I-2433 ... 14, 22, 202
C-159/90 Society for the Protection of the Unborn Child v. Grogan [1991] ECR I-4719 ... 252
C-320-322/90 (Joined Cases) Telemarsicabruzzo SpA v. Circostel [1993] ECR I-393 ... 267
1/91 (Opinion) Re Draft Treaty on a European Economic Area [1991] ECR I-6079 ... 12
C-271/91 Marshall v. Southampton and South-West Hampshire Area Health Authority (Marshall No. 2) [1993] ECR I-4367 ... 113
C-325/91 France v. Commission [1993] ECR I-3283 ... 267
C-91/92 Faccini Dori v. Recreb srl [1994] ECR I- 3325 ... 170
C-46 & 48/93 (Joined Cases) Brasserie du Pêcheur SA v. Germany [1996] ECR I-1029 ... 243, 272 C-280/93 Germany v. Council [1994] ECR I-4973 … 95
C-316/93 Vaneetveld v. SA Le Foyer [1994] ECR I- 763 ... 152
C-323/93 R. v. H.M. Treasury, ex parte British Telecommunications PLC [1996] ECR I-1631 ... 243
C-422/93-424/93 (Joined Cases) Erasun [1995] ECR I-1567 ... 20
C-466/93 Atlanta Fruchthandelsgesellschaft (II) v.
Bundesamt für Ernährung und Forstwirtschaft [1995] ECR I-3799 … 96, 252
C-473/93 Commission v. Luxembourg [1996] ECR I- 3207 ... 252
C-149/94 Criminal proceedings against Vergy [1996] ECR I-299 ... 150
C-24/95 Land Rheinland-Pfalz v. Alcan Deutschland [1997] ECR I-1591 ... 79
C-338/95 Wiener v. Hauptzollamt Emmerich [1997]
ECR I-6495 ... 260, 267
C-27/96 Danisco Sugar AB v. Almänna Ombudet [1997] ECR I-6653 ... 273
C-369/96 and C-376/96 (Joined Cases) Criminal proceedings against Arblade [1999] ECR I-8453 ...
253
C-49/98, C-50/98, C-52/98 to C-54/98 and C-68/98 to C-71/98 (Joined Cases) Finalarte v. Urlaubs- und Lohnausgleichskasse der Bauwirtschaft [2001] ECR I-7831 ... 253
C-165/98 Mazzoleni and Inter Surveillance Assistance SARL [2001] ECR I-2189 ... 253
C-403/98 Azienda Agricola Monte Arcosu Srl v.
Regione Autonoma della Sardegna [2001] ECR I- 103 ... 167
C-143/99 Adria-Wien Pipeline GmbH v.
Finanzlandesdirektion für Kärnten [2001] ECR I- 8365 ... 4, 241, 261, 264
C-510/99 Criminal proceedings against Tridon [2001] ECR I-7777 ... 150
C-30/00 William Hinton & Sons Lda v. Fazenda Pública [2001] ECR I-7511 ... 166
C-50/00 P Unión de Pequeños Agricultores v.
Council [2002] ECR I-6677 … 253
C-99/00 Lyckeskog v. Åklagarkammeren i Uddevalla [2002] ECR I-4839 ... 259, 260
EUROPEAN UNION (cont.)
EUROPEAN COURT OF JUSTICE (cont.) C-179/00 Weidacher v. Bundesminister für Land- und Forstwirtschaft [2002] ECR I-501 ... 147, 166, 168
C-453/00 Kühne & Heitz NV v. Productschap voor Pluimvee en Eieren [2004] ECR I-837 ... 273 C-465/00 (Joined Cases) Rechnungshof v.
Österreichischer Rundfunk [2003] ECR-I 4989 ...
241, 261, 264
C-171/01 Wählergruppe “Gemeinsam Zajedno/
Birlikte Alternative und Grüne Gewerkschafter- Innen/UG” v. Bundesminister für Wirtschaft und Arbeit [2003] ECR I-4301 ... 241, 261, 264
C-224/01 Köbler v. Austria [2003] ECR I-10239 ...
86, 89, 203, 267, 271-274
C-397-403/01 (Joined Cases) Pfeiffer v. Deutsches Rotes Kreuz, Kreisverband Waldshut eV [2004] ECR I-8835 ... 141, 149
C-36/02 Omega Spielhallen- und
Automatenaufstellungs-GmbH v. Oberbürger- meisterin der Bundesstadt Bonn [2004] ECR I-9609 ... 114, 253
C-105/03 Criminal proceedings against Maria Pupino [2005] ECR I-5285 ... 106, 107
C-173/03 Traghetti del Mediterraneo SpA v. Italy [2006] ECR I-5177... 86, 244, 272
C-461/03 Gaston Schul Douane-expediteur BV v.
Minister van Landbouw, Natuur en Voedselkwaliteit [2005] ECR I-10513 ... 260
C-480/03 Hugo Clemens, b.v.b.a. Valkaniersgilde v.
Walloon region, Council of Ministers, Order of ECJ:
OJ 2005 C6/22 ... 150-151
C-495/03 Intermodal Transports BV v.
Staatssecretaris van Financiën [2005] ECR I-8151 ... 260
C-14/04 Abdelkader Dellas v. Premier ministre [2005] ECR I-10253 ... 141, 226
C-131/04 and C-257/04 (Joined Cases) C.D.
Robinson-Steele v. R.D. Retail Services Ltd. [2006]
ECR I-2531 ... 141, 226
C-144/04 Mangold v. Helm [2005] ECR I-9981 ... 88, 103
C-145/04 Spain v. United Kingdom [2006] ECR I- 7917 ... 114
C-355/04 P Segi v. Council [2007] ECR I-1657 ...
253
C-484/04 Commission v. United Kingdom [2006]
ECR I-7471 ... 141, 226
C-303/05 Advocaten voor de Wereld VZW v. Leden van de Ministerraad [2007] ECR I-3633 ... 254, 264 C-305/05 Ordre des barreaux francophones and germanophone v. Conseil des Ministres [2007] ECR I-5305 ... 264
C-341/05 Laval un Partneri Ltd. v. Svenska Byggnadsarbetareförbundet [2007] ECR I-11767 ...
253
C-402/05 P and C-415/05 P (Joined Cases) Kadi v.
Council and Commission [2008] ECR I-6351 … 105 C-432/05 Unibet (London) Ltd. v. Justitiekanslern [2007] ECR I-2271 ... 253
C-438/05 International Transport Workers’
Federation v. Viking Line ABP [2007] ECR I-10779 ... 253, 254
C-212/06 Government of the French Community and Walloon Government v. Flemish Government [2008]
ECR I-1683 ... 264
C-239/07 Sabatauskas [2008] ECR I-7523 ... 264 C-73/08 Bressol v.Gouvernement de la Communauté française [2010] ECR, nyr ... 264
C-169/08 Presidente del Consiglio dei Ministri v.
Regione Sardegna [2009] ECR I-10821 ... 264 C-306/09 I.B. [2010] ECR, nyr ... 264
GENERAL COURT (FORMER COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE 1990-2009)
T-489/93 Unifruit Hellas EPE v. Commission [1994]
ECR II-1201 ... 168
GERMANY
FEDERAL CONSTITUTIONAL COURT Absatzfonds, 31 Mai 1990, 2 BvL 12, 13/88, 2 BvR 1436/87: BVerfGE 82, 159 ... 88, 199
Admiral a. D., In re, 15 Dezember 1965, 1 BvR 513/65: BVerfGE 19, 342 ... 64-65
Alcan, 17 Februar 2000, 2 BvR 1210/98: (2000) 35 EuR 257 ... 79
Alfons Lütticke GmbH (“Milk powder”/
“Milchpulver”), 9 Juni 1971, 2 BvR 225/69:
BVerfGE 31, 145 ... 78-81
Application of the Rechtsstaat principle to Land legislatures, 1 Juli 1953, 1 BvL 23/51: BVerfGE 2, 380 ... 64
Äußerungsrecht und Berücksichtigungsrecht, 2 BvR 731/80, 17 Mai 1983: BVerfGE 64, 135 ... 62 Bananas I, 25 Januar 1995, 2 BvR 2689/94 and 2 BvR 52/95: (1995) 48 NJW 950; (1995) 30 EuR 91 ... 95 Banana Market II, 7 June 2000, 2 BvL 1/97:
BVerfGE 102, 147; (2000) 21 HRLJ 251 ... 95-97, 105, 157, 168, 212, 242, 261
Basic Treaty between FRG and GDR (Grundlagenvertrag), 31 Juli 1973, BvF 1/73:
BVerfGE 36, 1 ... 153, 194
Biobronch Cough Sweets, BVerfG 30 Januar 2002, 1 BvR 1542/00: (2002) 55 NJW 1486 ... 88
Communist Party, 17 August 1956, 1 BvB 2/51:
BVerfGE 5, 85 ... 67
Constitutionality of Art. 211 of the Strafgesetzbuch, 21 Juni 1977, 1 BvL 14/76: BVerfGE 45, 187 ... 64 Constitutionality of Art. 232(2) of the Zivilprozeßordnung, 8 Mai 1973, 2 BvL 5, 6, 7, 13/72: BVerfGE 35, 41 ... 64
Constitutional Review of the Single Payment Implementation Act, 1 BvF 4/05, 14 Oktober 2008:
BVerfGE 122, 1; [2010] 2 CMLR 37, 986 ... 145 Data Retention, 2 März 2010, 1 BvR 256/08, 1 BvR 263/08 and 1 BvR 586/08: (2010) 37 EuGRZ 85 ...
108-109, 111
EMRK, 2 BvR 621/72, 14 März 1973: BVerfGE 34, 384 ... 62
Ermächtigung des Krankenkassenverbände für Arztnei- und Hilfsmittelfestbeträge, 17 Dezember 2002, 1 BvL 28, 29 und 30/95: BVerfGE 106, 275 ...
85
Erzwingungshaft zur Abgabe einer eidesstaatlichen Versicherung, 19 Oktober 1982, 1 BvL 34, 55/80:
BVerfGE 61, 126 ... 64-65
Eurocontrol I, 23 Juni 1981, 2 BvR 1107, 1124/77 und 195/79: BVerfGE 58, 1 ... 70, 76, 93, 102, 194, 209 Eurocontrol II, 10 November 1981, 2 BvR 1058/79:
BVerfGE 59, 63 ... 76, 86, 194
European Arrest Warrant, 18 Juli 2005, 2 BvR 2236/04: BVerfGE 113, 273; [2006] 1 CMLR 378 ...
5, 102, 106-108, 169, 225, 228-230, 234
European Community Regulations, 18 Oktober 1967, 1 BvR 248/63 und 216/67: BVerfGE 22, 293 ... 78, 92
European Defence Community, 15 Mai 1952, 1 BvQ 6/52: BVerfGE 1, 281 ... 153
Exclusion of Part-time Employees from Company Pension Scheme, BVerfG 5 August 1998, 1 BvR 264/98: (1999) 52 NJW 46 L; 1998 NZA 1246 ... 87 Fair Trial, 26 März 1987, 2 BvR 589/79: BVerfGE 74, 358 ... 194
Firma E.K., 13 Oktober 1970, 2 BvR 618/68:
BVerfGE 29, 198 … 86, 88
Firma K., In re, BVerfG 28 Juni 1972, 1 BvR 105/63 and 275/68: BVerfGE 33, 247 ... 62
Firma St. AG, In re, 7 November 1972, 1 BvR 338/68: BVerfGE 34, 103 ... 64-65
Gerichtliche Prüfungskontrolle, 17 April 1991, 1 BvR 419/81 and 213/83: BVerfGE 84, 34 ... 106 Germany Treaty, 30 Juli 1952, 1 BvF 1/52: BVerfGE 1, 396 ... 153
Görgülü I, 14 Oktober 2004, 2 BvR 1481/04:
BVerfGE 111, 307 ... 62, 67, 68, 194
H., In re, 21 Juni 1977, 2 BvR 308/77: BVerfGE 45, 363 ... 64-65
GERMANY (cont.)
FEDERAL CONSTITUTIONAL COURT (cont.) hamburgischen Hundesteuergesetzes, Re des, 24 Juli 1957, 1 BvL 23/52: BVerfGE 7, 89 ... 64
Herr B. und Frau T., In re, 7 Oktober 1980, 1 BvL 50, 89/79, 1 BvR 240/79: BVerfGE 55, 72 ... 64-65 Honeywell/Mangold, 6 Juli 2010, 2 BvR 2661/06:
(2010) 37 EuGRZ 497 ... 80, 85, 88-90, 103-105, 115, 173
Internationale Handelsgesellschaft (“Solange I”), 29 Mai 1974, 2 BvL 52/71: BVerfGE 37, 271; [1974] 2 CMLR 540 ... 24, 68, 70-71, 83, 91-92, 109, 112, 204, 209, 212, 216, 228, 240, 249
Karl-Heinz O., In re, 26 Mai 1970, 1 BvR 668, 710/68 and 337/69: BVerfGE 28, 264 ... 64
Kloppenburg, 8 April 1987, 2 BvR 687/85:
BVerfGE 75, 223; [1988] 3 CMLR 1 ... 79, 81-82, 87, 90, 102, 142-143, 149, 202
Konkordat, 21 März 1957, 1 BvR 65/54: BVerfGE 6, 290 ... 69
Kontaksperregesetz, 1 August 1978, 2 BvR 1013, 1019, 1034/77: BVerfGE 49, 24 ... 64-65
landwirtschaftliche Unternehmer, In re, 31 Mai 1988, 1 BvL 22/85: BVerfGE 78, 232 ... 64-65 Lebach, 5 Juni 1973, 1 BvR 536/72: BVerfGE 35, 202 ... 53
Legal Assistance Treaty of 11 September 1970 between the Federal Republic of Germany and Austria, 22 März 1983, 2 BvR 475/78: BVerfGE 63, 343 ... 64
Lisbon, 30 Juni 2009, 2 BvE 2/08 and 5/08, and 2 BvR 1010/08, 1022/08, 1259/08 and 182/09:
BVerfGE 123, 267; [2010] 2 CMLR 712; (2009) 36 EuGRZ 339 ... 6, 9, 15, 17, 19, 24, 26, 36, 58, 71, 74- 76, 79-80, 85, 91, 97-103, 112-115, 144, 154, 156, 162-163, 171-172, 195-196, 219, 221, 223, 228, 230, 234, 237, 239, 241, 242, 257, 258, 261, 263
M GmbH v. Bundesregierung, BVerfG 12 Mai 1989, 2 BvQ 3/89: (1989) 24 EuR 270; [1990] 1 CMLR 570 ... 105-106, 169, 228
Maastricht, 12 Oktober 1993, 2 BvR 2134 und 2159/92: BVerfGE 89, 155; [1994] 1 CMLR 57 ... 8, 26, 46, 73-75, 84-85, 91, 94-95, 97-99, 101-102, 111- 114, 135, 144, 153, 156, 172-173, 195-196, 202, 216, 223, 228-230, 234, 239, 242, 263
Mephisto, 24 Februar 1971, 1 BvR 435/68: BVerfGE 30, 173 ... 66
Nationaldemokratische Partei Deutschlands Verbot, 22 November 2001, 2 BvB 1/01: BVerfGE 104, 218 ... 109-111
National Implementation of EEC Regulations, 5 Juli 1967, 2 BvL 29/63: BVerfGE 22, 134 ... 70, 209 Ostverträge, 7 Juli 1975, 1 BvR 274/72: BVerfGE 40, 141 ... 194
Paul H., In re, 26 Februar 1969, 2 BvL 15, 23/68:
BVerfGE, 25, 269 ... 64
Peter D., In re, 27 März 1973, 2 BvR 311/72:
BVerfGE 35, 1 ... 64-65
Prinzessin Soraya, 1 BvR 112/65, 14 Februar 1973:
BVerfGE 34, 269 ... 124, 125
Reparationsschäden, 1 BvR 631/69 and 24/70, 13 Januar 1976: BVerfGE 41, 126 ... 62
Rinke, 9 Januar 2001, 1 BvR 1036/99: (2001) 54 NJW 1267 ... 88, 96, 242, 261
Sasbach, 8 Juli 1982, 2 BvR 1187/80: BVerfGE 61, 82 ... 106
Socialist Reich Party, 23 Oktober 1952, 1 BvB 1/51:
BVerfGE 2, 1 ... 67
Southwest State Case, 12 Oktober 1951, 1 BvR 201/51: BVerfGE 1, 14 ... 64-65, 124
Steinike & Weinlig (“Vielleicht”), 25 Juli 1979, 2 BvL 6/77: BVerfGE 52, 187 ... 68, 70, 83-84, 89-90, 92, 135, 153, 209
Südschleswigsche Wählerverband, Der, 5 April 1952, 2 BvH 1/52: BVerfGE 1, 208 ... 66
T. Gmbh & Co. KG (Preliminary Reference Concerning the Collective Redundancies Directive), 25 Februar 2010, 1 BvR 230/09: (2010) 37 EuGRZ 247; [2010] 3 CMLR 47 ... 88
Überwachung des Brief-, Post- und Fernmeldeverkehrs, 15 Dezember 1970, 2 BvF 1/69, 2 BvR 629/68 and 308/69: BVerfGE 30, 1 ... 64-65 Vermögenswerte in der Schweiz, 8 Juni 1977, 1 BvL 4/75: BVerfGE 45, 83 ... 69
GERMANY (cont.)
FEDERAL CONSTITUTIONAL COURT (cont.) Volkszählung, 15 Dezember 1983, 1 BvR 209, 269, 362, 420, 440 and 484/83: BVerfGE 65, 1 ... 53 Working Hours Equality, 28 Januar 1992, 1 BvL 16/83 und 10/91: BVerfGE 85, 191 ... 83
Wünsche Handelsgesellschaft (“Solange II”), 22 Oktober 1986, 2 BvR 197/83: BVerfGE 73, 339;
[1987] 3 CMLR 225 ... 24, 68, 77-80, 84, 85, 86, 93- 97, 105, 112, 114, 157, 168, 212, 228, 240, 249-250
FEDERAL FISCAL COURT
Kloppenburg, In re, 25 April 1985, VR 123/84: BFHE 143, 383 ... 77, 81
FEDERAL SUPREME COURT
Brasserie de Pêcheur II, 24 Oktober 1996, III ZR 127/91: BGHZ 134, 30; [1997] 1 CMLR 971 ... 243
HUNGARY
CONSTITUTIONAL COURT
Dec. 9/1990 (IV.25) AB: ABH 1990, 46 ... 145 Dec. 21/1990 (X.4) AB: ABH 1990, 73 ... 125
Dec. 23/1990 (X.31) AB: ABH 1990, 88 ... 124-125, 127-128, 156
Dec. 30/1990 (XII.15) AB: ABH 1990, 128 ... 121 Dec. 31/1990 (XII.18) AB: ABH 1990, 136 ... 123 Dec. 16/1991 (IV.20) AB: ABH 1991, 58 ... 123, 125 Dec. 34/1991 (VI.15) AB: ABH 1991, 170 ... 165
Dec. 48/1991 (IX.26) AB: ABH 1991, 217 ... 123, 125
Dec. 57/1991 (XI.8) AB: ABH 1991, 272 ... 146 Dec. 61/1991 (XI.20) AB: ABH 1992, 280 ... 145
Dec. 64/1991 (XII.17) AB: ABH 1991, 297 ... 125, 156
Dec. 7/1992 (I.30) AB: ABH 1992, 45 ... 165 Dec. 9/1992 (I.30) AB: ABH 1992, 59 ... 123, 187 Dec. 10/1992 (11.25) AB: ABH 1992, 72 ... 123 Dec. 11/1992 (III.5) AB: ABH 1992, 77 ... 123, 125 Dec. 25/1992 (IV.30) AB: ABH 1992, 131 ... 165 Dec. 28/1992 (IV.30) AB: ABH 1992, 155 ... 165 Dec. 30/1992 (V.26) AB: ABH 1992, 167 ... 127, 128
Dec. 36/1992 (VI.10) AB: ABH 1992, 207 ... 123, 125
Dec. 37/1992 (VI.10) AB: ABH 1992, 227 ... 123, 125, 127, 128
Dec. 61/B/1992 AB: ABH 1993, 831 ... 121 Dec. 2/1993 (I.22) AB: ABH 1993, 33 ... 130, 162
Dec. 4/1993 (II.12) AB: ABH 1993, 48 ... 123, 125, 127
Dec. 18/1993 (III.19) AB: ABH 1993, 161 ... 123 Dec. 38/1993 (VI.11) AB: ABH 1993, 256 ... 123
Dec. 53/1993 (X.13) AB: ABH 1993, 323 ... 120
Dec. 64/1993 (XII.2) AB: ABH 1993, 373 ... 123, 128, 156
Dec. 17/1994 (III.29) AB: ABH 1994, 84 ... 123 Dec. 28/1994 (V.20) AB: ABH 1994, 134 ... 125, 152 Dec. 36/1994 (VI.24) AB: ABH 1994, 219 ... 128 Dec. 45/1994 (X.21) AB: ABH 1994, 254 ... 123 Dec. 60/1994 (XII.24) AB: ABH 1994, 342 ... 156 Dec. 14/1995 (III.13) AB: ABH 1995, 82 ... 125 Dec. 28/1995 (V.19) AB: ABH 1995, 138 ... 123 Dec. 1154/B/1995 AB: ABH 2001, 823 ... 161
Dec. 4/1997 (I.22) AB: ABH 1997, 41 ... 121, 134- 136, 140, 152-154, 157, 158, 163-164, 168, 264 Dec. 39/1997 (VII.I) AB: ABH 1997, 263 ... 128 Dec. 52/1997 (X.14) AB: ABH 1997, 331 ... 126, 129
Dec. 30/1998 (VI.25) AB: ABH 1998, 220 ... 126, 130-131, 134, 136, 140, 152, 161-163, 166, 168 Dec. 723/B/1998 AB: ABH 1999, 795 ... 165
Dec. 36/1999 (XI.26) AB: ABH 1999, 320 ... 130, 161
Dec. 5/2001 (II.28) AB: ABH 2001, 86 ... 130, 197, 161
Dec. 10/2001 (IV.12) AB: ABH 2001, 123 ... 165 Dec. 942/B/2001 AB: ABH 2004, 1561 ... 140-141 Dec. 14/2003 (IV.9) AB: ABH 2003, 903 ... 127 Dec. 485/E/2003 AB: ABH 2008, 1963 ... 149-151
Dec. 17/2004 (V.25) AB: ABH 2004, 291 ... 147- 148, 158, 164-168
Dec. 57/2004 (XII.14) AB: ABH 2004, 809 ... 155, 158
Dec. 58/2004 (XII.14) AB: ABH 2004, 822 ... 158 Dec. 744/B/2004 AB: ABH 2005, 1281 ... 168-169
HUNGARY (cont.)
CONSTITUTIONAL COURT (cont.)
Dec. 61/B/2005 AB: ABH 2008, 2201 ... 139, 143- 144, 149-150, 155
Dec. 1053/E/2005 AB: ABH 2006, 1824 ... 137-138, 141, 144-145, 148, 158
Dec. 66/2006 (XI.29) AB: ABH 2006, 725 ... 138- 139
Dec. 72/2006 (XII.15) AB: ABH 2006, 819 ... 137- 138, 141-142, 148-149
Dec. 9/2007 (III.7) AB: ABH 2007, 177 ... 138
Dec. 32/2008 (III.12) AB: ABH 2008, 334 ... 159- 160, 169
Dec. 61/2008 (IV.29) AB: ABH 2008, 546 ... 158
Dec. 142/2010 (VII.14) AB: MK 2010/119 ... 145
Dec. 143/2010 (VII.14) AB: ABK 2010. 7-8, 872 ...
19, 113, 114, 119, 148, 159-163, 169-173, 221, 234, 238, 239, 241
SUPREME COURT
Case number: Kfv.III.37.043/2007/4 ... 142
POLAND
CONSTITUTIONAL TRIBUNAL
Dec. K 1/88, 30 November 1988: OTK ZU 1988, Item 6; OTK 1988, 81 ... 184
Dec. K 3/88, 4 October 1988: OTK ZU 1989, Item 2;
OTK 1989, 23 ... 186
Dec. K 3/89, 26 September 1989: OTK ZU 1989, Item 5 ... 189
Dec. K 7/89, 8 November 1989: OTK ZU 1989, Item 8; OTK 1989, 112 ... 186
Dec. K 1/90, 8 May 1990: OTK ZU 1990, Item 2 ...
183
Dec. K 5/90, 24 July 1990: OTK ZU 1990, Item 4 ...
186
Dec. K 6/90, 12 February 1991: OTK ZU 1991, Item 1 ... 189
Dec. K 7/90, 22 August 1990: OTK ZU 1990, Item 5; OTK 1990, 42 ... 183
Dec. K 11/90, 30 January 1991: OTK ZU 1991, Item 2; OTK 1991, 27 ... 188
Dec. K 1/91, 28 May 1991: OTK ZU 1991, Item 4 ...
188
Dec. K 3/91, 25 February 1992: OTK ZU 1992, Item 1 ... 206
Dec. K 8/91, 7 January 1992: OTK ZU 1992, Item 5;
OTK 1992, I, 76 ... 206
Dec. K 15/91, 29 January 1992: OTK ZU 1992, Item 8; OTK 1992, I, 149 ... 186
Dec. K 1/92, 20 October 1992: OTK ZU 1992, Item 23; OTK 1992, II, 27 ... 188
Dec. K 9/92, 2 March 1993: OTK ZU 1993, Item 6;
OTK 1993, I, 60 ... 183
Dec. K 14/92, 19 October 1993: OTK ZU 1993, Item 35 ... 183, 184
Dec. K 17/92, 29 September 1993: OTK ZU 1993, Item 33; OTK 1993, II, 297 … 207
Dec. K 5/93, 23 November 1993: OTK ZU 1995, Item 39; OTK 1993, II, 376 … 185
Dec. K 11/93, 9 November 1993: OTK ZU 1993, Item 37; OTK 1993, II, 350 ... 185
Dec. K 12/93, 16 May 1995: OTK ZU 1995, Item 14 ... 184
Dec. K 6/94, 21 November 1994: OTK ZU 1994, Item 39 ... 185
Dec. K 11/94, 26 April 1995: OTK ZU 1995, Item 12 ... 189
Dec. K 12/94, 12 June 1995: OTK ZU 1995, Item 2 ... 183
Dec. K 3/95, 7 March 1995: OTK 1995, Part 1, Item 5 ... 218
Dec. K 19/95, 22 November 1995: OTK ZU 1995, Item 35 ... 185
Dec. K 21/96, 24 June 1997: OTK ZU 1997/2, Item 23 ... 206
Dec. K 8/97, 16 December 1997: OTK ZU 1997/5-6, Item 70 ... 189-190
Dec. K 25/97, 22 September 1997: OTK ZU 1997/3- 4, Item 35 ... 185
Dec. K 28/97, 9 June 1998: OTK ZU 1998/4, Item 50 ... 189
Dec. K 3/98, 24 June 1998: OTK ZU 1998/4, Item 52 ... 185, 186, 189
Dec. K 25/98, 23 February 1999: OTK ZU 1999/2, Item 23 ... 185
Dec. K 3/99, 28 April 1999: OTK ZU 1999/4, Item 73 ... 185
Dec. K 8/99, 14 April 1999: OTK ZU 1999/3, Item 41 ... 185
Dec. K 16/99, 17 October 2000: OTK ZU 2000/7, Item 253 ... 185
Dec. K 20/99, 27 June 2000: OTK ZU 2000/5, Item 140 ... 185
Dec. K 21/99, 10 May 2000: OTK ZU 2000/4, Item 109 ... 190
Dec. K 30/99, 11 July 2000: OTK ZU 2000/5, Item 145 ... 186
Dec. K 16/00, 7 November 2000: OTK ZU 2000/7, Item 257 ... 185
POLAND (cont.)
CONSTITUTIONAL TRIBUNAL (cont.)
Dec. K 11/03, 27 May 2003: OTK ZU 2003/5A, Item 43 ... 192, 223
Dec. K 18/04, 11 May 2005: OTK ZU 2005/5A, Item 49 ... 170, 193-196, 200-201, 203-204, 207- 208, 210-217, 220, 228-229, 237-238, 241
Dec. K 32/09, 24 November 2010: OTK ZU 2010/9A, Item 108 ... 25, 171, 196, 217-223, 230, 237, 238, 239, 241
Dec. Kp 3/08, 18 February 2009: OTK ZU 2009/2/A, Item 9 ... 56, 183, 202-205, 206
Dec. P 2/87, 3 March 1987: OTK ZU 1987, Item 2;
OTK 1987, 20 ... 189
Dec. P 1/95, 11 September 1995: OTK ZU 1995, Item 26 ... 186
Dec. P 12/98, 22 March 2000: OTK ZU 2000/2, Item 67 ... 186
Dec. P 4/99, 31 January 2001: OTK ZU 2001/1, Item 5 ... 179, 200
Dec. P 8/00, 4 October 2000: OTK ZU 2000/6, Item 189 ... 186, 200
Dec. P 1/05, 27 April 2005: OTK ZU 2005/4A, Item 42; [2006] 1 CMLR 965 ... 19, 169, 224-230, 234, 238
Dec. P 37/05, 19 December 2006: OTK ZU 2006/11A, Item 177; [2007] 3 CMLR 48, 1323 ...
197-200, 201-202, 203, 208
Dec. S 6/91, 25 September 1991: OTK ZU 1991, Item 34; OTK 1991, 290 ... 183-184
Dec. SK 19/98, 16 March 1999: OTK ZU 1998/3, Item 36 ... 189, 206
Dec. SK 12/99, 10 July 2000: OTK ZU 2000/5, Item 143 ... 206
Dec. SK 18/00, 4 December 2001: OTK ZU 2001/8, Item 256 ... 179
Dec. SK 10/01, 24 October 2001: OTK ZU 2001/7, Item 225 ... 180
Dec. SK 32/01, 13 May 2002: OTK ZU 2002/3/A, Item 31 ... 206
Dec. SK 5/02, 11 June 2002: OTK ZU 2002/4/A, Item 41 ... 206
Dec. SK 7/06, 24 October 2007: OTK ZU 2007/9/A, Item 108 ... 206
Dec. U 1/86, 28 May 1986: OTK ZU 1986, Item 2;
OTK 1986, 32 ... 185, 189
Dec. U 5/86, 5 November 1986: OTK ZU 1986, Item 1; OTK 1986, 7 ... 189
Dec. U 8/90, 15 January 1991: OTK ZU 1991, Item 8; OTK 1991, 134 ... 188
Dec. U 6/92, 19 June 1992: OTK ZU 1992, Item 13;
OTK 1992, I, 196 ... 183, 187-188, 189
Dec. U 10/92, 26 January 1993: OTK ZU 1993, Item 2; OTK 1993, I, 19 ... 189
Dec. U 11/97, 27 November 1997: OTK ZU 1997/5- 6, Item 67 ... 183, 184
Dec. U 22/97, 24 March 1998: OTK ZU 1998/2, Item 16 ... 215
Dec. W 3/93, 2 March 1994: OTK ZU 1994, Item 17; OTK 1994, I, 157 ... 190
Dec. W 2/94, 13 April 1994: OTK ZU 1994, Item 21; OTK 1994, I, 190 ... 187
Dec. W 7/94, 10 May 1994: OTK ZU 1994, Item 23 ... 185
Dec. W 14/94, 25 January 1995: OTK ZU 1995, Item 19 ... 206
Dec. W 2/95, 11 April 1995: OTK ZU 1995, Item 22 ... 185
SUPREME COURT
Supreme Court, 13 December 2005, III KK 318/05:
OSNKW 2006/4, Item 37 ... 227
OTHER JURISDICTIONS
AUSTRIA
CONSTITUTIONAL COURT
VfGH, G17/52, 16 Dezember 1952, VfSlg. 2455 ... 58, 239
VfGH B 2300/95, 11 Dezember 1995, VfSlg. 14390 ... 78, 274
VfGH B 2477/95, 12 Juni 1996, VfSlg. 14499 ... 274 VfGH B 3486/96, 26 Juni 1997, VfSlg. 14889 ... 78, 274
VfGH B 877/96, 26 Juni 1997, VfSlg. 14886 … 140 VfGH G 2/97, 24 Juni 1998, VfSlg. 15215 ... 140, 245
VfGH B 2251/97, 13 Dezember 2001, VfSlg. 16401
… 241
VfGH B 1625/98, 24 Februar 1999, VfSlg. 15427 ...
32
VfGH W I-14/99, 2 März 2001, VfSlg. 16100 … 241 VfGH KR 1-6/00 and 8/00, 12 Dezember 2000, VfSlg. 16050 … 241
VfGH B 614/01 and B 1642/02, 30 September 2003, VfSlg. 16988 ... 78
VfGH, SV 1/10, 12 Juni 2010: (2010) 37 EuGRZ 493 ... 173
BELGIUM
COUR D’ARBITRAGE (1983-2007), COUR CONSTITUTIONNELLE (2007-DATE)
a.s.b.l. Fédération belge des chambres syndicales de médecins (Re), CA 19 février 1997, Arrêt no. 6/97:
Moniteur belge 4456 ... 39
O.V.A.M. v. de Smet, CA 29 janvier 1987, Arrêt no.
32: <www.arbitrage.be> ... 39
Scola europae v. Hermans, CA 3 février 1994, Arrêt no. 12/94: Moniteur belge 6137 ... 39
Van Damme v. Procureur général près la Cour d’appel d’Anvers, CA 26 avril 1994, Arrêt no. 33/94:
Moniteur belge 17034 ... 39
COUNCIL OF EUROPE
EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS Albert and Le Compte, Judgment of 10 February 1983, Series A, No. 58 ... 128
Bakker v. Austria, Decision No. 43454/98, 13 June 2002 … 274
Glasenapp v. Germany, Judgement of 28 August 1986, Series A, No. 104; (1986) 9 EHRR 25 ... 190 Klass v. Germany, Judgement of 6 September 1978, Series A, No. 28; (1979-80) 2 EHRR 214 ... 190 Leander v. Sweden, Judgement of 26 March 1987, Series A, No. 116; (1988) 9 EHRR 433 ... 190 Le Compte, Van Leuven and De Meyere, Judgment of 23 June 1981, Series A, No. 43 ... 128
Lutz John v. Germany, Application No. 15073/03, 13 February 2007 … 274-275
Matheis v. Germany, Decision No. 73711/01, 1 February 2005 … 274
Matthews v. United Kingdom (App. 24833/94), Judgment of 18 February 1999: (1999) 30 EHRR 361 … 110
Obermeier, Judgment of 28 June 1990, Series A, No.
179 ... 128
Pellegrin v. France (App. 28541/95), Judgement of 8 December 1999 ... 190
Rotaru v. Romania (App. 28341/95), Judgement of 4 May 2000 ... 190
Schweighofer and Others v. Austria, Decision Nos. 35673/97, 35674/97, 36082/97 and 37579/97, 24 August 1999 … 274
Tinnelly & Sons Ltd. and McElduff v. United Kingdom (App. 20390/92), Judgement of 10 July 1998; (1998) 27 E.H.R.R. 249 ... 190
Vogt v. Germany (App. 17851/91), Judgement of 26 September 1995; (1996) 21 EHRR 205 ... 190 Wille v. Liechtenstein (App. 28396/95), Judgement of 28 October 1999; (2000) 30 EHRR 558 ... 190
CZECH REPUBLIC
CONSTITUTIONAL COURT
Decision of 26 November 2008: Case No. Pl. ÚS 19/08 … 19, 114, 171, 221, 230, 237-238, 241 Decision of 3 November 2009: Case No. Pl. ÚS 29/09 ... 19, 114, 171, 221, 230, 237-238, 241
DENMARK
SUPREME COURT
Højesteret, 6 April 1998, Case I 361/1997, Carlsen v. Rasmussen [1999] 3 CMLR 854 ... 38, 195, 217
FRANCE
CONSEIL CONSTITUTIONNEL
Abolition of the Death Penalty, Re: Cons. constit. 22 mai 1985, n. 188, Rec. 15 ... 112
Direct Elections to the European Parliament, Re:
Cons. constit. 29 et 30 décembre 1976, n. 71, Rec.
15 ... 112
EU Constitutional Treaty and the French Constitution, Re the: Cons. constit. 19 novembre 2004, n. 505, Rec. 173; [2005] 1 CMLR 750 ... 22, 112, 113, 114
Law authorising the approval of the Schengen Agreement, Re: Cons. constit. 25 juillet 1991, n. 294, Rec. 91 ... 22, 112
Organic Law concerning the Application of Article 88(3) of the French Constitution, Re: Cons. constit.
20 mai 1998, n. 400, Rec. 251 ... 112
Treaty of Amsterdam, Re the: Cons. constit. 31 décembre 1997, n. 394, Rec. 344 ... 112
Treaty of Lisbon, Re the: Cons. constit. 20 décembre 2007, n. 560, Rec. 459 ... 114
Treaty of Luxembourg, Re the : Cons. constit. 19 juin 1970, n. 39, Rec. 15 … 22
Treaty on European Union (Maastricht I), Re the:
Cons. constit. 9 avril 1992, n. 308, Rec. 55 ... 112, 113
FRANCE (cont.)
CONSEIL CONSTITUTIONNEL (cont.)
Treaty on European Union (Maastricht II), Re the:
Cons. constit. 2 septembre 1992, n. 312, Rec. 76 ...
112, 113
CONSEIL D’ETAT
Boisdet: CE 24 septembre 1990, Rec. 251; [1991] 1 CMLR 3 … 81
Ministre de l’Intérieur v. Cohn-Bendit: CE 22 décembre 1978, Rec. 524; [1980] 1 CMLR 543 … 81 Nicolo: CE 20 octobre 1989, Rec. 190; [1990] 1 CMLR 173 … 81
Rothmans International France SA and Philip Morris France SA; and Arizona Tobacco Products GmbH Export KG and Philip Morris France SA: CE 28 février 1992, Rec. 78 et 81; [1993] 1 CMLR 253 … 81 Syndicat Géneral de Fabricants de Semoules de France: CE 1 mars 1968, Rec. 149; [1970] CMLR 395 … 81, 112
ITALY
CONSTITUTIONAL COURT
Corte cost. 24 aprile 2002, n. 135:
<http://www.cortecostituzionale.it> ... 261
Corte cost. 24 ottobre 2002, n. 445:
<http://www.cortecostituzionale.it> ... 261
Corte cost. Ordinanza No. 103/2008:
<http://www.cortecostituzionale.it> ... 261
Costa v. ENEL, Corte cost. 9 marzo 1964, n. 14: Giur.
cost. 1964, 129 … 112
Frontini c. Ministero delle Finanze, Corte cost. 27 dicembre 1973, n. 183: Giur. cost. 1973, 2401; [1974]
2 CMLR 372 ... 24
Provincia autonoma di Bolzano v. Presidente del Consiglio dei ministri: Corte cost. 11 luglio 1989, n.
389: Riv. dir. internaz. 1989, 404 ... 81
SpA Fragd c. Amministrazione delle Finanze dello Stato, Corte cost. 21 aprile 1989, n. 232: Giur. cost.
1989, I, 1001 ... 22, 33, 113
ITALY (cont.)
CONSTITUTIONAL COURT (cont.)
SpA Granital c. Amministrazione delle Finanze:
Corte cost. 5 giugno 1984, n. 170: Giur. cost. 1984, 1098 ... 24, 27, 199
S.p.A. Industria Dolciaria Giampaoli v. Ufficio del Registro di Ancona: Corte cost. 8 aprile 1991, n. 168:
Giur. cost. 1991, 327 ... 23, 81
Zerini: Corte cost. 23 marzo 1994, n. 117: Giur. cost.
1994, 785 ... 23, 81
SPAIN
CONSTITUTIONAL TRIBUNAL
Trib. Const. 14 febrero 1991, STC n. 28/1991: BOE n.
64, 15 marzo 1991; REDI 1991, 172 … 139
Trib. Const. 10 julio 1992, DTC n. 1/1991: BOE n.
177, Suppl. 24 julio 1992 … 23, 113
Trib. Const. 31 mayo 1993, STC n. 180/1993: BOE n. 159, 5 julio 1993 ... 23
Trib. Const. 30 noviembre 2000, STC n. 290/2000:
<http://www.tribunalconstitucional.es> … 261 Trib. Const. 27 febrero 2002, STC n. 53/2002:
<http://www.tribunalconstitucional.es> … 261 Trib. Const. 13 diciembre 2004, DTC n. 1/2004:
BOE 4 enero 2005 ... 113
