EXTERNAL
PRESSURES for
EXCELLENCE &
RELEVANCE
UNIVERSITIES as
STRATEGIC
ORGANISATIONS
‘MISSION
STRETCH’ &
GOVERNANCE
PARADOX
To w h at ex te n t can str ate gic u n ive rs ity go ve rn an ce fac ilitate an au th en ti c imp le me n tati o n o f th e re gio n al mi ss io n in th e s itu ati o n o f ‘mis sio n o ve rl o ad ’?s.kopelyan@utwente.nl
Sofya Kopelyan
Centre for Higher Education Policy Studies, University of Twente, the Netherlands
Universities creating, validating, and regulating
capabilities for regional engagement at the levels
of strategic management and academic staff
The project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research & innovation programme under Marie Sklodowska-Curie grant agreement No. 722295
Qualita
t
ive case studies of 3 universities Interviews, observations, documents Data structure (Gioia et al., 2013)
Strategy text (Fenton & Langley, 2011)
The regional mission of innovative universities:
Between strategic governance and institutional cultures
NEO-INSTITUTIONALISM:
c) historic
mission narratives
d) regional mission
narratives
Frølich et al., 2018; Maassen, 2017 INSTRUMENTALISM:a) strategic
agency
b) administrative
expansion
Baltaru & Soysal, 2018; Frølich et al., 2018 short-term instrumental solution “lost in translation” into academic profession uncoordinated academic engagement activities exist alongside prevalent models of strategic collaborations cooperative “umbrella” body decoupling regional engagement from academic units contemporary strategic, scholastic & stakeholder narratives can make regional missions non-actionable
Participation
of institutional
navigators in
strategic
decision-making
Regional
network &
community
building that
does not turn
back on
history
Empowerment
of capable
actors in
connection
with
engagement
identities
Narratives
that frame
regional
engagement
as prestigious
& valuable
To what extent can
strategic university
governance
facilitate an
authentic
implementation of
the regional mission
in the situation of
‘mission overload’
?!
INTERNAL BOUNDARY SPANNERS BOUNDARY SPANNING ORGANISATION EXTERNAL BOUNDARY SPANNERS reactive, symbolic & disconnected superstructure imposed onindividual values & practices universities as strategic organisations have not sought to accommodate major identity types of engaged individuals