• No results found

Independent agencies, political

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "Independent agencies, political"

Copied!
5
0
0

Bezig met laden.... (Bekijk nu de volledige tekst)

Hele tekst

(1)

Independent agencies, political

interference, and firm investment:

evidence from the European Union

A discussion by

Michiel Bijlsma

Head Competition and Regulation

(2)
(3)

Comments

• Effect of institutions on investment highly relevant

problem

• Analysis potentially suffers from endogeneity

• Decision whether or not to erect IRA is endogenous.

• Example in paper: governments signal commitment

(4)

Comments

• The paper claims ‘To tackle this problem, we use instrumental

variable methods that exploit the cross-country variation in the political and legal endowments that may ensure credibility to the regulatory institution (…).’

• In practice, they

– apply SYS-GMM, i.e., using first-differenced lagged variables as instruments

– Use external instruments such as ‘checks and balances and ‘rule of law.

• I am no expert on GMM, but a bit like von Munchhausen • Somewhat unconvincing that rule of law and check and

(5)

Comments

• Timing of IRA also endogenous

• Decision to instigate IRA may coincide with other

events.

– Opening up of national markets

– Privatization

– Buoyant stock markets

• If privatization drives effect, this may explain

lower effect IRA under right-wing governments

• Include privatization dummies, GDP growth into

Referenties

GERELATEERDE DOCUMENTEN

Finally, the third hypothesis, which states that the economic system of a country influences the relation between privatization and growth, where in a more liberal

I will analyze the rise of populism by using the economic security or economic inequality perspective, and develop an econometric model that looks at the relationship between

Hypothesis 3: FDI that is privatization or M&A activity will have only a reduced positive (or even negative) effect on the rate of economic growth compared to Greenfield FDI..

In the other fotmerly socialist economies, business can become more competitive if [he ex- change rate of the domestic currency is devalued or left free to float downwards on

By analyzing the effects of water privatization in Argentina, Peru, Colombia, Bolivia and Chile, and by linking these effects to the neo-liberalistic ideologies that

De drie cirkels met die diagonalen als middellijn moeten dan dus (volgens het gevolg 2 van stelling 4) een gemeenschappelijke machtlijn hebben (6b) waar elk van de vier

Of the subgroup (n = 173) who would potentially support the concept of PMSC peacekeeping operations, 48% was undecided on donating to such a cause and just under 10% would be

In this chapter I have discussed the major points from Clausewitz’s theory that I have used to analyze the current situation in Iraq, in relation to the use of private military