&RPPDQGDQWVZRQLQJ
Foto: Yke Reilink, 2013
9LOOD%URQEHHNFLUFD &RPPDQGDQWVZRQLQJDQQR
$QRQLHPVFKLOGHULM+LVWRULVFK0XVHXP$UQKHP
%XLWHQVLQGH9HOXZH]RRP
,QGH]XLGRRVWHOLMNH9HOXZH]RRP]LMQYULMJURWHKRRJWHYHUVFKLOOHQHQYHHOEURQQHQHQEHNHQPHW
VFKRRQVWURPHQGZDWHU'LWPDDNWHGHVWUHHNDDQWUHNNHOLMNDOVYHVWLJLQJVSODDWV9DQDIGHGH HHXZOHJGHQDGHOHQULMNHEXUJHUVHUWLHQWDOOHQEXLWHQSODDWVHQDDQ=HPDDNWHQGDQNEDDUJHEUXLN
YDQGHXLW]LFKWHQRYHUGH5LMQHQ,-VVHO+HWVWURPHQGHZDWHUZDVGHEDVLVYRRUIRQWHLQHQ
ZDWHUYDOOHQHQYLMYHUVWHUYHUIUDDLLQJYDQKXQEXLWHQV,QGHGHRQWZLNNHOGHGHKRRIGVWDG$UQKHP
]LFKVWHUNDOVYHVWLJLQJVSODDWVYRRUZHOJHVWHOGHQZDDURQGHUYHHOPHQVHQXLW1HGHUODQGV,QGLs=LM
OLHWHQKXQYLOOD¶VERXZHQDDQGHXLWYDOVZHJHQYDQGHVWDG=RRQWZLNNHOGHGH9HOSHUZHJ]LFKLQGH
GHHHXZWRWGHGXXUVWHZHJLQ$UQKHP+HWODQGJRHG%URQEHHNLVHHQYURHJYRRUEHHOGYDQGH
EXLWHQYHUEOLMYHQGLHWRHQDDQGH9HOSHUZHJZHUGHQDDQJHOHJG,QHQNHOHGHFHQQLDRQWZLNNHOGHKHW
]LFKYDQHHQYULMHHQYRXGLJEXLWHQJRHGWRWHHQNRQLQNOLMNHOXVWKRI
'HJURQGOHJJHU
'HVWLFKWHUYDQKHWODQGJRHG%URQEHHNLV+HUPHQ6WHLMJHUZDOW+LM]LHWLQKHW
GDJOLFKWDOV]RRQYDQHHQODQGERXZHUGLHURQGXLW'XLWVODQGQDDU1HGHUODQGNRPWHQ]LFKDOV
ODQGERXZHUKHHIWJHYHVWLJGLQ'H6WHHJ2YHU]LMQMHXJGLVQLHWVEHNHQG=HNHULVZHOGDWKLMLQ
LQ$PVWHUGDPWURXZWHQGDDUORJHPHQWKRXGHULVLQGHµ1LHXZH6WDGVKHUEHUJ¶DDQKHW,-+LM
SDFKWGHKHUEHUJYDQGHJHPHHQWH$PVWHUGDP1D]HVMDDURYHUOLMGW]LMQYURXZ+HWSDDUKHHIW
JHHQNLQGHUHQHQ+HUPHQEHVOXLWWHUXJWHNHUHQQDDU]LMQJHERRUWHJURQGLQGH9HOXZH]RRP
'H1LHXZH6WDGVKHUEHUJWH$PVWHUGDPFD
)RWR-)+XON%HHOGEDQN$PVWHUGDP
8LWHHQSXEOLHNHYHLOLQJNRRSW+HUPHQLQYDQ$GULDQD:LMERUJKKHWODQGJRHGµ/DQJH:DWHU¶
'LWODQGJRHGYDQRQJHYHHUKDOLJWGHHOVLQ$UQKHPGHHOVLQ9HOSHQRPYDWRRNGHUXLPKD
YDQKHWODWHUH%URQEHHN2Sµ/DQJHZDWHU¶VWDDWHHQKXLVPHWGH]HOIGHQDDP+HWODQGJRHGNRVW
+HUPHQELMQDJXOGHQHQLVQLHWEH]ZDDUGPHWHHQK\SRWKHHN.HQQHOLMNKHHIW+HUPHQ
NDSLWDDO+RHKLMGLWYHUZRUYHQKHHIWLVHHQLQWULJHUHQGHYUDDJZDQWYDQ]LMQRYHUOHGHQYURXZ
NZDPKHWQLHW,QHONJHYDOVWDDWKLMQXWHERHNDOV³UHQWHQLHU´HQ´]RQGHUEHURHS´
GDWODWHUµ%URQEHHN¶]DOKHWHQ'HVSUHQJEURQQHQHQZDWHUSDUWLMHQYDQKHWKXLGLJH%URQEHHN
GDWHUHQGXVDOXLW2SGHNDGDVWUDOHNDDUWXLWLVWH]LHQKRH+HUPHQGHYLMYHUVKHHIW
ODWHQDDQOHJJHQJHYRHGGRRUGHEURQQHQRS]LMQJURQG'HWHJHQZRRUGLJHZDWHUSDUWLMHQKHEEHQ
JURWHQGHHOVQRJGH]HOIGHYRUP
,QEHVOXLW+HUPHQ]LMQJURQGWHQ]XLGHQYDQGH9HOSHUZHJPHWGDDURSKHWKXLVµ/DQJH
:DWHU¶DIWHVWRWHQ+LMYHUNRRSW]HDDQGHKHHU9LWULQJD+HWQRJRQEHERXZGHWHUUHLQPHWGH
EURQQHQHQYLMYHUVWHQQRRUGHQYDQGH9HOSHUZHJEOLMIW]LMQHLJHQGRPHQQRHPWKLMµ1LHXZH/DQJH
:DWHU¶+HWLVDDQQHPHOLMNGDWGHEURQHQKHWXLW]LFKWRYHUGHODJHUJHOHJHQYHOGHQULFKWLQJ,-VVHO
GHUHGHQHQ]LMQZDDURP6WHLMJHUZDOWJHwQWHUHVVHHUGLVLQMXLVWGLWKRJHUJHOHJHQWHUUHLQ+LMODDW
GDDUNRUWQDELMGHYLMYHUVGDQRRNHHQKXLVERXZHQ'DDUJDDWKLMPHW]LMQWZHHGHYURXZ
0DJGDOHQD(VNHQVZRQHQHQZRUGHQ]LMQ]HYHQNLQGHUHQJHERUHQ=HYHUDQGHUHQGHQDDPYDQKXQ
EXLWHQJRHGµ1LHXZH/DQJH:DWHU¶VSRHGLJLQKHWWRHSDVVHOLMNHµ%URQEHHN¶9DQKHWKXLV]LMQJHHQ
DIEHHOGLQJHQEHNHQG
+HUEHUJ%URQEHHN"
,QGLYHUVHVWXNNHQZRUGWEHZHHUGGDW%URQEHHNRRLWHHQKHUEHUJLVJHZHHVW(HQ
RQGHU]RHNUDSSRUWYDQGH5LMNV*HERXZHQ'LHQVWXLWZHHUOHJWGLWPHWDUJXPHQWHQ0DDUYDQ
7RQGHU0HHUGHHGRQGHU]RHNHQKHHIWWRFKDDQZLM]LQJHQYRRUGHKHWEHVWDDQYDQHHQKHUEHUJ
7HQHHUVWHODDW6WHLMJHUZDOWELMGHJHERRUWHDDQJLIWHYDQ]LMQ]RRQ1LFRODDVLQDOV]LMQEHURHS
DDQWHNHQHQ³KHUEHUJLHURS%URQEHHNHWH$UQKHP´9HUGHUEOLMNWXLWGHLQYHQWDULVDWLHGLHLQ
QD]LMQGRRGLVYHUULFKWGDWHUWZHHRSHQVWDDQGHUHNHQLQJHQ]LMQYDQWRWDDOJXOGHQYRRU
JHOHYHUGHZLMQJHHQKRHYHHOKHLGGUDQNYRRUHHQJHZRRQKXLVKRXGHQ8LWGHLQYHQWDULVDWLHEOLMNW
RRNGDWRS]ROGHUWLHQWDOOHQVWRHOHQVWRYHQWDIHOWMHVHQYRHWEDQNMHVVWDDQ,QGHNDPHU]LMQRQGHU
PHHUGR]LMQHQNRSHQVFKRWHOVDDQZH]LJZLMQJOD]HQELHUJOD]HQHQYLHUVHUYLH]HQ6DNVLVFK
DDUGHZHUN9RRUGHDDQZH]LJKHLGYDQDOGDWPHXELODLUHQVHUYLHVJRHGKHHIW9DQGHU0HHUHHQ
K\SRWKHVH+HUPHQVEURHU%HUQDUGXVKHHIWLQGLHWLMGLQ$UQKHPHHQKHUEHUJDDQGH
5R]HQGDDOVHZHJ$OV%HUPDUGXVLQNLQGHUORRVRYHUOLMGWKHHIW+HUPHQGLHQVLQERHGHO
PHHJHQRPHQQDDU%URQEHHNHQQHHPWKLMGDDU]LMQRXGHEHURHSZHHURS2PGDWKLMDO]LMQNDSLWDDO
LQ%URQEHHNKHHIWEHOHJGHQHUHHQK\SRWKHFDLUHVFKXOGYDQJXOGHQLVRQWVWDDQNDQKLMPHGH
RPGH]HUHGHQEHVORWHQKHEEHQWHUXJWHJDDQLQ]LMQRXGHYDNHQRS%URQEHHNHHQKHUEHUJWH
RSHQHQ1D]LMQGRRGLQVOXLW]LMQZHGXZHGH]DDNHQ]HWGHLQERHGHORS]ROGHU
:HGXZH0DJGDOHQDYHUNRRSW
,QRYHUOLMGW+HUPHQRS%URQEHHN2PGHEHODQJHQYDQKDDUNLQGHUHQYHLOLJWHVWHOOHQODDW
]LMQZHGXZHQRJLQKHW]HOIGHMDDUQRWDULHHOHHQEHVFKULMYLQJYDQDOOHEH]LWWLQJHQRSPDNHQ+LHUXLW
ZHWHQZHGDWKHWKXLVRS%URQEHHNRSGDWPRPHQWEHVWDDWXLWHHQKXLVPHWNHOGHUNHXNHQGHHO
]ROGHUHQWHQPLQVWHWZHHNDPHUV+HWLVDDQQHPHOLMNGDWGHODWHUHYLOOD%URQEHHNRSGHIXQGHULQJ
YDQGLWHHUVWHKXLVLVJHERXZGZDDUELMGHGHHO]LFKDFKWHUHHQEUHHGYRRUKXLVEHYRQG$QWRQ
0DUNXVVFKULMIWGDW³KHWKXLV%URQEHHNYRRUGDWKHWLQGRRUGHQKHHU9HUNRXWHUHQWRWHHQH
YLOODZDVKHUERXZGHHQEHVFKHLGHQZLWKXLVMHZDVGDWDDQJHQDDPWXVVFKHQKHWKRRJHJHERRPWH
JHOHJHQZDV´+HWWHUUHLQRPYDWLQEHKDOYHKHWKXLVRRNKHLGHKDNKRXWWXLQHHQZDWHUSDUWLM
PHWHLODQGMHVERXZODQGHQRSJDDQGHERPHQ
+HUPHQVZHGXZH0DJGDOHQDKHUWURXZWLQPHWGHKRXWKDQGHODDU0DWWKHXVYDQ6RHVW(HQ
DNWHXLWWRRQWDDQGDWKHWHFKWSDDURS%URQEHHNYHUDQGHULQJHQKHHIWDDQJHEUDFKWRPKHW
KXLVDOVEXLWHQYHUEOLMIWHYROWRRLHQ0DJGDOHQDYHUNRRSWKHWKHOHODQGJRHGLQDDQ3LHUUH
&RQVWDQW%HUJpHHQ5RWWHUGDPVIDEULNDQWGLHHHQMDDUHHUGHUQDDU$UQKHPZDVYHUKXLVGHQGDDU
GHZLMQD]LMQIDEULHNµ'H(HQGUDFKW¶ZDVEHJRQQHQ=RZHOXLWGHNDGDVWUDOHNDDUWDOVXLWGH
EHVFKULMYLQJLQGHYHUNRRSDNWHEOLMNWGDWKHWODQGJRHGLQGLHWLMGQLHWDOOHHQLVJHULFKWRS
DDQJHQDDPZRQHQPDDURRNRSSURGXFWLH+HWUHFKWRPERPHQWHSODQWHQODQJVGH9HOSHUZHJ
YHUHQLJWHYHQHHQVKHWQXWWLJHPHWKHWDDQJHQDPHKRXWLVHHQLQNRPVWHQEURQ
+HWDUWLNHOQRHPW6WHLMJHUZDOWLQYHUEDQGPHW³HHQHQQLHXZHQDDQOHJDDQKHW]RRJHQDDPGH/DQJH
:DWHU>«@ZDDUDDQJHHQHNRVWHQRQW]LHQKHHIWRPYDQGH>«@RQWVSULQJHQGHEURQQHQSDUWLMWHWUHNNHQYRRU
:DWHU:HUNHQGLHWXVVFKHQGHDDQJHOHJGHGUHYHQHQRQGHUVFKHLGHSODQWVRHQHHQH]HHUJRHGHZHUNLQJGRHQ
]RRGDWGRRUGH]HNRVWEDUHRQGHUQHPLQJYDQGHQHLJHQDDU]LMQGHGH+HHU+6WLMJHUZDOG>«@GHQIUDDLMHQ
RPWUHNGH]HUVWDGHHQHQQLHXZHDDQZLQVWKHHIWEHNRPHQ´
2'HYHUNRRSDNWHJHHIWYDQ%URQEHHNGHYROJHQGHEHVFKULMYLQJ³+HW%XLWHQJRHG%URQEHHNJHQDDPG>«@
EHVWDDQGHXLW+HHUHQKXLVPHWDFKWHUKXLVZDDULQSDDUGHQHQEHHVWHQVWDOOLQJZLMGHUVWXLQERRPJDDUGWZHH
VWXNNHQERXZODQGZDDUYDQppQDDQGHQ6WUDDWZHJERVFKHQZDQGHOLQJHQPHWEURQQHQHQZDWHUZHUNHQRSGH
SODDWV]HOYHRQWVSUXLWHQGH>«@PHWGHRSJDDQGHERRPHQHQKHWUHJWYDQEHSRWLQJODQJVGHQ6WUDDWZHJ>«@´
.RORQLDDONDSLWDDO
%HUJpYHUNRRSW%URQEHHNQDWZHHMDDUDDQ&DUHO-RKDQ9HUNRXWHUHQ9HUNRXWHUHQ ZDVYDQWRWHQPHWLQ1HGHUODQGV,QGLsGHGHUGHSUHVLGHQWYDQGH)DFWRULMYDQGH
1HGHUODQGVH+DQGHOPDDWVFKDSSLMLQ%DWDYLD+LMNHHUWLQXLWGH2RVWWHUXJPHWHHQYHUPRJHQ
YDQJXOGHQ,QMXOLYDQGDWMDDUNRRSWKLM%URQEHHNYDQ%HUJpYRRUJXOGHQ'DWLV
JXOGHQPLQGHUGDQ%HUJpHULQ]HOIYRRUKHHIWEHWDDOGWHUZLMOGH
JURQGRSSHUYODNWHHYHQJURRWLVJHEOHYHQ%HUJpKDGYHUPRHGHOLMNJHOGSUREOHPHQ
%URQEHHNPLGGHQMDUHQ &DUHO-RKDQ9HUNRXWHUHQ
/LWKR&$6SLQ8LWJHYHULM)%XIID 6FKLOGHULM&.UXVHPDQ
FROOHFWLH'H%UXLMQ.RSV
0HWGHNRPVWYDQ9HUNRXWHUHQEUHHNWHHQEHODQJULMNHIDVHDDQ+LMODDWKHWKXLVLQ KHUERXZHQZDDUVFKLMQOLMNRSGHIXQGDPHQWHQYDQKHWRXGHKXLVHQERXZWHHQNRHWVKXLVPHW
VWDOOHQ'HYURHJVWHRQVEHNHQGHDIEHHOGLQJYDQGLWQLHXZHKXLVLVHHQVWHHQGUXNXLWKHWPLGGHQ
GHUMDUHQ'DDUXLWEOLMNWGDWZHLQJHHQJHYDOPHHUWHPDNHQKHEEHQPHW³HHQEHVFKHLGHQ
ZLWKXLVMH´]RDOV0DUNXVKHWEHVFKUHHI:H]LHQHHQYLOODLQGHGDQPRGHUQHQHRFODVVLFLVWLVFKH
VWLMOZDDULQPHQJHEUXLNPDDNWYDQVWUDNNHVWLMONHQPHUNHQYDQGH*ULHNVHHQ5RPHLQVH
DUFKLWHFWXXU+HWEORNYRUPLJHSDQGPHWHHQSODWWHJURQGYDQ[PHWHUGULHYHUGLHSLQJHQHQ
HHQVWUHQJV\PPHWULVFKHJHYHORSERXZLVQXQRJJRHGWHKHUNHQQHQKHWNRPWRYHUHHQPHWKHW
KRJHPLGGHQGHHOYDQGHKXLGLJHYLOOD+HWKXLVKHHIWHHQIODXZKHOOHQG]LQNHQGDNGDWGRRUHHQ
ODJHEDOXVWUDGHPHWVLHUYD]HQDDQKHW]LFKWRQWWURNNHQZRUGW+HWEDNVWHQHQKXLVUXVWRSHHQ
JULMVQDWXXUVWHQHQSOLQWHQLVDOWLMGEHSOHLVWHUGJHZHHVWGLWURHSWGHJHZHQVWHDVVRFLDWLHVPHWGH
PDUPHUHQJHERXZHQXLWGH.ODVVLHNH2XGKHLGRS
9HUNRXWHUHQYHUNRRSWKHW³%XLWHQJRHG%URQEHHN´LQHQQHHPWGDDUQD]HOI]LMQLQWUHNRS
YHUVFKLOOHQGHDGUHVVHQLQ$UQKHP'HSULMVYDQ%URQEHHNLVELMGH]HWUDQVDFWLHYHUGULHYRXGLJGKHW
JDDWYDQGHKDQGYRRUJXOGHQ2SJURQGYDQKHWGLWHQRUPHSULMVYHUVFKLONXQMHDDQQHPHQ
GDW9HUNRXWHUHQYHHOLQ%URQEHHNKHHIWJHwQYHVWHHUG'HNRSHULV-DQ-DFREYDQ%UDDP9DQ
%UDDPLVJHERUHQLQ%DWDYLDEH]DWODQGHULMHQLQ%XLWHQ]RUJHQEHNOHHGGHKRJH
IXQFWLHVLQGHNRORQLH0HW]LMQHFKWJHQRWH&DWKDULQD%DXGGRFKWHUYDQGH0LQLVWHUYDQ.RORQLsQ
NRPWKLMLQQDDU1HGHUODQGHQYHVWLJW]LFKRS%URQEHHN'DDUEUHQJWKLMYHUDQGHULQJHQRSKHW
ODQGJRHGDDQ+LMODDWGHRSULMODDQYHUOHJJHQQDDUGHKRHNYDQKHWWHUUHLQHQLQVWDOOHHUWELMKHWKXLV
HHQIRQWHLQGLHYLDHHQORGHQEXLVZRUGWJHYRHGGRRUZDWHUXLWHHQKRJHUJHOHJHQYLMYHU'HYLOOD
KHHIWLQYDQ%UDDPVWLMGHHQZLWWHEHSOHLVWHULQJPHWJURHQHOXLNHQHQURGHNR]LMQHQ,QPDDUW
YHUNRRSW9DQ%UDDP%URQEHHNDDQNRQLQJ:LOOHP,,,YRRUJXOGHQ
.RQLQNOLMNJRHG
2QGHU]RHNVUDSSRUW5LMNVJHERXZHQGLHQVW
4%URQEHHNZRUGWLQGHNRRSDNWHYDQRPVFKUHYHQDOV³+HW%XLWHQJRHG%URQEHHNJHQDDPGEHVWDDQGHXLW
+HHUHQKXLVHQYHUGHUHJHERXZHQWXLQHQWRWZDQGHOLQJDDQJHOHJGWHUUHLQERXZHQZHLODQG
DNNHUPDDOVERVFKHQZDWHUDDQHHQJHKHHO>«@HQZDWDDQJDDWGHJHERXZHQHQYHUGHUHDDQOHJGRRUGH+HHU
9HUNRRSHULVGDDUJHVWHOG>«@´,QKHWODDWVWHGHHOYDQGH]H]LQVWDDWGXVGDW%HUJpLQDOOHHQGHJURQG
KHHIWDDQJHNRFKWHQGDWKHW9HUNRXWHUHQLVGLHGHJHERXZHQHQWXLQDDQOHJKHHIWJHUHDOLVHHUG
WRWGHYROOHKRRJWH$DQGHYRRU]LMGHYHUVFKLMQWHHQULMNYHUVLHUGHJLHWLM]HUHQJDOHULMLQQHRJRWLVFKH
VWLMODINRPVWLJYDQGH'HYHQWHULM]HUJLHWHULM1HULQJ1|JHO'H]HVWLMOLVKLHUKHUNHQEDDUDDQGH
NODYHUEODGDFKWLJHYRUPHQHQGHYHUWLFDOHRUQDPHQWHQ
2RNKHWLQWHULHXUZRUGWDDQJHSDVW8LWGHUHNHQLQJHQYDQGLYHUVHOHYHUDQFLHUVLVHHQ
IUDJPHQWDULVFKEHHOGRSWHPDNHQ'HZDQGHQZRUGHQEHNOHHGPHWSDSLHUHQOLQQHQ'HEHVWDDQGH
VWXFSODIRQGVZRUGHQJHUHSDUHHUGHQQLHXZHDDQJHEUDFKW+HWSODIRQGLQGHGDQV]DDOZRUGWZLWPHW
UR]HJHVFKLOGHUG(ULVYHUGHUVSUDNHYDQYHUILQGHNOHXUHQ%HUOLMQVEODXZOLFKWEODXZJHHO3DULMV
JURHQRNHU9HUPLOMRHQURRGEUXLQ]ZDUWJULMVHQZLW2RNZRUGHQEODGJRXGHQURRGEODXZ
JURHQHQµPDWJHEORHPG¶JODVWRHJHSDVW9HUGHUZRUGWKHWLQWHULHXUEHNOHHGPHWPDUPHUHQ
QDWXXUVWHHQHQHUZRUGHQYLMIVFKRRUVWHHQPDQWHOVLQ/RXLV;9VWLMOLQJHERXZG9HUPHOGHQVZDDUG
]LMQGHVSUHHNEXL]HQWXVVHQGHEHJDQHJURQGHQGHHHUVWHYHUGLHSLQJ0HQJDIHHQVLJQDDODDQGH
DQGHUHYHUGLHSLQJGRRURSIOXLWMHVLQGHEXLVPRQGHQWHEOD]HQ+HWV\VWHHPLVDDQJHOHJGGRRU9DQ
GH:DOO &RXLW$UQKHPHQGHHOVQRJDDQZH]LJLQGHRRVWHOLMNHJDQJ
'HYHUERXZLQJYDQGHYLOODGXXUWYDQWRWHQNRVWPHHUGDQKHWKHOHODQGJRHG
JXOGHQ1DGHYHUERXZLQJZRUGWKHWKXLVRPVFKUHYHQDOVHHQ³NDSLWDDOKHUHQKXLVYRRU]LHQYDQ
DOOHPRJHOLMNHJHPDNNHQNRVWEDUHEDGLQULJWLQJPHWPDUPHUHQEDGHQ]´+HWDGUHVERHNXLWGLHWLMG
YHUPHOGWµ=0GH.RQLQJRS+RRJVWGHV]HOIV3DOHLV%URQEHHNDDQGHQ9HOSHUVWHHQZHJ¶6LQGV
GH]HYHUERXZLQJLVDDQGHEXLWHQ]LMGHYDQGHYLOODZHLQLJPHHUYHUDQGHUG$OOHHQGHVHUUHDDQGH
ZHVW]LMGHLVHHQDDQERXZYDQNRUWQD
2RNKHWWHUUHLQRQGHUJDDWLQGH]HMDUHQYHUDQGHULQJ'HLQJDQJZDVNRUWHUYRRUDOYHUSODDWVW
QDDUGH]XLGZHVWKRHNHQGDDUZRUGWQXKHWEDNVWHQHQZDFKWKXLVJHERXZGGDWHUQRJVWHHGVVWDDW
(UNRPWEXLWHQYHUOLFKWLQJPHWWZLQWLJJLHWLM]HUHQODQWDDUQV2RNGHEHSODQWLQJZRUGWKHU]LHQHQ
DDQJHYXOGJH]LHQ]LMQOLJJLQJSDOQDDVWGHFRPPDQGDQWVZRQLQJLVKHWDDQQHPHOLMNGDWGHGLNNH
WDPPHNDVWDQMHXLWGH]HWLMGGDWHHUW'HRPKHLQGHZHLGHQYRRUKHWKXLVZRUGHQRSHQJD]RQVPHW
EORHPSHUNHQ
*LHWLM]HUHQYHUDQGDLQQHRJRWLVFKHVWLMOGHWDLO%URQEHHNFLUFD
)RWR/LWKR*HOGHUV$UFKLHI
:DDURPZLOGHNRQLQJ:LOOHP%URQEHHNHLJHQOLMNNRSHQ"+LMEH]LWDOYHHOJURQGURQG$SHOGRRUQHQ
KHHIWEHODQJVWHOOLQJYRRUODQGERXZHQYHHWHHOW$DQNRRSYDQHHQODQGJRHGEXLWHQ$UQKHPSDVWLQ
GH]HLQWHUHVVHVIHHU(HUGHUJHQRHPGH0DUNXVVFKUHHIRRLWGDWGHNRQLQJ%URQEHHN³QDDUPHQ
DOJHPHHQYHU]HNHUGH´NRFKWYRRU]LMQPRHGHU$QQD3DXORZQD'H]HYHURQGHUVWHOOLQJLVVLQGVGLHQ
GRRUYHOHQJHFLWHHUGPDDUQRRLWPHWEURQQHQRQGHUERXZG)HLWLVGDWGHNRQLQJLQPRHGHUQLHWRS
%URQEHHNKHHIWJHZRRQG2RNGHNRQLQJ]HOIPDDNWZHLQLJJHEUXLNYDQ]LMQODQGJRHG+LMKHHIWHU
DDQWRRQEDDUVOHFKWVHQNHOHPDOHQNRUWHWLMGJHORJHHUG+LMVFKHQNWKHWODQGJRHGLQDDQGH
6WDDWRQGHUGHYRRUZDDUGHGDWGLHHUHHQPLOLWDLUWHKXLVYRRULQYDOLGHHQJHSHQVLRQHHUGHVROGDWHQ
HQRQGHURIILFLHUHQYDQKHW.RQLQNOLMN1HGHUODQGV,QGLVFK/HJHU.1,/ODDWERXZHQ
'HRYHUGUDFKWDDQGH6WDDWYLQGWLQSODDWVLQFOXVLHIHHQGHHOYDQGHPHXEHOVYDQGH
NRQLQJZDDURQGHUHQLJHGLH]LMQJHVFKRQNHQGRRUGH-DSDQVHNHL]HU$QGHUHPHXEHOVYLHU
VFKRRUVWHHQPDQWHOVHQGHSDUNHWYORHUHQQHHPWGHNRQLQJPHH
$PEWVZRQLQJ
6LQGVGHYHVWLJLQJYDQKHWPLOLWDLUWHKXLVRSKHWODQGJRHGGLHQWKHWYRRUVWHGHHOYDQGHYLOODDOV
DPEWVZRQLQJYDQGHFRPPDQGDQW+HWDFKWHUVWHGHHOZHUGYRRUKHHQEHZRRQGGRRUGH
RQGHUFRPPDQGDQWHQGHGRNWHUPDDUIXQFWLRQHHUWQXDOVNDQWRRUUXLPWHYRRUKHWSHUVRQHHOYDQ
%URQEHHN+HWLQWHULHXULVQDKHWYHUWUHNYDQGHNRQLQJYHUERXZG=RLVGHJURRWVWH]DDOGH
GDQV]DDORSGHEHJDQHJURQGYHUGZHQHQWHQJXQVWHYDQHHQJDQJHQWZHHNOHLQHUHYHUWUHNNHQHQ
]LMQYRRUHQDFKWHUKXLVYDQHONDDUJHVFKHLGHQ$OOHHQGULHNDPHUVRSGHEHQHGHQYHUGLHSLQJGH
5RGHGH%ODXZHHQGH5RRNRI+HUHQNDPHUKHEEHQKXQDQWLHNHNDUDNWHUEHKRXGHQ=RKHHIWGH
%ODXZH.DPHULQGHZHVWHOLMNHYOHXJHOXLWHQRRLWPX]LHN]DDOHHQKRXWHQSODIRQGGDWLV
EHVFKLOGHUGPHWWURPSHO¶RHLOYRRUVWHOOLQJYDQHHQGRRUEORHPHQRPUDQNWHEODXZHKHPHO$OV
JHYROJYDQZDWHUVFKDGHLVGH]HOXFKWRQJHZLOGHQLJV]LQVEHZRONWJHUDDNW'HGULHNDPHUVZRUGHQ
QXJHEUXLNWYRRUUHSUHVHQWDWLHYHRQWYDQJVWHQYDQGHFRPPDQGDQW
5HFRQVWUXFWLHLQGHOLQJEHOOHHWDJHFRPPDQGDQWVZRQLQJYRRU 7HNHQLQJ5*'QDDURXGHUHRSPHWLQJHQ
%ODXZHNDPHU 'HWDLOYDQEHVFKLOGHUGSODIRQGLQGH%ODXZHNDPHU
)RWR )RWR
%URQQHQHQOLWHUDWXXU
- &-YDQGHU3HHW *6WHHQPH\HU'H5LMNVERXZPHHVWHUV7ZHHHHXZHQDUFKLWHFWXXUYDQGH
5LMNVJHERXZHQGLHQVW5RWWHUGDP
- %HYDDUW:%URQEHHNWHPSRGRHORHGHUOLHIGDGLJKHLG'HQ+DDJHGUXN
-
5LMNVJHERXZHQGLHQVW%XUHDX5LMNVERXZPHHVWHU>'%0+HUPDQVHQ-.DPSKXLV@%RXZKLVWRULVFKHGRFXPHQWDWLHHQZDDUGHEHSDOLQJ.RQLQNOLMN7HKXLVYRRU2XG0LOLWDLUHQ
³%URQEHHN´'HQ+DDJ
EULHIZLVVHOLQJWXVVHQ(/XFDVHQPU&//X]DF
- 'DJERHN$OH[DQGHU9HUKXHOO-DQ%HUYRWHVS
- KWWSZZZKLVWRULHYDQGDDOKXL]HQQOLQGH[SKS
- 1HGHUODQGVSDWULFLDDW