• No results found

A Priori truth in the natural world : a non-referentialist response to Benacerraf's dilemma Novák, Z.

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "A Priori truth in the natural world : a non-referentialist response to Benacerraf's dilemma Novák, Z."

Copied!
43
0
0

Bezig met laden.... (Bekijk nu de volledige tekst)

Hele tekst

(1)A Priori truth in the natural world : a non-referentialist response to Benacerraf's dilemma Novák, Z.. Citation Novák, Z. (2010, June 23). A Priori truth in the natural world : a non-referentialist response to Benacerraf's dilemma. Retrieved from https://hdl.handle.net/1887/15729 Version:. Corrected Publisher’s Version. License:. Licence agreement concerning inclusion of doctoral thesis in the Institutional Repository of the University of Leiden. Downloaded from:. https://hdl.handle.net/1887/15729. Note: To cite this publication please use the final published version (if applicable)..

(2) .   . 

(3)        

(4)         

(5)   .       

(6)                               

(7)              

(8) 

(9)   

(10)                     .                           

(11)          .         

(12) 

(13)     

(14)                        !                                        "                      .  

(15)      #                           

(16)                  .  

(17)  

(18)         

(19)                   $                    !                      

(20)        "     %                  .    

(21)     !    

(22)          .

(23) 

(24)    

(25)        !  

(26)                                  

(27)       

(28)      !          ( )   %     %                                                        %   

(29)         

(30)    *%.                 !                 !                       .   

(31)  +  .              

(32)                                     %                     "          %       %    

(33)                   !             ,    %   .  -   . "                   * /  0"                               1       .     

(34)   

(35)      ,   %               2 %   

(36)             

(37)        . 0             "                        .        2   %                                         .   

(38) %         .  &'.  

(39)                !      . !"    #   $

(40)   %   1    

(41)    !           -   .               .   4  5   / + 1        

(42)                !          1     

(43)         .   *1      

(44) 6      .  .  (738) .  (77) .  (77#) 5   (77#) /  (773)  1  (773)          

(45)     . !  

(46)  !           .            1  

(47)           5  "  6      9  6      ! 

(48) 91     

(49)     6    .      

(50)                  

(51)           "      9 5   (77#) *') 1                

(52)   5   "   .   !

(53)     

(54)  

(55)         

(56)           &

(57)                     

(58)  

(59)      .         

(60) %        

(61)             

(62)  %                   

(63)       1   

(64)  5  "        .   6.  9   %     . %        .   %      %           

(65)    (  )    (  )        

(66)                         %      %  

(67)   /

(68)  

(69)    

(70)  :    ;  < /

(71)     .           !         

(72) 

(73)    (           

(74)           ) /

(75)   (*==>) *!# 8!8* :  (77&)  (77&)  ;   /

(76)     (773) 5  "     

(77)  . . &3.

(78) 

(79)    

(80)                     ! 9

(81)      6    

(82)    

(83)             .                  

(84)                  9#                                                    5                      +   .                   1    .             5   "                       ?             

(85)  @             !            

(86)        

(87)   

(88)    6  .         !  95  (77#)*8%   5  " .             

(89)                        

(90)                  !              

(91)  +

(92) % 

(93)  5  +  :               

(94)   .    .                   

(95)     !   

(96)                           1          

(97)                                  1       

(98)             A                       !                          

(99)       

(100) 

(101)       

(102)    .  1      

(103)              

(104)       

(105)   !     !.        !  

(106)         %  !     

(107)    $!                 !                          (        )    .            

(108)                         %     .     !     1        5  "    

(109)     . . "        

(110)  

(111)   5  (77#)*'.  &8.     .        .      .   

(112)   

(113)      . ,   5                   * B          

(114)     &  C     ,  # 5    

(115)                                    ,  & 1            ,                        

(116)     

(117)        .                                >    . $                1               (      .   )    

(118) %     

(119)  .        !                 .  . (73#)**>**'!**3*#=!*# 

(120)     & 

(121)                  

(122)   

(123)                                       !       

(124) C !        . (73#)*#*. (77)#3!#85  (77#)8   .      .   .   

(125)    !      

(126)          

(127) !    !    

(128)                                   .  (77) #=&!#=> A       (  

(129)      )  . . &7.

(130) 

(131)    

(132)  C (#)(&)        ,  > 5    

(133)               /                D    

(134)     (    )  . 

(135)             

(136)   (>) %             

(137)  .  ,  ' 

(138)         3 5     

(139)               %       ,  8  

(140)                             .    7 ?

(141)                                      $            .                (>)   (  

(142)     

(143)               ) C     ()  (*)          (>)       (&)                        .  

(144)          

(145)    !   .              ()    %       

(146)   .      

(147)     E  "

(148)   .  

(149)       %         

(150)       !             6  9    

(151)           

(152)         !  . (77)#*'.  >=.          (                   )               

(153)   1  .        

(154)        C                   

(155)   .          ( (') (3)(8)   (7)   )  (>)

(156)  (&)                        

(157)          .                         E      "  

(158)   (&)               ' $        .      

(159)                          C       

(160)        (') 1        (8)                   

(161)     

(162)              

(163) 

(164)        !    $         .                                  (3)     (7)                         E      " 

(165)     (&)   

(166)     +

(167)     

(168)       .    . "          .               

(169)    (   )       E       "E     "           . "    5     

(170)          . "    .      

(171)             

(172)     

(173)  

(174)     %                               

(175)  . "     .  C     

(176)        

(177)        . "         / (773)*8#!*88. . >.

(178) 

(179)    

(180)                3 /                (  )

(181)                                                         A 

(182)        . "                    

(183)            !   

(184)                             %      .       

(185)          %                   

(186)          %                          %     .                              %        .               C                                 

(187)                        

(188)  8 1              .     

(189)             

(190)    75       

(191)        

(192)        "                             

(193)            

(194)      

(195)                   

(196)             

(197)   A . "  

(198)                                                                  . . (77)&!8 . (77)#**. . (77)#3.  >*.   1  

(199) 

(200)                        

(201)            

(202)                           1   

(203)                             

(204)                                   

(205)             

(206)                    .                                                         %                     !           

(207)                       

(208)                    +

(209)                  . "              

(210)      !         

(211)    %

(212)         

(213)   A      %                                              

(214)                            

(215)            5               

(216)               .                 @           

(217)            

(218)                                

(219)           

(220)          

(221)           

(222)                    A . "    

(223)   !                    

(224) 

(225)    

(226)                 

(227)  

(228) 

(229)  (   . . >#.

(230) 

(231)    

(232)    !                 )%   

(233) . " !  .                            "   

(234)           .            

(235)                    

(236)      (     

(237)                    

(238)         )1   

(239)  !                     

(240)  ,     

(241)    

(242)                              .             = . "                                     

(243)                         $ !                                &             

(244)    .        *         . "          

(245)    !              .                      . "  !               !                            . %  . 

(246)      !              

(247)                                          

(248) 1   

(249)          !    . "         %                               .            

(250)                    

(251)        C       

(252)                       . " 

(253)    !       .  >&.                    (      )     %         !     

(254)    . " !                                 "             .  

(255)  

(256)         

(257)              % 

(258)     

(259)             . "  !           !          

(260)                  %                                                        %         

(261)          .   . "                                  

(262)     .         5 .    

(263)  

(264)                

(265)     

(266)         -        

(267)  

(268)        .              

(269)          

(270)    ( ) 

(271)       . 

(272)       

(273)            6  9

(274) 

(275)   %

(276)           

(277)                 /       

(278)   

(279)  

(280)   . "          

(281)                                      . 

(282)     6!  9    1         .  .            

(283)    . "     .    %

(284)                   . . >>.

(285) 

(286)    

(287)   

(288)   

(289)   

(290)  (   )    E     "E     "

(291)                    . "    5   

(292)                         

(293)  . "      

(294)        

(295)          

(296)        

(297)        .  

(298)                       

(299)                              (            

(300)                )%

(301)   

(302)     

(303)                                                          (                   )                        %

(304)               .     

(305)                

(306)    

(307)                         

(308)   

(309)  .             

(310)   

(311)                             ,  (>F) 5    

(312)         

(313)        

(314)                      *     .   E  "   E   " (

(315)        )          C (7'#)              

(316) 

(317)         

(318)       %             

(319)   .  >'.   +

(320)  . "           (>F)

(321)              E      "           .       $                                  (3) 

(322)    (7)1      

(323)   

(324)   ,  (3F) 5     

(325)        

(326)        

(327)                        (7F)?

(328)      

(329)      

(330)                                    .         .    . "                  .  (>F)        . (3F)(7F)   $   %            

(331)           

(332)          

(333)        

(334)                 1            

(335)  . "            .      (3F)     (7F) -     

(336) 

(337)     .      . 

(338)  

(339)  

(340) !

(341) %              (>)

(342)  (>F)      .              .  (>F)           (>)C      . 5 (*===)*3=!*3>(1   G $      ). . >3.

(343) 

(344)    

(345)        !    . " .  !  # 1       

(346)  

(347)             (3F)  (7F)

(348)                           

(349)  

(350)  .    

(351)  %                  !          .                    C  .                       .  

(352)              

(353)   

(354) .        

(355)                                !          C 

(356)                 

(357)      .     C   

(358)                          "      

(359)                              "     $ 

(360)              A               .                   %. " !  

(361)                                   

(362) 

(363)                   $ . " !  

(364)                          .       

(365)         1    .   

(366)                                                  & C            .  C           .       

(367)   /  (773)*3'!*8#   -.

(368)  (78) #** 1               - "             - (*==*).  >8.                 

(369)                   (              

(370)    . )               

(371)        > .                         !             C          .    

(372)    

(373)                "        ' /         .              

(374)  ,                           .           

(375)                

(376)                5     .                                          2 

(377)                        

(378)      3  1     .    ,  H            

(379)                          .       

(380)                   . 5  (77*) . (73#)*8. (77)#&!#&*  . (73#)**= . . >7.

(381) 

(382)    

(383)    ,   IHJ  

(384) 

(385)         

(386)  #

(387)  8.  +  

(388)     . "                                      

(389)            1                                             

(390)     . "    

(391)         

(392)           .     %           

(393)    .              .                    

(394)     

(395)  %            

(396) 

(397)               

(398)         5                   

(399)                                                   7 1      

(400) ! . %. "  

(401)                  %       

(402)       

(403)           1    

(404)      . . (73#)**  1                    #     

(405) 

(406)          "   !      % .     

(407)                                   .   $ .            

(408)          !         1       .          ,                                                                     .   

(409)          .  '=.                                   .    .              

(410) ,  %     

(411)                         

(412)   .                       5               

(413) 

(414)           

(415)                                  

(416)     

(417) 

(418) 

(419)  

(420) 

(421)       

(422)               

(423)   

(424)   

(425)  

(426)               .      

(427) 

(428)    

(429)  

(430)     

(431)      

(432)    .  

(433) 

(434)   

(435)   

(436)           *=  $         .    

(437)        

(438)                 

(439)                                                    

(440)                   5                              E4    K >      7    "                  

(441)  

(442) 

(443)           

(444)          

(445)             . . (77)#&*. . '.

(446) 

(447)    

(448)                   L . "           

(449)      C      

(450)          .  

(451)          !         

(452)                    .           .       .               

(453)           

(454)               

(455)      * .  

(456)      

(457)         

(458) $         

(459) 

(460)  

(461)   

(462)            

(463)  (    

(464) )          ** +

(465)      . "         

(466)    

(467)              $  

(468)         

(469)            C 

(470)                

(471)               .     

(472)         B  

(473)           

(474)         

(475)  $                                      

(476)                   A       .        

(477)          

(478)           

(479)     

(480) 

(481)     C . " .             

(482)                           

(483)   1  

(484) 

(485)   

(486) 

(487) 

(488)         

(489)        

(490)                   . . (73#)**& . (73#)**&!**>.  '*.               

(491)                 

(492)       %       

(493)     . "     (7F)    ,      

(494)         

(495)        

(496)                                       *# A          . 

(497)                                                           . 

(498)           !        1       

(499)  

(500)  

(501) . "  ,    

(502)                        

(503)                                         !                    5      . "              .           %                     .     . "  

(504)          .  

(505)                        .  (3F)(7F)   .            !                 %                  L 5             . " !    L    .          .    (7F)               (3F)  $                           $.       

(506)                                   .   (7F)    .   (3F) 

(507) . . '#.

(508) 

(509)    

(510)  5  %           

(511)   . "  !        

(512)        

(513)   

(514)    

(515)   1     

(516)          

(517)                                        

(518)    %        !                                                                                    

(519)     

(520)                !  %   

(521)       .                            -   

(522)       

(523)   

(524)                                            

(525)                        %      

(526)                 E4    K  >      7    "

(527)          

(528)        

(529)                         

(530)       

(531)                    E+   K >   7   "1           "     . "           

(532)     A                        

(533)  

(534)                          A            

(535)        .         . 

(536)        

(537)   

(538)  

(539)       .  '&.   

(540)                      0       

(541)   .                                                        1        !                            

(542)             

(543)      !  .   

(544)   +   .                      

(545)          .           

(546)  

(547)  

(548)          

(549)         ,        

(550)                         !             

(551)                                              *& A  

(552)      

(553)   

(554)           

(555)         

(556) 

(557)     

(558)                                     .    

(559)             4         E4  .  K  >      7    " 5                                                                        

(560)                 .      E  K "  E  "                          .   %   

(561)              

(562)  . "  

Referenties

GERELATEERDE DOCUMENTEN

Licence agreement concerning inclusion of doctoral thesis in the Institutional Repository of the University of Leiden.. Note: To cite this publication please use the final

Licence agreement concerning inclusion of doctoral thesis in the Institutional Repository of the University of Leiden.. Note: To cite this publication please use the final

Licence agreement concerning inclusion of doctoral thesis in the Institutional Repository of the University of Leiden.. Note: To cite this publication please use the final

Licence agreement concerning inclusion of doctoral thesis in the Institutional Repository of the University of Leiden.. Note: To cite this publication please use the final

Licence agreement concerning inclusion of doctoral thesis in the Institutional Repository of the University of Leiden.. Note: To cite this publication please use the final

Licence agreement concerning inclusion of doctoral thesis in the Institutional Repository of the University of Leiden.. Note: To cite this publication please use the final

Licence agreement concerning inclusion of doctoral thesis in the Institutional Repository of the University of Leiden.. Note: To cite this publication please use the final

Licence agreement concerning inclusion of doctoral thesis in the Institutional Repository of the University of Leiden.. Note: To cite this publication please use the final