De kosten-effectiviteit van preventie - een verkennende studie

5,90UDSSRUW 'HNRVWHQHIIHFWLYLWHLWYDQSUHYHQWLH (HQYHUNHQQHQGHVWXGLH 7'LUNPDDW0//YDQ*HQXJWHQ*$GH:LW 'LWRQGHU]RHNZHUGYHUULFKWLQRSGUDFKWHQWHQODVWHYDQKHWPLQLVWHULHYDQ9:6'LUHFWLH 32*LQKHWNDGHUYDQSURMHFW($(FRQRPLVFKHHYDOXDWLHYDQ]RUJHQSUHYHQWLH 5,903RVWEXV%$%LOWKRYHQWHOHIRRQID[

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

$EVWUDFW

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ZKLOHRWKHUVDUHFXUUHQWO\QRWRSWLPDOO\SURYLGHGRU RUJDQLVHGHJIRODWHLQWDNHE\SUHJQDQWZRPHQ6RPHSURJUDPPHVVHHPHVSHFLDOO\ LQWHUHVWLQJIURPDQHPSOR\HUV¶SRLQWRIYLHZLQIOXHQ]DYDFFLQDWLRQRIWKHHPSOR\HG ZKHUHDVRWKHUVKDYHWRGDWHQRWEHHQWKHVXEMHFWRIKHDOWKFDUHSROLF\PDNLQJHJ VFUHHQLQJIRUWKHVH[XDOO\WUDQVPLWWDEOHEDFWHULXP&KODP\GLDWUDFKRPDWLV,QFRQFOXVLRQ WKLVH[SORUDWLYHVWXG\GHPRQVWUDWHVKRZWKHSURYHUEµDQRXQFHRISUHYHQWLRQLVZRUWKD SRXQGRIFXUH¶PD\LQGHHGDSSO\WRFHUWDLQSUHYHQWLYHKHDOWKFDUHSURJUDPPHV

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

,QKRXG

6DPHQYDWWLQJ   ,QOHLGLQJHQDFKWHUJURQG   0HWKRGHQ   $IEDNHQLQJ   :HUNZLM]H   5HVXOWDWHQ   ,QWHUYLHZV   3UHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶V   'LVFXVVLHHQFRQFOXVLH  *HUDDGSOHHJGHOLWHUDWXXUDOJHPHHQ  %LMODJH 9HU]HQGOLMVW  %LMODJH 9UDJHQOLMVWYRRULQWHUYLHZV  %LMODJH 9HUNODUHQGHZRRUGHQOLMVWELMLQWHUYLHZV  %LMODJH /LMVWYDQJHwQWHUYLHZGHSHUVRQHQ  %LMODJH /LMVWYDQJHUDDGSOHHJGHLQWHUQHWVLWHV  %LMODJH 9RRUEHHOGHQYDQNRVWHQHIIHFWLHYHHQNRVWHQEHVSDUHQGHSUHYHQWLHSURMHFWHQ 

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

6DPHQYDWWLQJ

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¶VNRQYRRUSURJUDPPD¶V YROGRHQGHHQNZDOLWDWLHIJRHGHLQIRUPDWLHZRUGHQJHYRQGHQRYHUGHNRVWHQHIIHFWLYLWHLW 'DDUELM]LMQSURJUDPPD¶VGLHVWHYLJ]LMQYHUDQNHUGLQKHW1HGHUODQGVH JH]RQGKHLGV]RUJV\VWHHP]RDOVGHKLHOSULNSURJUDPPD¶VGLHPRPHQWHHOVXERSWLPDDO ZRUGHQXLWJHYRHUG]RDOVIROLXP]XXUVXSSOHWLHWHUSUHYHQWLHYDQQHXUDOHEXLVGHIHFWHQ SURJUDPPD¶VGLHYRRUDOLQWHUHVVDQW]LMQYDQXLWKHWSHUVSHFWLHIYDQGHZHUNJHYHU]RDOV JULHSYDFFLQDWLHYDQJH]RQGHZHUNHQGHQHQSUHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶VZDDURSPRPHQWHHOQRJ JHHQEHOHLGZRUGWJHYRHUG]RDOVVFUHHQLQJRSGHVH[XHHORYHUGUDDJEDUH&KODP\GLD EDFWHULH'LWH[SORUDWLHYHRQGHU]RHNODDW]LHQGDWKHWDGDJLXPµDQRXQFHRISUHYHQWLRQLV ZRUWKDSRXQGRIFXUH¶LQYHHOJHYDOOHQLQGHUGDDGRSJDDW

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

 ,QOHLGLQJHQDFKWHUJURQG

%LQQHQGH'LUHFWLH3UHYHQWLHHQ2SHQEDUH*H]RQGKHLGV]RUJ32*YDQKHWPLQLVWHULHYDQ 9:6ZRUGWPRPHQWHHOJHZHUNWDDQGHQRWD3UHYHQWLHEHOHLGGLHGRRUKHWQLHXZH.DELQHW DDQGH7ZHHGH.DPHU]DOZRUGHQDDQJHERGHQ(HQEHODQJULMNGRHOYDQGHQRWDLVRPGH µRSEUHQJVW¶YDQSUHYHQWLHLQEHHOGWHEUHQJHQ=RZHOELQQHQDOVEXLWHQKHWPLQLVWHULHKHHUVW YDDNGHRSYDWWLQJGDWSUHYHQWLHDOOHHQPDDUJHOGNRVWHQZHLQLJRSOHYHUW%LQQHQGHGLUHFWLH 32*EHVWDDWGDDURPGHEHKRHIWHRPLQGHQRWDRRNGHSRVLWLHYHHIIHFWHQYDQSUHYHQWLHWH SURILOHUHQ'DDUELMZRUGWJHGDFKWDDQ]RZHOHIIHFWHQLQWHUPHQYDQJH]RQGKHLGVZLQVWDOVDDQ HFRQRPLVFKHHQDQGHUHPDDWVFKDSSHOLMNHHIIHFWHQ'HGLUHFWLH32*KHHIWGDDURPDDQKHW &HQWUXPYRRU=RUJRQGHU]RHNYDQKHW5,90QX&HQWUXPYRRU3UHYHQWLHHQ=RUJRQGHU]RHN JHYUDDJGRPRQGHUVWHXQLQJWHELHGHQELMKHW]RHNHQQDDUDDQVSUHNHQGHSUHYHQWLHSURMHFWHQ PHWSRVLWLHYHHFRQRPLVFKHHIIHFWHQ=RPRJHOLMN]RXGHQGH]HDDQVSUHNHQGHYRRUEHHOGHQ EHWUHNNLQJPRHWHQKHEEHQRSGHYHUVFKLOOHQGHGHHOJHELHGHQYDQSUHYHQWLH]RDOV JH]RQGKHLGVEHYRUGHULQJJH]RQGKHLGVEHVFKHUPLQJHQ]LHNWHSUHYHQWLH9HUVFKLOOHQGH LQWHUYHQWLHVHQLQVWUXPHQWHQNXQQHQGDDUELMDDQERGNRPHQ*92ZHWHQUHJHOJHYLQJ SUHYHQWLHELQQHQGH]RUJ]RDOVYHUODJLQJYDQEORHGGUXNHQFKROHVWHUROJHKDOWHYDQKHWEORHG YDFFLQDWLHHQVFUHHQLQJ ,QGHRSGUDFKWZHUGJHIRFXVWRSGHHFRQRPLVFKHRSEUHQJVWYDQSUHYHQWLHYH JH]RQGKHLGVPDDWUHJHOHQ3UHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶VZDDUELMGXVDOOHHQGHJH]RQGKHLGVHIIHFWHQ ]LMQJHsYDOXHHUG]RQGHUGDWDDQGDFKWZRUGWJHVFKRQNHQDDQELMYRRUEHHOGGHWRHNRPVWLJH EHVSDULQJHQRSJH]RQGKHLGV]RUJRIYHUEHWHUGHDUEHLGVSURGXFWLYLWHLWGLHVDPHQKDQJWPHWKHW SUHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD]LMQYRRUGLWRQGHU]RHNGXVPLQGHUUHOHYDQW'DDURYHULVXLWJHEUHLG JHUDSSRUWHHUGLQGH9799DQ2HUV +HWXLWYRHUHQYDQHHQV\VWHPDWLVFKHDOOHVRPYDWWHQGHVWXGLHQDDUµGH¶RSEUHQJVWYDQ µSUHYHQWLH¶ZDVELQQHQGHEHVFKLNEDUHWLMGYDQ]HOIVSUHNHQGQLHWPRJHOLMN:HKHEEHQHUYRRU JHNR]HQRPGHELQQHQHQEXLWHQKHW5,90DDQZH]LJHNHQQLVDDQWHERUHQGRRUPLGGHOYDQ LQWHUYLHZVPHWH[SHUWVHQRSJHOHLGHYDQLQIRUPDWLHXLWGHLQWHUYLHZVJHULFKWQDDUUHOHYDQWH OLWHUDWXXURS]RHNWHJDDQ'HVWXGLHPRHWGDQRRNQDGUXNNHOLMNDOVHHQYHUNHQQLQJYDQKHW RQGHUZHUSZRUGHQJH]LHQ

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

 0HWKRGHQ

 $IEDNHQLQJ

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LQNDDUWJHEUDFKWHQJHUDSSRUWHHUG]LMQ3RVLWLHYH JH]RQGKHLGVHIIHFWHQLQWHUPHQYDQODQJHUOHYHQHQRIYHUEHWHULQJHQLQGHNZDOLWHLWYDQOHYHQ YDOOHQ]RDOVJH]HJGEXLWHQGHYUDDJVWHOOLQJYDQGLWSURMHFW3RVLWLHYHPDDWVFKDSSHOLMNH DVSHFWHQELMYRRUEHHOGLQWHUPHQYDQPDDWVFKDSSHOLMNHSDUWLFLSDWLHYDOOHQRRNEXLWHQGH VFRSHYDQGLWSURMHFW'HPDDWVFKDSSHOLMNHDVSHFWHQGLHRRNLQHFRQRPLVFKHWHUPHQ JHZDDUGHHUGNXQQHQZRUGHQ]RDOVYHUPLQGHUG]LHNWHYHU]XLP]LMQHFKWHUZHORQGHUZHUS YDQGHVWXGLHYRRU]RYHUGDDURYHUJRHGHLQIRUPDWLHEHVFKLNEDDULV $OOHYRUPHQYDQSUHYHQWLHWHZHWHQ  SULPDLUHSUHYHQWLHKHWYRRUNRPHQYDQ]LHNWHQGRRUKHWZHJQHPHQYDQGHRRU]DNHQ  VHFXQGDLUHSUHYHQWLHKHWLQHHQYURHJVWDGLXPRSVSRUHQYDQ]LHNWHQZDDUGRRUHHUGHU PHWEHKDQGHOLQJJHVWDUWNDQZRUGHQHYHQWXHHOJHQH]LQJEHZHUNVWHOOLJGNDQZRUGHQRI YHUHUJHULQJYDQ]LHNWHYRRUNRPHQNDQZRUGHQHQ  WHUWLDLUHSUHYHQWLH]RUJNZDOLWHLWYDQOHYHQKHWRSKHIIHQUHGXFHUHQRIFRPSHQVHUHQ YDQHHQYHUPLQGHUGHJH]RQGKHLGVWRHVWDQGHQRI]HOIUHG]DDPKHLGYDQLQGLYLGXHQ ZRUGHQLQSULQFLSHLQKHWRQGHU]RHNEHWURNNHQ

 :HUNZLM]H

,QGLWRQGHU]RHNZHUGJHEUXLNJHPDDNWYDQHHQFRPELQDWLHYDQH[SHUWLQWHUYLHZVHQJHULFKWH OLWHUDWXXUVWXGLH+HWGRHOYDQGLWRQGHU]RHNLVQLHWRPHHQXLWSXWWHQGRYHU]LFKWYDQDOKHW HFRQRPLVFKHYDOXDWLHRQGHU]RHNRSKHWWHUUHLQYDQSUHYHQWLHWHJHYHQPDDURPDDQVSUHNHQGH YRRUEHHOGHQWHSUHVHQWHUHQYDQSUHYHQWLHYHLQWHUYHQWLHVPHWHQ]HHUJXQVWLJHYHUKRXGLQJ WXVVHQNRVWHQHQHIIHFWHQ9DQZHJHGHEUHHGWHYDQKHWRQGHUZHUSSUHYHQWLHHQKHWNRUWH WLMGVEHVWHNYDQGHVWXGLHWZHHPDDQGHQNRQJHHQYROOHGLJHOLWHUDWXXURQGHU]RHNRYHUGLW RQGHUZHUSZRUGHQXLWJHYRHUG2PVQHOLQWHUHVVDQWHYRRUEHHOGHQWHYLQGHQYDQHFRQRPLVFK LQWHUHVVDQWHSUHYHQWLHSURMHFWHQLVHHQJURRWDDQWDOH[SHUWVJHwQWHUYLHZGDDQGHKDQGYDQHHQ NRUWHYUDJHQOLMVWGLHYRRUKHWLQWHUYLHZZHUGWRHJHVWXXUG]LH%LMODJH'H]HYUDJHQOLMVW JLQJYHUJH]HOGYDQHHQNRUWHXLWHHQ]HWWLQJRYHUGHLQGHYUDJHQOLMVWJHKDQWHHUGHEHJULSSHQ ]RDOVHFRQRPLVFKHHYDOXDWLHNRVWHQHIIHFWLYLWHLWHQHFRQRPLVFKHDVSHFWHQYDQSUHYHQWLH]LH %LMODJHYRRUGH]HEHJULSSHQOLMVW$DQGHH[SHUWVZHUGJHYUDDJGRIKLM]LMYRRUEHHOGHQZLVW YDQRQGHU]RHNZDDUELMDDQGDFKWZDVJHVFKRQNHQDDQGHHFRQRPLVFKHDVSHFWHQYDQSUHYHQWLH 2RNZHUGJHYUDDJGRI]LMSUHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶VNRQGHQQRHPHQGLHYDQXLWHFRQRPLVFK RRJSXQWLQWHUHVVDQWNXQQHQ]LMQELMYRRUEHHOGRPGDW]LMOHLGHQWRWYHUPLQGHUG]LHNWHYHU]XLP 7HQVORWWHZHUGJHYUDDJGRPUHIHUHQWLHVQDDUERHNHQDUWLNHOHQHQJULM]HOLWHUDWXXU 'HLQIRUPDWLHGLHXLWGHLQWHUYLHZVZHUGYHUNUHJHQLVRSEDVLVYDQEUXLNEDDUKHLGJHVFKLIW'LW KHHIWJHOHLGWRWHHQYRRUORSLJHOLMVWYDQRQGHUZHUSHQ3HURQGHUZHUS]LMQJHULFKWGHUHOHYDQWH SXEOLFDWLHVELMHONDDUJH]RFKW'LWLVJHEHXUGRSEDVLVYDQGHGRRUH[SHUWVDDQEHYROHQ

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ SXEOLFDWLHVGRRUWH]RHNHQLQPHGLVFKHHQHFRQRPLVFKHGDWDEDVHV]RDOV0HG/LQHGH &RFKUDQH/LEUDU\2+(GDWDEDVHHQGRRUWH]RHNHQRS,QWHUQHWELMYRRUEHHOGYLDGHZHEVLWHV YDQGH863UHYHQWLYH6HUYLFHV7DVN)RUFH6FLUXV&'&HQ1+6(FRQRPLF(YDOXDWLRQ 'DWDEDVH1+6((']LH%LMODJHYRRUOLMVWYDQJHUDDGSOHHJGHLQWHUQHWVLWHV,QHHUVWH LQVWDQWLHZHUGJH]RFKWQDDUUHYLHZVRYHUGHLQGHLQWHUYLHZVJHQRHPGHRQGHUZHUSHQRPGDW LQUHYLHZVGHPHHVWEHODQJULMNHSXEOLFDWLHVRSHHQEHSDDOGWHUUHLQZRUGHQJHwGHQWLILFHHUG $OVJHHQUHYLHZVEHVFKLNEDDUZDUHQZHUGJHULFKWJH]RFKWQDDUUHOHYDQWHOLWHUDWXXU3HU RQGHUZHUSZHUGHQGHJHYRQGHQSXEOLFDWLHVEHRRUGHHOGRS  GHHFRQRPLVFKHDVSHFWHQZRUGHQNRVWHQEHVSDULQJHQJHUDSSRUWHHUGLVGDWRSEDVLVYDQ GLUHFWHJH]RQGKHLGV]RUJNRVWHQRIRRNRSEDVLVYDQEHVSDULQJHQRSLQGLUHFWHNRVWHQ EXLWHQGHJH]RQGKHLGV]RUJ]RDOVDUEHLGVYHU]XLPHQDUEHLGVRQJHVFKLNWKHLG",QGLHQHHQ SUHYHQWLHSURJUDPPDQLHWNRVWHQEHVSDUHQGLVZRUGWHHQ]HHUJXQVWLJHNRVWHQ HIIHFWLYLWHLWJHUDSSRUWHHUG"9RRUGHPDWHYDQNRVWHQHIIHFWLYLWHLW]LMQLQKHWDOJHPHHQ JHHQKDUGHJUHQ]HQDDQWHJHYHQDQGHUHRYHUZHJLQJHQ]RDOVGHLQGLYLGXHOHRI FROOHFWLHYH]LHNWHODVWYDQHHQDDQGRHQLQJHQGHWRWDOHEXGJHWWDLUHLPSDFWYDQHHQ SUHYHQWLHSURJUDPPDVSHOHQYDDNRRNHHQUROELMKHWDOGDQQLHWDDQWUHNNHOLMN]LMQYDQKHW SURJUDPPD9RRUSUHYHQWLHYHSURJUDPPD¶VZRUGWZHOJHVSURNHQYDQHHQDINDSSXQW URQGRPFLUFD SHUJHZRQQHQOHYHQVMDDU&DVSDULHHWDO3URJUDPPD¶V PHWHHQODJHUHNRVWHQHIIHFWLYLWHLWVUDWLR]RXGHQGDQDFFHSWDEHO]LMQ2PGDWLQKHWKXLGLJH RQGHU]RHNSULPDLUJHIRFXVWZRUGWRSNRVWHQEHVSDUHQGHRI]HHUNRVWHQHIIHFWLHYH LQWHUYHQWLHVLVDOVDUELWUDLUVHOHFWLHFULWHULXPJHNR]HQYRRUPD[LPDDO SHU JHZRQQHQOHYHQVMDDU  YRRUSUHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶VGLHUHVWHHUGHQQDGH]HHHUVWHVWDSLVNULWLVFKJHNHNHQQDDUGH NZDOLWHLWYDQGHHFRQRPLVFKHHYDOXDWLHV$DQGHUJHOLMNRQGHU]RHNPRJHQEHSDDOGH NZDOLWHLWVHLVHQJHVWHOGZRUGHQGLHXLWSXWWHQG]LMQEHVFKUHYHQLQKDQGERHNHQ]RDOV 'UXPPRQGHWDOHQ*ROGHWDOHQLQQDWLRQDOHULFKWOLMQHQYRRUIDUPDFR HFRQRPLVFKRQGHU]RHN&9=2PGDWGHEHRRUGHOLQJRIHHQRQGHU]RHNXLWJHYRHUG LVYROJHQVGHGDDUYRRUJHOGHQGHNZDOLWHLWVHLVHQWLMGURYHQGLVZHUGLQGLHQEHVFKLNEDDU RRNJHEUXLNJHPDDNWYDQKHWRRUGHHO]RDOVRSJHQRPHQLQUHYLHZVXLWGH1+6(('%LM HONDUWLNHORYHUHFRQRPLVFKHHYDOXDWLHGDWLQGLHGDWDEDVHLVRSJHQRPHQZRUGHQGH NULWLHNSXQWHQYDQJHNZDOLILFHHUGHUHYLHZHUVZHHUJHJHYHQ 1DGH]HEHRRUGHOLQJ]LMQGHLQGLWRQGHU]RHNJHSUHVHQWHHUGHYRRUEHHOGHQYDQ SUHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶VPHWJXQVWLJHHFRQRPLVFKHHIIHFWHQRYHUJHEOHYHQ]LH%LMODJHYRRU EHVFKULMYLQJHQ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 JHEUXLNJHPDDNW

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

 5HVXOWDWHQ

 ,QWHUYLHZV

'HLQWHUYLHZV]LMQRYHUWZHHURQGHVJHKRXGHQ,QGHHHUVWHURQGH]LMQGHVNXQGLJHQELQQHQ KHW5,90JHwQWHUYLHZG$DQKHQLVJHYUDDJGRI]LMRQVDQGHUHGHVNXQGLJHQELQQHQHQEXLWHQ KHW5,90NRQGHQDDQUDGHQ2SEDVLVKLHUYDQLVHHQWZHHGHURQGHLQWHUYLHZVJHKRXGHQPHW GHVNXQGLJHQELQQHQKHW5,90HQH[WHUQHGHVNXQGLJHQ'HLQWHUYLHZVPHWH[WHUQH GHVNXQGLJHQZHUGHQYULMZHODOOHPDDOWHOHIRQLVFKDIJHQRPHQ,QWRWDDOZHUGHQGXVPHQVHQ JHwQWHUYLHZG]LH%LMODJHYRRUHHQOLMVWYDQJHwQWHUYLHZGHSHUVRQHQ9DQDOOHLQWHUYLHZVLV HHQNRUWYHUVODJJHPDDNWGDWDDQGHJHwQWHUYLHZGHQLVJHVWXXUG

 3UHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶V

7LMGHQVGHLQWHUYLHZVZHUGHQLQWRWDDOSUHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶VJHQRHPGGLHPRJHOLMN]HHU NRVWHQHIIHFWLHIRI]HOIVNRVWHQEHVSDUHQG]RXGHQ]LMQ1DGDWGHOLWHUDWXXURYHUGH]H RQGHUZHUSHQLVEHVWXGHHUGNRQGHQGH]HRQGHUZHUSHQLQYLHUYHUVFKLOOHQGHJURHSHQ LQJHGHHOGZRUGHQ *URHS3UHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶VZDDUYDQJXQVWLJHNRVWHQHIIHFWLYLWHLWRQGHUERXZGLVRI GLHPRJHOLMNNRVWHQEHVSDUHQG]LMQ]LH%LMODJHYRRUEHVFKULMYLQJYDQSURJUDPPD¶V œ LQWHQVLHYHEORHGGUXNFRQWUROHELMGLDEHWHVSDWLsQWHQ œ LQWHQVLHYHFRQWUROHYDQEORHGJOXFRVHZDDUGHQELMGLDEHWHVSDWLsQWHQ œ RQGHUGHOHQYDQKHW5LMNVYDFFLQDWLHSURJUDPPDXLWJHZHUNWYRRU%05YDFFLQDWLH œ YHUPLQGHULQJYHWFRQVXPSWLHWHUSUHYHQWLHFRURQDLUHKDUW]LHNWHQ œ JULHSYDFFLQDWLHRXGHUHQ œ IOXRULGHULQJGULQNZDWHU œ JULHSYDFFLQDWLHZHUNHQGHQ œ YDFFLQDWLHWHJHQKHSDWLWLV$ELMJHVHOHFWHHUGHJURHSHQZHUNQHPHUV œ +,9SUHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶V œ IROLXP]XXUVXSSOHWLHWHUSUHYHQWLHYDQQHXUDOHEXLVGHIHFWHQ œ 3.8&+7VFUHHQLQJ œ YDULFHOODZDWHUSRNNHQYDFFLQDWLH œ SUHYHQWLHYDQDFFLGHQWHOHYDOELMRXGHUHQ œ VFUHHQLQJYDQ]ZDQJHUHQRSV\ILOLV œ VWRSSHQPHWURNHQLQWHUYHQWLHV œ FKODP\GLDVFUHHQLQJ œ SQHXPRNRNNHQYDFFLQDWLHYDQRXGHUHQ œ EHYRUGHUHQERUVWYRHGLQJ *URHS3UHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶VGLHPRJHOLMNNRVWHQHIIHFWLHIRINRVWHQEHVSDUHQG]LMQ PDDUZDDUYRRURQYROGRHQGHLQIRUPDWLHRIRQYROGRHQGHNZDOLWDWLHIJRHGHLQIRUPDWLH ZHUGJHYRQGHQEOLMYHQYHUGHUEXLWHQEHVFKRXZLQJLQGLWUDSSRUW œ EHKDQGHOLQJYDQQHNHQODJHUXJSLMQ œ SUHYHQWLHYDQSV\FKRVRFLDOHSUREOHPDWLHN œ RSYRHGLQJVRQGHUVWHXQLQJ œ KHSDWLWLV%VFUHHQLQJ]ZDQJHUHQ

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ œ YHUNHHUVYHLOLJKHLGVPDDWUHJHOHQ œ OHHIVWLMOSURJUDPPD¶VJHULFKWRSPHHUEHZHJHQ œ IDFHWEHOHLG *URHS3UHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶VGLHPRJHOLMN]HHUNRVWHQHIIHFWLHIRINRVWHQEHVSDUHQG ]LMQPDDUZDDURYHUFRQIOLFWHUHQGHLQIRUPDWLHZHUGJHYRQGHQEOLMYHQYHUGHUEXLWHQ EHVFKRXZLQJLQGLWUDSSRUW œ VFUHHQLQJGLDEHWLVFKHUHWLQRSDWKLH œ KHSDWLWLV%YDFFLQDWLHYDQ]XLJHOLQJHQ *URHS3UHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶VPHWJXQVWLJHNRVWHQHIIHFWLYLWHLWGLHRPHHQDQGHUH UHGHQEXLWHQEHVFKRXZLQJEOLMYHQLQGLWUDSSRUW œ WXEHUFXORVHVFUHHQLQJRSPLGGHOEDUHVFKROHQLQ1HGHUODQGJHHQJURRW JH]RQGKHLGVSUREOHHP œ SURJUDPPD¶VJHULFKWRSYRRUNRPHQYDQORRGYHUJLIWLJLQJELMNLQGHUHQLQ1HGHUODQGJHHQ JURRWJH]RQGKHLGVSUREOHHP œ URWDYLUXVYDFFLQDWLHYDFFLQLVYDQGHPDUNWJHKDDOGPRPHQWHHOJHHQYDFFLQEHVFKLNEDDU

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

 'LVFXVVLHHQFRQFOXVLH

9DQGHSUHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶VGLHXLWGH]HLQYHQWDULVDWLHQDDUYRUHQNRPHQDOV]HHU NRVWHQHIIHFWLHIRIPRJHOLMNNRVWHQEHVSDUHQGLVHHQDDQWDOSURJUDPPD¶VVWHYLJYHUDQNHUGLQ RQV1HGHUODQGVHJH]RQGKHLGV]RUJV\VWHHP'DDUWRHEHKRUHQ œ %05YDFFLQDWLH œ JULHSYDFFLQDWLHRXGHUHQ œ 3.8&+7VFUHHQLQJ œ VFUHHQLQJYDQ]ZDQJHUHQRSV\ILOLV $DQGHDQGHUHNDQW]LMQHURRNSUHYHQWLHYHLQWHUYHQWLHVELMZDDUYRRUPRPHQWHHOQRJJHHQ EHOHLGJHYRHUGZRUGW œ FKODP\GLDVFUHHQLQJ œ YDULFHOODZDWHUSRNNHQYDFFLQDWLH œ SQHXPRNRNNHQYDFFLQDWLHYDQRXGHUHQ œ IOXRULGHULQJGULQNZDWHU 9RRUGHYROJHQGHLQWHUYHQWLHVJHOGWGDW]HZHOWRWRS]HNHUHKRRJWHJHwPSOHPHQWHHUG]LMQ PDDUGDWRQGXLGHOLMNLVLQKRHYHUUHGHYROOHGLJHGRHOJURHSEHUHLNWZRUGWFTWRHJDQJKHHIW WRWGHLQWHUYHQWLHV,QHONJHYDOZRUGHQGHYROJHQGHLQWHUYHQWLHVQLHWV\VWHPDWLVFK DDQJHERGHQ œ LQWHQVLHYHEORHGGUXNFRQWUROHELMGLDEHWHVSDWLsQWHQ œ LQWHQVLHYHFRQWUROHYDQEORHGJOXFRVHZDDUGHQELMGLDEHWHVSDWLsQWHQ œ SURJUDPPD¶VJHULFKWRSYHUPLQGHULQJYHWFRQVXPSWLHWHUSUHYHQWLHFRURQDLUHKDUW]LHNWHQ œ +,9SUHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶V œ IROLXP]XXUVXSSOHWLHWHUSUHYHQWLHYDQQHXUDOHEXLVGHIHFWHQ œ VWRSSHQPHWURNHQLQWHUYHQWLHV œ SUHYHQWLHYDQDFFLGHQWHOHYDOELMRXGHUHQ œ LQWHUYHQWLHVJHULFKWRSKHWEHYRUGHUHQYDQERUVWYRHGLQJ 7HQVORWWH]LMQHUQRJSUHYHQWLHYHLQWHUYHQWLHVGLHYRRUDOYDQXLWKHWZHUNJHYHUVSHUVSHFWLHI DDQWUHNNHOLMN]LMQKHWOLJWGDQRRNPLQGHUYRRUGHKDQGGDWGHRYHUKHLGKLHURSEHOHLG]DO JDDQYRHUHQ œ JULHSYDFFLQDWLHZHUNHQGHQ œ YDFFLQDWLHWHJHQKHSDWLWLV$ELMJHVHOHFWHHUGHJURHSHQZHUNQHPHUV 'HRSVRPPLQJYDQYDQXLWHFRQRPLVFKRRJSXQWDDQWUHNNHOLMNHSUHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶V KLHUERYHQLVJHHQV]LQVYROOHGLJ+HWLVHHQLQYHQWDULVDWLHYDQRQGHUZHUSHQGLHZLMJHGXUHQGH HHQNRUWHSHULRGHHQ]RQGHUV\VWHPDWLVFKHPHWKRGHGHUHYXH]DJHQSDVVHUHQ+HWLVGXV ]HNHU]RGDWHHQJURRWDDQWDOSUHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶VKHWDGDJLXPµDQRXQFHRISUHYHQWLRQLV ZRUWKDSRXQGRIFXUH¶EHYHVWLJHQ ,QGHLQWHUYLHZVPHWH[SHUWVZHUGUHJHOPDWLJJHQRHPGGDWKHWLQSULQFLSH]LQORRVLVRPQDDU GHHFRQRPLVFKHDVSHFWHQYDQSUHYHQWLHWHNLMNHQRPGDWVXFFHVYROOHSUHYHQWLHQLHWWRW EHVSDULQJHQPDDUMXLVWWRWHHQGXXUGHUHJH]RQGKHLGV]RUJ]DOOHLGHQDOVJHYROJYDQGH VWLMJLQJYDQGHJHPLGGHOGHOHYHQVYHUZDFKWLQJ+HWVXFFHVYROEHVWULMGHQYDQ]LHNWHQ]DO OHLGHQWRWYHUYDQJHQGH]LHNWHQGLHZHOOLFKWGXXUGHUH]RUJYHUHLVHQ%RQQHX[HWDO 'LWUDDNWDDQKHWSXQWYDQGHLQGLUHFWHNRVWHQELQQHQGHJH]RQGKHLGV]RUJHHQ

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ NRVWHQFDWHJRULHGLHYROJHQVGHWKHRULHYDQHFRQRPLVFKHHYDOXDWLH'UXPPRQGHWDO *ROGHWDOPHHJHQRPHQPRHWZRUGHQLQGHDQDO\VHPDDUGLHLQSUDNWLMN]HOGHQRI QRRLWRQGHUZHUSYDQVWXGLHLV'H]HNRVWHQFDWHJRULHKHHIWEHWUHNNLQJRSNRVWHQGLHJHPDDNW ]XOOHQZRUGHQLQOHYHQVMDUHQGLHDOVJHYROJYDQGHKXLGLJHLQWHUYHQWLHJHZRQQHQZRUGHQ %HKDOYHGDWHUHHQSUDNWLVFKSUREOHHPLVRPGH]HNRVWHQWHNZDQWLILFHUHQGRHWKHW PHHQHPHQYDQGH]HNRVWHQRRNJHHQUHFKWDDQKHWIHLWGDWHHQYDQGHEHODQJULMNVWH GRHOVWHOOLQJHQYDQJH]RQGKHLGV]RUJLVRPPHQVHQHHQ]RODQJHQ]LHNWHYULMPRJHOLMNOHYHQWH ELHGHQ %LMGHLQWHUSUHWDWLHYDQGHSUHYHQWLHDFWLYLWHLWHQGLHLQ%LMODJHZRUGHQRPVFKUHYHQDOV PRJHOLMNNRVWHQEHVSDUHQGRI]HHUNRVWHQHIIHFWLHIPRHWHQHQNHOHSXQWHQLQRJHQVFKRXZ ZRUGHQJHQRPHQ$OOHUHHUVWLVHUKHWSUREOHHPYDQGHYHUWDDOEDDUKHLGYDQEXLWHQODQGVH RQGHU]RHNVUHVXOWDWHQQDDUGH1HGHUODQGVHVLWXDWLH1LHWYRRUHONHLQWHUYHQWLH]LMQ 1HGHUODQGVHHFRQRPLVFKHHYDOXDWLHVEHVFKLNEDDU:DQQHHUXLWEXLWHQODQGVRQGHU]RHNEOLMNW GDWEHSDDOGHLQWHUYHQWLHVHHQJXQVWLJHNRVWHQHIIHFWLYLWHLWKHEEHQPDJQLHW]RQGHUPHHU ZRUGHQDDQJHQRPHQGDWGDWRRNLQGH1HGHUODQGVHFRQWH[W]RLV)DFWRUHQGLHGDDUELMHHQURO VSHOHQ]LMQRD œ PHWKRGRORJLVFKHYHUVFKLOOHQLQQDWLRQDOHULFKWOLMQHQYRRUHFRQRPLVFKHHYDOXDWLHV]R]LMQ HUJURWHYHUVFKLOOHQLQKHWYRRUJHVFKUHYHQGLVFRQWRSHUFHQWDJHWXVVHQODQGHQHQLV EHNHQGGDWGHGLVFRQWRYRHWYDQJURWHLQYORHGNDQ]LMQRSGHNRVWHQHIIHFWLYLWHLWYDQ LQWHUYHQWLHVYRRUDOYDQLQWHUYHQWLHVGLHRRNRSODQJHUHWHUPLMQHIIHFWHQVRUWHUHQ œ GHHSLGHPLRORJLHYDQHHQ]LHNWHZDQQHHUELMYRRUEHHOGHHQEHSDDOGHLQIHFWLH]LHNWHYHHO YRRUNRPWLVKHWPDNNHOLMNHURPGDDUWHJHQRSHHQNRVWHQHIIHFWLHYHPDQLHUWHYDFFLQHUHQ GDQZDQQHHUGH]LHNWHKRRJVW]HOG]DDPLV œ GHYHUVFKLOOHQLQJH]RQGKHLGV]RUJV\VWHPHQWXVVHQODQGHQHHQDQGHUHRUJDQLVDWLHYDQGH ]RUJNDQWRWHHQKHHODQGHUHNRVWHQVWUXFWXXULQGH]RUJYRRUEHSDDOGHDDQGRHQLQJHQ OHLGHQ œ YHUVFKLOOHQWXVVHQSRSXODWLHVELMKHWEHUHNHQHQYDQKHWDDQWDOWHZLQQHQOHYHQVMDUHQLVGH JHPLGGHOGHOHYHQVYHUZDFKWLQJLQHHQODQGYDQEHODQJ œ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µLQWHUYHQWLHV¶GLHHLJHQOLMN QRJJHHQLQWHUYHQWLH]LMQKHWJDDWRPPRGHOPDWLJHEHUHNHQLQJHQZDDULQDDQJHWRRQGZRUGW GDWEHVSDULQJHQYRRUGHVDPHQOHYLQJPRJHOLMN]LMQLQGLHQKHWOXNWRPEHSDDOGH ULVLFRIDFWRUHQLQJXQVWLJH]LQWHEHwQYORHGHQ'HLQWHUYHQWLHVZDDUYRRUGLWJHOGW]LMQGH YHUPLQGHULQJYDQGHYHWFRQVXPSWLHWHUSUHYHQWLHYDQFRURQDLUHKDUW]LHNWHQHQKHWEHYRUGHUHQ YDQERUVWYRHGLQJ9RRUEHLGHYRRUEHHOGHQJHOGWGDWGDDUYRRUZHOLQWHUYHQWLHVEHVFKLNEDDU ]LMQELMYRRUEHHOGSURMHFWHQELQQHQGHNUDDP]RUJRPERUVWYRHGLQJWHVWLPXOHUHQPDDUGDW WRWRSKHGHQQRJJHHQFRQFUHWHHFRQRPLVFKHHYDOXDWLHVYDQGLHLQWHUYHQWLHV]HOI]LMQ XLWJHYRHUG+HWLVYDQJURRWEHODQJGDWLQVWXGLHVQDDUGHHIIHFWLYLWHLWYDQGH]HLQWHUYHQWLHV RRNDDQGDFKWZRUGWJHVFKRQNHQDDQGHNRVWHQHIIHFWLYLWHLWYDQGHLQWHUYHQWLHV (HQODDWVWHRYHUZHJLQJELMGHLQWHUSUHWDWLHYDQGHEHVFKULMYLQJHQYDQNRVWHQHIIHFWLHYH LQWHUYHQWLHVLQ%LMODJHLVGDWVRPPLJHLQWHUYHQWLHVNRVWHQHIIHFWLHI]LMQRSEDVLVYDQGLUHFWH

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ NRVWHQDOOHHQGLUHFWHNRVWHQELQQHQGHJH]RQGKHLGV]RUJWHUZLMODQGHUHLQWHUYHQWLHVµSDV¶ NRVWHQHIIHFWLHIZRUGHQZDQQHHURRNGHLQGLUHFWHNRVWHQEXLWHQGHJH]RQGKHLGV]RUJGH NRVWHQYDQSURGXFWLHYHUOLH]HQZRUGHQPHHJHQRPHQ,QHHQPDDWVFKDSSHOLMNSHUVSHFWLHI]LMQ EHLGHNRVWHQVRRUWHQYDQEHODQJPDDUYRRUGHJH]RQGKHLGV]RUJEHWDOHULVYDDNYDQ GRRUVODJJHYHQGEHODQJRIHHQLQYHVWHULQJLQHHQEHSDDOGHLQWHUYHQWLHEHVSDULQJHQYDQXLWKHW SHUVSHFWLHIYDQGHEHWDOHU]HOIRS]DOOHYHUHQ 2PGDWGH]HVWXGLHSULPDLULVJHULFKWRSKHWLGHQWLILFHUHQYDQNRVWHQEHVSDUHQGHRI]HHU NRVWHQHIIHFWLHYHLQWHUYHQWLHVLVGHJUHQVYRRUµ]HHUNRVWHQHIIHFWLHI¶JHVWHOGRSHHQEHGUDJ YDQPD[LPDDO SHUJHZRQQHQOHYHQVMDDU,QEHSDDOGHRPVWDQGLJKHGHQZRUGHQHFKWHU YHHOKRJHUHDINDSZDDUGHVYRRUNRVWHQHIIHFWLHYHSUHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶VJHKDQWHHUG=R ZRUGWLQGHFKROHVWHUROULFKWOLMQXLWJHJDDQYDQHHQEHGUDJYDQFLUFD SHUJHZRQQHQ OHYHQVMDDU&DVSDULHHWDO'HGRRURQVJHKDQWHHUGHDINDSZDDUGHYDQ EHWUHIW GXVHHQ]HHUDUELWUDLUHJUHQVHQZHHUVSLHJHOWGDWGHJHVHOHFWHHUGHSURJUDPPD¶VWRWGHPHHVW NRVWHQHIIHFWLHYHSUHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶VPRJHQZRUGHQJHUHNHQG+DGGHQZHGH DINDSZDDUGHRS JHOHJGGDQ]RXGHQHU]HNHUPHHULQWHUYHQWLHVRSGHOLMVWWHUHFKW]LMQ JHNRPHQ0DDURRNLQGHQXUHVXOWHUHQGHOLMVWYDQLQWHUYHQWLHVZDDURSPRPHQWHHOQRJJHHQ EHOHLGZRUGWJHYRHUGRIZDDUYRRUKHWEHUHLNYDQEHVWDDQGHSURJUDPPD¶VQRJVXERSWLPDDO LV]LHKLHUERYHQ]LWWHQUHHGVYHHODDQJULMSLQJVSXQWHQRP]RZHOGHJH]RQGKHLGVXLWNRPVWHQ DOVGHNRVWHQYDQGH]RUJLQSRVLWLHYH]LQWHEHwQYORHGHQ

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

*HUDDGSOHHJGHOLWHUDWXXUDOJHPHHQ

%RQQHX[/%DUHQGUHJW--1XVVHOGHU:-YDQGHU0DDV3-3UHYHQWLQJIDWDOGLVHDVHV LQFUHDVHVKHDOWKFDUHFRVWVFDXVHHOLPLQDWLRQOLIHWDEOHDSSURDFK%U0HG- &DVSDULH$)YDQ+RXW%$6LPRRQV0/5LFKWOLMQHQHQNRVWHQ1HG7LMGVFKU*HQHHVNG  &ROOHJHYRRU=RUJYHU]HNHULQJHQ&9=5LFKWOLMQHQYRRUIDUPDFRHFRQRPLVFKRQGHU]RHN $PVWHOYHHQ&ROOHJHYRRU=RUJYHU]HNHULQJHQ 'DYLHV-.0DF'RQDOG*5HG4XDOLW\HYLGHQFHDQGHIIHFWLYHQHVVLQKHDOWKSURPRWLRQ 6WULYLQJIRUFHUWDLQWLHV/RQGRQ5RXWOHGJH 'UXPPRQG0)2¶%ULHQ%6WRGGDUW*/7RUUDQFH*:0HWKRGVIRUWKH(YDOXDWLRQRI +HDOWK&DUH3URJUDPPHV2[IRUG2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV *ROG056LHJHO-(5XVVHOO/%:HLQVWHLQ0&&RVW(IIHFWLYHQHVVLQ+HDOWKDQG0HGLFLQH 1HZ<RUN2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV *XQQLQJ6FKHSHUV/--DQVHQ-5HG9RONVJH]RQGKHLG7RHNRPVW9HUNHQQLQJ'HHO ,9(IIHFWHQYDQ3UHYHQWLH0DDUVVHQ(OVHYLHUGH7LMGVWURRP 5RRWPDQ,*RRGVWDGW0+\QGPDQ%0F4XHHQ'93RWYLQ/6SULQJHWW-=LJOLR(5HG (YDOXDWLRQLQKHDOWKSURPRWLRQ3ULQFLSOHVDQGSHUVSHFWLYHV:+25HJLRQDO3XEOLFDWLRQV (XURSHDQ6HULHVQR 5XWWHQYDQ0|ONHQ030+YDQ%XVVFKEDFK--5XWWHQ))+UHG9DQNRVWHQWRWHIIHFWHQ (HQKDQGOHLGLQJYRRUHYDOXDWLHVWXGLHVLQGHJH]RQGKHLGV]RUJ0DDUVVHQ(OVHYLHU *H]RQGKHLGV]RUJ 9DQ2HUV-$0UHG*H]RQGKHLGRSNRHUV"9RONVJH]RQGKHLG7RHNRPVW9HUNHQQLQJ %LOWKRYHQ5LMNVLQVWLWXXWYRRU9RONVJH]RQGKHLGHQ0LOLHX

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

%LMODJH

9HU]HQGOLMVW

1. Directeur-Generaal van de Volksgezondheid, ir. J.I.M. de Goeij

2. Directeur Preventie en Openbare Gezondheidszorg, drs. A.A.W. Kalis, arts 3. Directie POG, mw. ir. W.M.A.H. Thien

4. Directie POG, mw. ir. S.I. Rutz.

5. Directie POG, mw. drs. M. van der Voet 6. Directie POG, dhr. drs. J.J.M. van Dijk 7. Directie POG, dhr. H.H.P. Meijer 8. Directie POG, mw. drs. N. Fotinos 9. Directie POG, mw. drs. C.A.M. van Gorp 10. Directie POG, drs. P.H. van Laarhoven 11. Directie DBO, dhr. G. Riphagen 12. Directie DVC, mw. drs. M.M. Slump 13. Directie POG, mw. R. Korevaar 14. Directie FEZ, dhr. drs. C. van de Burg 15. Directie FEZ, dhr. drs. A.R. van den Berg

16. Voorzitter van de Gezondheidsraad, prof. dr. J.A. Knottnerus

 ** *'$PVWHUGDPGU$YDQGH+RHN  **'1HGHUODQGGU38QLNHQ9HQHPD  =RQ0ZGU0-DQVVHQV  =RQ0ZGU-5DYHQVEHUJHQ  =RQ0ZSURIGUV-YDQ/RQGHQ  =RQ0ZGUV'-''HHV  0LQLVWHULHYDQ)LQDQFLsQPUGUV$YDQ%ULHPHQ  1HGHUODQGV,QVWLWXXWYRRU=RUJHQ:HO]LMQGU0*RXPDQV  (0*2LQVWLWXXW9ULMH8QLYHUVLWHLWSURIGU:YDQ0HFKHOHQ

 ,QVWLWXWHIRU5HKDELOLWDWLRQ5HVHDUFKUniversiteit Maastricht, dr. M.E.J.B. Goossens  -XOLXV&HQWUXP8QLYHUVLWHLW8WUHFKWGU/XF%RQQHX[  &RQVXPHQWHQ9HLOLJKHLG05LGGHU  /80&GU.6FKDDSYHOG  5LMNVXQLYHUVLWHLW*URQLQJHQGU0-3RVWPD  8QLYHUVLWHLW0DDVWULFKW%(2=GU$$PHQW  9RHGLQJVFHQWUXP%%UHHGYHOG  &HQWUXP*H]RQGKHLGVEHYRUGHULQJRSGHZHUNSOHN1,*=GULU/9DDQGUDJHU  712.3YDQGHU3DOGH%UXLQ  6WLFKWLQJ:HWHQVFKDSSHOLMN2QGHU]RHN9HUNHHUVYHLOLJKHLG0U3:HVHPDQQ  (UDVPXV8QLYHUVLWHLWGU5030%DOWXVVHQ  1,*=LU--DQVHQ 38. Directie RIVM

39. Directeur Volksgezondheid, dr. D. Ruwaard 40. 3=2GU:-(%HPHOPDQV  3=2GU+6-3LFDYHW  3=2GULU$-6FKXLW  3=2GULU:009HUVFKXUHQ  3=2GU7/69LVVFKHU  &,(GU$6GH%RHU  &,(GU0$(&RQ\QYDQ6SDHQGRQFN  &,(GU<7+3YDQ'XLMQKRYHQ

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ  &,(GULU0-:YDQGH/DDU  &,(GU+GH0HONHU  &9*GU+%%XHQRGH0HVTXLWD  &9*GULU(-0)HVNHQV  &9*GULU0&2FNp  979GU3:$FKWHUEHUJ  979GUV$(0GH+ROODQGHU  979GU)YDQGHU/XFKW  979GULQJ-$0YDQ2HUV  979LU.(:LWWH  3XEOLF+HDOWK)RUXPGUV+YDQ/LHQGHQ  $IGHOLQJ3=2  $IGHOLQJ979  'HSRW1HGHUODQGVH3XEOLNDWLHVHQ1HGHUODQGVH%LEOLRJUDILH 92-94. Auteurs 95. SBC / Communicatie 96. Bureau Rapportenregistratie 97. Bibliotheek RIVM 98-110.Bureau Rapportenbeheer 111-150.Reserve exemplaren

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

%LMODJH

9UDJHQOLMVWYRRULQWHUYLHZV

 :DWLVXZH[SHUWLVHJHELHG"  %HQWX]HOIELMHYDOXDWLHRQGHU]RHNYDQSUHYHQWLHYHLQWHUYHQWLHVEHWURNNHQJHZHHVW"  ,QGLHQYUDDJPHWMDZRUGWEHDQWZRRUG:HUGHQLQGDWRQGHU]RHNHFRQRPLVFKHDVSHFWHQ YDQSUHYHQWLHRQGHU]RFKW"7HUWRHOLFKWLQJ'LWLVRRNUHOHYDQWZDQQHHUHFRQRPLVFKH DVSHFWHQVOHFKWV]LMGHOLQJVDDQGHRUGHNZDPHQ'LWLVRRNUHOHYDQWZDQQHHUHFRQRPLVFKH DVSHFWHQZHOPHHJHQRPHQ]LMQLQKHWRQGHU]RHNPDDUPLVVFKLHQQRRLWJHUDSSRUWHHUG  %HQWXEHNHQGPHWJHSXEOLFHHUGHHFRQRPLVFKHHYDOXDWLHVYDQSUHYHQWLHLQGHOLWHUDWXXU" 7HUWRHOLFKWLQJGHQNRRNDDQµJULM]H¶OLWHUDWXXUQLHWLQSHHUUHYLHZHGWLMGVFKULIWHQ JHSXEOLFHHUGHHQDDQRQGHU]RHNVYHUVODJHQYDQDQGHUHRQGHU]RHNVLQVWLWXWHQ  %HQWXEHNHQGPHWORSHQGHRIDIJHVORWHQ1HGHUODQGVHRQGHU]RHNVSURMHFWHQZDDULQ DDQGDFKWJHVFKRQNHQZRUGWDDQHFRQRPLVFKHHIIHFWHQYDQSUHYHQWLH"8PDJRRN EXLWHQODQGVHVWXGLHVGLHPLVVFKLHQYDQEHODQJ]LMQQRHPHQ  %HQWXEHNHQGPHWKHWEHVWDDQYDQGDWDEHVWDQGHQYDQLQWHUYHQWLHVGLHZHORSHIIHFWLYLWHLW PDDUQRJQLHWRSHFRQRPLVFKHHIIHFWHQ]LMQJHDQDO\VHHUGHQZDDUXLWGRRUPLGGHOYDQ VHFXQGDLUHDQDO\VHYDQJHJHYHQVLQIRUPDWLHRYHUHFRQRPLVFKHHIIHFWHQYHUNUHJHQ]RX NXQQHQZRUGHQ"  2RNZDQQHHUXJHHQHYLGHQFHEDVHGUHVXOWDWHQNHQW]LMQHUSUHYHQWLHYHLQWHUYHQWLHV ZDDUYDQXGHQNWRIGDW]HNRVWHQEHVSDUHQGRIDQGHUV]LQVHFRQRPLVFKLQWHUHVVDQW]RXGHQ NXQQHQ]LMQ"7HUWRHOLFKWLQJGHQNGDDUELMRRNDDQHIIHFWHQ]RDOVYHUPLQGHUG ]LHNWHYHU]XLP  :HONHDQGHUHSHUVRQHQ]RXGHQZHELQQHQKHW5,90PRHWHQLQWHUYLHZHQ"  :HONHDQGHUHSHUVRQHQ]RXGHQZHEXLWHQKHW5,90PRHWHQLQWHUYLHZHQ"

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

%LMODJH

9HUNODUHQGHZRRUGHQOLMVWELMLQWHUYLHZV

(FRQRPLVFKHYDOXDWLHRQGHU]RHN (HQYRUPYDQHYDOXDWLHRQGHU]RHNZDDUELMGHNRVWHQYDQHHQLQWHUYHQWLHJHUHODWHHUGZRUGHQ DDQGHHIIHFWHQYDQGLHLQWHUYHQWLH%LMHIIHFWHQJDDWKHWGDQ]RZHORPJH]RQGKHLGVHIIHFWHQ ELMYRRUEHHOGJHZRQQHQOHYHQVMDUHQRIYHUEHWHUGHNZDOLWHLWYDQOHYHQDOVRPHFRQRPLVFKH HIIHFWHQYDQGHLQWHUYHQWLH]RDOVPLQGHU]LHNHQKXLVRSQDPHVHQYHUPLQGHUG]LHNWHYHU]XLP ,QGHYDNOLWHUDWXXUZRUGHQRRNGHYROJHQGHWHUPHQJHEUXLNWYRRUVSHFLILHNHYRUPHQYDQ HFRQRPLVFKHYDOXDWLHRQGHU]RHN œ NRVWHQEDWHQDQDO\VH œ NRVWHQHIIHFWLYLWHLWVDQDO\VH œ NRVWHQXWLOLWHLWVDQDO\VH .RVWHQEHVSDUHQG (HQLQWHUYHQWLHLVNRVWHQEHVSDUHQGZDQQHHUGHQHWWRRSEUHQJVWHQJURWHU]LMQGDQGHQHWWR NRVWHQYDQGLHLQWHUYHQWLH(HQILFWLHIYRRUEHHOGDOVHHQVSXLWRPUXLOSURJUDPPDYRRU LQWUDYHQHX]HGUXJJHEUXLNHUVMDDUOLMNV NRVWHQ+,9LQIHFWLHVSHUMDDUYRRUNRPW WHUZLMOGHOHYHQVODQJHEHKDQGHONRVWHQYDQ+,9JHw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j LQ1HGHUODQG LQGHUHJHODOVNRVWHQHIIHFWLHIEHVFKRXZG (FRQRPLVFKHDVSHFWHQYDQSUHYHQWLH 'HQNKLHUELMKHHOEUHHGDDQDOOHLQJHOGWHZDDUGHUHQHIIHFWHQYDQSUHYHQWLH(HQQLHW XLWSXWWHQGHOLMVWYDQYRRUEHHOGHQ œ ODQJHUOHYHQ œ HHQYHUEHWHUGHNZDOLWHLWYDQKHWOHYHQ œ YHUPLQGHUG]LHNWHYHU]XLP œ YHUPLQGHUG]LHNWHYHU]XLPYDQRXGHUVRPGDWNLQGHUHQDOVJHYROJYDQYDFFLQDWLHPLQGHU ]LHN]LMQ œ PLQGHU]LHNHQKXLVRSQDPHV œ PLQGHUPHGLFLMQJHEUXLN

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

%LMODJH

/LMVWYDQJHwQWHUYLHZGHSHUVRQHQ

*HwQWHUYLHZGHQELQQHQKHW5LMNVLQVWLWXXWYRRU9RONVJH]RQGKHLGHQ0LOLHX5,90 &HQWUXPYRRU&KURQLVFKH=LHNWHQ(SLGHPLRORJLH GU:-(%HPHOPDQV GU+6-3LFDYHW GULU$-6FKXLW GULU:009HUVFKXUHQ GU7/69LVVFKHU &HQWUXPYRRU,QIHFWLH]LHNWHQ(SLGHPLRORJLH LU$6GH%RHU GU0$(&RQ\QYDQ6SDHQGRQFN GUV<7+3YDQ'XLMQKRYHQ LU0-:YDQGH/DDU GU+GH0HONHU &HQWUXPYRRU9RHGLQJVHSLGHPLRORJLH GU+%%XHQRGH0HVTXLWD GULU(-0)HVNHQV GULU0&2FNp &HQWUXPYRRU9RONVJH]RQGKHLG7RHNRPVW9HUNHQQLQJHQ GU3:$FKWHUEHUJ GUV$(0GH+ROODQGHU LU--DQVHQ GU)YDQGHU/XFKW GULQJ-$0YDQ2HUV LU6,5XW] GUV.(:LWWH *HwQWHUYLHZGHQEXLWHQKHW5,90 GU$YDQGH+RHN** *'$PVWHUGDP GU38QLNHQ9HQHPD**'1HGHUODQG GU-5DYHQVEHUJHQ=RQ0Z GU0*RXPDQV1HGHUODQGV,QVWLWXXWYRRU=RUJHQ:HO]LMQ SURIGU:YDQ0HFKHOHQ(0*2LQVWLWXXW9ULMH8QLYHUVLWHLW80&

dr. M.E.J.B. Goossens, ,QVWLWXWHIRU5HKDELOLWDWLRQ5HVHDUFKUniversiteit Maastricht GU/XF%RQQHX[-XOLXV&HQWUXP8QLYHUVLWHLW8WUHFKW 05LGGHU&RQVXPHQWHQ9HLOLJKHLG GU.6FKDDSYHOG/80& GU0-3RVWPD5LMNVXQLYHUVLWHLW*URQLQJHQ GU$$PHQW%(2=8QLYHUVLWHLW0DDVWULFKW %%UHHGYHOG9RHGLQJVFHQWUXP GULU/9DDQGUDJHU&HQWUXP*H]RQGKHLGVEHYRUGHULQJRSGHZHUNSOHN1,*= .3YDQGHU3DOGH%UXLQ712 0U3:HVHPDQQ6WLFKWLQJ:HWHQVFKDSSHOLMN2QGHU]RHN9HUNHHUVYHLOLJKHLG GU5030%DOWXVVHQ:+2

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

%LMODJH

/LMVWYDQJHUDDGSOHHJGHLQWHUQHWVLWHV

KWWSSXEPHGFRP KWWSZZZFGFJRY KWWSZZZVHRQO KWWSZZZQ\IHUQO KWWSZZZDHLEURRNLQJVRUJSXEOLFDWLRQVUHJDQDO\VHVUHJBDQDO\VLVBBSGI KWWSZZZHXURSDHXLQW KWWSZZZQDWLRQDDONRPSDVQO KWWSZZZULYPQONRVWHQYDQ]LHNWHQ KWWSZZZQLGGNQLKJRY KWWSZZZJH]RQGKHLGVSOHLQQO KWWSZZZVFLUXVFRP KWWSZZZQKVXN KWWSZZZDKFSUJRYFOLQLFXVSVWIL[KWP KWWSZZZWKHFRPPXQLW\JXLGHRUJ KWWSZZZ\RUNDFXNLQVWFUG

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

%LMODJH

9RRUEHHOGHQYDQNRVWHQHIIHFWLHYHHQ

NRVWHQEHVSDUHQGHSUHYHQWLHSURMHFWHQ

3UHYHQWLHELQQHQGH]RUJ+\SHUWHQVLHEHKHHUVLQJELMW\SHGLDEHWHV

0HQVHQPHWW\SHGLDEHWHV_{KHEEHQHHQYHUKRRJGULVLFRRSKDUWHQYDDW]LHNWHQHQHHQ} EHURHUWHLQYHUJHOLMNLQJPHWPHQVHQ]RQGHUGLDEHWHV'HKXLGLJHEHKDQGHOLQJEHVWDDWXLW YHUODJLQJYDQGHEORHGGUXNPLGGHOVGLHHWHQRIDQWLK\SHUWHQVLYDHQUHGXFWLHYDQHHQ HYHQWXHHOYHUKRRJGVHUXPFKROHVWHUROJHKDOWH ,QWHQVLHYHEHKDQGHOLQJYDQKRJHEORHGGUXNYHUJHOHNHQPHWJHPDWLJGHEHKHHUVLQJLVHHQ EHWHUEHKDQGHOLQJVPHWKRGH2QGHULQWHQVLHYHEHKHHUVLQJZRUGWEHKDQGHOLQJPHW$&( UHPPHUVRI EORFNHUVYHUVWDDQ2QGHUJHPDWLJGHEHKHHUVLQJZRUGWEHKDQGHOLQJPHWGLHHWHQ PHGLFLMQHQDQGHUVGDQ$&(UHPPHUVRI EORFNHUVYHUVWDDQ8LWGH8QLWHG.LQJGRP 3URVSHFWLYH'LDEHWHV6WXG\8.3'6EOHHNGDWGHNDQVRSHHQEHURHUWHDOVPHGHGHNDQVRS KHWRQWZLNNHOHQYDQQHIURSDWKLHHQUHWLQRSDWKLHDIQDPZDQQHHUGHEORHGGUXNPHW$&( UHPPHUVRI EORFNHUVZHUGJHUHJXOHHUGLQWHQVLHYHEHKDQGHOLQJ 2SEDVLVYDQGHJHJHYHQVXLWGH8.3'6VWXGLHZHUGGRRUGH&'&'LDEHWHV&RVW HIIHFWLYHQHVV*URXSEHFLMIHUGGDWGH]HLQWHQVLHYHEHKDQGHOLQJYDQK\SHUWHQVLH]RZHOEHWHUH HIIHFWHQJHHIWLQWHUPHQYDQJHZRQQHQOHYHQVMDUHQHQJHZRQQHQ4$/<¶VDOVNRVWHQ EHVSDDUW_{'DDUPHHZDVGHLQWHQVLHYHEHKDQGHOLQJLQDOOHRS]LFKWHQWHYHUNLH]HQERYHQGH} VWDQGDDUGEHKDQGHOLQJ2RNGH8.3'66WXG\*URXS]HOIKHHIWRSEDVLVYDQGHJHJHYHQVXLW GHNOLQLVFKHWULDOHHQNRVWHQHIIHFWLYLWHLWVRQGHU]RHNJHUDSSRUWHHUG+RHZHOGHLQWHQVLHYH EHKDQGHOLQJYROJHQVGH]HVWXGLHQLHWNRVWHQEHVSDUHQGLV]LMQGHNRVWHQHIIHFWLYLWHLWVUDWLR¶V YDQLQWHQVLHYHEHKDQGHOLQJ]HHUJXQVWLJLQYHUJHOLMNLQJPHWDQGHUH JH]RQGKHLGV]RUJLQWHUYHQWLHVNRVWHQSHUJHZRQQHQOHYHQVMDDUWXVVHQ HQ   _{7\SHGLDEHWHVQLHWLQVXOLQHDIKDQNHOLMNHGLDEHWHVPHOOLWXV} 2 8.3URVSHFWLYH'LDEHWHV6WXG\*URXS7LJKEORRGSUHVVXUHFRQWURODQGULVNRIPDFURYDVFXODUDQGPLFURYDVFXODU FRPSOLFDWLRQVLQW\SHGLDEHWHV8.3'6%ULWLVK0HGLFDO-RXUQDO _{4$/<DINRUWLQJYDQ4XDOLW\$GMXVWHG/LIH<HDU(HQELMHFRQRPLVFKHHYDOXDWLHYDQJH]RQGKHLGV]RUJSURJUDPPD¶VYHHO} JHEUXLNWHXLWNRPVWPDDWGLH]RZHOKHWDDQWDOJHZRQQHQOHYHQVMDUHQDOVGHNZDOLWHLWYDQKHWOHYHQJHGXUHQGHGLHJHZRQQHQ OHYHQVMDUHQFRPELQHHUW 7KH&'&'LDEHWHVFRVWHIIHFWLYHQHVVJURXS&RVWHIIHFWLYHQHVVRILQWHQVLYHJO\FHPLFFRQWUROLQWHQVLILHGK\SHUWHQVLRQ FRQWURODQGVHUXPFKROHVWHUROOHYHOUHGXFWLRQIRUW\SHGLDEHWHV-RXUQDORIWKH$PHULFDQ0HGLFDO$VVRFLDWLRQ  _{8.3URVSHFWLYH'LDEHWHV6WXG\*URXS&RVWHIIHFWLYHQHVVDQDO\VLVRILPSURYHGEORRGSUHVVXUHFRQWUROLQK\SHUWHQVLYH} SDWLHQWVZLWKW\SHGLDEHWHV8.3'6%ULWLVK0HGLFDO-RXUQDO

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

3UHYHQWLHELQQHQGH]RUJ,QWHQVLHYHEORHGJOXFRVHEHKHHUVLQJELMW\SH

GLDEHWHVSDWLsQWHQPHWRYHUJHZLFKW

 'LDEHWHVPHOOLWXVRIZHOVXLNHU]LHNWHLVHHQFKURQLVFKHVWRIZLVVHOLQJV]LHNWHGLHJHSDDUGJDDW PHWHHQWHKRRJJOXFRVHJHKDOWHLQKHWEORHG0HQVHQPHWW\SHGLDEHWHVKHEEHQHHQ YHUKRRJGULVLFRRSKDUWHQYDDW]LHNWHQHQHHQEHURHUWHLQYHUJHOLMNLQJPHWPHQVHQ]RQGHU GLDEHWHV'HKXLGLJHEHKDQGHOLQJEHVWDDWXLWYHUODJLQJYDQGHEORHGGUXNPLGGHOVGLHHWHQRI DQWLK\SHUWHQVLYDHQUHGXFWLHYDQHHQHYHQWXHHOYHUKRRJGVHUXPFKROHVWHUROJHKDOWH ,Q(QJHOVRQGHU]RHNRQGHUW\SHGLDEHWHVSDWLsQWHQPHWRYHUJHZLFKWLVGHLQWHQVLHYH EHKHHUVLQJYDQKHWJOXFRVHJHKDOWHLQKHWEORHGGRRUPLGGHOYDQPHWIRUPLQHYHUJHOHNHQPHW GHFRQYHQWLRQHOHEHKDQGHOLQJVPHWKRGHKHWKRXGHQYDQHHQGLHHW8LWGLWRQGHU]RHNNZDP QDDUYRUHQGDWPHWIRUPLQH]RZHOGHOHYHQVYHUZDFKWLQJYHUJURRWPHWJHPLGGHOGMDDUDOV NRVWHQEHVSDUHQGLV'HPHWIRUPLQHJURHSKDGPLQGHUFRPSOLFDWLHVJHGXUHQGHGHIROORZXS GDDURPZDUHQGHJHPLGGHOGHNRVWHQYDQGH]HSDWLsQWHQJURHSJHGXUHQGHGHIROORZXS SHULRGH ODJHUGDQYDQGHSDWLsQWHQGLHDOOHHQHHQGLHHWYROJGHQ0HGLFDPHQWHX]H EHKDQGHOLQJYDQW\SHGLDEHWHVPHOOLWXVPHWPHWIRUPLQHLVGXVNRVWHQHIIHFWLHILQ YHUJHOLMNLQJPHWKHWKRXGHQYDQHHQGLHHWDOOHHQ  _{7\SHGLDEHWHVQLHWLQVXOLQHDIKDQNHOLMNHGLDEHWHVPHOOLWXV} _{1DWLRQDDO.RPSDV9RONVJH]RQGKHLGZZZULYPQOQDWLRQDDONRPSDV} _{&ODUNH3*UD\$$GOHU$6WHYHQV55DLNRX0&XOO&6WUDWWRQ,+ROPDQ5RQEHKDOIRIWKH8.3'6} *URXS&RVWHIIHFWLYHQHVVDQDO\VLVRILQWHQVLYHEORRGJOXFRVHFRQWUROZLWKPHWIRUPLQLQRYHUZHLJKWSDWLHQWV ZLWK7\SH,,GLDEHWHV'LDEHWRORJLD

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

9DFFLQDWLHV%05YDFFLQDWLH

'H%05YDFFLQDWLHWHJHQERIPD]HOHQHQURGHKRQGLVVLQGVRSJHQRPHQLQKHW ULMNVYDFFLQDWLHSURJUDPPD'HYDFFLQDWLHZRUGWDDQJHERGHQRSGHOHHIWLMGYDQPDDQGHQHQ MDDU 'HRSEUHQJVWHQYDQHHQHQNHOYRXGLJH%05YDFFLQDWLHZHJHQRSWHJHQGHNRVWHQ9ROJHQV $PHULNDDQVRQGHU]RHNLVGHRSEUHQJVWHQNRVWHQUDWLRLQGLHQDOOHHQJHNHNHQZRUGW QDDUGLUHFWHNRVWHQ_{'DWZLO]HJJHQGDWGHNRVWHQYDQYDFFLQDWLHLQKHWQLHWYDOOHQELM} WRHNRPVWLJHEHVSDULQJHQRSJH]RQGKHLGV]RUJNRVWHQWHQJHYROJHYDQEHVPHWWLQJHQ:DQQHHU RRNLQGLUHFWHNRVWHQNRVWHQWHQJHYROJHYDQSURGXFWLHYHUOLH]HQZRUGHQPHHJHQRPHQLQGH DQDO\VHZRUGHQGHRSEUHQJVWHQYDQYDFFLQDWLHWHQRS]LFKWHYDQGHNRVWHQQRJJXQVWLJHU RSEUHQJVWHQNRVWHQUDWLR%05YDFFLQDWLHLVGXVHHQNRVWHQEHVSDUHQGHPDDWUHJHO  _{1DWLRQDDO.RPSDV9RONVJH]RQGKHLGZZZULYPQOQDWLRQDDONRPSDV} _{+DW]LDQGUHX(-%URZQ5(+DOSHUQ07$FRVWEHQHILWDQDO\VLVRIWKHPHDVOHVPXPSVUXEHOOD005} YDFFLQH)LQDOUHSRUWSUHSDUHGIRU1DWLRQDO,PPXQL]DWLRQ3URJUDP&HQWHUVIRU'LVHDVH&RQWURODQG3UHYHQWLRQ $UOLQJWRQ9$&HQWHUIRU3XEOLF+HDOWK5HVHDUFKDQG(GXFDWLRQ%DWWHOOH0HPRULDO,QVWLWXWH

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

9DFFLQDWLHV*ULHSYDFFLQDWLHELMRXGHUHQ

,QIOXHQ]DZRUGWYHURRU]DDNWGRRUKHWLQIOXHQ]D$RILQIOXHQ]D%YLUXV_{+HWLVHHQDFXWH}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{1DWLRQDDO.RPSDV9RONVJH]RQGKHLGZZZULYPQOQDWLRQDDONRPSDV} _{3RVWPD0-%RV-0YDQ*HQQHS0-DJHU-&%DOWXVVHQ56SUHQJHU0-:(FRQRPLF(YDOXDWLRQRI,QIOXHQ]D} 9DFFLQDWLRQ$VVHVVPHQWIRU7KH1HWKHUODQGV3KDUPDFRHFRQRPLFV _{3RVWPD0-%DOWXVVHQ5030+HLMQHQ0/GH-RQJYDQGHQ%HUJ/7-DJHU-&3KDUPDFRHFRQRPLFVRI} LQIOXHQ]DYDFFLQDWLRQLQWKHHOGHUO\UHYLHZLQJWKHDYDLODEOHHYLGHQFH'UXJV$JLQJ

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

9DFFLQDWLHV*ULHSYDFFLQDWLHYDQZHUNQHPHUV

,QIOXHQ]DZRUGWYHURRU]DDNWGRRUKHWLQIOXHQ]D$RILQIOXHQ]D%YLUXV_{+HWLVHHQDFXWH}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_{+LHUELM]LMQQLHWPHGLVFKHNRVWHQ} ]RDOVSURGXFWLYLWHLWVYHUOLH]HQPHHJHQRPHQ:DQQHHUDOOHHQQDDUGHPHGLVFKHNRVWHQZRUGW JHNHNHQJH]RQGKHLGV]RUJSHUVSHFWLHIODWHQGHVWXGLHVJHHQEHVSDULQJHQ]LHQ  _{1DWLRQDDO.RPSDV9RONVJH]RQGKHLGZZZULYPQOQDWLRQDDONRPSDV} _{3RVWPD0--DQVHPD3YDQ*HQXJWHQ0//+HLMQHQ0$-DJHU-&GH-RQJYDQGHQ%HUJ/7:} 3KDUPDFRHFRQRPLFVRI,QIOXHQ]DYDFFLQDWLRQIRUKHDOWK\ZRUNLQJDGXOWVUHYLHZLQJWKHDYDLODEOHHYLGHQFH 'UXJV

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

9DFFLQDWLHV9DFFLQDWLHYDQJHVHOHFWHHUGHJURHSHQZHUNQHPHUVWHJHQ

KHSDWLWLV$

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{ZZZJH]RQGKHLGVSOHLQQO} _{*XWHUVRKQ76WHIIHQ59DQ'DPPH3+ROGHQHU)%HXWHOV3+HSDWLWLV$LQIHFWLRQLQDLUFUHZVULVNRI} LQIHFWLRQDQGFRVWEHQHILWDQDO\VLVRIKHSDWLWLV$YDFFLQDWLRQ$YLDWLRQ6SDFH (QYLURQPHQWDO0HGLFLQH  _{-DFREV5-*URYHU6)0H\HUKRII$63DLYDQD7$&RVWHIIHFWLYHQHVVRIYDFFLQDWLQJIRRGVHUYLFHZRUNHUV} DJDLQVWKHSDWLWLV$LQIHFWLRQ-RXUQDORI)RRG3URWHFWLRQ8LWGLWRQGHU]RHNEOLMNWGDWKHW SHUJHZRQQHQOHYHQVMDDUNRVWRPPHQVHQWHJHQKHSDWLWLV$WHYDFFLQHUHQ9DQXLWPDDWVFKDSSHOLMN SHUVSHFWLHILVKHWHFKWHUNRVWHQEHVSDUHQGQDPHOLMNPLOMRHQSHUJHYDFFLQHHUGHZHUNQHPHUV _{+RSSHUXV%XPD$%HXWHOV3YDQ'DPPH37RUPDQV*YDQ'RRUVODHU(/HHQWYDDU.XLMSHUV$$Q} HFRQRPLFHYDOXDWLRQRIKHSDWLWLV$YDFFLQDWLRQLQ'XWFKPLOLWDU\SHUVRQQHO0LOLWDU\0HG

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

9DFFLQDWLHV9DULFHOODZDWHUSRNNHQYDFFLQDWLH

9ULMZHOLHGHUNLQGNULMJWYDULFHOODZDWHUSRNNHQ'HWRWDOH]LHNWHODVWYDQZDWHUSRNNHQLV LPPHQVGHQNELMYRRUEHHOGRRNDDQRXGHUVGLHYULMPRHWHQQHPHQRPGDWKXQ]LHNHNLQGQLHW QDDUKHWGDJYHUEOLMINDQ,QKHWKXLGLJH5LMNVYDFFLQDWLHSURJUDPPDLVQRJJHHQYDFFLQWHJHQ ZDWHUSRNNHQRSJHQRPHQ (HQYDFFLQDWLHSURJUDPPDZDDUELMYDQDOOHJH]RQGHNLQGHUHQZRUGWJHYDFFLQHHUGWHJHQ YDULFHOODNDQYDQGHSRWHQWLsOHZDWHUSRNNHQJHYDOOHQYRRUNRPHQ_9DQXLWKHW SHUVSHFWLHIYDQGHJH]RQGKHLGV]RUJEHWDOHUOHYHUWHONHJHwQYHVWHHUGHHXURHXURRSDDQ XLWJHVSDDUGHNRVWHQ9DQXLWPDDWVFKDSSHOLMNSHUVSHFWLHIZDDUELMUHNHQLQJZRUGWJHKRXGHQ PHWSURGXFWLHYHUOLHVOHYHUWHHQZDWHUSRNNHQYDFFLQDWLHSURJUDPPDRSYRRUHONH JHwQYHVWHHUGHGROODU'DWHHQYDFFLQDWLHSURJUDPPDYDQXLWPDDWVFKDSSHOLMNRRJSXQW NRVWHQEHVSDUHQGLVZRUGWRRNEHYHVWLJGGRRUHHQUHFHQWRQGHU]RHNYDQ%ULVVRQHQ (GPXQGV=LMYLQGHQGDWGHRSEUHQJVWHQNRVWHQUDWLRLQDOOHGRRUJHUHNHQGHVFHQDULR¶VJURWHU LVGDQ  _{=HLMVW%$0YDQGHU'LMNPDQ0,.UDPHUV3*1/X\WMHV:5XPNH+&:HOWH57RZDUGVD'XWFKQDWLRQDO} YDFFLQDWLRQSURJUDPPHIRUWKHVWFHQWXU\%LOWKRYHQ5LMNVLQVWLWXXWYRRU9RONVJH]RQGKHLGHQ0LOLHX 5,90UDSSRUWQXPPHU _{9ROJHQVKHW$PHULNDDQVHRQGHU]RHNZDDUGH]HFLMIHUVRS]LMQJHEDVHHUGZRUGWGHNNLQJJHKDDOGGRRU} YDFFLQDWLHRSVFKROHQ _{/LHX7$&RFKL6/%ODFN6%HWDOFRVWHIIHFWLYHQHVVRIDURXWLQHYDULFHOODYDFFLQDWLRQSURJUDPIRU86} FKLOGUHQ-RXUQDORIWKH$PHULFDQ0HGLFDO$VVRFLDWLRQ _{%ULVVRQ0(GPXQGV:-7KHFRVWHIIHFWLYHQHVVRIYDULFHOODYDFFLQDWLRQLQ&DQDGD9DFFLQH} 

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

9DFFLQDWLHV3QHXPRNRNNHQYDFFLQDWLHYDQRXGHUHQ

3QHXPRNRNNHQHQPHQLQJRNRNNHQ]LMQGHEHODQJULMNVWHYHURRU]DNHUVYDQPHQLQJLWLV_ 3QHXPRNRNNHQYHURRU]DNHQRQGHUPHHUGHYROJHQGH]LHNWHQSQHXPRQLHORQJRQWVWHNLQJ PHQLQJLWLVKHUVHQUXJJHQPHUJYOLHVRQWVWHNLQJHQRWLWLVPHGLDPLGGHQRRURQWVWHNLQJ'H PHHVWHVODFKWRIIHUVYDQSQHXPRNRNNHQLQIHFWLHVZRUGHQJHYRQGHQELMMRQJHNLQGHUHQHQ RXGHUHQ $OJHUXLPHWLMG]LMQHUYDFFLQVWHJHQSQHXPRNRNNHQRSGHPDUNW1DGDWXLWGLYHUVH $PHULNDDQVVWXGLHVZDVJHEOHNHQGDWKHWNRVWHQEHVSDUHQGLVRPSHUVRQHQGLHSQHXPRQLH JHKDGKHEEHQSHUVRQHQGLHDDQOHJKHEEHQRPSQHXPRQLHWHRQWZLNNHOHQHQSHUVRQHQRXGHU GDQMDDUWHYDFFLQHUHQ__{ZHUGRRNYRRUGH%HOJLVFKH}_{HQ1HGHUODQGVH}_{VLWXDWLHEHYHVWLJG}

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{&RVWHIIHFWLYHQHVVRIYDFFLQDWLRQDJDLQVWSQHXPRFRFFDODQGPHQLQJRFRFFDOLQIHFWLRQVLQFKLOGUHQ} %RV-05XPNH+&:HOWH53RVWPD0-=ZDQHSRO(-DJHU-& SLQ'XWFK5,905DSSRUW _{*DEOH&%+RO]HU66(QJHOKDUW/)ULHGPDQ5%6PHOW])6FKURHGHU'%DXP.3QHXPRFRFFDOYDFFLQH} HIILFDF\DQGDVVRFLDWHGFRVWVDYLQJV-$P0HG$VVRF _{6LVN-(0RVNRZLW]$-:KDQJ:/LQ-')HGVRQ'60F%HDQ$03ORXIIH-)&HWURQ06%XWOHU-&} &RVWHIIHFWLYHQHVVRIYDFFLQDWLRQDJDLQVWSQHXPRFRFFDOEDFWHULPLDDPRQJHOGHUO\SHRSOH-$P0HG$VVRF  _{'H*UDHYH'/RPEDHUW**RRVVHQV+&RVWHIIHFWLYHQHVVDQDO\VLVRISQHXPRFRFFDOYDFFLQDWLRQRIDGXOWV} DQGHOGHUO\SHUVRQVLQ%HOJLXP3KDUPDFRHFRQRPLFV _{%DOWXVVHQ5030$PHQW$-+$/HLGO50YDQ)XUWK5&RVWHIIHFWLYHQHVVRIYDFFLQDWLRQDJDLQVW} SQHXPFRFFDOSQHXPRQLDLQWKH1HWKHUODQGV(XU-3XEOLF+HDOWK

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

6FUHHQLQJ3.8&+7VFUHHQLQJ

,Q1HGHUODQGZRUGHQSDVJHERUHQHQHQNHOHGDJHQQDGHJHERRUWHRQGHUDQGHUHJHVFUHHQGRS WZHHVWRIZLVVHOLQJV]LHNWHQSKHQ\ONHWRQXULH3.8HQFRQJHQLWDOHK\SRWK\UHRLGwH&+7 +LHUWRHZRUGWELMGHSDVJHERUHQHQGRRUPLGGHOYDQHHQKLHOSULNZDWEORHGDIJHQRPHQ 6FUHHQLQJRS3.8HQ&+7JHYROJGGRRUDGHTXDWHGLDJQRVWLHNHQEHKDQGHOLQJYRRUNRPWGH RQWZLNNHOLQJYDQHUQVWLJHPHQWDOHUHWDUGDWLHELMGHJHYRQGHQSDWLsQWHQ,HGHUMDDUZRUGWHHQ NOHLQDDQWDOSDWLsQWHQRSJHVSRRUGFLUFDNLQGHUHQPHW3.8HQFLUFDNLQGHUHQPHW&+7 2SJHVSRRUGHNLQGHUHQNULMJHQHHQVSHFLDDOGLHHW3.8RIKRUPRRQEHKDQGHOLQJ&+7 ZDDUGRRUHHQYHUVWDQGHOLMNHKDQGLFDSNDQZRUGHQYRRUNRPHQ +HWWRWDOHVFUHHQLQJVSURJUDPPDLQFOXVLHIVFUHHQLQJRSDGUHQRJHQLWDDOV\QGURRPNRVW MDDUOLMNVFLUFD PLOMRHQ'HNRVWHQSHUJHYRQGHQSDWLsQWEHGUDJHQYRRU3.8RQJHYHHU HQYRRU&+8 ,QLVYRRU3.8EHFLMIHUGGDWGHNRVWHQYDQKHWGRRU VFUHHQLQJYURHJWLMGLJRQWGHNNHQYDQppQSDWLsQWRQJHYHHUEHGUDJHQYDQGHNRVWHQGLH KRVSLWDOLVDWLHLQHHQLQULFKWLQJPHW]LFKPHHEUHQJW9RRU&+7ZDVGLWJHWDO 'H]HEHYLQGLQJHQZRUGHQRQGHUVWHXQGGRRULQWHUQDWLRQDDORQGHU]RHN'HNRVWHQEDWHQUDWLR YRRUHHQ3.8&+7VFUHHQLQJVSURJUDPPDLVYROJHQV-DSDQVRQGHU]RHN_{9ROJHQV)UDQV} RQGHU]RHNLVGHNRVWHQEDWHQUDWLRYRRU3.8HQYRRU&+7'H]HODDWVWH)UDQVH VWXGLHYDWRRNYLMIDQGHUHVWXGLHVRSGLWJHELHGVDPHQXLWJHYRHUGLQYLMIYHUVFKLOOHQGH ZHVWHUVHODQGHQ$OOHVWXGLHVNRPHQWRWGHFRQFOXVLHGDWVFUHHQLQJRS3.8HQ&+7 NRVWHQEHVSDUHQGLV,QDOOHVWXGLHVLVGHFRQFOXVLHRQDIKDQNHOLMNYDQKHWDOGDQQLHW PHHQHPHQYDQSURGXFWLHYHUOLH]HQLQGHDQDO\VH'HSURJUDPPD¶V]LMQGXVNRVWHQEHVSDUHQG RRNZDQQHHUGHWRHNRPVWLJHSURGXFWLHYHUOLH]HQYDQKHWNLQGPHW3.8RI&+7HQGLHYDQ GHRXGHUVGLHYRRUKHQ]RUJHQEXLWHQEHVFKRXZLQJZRUGHQJHODWHQ  _{(OYHUV/+/RHEHU-*$VVHVPHQWRISHUIRUPDQFHLQFDUU\LQJRXWWKHKHHOVWLFNXVHGLQQHRQDWDOVFUHHQLQJIRU} SKHQ\ONHWRQXUHD3.8DQGFRQJHQLWDOK\SRWK\URLGLVP&+7%LOWKRYHQ5,90UHSRUWQU _{.DWH/3WHQ&RUQHO0&:DW]LMQGHNRVWHQ",Q9RONVJH]RQGKHLG7RHNRPVW9HUNHQQLQJ1DWLRQDDO.RPSDV} 9RONVJH]RQGKHLG%LOWKRYHQ5,90KWWSZZZQDWLRQDDONRPSDVQO _{+LVDVKLJH$+HDOWKHFRQRPLFDQDO\VLVRIWKHQHRQDWDOVFUHHQLQJSURJUDPLQ-DSDQ,QW-7HFKQRO$VVHVVP} +HDOWK&DUH _{'KRQGW-/)DUULDX[-3/HEUXQ76DLOO\-&(WXGHFRXWEpHQpILFHGXGpSLVWDJHQpRQDWDOGHODSKpQ\OFpWRQXULH} HWGHO¶K\SHUWK\URwGLH3pGLDWULH

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

6FUHHQLQJ6FUHHQLQJYDQ]ZDQJHUHQRSV\ILOLV

6\ILOLVLVHHQJHVODFKWV]LHNWHGLHUHODWLHIZHLQLJYRRUNRPW,QZHUGHQLQWRWDDOFLUFD JHYDOOHQJHPHOGGRRUVRDUHJLVWUDWLHV_{(HQJHwQIHFWHHUGH]ZDQJHUHYURXZNDQGHEDFWHULH}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DOVLQGH UHVWYDQ1HGHUODQG_{'HEDWHQNRVWHQUDWLRZDVYRRUKHHO1HGHUODQGHQLQGHJURWH} VWHGHQ8LWHHQRYHU]LFKWVVWXGLHZDDULQYLMIJHSXEOLFHHUGHHFRQRPLVFKHHYDOXDWLHV RSGLWWHUUHLQZHUGHQVDPHQJHYDWEOHHNGDWRRNDQGHUHVWXGLHVSRVLWLHYHEDWHQNRVWHQUDWLR¶V RSOHYHUHQ_{$OOHYLMIEHVFKLNEDUHVWXGLHV]LMQJHEDVHHUGRSHHQPRGHOXLWZDDUYRRU} HFKWHUQRRLWHHQVHQVLWLYLWHLWVDQDO\VHLVJHSXEOLFHHUG'DDURPZHUGKHWPRGHOGRRU6WUXLMVHW DOJHUHSOLFHHUGHQZHUGGHJHYRHOLJKHLGYDQGHUHVXOWDWHQYRRUGHJHPDDNWH YHURQGHUVWHOOLQJHQRQGHU]RFKW8LWGH]HVHQVLWLYLWHLWVDQDO\VHEOHHNGDWGHVFUHHQLQJYDQ ]ZDQJHUHQRSV\ILOLVRRNLQGHPHHVWFRQVHUYDWLHYHEHUHNHQLQJHQNRVWHQEHVSDUHQGLV_  _{+DNV.YDQGH/DDU0-:+RHYDDNNRPWV\ILOLVYRRUHQKRHYHHOPHQVHQVWHUYHQHUDDQ",Q} 9RONVJH]RQGKHLG7RHNRPVW9HUNHQQLQJ1DWLRQDDO.RPSDV9RONVJH]RQGKHLG%LOWKRYHQ5,90 KWWSZZZQDWLRQDDONRPSDVQO _{*UXWHNH33RVWPD0-*URVKHLG30-DJHU-&&RQ\QYDQ6SDHQGRQFN0$(/RHEHU-*3UHYHQWLHYDQ} FRQJHQLWDOHV\ILOLVHFRQRPLVFKHHYDOXDWLHPHWFLMIHUVYDQGH6WUHHNODERUDWRULDYRRUGHYRONVJH]RQGKHLG %LOWKRYHQ5LMNVLQVWLWXXWYRRU9RONVJH]RQGKHLGHQ0LOLHXUDSSRUWQXPPHU _{6WUXLMV-1GH:LW*$-DJHU-&/LWHUDWXXURQGHU]RHNQDDUNRVWHQHIIHFWLYLWHLWVDVSHFWHQYDQGHVFUHHQLQJYDQ} ]ZDQJHUHQRSV\ILOLVWHUSUHYHQWLHYDQFRQJHQLWDOHV\ILOLV%LOWKRYHQ5LMNVLQVWLWXXWYRRU9RONVJH]RQGKHLGHQ 0LOLHXUDSSRUWQXPPHU

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

6FUHHQLQJ&KODP\GLDVFUHHQLQJ

 &KODP\GLDLVZDDUVFKLMQOLMNGHPHHVWYRRUNRPHQGHVRDLQ1HGHUODQG&KODP\GLDLVHHQ EDFWHULsOHVRDGLHZRUGWYHURRU]DDNWGRRU&KODP\GLDWUDFKRPDWLVHQNDQRQWVWHNLQJHQDDQGH XULQHEXLVHQGHOGDUPELMEDOOHQEDDUPRHGHUKDOVHQHLOHLGHUVYHURRU]DNHQ'DDUGRRUNDQ LHPDQGRQYUXFKWEDDUZRUGHQ&KODP\GLDZRUGWPHHVWDOGRRUVHNVXHHOFRQWDFWRYHUJHEUDFKW 8LWGH6RDUHJLVWUDWLHLQFOXVLHI6RDSROLNOLQLHN$PVWHUGDPEOLMNWGDWHULQ QLHXZHJHYDOOHQYDQFKODP\GLD]LMQJHYRQGHQ ,QGHDIJHORSHQMDUHQ]LMQ]HHUJHYRHOLJHHQVSHFLILHNH&KODP\GLDWUDFKRPDWLVWHVWHQ RQWZLNNHOWGLHVFUHHQLQJYDQJURWHJURHSHQPHQVHQPRJHOLMNPDNHQ5HFHQW]LMQPHHUGHUH NRVWHQHIIHFWLYLWHLWVWXGLHVYDQ&KODP\GLDWUDFKRPDWLVVFUHHQLQJVSURJUDPPD¶VXLWJHYRHUG 'H]HVWXGLHVWRQHQDDQGDWLQYHHOJHYDOOHQGHVFUHHQLQJVSURJUDPPD¶VNRVWHQHIIHFWLHIRI ]HOIVNRVWHQEHVSDUHQG]LMQ 1HGHUODQGVRQGHU]RHNYDQ:HOWHHWDOODDW]LHQGDWVFUHHQLQJYDQYURXZHQHQPDQQHQWXVVHQ GHHQGHMDDUJHGXUHQGHHHQSHULRGHYDQMDDUNRVWHQEHVSDUHQGLV$IKDQNHOLMNYDQ KHWDOGDQQLHWPHHQHPHQYDQLQGLUHFWHNRVWHQNDQGRRUVFUHHQLQJRSFKODP\GLDWRW SHUYHUPHGHQHUQVWLJHFRPSOLFDWLH]RDOVRQYUXFKWEDDUKHLGEHVSDDUGZRUGHQ'H EHVSDULQJWUHHGWRSZDQQHHUGHVFUHHQLQJODQJHUGDQMDDUZRUGWYRRUWJH]HW:DQQHHURRN GHLQGLUHFWHNRVWHQZRUGHQPHHJHQRPHQLVKHWSURJUDPPDUHHGVQDMDDUNRVWHQEHVSDUHQG  _{1DWLRQDDO.RPSDV9RONVJH]RQGKHLGZZZULYPQOQDWLRQDDONRPSDV} _{.UHW]VFKPDU0:HOWH5YDQGH+RHN$3RVWPD0-&RPSDUDWLYH0RGHOEDVHG$QDO\VLVRI6FUHHQLQJ} 3URJUDPVIRU&KODP\GLDWUDFKRPDWLV,QIHFWLRQV$PHULFDQ-RXUQDORI(SLGHPLRORJ\ _{:HOWH5-DJHU+3RVWPD0-&RVWHIIHFWLYHQHVVRIVFUHHQLQJIRUJHQLWDO&KODP\GLDWUDFKRPDWLV([SHUW} 5HYLHZRI3KDUPDFRHFRQRPLFV 2XWFRPHV5HVHDUFK _{:HOWH5.UHW]VFKPDU0-DJHU-&/HLGO5YDQGHQ+RHN$-DJHU-&3RVWPD0-&RVW(IIHFWLYHQHVVRI} 6FUHHQLQJ3URJUDPVIRU&KODP\GLDWUDFKRPDWLV$3RSXODWLRQ%DVHG'\QDPLF$SSURDFK6H[XDOO\7UDQVPLWWHG 'LVHDVHV

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

/HHIVWLMO3UHYHQWLHYDQFRURQDLUHKDUW]LHNWHQGRRUYHUPLQGHUGHFRQVXPSWLH

YDQYHU]DGLJGHYHWWHQ

&RURQDLUHKDUW]LHNWHQ&+=]LMQGHPHHVWYRRUNRPHQGHKDUWHQYDDW]LHNWHQLQ1HGHUODQG .HQPHUNHQGYRRU&+=]LMQYHUQDXZLQJHQLQGHNUDQVVODJDGHUV'HYRUPYDQ&+=GLHKHW PHHVWYRRUNRPWLVKHWDFXWHKDUWLQIDUFW+HWDDQWDOQLHXZHKDUWLQIDUFWHQLQZRUGWRS EDVLVYDQKXLVDUWVHQUHJLVWUDWLHVJHVFKDWRSPDQQHQHQYURXZHQ,Q RYHUOHGHQPDQQHQHQYURXZHQDDQHHQKDUWLQIDUFW 7RWGHULVLFRIDFWRUHQYRRU&+=EHKRUHQHHQYHUKRRJGFKROHVWHUROJHKDOWHRYHUJHZLFKWGH FRQVXPSWLHYDQYHU]DGLJGYHWWHQHQHHQJHULQJHFRQVXPSWLHYDQJURHQWHHQIUXLW,QHHQ $PHULNDDQVRQGHU]RHNZHUGJHNHNHQQDDUGHWKHRUHWLVFKWHEHKDOHQJH]RQGKHLGVZLQVWYDQ KHWYHUPLQGHUHQYDQGHFRQVXPSWLHYDQYHU]DGLJGHYHWWHQLQGHEHYRONLQJWXVVHQHQ MDDURXGHQQDDUUHGXFWLHYDQJH]RQGKHLGV]RUJNRVWHQGLHGDDUPHHVDPHQKDQJW %LMSHUVRQHQGLHHHQFKROHVWHUROQLYHDX˜PPRO/KHEEHQPDDUQRJJHHQ&+=]XOOHQLQ GH9HUHQLJGH6WDWHQLQHHQSHULRGHYDQMDDUELMEHQDGHULQJPLOMRHQQLHXZHKDUWLQIDUFWHQ SODDWVYLQGHQ,QGLHQKHWJHEUXLNYDQYHU]DGLJGHYHWWHQPHWppQWRWGULHSURFHQWNDQZRUGHQ WHUXJJHEUDFKW]DOKHWDDQWDOFRURQDLUHKDUW]LHNWHQPHWWRWDIQHPHQ'HWRWDOH EHVSDULQJRSGLUHFWHPHGLVFKHNRVWHQHQLQGLUHFWHNRVWHQDOVJHYROJYDQYHUPLQGHUGH DUEHLGVSURGXFWLYLWHLWZRUGWLQGH]HVWXGLHEHFLMIHUGWXVVHQPLOMDUGGROODUELM UHGXFWLHLQQDPHYHU]DGLJGYHWHQPLOMDUGELMSURFHQWUHGXFWLHRYHUHHQSHULRGHYDQ MDDU:DQQHHUDOOHHQGHEHVSDULQJHQRSWRHNRPVWLJHPHGLVFKHNRVWHQLQGHEHVFKRXZLQJ ZHUGHQEHWURNNHQZDUHQGHYHUZDFKWHEHVSDULQJHQPLOMRHQUHGXFWLHWRW PLOMDUGUHGXFWLH'HDXWHXUVYHUZDFKWHQGDWGHHIIHFWHQQRJJURWHU]LMQZDQQHHURRN HIIHFWHQRSDQGHUHOHHIWLMGVJURHSHQHQRSJURHSHQSDWLsQWHQGLHDOEHNHQG]LMQPHW&+= ZRUGHQPHHJHQRPHQ+HWEHWUHIWKLHURYHULJHQVHHQVWXGLHQDDUWKHRUHWLVFKWHEHKDOHQ JH]RQGKHLGVZLQVWGHDXWHXUVJHYHQGXVQLHWDDQKRHKHWHIIHFWEHUHLNWPRHWZRUGHQLQGH SUDNWLMN  _{1DWLRQDDO.RPSDV9RONVJH]RQGKHLGZZZULYPQOQDWLRQDDONRPSDV} _{2VWHU*7KRPSVRQ'(VWLPDWHGHIIHFWVRIUHGXFLQJGLHWDU\VDWXUDWHGIDWLQWDNHRQWKHLQFLGHQFHDQGFRVWVRI} FRURQDU\KHDUWGLVHDVHLQWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV-RXUQDORIWKH$PHULFDQ'LHWHWLF$VVRFLDWLRQ

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

/HHIVWLMO6WRSSHQPHWURNHQLQWHUYHQWLHV

5RNHQZDVLQYHUDQWZRRUGHOLMNYRRURQJHYHHUYDQGHWRWDOHVWHUIWHLQ1HGHUODQG VWHUIJHYDOOHQ,QGDWMDDUURRNWHYDQGH1HGHUODQGHUVYDQMDDURIRXGHU YDQGHPDQQHQHQYDQGHYURXZHQ(HQJURRWDDQWDOFKURQLVFKH]LHNWHQLV JHDVVRFLHHUGPHWURNHQ=RNDQELMQDYDQGHVWHUIJHYDOOHQGRRUORQJNDQNHUDDQURNHQ ZRUGHQWRHJHVFKUHYHQ5RNHQYHUJURRWWHYHQVGHNDQVRSVWHUIWHDDQFKURQLVFKHREVWUXFWLHYH ORQJ]LHNWHQPHWELMQD2QJHYHHUYDQGHVWHUIWHDDQFRURQDLUHKDUW]LHNWHQHQ RQJHYHHUYDQGHVWHUIWHDDQEHURHUWHLVWHZLMWHQDDQURNHQ5RNHQWLMGHQVGH ]ZDQJHUVFKDSHQQDGHJHERRUWHYHUJURRWKHWULVLFRRS]XLJHOLQJHQVWHUIWHHQZLHJHQGRRG_'H WRWDDODDQURNHQWRHWHVFKULMYHQNRVWHQYDQGHJH]RQGKHLGV]RUJYRRUSOXVVHUVEHGURHJHQ LQUXLP PLOMRHQ'HNRVWHQDOVJHYROJYDQSURGXFWLHYHUOLHVGRRUWDEDNVJHEUXLN EHGURHJHQLQGDW]HOIGHMDDUUXLP PLOMRHQ SHUZHUNQHPHU

9RRUYHHOURNHUVLVKHWPRHLOLMNRP]RQGHUKXOSWHVWRSSHQ6OHFKWVYDQGHURNHUVGLHHHQ VWRSSRJLQJGRHWLVQDHHQMDDUQLHWWHUXJJHYDOOHQLQ]LMQRXGHJHZRRQWH,QWHUYHQWLHVRPWH KHOSHQELMKHWVWRSSHQPHWURNHQNXQQHQDIKDQNHOLMNYDQGHLQWHQVLWHLWKHWSHUFHQWDJH EOLMYHQGHVWRSSHUVYHUJURWHQWRWPD[LPDDO,Q1HGHUODQG]LMQYHUVFKLOOHQGHLQWHUYHQWLHV EHVFKLNEDDU]RDOVDQWLURRNFDPSDJQHV]HOIKXOSIROGHUVGHµPLQLPDOHLQWHUYHQWLHVWUDWHJLH¶ LQGLYLGXHOHFRDFKLQJJURHSVSURJUDPPD¶VURRNVWRSSROL¶VQLFRWLQHYHUYDQJHUVDQWLGHSUHVVLYD RIDFXSXQFWXXU ,QHHQ1HGHUODQGVHNRVWHQHIIHFWLYLWHLWVDQDO\VHZHUGHHQLQWHQVLHIJURHSVSURJUDPPDJHULFKW RSJHGUDJVPDWLJHYHUDQGHULQJHQYHUJHOHNHQPHWHHQ]HOIKXOSJLGV_'HNRVWHQ HIIHFWLYLWHLWVUDWLR¶VYDQXLWKHWSHUVSHFWLHIYDQGHJH]RQGKHLGV]RUJZDUHQUHVSHFWLHYHOLMN HQ SHUJHVODDJGHVWRSSHUJHGXUHQGHWHQPLQVWHPDDQGHQQLHWJHURRNW,Q HHQUHFHQWYHUVFKHQHQV\VWHPDWLVFKHUHYLHZYDQLQWHUQDWLRQDOHHFRQRPLVFKHHYDOXDWLHV]LMQ FRPELQDWLHVYDQLQWHUYHQWLHVRPWHVWRSSHQPHWURNHQNRVWHQHIIHFWLHIJHEOHNHQ'HNRVWHQ SHUJHZRQQHQOHYHQVMDDUYDULHHUGHQWXVVHQ HQ ZDDUELMKHWJURVYDQGH VWXGLHVUDWLR¶VUDSSRUWHHUGHRPHQQDELM SHUJHZRQQHQOHYHQVMDDU'HNRVWHQSHU JHVODDJGHVWRSSHUYDULHHUGHQWXVVHQ HQ _{(UZDVJHHQGXLGHOLMNHUHODWLHZDDU} WHQHPHQWXVVHQGHKRRJWHYDQGHNRVWHQHIIHFWLYLWHLWVUDWLRHQGHLQWHQVLWHLWYDQGH LQWHUYHQWLH  _{6WDW/LQH&%6ZZZFEVQO} _{-DDUYHUVODJ'HQ+DDJ'()$&72} _{1DWLRQDDO.RPSDV9RONVJH]RQGKHLGZZZULYPQOQDWLRQDDONRPSDV} _{3ROGHU--7DNNHQ-HWDO.RVWHQYDQ]LHNWHQLQ1HGHUODQG'H]RUJHXURRQWUDIHOG%LOWKRYHQ5,90} _{-DFREVYDQGH%UXJJHQ0$0:HOWH5$HWDO$DQURNHQWRHWHVFKULMYHQSURGXFWLYLWHLWVNRVWHQYRRU1HGHUODQGVH} ZHUNJHYHUVLQ%LOWKRYHQ5,90 _{:LOOHPVHQ0&:DJHQD(-YDQ6FKD\FN&3'HHIIHFWLYLWHLWYDQVWRSSHQPHWURNHQPHWKRGHQGLHLQ1HGHUODQG} EHVFKLNEDDU]LMQ(HQV\VWHPDWLVFKHUHYLHZRSEDVLVYDQ&RFKUDQHJHJHYHQVYHUVFKLMQWELQQHQNRUWLQ1HGHUODQGV 7LMGVFKULIWYRRU*HQHHVNXQGH _{0XGGH$1GH9ULHV+6WUHFKHU9-&RVWHIIHFWLYHQHVVRIVPRNLQJFHVVDWLRQPRGDOLWLHV&RPSDULQJ$SSOHVZLWKRUDQJHV"} 3UHYHQWLYH0HGLFLQH _{:RRODFRWW1)-RQHV1)HWDO7KHFOLQLFDOHIIHFWLYHQHVVDQGFRVWHIIHFWLYHQHVVRI%XSURSLRQDQGQLFRWLQHUHSODFHPHQW} WKHUDS\IRUVPRNLQJFHVVDWLRQDV\VWHPDWLFUHYLHZDQGHFRQRPLFHYDOXDWLRQ+HDOWK7HFKQRORJ\$VVHVVPHQW  _{$OOHJHQRHPGHEHGUDJHQ]LMQRPJHUHNHQGQDDU(XUR¶VPHWDOVEDVLVMDDU}

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

2YHULJHSUHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶V)ROLXP]XXUVXSSOHWLHWHUSUHYHQWLHYDQ

QHXUDOHEXLVGHIHFWHQ

(HQQHXUDOHEXLVGHIHFWLVHHQHUQVWLJHDDQJHERUHQDIZLMNLQJYDQKHWFHQWUDOH]HQXZVWHOVHO(HQ QHXUDOHEXLVGHIHFWRQWVWDDWWXVVHQGHGHUGHHQYLHUGHZHHNQDGHFRQFHSWLHGRRUGDWGHQHXUDOH EXLVQLHWYROOHGLJVOXLW'HEHODQJULMNVWHYHUVFKLMQLQJVYRUPHQYDQQHXUDOHEXLVGHIHFWHQ]LMQ DIZH]LJKHLGYDQGHKHUVHQHQHQHHQµRSHQUXJJHWMH¶VSLQDELILGD )ROLXP]XXULVHHQYLWDPLQHGLHRQGHUPHHUYRRUNRPWLQJURHQHJURHQWHQHQYRONRUHQ SURGXFWHQ2QGHU]RHNKHHIWDDQJHWRRQGGDWGRRUHHQYROGRHQGHLQQDPHYDQIROLXP]XXUURQG GHFRQFHSWLHKHWULVLFRRSHHQNLQGPHWHHQQHXUDOHEXLVGHIHFWDDQ]LHQOLMNZRUGWYHUODDJG 8LW$PHULNDDQVRQGHU]RHNEOLMNWGDWKHWNRVWHQHIIHFWLHILVRPIROLXP]XXUDDQJUDDQWRHWH YRHJHQ_{$IKDQNHOLMNRIHUJHNR]HQZRUGWYRRUHHQODDJWRHYRHJLQJVJHKDOWHRIHHQKRRJ} WRHYRHJLQJVJHKDOWH]DOYROJHQVGLWRQGHU]RHNHHQQHWWRNRVWHQEHVSDULQJSODDWVYLQGHQYDQ PLOMRHQUHVSHFWLHYHOLMNPLOMRHQSHUMDDU'LWZRUGWEHYHVWLJGGRRUHHQDQGHU $PHULNDDQVRQGHU]RHNZDDUXLWEOLMNWGDWHHQWRHYRHJLQJVJHKDOWHYDQPJUHHGV NRVWHQEHVSDUHQGLVPDDUHHQWRHYRHJLQJVJHKDOWHYDQRIPJHHQQRJJURWHUH EHVSDULQJRSOHYHUW2PGDWRRNKHWDDQWDOYRRUNZDOLWHLWJHFRUULJHHUGHJHZRQQHQOHYHQVMDUHQ 4$/<¶V_{WRHQHHPWLQHONYDQGHGULHGRRUJHUHNHQGHIRUWLILFDWLHVWUDWHJLHsQLVGHNRVWHQ} HIIHFWLYLWHLWVUDWLRQHJDWLHISHUYRRUNZDOLWHLWJHFRUULJHHUGOHYHQVMDDULQGH PJIRUWLILFDWLHVWUDWHJLH  _{&]HL]HO$('XGDV83UHYHQWLRQRIWKHILUVWRFFXUUHQFHRIQHXUDOWXEHGHIHFWVE\SHULFRQFHSWLRQDOYLWDPLQ} VXSSOHPHQWDWLRQ1(QJO-0HG  5RPDQR36:DLW]PDQ1-6FKHIIOHU503L5')ROLFDFLGIRUWLILFDWLRQRIJUDLQDQHFRQRPLFDQDO\VLV$P-3XEOLF+HDOWK _{4$/<DINRUWLQJYDQ4XDOLW\$GMXVWHG/LIH<HDU(HQELMHFRQRPLVFKHHYDOXDWLHYDQ} JH]RQGKHLGV]RUJSURJUDPPD¶VYHHOJHEUXLNWHXLWNRPVWPDDWGLH]RZHOKHWDDQWDOJHZRQQHQOHYHQVMDUHQDOVGH NZDOLWHLWYDQKHWOHYHQJHGXUHQGHGLHJHZRQQHQOHYHQVMDUHQFRPELQHHUW _{.HOO\$(+DGGL[$&6FDQORQ.6+HOPLFN&*0XOLQDUH-&RVWHIIHFWLYHQHVVRIVWUDWHJLHVWRSUHYHQWQHXUDO} WXEHGHIHFWV,Q*ROG056LHJHO-(5XVVHOO/%:HLQVWHLQ0&&RVWHIIHFWLYHQHVVLQKHDOWKDQGPHGLFLQH 1HZ<RUN2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVVSS

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

2YHULJHSUHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶V3UHYHQWLHYDQDFFLGHQWHOHYDOELMRXGHUHQ

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LQULFKWLQJYDQKHWKXLVPHHUEHZHJLQJHQ YHUPLQGHULQJYDQPHGLFDWLH,QYHUJHOLMNLQJPHWRXGHUHQGLHJHHQLQWHUYHQWLHSURJUDPPD YROJGHQQDP]RZHOKHWDDQWDOYDODFFLGHQWHQDOVGHWRWDOHJH]RQGKHLGV]RUJNRVWHQLQKHWMDDU QDGHLQWHUYHQWLHDI+HWHIIHFWZDVKHWVWHUNVWLQGLHJURHSRXGHUHQPHWKHWKRRJVWH ULVLFRSURILHO+HWLQWHUYHQWLHSURJUDPPDZDVNRVWHQEHVSDUHQGLQGHEDVLVDQDO\VHHQEOHHN RRNLQGHVHQVLWLYLWHLWVDQDO\VHV]HHUJXQVWLJHNRVWHQHIIHFWLYLWHLWVUDWLR¶VWHKHEEHQPD[LPDDO SHUYRRUNRPHQYDO  _{+HUWRJ3GHQ+HQQHV%0XOGHU63ULYpRQJHYDOOHQ,Q9RONVJH]RQGKHLG7RHNRPVW9HUNHQQLQJ1DWLRQDDO} .RPSDV9RONVJH]RQGKHLG%LOWKRYHQ5,90KWWSZZZQDWLRQDDONRPSDVQO _{5L]]R-$%DNHU',0F$YD\*7LQHWWL0(7KHFRVWHIIHFWLYHQHVVRIDPXOWLIDFWRULDOWDUJHWHGSUHYHQWLRQ} SURJUDPIRUIDOOVDPRQJFRPPXQLW\HOGHUO\SHUVRQV0HG&DUH

5,90UDSSRUW SDJYDQ

2YHULJHSUHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶V%HYRUGHULQJERUVWYRHGLQJ

%RUVWYRHGLQJKHHIWHHQJXQVWLJHIIHFWRSHHQDDQWDODDQGRHQLQJHQ=RKHHIWERUVWYRHGLQJELM KHWNLQGHHQSRVLWLHIHIIHFWRSGHFRJQLWLHYHRQWZLNNHOLQJHQYRRUNRPWERUVWYRHGLQJDFXWH PLGGHQRRURQWVWHNLQJGDUPLQIHFWLHVHQDWRSLVFKHDDQGRHQLQJHQ%LMGHPRHGHUYHUNOHLQWKHW JHYHQYDQERUVWYRHGLQJGHNDQVRSERUVWNDQNHUYyyUGHRYHUJDQJ9HUGHULVERUVWYRHGLQJ JHDVVRFLHHUGPHWWDOYDQDQGHUHDDQGRHQLQJHQ]RDOVYRHGVHORYHUJHYRHOLJKHLGHQGLDEHWHV 9DQZHJHGHSRVLWLHYHJH]RQGKHLGVHIIHFWHQYDQERUVWYRHGLQJDGYLVHHUWGH:+2RPNLQGHUHQ WRWHQPHWGHOHHIWLMGYDQ]HVPDDQGHQXLWVOXLWHQGERUVWYRHGLQJWHJHYHQGXV]RQGHUNXQVW RIELMYRHGLQJ(QKRHZHOHUUHFHQWHOLMNHHQ]HNHUHWRHQDPHLQKHWJHYHQYDQERUVWYRHGLQJ ZRUGWJH]LHQYROJGHLQVOHFKWVpp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HQHHQ OHYHQVEHGUHLJHQGHGDUPDDQGRHQLQJQHFURWLVHUHQGHHQWHURFROLWLVYRRUNLQGHUHQPHWHHQODDJ JHERRUWHJHZLFKWNLQGHUHQGLHERUVWYRHGLQJNULMJHQLQGHSHULRGHWRWRQWVODJXLWKHW ]LHNHQKXLVYHUJHOHNHQPHWNLQGHUHQGLHIOHVYRHGLQJNULMJHQ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¶V]DOOHLGHQWRWEHVSDULQJHQRS JH]RQGKHLGV]RUJXLWJDYHQ  _{1DWLRQDDO.RPSDV9RONVJH]RQGKHLGZZZULYPQOQDWLRQDDONRPSDV} _{/DQWLQJ&,+HUVFKGHUIHU.YDQ:RXZH-35HLMQHYHOG6$3HLOLQJPHONYRHGLQJYDQ]XLJHOLQJHQ} HQKHWHIIHFWYDQFHUWLILFHULQJRSGHERUVWYRHGLQJVFLMIHUV/HLGHQ7123UHYHQWLHHQ*H]RQGKHLG _{:HLPHU-7KHHFRQRPLFEHQHILWVRIEUHDVWIHHGLQJDUHYLHZDQGDQDO\VLV86'HSDUWPHQWRI$JULFXOWXUH} (FRQRPLFV5HVHDUFK6HUYLFH)RRG$VVLVWDQFHDQG1XWULWLRQ5HVHDUFK5HSRUWQR _{+ROWHUPDQ01RXW607KHHFRQRPLFEHQHILWRIEUHDVWIHHGLQJLQWKH1HWKHUODQGV5HSRUWRQWKHVDYLQJVRI} KHDOWKFDUHFRVWVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKEUHDVWIHHGLQJGXHWRWKHSURWHFWLYHHIIHFWRIEUHDVWIHHGLQJRQLOOQHVVHVRIWKH FKLOGDQGWKHPRWKHU$PVWHUGDP9ULMH8QLYHUVLWHLW:HWHQVFKDSVZLQNHO