Henk, Ingrid en de rechtsstaat

Tilburg University

Henk, Ingrid en de rechtsstaat

Hirsch Ballin, E.M.H.

Published in: Populisme

Publication date: 2011

Document Version

Publisher's PDF, also known as Version of record Link to publication in Tilburg University Research Portal

Citation for published version (APA):

Hirsch Ballin, E. M. H. (2011). Henk, Ingrid en de rechtsstaat. In Populisme: Verrijking of bedreiging van de democratie? (blz. 13-19). Koninklijke Nederlandse Akademie van Wetenschappen.

https://knaw.nl/nl/actueel/agenda/populisme-verrijking-of-bedreiging-voor-democratie

General rights

Copyright and moral rights for the publications made accessible in the public portal are retained by the authors and/or other copyright owners and it is a condition of accessing publications that users recognise and abide by the legal requirements associated with these rights. • Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the public portal for the purpose of private study or research. • You may not further distribute the material or use it for any profit-making activity or commercial gain

• You may freely distribute the URL identifying the publication in the public portal

Take down policy

 "    

88 

U*2'/ *./2F$)/(/$$/(%)/+*/$$ $%)/I* H(/ $$HI!!  S!F(/! T.*/2(/'%/'$(H++!*EH$ !F$ S!I*+(T J8U+ S!I*+(T$$/ ' "H)*FJ'2HI!!/.(F$S)/ F*2T/(.2$$$ S!T!*.FIDJ +/$E*"J*$(S125! T" F*(/$$*+.*N/!F$$F* (/ F(%)+/H'!( *.!IDJ" HDF**H  **)2*+(/*E$N2*+(/"/*/ S$ TI* !2 8<J2$$2/(/2 F$.*.'(/(%)HI!!+$$2/ ' D2I$$*+JDJ%)/$/! S$ T 2"+$$**2/! (//'/(F$ %)/((/$$/I$$$$)/!( $/J  !D2D22H(%)+8 Populisme in de polder 6($ *+*($E/F$!")*.*.'(/(%)HI!!J%)F)*' /*/  '/!$!(.'/F$ +*%$/(%)%)/((/$$/8>$I 2$$)  $$!( 0 $ (.*/2HI!!$( -33"2'I%*(/$/ $/  F$ J HI!!JE%/2$//FI)/I** S.*.'(/T$(!'J$$+H(%)*'I/8 S0$$ 2J'(/T"$ '(W/> (0dXF$:B+$$/BC::"SF 2  /(+**(" J(.*.'(+!'J$$+87$$D+*/**2)/E)HH/(/ *.I$$D$%)/H$/$%)/(/$$/8<$/)HHIT"I$$HD)D $FID(/$$JD (/++!+/e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d*H>DH!!$$/*.  F(%)D!(F*+F$.*.'(+"+/$(F/2.'/ $/S '! J$$+)*+*! F*2TJ%)H ! $%)/ ** /*ES!F$$D2$ T8:_{52J**22+*E+} !+(%)$..D22+2.*.'(/(%)HI!!)/!H'2F$$$ S!T !*.FIDJ /+*E+/$E*"I$/*'I*E$EIDJ!F$ S/(T" /N%$/F$

/!(/$ (+/FIDJ!$$!$( 2+2"FD$ !)*' ! /*.J%)/F$(//'/( HI D2 )$ F$ /!(/$ (JD8<+$/ F*+I$$ J2+2HD  F(.*.'(/(%)HI!!'/) F  $$ID(H$$JD"F(%)/8 7*/.*.'(+ $+$$I* H(%)*'I $(/L..*/2(/*+!J*$( $ 1/-*!$+F$]/!$!(.'/F$)/X<P"F$(/!(/ :YY;"J!/ $$*F * + $/S%)/((/$$/ +*%$/*$E(%) D2+/2$$FH* TJD" $/ SW +*%$/(%).$/D"  H!(F$)/(/$$/(H(/$$F$$ /"Mf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g  /H*.*. %)/()/HDJ* **2+*!D2/)$ )$F!F$ !* %)/" E' $+/%)/F$ +("I$$*F**2  +*%$/(%)!!/+ I/!F /FDD22$H(%)228> 2!) " "$!+JD 2+2 

/EI** HD (//'/*I$$H*!!F$ %)/((/$$/8

<++!$/I*  '($( S$ T!J//*/)/0 $ (F*2 !2 g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{1/ DE/*.J  +*/(F$*H)$!"*J2) "F$$2} **2$%'8TU*2ID(/=D F *. $/S+/!H'2F$*!'$% !$($/( FH'/ $%)/(/$ (ID2" **!$$(!!* 2!"**2J   *F +/ +'/%'/'"+'/?/(%)+$$/(%)$..D(*/(/$$8<J/$/* H$!'+/ "J  *F (. /J%)$(*F2*F ($+F!'/8T3 Vriend en vijand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

<%*%/F (2I$N%$/F$!*.R ++!$/" S/(TR(H*F  J(2$//*.$((!F$)/F ?FD$ (%)+$ .*/2"*+ $/J*.IJD2 .'/F(%)/F$$ F*+F$.*$( .*/2E/JDF$/8<$$ * (%) /2!*.(!IDJH(/D !J%)F$.*/2 (%'((+/.*/2 S/!(/$ TF$I+H.$$ *.F$//!M '(/(%)/()/H)*/*/H.$$  !*.OH(/D /8=('/ D2) F$)/.*/2 (%*'(HDF**H$$/'/"I$/ I* /!H*.! $$*. +*!D2) F$F$ !F$*.F$//!86F$  *!'22!HDF(%)D(F$.*/2F$'/FD$ H ()/.$/( $/J!/*+  .*/2(/$ .'/8! J$%)/!* I2'*. (.%N2.'/!$$  FD) F$+!('/!" (/D /! S/(T" F)*' !/*/ H'/I 8 De vrijheid van meningsuiting

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anything goes / ! 81/*.FD'/I((!F$$!'+/!H$( :Y 'I( +*%$/(%) $$ (+/)//)$(.*.'$$ $!'+S $/ $(+*/2'J!!T!$ %$( " +$$**2*/ $$F$(F$ D2) $$ )*' 8

*EIF  !8</  M*E */OJ%)F**HD$$F$*.%)/(*. 6]M)/ 3 $!F$A(($H*O8

De instituties als vijand

=2")/( *F$*..*(/*.*/2HI!!"2/2/F*.H('/ )$ !F$ J// H(/'' (8<!$/FF$()*2F$F.*.'(/(%) HI!!2/%)/F )/F/*'IH$!D2(//'/(F$ ($+F! I* /+$!+J* +D "HDF**H  **%)/(/ /N%+/ $(FD$ H(%)*'I /( $I **.*/(!/H DFF$ (//'/(  F* (/ I* )'/$2/FF'*!$%)/(.%N2.*/2*V/$/("I$/**2 ! /F**)/U.H$$7(/'/$$ HD'/(/2F** K*!$(%*(//'/* (/$$/()**E 8#'(/ HDJ* .*(/F$ J(/!+$$2/ $/J (/D F$  .*.'(/I* !+$$2//*/*HD%/F$IF*!*!gF*/'(/H'!(I*  J*WutbürgerZ8_{1HD+*/I* H $%)/ $/ J*/I22! )$ (!I2/ **}

JI$2/IE+* !)  F  !!F$J'2(//'/(8

<%/$(//'/(F$)/(/$$/(H(/)HH$/$$2)/%*%/( $(F$I$$ F$%)/F$$ !) (* $//8<$$/*H)**/'/$$  **2 )$ )$F!F$ !(/ !(8=*$(d*H>DH!*$!(*.+2/,_{I* /)/}

E'%/*F$ J(//'/(IIF$)'%*(//'/*.*(/ .*/2(E !/*2281/!/F** )$  $/D'(/(//'/(+/S!J$!T F** ($+F!$( !)R**2  (% /!H$%)/!*.RFH  I$$ 2'*FH! MK*!"%)/(0$/*$*+H' (+$HDF**H O.*.'(/(%) (%*'( (% /I* !H$%)/8

De buitenwereld als vijand

Democratie zonder uitsluiting 52I($*.  ' !F$.*/2)/(%)+$F$F FD$ 8<I/(%)$..D2 (%'(( $$*F(FH* +/%*/*F(*FF+$$ '/(.$$2F$6(/? >*E!$!9i%2Ei  S<E)/%)"(j2'$(/@/$$/H/F*3*$'((/J'!" (H(/%)/ !$$/2$8<$((/ $(!*((>$!(" $("'+ `)/I"!!$! (/8P(E)/%)@/$$/2$(/('H(/)"I(%) `)/"  (9k!!Ij)/"F*)"$'( +*$(%)@'H(/$J (J '  1*+*!/j/ W((%)$E/"!'/8P (/(2$+ ( d!''!(2jE/%)/F*(%)$'(" $()((/"+/ 7// (d%)/(JI$!( ' $'/*/$/FWH*/("J'!$$/F('%)"*)(`)/%)2/ $'EJ'!H' R$'E(j2'$(/6HRD*/$/j/($(.'%) J'k%2J'E$"$'( + 2*E((*9k!2!)$'(!Ek)/)$/T8[ <J.$(($!.'H%$/ **(.*2D2:Y_[F(%)")E/F$$2$$ ! !!F/*/ ! $%)/ $/ +* %)/((/$$/F*!(9i%2Ei $N)$2D2J*' JDF$FH !+/%)(/D2 VH*81/( F$$!*E /./$/ .$'(H("!!F %*/^/F$)/(%'$(!(.*%(I$$*F9i%2Ei (%)DE/84 1$H+$(+/(/$ .'/ $//$N)$2D2(F$^/ V!/+$/F$  +*%$/(%)%)/((/$$/85JD! $%)/!$!+.%/  F$  +*%$/  %)/(/$/D2) $(IDJI$$*.JD)$$HF*! ) '/*E/g %)/((/$$/( '(! H.2!")D(/M *!F$(*++!) D2O/!I%)/F$  +*%$/" +$$I* / **!2+2/ $/!%)/(J* !* %)/"J*$(2H2*/ $ FH$ )**.'//I28<J/I*.F$//!(/$$+ (%)./!*F 2$$ $)/D2/8< +*%$/(%)%)/((/$$/2$JD!/+$//$E I!"+$$F / !/+$/ $!+.$/%.$/F$JDH'!(R $2JD.*%((F$F*+! +$$/(%)$..D2+*/F$/RHD +*%$/(%)JNH(/'' $/*. IDJF$ %)/((/$$/( !%)/8+dlF$/ /J*($+ $/)/ +*%$/(%).*%(S $(m! 9$ TM(/O" $( 9k!(d%)/((/$$/(+/$ FH /T8Y_{62$! +*%$/JDJ* } %)/((/$$/"*+!2 8 <$$+(**2!J!  $/ +*%$//2$E'%/*I$JD!.$$  !$$/+/'/('/!F$H.$$ !*.'/ HF*2!F$F*I$$ !.$/%.$/8U*2 $(.*/2(/*+!+ )  HF*2!/*/J'2F*+F$'/('/! J$HI!"( /*F!H$$+/ H!(F$)/ +*%$/(%)?%)/((/$/D2 (/$$/(H(/86 +*%$/(%)%)/((/$$/(F** "*E)D(/8

[_{Recht, Staat, Freiheit8`$2E'/$+7$@')2$+.3$!BCC_".8::B}

4_{=+dl"1*+*!/j/* <+*2$/$(m! (9$ n='<(2'((* m3*$'((/J'! (}

d%)/((/$$/(nH9i%2Ei ' 1$H+$("MenschenRechtsMagazin1E/BhBCC4".8BC,?B:Y8

Slot