Acute kinetic and kinematic differences between minimalist sandal, shod and barefoot running in habitually shod male recreational trail runners

Hele tekst

(1) ,>=.27.=2,*7-27.6*=2,2//.;.7,.<+.=@..7 2726*52<=#*7-*5#18-*7-*;./88=">7727027 *+2=>*55B#18-*5.".,;.*=287*5$;*25">77.;< 6M. *==1.@#@*;= . $/,:0:79,:,5;,+057(9;0(3-<3-034,5;6-;/,9,8<09,4,5;:-69;/,+,.9,, 6-(:;,96-#*0,5*,05;/,,7(9;4,5;6-#769;#*0,5*, (*<3;@6-,+0*05,(5+,(3;/#*0,5*,: (;#;,33,5)6:*/%50=,9:0;@ . #>9.;?2<8; ;8/"*7.5&.7=.; 8<>9.;?2<8;;#2687-.'**5 . *;,1 .

(2) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za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cG CKB DF9J=CIG@M 9J5@I5H98 CF DI6@=G<98 A5H9F=5@ K=H<CIH 57?BCK@98;9A9BH CF =B8=75H=CB H<9F9C: G9@:D@5;=5F=GA CF H9LHF97M7@=B; " 5@GC IB89FGH5B8 H<5H 8=F97H HF5BG@5H=CBG 5F9 D@5;=5F=GA 77CF8=B;@M 5@@ EICH5H=CBG 5B8 7CBHF=6IH=CBG :FCA 5BM GCIF79K<5HGC9J9F=B7@I8=B;H<9=BH9FB9H<5J9699B7=H98:I@@M "IB89FGH5B8H<5HH<9 F9DFC8I7H=CB C: H9LH K=H<CIH EICH5H=CB A5F?G 9J9B K<9B H<9 GCIF79 =G 7=H98 =G D@5;=5F=GA March 2021 CDMF=;<HY

(3) ,H9@@9B6CG7<.B=J9FG=HM @@F=;<HGF9G9FJ98. . = .

(4) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za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

(5) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. $87B*<=.;1>2C.7:FCAH<99D5FHA9BHC:D=89A=C@C;M5B8=CGH5H=GH=7G:CF<9F <9@DK=H<GH5H=GH=75@5B5@MG=G =1.7*B<*7-;8>:CF<9F<9@DK=H<H<9H97<B=75@98=HGC:H<9H<9G=G5B8:CF9BGIF=B; H<5H"B9J9F;9HAM7@5IG9GA=L98ID5;5=B ;8/*552.?*7.?.7=.;:CF<=G<9@D=BHF5BG@5H=B;AMGIAA5FMHC:F=?55BG -<9 CH<9F A9A69FG C: H<9 7<=7?9B FIB ;5B; 0<5HGDD ;FCID *;,8 #*2.?* 5B8 *==1.@$299.==:CFDFCJ=8=B;5B89J9F9B8IF=B;:F=9B8G<=D5B858J9BHIF9GH<5HK=@@ @5GH 5 @=:9H=A9 %5GH@M H<9 7<=7?9B FIB ;5B;cG ACGH HF95GIF98 GIDDCFH9F 5B8 AM :@5HA5H92*%B<K<CG<5F98H<9GHFI;;@9GC:5@GC7CAD@9H=B;5A5GH9FcG6IHK5G 5@K5MGH<9F9:CFGCA9AI7<B99898H<9G=G7<5HG5B8GIDDCFH . . . . === .

(6) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. #%") 'C GHI8=9G =B G7=9BH=:=7 B;@=G< @=H9F5HIF9 K9F9 :CIB8 H<5H 9LD@CF98 H<9 57IH9 6=CA97<5B=75@ 9::97HG C: FIBB=B; =B 5 A=B=A5@=GH G5B85@ K=H<=B 5 <56=HI5@@M G<C8 DCDI@5H=CB IFH<9FACF9 H<9F9 =G @=A=H98 F9G95F7< 89G7F=6=B; H<9 K5M =B K<=7< HF5=@ FIBB9FG585DHHCIB:5A=@=5F:CCHK95F7CB8=H=CBG -<95=AC:H<=GGHI8MK5GH<9F9:CF9 HC=BJ9GH=;5H9H<957IH9?=B9H=75B8?=B9A5H=78=::9F9B79G69HK99BA=B=A5@=GHG5B85@ G<C8 5B8 65F9:CCH FIBB=B; =B <56=HI5@@M G<C8 A5@9 F97F95H=CB5@ HF5=@ FIBB9FG -<9 <MDCH<9G=GGH5H98H<5HA=B=A5@=GHG5B85@FIBB=B;KCI@8F9GI@H=BG=A=@5F?=B9H=7G5B8 ?=B9A5H=7GHC65F9:CCHFIBB=B;5GCDDCG98HC5G<C8FIBB=B;7CB8=H=CBK<=@9H<9BI@@ <MDCH<9G=GGH5H98H<5HH<9F9KCI@869BCG=;B=:=75BH?=B9H=75B8?=B9A5H=78=::9F9B79G 69HK99B A=B=A5@=GH G5B85@ G<C8 5B8 65F9:CCH 7CB8=H=CBG 8IF=B; GI6A5L=A5@ @9J9@ HF958A=@@FIBB=B; -<=FH99B'

(7) HF5=@FIBB9FG5;9 \ M95FG<9=;<H

(8) \ A9HF9GA5GG \ ?=@C;F5AG G<C9 G=N9 .$

(9) \

(10) F5B CB 5 9FH97X =BGHFIA9BH98 HF958A=@@G9H5H5 ^;F58=9BH5HH<F998=::9F9BHGI6A5L=A5@J9@C7=H=9G A G A G 5B8

(11) A G IG=B; H<F99 8=::9F9BH :CCHK95F 7CB8=H=CBG 65F9:CCH A=B=A5@=GH G5B85@ 5B8 H<9=F 7CBJ9BH=CB5@ HF5=@FIBB=B; G<C9G ,IDD@9A9BH5FM HC H<9 9FH97X =BGHFIA9BH98HF958A=@@5'CF5LCB&MC&(-"('+9G95F7<)FC"B9FH=5@&95GIF9A9BH .B=H"&.GMGH9AK5GIG98HC75DHIF9@CK9F@=A6?=B9A5H=75B8;FCIB8F957H=CB :CF79 +85H5GMB7<FCBCIG@M $=B9A5H=75B8 +85H5K9F975DHIF985H !N 5B8 !NF9GD97H=J9@M=BCF89FHCA95GIF9J9FH=75@5J9F5;9@C58=B;F5H9/%+ J9FH=75@=BGH5BH5B9CIG@C58=B;F5H9/"%+:CCHGHF=?95B;@9,5B?@98CFG=:@9L=CB 5B8?B99:@9L=CB5B;@9G5H7CBH57H5GK9@@5G?B99:@9L=CBF5B;9C:ACH=CB+(& 8IF=B; H<9 GH5B79 D<5G9 BCBD5F5A9HF=7 F=98A5B H9GH K5G IG98 HC H9GH 7CAD5F=GCBG5ACB;:CCHK95F7CB8=H=CBGK=H<5IBBCB:9FFCB=DCGH<C7H9GH -<9 @9J9@C:G=;B=:=75B79K5GG9H5HD IFH<9FACF9$9B85@@cG0K5GIG98HC 75@7I@5H99::97HG=N9 -<9 F9GI@HG =B8=75H9 H<5H G9J9F5@ 8=GH=B7H 57IH9 F9GDCBG9G HC 5@@ H<F99 :CCHK95F 7CB8=H=CBGK9F9:CIB8K=H<=BH<9H<F998=::9F9BHGD998G 0=H<=BH<9 A GJ9@C7=HM 6CH<H<965F9:CCH5B8A=B=A5@=GHG5B85@7CB8=H=CBF9GI@H98=B5G=;B=:=75BH@MF98I798 . =J .

(12) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. ,D

(13) =B7CAD5F=GCBK=H<G<C8FIBB=B;=B8=75H=B;5G<=:HHCK5F8G5:CF9:CCH GHF=?9 88=H=CB5@@M5H5J9@C7=HMC: A GA=B=A5@=GHFIBB=B;F9GI@H98=BG=;B=:=75BH@M @9GG5B?@98CFG=:@9L=CB5H7CBH57HD H<5B5G<C87CB8=H=CB %5GH@MK=H<=B5 A GJ9@C7=HM65F9:CCHFIBB=B;F9GI@H98=BG=;B=:=75BH@M@9GG?B99+(&8IF=B;GH5B79 D<5G97CAD5F98HC5G<C87CB8=H=CBD 0=H<=B5 A GJ9@C7=HMH<9CB@M GH5H=GH=75@@MG=;B=:=75BH8=::9F9B79GK9F9:CIB869HK99B565F9:CCH5B8G<C87CB8=H=CB :CF,D 5B8/"%+D K<9F96M5GA5@@9F,5B8@5F;9F/"%+K5G :CIB8K<9BFIBB=B;65F9:CCH +IBB=B;5H5

(14) A GJ9@C7=HMF9GI@H98=BG=;B=:=75BH@M @9GG8CFG=:@9L=CB5H7CBH57H=B565F9:CCHD 5B8A=B=A5@=GHD 7CB8=H=CB 7CAD5F98HCFIBB=B;=B5G<C87CB8=H=CB 88=H=CB5@@MFIBB=B;65F9:CCH5GCDDCG98HC G<C8 F9GI@H98 =B 5 G=;B=:=75BH@M F98I798 , D

(15) 5B8 ?B99 +(& 8IF=B; H<9 GH5B79D<5G9D

(16) -<9F9K9F9BCGH5H=GH=75@@MG=;B=:=75BH8=::9F9B79G:CIB8:CF ?B99:@9L=CB5H7CBH57H5B8/%+57FCGG5@@H<F99:CCHK95F7CB8=H=CBGK=H<=B5@@H<F99 GD998G -<9A5>CF:=B8=B;C:H<=GGHI8MK5GH<5HA=B=A5@=GHFIBB=B;G=AI@5H9G65F9:CCHFIBB=B; 6975IG9BCG=;B=:=75BH8=::9F9B79GK9F9:CIB869HK99BH<9HKC7CB8=H=CBG:CF5BMC: H<9GD998GH<9F96MH<9<MDCH<9G=GK5G5779DH98 IFH<9FACF9H<9BI@@<MDCH<9G=G K5GF9>97H985G57IH9?=B9A5H=75B8?=B9H=78=::9F9B79GK9F9:CIB869HK99B65F9:CCH 5B8G<C85GK9@@5G69HK99BA=B=A5@=GH5B8G<C8FIBB=B;57FCGGBIA9FCIGJ5F=56@9G %5GH@MH<9F9GI@HG=B8=75H98H<5HJ9FH=75@@C58=B;F5H9GA5M69<=;<9F=B565F9:CCH5B8 A=B=A5@=GH G5B85@ 7CB8=H=CB 8IF=B; H<9 =B=H=5@ HF5BG=H=CB D9F=C8 6975IG9 C: 5 @57? C: ?=B9A5H=77<5B;9G5HH<9?B99 "B7CB7@IG=CBFIBB=B;=B5A=B=A5@=GHG5B85@7CB8=H=CB K5GG=A=@5FHCFIBB=B;65F9:CCH5@H<CI;<6CH<7CB8=H=CBGK9F9BCHB979GG5F=@M5@K5MG 8=::9F9BH HC 5 G<C8 7CB8=H=CB :CF 79FH5=B J5F=56@9G 5IH=CB =G 58J=G98 HC FIBB9FG G99?=B;HC7<5B;9:FCA5<56=HI5@@MG<C87CB8=H=CBHCFIBB=B;=B5A=B=A5@=GHG5B85@ CF65F9:CCH7CB8=H=CB6975IG9C:=B7F95G98J9FH=75@@C58=B;/%+F5H9G9LD9F=9B798 =B H<9 =B=H=5@ HF5BG=H=CB D<5G9 IHIF9 GHI8=9G G<CI@8 7CBG=89F F9D@=75H=B; H<9 7IFF9BH GHI8M=B5BCIH8CCFG9HH=B;H<5H=GACF95DD@=756@9HCHF5=@FIBB9FG "BCF89FHC89H9FA=B9 H<9 7<FCB=7 585DH=CBG HC FIBB=B; =B 5 A=B=A5@=GH G5B85@ @CB;=HI8=B5@ GHI8=9G 5F9 B99898 $9MKCF8G 286.,1*72,< ">77270 427.6*=2,< 2726*52<= /88=@.*; *;./88= ;>77270 . J .

(17) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. # 99B GHI8=9G =B K9H9BG?5D@=?9 B;9@G9 @=H9F5HIIF ?CB ;9J=B8 KCF8 K5H 8=9 5?IH9 6=CA9;5B=9G9 9::9?H9 J5B <5F8@CCD A9H cB A=B=A5@=GH=9G9 G5B855@ =B cB ;9KCB9 G?C9BDCDI@5G=9 CB89FGC9? B=9 CCBCD =G 855F 69D9F?H9 B5JCFG=B; F5?9B89 8=9 A5B=9F<C9J9@8K98@CD9FG6MCB69?9B89G?C9=G9@HC9GH5B8955BD5G =98C9@J5B8=9 <I=8=;9GHI8=9K5G8IG855FCD;9F=;CA8=95?I@H9?=B9H=9G99B?=B9A5H=9G9J9FG?=@@9 HIGG9B8=9A=B=A5@=GH=9G9G5B855@G?C9B9B?55@JC9H<5F8@CCD6MA5B@=?9F9?F95G=9 J9@8K98@CD9FGK5H;9KCCB@=?A9HG?C9B9<5F8@CCDB5H9JCFG =9<=DCH9G969KMG 85H8=9?=B9H=?59B?=B9A5H=?5J5B<5F8@CCDA9HA=B=A5@=GH=9G9G5B85@9GCCFH;9@M?55B ?55@JC9H<5F8@CCD=G !5F8@CCD=BA=B=A5@=GH=9G9G5B85@9=G=BH99BGH9@@=B;A9HG?C9B <5F8@CCD =9 BI@<=DCH9G9 GH9@ 85H 855F ;99B 698I=89B89 ?=B9H=9G9 9B ?=B9A5H=9G9 J9FG?=@@9 HIGG9B 8=9 8F=9 HC9GH5B89 ?55@JC9H G5B85@9 9B G?C9B9 GCI K99G HM89BG GI6A5G?=A5@9<5F8@CCDCDgHF5DA9I@B=9 9FH=9B'

(18) J9@8K98@CD9FGCI89F8CA \ >55F@9B;H9

(19) \ A9H9F ;9K=; \ ?=@C;F5A G?C9B;FCCHH9 /$

(20) \

(21) <9H CD cB 9FH97X ;9UBGHFIA9BH99F89 HF5DA9I@ ;9GH9@ CD cB ^ ;F58=SBH 6M 8F=9 J9FG?=@@9B89 GI6A5?G=A5@9 GB9@<989 A G A G 9B

(22) A G ;9<5F8@CCD 9B 8F=9 J9FG?=@@9B89 G?C9=G9@ HC9GH5B89 =G ;96FI=? ?55@JC9H A=B=A5@=GH=9G9 G5B855@ 9B ?CBJ9BG=CB9@9J9@8K98@CCD<5F8@CCDG?C9B9 cB69(?65@6 $ ",:,(9*/!96 5,9;0(3 ,(:<9,4,5; %50; % =G 55BJI@@9B8 HCH 8=9 9FH97X ;9UBGHFIA9BH99F89 HF5DA9I@;96FI=?CA85H5J5B?=B9A5H=9G99B;FCB8F95?G=9?F5; +$J5B8=9 CB89FGH9@989A5H9G=B7<FCB=9GH969D55@ $=B9A5H=9G99B +$85H5=GCB89FG?9=89@=? CD !N 9B !N J5G;9@R CA 8=9 ;9A=889@89 J9FH=?5@9 @55=GB9@<9=8 /%, CCA6@=?@=?9J9FH=?5@9@55=GB9@<9=8(/%,JC9HD@5G=B;G<C9?/)!9B?9@8CFG=:@9?G=9 9B?B=9:@9?G=9<C9?96M?CBH5?H9A99HGCK9@5G69K9;=B;J5B8=9?B=9:@9?G=9(/ ;98IF9B89 8=9 <CI8=B;G:5G9 cB '=9D5F5A9HF=9G9 F=98A5BHC9HG =G ;96FI=? CA J9F;9@M?=B;GHIGG9BG?C9=G9@HC9GH5B89H9HC9HGA9HIBBCB:9FFCB=DCGH<C7HC9HG =969H9?9B=G5JC@<9=8GJ@5?=GCD) ;9GH9@ $9B85@@G90=G;96FI=?CA 8=99::9?;FCCHH9H969F9?9B . . J= .

(23) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. =9 F9GI@H5H9 HCCB 85H 8=9 8F=9 J9FG?=@@9B89 HC9GH5B89 9@? J9FG?=@@9B89 5?IH9 9=9BG?5DD99=955B<I@G9@:<9H=BH9FA9J5B8=9GB9@<989 =BB98=9GB9@<9=8J5B A G <9H 69=89 8=9 ?55@JC9H 9B A=B=A5@=GH=9G9 G5B855@HC9GH5B89 ;9@9= HC cB 69H9?9B=GJC@@9J9FA=B89F89/)!D

(24) =BJ9F;9@M?=B;A9HG?C9B9@CCDK5H8I= CD cB G?I=: B5 JCCFJC9H D@5G=B; 55F69B9K9BG <9H A=B=A5@=GH=9G9 <5F8@CCD 6M cB GB9@<9=8 J5B A G ;9@9= HCH 55BG=9B@=? A=B89F 9B?9@ 8CFG=:@9?G=9 6M ?CBH5? D =BJ9;9@M?=B;A9HcBG?C9BHC9GH5B8 -9BG@CHH96=BB9cBGB9@<9=8J5B A G <9H ?55@JC9H <5F8@CCD HCH 698I=89B8 A=B89F ?B=9(/ HM89BG 8=9 <CI8=B;G:5G9 =B J9F;9@M?=B;A9HcBG?C9BHC9GH5B8D ;9@9= =99B=;GH9GH5H=GH=9G698I=89B89 J9FG?=@HM89BGcB A GGB9@<9=8=GHIGG9BcB?55@JC9H9BG?C9BHC9GH5B8J=F/)!D 9B (/%, D K55F;9B99A H9FKM@ cB ?@9=B9F /)! 9B ;FCH9F (/%, ;98IF9B89?55@JC9H<5F8@CCD;9J=B8=G %55GH9BG<9H<5F8@CCDH99BcBGB9@<9=8J5B

(25) A G 55B@9=8=B; ;9;99 HCH 55BG=9B@=? A=B89F 8CFG=:@9?G=9 6M ?CBH5? HM89BG ?55@JC9H D 9B A=B=A5@=GH=9G9 D HC9GH5B89 =B J9;9@M?=B; A9H cB G?C9BHC9GH5B8 55F69B9K9BG <9H ?55@JC9H <5F8@CCD =B H99BGH9@@=B; A9H G?C9B9 55B@9=8=B; ;9;99 HCH cB 55BG=9B@=? J9FA=B89F89 /)! D

(26) 9B ?B=9 (/ ;98IF9B89 8=9 <CI8=B;G:5G9 D

(27) =9 85H5 HCCB ;99B GH5H=GH=9G 698I=89B89 J9FG?=@@9H9BCDG=;H9J5B?B=9:@9?G=96M?CBH5?9B /%,6M5@8F=9G?C9=G9@HC9GH5B89 9B8=98F=9GB9@<989B=9 =9 69@5B;F=?GH9 69J=B8=B; J5B <=9F8=9 GHI8=9 HCCB 85H A=B=A5@=GH=9G9 <5F8@CCD ?55@JC9H<5F8@CCDG=AI@99FCA85H;99BBC9A9BGK55F8=;9J9FG?=@@9HIGG9B8=9HK99 HC9GH5B89 J=F 9B=;9 J5B 8=9 GB9@<989 ;9J=B8 =G B=9 9B 855FCA KCF8 8=9 <=DCH9G9 55BJ55F /9F89F =G 8=9 BI@<=DCH9G9 J9FK9FD CA85H 5?IH9 ?=B9A5H=9G9 9B ?=B9H=9G9 J9FG?=@@9HIGG9B?55@JC9H9BA9HG?C9B9<5F8@CCD6MJ9FG?9=9J9F5B89F@=?9G;9J=B8=G 5GCC?HIGG9BA=B=A5@=GH=9G99BG?C9B<5F8@CCD %55GH9BG8I=8=9F9GI@H5H955B85H J9FH=?5@9@55=GB9@<9895G;9JC@;J5BcB;96F9?55B?=B9A5H=9G9J9F5B89F=B;955B8=9 ?B=9 <CSF ?5B K99G 6M cB ?55@JC9H 9B A=B=A5@=GH=9G9 G5B855@HC9GH5B8 HM89BG 8=9 55BJ5B?@=?9 CCF;5B;GHM8D9F? -9B G@CHH9 <5F8@CCD =B cB A=B=A5@=GH=9G9 G5B855@HC9GH5B8K5GGCCFH;9@M?55B?55@JC9H<5F8@CCD5@<C9K9@69=89HC9GH5B89B=9 BCC8K9B8=;5@HM8J9FG?=@@9B8K5G55BcBG?C9BHC9GH5B8J=FG9?9F9J9F5B89F@=?9GB=9 !5F8@CD9FG K5H J5B 8=9 ;96FI=?@=?9 G?C9BHC9GH5B8 K=@ J9F5B89F B5 <5F8@CCD A9H cB A=B=A5@=GH=9G9G5B855@C:?55@JC9HKCF855B;9F55=CAJ9FG=;H=;H9K99G5G;9JC@;J5B 8=9HC9B5A9=BJ9FH=?5@9@55=GB9@<989K5HHM89BG8=955BJ5B?@=?9CCF;5B;G:5G99FJ55F . J== .

(28) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. KCF8 -C9?CAGH=;9 GHI8=9G AC9H 8=H CCFK99; CA 8=9 <I=8=;9 GHI8=9 =B cB 6I=H9@I; CA;9K=B;H9<9F<55@K5HA99FHC9D5G@=?=GJ=FJ9@8K98@CD9FG 55F69B9K9BG=GA99F @CB;=HI8=B5@9GHI8=9GBC8=;CA8=9?FCB=9G955BD5GG=B;GJ=F<5F8@CCD=BA=B=A5@=GH=9G9 G5B85@9H969D55@ #5.>=.5@88;-. =CA9;5B=9?5 $=B9A5H=9G9 5GD9?H9 J5B <5F8@CCD &=B=A5@=GH=9G9 G?C9=G9@G$55@JC9H<5F8@CCD. . . . J=== .

(29) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. $$$# "$DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD2 '$#DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD22 #%")DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD2? #DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD?2 #$%"#DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDA222 #$$#DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDA2? #$"&$#")#DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDA? &"&'$##DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDA?22 $"$"%$

(30)

(31) $ +(.'

(32)

(33) )+(%&,--&'-'+-"('%(+-!,-.1

(34) +,+!*.,-"('"&(#-"/,'!1)(-!,, ",:,(9*/8<,:;065 046-;/,:;<+@ . )1,*;0=,:. @76;/,:0::;(;,4,5;

(35) /+"%,

(36)

(37) ,,.&)-"(',

(38) $" $"$$($

(39) "'-+(.-"('

(40) -! "-1%.+"' ",-'+.''"'

(41) "<5505.=,9:<:>(3205..(0; = ,D5H=CH9ADCF5@7<5F57H9F=GH=7GF9:@97H98=BH<98IHM:57HCF

(42) == @I7HI5H=CBG=B;F5J=H5H=CB5@DCH9BH=5@9B9F;M5B8?=B9H=79B9F;M

(43) +((-'&"'"&%",-+.''"'

(44) 65*,7;<(30:05.)(9,-66;(5+40504(30:;9<5505. (*;69:+90=05.;/,79646;0656-)(9,-66;(5+40504(30:;9<5505. = -<99JC@IH=CB5FM 5BH<FCDC@C;=75@9LD@5B5H=CB +((-'&"'"&%",-+.''"' $"'&-", 5;96+<*;065 66;:;902,7(;;,95#!(5+(5.3,# . . =L .

(45) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. = +IBB=B;GD998 == +IBB=B;GIF:579 === 5H=;I9 =J CCHK95F 523,+69:0-3,?065(5.3,. 5,,-3,?065(5.3,(;*65;(*;

(46) 5,,-3,?065" +<905.:;(5*,7/(:,

(47) +((-'&"'"&%",-+.''"' $"'-",

(48) 5;96+<*;065

(49) &,9;0*(3.96<5+9,(*;065-69*,="

(50) &,9;0*(336(+05.9(;,

(51)

(52) &,9;0*(336(+05.9(;,(5+0;:(::6*0(;065>0;/"":

(53) -+"%+.''"' $/,/0:;69@6-;9(039<5505.

(54) 064,*/(50*(3796-03,6-(;9(039<55,9

(55) ,.&&+1 $" $)

(56) "'-+(.-"(' ,-.1," ' )+-"")'-,

(57) . #(47305.(5+9,*9<0;4,5; . 5*3<:065*90;,90( . ?*3<:065*90;,90( ,-.1(/+/"0 -!"%,)-, .

(58) 65-30*;6-05;,9,:;:;(;,4,5;

(59) -,-"' '&,.+&'-, . 5;/96764,;90*(::,::4,5;

(60) = ,H5HIF9 == C8MA5GG === &" =J %9;@9B;H< . #/6,(::,::4,5; . . L .

(61) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. = ,<C9G=N9 == ,<C95;9 . 6>,9304)205,;0*:(5+205,4(;0*: = "B9FH=5@A95GIF9A9BHIB=HG"&.G == "BGHFIA9BH98HF958A=@@ -'%1,", . =,5;+,;,*;065:(5+205,4(;0*6<;*64,=(90()3,: = CCHGHF=?95B;@9, == B?@98CFG=:@9L=CB5B;@95H7CBH57H === $B99:@9L=CB5B;@95H7CBH57H =J $B99:@9L=CB+(&8IF=B;GH5B79D<5G9 . 47(*;7,(2:(5+=,9;0*(336(+05.9(;,&"6<;*64,: = /%+ == /"%+ ,--",-"%'%1,", $" "#""$ $"

(62) %#

(63) "'-+(.-"('

(64)

(65) @76;/,:0::;(;,4,5; )+-"%))%"-"(',

(66) ,-.1%"&"--"(',

(67) .-.++,+!+(&&'-"(',

(68) ""# . (""%$$)". . ("#$"#. . ("#$""#. . ($#. . ($#$##%. . ("#$#"# $'". . "&$$". L= . "#.

(69) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. . ("()$#$'"%. . (%"# "$###$"%$#"%$"#. . ( "##"%#%" . . ( "##"%#%" . . ( "##"%#%"

(70) . . L== . .

(71) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. #$%"# 20>;. ,7<9A5H=7F9DF9G9BH5H=CBC:H<9D<5G9GC:H<9K5@?=B;5B8FIBB=B;7M7@9G K=H<GD97=5@5HH9BH=CBHCH<9DF9G9B79C:8CI6@9:@C5H=BFIBB=B;"B=H=5@CBH57H" &=8GH5B79 &,H -9FA=B5@ ,H5B79 -,H )F9GK=B; ),K "B=H=5@GK=B; ",K &=8 GK=B;&,K5B8-9FA=B5@GK=B;-,K 0=H<D9FA=GG=CB:FCA%C<A5B""",57?=F=M5G 5B8,K9B

(72)

(73)

(74) 20>;. F5D<=75@ F9DF9G9BH5H=CB C: H<9 CG7=@@5H=CBG C: 79BHF9 C: A5GG C& =B K5@?=B; 5B8 FIBB=B; =B K<=7< H<9 C& =G <=;<9GH =B K5@?=B; 5B8 @CK9GH =B FIBB=B;5HA=8GH5B79,CIF79&5HH<9K,K5FH 85DH98:FCA%=

(75)

(76)

(77) 20>;. F5D<=75@F9DF9G9BH5H=CBC:57CAACB+,J +7IFJ9=B8=75H=B;HKC D95?GB5A9@M5B=AD57HD95?5B85B57H=J9D95? 0=H<D9FA=GG=CB:FCA0=BH9F5B8 <5@@=G

(78) 20>;. F5D<=75@F9DF9G9BH5H=CBC:J +A95GIF98=B'9KHCBG':CF5F95F:CCH GHF=?9+J9FGIG5:CF9:CCHGHF=?9=B8=75H=B;CB@MCB98=GH=B7HD95?:CF5:CF9:CCH GHF=?9 !5A=@@5B8 FI69F

(79) 'CD9FA=GG=CBF9EI=F98 20>;.

(80) F5D<=75@F9DF9G9BH5H=CBC:/%+%+5B8/"%+"%+K=H<=BH<9J + 7IFJ9 -<9/%+5B8/"%+5F975@7I@5H9869HK99BHKCGI779GG=J9DC=BHG;9B9F5@@M 69HK99B7CBH57H5B8J9FH=75@=AD57HD95?/"):FCAH<9J9FH=75@:CF79=B'9KHCBG' J9FGIGH=A9=BA=@@=G97CB8GAG;F5D< 0=H<D9FA=GG=CB:FCA5J=G5B8IHF9@@

(81)

(82) 20>;. %C75H=CBG :CF "&. D@579A9BH 5 @9:H 5B8 F=;<H G<5B? 6 @9:H 5B8 F=;<H H<=;<G7D9@J=G8A=88@9H<CF57=79IDD9FH<CF57=7:A=GG=B;@9:H5B8F=;<H:99H ,CIF79(@C::9F;< 20>;. F5D<=75@8=GD@5MC:H<9G9@:58<9G=J9H5D9IG98HCG97IF9H<9"&.G=B D@579,CIF79&5HH<9K,K5FH 20>;. F5D<=75@8=GD@5MC:H<9HF958A=@@G9HIDK=H<5G5:9HM65F:=HH98CBH<9:FCBH ,CIF79&5HH<9K,K5FH

(83) . . . L=== .

(84) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. #$$# $*+5.-56@9C:J5F=56@9GF9@5H98HCH<9GHI8M

(85) $*+5. ,IAA5FMC:GHI8=9G7CAD5F=B;H<99::97HGC:A=B=A5@=GH:CCHK95FCB,) HCG<C865F9:CCHCF6CH<G=B79

(86) $*+5. ,IAA5FMC:GHI8=9G7CAD5F=B;H<99::97HGC:A=B=A5@=GH:CCHK95FCB5B?@9 8CFG=:@9L=CB5B;@9HCG<C865F9:CCHCF6CH<G=B79

(87) $*+5. ,IAA5FM C: GHI8=9G 7CAD5F=B; H<9 9::97HG C: A=B=A5@=GH :CCHK95F ?B99 :@9L=CB5B;@95H7CBH57HHCG<C865F9:CCHCF6CH<G=B79

(88) $*+5. ::97H G=N9 H<F9G<C@8G 577CF8=B; HC GHF9B;H< C: DF57H=75@ G=;B=:=75B79 585DH98:FCA9F;IGCB $*+5.

(89) ,IAA5FMC:<MDCH<9G9G5B8CIH7CA9G65G98CBH<9J5F=56@9G5GG9GG98

(90) . . . . . . . L=J .

(91) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za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

(92) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. +(& . . . F5B;9C:ACH=CB. ++". . . . FIBB=B;F9@5H98=B>IFM. ,". . . . ,HF=?9"B89L. -8 . . . -CF89G 95BHGX. -!& . . . H=A969HK99B<99@5B8A9H5H5FG5@5779@9F5H=CBD95?G. -,H. . . . -9FA=B5@,H5B79. -,K . . . -9FA=B5@GK=B;. .$. . . . .B=H98$=B;8CA. .,. . . . .B=H98,5H9G. .-&. . . .@HF5-F5=@8I&CBH@5B7X. /%+ . . . J9FH=75@5J9F5;9@C58=B;F5H9. J + . . . J9FH=75@;FCIB8F957H=CB:CF79. /"%+ . . . J9FH=75@=BGH5BH5B9CIG@C58=B;F5H9. /%+ . . . J9FH=75@@C58=B;F5H9. . . LJ= .

(93) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. &"&'$$## -<9 H<9G=G =G DF9G9BH98 =B 5 F9G95F7< 5FH=7@9 :CFA5H (B9 F9G95F7< 5FH=7@9 <5DH9F CIFK5GDF9D5F98577CF8=B;HCH<95IH<CF;I=89@=B9GC:H<96<95(36-#769;#*0,5*,: 99.7-2A CBG9EI9BH@MH<9F9:9F9B7=B;5B8:CBHGHM@9IG98=B<5DH9FCIFK=@@ 8=::9F:FCAH<5HC:H<9F9A5=B=B;7<5DH9FG -<9F9:9F9B7=B;:CFA5H:CFH<=GH<9G=G:C@@CKG H<9!5FJ5F8+9:9F9B7=B;GHM@9H<5H=GDFCJ=898CBH<9.B=J9FG=HMC:,H9@@9B6CG7<@=6F5FM ;I=89@=B9GK96G=H9585DH98:FCA/5BM?5B8C9HN99

(94) 1*9=.; 7. "BHFC8I7H=CB -<=G 7<5DH9F 7CBH5=BG H<9 =BHFC8I7H=CB 5B8 DFC6@9A GH5H9A9BH5GK9@@5GH<9F9G95F7<EI9GH=CBG5=AGC6>97H=J9G<MDCH<9G9GJ5F=56@9G 5B85GGIADH=CBGH<5H;I=898H<9GHI8M 1*9=.;$@8-<9CF9H=75@7CBH9LH -<9DIFDCG9C:H<=G7<5DH9FK5GHCGIAA5F=G9H<9 9L=GH=B; @=H9F5HIF9 F9@5H=B; HC 8=GH5B79 FIBB=B; ,97CB8@M HC DFCJ=89 =BG=;<H =BHC 65F9:CCH5B8A=B=A5@=GHFIBB=B;6=CA97<5B=7G %5GH@MH<=G7<5DH9FF9J=9KG@=H9F5HIF9 GIFFCIB8=B;HF5=@FIBB=B; 1*9=.; $1;.. &9H<C8C@C;M -<=G 7<5DH9F 9LD@5=BG H<9 GHI8M 89G=;B G5AD@9 GD97=:=7 A9H<C8G H<5H K9F9 IG98 :CF 85H5 7C@@97H=CB 5B8 9H<=75@ 7CBG=89F5H=CBG IFH<9FACF9H<9H9GHG5B8A95GIF9A9BHG5F989G7F=698=B7@I8=B;<CKH<985H5K9F9 9L5A=B985B8GH5H=GH=75@@M5B5@MG98 1*9=.; 8>; +9G95F7< 5FH=7@9 H=H@98 0504(30:; 9<5505. :(5+(3 4040*: )(9,-66; 205,4(;0*:(5+=,9;0*(336(+05.9(;,05/()0;<(33@:/6+;9(039<55,9:-<=G7<5DH9FK5G KF=HH9B577CF8=B;HCH<95IH<CF;I=89@=B9GC:6<95(36-#769;#*0,5*,:99.7-2A -<9DF=A5FM:C7IGC:H<95FH=7@9=GHC7CAD5F957IH9@CK9F@=A6?=B9A5H=7G5B8J9FH=75@ @C58=B;F5H98=::9F9B79G69HK99BG<C865F9:CCH5B8A=B=A5@=GHFIBB=B;K<=@GHFIBB=B; K=H<=B H<F99 8=::9F9BH GD998G A G A G 5B8

(95) A G CBG9EI9BH@M H<9 F9:9F9B7=B; GHM@9 K=@@ 8=::9F HC H<5H C: H<9 F9GH C: H<9 H<9G=G 5G H<9 A9F=75B )GM7<C@C;=75@GGC7=5H=CBG9J9BH<98=H=CB)=GH<9DF9:9FF98F9:9F9B7=B;GHM@9 :CFH<9>CIFB5@ . LJ== .

(96) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. 1*9=.; 2?. CB7@IG=CB @=A=H5H=CBG 5B8 :IHIF9 F9G95F7< -<=G 7<5DH9F DFCJ=89G 5 6F=9:7CB7@IG=CBF9@5H=B;HCH<9<MDCH<9G9GC:H<9GHI8M5GK9@@5GH<9@=A=H5H=CBGC: H<9GHI8M5B8=AD@=75H=CBG:CF:IHIF9F9G95F7< . . LJ=== .

(97) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za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

(98) "B :57H H<9 C@89GH G<C9 9J9F 8=G7CJ9F98 85H9G 657? FCI;<@M M95FG 5;C )=B<5G=. 5GD5F=5B F9G<=5B. 25F85FM5B ,A=H< 5F(N !=;<5A

(99) !CK9J9F H<9F9 =G 5B5HCA=75@ :CGG=@ 9J=89B79H<5H85H9G:CCHK95FIG9HC M95FG5;CA5899J=89BH6MH<9K95?9B=B; C: GA5@@ DFCL=A5@ D<5@5B;9G =B <IA5BG CJ9F H=A9 -F=B?5IG ,<5B; -<9 :CCHK95F IG98 8IF=B; H<5H H=A9 D9F=C8 5B8 M95FG HC :C@@CK =B7@I898 G5B85@G 5B8 AC775G=BG:5G<=CB98CIHC:A5H9F=5@G:FCAH<9GIFFCIB8=B;9BJ=FCBA9BHGK=H<H<9GC@9 DIFDCG9C:DFCJ=8=B;DFCH97H=CB5;5=BGH57IH9=B>IFMGI7<5GGH9DD=B;CBG<5FDFC7?G 5GK9@@5GDFCH97H=CB:FCA<CH5B87C@8GIF:579G+=L9 5@@C,=@J=G

(100) 5J=G

(101) H<@9H=7 G<C9G <5J9 IB89F;CB9 A5BM 7<5B;9G CJ9F H<9 D5GH HKC <IB8F98 M95FG <CK9J9F =H K5G BCH IBH=@

(102) H<5H H<9 :=FGH D5=F C: 7IG<=CB98 FIBB=B; G<C9G K5G F9@95G98 CB H<9 A5GG A5F?9H K=H< H<9 =BJ9BH=CB C: H<9 (B=HGI?5 -=;9F K<=7< @5H9F 6975A9,",$C69#5D5B/5B89F6=@H

(103) 5J=G

(104) -<IGH<9K=89GDF958 IG9C:AC89FBFIBB=B;:CCHK95F<5GC77IFF98=B5J9FMG<CFHGD579C:H=A9F9@5H=J9HC <IA5B 9JC@IH=CB F5B7=G ,7<C:=9@8 77CF8=B; HC F5B7=G 5B8 ,7<C:=9@8

(105) 0<9BF5D=87<5B;9G=BD<MG=75@CFBIHF=H=CB5@9BJ=FCBA9BHGC77IF=H=G89G7F=6985G5 A=GA5H7< 69HK99B 6=C@C;=75@ 9JC@IH=CB C77IFF=B; G@CK@M CJ9F A=@@=CBG C: M95FG 5B8. .

(106) .

(107) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. 7I@HIF5@9JC@IH=CBC77IFF=B;F5D=8@M8I9HC9J9BHGGI7<5GH<9=B8IGHF=5@CFH97<BC@C;=75@ F9JC@IH=CB . CBG9EI9BH@MH<=GA=GA5H7<H<9CFMC:9JC@IH=CB<5G699BDFCDCG986M9JC@IH=CB5FM 6=C@C;=GHGHC9LD@5=BA5BMC:H<98=G95G9GC6G9FJ98HC85M%=969FA5B

(108) F5B7=G ,7<C:=9@8 GGH5H986MF5B7=G5B8,7<C:=9@8 7CAACB9L5AD@9GC: H<9 9::97HG C: A=GA5H7< 9JC@IH=CB =B7@I89 8=G95G9G GI7< 5G HMD9 8=569H9G 5B8 CGH9CDCFCG=GK<=7<K9F9DF9J=CIG@MF5F9F5B85F9H<CI;<HHC<5J989J9@CD986975IG9 C:F5D=87<5B;9G=B9B9F;M5J5=@56=@=HM5B8D<MG=75@57H=J=HMF9GD97H=J9@M !9B79 H<FCI;< 5B 9JC@IH=CB5FM @9BG H<9 9::97HG C: 5 F5D=8@M 7<5B;=B; D<MG=75@ 9BJ=FCBA9BH A5M :IFH<9F 69 9L9AD@=:=98 6M H<9 <=;< =B7=89B79G C: FIBB=B;F9@5H98 =B>IFM++"F9DCFH98K=H<H<99A9F;9B79C:H<9aFIBB=B;6CCAb=BH<9

(109) G8IF=B; K<=7<7IG<=CB98FIBB=B;G<C9G<58697CA9=B7F95G=B;@MDCDI@5F%=969FA5B

(110) 5J=G

(111) 5J=G +=79 095F=B;

(112) 0<9H<9F =H K5G H<9 =BJ9BH=CB C: H<9 7IG<=CB98FIBB=B;G<C9H<5HDFCACH98H<=GFIBB=B;6CCACFH<9FIBB=B;6CCA=HG9@: H<5H :I9@@98 H<9 58J9BH C: H<9 AI@H=6=@@=CB8C@@5F 7IG<=CB98 G<C9 =B8IGHFM F9A5=BG 8965H98 K=H<=B @=H9F5HIF9 ,<CFH9B +=L9 9H 5@

(113) '9J9FH<9@9GG 8=GH5B79 FIBB=B;G<C9GK=H<9@9J5H987IG<=CB98<99@G5B8ACH=CB7CBHFC@:95HIF9G<5J9699B DFCACH98 6M G9J9F5@ 7@=B=7=5BG 5B8 5IH<CFG 5G 5 A95BG HC F98I79 ++"G %9<A5B

(114) #C<BGHCB -5IBHCB %@CM8,A=H< &7$9BN=9 GD@IB8 FCKB 15A5G<=H5 !CK9J9FH<9F95DD95FGHC695@57?C:9J=89B79GIDDCFH=B;H<9G9 7@5=AG+=7<5F8G&5;=B5@@=GH9F '=;;5@H=7<!C9FN9FB89FG

(115) 5B8 H<9HCD=7F9A5=BG7CBHFCJ9FG=5@ 0<=@9H<9F9<5J9699BA5>CF7<5B;9G=B:CCHK95FH97<BC@C;MG=B79H<9

(116) G=B>IFM F5H9G <5J9 F9A5=B98 7CBG=GH9BH@M <=;< K<9B 7CAD5F98 HC CH<9F BCB7CBH57H GDCFHG GI7< 5G K5@?=B; GK=AA=B; 5B8 7M7@=B; 9FHC@5 ,5FHCF= CFF95 2CHN CA9G

(117) ,5@ACB CC89%9BBQ=B7<5GG9@@

(118) !5IF9H98BC%CF=B;9F$5C &5@@CB#CB9G

(119) F979BHGMGH9A5H=7F9J=9KH<5HF9DCFH98CB++"GF9J95@985B =B>IFMC77IFF9B79C:

(120) =B>IF=9GD9F

(121) <CIFGC:FIBB=B;=BBCJ=79FIBB9FG5B8 =B>IF=9GD9F

(122) <CIFG=BF97F95H=CB5@FIBB9FG/=896_?I9BC'=9@G9B+5GIGG9B . .

(123) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za.

(124) -<9 ACGH 7=H98 F9;=CBG :CF H<9G9 =B>IF=9G 5F9 5H H<9 ?B99 @9; 5B8 :CCH /5B 9BH,=9AJ5B&=889@?CCDJ5B(G=9FA529=BGHF5$C9G -<9 59H=C@C;M C: ++"G =G AI@H=:57HCF=5@ 5B8 G9J9F5@ DCGHI@5H=CBG F9;5F8=B; =B>IFM DF98=GDCG=H=CB <5J9 699B 5;F998 CB K=H<=B H<9 @=H9F5HIF9 -<9 ACGH 7CAACB :57HCF DF98=GDCG=B;FIBB9FGHC++"=G5B=B:@5H98J9FH=75@@C58=B;F5H9/%+K<=7<<5G699B 5GGC7=5H98K=H<H=6=5@GHF9GG:F57HIF9G&=@B9F9F69F)C@@5F8!5A=@@5J=G 258DCCF '=?CCM5B

(125)

(126) D@5BH5F :5G7==H=G )C<@ !5A=@@ 5J=G 5B8 D5H9@@C:9ACF5@ D5=B GMB8FCA9 5J=G FCKG9F !5A=@@

(127) <9IB; 5J=G

(128)

(129) CBG9EI9BH@MH<9G95F9H<F99C:H<9:=J9ACGH7=H98++"GK<=7<<=;<@=;<HGH<9 =ADCFH5B79C:9L5A=B=B;/%+GK=H<=B8=GH5B79FIBB=B;F9G95F7<%CD9G!9GD5B<C@ #F 19IB;CGH5

(130) 7CAACB@M GI;;9GH98 5@H9FB5H=J9 HC G<C9 G<C8 FIBB=B; =G FIBB=B; 65F9:CCH IBG<C8 (:H9BH=A9GH<95GGIADH=CB=GH<5HH<=GaB5HIF5@bK5MC:FIBB=B;K=@@F98I79 ++"5B8=ADFCJ9FIBB=B;97CBCAM+%=969FA5B

(131) -5A0=@GCB'C5?9G -I7?9F

(132) -<9F95GCB:CF@CK9FGC:HH=GGI95B8>C=BH=B>IFMF=G?=B65F9:CCHFIBB=B; =GDIFDCFH98@M8I9HCH<9DFCACH=CBC:5A=8:CCHGHF=?9&,CF:CF9:CCHGHF=?9, 5GCDDCG98HCH<97CAACBGHF=?=B;D5HH9FB9LD9F=9B7986MG<C8FIBB9FGB5A9@M5 F95F:CCHGHF=?9+,%=969FA5B9H5@

(133) @HA5B5J=G

(134) 5)5EI9HH92<5B; 5IA;5FHB9F

(135) %=969FA5B

(136) &,5B8,G=;B=:=75BH@M897F95G9GH<9 /%+ 5B8 H<9 =B=H=5@ D95? J9FH=75@ ;FCIB8 F957H=CB :CF799 0=H 9 @9F7E 9FHG !F9@>57 )C<@9H5@ 5J=G9H5@

(137) %=969FA5B9H5@

(138) CGG FCGG

(139) K<=7<<5J9699BG<CKBHC69<=;<9F=BH<CG9K<C<5J9GIGH5=B985B ++"J9FGIGH<CG9K<C<5J9BCH!F9@>57&5FG<5@@!IA9 &=@B9F9H5@ )C<@9H5@ 88=H=CB5@@M5&,HC,D5HH9FB<5G699B5GGC7=5H98K=H<CH<9F ?=B9A5H=77<5B;9G=B7@I8=B;5ACF9D@5BH5F:@9L985B?@95B8:@9L98?B995H=AD57H5G CDDCG98HC5+,@A9=855J=G%CD9G

(140) "B 588=H=CB 5 8CFG=:@9L98 5B?@9 K<=7< =G GMBCBMACIG K=H< 5 +, 75IG9G @C75@ DF9GGIF9CBH<9<99@IDHC:CIFH=A9GH<96C8MK9=;<HIDCB7CBH57HK=H<H<9;FCIB8 5J5B5;<%5:CFHIB9

(141) -<958CDH=CBC:5D@5BH5F:@9L985B?@9DCG=H=CB8IF=B; . .

(142) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. 65F9:CCH FIBB=B; <5G 699B 5GGC7=5H98 K=H< H<9 B998 HC @9GG9B H<=G DF9GGIF9 9LD9F=9B798 5H H<9 <99@ K<9B GHF=?=B; H<9 ;FCIB8 K=H< H<9 F95F:CCH ,EI58FCB9 5@@CNN= %=969FA5B

(143) IFH<9FACF9K<=@GHFIBB=B;=H<5G699BGI;;9GH98 H<5H H<9 ?B99 57HG 5G 5 A5>CF G<C7? 56GCF69F HC 5HH9BI5H9 G<C7? 5H :CCH`;FCIB8 7CBH57H 5B8 HC A5=BH5=B @9; GH=::B9GG -<CA5G 9FF=7? !5A=@@ FI69F 9FF=7?

(144) CCHK95FK=H<5B9@9J5H98<99@A5M5@GC57HHC5HH9BI5H9G<C7?GC 5@H9F5H=CBG5HH<9?B99>C=BHA5M69=BH9FDF9H985G589G=F9HCA5=BH5=B7CA6=B98@9;` G<C9 GH=::B9GG 5H =AD57H ,EI58FCB9 +C85BC !5A=@@ )F95HCB=

(145) !CK9J9F 7CBHF58=7H=CBG 5F=G9 5G HC K<9H<9F H<9 ?=B9A5H=7 8=::9F9B79G 69HK99B G<C8 5B8 65F9:CCHFIBB=B;5F9;F95H9F5HH<95B?@9CFH<9?B99 ,CA95IH<CFG7CBH9B8H<5HH<9 5B?@9=GA5=B@MF9GDCBG=6@9:CF5HH9BI5H=B;G<C7?5B8H<IG8=::9F9B79G5F9;F95H9F5H H<95B?@990=H9H5@ =G<CD=C@?CKG?=CBF58FIBH!CFC8MG?= @H9FB5H=J9@M CH<9F G7<C@5FG 69@=9J9 H<5H H<9 ?=B9A5H=7G C: H<9 ?B99 A5M 8=GD@5M ;F95H9F8=::9F9B79G8I9HC=HG=ADCFH5B79=B5HH9BI5H=B;G<C7?9FF=7? :IFH<9FGI;;9GH9869B9:=HC:65F9:CCHFIBB=B;=GH<5H<9=;<H9B98G9BGCFM:998657? 75IG986MH<99LDCG98:CCH5@@CKG:CFCDH=A=G5H=CBC:@CK9F@9;GH=::B9GG=G<CD9H5@ -<9 <9=;<H9B98 G9BGCFM :998657? =B 65F9:CCH FIBB=B; F9GI@HG :FCA 5 89BG9 7C@@97H=CBC:A97<5BCF979DHCFGCBH<9D@5BH5FGIF:579C:H<9:CCH$9BB98M"B;@=G !9BB=; ,H9FN=B; K<=7< 5DD95FG HC 69 =BGI@5H98 =B AC89FB FIBB=B; G<C9G !C@CK?5 0MB5B8G F97<G9@ 19;=5B -C6C@8G?M (?IHCM= (>5A6C !5=@9 ,=;9= 2=DD9B:9BB=; &=@5B= %=969FA5B

(146) CF A5BM FIBB9FG =B7@I8=B; HF5=@ FIBB9FG65F9:CCHFIBB=B;A5M69IBGI=H56@9HC8=::9F9BHH9FF5=BG5B8IBG5:9GIF:579G K<=7< A5M @=A=H D9F:CFA5B79 0=@@M 5J=G

(147) -<IG FIBB9FG A5M CDH :CF 5B 5@H9FB5H=J9CDH=CB5A=B=A5@=GHG<C9 &=B=A5@=GHG<C9G5F989:=B986MG7I@=9FI6C=F =CBB9%96@CB85B8+CM

(148) `5G 5BM:CCHK95FH<5HDFCJ=89GA=B=A5@=BH9F:9F9B79K=H<H<9B5HIF5@ACJ9A9BHC:H<9:CCH 8I9HC=HG<=;<:@9L=6=@=HM@CK<99@HCHC98FCDK9=;<H5B8GH57?<9=;<H5B85B56G9B79 C:ACH=CB7CBHFC@5B8GH56=@=HM89J=79G . -<=GHMD9C:G<C9F9DF9G9BHG5DCH9BH=5@CDDCFHIB=HMHC;5=BH<969B9:=HGC:6CH<G<C8 7IG<=CB DFCH97H=CB5;5=BGH<5FG<GIF:579G5B865F9:CCHDCG=H=J9?=B9A5H=77<5B;9G. . .

(149) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. FIBB=B; "H 5DD95FG H<5H A=B=A5@=GH G<C9G GIDDCFH 5 <=;<9F G9BGCFM :998657? H<5B 7IG<=CB98 G<C9G K<=7< A5M 69 5 D@5IG=6@9 9LD@5B5H=CB 5G HC K<M ?=B9A5H=7 F9GDCBG9G G=A=@5F HC 65F9:CCH 5F9 G99B <CK9J9F H<=G F9A5=BG GD97I@5H=J9 +CG9 FCKG9F&7 F5H<,5@9FBC05@@5795J=G

(150)

(151) ,EI58FCB9 5@@CNN=

(152)

(153) =B8=B;G:FCA65F9:CCH5B8A=B=A5@=GHFIBB=B;GHI8=9G<5J9F5=G98G9J9F5@=ADCFH5BH DC=BHGC:7CBG=89F5H=CB =FGH@M58=G7CF89L=GHG5GHCK<9H<9F65F9:CCH585DH=CBGC77IF 57IH9@MCF8I9HC7<FCB=765F9:CCHFIBB=B;9LDCGIF9 +9G95F7<CB65F9:CCHFIBB=B; <5G 89ACBGHF5H98 57IH9 58>IGHA9BHG =B :57HCFG GI7< 5G 5B?@9 5B8 ?B99 5B;@9 CB =AD57H5B8F9GI@H5BH7<5B;9G=B:CCHGHF=?9<CK9J9F577CF8=B;HC-5A9H5@

(154) aH<9G97<5B;9G8CBCHC77IF9EI5@@M:CF5@@FIBB9FGb "B7CBHF5GH%=969FA5B9H 5@

(155) <5J989ACBGHF5H98H<5HK<9B<56=HI5@@MG<C8FIBB9FGF5B65F9:CCHC: H<9A 7CBH=BI98 HC <99@ GHF=?9 G CDDCG98 HC FIBB=B; =B H<9 G<C8 7CB8=H=CB H<9 D5FH=7=D5BHG =B H<=G GH5H9 65F9:CCH 5B8 <99@ GHF=?9 K9F9 IB56@9 HC 585DH 5B8 7CBG9EI9BH@M K9F9 9LDCG98 HC <=;<9F =AD57H :CF79G 5B8 @C58=B; F5H9G K<=7< A5M DCG95;F95H9F=B>IFMF=G?H<5B7CBH=BI=B;HCFIB=BG<C9GK=H<5<99@GHF=?9%=969FA5B 9H5@

(156) GGI7<=H=GIB7@95FK<9H<9F585DH=CBGC77IF57IH9@M=AA98=5H9@M5:H9F ACJ=B;:FCAG<C8HC65F9:CCHCF7<FCB=75@@MCJ9FH=A9K=H<5;F58I5@G<=:H5K5M:FCA <56=HI5@6=CA97<5B=7G ,97CB8@MH<97CAACB@MDCDI@5F=G98H<9CFMH<5H5@@G<C8FIBB9FGGHF=?9K=H<H<9<99@ 5B8H<5H5@@65F9:CCHFIBB9FGG<=:HHC5A=8:CCH :CF9:CCHGHF=?9=G5;9B9F5@=G5H=CB5B8 5B CJ9FG=AD@=:=75H=CB C: 5 7CAD@9L 6=CA97<5B=75@ =GGI9 -5A 9H 5@

(157) !5H5@5 =B;K5@@0IB89F@=7<5B8+=7<ACB8

(158) <5J989ACBGHF5H98H<5H9J9B5ACB;GH5 <56=HI5@@M65F9:CCHDCDI@5H=CB C:H<9FIBB9FG@5B898CBH<9=F<99@G 88=H=CB5@@M 6CH<:CCHGHF=?95B;@95B8HMD9+,&,CF,75B69<=;<@MJ5F=56@96CH<K=H<=B 5B869HK99B=B8=J=8I5@G9GD97=5@@M5ACB;<56=HI5@@M65F9:CCH=B8=J=8I5@G%=969FA5B 9H5@

(159) 7CAACBH<9A95ACB;GH65F9:CCH5B8A=B=A5@=GHFIBB=B;GHI8=9G=GHC 7CBHFC@ :CF H<9 GHF=?=B; D5HH9FB C: D5FH=7=D5BHG K=H<=B H<9 =B7@IG=CB 7F=H9F=5 ` =B CH<9F KCF8G5@K5MGIG=B;F95F:CCHGHF=?9FG:CF5<56=HI5@@MG<C8DCDI@5H=CB,=B7@5=F9H5@

(160) 0=@@M5J=G

(161) ,EI58FCB99H5@

(162) -<9F9:CF9=H=GIB7@95FK<9H<9F. . .

(163) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. D5FH=7=D5BHG=B5GHI8MK=H<8=::9F9BH=5@:CCHGHF=?9D5HH9FBGA5M9L<=6=HG=A=@5F?=B9H=7 5B8?=B9A5H=75@H9F5H=CBGK=H<H<9=BHFC8I7H=CBC:A=B=A5@=GH:CCHK95F %5GH@MH<9=B8=J=8I5@6=CA97<5B=75@58>IGHA9BHG=BF9GDCBG9HCA=B=A5@=GH:CCHK95F GHF5H9;=9G 5DD95F HC 69 G=;B=:=75BH@M =B:@I9B798 6M H<9 HMD9 C: :CCHK95F IG98 B IB79FH5=BHM 9L=GHG 5G HC K<=7< :CCHK95F A5F?9H98 5G A=B=A5@=GH 69GH G=AI@5H9G 65F9:CCHFIBB=B;A97<5B=7G!C@@5B89FF;I6=0C@@9G9B+99F297<

(164) 'CB 7IG<=CB98 A=B=A5@=GH :CCHK95F K=H< @CK <99@ <9=;<HG 5B8 A=B=A5@ G<C7? 56GCFDH=CB 5DD95FHC69ACF99::97H=J9=BG=AI@5H=B;65F9:CCH7CB8=H=CBG!C@@5B89F9H5@

(165) ,EI58FCB99H5@

(166) !CK9J9FG=B79H<9F95F98=::9F9BH:CCHK95FCDH=CBGA5F?9H98 5GaA=B=A5@=GHb5IB=J9FG5@@M5779DH986=CA97<5B=75@GH5B79HCA=B=A5@=GHFIBB=B;=G IB:95G=6@9 -<=G<=;<@=;<HGH<9B998:CFA=B=A5@=GH:CCHK95FHC69GHI8=98=B=GC@5H=CB 5B8H<989;F99HCK<=7<9LHF5DC@5H=CBG5B8;9B9F5@=G5H=CBG5F9A589AIGH698CB9 K=H<75IH=CB -<9F9@95G9C:<F=GHCD<9F&57CI;5@@cG6CC?695;6"<50++,5$90),#<7,9 (;/3,;,:(5+;/,9,(;,:;"(*,05;/,'693+ =G7CAACB@M7=H985GH<9HIFB=B; DC=BH =B K<=7< =BH9F9GHG =B 65F9:CCH 5B8 A=B=A5@=GH FIBB=B; GH5FH98 HC =B7F95G9 8F5A5H=75@@M )5I@G $F5J=HN

(167) #9B?=BG 5IH<CB

(168)

(169) +=L9 9H 5@

(170) &IFD<MIFFM&5HN?=B

(171) 5J=G

(172) $5D@5B

(173) "BH<=GF97CF86F95?=B; 69GH G9@@9F &57CI;5@@ 89G7F=69G <CK 5 F9ACH9 &9L=75B HF=69 H<9 -5F5<IA5F5"B8=5BGG9@:=89BH=:=985GH<9+5FOAIF=FCIH=B9@MFIB<IB8F98GC:A=@9G 5 K99? K<=@GH K95F=B; G5B85@G :5G<=CB98 :FCA H=F9HF958 GC@9G &57CI;5@@ K9BHCBHC9LD@5=B<CKH<9G9FIBB9FG58CDH5a65F9:CCHGHM@9bC:FIBB=B;7<5F57H9F=G98 6M:CF9:CCHGHF=?9G5B8G<CFH9FGHF=89GK<=7<<97F98=H98HCH<9A=B=A5@DFCH97H=CB5B8 A5L=A5@:@9L=6=@=HMC:H<9=FG5B85@G+=L99H5@

(174) ,=B79H<9B5;@C65@8=G7IGG=CB 5ACB;GHF9G95F7<9FG7C57<9G7@=B=7=5BG5B85H<@9H9G<5GH5?9BD@579@958=B;HC5 D@9H<CF5C:<MDCH<9G9GF9;5F8=B;A=B=A5@=GHFIBB=B; BIA69FC:A=B=A5@=GH:CCHK95F GHI8=9G9L=GHM9HHCCIF?BCK@98;9CB@MCB9CH<9FGHI8M<5G5HH9ADH98HC89G7F=69 H<9 6=CA97<5B=75@ 9::97HG C: FIBB=B; =B A=B=A5@=GH G5B85@G %=969FA5B

(175) <5G 5GG9GG98H<9J5F=5H=CBG=B:CCHGHF=?9D5HH9FBG5ACB;GH5;FCIDC:-5F5<IA5F5"B8=5BG K<CK9F9H<9:C7IGHF=69C:&57CI;5@@cG 6CC? %=969FA5B

(176) C6G9FJ98. . .

(177) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. H<5H-5F5<IA5F5GK<C<56=HI5@@MKCF9A=B=A5@=GHG5B85@GK9F9DF98CA=B5BH@MA=8:CCH GHF=?9FG K<9F95G<56=HI5@@MG<C8-5F5<IA5F5G9L<=6=H985AI7<ACF9F95F:CCH GHF=?=B;D5HH9FB -<9?=B9A5H=75B5@MG=GC:H<9-5F5<IA5F5:CCHGHF=?9D5HH9FBG =GCB9C:BCJ9@HM<CK9J9F=HG97C@C;=75@J5@=8=HM=GEI9GH=CB98CB577CIBHC:H<9GHI8M G5AD@969=B;8F5KB:FCA5GA5@@DCDI@5H=CBH<5HA5M<5J9GCA9GD97=:=79JC@IH=CB5FM 5B8;9C;F5D<=75@585DH=CBGH<5H8CBCH5DD@MHC5@@8=GH5B79FIBB9FG 88=H=CB5@@M &57CI;5@@cG 6CC? =G 5@GC 7F98=H98 :CF 7CBHF=6IH=B; HC 5BCH<9F FIBB=B;F9JC@IH=CBB5A9@MFIBB=B;@CB;9F5B88C=B;GCCBHF5=@G5J=8%9<97?5

(178) -F5=@ FIBB=B; 5G =H =G DCDI@5F@M ?BCKB =G 89:=B98 6M H<9 "BH9FB5H=CB5@ -F5=@ +IBB=B;GGC7=5H=CB"-+5Ga5D989GHF=5B5B8C::FC58F5797CB8I7H98=B5B5HIF5@ 9BJ=FCBA9BH9 ; ACIBH5=BK=H<A=B=A5@DCGG=6@9D5J98CF5GD<5@HFC58 C:H<9 HCH5@ 8IF5H=CB F579b <FGHFWA -5FH5FI;5 5GH<CD9 F=GGK5@H9F &CF=B /9F7FIMGG9B

(179) "B 577CF85B79 K=H< H<=G 89:=B=H=CB HF5=@ FIBB=B; =G 7<5F57H9F=G986M@5F;9DCG=H=J95B8B9;5H=J99@9J5H=CB7<5B;9GK<=7<=B8I79A5>CF D<MG=C@C;=75@5B8A97<5B=75@F9GDCBG9G8=::9F=B;;F95H@M:FCAH<9F9GDCBG9G9@=7=H98 6MFC58CF@9J9@FIBB=B;DFC:=@9G =5B8C@=B=!CFJ5=G+CGG=&=@@9H&CF=B,5ACN=BC

(180) <FGHFWA9H5@

(181) -F5=@FIBB=B;DFC:=@9GA5M697@5GG=:=985GG<CFH8=GH5B79 @9GGH<5B ?=@CA9HF9GHCI@HF58=GH5B79K<=7<=B7@I89GH<9DCDI@5F ?=@CA9HF9 A=@9

(182) ?=@CA9HF95B8

(183) ?=@CA9HF9

(184) A=@9F5798=GH5B79G DFCDCFH=CB5@@M @5F;9F BIA69F C: HF5=@ FIBB9FG IG9 A=B=A5@=GH G<C9G 5G CDDCG98 HC FC58 FIBB9FG $5GA9F %=I +C69FHG /5@585C

(185) 77CF8=B; HC $5GA9F 9H 5@

(186)

(187) aA=B=A5@=GHG<C9GA5MF9DF9G9BH5F95GCB56@9HF5=B=B;AC8=:=75H=CB:CFH<CG9FIBB9FG K95F=B;HF58=H=CB5@G<C9GHC=ADFCJ9D9F:CFA5B79b=BHF5=@FIBB=B; -<9 ;@C65@ 8=G7IGG=CB GIFFCIB8=B; H<9 65F9:CCH 5B8 A=B=A5@=GH FIBB=B; 8965H9 5DD95FGHC<5J98=A=B=G<98=BF979BHM95FG "H=G7@95FH<5HH<9F95F9GH=@@5BIA69FC: IB5BGK9F98 EI9GH=CBG 5B8 7CBHF58=7H=CBG GIFFCIB8=B; J5F=CIG 5GD97HG C: H<=G 5:CF9A9BH=CB98 HCD=7 @H<CI;< H<9F9 =G BC 897=G=J9 85H5 HC GI;;9GH 5 75IG5@ F9@5H=CBG<=D69HK99B:CCHK95FIG95B8++"F=G?H<9F9=G57CAD9@@=B;5F;IA9BH:CF H<9=B7@IG=CBC:65F9:CCHCFA=B=A5@=GHHF5=B=B;=B5FIBB9FcGDFC;F5AA99GD97=5@@M=B H<9 75G9 C: HF5=@ FIBB9FG "B:CFA5H=CB F9;5F8=B; H<9 57IH9 585DH=CBG HC A=B=A5@=GH. . .

(188) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. :CCHK95FA5M5@@CKFIBB9FGHCA5?9=B:CFA98897=G=CBGCBK<=7<A=B=A5@=GH:CCHK95F HCIG9G<CI@8H<9M7<CCG9HC58CDH5A=B=A5@=GHFIBB=B;DFC;F5AA9 -<IGH<=GGHI8M 7CI@8F9=;B=H9H<9;@C65@8=G7IGG=CBCBA=B=A5@=GH5B865F9:CCHFIBB=B;6MIG=B;CB9 C:H<9ACGHDF=A=H=J9:CFAGC:FIBB=B;:CCHK95FH<9G5B85@ "H5@GCG99AG:=HH=B;H<5H H<=G HMD9 C: A=B=A5@=GH :CCHK95F 69 IG98 HC GD5F? 8=G7IGG=CB 65G98 CB =HG <=;<@M DCDI@5F=G98FC@9=B&57CI;5@@cG F97CF86F95?=B;BCJ9@ IFH<9FACF96MBCH 7CBHFC@@=B;:CF:CCHGHF=?9D5HH9FB=B7@IG=CB7F=H9F=5H<9;5DG=BH<9@=H9F5HIF97CB79FB=B; H<9J5F=56=@=HMC:6=CA97<5B=75@F9GDCBG9G:FCAFIBB9FGA5M9=H<9F697CB:=FA98CF F9:IH98K=H<H<=GGHI8M . "#$$$"$"$#$%) "H =G 7@95F H<5H =B8=J=8I5@ A=B=A5@=GH :CCHK95F A5?9G AC89@G A5M 9@=7=H 8=::9F9BH=5@ 6=CA97<5B=75@F9GDCBG9GH<5H5F99=H<9FACF9G=A=@5FHC69=B;65F9:CCHCFHCK95F=B; G<C9G -<9F9 5F9 7IFF9BH@M A=B=A5@=GH FIBB=B; G5B85@G 5J5=@56@9 CB H<9 A5F?9H <CK9J9FH<9F9=GBCF9G95F7<65G98@=H9F5HIF9HC89G7F=69K<9F9CBH<96=CA97<5B=75@ 7CBH=BIIA69HK99B65F9:CCH5B8G<C8H<=G:CCHK95FG=HG 88=H=CB5@@M5GA=B=A5@=GH FIBB=B;=G697CA=B;ACF9DCDI@5F5ACB;GHHF5=@FIBB9FG8I9HCH<9DFCDCG9869B9:=HG C:897F95G98=B>IFM5B8=B7F95G98D9F:CFA5B7957589A=7@=H9F5HIF9GIFFCIB8=B;H<9 5:CF9A9BH=CB98 HCD=7 =G GH=@@ =B =HG =B:5B7M @H<CI;< H<9F9 <5J9 699B A5BM GHI8=9G 89G7F=6=B;H<957IH99::97HGC:A=B=A5@=GH:CCHK95FCBFC585B8HF57?FIBB9FGJ9FM:9K GHI8=9G9L=GHH<5H5F9GD97=:=7HCHF5=@FIBB9FG -<IGH<9=BJ9GH=;5H=CB=BHCH<99::97HGC: A=B=A5@=GHG5B85@GCBHF5=@FIBB=B;6=CA97<5B=7GG<CI@8G9FJ9HKC:C@8HC7CBHF=6IH9 HCH<9G75F79@=H9F5HIF9GIFFCIB8=B;HF5=@FIBB=B;5B8=B8C=B;GCHC7CBHF=6IH9HCH<9 @=H9F5HIF9GIFFCIB8=B;5A=B=A5@=GH:CCHK95FCDH=CBH<5H<5GBCH699B57IH9@MGHI8=98 69:CF9 &CF9CJ9F H<9 @CK9F@=A6 J5F=56@9G A95GIF98 =B H<=G GHI8M K9F9 GD97=:=75@@M 7<CG9B6975IG9C:H<9=FF9@5H=CBG<=DK=H<=B>IFM5B8D9F:CFA5B79H<IGHF5=@FIBB9FG A5M 69 56@9 HC IG9 9J=89B7965G98 =B:CFA5H=CB =B A5?=B; =B:CFA98 897=G=CBG F9;5F8=B;H<9IG9C:A=B=A5@=GHG5B85@G=BH<9=FHF5=B=B;DFC;F5AA9G . . .

(189) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za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

(190) J9FH=75@5J9F5;9@C58=B;F5H9/%+ J9FH=75@=BGH5BH5B9CIG@C58=B;F5H9/"%+ :CCHGHF=?95B;@9, 5B?@98CFG=:@9L=CB5B;@95H7CBH57H ?B99:@9L=CB5B;@95H7CBH57H ?B99:@9L=CBF5B;9C:ACH=CB+(&8IF=B;GH5B79D<5G9 B98=1.<2<<=*=.6.7= ".<.*;,1 1B98=1.<2< "H K5G <MDCH<9G=G98 H<5H A=B=A5@=GH G5B85@ FIBB=B; KCI@8 F9GI@H =B G=A=@5F ?=B9H=7G 5B8 ?=B9A5H=7G HC 65F9:CCH FIBB=B; 5G CDDCG98 HC 5 G<C8 FIBB=B;7CB8=H=CB8IF=B;5B57IH9GI6A5L=A5@@9J9@HF958A=@@FIBB=B;6CIH=B7@I8=B; <=;<9F/%+5B8/"%+GA5@@9F,@9GG5B?@98CFG=:@9L=CB5H7CBH57H;F95H9F?B99 :@9L=CB5H7CBH57H5B8@9GG?B99:@9L=CB+(&8IF=B;GH5B79D<5G9 . .

(191) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. $1.7>551B98=1.<2<:CFH<9DF9798=B;F9G95F7<<MDCH<9G=G=GH<5HH<9F9KCI@8 69BCG=;B=:=75BH?=B9H=75B8?=B9A5H=78=::9F9B79G69HK99BA=B=A5@=GHG5B85@G<C8 5B865F9:CCHGI6A5L=A5@@9J9@HF958A=@@FIBB=B;! ]

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

(193) ##% $# 9FH5=B5GGIADH=CBGK9F9A589K=H<F9;5F8HCH<9D5FH=7=D5BHG85H57C@@97H=CB5B8 H<9GHI8M=HG9@: IF=B;H<9F97FI=HA9BHDFC79GGD5FH=7=D5BHGK9F9A5895K5F9C:H<9 =B7@IG=CB5B89L7@IG=CB7F=H9F=5 "HK5G5GGIA98H<5HD5FH=7=D5BHGK9F9<CB9GH56CIH. .

(194) .

(195) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. H<9=FHF5=@FIBB=B;9LD9F=9B795B8H<9D9F79BH5;9C:H<9=FHCH5@HF5=B=B;A=@95;9GD9BH CB5HF5=@FIBB=B;GIF:579=BCF89FHC69=B7@I898=BH<9GHI8M IFH<9FACF9F9;5F8=B; H<9D5FH=7=D5BHG75IH=CBK5G58J=G985;5=BGH7CBGIA=B;5@7C<C@5B875::9=B9K=H<=B HK9BHM:CIF <CIFG DF=CF HC H9GH=B; 5B8 =H K5G 5GGIA98 H<5H H<9M :C@@CK98 H<9 =BGHFI7H=CBGH<5HK9F9;=J9BHCH<9A "HK5G5@GC5GGIA98H<5HH<9D5FH=7=D5BHGK9F9 <CB9GH CB K<9H<9F H<9M F9:F5=B98 :FCA 7CBGIA=B; 5@7C<C@ 5B8 75::9=B9 K<9B EI9GH=CB986MH<9F9G95F7<9FG %5GH@MH<95GGIADH=CBK5GA589H<5HD5FH=7=D5BHG<58 BCDF=CF?BCK@98;9CF9LD9F=9B79K=H<F9;5F8HCA=B=A5@=GH:CCHK95F -<9H9GH=B;9EI=DA9BHK5G7<97?986M6CH<H<9F9G95F7<9FG5B8@56CF5HCFMGH5::DF=CF HC85H57C@@97H=CBH<IG=HK5G5GGIA98H<5HH<99EI=DA9BHDFC8I798J5@=85B8F9@=56@9 85H5CBH<98=::9F9BHH9GH=B;85MG IF=B;H<9G9GG=CBF975@=6F5H=CBGK9F97CBH=BICIG@M 8CB9HC9BGIF9H<985H5K9F9F9@=56@9 . . . .

(196)

(197) .

(198) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. $" $"$$($ $"%$ +IBB=B; <5G 9JC@J98 :FCA 5 :CFA C: @C7CACH=CB H<5H =G B979GG5FM :CF GIFJ=J5@ HC 5 F97F95H=CB5@ 57H=J=HM 9B>CM98 6M A=@@=CBG KCF@8K=89 +=L9 9H 5@

(199) IF=B; H<=G HF5BG=H=CB :CCHK95F <5G 7<5B;98 8F5A5H=75@@M :FCA H<9 A=B=A5@=GH :CCHK95F :=FGH 89J9@CD986MCIF5B79GHCFGHCH<97IG<=CB98G<C9GBCKA5F?9H98:CF7CA:CFH=B>IFM DFCH97H=CB5B87CFF97H=B;ACJ9A9BHD5HH9FBG@HA5B5J=G

(200) 19H=B>IF=9GGH=@@ D9FG=GH9J9BK=H<H<958J5B79A9BH=B7IFF9BHG<C989G=;B5B8H97<BC@C;M -<9GHI8M C: 6=CA97<5B=7G 5@@CKG IG HC 9GH56@=G< H<9 59H=C@C;M C: J5F=CIG AIG7I@CG?9@9H5@ =B>IF=9G5GK9@@5GH<9DF=B7=D@9GIB89F@M=B;GI779GG:I@H97<B=EI9/5I;<5B

(201) -<=G 7<5DH9F GH5FHG C:: 6M 89:=B=B; H<9 FIBB=B; ;5=H 7M7@9 =B CF89F HC F97C;B=G9 H<9 G9EI9B79 C: ACJ9A9BHG 5B8 ACA9BHG =B H=A9 B979GG5FM HC IB89FGH5B8 H<9 6=CA97<5B=7GC:65F9:CCH5B8A=B=A5@=GHFIBB=B;89G7F=698@5H9FCB=BH<97<5DH9F 8=GH=B7H=CB =G A589 69HK99B K5@?=B; 5B8 FIBB=B; ;5=H HC :IFH<9F 9B<5B79 H<9 IB89FGH5B8=B;C:FIBB=B;;5=H C@@CK=B;CB:FCAH<=G65F9:CCH5B8A=B=A5@=GHFIBB=B; =G 7CB79DHI5@=G98 H<9F96M 8=GH=B;I=G<=B; 69HK99B HKC 7CB8=H=CBG "B CF89F HC 69HH9F IB89FGH5B8 K<M 65F9:CCH 5B8 A=B=A5@=GH FIBB=B; <5J9 697CA9 DCDI@5F=G98 :57HCFG =B7@I8=B; H<9 9B8IF5B79FIBB=B; <MDCH<9G=G 5B8 A=GA5H7< H<9CFM C: 9JC@IH=CB 5F9 DF9G9BH98 0<=@9 H<9G9 H<9CF=9G C::9F 5 7CAD9@@=B; 5F;IA9BH :CF H<9 =B7@IG=CB C: 65F9:CCH 5B8 A=B=A5@=GH FIBB=B; =B 5 FIBB9FcG HF5=B=B; DFC;F5AA9 5 6=CA97<5B=75@ >IGH=:=75H=CB =G 5@GC B99898 -<IG 5 A5>CF :C7IG :C@@CK=B; CB :FCA H<=G G97H=CB 5GG=A=@5H9GH<9?BCKB@CK9F@=A6?=B9A5H=7G5B8?=B9H=7GC:A=B=A5@=GHFIBB=B;G<C9G 7CBJ9BH=CB5@FIBB=B;G<C9G5B8FIBB=B;65F9:CCH HH<9HKC9B8GC:H<9GD97HFIAH<98=::9F9B79G69HK99B65F9:CCH5B8G<C8FIBB=B; 5F989G7F=698K=H<=B957<A9BH=CB98?=B9A5H=75B8?=B9H=7J5F=56@95GGC7=5H98K=H< H<=GGHI8M "BH9FAGC:?=B9A5H=7G$*+5.< =8 <5J9699BIG98HCGIAA5F=G9 GHI8=9G G<CK=B; H<9 57IH9 9::97HG C: A=B=A5@=GH :CCHK95F CB :CCH GHF=?9 5B;@9G 5B8 .

(202) .

(203) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. D5HH9FBG 5B?@9 8CFG=:@9L=CB 5B;@9 5H 7CBH57H 5B8 ?B99 :@9L=CB 5B;@9G 5H 7CBH57H F9GD97H=J9@M8IF=B;GI6A5L=A5@@9J9@FIBB=B; ,D97=5@5HH9BH=CB=G8F5KBHCH<9HMD9 C:A=B=A5@=GH:CCHK95FIG985GK9@@5GH<9A9H<C8C@C;M9AD@CM98 -<9F95F9J9FM:9KGHI8=9G89G7F=6=B;H<99::97HGC:A=B=A5@=GH:CCHK95FCB?B99:@9L=CB +(& K<=7< =G K<M 5 6F=9: G97H=CB =G =B7@I898 -<9 5:CF9A9BH=CB98 ?=B9A5H=7G C: 65F9:CCH5B8A=B=A5@=GHFIBB=B;5F98=G7IGG98=B@=;<HC:F98I7=B;=AD57H:CF79GK<=7< 5F9 89G7F=698 @5H9F CB =B H<=G 7<5DH9F GD97=:=75@@M K=H< F9;5F8G HC FIBB=B;F9@5H98 =B>IF=9G -<97<5DH9F9B8GC::K=H<56F=9:=BHFC8I7H=CB=BHCHF5=@FIBB=B;5B85BCJ9FJ=9K C: H<9 HMD=75@ 6=CA97<5B=75@ DFC:=@9 C: 5 HF5=@ FIBB9F -<=G F9J=9K 8C9G BCH 5=A HC GIDDCFH9=H<9F7CBJ9BH=CB5@FIBB=B;G<C9G65F9:CCHCFA=B=A5@=GHFIBB=B;G<C9G6IH F5H<9FHC<=;<@=;<HH<9?BCKB@=H9F5HIF969<=B8957<7CB8=H=CB 0<9F9DCGG=6@96CH< H<969B9:=HG5B8F=G?GC:957<:CCHK95F7CB8=H=CB5F9A9BH=CB98 88=H=CB5@@M;5DG=B H<9@=H9F5HIF95F9=89BH=:=98K<=7<H<=GGHI8M5=AGHC588F9GG . $$)%"#$"% ">77270?.;<><@*542700*2= G H<9 BIA69F C: D5FH=7=D5BHG =B 8=GH5B79 FIBB=B; 7CBH=BI9G HC ;FCK =B7F95G98 =B7=89B79GC:57IH95B87<FCB=7=B>IF=9G7CBH=BI9HCC77IF577CF8=B;@MI;5B<5H H<CFCI;< IB89FGH5B8=B; C: HMD=75@ FIBB=B; ;5=H =G H<IG 7F=H=75@ =B CF89F HC DF9J9BH 5B8 DFCD9F@M HF95H H<9G9 =B>IF=9G -<9 ;5=H 7M7@9 75B 69 89G7F=698 5G 5 G9EI9B79 C: ACJ9A9BHG C: H<9 @CK9F @=A6G H<5H 69;=BG K<9B CB9 :CCH 7CA9G =BHC 7CBH57H K=H< H<9 ;FCIB8 =B=H=5@ 7CBH57H 5B8 H9FA=B5H9G K<9B H<9 G5A9 :CCH A5?9G 7CBH57HK=H<H<9;FCIB85;5=B'CJ57<97?

(204) -C9B<5B79H<9IB89FGH5B8=B;C: H<9FIBB=B;;5=H7M7@958=GH=B7H=CB=GA58969HK99BK5@?=B;5B8FIBB=B;;5=H 9GD=H9 A5BMG=A=@5F=H=9GFIBB=B;5B8K5@?=B;8=::9FA5=B@M=B=GD5H=CH9ADCF5@7<5F57H9F=GH=7G F9:@97H98=BH<9+<;@-(*;69H<9:F57H=CBC:H=A969HK99BGHF=89GK<9F9H<9:CCH=G=B 7CBH57HK=H<H<9;FCIB8==:@I7HI5H=CBG=B;F5J=H5H=CB5@DCH9BH=5@5B8?=B9H=79B9F;MC: H<9 6C8McG 79BHF9 C: A5GG C& K<=7< 5F9 CIHC:D<5G9 =B K5@?=B; 5B8 =BD<5G9 8IF=B;FIBB=B;5B8===8=::9F9B79G=BH<9=F9::97H=J9B9GGC:GD998F5B;9G= 9 G@CK GD998:CFK5@?=B;5B8:5GH9FGD998:CFFIBB=B;,9;9FG%9BC=F9FHG9@9F7E .

(205) .

(206) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. -<9:CFA9FHKC8=GH=B7H=CBGH<9GD5H=CH9ADCF5@89:=B=H=CB5B89B9F;M89:=B=H=CB 5F9H<9ACGH7CAACBA9H<C8G:CF8=GH=B;I=G<=B;K5@?=B;:FCAFIBB=B;5B85F9H<IG 89G7F=698K=H<=BH<=GG97H=CB 0 #7(;06;,4769(3*/(9(*;,90:;0*:9,-3,*;,+05;/,+<;@-(*;69 CH< K5@?=B; 5B8 FIBB=B; ;5=H =B7@I89 HKC A5=B D<5G9G H<9 GH5B79 D<5G9 5B8 H<9 GK=B;D<5G95GK9@@5GH<F99A5=BACA9BHG=BH=A9=B=H=5@7CBH57H<9F95:H9F7CBH57H A=8GH5B795B8HC9C::'CJ57<97?

(207) I;5B<5H -<9GH5B79D<5G9 C77IFG8IF=B;H<9D9F=C8C:H=A9K<9BH<9:CCH=G=B7CBH57HK=H<H<9;FCIB8K<9F95G H<9 GK=B; D<5G9 C77IFG K<9B H<5H G5A9 :CCH @95J9G H<9 ;FCIB8 5H HC9C:: IBH=@ H<9 :C@@CK=B;:CCH7CBH57H=7<5FFM

(208) +IBB=B;7CBH5=BG5B588=H=CB5@a:@C5HD<5G9b K<=7<C77IFGHK=798IF=B;H<9FIBB=B;;5=H7M7@95B8=GH<9D9F=C8C:H=A969HK99BH<9 GH5B79D<5G95B8GK=B;D<5G9K<9B6CH<@CK9F9LHF9A=H=9G5F9BCH=B7CBH57HK=H<H<9 ;FCIB8G9920>;. =7<5FFM

(209) '=7C@5#9K=GCB

(210) -<9F9:CF9K5@?9FG 7CBGH5BH@M<5J99=H<9FCB9G=B;@9GIDDCFHCFHKC8CI6@9GIDDCFHC:H<9=F@CK9F@=A6G =B7CBH57HK=H<H<9;FCIB8K<9F95GFIBB9FG9=H<9F<5J95G=B;@9@=A6CFBC@=A6G=B 7CBH57HK=H<H<9;FCIB88IF=B;H<9;5=H7M7@9=7<5FFM

(211) I9HCH<9DF9G9B79C:H<9:@C5HD<5G9H<9GH5B79D<5G9=BFIBB=B;=GG<CFH9FK<=@9 H<9GK=B;D<5G9=G@CB;9F=B7CAD5F=GCBHCK5@?=B;I;5B<5H -<9FIBB=B; GH5B79D<5G9=GHMD=75@@MG<CFH9FH<5B C:H<9;5=H7M7@9K<9F95GH<9GH5B79D<5G9 =BK5@?=B;=G@CB;9FH<5B C:H<9HCH5@;5=H7M7@9'CJ57<97?

(212) B=B7F95G9=B J9@C7=HM F9GI@HG =B 5 :IFH<9F F98I7H=CB =B GH5B79 D<5G9 K<=@9 GK=B; D<5G9 8IF5H=CB =B7F95G9G I;5B <5H ,D998 =G H<IG 5 7F=H=75@ :57HCF =B 89H9FA=B=B; H<9 D9F79BH5;9C:H=A98IF=B;K<=7<5FIBB9F=G=BGH5B79D<5G9 -<9:IFH<9F9::97HGC: FIBB=B;GD998CB6=CA97<5B=7G5F98=G7IGG98@5H9FCB=BH<=GG97H=CB . .

(213) .

(214) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. 20>;. ,7<9A5H=7F9DF9G9BH5H=CBC:H<9D<5G9GC:H<9K5@?=B;5B8FIBB=B;7M7@9GK=H< GD97=5@ 5HH9BH=CB HC H<9 DF9G9B79 C: 8CI6@9 :@C5H =B FIBB=B; "B=H=5@ CBH57H " &=8GH5B79 &,H -9FA=B5@ ,H5B79 -,H )F9GK=B; ),K "B=H=5@GK=B; ",K &=8GK=B; &,K 5B8 -9FA=B5@GK=B;-,K 0=H<D9FA=GG=CB:FCA%C<A5B""",57?=F=M5G5B8,K9B

(215)

(216) . 00 3<*;<(;065:05.9(=0;(;065(376;,5;0(3,5,9.@(5+205,;0*,5,9.@ -<9 56IB85BH @=H9F5HIF9 C6G9FJ=B; H<9 F9@5H=CBG<=D 69HK99B ?=B9H=7 5B8 DCH9BH=5@ 9B9F;M <5G G<CKB H<=G F9@5H=CBG<=D HC 69 =ADCFH5BH K<9B 8=::9F9BH=5H=B; 69HK99B FIBB=B;5B8K5@?=B;5F@9M9FF=G

(217) 'CJ57<97?

(218) IF=B;K5@?=B;6CH< ?=B9H=7 5B8 ;F5J=H5H=CB5@ DCH9BH=5@ 9B9F;M 5F9 CIHC:D<5G9 A95B=B; H<5H K<9B DCH9BH=5@ 9B9F;M =G <=;< ?=B9H=7 9B9F;M =G @CK 5B8 J=79 J9FG5 'CJ57<97?

(219) ,9J9F5@5IH<CFGGI;;9GHH<95B5@C;MC:K5@?=B;HC69H<5HC:5B=BJ9FH98D9B8I@IA G9920>;. =BK<=7<H<96C8McGC&J5I@HGCJ9F5GCA9K<5HGH=::GH5B79@=A6 IBH=@=HF957<9G=HG<=;<9GHDC=BH=BH<9A=88@9C:GH5B79D<5G95F@9M9FF=G

(220) . .

(221) .

(222) Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za. 'CJ57<97?

(223) 9@5HHF9 %5:CFHIB9 &CF9HHC =7<5FFM

(224) CBG9EI9BH@M A97<5B=75@ 9B9F;M =G @5F;9@M 7CBG9FJ98 8IF=B; K5@?=B; K=H< H<9 7CBJ9FG=CBC:?=B9H=79B9F;M=BHC;F5J=H5H=CB5@DCH9BH=5@9B9F;M5GK9@@5GH<9F97CJ9FM C:?=B9H=79B9F;M:FCAH<9DCH9BH=5@9B9F;M=BH<9GI6G9EI9BHGH9D5J5;50=@@9AG !9;@IB8 CBJ9FG9@MFIBB=B;<5G699B@=?9B98HCH<5HC:5GDF=B;=BK<=7< 95F@M5IH<CFGH9FA98H<=GH<9GDF=B;A5GGAC89@G9920>;. &7&5<CB/5@=5BH F989F=7?

(225) @=7?<5B

(226) &7 99F

(227) -<9 CG7=@@5H=CBG C: ?=B9H=7 5B8 ;F5J=H5H=CB5@ 9B9F;M :@I7HI5H9 =BD<5G9 A95B=B; H<9 6C8McG C& =G @CK9GH 5H A=8 GH5B795F@9M9FF=G

No results found