Evaluating infrastructure project planning and implementation: A study using qualitative comparative analysis

Hele tekst

(1)University of Groningen. Evaluating infrastructure project planning and implementation Verweij, Stefan; Gerrits, Lasse Published in: SAGE Research Methods Cases DOI: 10.4135/978152646997 IMPORTANT NOTE: You are advised to consult the publisher's version (publisher's PDF) if you wish to cite from it. Please check the document version below.. Document Version Other version. Publication date: 2019 Link to publication in University of Groningen/UMCG research database. Citation for published version (APA): Verweij, S., & Gerrits, L. (2019). Evaluating infrastructure project planning and implementation: A study using qualitative comparative analysis. In SAGE Research Methods Cases (Vol. 2, pp. 1-16). SAGE Publishing. https://doi.org/10.4135/978152646997. Copyright Other than for strictly personal use, it is not permitted to download or to forward/distribute the text or part of it without the consent of the author(s) and/or copyright holder(s), unless the work is under an open content license (like Creative Commons). Take-down policy If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim.. Downloaded from the University of Groningen/UMCG research database (Pure): http://www.rug.nl/research/portal. For technical reasons the number of authors shown on this cover page is limited to 10 maximum.. Download date: 28-06-2021.

(2) 8$/7$6,1*1)4$5647&674(42-(&6 /$11,1*

(3) 1'03/(0(16$6,21

(4) 67'; 5,1*7$/,6$6,8( 203$4$6,8(

(5) 1$/;5,5. BAGE<5HGBEF*G894A-8EJ8<=#4FF8$8EE<GF 'H54G8

(6) 668FF4G8!4AH4EL

(7) 6478@<6#8I8?7I4A687,A78E:E47H4G8 'H5?<F;<A:B@C4AL*'H5?<64G<BAF#G7 <GL#BA7BA &A?<A8 *%

(8) & ;GGC 7K7B<BE:

(9) Q

(10) *'H5?<64G<BAF#G7??)<:;GF)8F8EI87 +;<F';4F588A:8A8E4G879EB@*)8F84E6;$8G;B7F4F8F.

(11)

(12) .

(13) (5($4&+(6+2'5$5(5$46.

(14) *'H5?<64G<BAF#G7. 746+(4($',1* (44,65!(49(,-

(15) $!!2(10%+*+"+),(!4%*"./0.101.!,.+&!0/#1% !0+-1(%00%2! +),.0%2!*(5/%/;8?G8A;4@,"7J4E7?:4E. ,+27: $*,1 7F

(16). +*"%#1.0%+*( +),.0%2! )!0$+ / 1(%00%2! +),.0%2! *(5/%/* .!(0! 0!$*%-1!/+;BHF4A7&4>F*. &+1(,'(4 "$*(0$11

(17)

(18) !00$!+.!0% )!0$+ / "+. 0$! /+%( /%!*!/ #1% ! 0+ -1(%00%2!+),.0%2!*(5/%/4@5E<7:8,"4@5E<7:8,A<I8EF<GL'E8FF. "(%(5274&(5 *88 JJJ6B@C4FFFBE: 9BE 4A 8KG8AF<I8 BI8EI<8J B9 ( 5BB>F 4EG<6?8F FB9GJ4E8 GE4<A<A: 6BHEF8F 4A7 6BA98E8A68F. ()(4(1&(5 $57462 # 3((4

(19)

(20) *GEH6GHE<A: G;8 64?<5E4G<BA B9 DH4?<G4G<I8 74G4 4F F8GF 9BE DH4?<G4G<I8 6B@C4E4G<I84A4?LF<F( %!( !0$+ /

(21) S . 2(,-(

(22). *(5/%/%*-1(%00%2!.!/!.$#BA7BAA:?4A7* 755&+(4!(49(,-!$1'(1 4,1.'(/(1%25 2790$1!$1'(1 42(.

(23) !0 +.#*%/!.!* 2* .1%)0!(%&'! '3(%0!%0 *6%$0!* 1%0 1%)0! 2++. ! %2%!. .#*%6%*# /,0%( -1(%05 */%#$0/".+)++)"+.0$!%2!.EBA<A:8A+;8%8G;8E?4A7F)<=>FHA<I8EF<G8<GEBA<A:8A. ( /2&.!,5

(24) 77E8FF<A:G;86;4??8A:8FE8?4G87GBGE4AF9BE@<A:DH4?<G4G<I8<AGBDH4AG<G4G<I8 74G4 <A DH4?<G4G<I8 6B@C4E4G<I8 4A4?LF<F +1.*( +" %4! !0$+ / !/!.$ 7I4A68 BA?<A8 CH5?<64G<BA 7B<;GGC 7K7B<BE: . . '(/(1%25 /,-1

(25). 'EB=86G I8EFHF CEB68FF @4A4:8@8AG <A CH5?<6CE<I4G8 C4EGA8EF;<C )8?4G<BA58GJ88A@4A4:8@8AGFGL?84A7BHG6B@8F*0!.*0%+*(1(%*#!)!*0+1.*(

(26) S . /;8%-(4* 47<(/,75 26+(1*$66(4 "

(27). !#,.+&!0/ * .%/' * *0+)5 +" )%0%+* 4@5E<7:8,"4@5E<7:8,A<I8EF<GL'E8FF. (44,65!(49(,-

(28) E<G<64?E84?<F@4F4@8G49E4@8JBE>9BEHA78EFG4A7<A:G;8E8?4G<BAF;<CF 58GJ88A6B@C?8K<GL4A7DH4?<G4G<I86B@C4E4G<I84A4?LF<F+1.*(+".%0%(!(%/)

(29) S

(30) . (44,65 !(49(,-

(31) (H4?<G4G<I86B@C4E4G<I84A4?LF<F4F4@8G;B79BE8I4?H4G<A:6B@C?8K '4:8 B9 . I4?H4G<A: A9E4FGEH6GHE8'EB=86G'?4AA<A:A7 @C?8@8AG4G<BA*GH7L ,F<A:(H4?<G4G<I8B@C4E4G<I8A4?LF<F.

(32)

(33) .

(34) (5($4&+(6+2'5$5(5$46.

(35) *'H5?<64G<BAF#G7. 64F8FABI8EI<8JB9?<G8E4GHE84A74FG8CJ<F8:H<78J<G;8@C<E<64?4CC?<64G<BA!%0/$.%"0"7. 2(10%+* S

(36)

(37) . (44,65!(49(,-

(38) $!!2(10%+*+"+),(!4%*"./0.101.!,.+&!0/#1% !0+-1(%00%2! +),.0%2!*(5/%/;8?G8A;4@,"7J4E7?:4E. $66;1 !(44,65 !(49(,-

(39) (H4?<G4G<I8 6B@C4E4G<I8 4A4?LF<F $88E 58;BE8A7 5<= 78 >J4?<G4G<8I874A78>J4AG<G4G<8I858A478E<A:3(+*

(40)

(41) S . $66;1 ! 2/(18(/'

(42) ()$1,

(43) (H4?<G4G<I8 6B@C4E4G<I8 4A4?LF<F 4F 4A 8I4?H4G<BA GBB? #8FFBAF9EB@4A4CC?<64G<BA<A78I8?BC@8AG6BBC8E4G<BA )!.%*+1.*(+" 2(10%+*7I4A68BA?<A8 CH5?<64G<BA7B<;GGC 7K7B<BE:

(44)

(45) . $*,1 $! +),.0%2! )!0$+ +2%*# !5+* -1(%00%2! * -1*0%00%2! /0.0!#%!/ 8E>8?8L,A<I8EF<GLB94?<9BEA<4'E8FF. $*,1

(46). 1665/!0/+%(/%!*!;<64:B #+;8,A<I8EF<GLB9;<64:B'E8FF $*,1

(47). ! !/%#*%*# /+%( %*-1%.5 1665 /!0/ * !5+* ;<64:B # +;8 ,A<I8EF<GL B9 ;<64:B'E8FF. ,+27:

(48). E<7:<A: G;8 :4C 58GJ88A G;8 DH4?<G4G<I8 4A7 DH4AG<G4G<I8 JBE?7F E8GEBFC86G<I8 4A7 CEBFC86G<I8I<8JBADH4?<G4G<I86B@C4E4G<I84A4?LF<F %!( !0$+ / S . ,+27:

(49) (H4?<G4G<I86B@C4E4G<I84A4?LF<F(4AAB

(50) )89E4@<A:G;8B@C4E4G<I8$8G;B7WF F8@<A4?FG4G8@8AGF3%//+(%0%(%!*!!2%!3

(51) S

(52) . ,+27: 2%(

(53). +;8 64F8 9BE DH4?<G4G<I8 6B@C4E4G<I8 4A4?LF<F ( 77<A: ?8I8E4:8 9BE G;<6> 6EBFF64F8 6B@C4E<FBA A ;41( $*,1 7F $!

(54) $* ++' +" /!/! )!0$+ /CC

(55)

(56)

(57) S

(58)

(59) #BA7BAA:?4A7*. ,+27: $*,1 7F

(60). +*"%#1.0%+*( +),.0%2! )!0$+ / 1(%00%2! +),.0%2! *(5/%/* .!(0! 0!$*%-1!/+;BHF4A7&4>F*. 2+/),1* &+1(,'(4

(61) @CEBI<A: E8F84E6; BA A868FF4EL 6BA7<G<BAF BE@4?<M87 64F8 F8?86G<BA9BECEB68FFGE46<A:49G8E(+(%0%(!/!.$1.0!.(5

(62)

(63) S

(64) . &+1(,'(4 2+/),1*

(65) 4F8FGH7<8FA8FG87<A9HMMLF8G(BAFH99<6<8A6LBE@4?<M<A: 64F8F8?86G<BA4A764HF4?<A98E8A68+%+(+#%(!0$+ /!/!.$

(66) S. &+1(,'(4 "$*(0$11

(67). *G4A74E7FB9:BB7CE46G<68<ADH4?<G4G<I86B@C4E4G<I84A4?LF<F (4A79HMMLF8GF+),.0%2!+%+(+#5 S . &+1(,'(4 "$*(0$11

(68)

(69) !00$!+.!0% )!0$+ / "+. 0$! /+%( /%!*!/ #1% ! 0+ '4:8 B9 . I4?H4G<A: A9E4FGEH6GHE8'EB=86G'?4AA<A:A7 @C?8@8AG4G<BA*GH7L ,F<A:(H4?<G4G<I8B@C4E4G<I8A4?LF<F.

(70)

(71) .

(72) (5($4&+(6+2'5$5(5$46.

(73) *'H5?<64G<BAF#G7. -1(%00%2!+),.0%2!*(5/%/4@5E<7:8,"4@5E<7:8,A<I8EF<GL'E8FF. !(49(,-

(74) *8GG;8BE8G<6@8G;B7F9BEG;8FB6<4?F6<8A68F:H<78GBDH4?<G4G<I86B@C4E4G<I84A4?LF<F *0!.*0%+*(+1.*(+"+%(!/!.$!0$+ +(+#5 S . !(49(,-

(75) 4 6;<8I<A: F4G<F946G<BA J;8A <@C?8@8AG<A: ''' GE4AFCBEG4G<BA <A9E4FGEH6GHE8 CEB=86GF DH4?<G4G<I8 6B@C4E4G<I8 4A4?LF<F B9 G;8 ;<:;J4L $ CEB=86G *0!.*0%+*( +1.*( +" .+&!0 *#!)!*0 S

(76). . !(49(,-

(77) 5 'EB7H6<A: F4G<F946GBEL BHG6B@8F <A G;8 <@C?8@8AG4G<BA C;4F8 B9 ''' <A9E4FGEH6GHE8 CEB=86GF 9HMML F8G DH4?<G4G<I8 6B@C4E4G<I8 4A4?LF<F B9

(78) EB47 6BAFGEH6G<BAF <A G;8 %8G;8E?4A7F *0!.*0%+*(+1.*(+".+&!0*#!)!*0 S . !(49(,-

(79) 77E8FF<A:G;88I4?H4G<BA<@C?8@8AG4G<BA:4C<A<A9E4FGEH6GHE8@8:4CEB=86GE8F84E6;J<G; DH4?<G4G<I86B@C4E4G<I84A4?LF<F A(+621(1 2/;

(80) 3$4,&,27F+%+!+*+)%!2(10%+* +")!#,.+&!0/ !(%*#3%0$1*!.0%*0%!/CC

(81)

(82) S

(83) 5<A:7BA,")BHG?87:8. !(49(,- (44,65

(84)

(85) FF8FF<A:G;84CC?<645<?<GLB9DH4?<G4G<I86B@C4E4G<I84A4?LF<F9BEG;8 8I4?H4G<BA B9 6B@C?8K CEB=86GF A (44,65 $4.5 7F +),0 1(% )%*%/0.0%+* %* +),(!4%05CC S #<G6;9<8?7'4E>1@8E:8AG'H5?<64G<BAF. !(49(,-(44,65

(86) ,A78EFG4A7<A:4A7E8F84E6;<A:6B@C?8K<GLJ<G;DH4?<G4G<I86B@C4E4G<I8 4A4?LF<FI4?H4G<A:GE4AFCBEG4G<BA<A9E4FGEH6GHE8CEB=86GF 2(10%+* S. !(49(,-(44,65

(87) $4A4:<A:HAC?4AA878I8AGF<A?4E:8<A9E4FGEH6GHE8CEB=86GF)8FH?GF9EB@ 4A<A78CG;6B@C4E4G<I864F88I4?H4G<BA A"((.$45+$//7F+),0 )%*%/0.0%2! /0.0!#%!/"+.+),(!4#+2!.**!/5/0!)/CC S #<G6;9<8?7'4E>1@8E:8AG'H5?<64G<BAF. !(49(,- (44,65

(88) BJ F4G<F946G<BA <F 46;<8I87 <A G;8 <@C?8@8AG4G<BA C;4F8 B9 ?4E:8 GE4AFCBEG4G<BA <A9E4FGEH6GHE8 CEB=86GF DH4?<G4G<I8 6B@C4E4G<I8 4A4?LF<F <AGB G;8

(89) GHAA8? CEB=86G 1(% +.'/*#!)!*0+(%5

(90) S

(91) . !(49(,- (,50$1 (44,65

(92) @C?8@8AG<A: CH5?<6CE<I4G8 C4EGA8EF;<CF BJ @4A4:8@8AGE8FCBAF8FGB8I8AGFCEB7H68HAF4G<F946GBELBHG6B@8F 1(%+.'/*#!)!*0+(%5

(93)

(94) S . "(,55 !.*%*#".+)/0.*#!./$!.0* )!0$+ +"-1(%00%2!%*0!.2%!3/01 %!/%8J0BE> %0+;8E88'E8FF. '4:8 B9 . I4?H4G<A: A9E4FGEH6GHE8'EB=86G'?4AA<A:A7 @C?8@8AG4G<BA*GH7L ,F<A:(H4?<G4G<I8B@C4E4G<I8A4?LF<F.

(95)

No results found