• No results found

Raadsbesluit Toetsingsmatrix tbv locatiekeuze nieuw gemeenschapshuis Asten

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Share "Raadsbesluit Toetsingsmatrix tbv locatiekeuze nieuw gemeenschapshuis Asten"

Copied!
12
0
0

Bezig met laden.... (Bekijk nu de volledige tekst)

Hele tekst

(1)

<..1=/2=8?5>

3GOGGPUGN

LUfgYb

IbXYejYed6 >U[gY_Yb]b[6 ;[YbXUbhaaYe6

McYgf]b[faUge]k gYb VY\cYiY Yb `cWUg]Y_YhmY b]Yhj

[YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f ;fgYb -- XYWYaVYe .,-4 -4*-.*,0

>Y eUUX iUb XY [YaYYbgY ;fgYb7

[Ym]Yb \Yg iccefgY` iUb \Yg Wc``Y[Y iUb Vhe[YaYYfgYe Yb jYg\chXYef iUb /, c_gcVYe .,-4 aYg mUU_bhaaYe .,-4,2.-,57

[Y\cceX \Yg UXi]Yf iUb XY Wcaa]ff]Y <he[Yef iUb -5 bciYaVYe .,-47

VYf`h]g6

-* XY gcYgf b[faUge]k aYg V]^VY\ceYbXY jY[]b[fZUWgceYb iUfg gY fgY``Yb mcU`f cd[YbcaYb ]b XY V]^`U[Y VY\ceYbXY V]^ X]g iccefgY` Yb XYmY gY \UbgYeYb U`f gcYgf]b[ icce XY `cWUg]Y_YhmY iUb \Yg $iYe%b]Yhj$X% [YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f ;fgYb .* jYbfYb Yb VYXYb_]b[Yb _YbVUUe gY aU_Yb gYb UUbm]Yb iUb6

) XY [YZceah`YYeXY eUbXiccejUUeXYb X]Y jceXYb [Y\UbgYYeX ]b \Yg iYeic`[decWYf

$cbXYeXYY` <%

) XY ghffYb XY [YaYYbgY Yb XY Lg]W\g]b[ AYaYYbfW\Udf\h]f ;fgYb gY f`h]gYb ]bgYbg]YciYeYYb_cafg $cbXYeXYY` =%*

;`Xhf iUfg[YfgY`X ]b XY cdYbVUeY iYe[UXYe]b[ iUb XY eUUX iUb XY [YaYYbgY ;fgYb iUb -- XYWYaVYe .,-4*

iccebcYaX*

>Y eU U

(ae* G *P* iUb ?ed)LcbbYaUbf(

iccem]ggYe(

ae* B*A* Ocf

(2)

3GOGGPUG

<..1=@;;<=>28

/56 B..7:?992<, (&'*&)('&+

S;SfgYb

IbXYejYed6 <]^`U[Y$b%6 OYe[UXYe]b[

iUb6

;[YbXU) bhaaYe6

d*\*6

McYgf]b[faUge]k gYb VY\cYiY iUb `cWUg]Y_YhmY

b]Yhj [YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f ;fgYb )-,) -- XYWYaVYe

.,-4 -4*-.*,0 DL

XY eUUX

iUb XY [YaYYbgY

;fgYb

=COGPWCUUKPI

>cce XY dec^YWg`Y]XYe mU` g]^XYbf XY Wcaa]ff]YiYe[UXYe]b[ YYb gcY`]W\g]b[ jceXYb [Y[YiYb* B]^ mU`

YYb gcY`]W\g]b[ [YiYb cd XY gcYgf]b[faUge]k Yb XY V]^VY\ceYbXY jY[]b[fZUWgceYb( U`faYXY ciYe \Yg iYe`ccd iUb \Yg decWYf*

Cb XY UZ[Y`cdYb dYe]cXY ]f XY WYbgeU`Y ieUU[( X]Y ic`[g h]g XY YYeXYe Xcce hj eUUX iUfg[YfgY`XY VYfghhefcdXeUW\g eYU`]fUg]Y b]Yhj [YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f ;fgYb( iYeXYe iYeX]Ydg Yb ]f XY ]bZceaUg]Y h]g

\Yg iYe`YXYb [YUWghU`]fYYeX*

1GEGPUSCNGWSCCIKPFGDGTUVVSTQRFSCEJUKTJQGSGCNKTGSGPXGZZPEGPUSCCNIGNGIGP IGOGGPTEJCRTJVKTKPFGMGSP.TUGP-

BcYeYU`]fYeYbjY(cbXYeeY[]YiUbXY[YaYYbgYYb]bfUaYbjYe_]b[ aYgXYfg]W\g]b[fVYfgheYb(

iYeYb][]b[YbYb UbXYeYVY`Ub[\YVVYbXYb(YYbb]Yhj+iYeb]YhjXWYbgeUU`[Y`Y[Yb[YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f]bXY_Yeb;fgYb(

XUgic`XcYbXYXeUU[i`U_cbXYeXYVYcc[XY[YVeh]_Yef_Ybg( VYgUU`VUUe]f$YYbVY\YYefVUeYVY[ecg]b[\YYZgmcjY`V]^

eYU`]fUg]Y(U`fV]^gcY_cafg][VY\YYeYbYkd`c]gUg]Y%YbjUUeV]^fdeU_Y]fiUb\hhede]^mYbX]Y]bXY`]^b`][[YbaYgXY de]^mYbV]^[YaYYbfW\Udf\h]mYb BYhfXYbYbIaaY`*

B]YegcY m]^b YYb i]YegU` jYe_V]^YYb_cafgYb icceVYeY]X Yb Xcce`cdYb* >Y ]bZceaUg]Y X]Y g]^XYbf XYmY V]^YYb_cafgYb ]f cd[Y\UU`X ]f iYejYe_g gcg YYb gcYgf]b[faUge]k Yb aYg XY UUbjYm][Yb+XYY`bYaYef iYegUU`X bUUe jY[]b[fZUWgceYb* Occe[YfgY`X jceXg ca XY icce`][[YbXY gcYgf]b[faUge]k Yb

jY[]b[fZUWgceYb iUfg gY fgY``Yb*

>UUebUUfg ]f \Yg bccXmU_Y`]^_ ca V]^ XY iYeXYeY h]gjYe_]b[ iUb XY fWYbUe]c#f YYb UUbgU`

eUbXiccejUUeXYb gY \UbgYeYb( gYbY]bXY gY icce_caYb XUg b]Yg \UU`VUeY iYejUW\g]b[Yb jceXYb [YjY_g* >YmY eUbXiccejUUeXYb m]^b [YZceah`YYeX ]b cbXYeXYY` < iUb X]g iccefgY`*

MYbf`cggY ]f \Yg bccXmU_Y`]^_ XUg Ye YYb $b]YhjY% ]bgYbg]Y ciYeYYb_cafg jceXg [Yf`cgYb ghffYb XY [YaYYbgY Yb XY Lg]W\g]b[ AYaYYbfW\Udf\h]f ;fgYb* >YmY jceXg ]b cbXYeXYY` = iUb \Yg iccefgY`

bUXYe gcY[Y`]W\g*

P]^ iYemcY_Yb hj eUUX jYbfYb Yb VYXYb_]b[Yb _YbVUUe gY aU_Yb gYb UUbm]Yb iUb XY eUbXiccejUUeXYb Yb XY ]bgYbg]YciYeYYb_cafg*

\5



(3)

/GTNKTRVPUGP

-* BYg iUfgfgY``Yb iUb XY gcYgf]b[faUge]k aYg V]^VY\ceYbXY jY[]b[fZUWgceYb U`f iYeX]Yd]b[ Yb h]gjYe_]b[ iUb XY VYfghhefcdXeUW\g eYU`]fUg]Y b]Yhj [YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f ;fgYb $cbXYeXYY` ;%7 .* PYbfYb Yb VYXYb_]b[Yb _YbVUUe aU_Yb gYb UUbm]Yb iUb6

) XY [YZceah`YYeXY eUbXiccejUUeXYb X]Y jceXYb [Y\UbgYYeX ]b \Yg iYeic`[decWYf $cbXYeXYY`

<%7

) XY ghffYb XY [YaYYbgY Yb XY Lg]W\g]b[ AYaYYbfW\Udf\h]f ;fgYb gY f`h]gYb ]bgYbg]YciYeYYb_cafg $cbXYeXYY` =%*

5PNGKFKPI

HUUe UUb`Y]X]b[ iUb XY VYfghhefcdXeUW\g eYU`]fUg]Y b]Yhj [YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f ;fgYb ]f V]^ \Yg VY[]b iUb \Yg decWYf YYb d`Ub iUb UUbdU_ cd[YfgY`X* >]g d`Ub iUb UUbdU_ ]f cd[YVchjX h]g iYefW\]``YbXY ZUfYb ca h]gY]bXY`]^_ gY _caYb gcg YYb `cWUg]Y_YhmY* <]^ \Yg Xcce`cdYb iUb \Yg decWYf ]f \Yg iUb VY`Ub[ XUg XY iYefW\]``YbXY fgU_Y\c`XYef $mcU`f fg]W\g]b[fVYfgh$h%e$Yb%( [YVeh]_Yef( Wc``Y[Y Yb [YaYYbgYeUUX% ]b \Yg decWYf Yb( jUUe bcX][( cd XY ]b\chX jceXYb aYY[YbcaYb* Cb \Yg d`Ub iUb UUbdU_ m]^b YYb gjYYgU` acaYbgYb iccem]Yb XUg Xcce XY [YaYYbgYeUUX YYb VYf`h]g acYg jceXYb [YbcaYb* >]g VYgeYZg XY iUfgfgY``]b[ iUb XY gcYgf]b[faUge]k Yb XY h]gY]bXY`]^_Y `cWUg]Y_YhmY aYg XY V]^VY\ceYbXY iccejUUeXYb* Cb \Yg d`Ub iUb UUbdU_ ]f X]g XY ciYe[Ub[ iUb fgUd CCC bUUe fgUd CO

$gcYgf]b[faUge]k% Yb XY ciYe[Ub[ iUb fgUd OC bUUe fgUd OCC $`cWUg]Y_YhmY%*

Cba]XXY`f ]f \Yg decWYf mciYe [YiceXYeX XUg XY gcYgf]b[faUge]k aYg V]^VY\ceYbXY jY[]b[fZUWgceYb ]b WcbWYdg [YeYYX ]f Yb gYe iUfgfgY``]b[ UUb hj eUUX _Ub jceXYb icce[Y`Y[X*

>UUebUUfg ]f \Yg iUb VY`Ub[ XUg V]^ XY iYeXYeY h]gjYe_]b[ iUb XY fWYbUe]c#f YYb UUbgU`

eUbXiccejUUeXYb jceXYb [Y\UbgYYeX ca gY icce_caYb XUg ]b \Yg iYeXYeY decWYf iUb b]Yg \UU`VUeY h]g[Ub[fdhbgYb jceXg h]g[Y[UUb*

MYbf`cggY ]f \Yg bccXmU_Y`]^_ YYb b]YhjY ]bgYbg]YciYeYYb_cafg gY f`h]gYb aYg XY Lg]W\g]b[

AYaYYbfW\Udf\h]f ;fgYb* AY`Yg cd \Yg $aUUgfW\UddY`]^_% VY`Ub[ XUg iUb X]g dec^YWg fgY``Yb j]^ hj eUUX ]b XY [Y`Y[Yb\Y]X ca jYbfYb Yb VYXYb_]b[Yb gYb UUbm]Yb iUb XYmY ]bgYbg]YciYeYYb_cafg _YbVUUe gY aU_Yb*

;^* McYgf]b[faUge]k Yb jY[]b[fZUWgceYb

IbXYefgUUbX jceXg \Yg decWYfiYe`ccd gcg bh gcY bUXYe gcY[Y`]W\g*

PYe_V]^YYb_cafgYb*

GYg \Yg ce[Ub]fYeYb iUb XY fgUegV]^YYb_cafg cd 1 ^h`] .,-4 ]f \Yg fgUegfY]b [Y[YiYb UUb U``Y [YpbgYeYffYYeXYb( cajcbYbXYb Yb \h]X][Y [YVeh]_Yef iUb XY E`YdY` Yb XY <Y]UUeX* >YmY UicbX jUf [cYX VYmcW\g Yb ]f [YVeh]_g ca ]YXYeYYb geUbfdUeUbg gY ]bZceaYeYb ciYe \Yg decWYf XUg mU`

jceXYb Xcce`cdYb*

OYeic`[Ybf ]f a]XXY`f YYb 0)gU` UWg]YiY jYe_V]^YYb_cafgYb ]b iYefW\]``YbXY [ecYdYb ]bZceaUg]Y

\Ye]^_g Yb UUb[Yih`X U`f iYeX]Yd]b[ iUb XY VYfghhefcdXeUW\g* >Y eYfh`gUgYb iUb XY jYe_V]^YYb_cafgYb m]^b \]YecbXYe fUaYb[YiUg* Occe YYb [YXYgU]``YYeXY jYYe[UiY iUb XY jYe_V]^YYb_cafgYb iYej]^mYb j]^ h [eUU[ bUUe XY jYVf]gY6

\ggdf6++jjj*UfgYb*b]+VchjYb+>ec]YWgYb+[YaYYbfW\U>f\h]f*\ga` jUUe U``Y deYfYbgUg]Yf Yb gUZY`iYef`U[Yb iUb XYmY jYe_V]^YYb_cafgYb gY i]bXYb m]^b*

2KLGGPMQOUV + #,. CWIWUVWU ,*+.$0 AKUKG GP JGTKLMGP IGIGXGPU TWKOVGNKLMG DGJQGHVG(

Cb XY YYefgY V]^YYb_cafg ]f YYb V]^XeU[Y cd[Y\UU`X ciYe XY i]f]Y iUb \Yg [YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f ]b XY g\YaU#f6

) jY`_Y XcY`fgY``]b[ acYg \Yg [YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f bUfgeYiYb9 jY`_Y gUU_ mch \Yg acYgYb iYeih``Yb9

) jY`_Y bccXmU_Y`]^_Y( jYbfY`]^_Y Yb cdg]cbY`Y ZhbWg]Yf \ceYb \]Ye XUb V]^9

;`f UZf`h]g]b[ iUb XYmY jYe_V]^YYb_cafg ]f [YieUU[X XY eh]agY`]^_Y VY\cYZgY _YbVUUe gY aU_Yb Yb UUb gY eY]_Yb*

"!!"

(4)

Id \ccZX`]^bYb ]f XY h]g_cafg iUb XY YYefgY RjYe_V]^YYb_cafg U`f ic`[g fUaYb gY iUggYb6 ) \Yg ZUX`]gYeYb iUb `c_U`Y [YVeh]_Yef cd YYb `UU[XeYadY`][Y j]^mY Zlf]Y_( Z]bUbW]YY` Yb

dec[eUaaUg]fW\7

) XY _eh]fVYfgh]i]b[ gY fg]ah`YeYb Yb U`f f`YhgY`ZhbWg]Y gY Zhb[YeYb icce ]bih``]b[ iUb XY aUUgfW\UddY`]^_Y VY\cYZgY Yb XcY`fgY``]b[Yb( YYb mc[YbUUaXY #\h]f_UaYe iUb ;fgYb#7 ) bccXmU_Y`]^_Y ZhbWg]Y ca YYb _cfgYbXY__YbXY Ykd`c]gUg]Y gY eYU`]fYeYb Yb UUb gY f`h]gYb V]^

[YVeh]_Yef X]Y UWg]YZ m]^b ]b \Yg fcW]U`Y XcaY]b* PYbfY`]^_ ca XY V]V`]cg\YY_ gY ]bgY[eYeYb ]b mcjY` XY Ykd`c]gUg]Y U`f \Yg [YVchj Yb cdg]cbYY` ]f YYb jccbZhbWg]Y icce U``YYbfgUUbXY chXYeYb7

aYg bUaY XY ic`[YbXY _YebVY[e]ddYb _jUaYb bUUe iceYb6 aYg Y`_UUe( icce Y`_UUe( XUUe m]^b jY gecgf cd! *

>Y eh]agY`]^_Y VY\cYZgY ]f iYemUaY`X ]b YYb ciYem]W\g Yb mU` U`f ]bdhg X]YbYb icce XY

]bdUff]b[fghX]Yf X]Y ]b XY ic`[YbXY ZUfY jceXYb cd[YfgY`X* H]Yg U``Y iYeYb][]b[Yb \YVVYb U`

[YeYU[YYeX cd XY cdecYd ca \hb eh]agY`]^_Y VY\cYZgY _YbVUUe gY aU_Yb* >Y cbgVeY_YbXY [Y[YiYbf mh``Yb( icce XYmY ZUfY( iUbh]g YYeXYe [YdecXhWYYeXY fgh__Yb jceXYb ciYe[YbcaYb* <]^

XY deYfYbgUg]Y iUb XY YYefgY fW\YgfYb mU` X]g UUb XY \UbX iUb YYb i`Y__Ybd`Ub+fW\Ygf bc[ YYbf jceXYb [YgcYgfg ]b YYb jYe_V]^YYb_cafg*

<]^YYb_cafg .$2 fYdgYaVYe .,-4%6 ?kd`c]gUg]Y " \Ye]^_Yb [Y[YiYbf WcbgeUWghY`Y UZfdeU_Yb*

Cb XY gjYYXY V]^YYb_cafg ]f YYb V]^XeU[Y cd[Y\UU`X icce XY Ykd`c]gUg]Yj]^mY ]b XY UUbXUW\gfdhbgYb VYXe]^ZficYe]b[( Z]bUbW]ob( UWg]i]gY]gYb Yb X]iYefYb*

Id \ccZX`]^bYb ]f XY h]g_cafg iUb XY gjYYXY jYe_V]^YYb_cafg U`f ic`[g fUaYb gY iUggYb6 ) VYXe]^ZficYe]b[6 YYb decZYff]cbYY` VYfghhe XUg fg]ah`YYeg ca fUaYb UWg]i]gY]gYb gY XcYb!

OUfgY [YVeh]_Yef fdY`Yb YYb ec` ]b XY Ykd`c]gUg]Y* >]g _Ub Xcce gU_Yb+iYeUbgjcceXY`]^_\YXYb gY iYeih``Yb* IbXYemcW\g mch acYgYb jceXYb \cY \]Ye $Z]bUbW]YY`% eYfh`gUUgXY`]b[ UUb _Ub jceXYb iYeVcbXYb*

) Z]bUbW]YY`6 eYU`]fg]fW\Y VY[ecg]b[ X]Y _cfgYbXY__YbX ]f* Nb]ZceaY \hhede]^mYb aUUe jY` YYb cbXYefW\Y]X ghffYb WcaaYeW]YY` Yb aUUgfW\UddY`]^_Y \hhede]^mYb* ?iYbghY`Y V]^XeU[Y [YaYYbgY iYeV]bXYb UUb fcW]U`Y + aUUgfW\UddY`]^_Y XcY`fgY``]b[Yb*

) UWg]i]gY]gYb6 eh]agY cdYb]b[fg]^XYb* Fc_YgZhbWg]Yf ]b ;fgYb iYeV]bXYb* =caaYeW]YY` Yb aUUgfW\UddY`]^_ `c_UU` [Yce]obgYYeX aYg YYb XY[Y`]^_Y \ceYWUZhbWg]Y U`f cbXYefgYhb]b[*

) X]iYefYb6 Ye jceXg UUbXUW\g [YieUU[X icce c*U* YYb ;?> UddUeUUg( [Y`XUhgcaUUg(

VYgeY__Yb Vh]gYbeh]agY Yb YYb cd`UUXdhbg $Uhgc( Z]Ygf( fWccgacV]Y`%*

;`f UZf`h]g]b[ m]^b V]^ XY \h]X][Y [YVeh]_Yef XY \h]X][Y ciYeYYb_cafgYb+WcbgeUWgYb iYemUaY`X ca XY VYfgUUbXY UZfdeU_Yb ]b VYY`X gY VeYb[Yb* >YmY mh``Yb ]b XY ic`[YbXY ZUfY jceXYb [YVeh]_g V]^ XY Ykd`c]gUg]YVYeY_Yb]b[Yb* H]Yg U``Y iYeYb][]b[Yb \YVVYb [YeYU[YYeX cd XY cdecYd ca XY VYfgUUbXY

$WcbgeUWghY`Y% UZfdeU_Yb UUb gY `YiYeYb* >Y cbgVeY_YbXY [Y[YiYb mh``Yb( icce XYmY ZUfY( iUbh]g YYeXYe [YdecXhWYYeXY fgh__Yb jceXYb ciYe[YbcaYb*

<]^YYb_cafg / $-/ fYdgYaVYe .,-4%6 McYgf]b[faUge]k cdfgY``Yb

M]^XYbf XY XYeXY V]^YYb_cafg ]f XY V]^XeU[Y iUb icce[UUbXY V]^YYb_cafgYb iYegUU`X ]b 0

VchjfgYbYb Yb .0 V]^VY\ceYbXY dUeUaYgYef* ;`f UUbih``]b[ cd XYmY dUeUaYgYef m]^b Ye UUbih``YbXY ieU[Yb [YZceah`YYeX X]Y XY UUbjYm][Yb VY`Ub[e]^_ icbXYb Yb jUUe a]b]aUU` YYb gcY`]W\g]b[ cd mch acYgYb jceXYb [Y[YiYb V]^ XY iYefW\]``YbXY fWYbUe]c#f ]b XY gcYgf]b[f)+VYcceXY`]b[faUge]k*

2KLGGPMQOUV - #+. UGRVGODGT ,*+.$0 @QGVUKPIUOCVTKZ XCUVUVGNNGP CNU CFXKGU PCCT UVWWTITQGR GP EQNNGIG

Cb XY i]YeXY V]^YYb_cafg m]^b XY UUbih``]b[Yb h]g XY icce[UUbXY V]^YYb_cafg iYejYe_g*

>Y i]YeXY V]^YYb_cafg ]f cd[YXYY`X ]b gjYY cbXYeXY`Yb*

Cb \Yg YYefgY cbXYeXYY` \YVVYb XY UUbjYm][Yb XY g]Yb VY`Ub[e]^_fgY dUeUaYgYef UUb[Y[YiYb* Cb

\Yg YYefgY XYY` iUb XY i]YeXY V]^YYb_cafg m]^b g]Yb dUeUaYgYef UUb[Y[YiYb X]Y U`f VY`Ub[e]^_fgY jceXYb [Ym]Yb ]b XY VYcceXY`]b[ Yb U`f UXi]Yf jceXYb UUb[YeY]_g bUUe XY Lghhe[ecYd Yb \Yg

=c``Y[Y* >]g m]^b ]b j]``Y_Yhe][Y ic`[ceXY6 Z]bUbW]YY` eYfh`gUUg Ykd`c]gUg]Y( Z]bUbW]YY` e]f]Wc*

#!!"

(5)

\hhede]^mYb [YVeh]_Yef( bccXmU_Y`]^_Y eh]agYVY\cYZgY( ZhbWg]cbU`]gY]g( gcY_cafgVYfgYbX][(

dec[eUaaYe]b[( $Ykd`c]gUg]Y% VYfghhe( cbXYebYaYefW\Ud Yb XeUU[i`U_ $\h]X][Y% [YVeh]_Yef*

Cb \Yg gjYYXY XYY` iUb XY V]^YYb_cafg \YVVYb XY UUbjYm][Yb UUb XYmY -, dUeUaYgYef

YYb jY[]b[fZUWgce iUb - gcg -, gcY[Y_YbX( jUUeV]^ - VY`Ub[e]^_fgY ]f Yb -, XY a]bfg VY`Ub[e]^_Y*

B]Yeh]g ]f XY ic`[YbXY ic`[ceXY cbgfgUUb6 -* bccXmU_Y`]^_ eh]agY VY\cYZgY7 .* ZhbWg]cbU`]gY]g7

/* Z]bUbW]YY` eYfh`gUUg Ykd`c]gUg]Y7 0* Z]bUbW]YY` e]f]Wc7

1* \hhede]^mYb [YVeh]_Yef7 2* gcY_cafgVYfgYbX][\Y]X7 3* cbXYebYaYefW\Ud7

4* XeUU[i`U_ $\h]X][Y% [YVeh]_Yef7 5* $Ykd`c]gUg]Y% VYfghhe7

-,* dec[eUaaYe]b[*

>Y jY[]b[fZUWgceYb [YiYb UUb jY`_Y -, dUeUaYgYef iUb XY .0 \Yg VY`Ub[e]^_fgY m]^b* >cce \Yg gcY_YbbYb iUb YYb iYeaYb][ih`X][]b[fZUWgce& mU` X]g cc_ m]^b jYYef`U[ i]bXYb ]b XY VYcceXY`]b[*

%$AGTVCNKPIYGIKPIUHCEVQTKPXGTOGPKIXWNFKI0

>YgcYgf]b[iUbXY.0dUeUaYgYefmh``YbXccegcY_Ybb]b[iUbjY[]b[fZUWgceYbYYbiYefW\]``YbXYmjUUegY\YVVYb]bXY VYcceXY`]b[* P]f_hbX][]fX]gU`fic`[gicea[Y[YiYb*;``YdUeUaYgYefgY``YbaYY]bXYVYcceXY`]b[(XUUeV]^m]^bXY-, VY`Ub[e]^_fgYdUeUaYgYefiYeV]^mcbXYeX*>YmY-,dUeUaYgYef\YVVYb]bXYVYcceXY`]b[YYbmjUUeXYeUUbXYY`*AYm]Yb\Yg ZY]gXUg-XYVY`Ub[e]^_fgYdUeUaYgYef]f_e]^[gXYmYXY[eccgfgYiYeaYb][ih`X][]b[fZUWgce]bXYVYcceXY`]b[* P]f_hbX][

\YYZgX]gm]^bjYYef`U[]bYYbiYeaYb][ih`X][]b[ZUWgceiUb--* PUUeca--9>]g_cagcaXUgjYU``YdUeUaYgYef`UgYb aYYgY``Ybicce`kXYfWceYYbXUgXYjY[]b[fZUWgce-,XUbVY[]bgaYgYYbiYeaYb][ih`X][]b[iUb.kXYfWceY*TTTTTTTTT

?Yb Yb UbXYe ]f iYejYe_g ]b XY gcYgf]b[faUge]k X]Y U`f V]^`U[Y V]^ \Yg WcbWYdg)eUUXfVYf`h]g ]f [YicY[X*

@8>CUVGP(PN

>Y gcYgf]b[faUge]k ]f gYiYbf UUb[YVcXYb i]U MCJUfgYb*b` UUb XY 2,, UUb[Yf`cgYb Vhe[Ye) dUbY``YXYb* >Y h]g_cafg ]f VYXcY`X U`f [eUUXaYgYe icce XY VciYbfgUUbXY de]ce]gYe]b[ iUb XY jY[]b[fZUWgceYb* M]^XYbf XY jYe_V]^YYb_cafgYb ]f ]b fUaYbfdeUU_ aYg XY UUbjYm][Yb UUb[Y[YiYb XUg XY h]gf`U[ iUb MCJUfgYb*b` U`f [eUUXaYgYe+fd]Y[Y` mU` X]YbYb Yb b]Yg U`f fgYa*

N]g XY .1- eYfdcbXYbgYb( jUUeiUb .-3 h]g ;fgYb( ]f XY ic`[YbXY de]ce]gYe]b[ cd gY aU_Yb6 -* Z]bUbW]YY` eYfh`gUUg Ykd`c]gUg]Y7

.* gcY_cafgVYfgYbX][\Y]X7 /* \hhede]^mYb [YVeh]_Yef7 0* Z]bUbW]YY` e]f]Wc7

1* bccXmU_Y`]^_Y eh]agYVY\cYZgY7 2* ZhbWg]cbU`]gY]g7

3* XeUU[i`U_ $\h]X][Y% [YVeh]_Yef7 4* dec[eUaaYe]b[7

5* cbXYebYaYefW\Ud7 -,* $Ykd`c]gUg]Y% VYfghhe*

N]g YYb iYe[Y`]^_]b[ ghffYb XY jY[]b[fZUWgceYb iUbh]g XY jYe_V]^YYb_cafgYb Yb MCJUfgYb*b` _Ub jceXYb [YWcbW`hXYYeX XUg Ye YYb . XY`]b[ ]f gY aU_Yb ghffYb XY VY`Ub[e]^_fgY mYf jY[]b[fZUWgceYb(

- g+a 2 Yb XY ciYeV`]^iYbXY i]Ye( 3 g+a -,*

MYiYbf ]f gY WcbW`hXYeYb XUg MCJ ;fgYb*b` YYb Xh]XY`]^_Y fW\Y]X]b[ `UUg m]Yb ghffYb XY YYefgY 2 jY[]b[fZUWgceYb Yb XY eYfgYeYbXY* BYg UUbgU` iYefW\h]i]b[Yb ]b XY jY[]b[fZUWgceYb - g+a 2 ]f cc_

U``YYb ]b XUg VYeY]_* OYeic`[Ybf ]f gY m]Yb XUg XY jY[]b[fZUWgceYb 3 g+a -, U``YYb iYefW\h]iYb ]b

\Yg VYeY]_ 3 g+a -,* >UUeaYY ]f \Yg cc_ ]b UUbf`h]g]b[ cd Yb U`f [eUUXaYgYe gY Ye_YbbYb icce XY ]bZceaUg]Y X]Y jY \YVVYb cd[Y\UU`X h]g XY jYe_V]^YYb_cafgYb*

$!!"

(6)

1FXKGU ?VKEJVKPI 6GOGGPUEJCRUJWKU 1UVGP(

>Y VYfghhef`YXYb iUb Lg]W\g]b[ [YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f ;fgYb \YVVYb _Ybb]f[YbcaYb iUb iccefgY` UUb

\Yg Wc``Y[Y Yb XY V]^VY\ceYbXY fgh__Yb* >Y m]Ybfj]^mY cd \Yg decWYf( XY fgh__Yb Yb XY gcYgf]b[faUge]k ]f Xcce \Yb U`f ic`[g cd \ccZX`]^bYb gY iYejcceXYb7

AQQT W NKIV GGP NKLXKI DQGMYGTM QXGT GGP XGGNDGURTQMGP QPFGTYGTR& GGP PKGWY IGOGGPUEJCRUJWKU

=PU UVCPFRWPV JGDDGP YKL CN GGTFGT XGTMQPFKIF GP DNKLXGP YG FQGP& YKL DGITKLRGP PKGV FCV FG IGOGGPVG 1UVGP FG GPKIG IGOGGPVG KP <QQTF'2TCDCPV KU FKG JGV QPTQGTGPF IQGF XCP

IGOGGPUEJCRUJWK[GP PKGV KP GKIGPFQO Y7 JGDDGP( 4CV DTGPIV OGV [KEJ OGG FCV QP[G UVKEJVKPIGP VQV GGP XGGN ITQVGTG HKPCPEK\NG XGTRNKEJVKPI YQTFGP IGFYQPIGP& OGV CNNG FCCTDKL DGJQTGPFG TKUKEQ"U(

5GP IGOGGPVG JQQTV GT VG [KLP XQQT JCCT DWTIGTU& FG DWTIGTU PKGV XQQT FG IGOGGPVG(

=O PQI VYGG MGW[GU VG JGDDGP& JGV JWKFKIG IGOGGPUEJCRUJWKU FG 9NGRGN& QH JGV RCVGTUMNQQUVGT&

OQGVGP YKL QXGTICCP VQV CCPMQQR XCP JGV RCVGTUMNQQUVGT( 4CVWO XCP QXGTPCOG KU WKVGTNKLM + CRTKN ,*+/( BKL MWPPGP CKNGGP VQV CCPMQQR QXGTICCP OKVU YKL GGP +** ICTCPVKG JGDDGP QO JGV RCPF FQQT VG MWPPGP XGTMQRGP& KPFKGP FG MGW[G PKGV QR JGV RCVGTUMNQQUVGT XCNV( =H CNU GT YGN XQQT JGV RCVGTUMNQQUVGT IGMQ[GP KU XQQT + UGRVGODGT ,*+/ WKV CNNG IGIGXGPU DNKLMV FCV FG HKPCPEK\NG

KPURCPPKPIUXGTRNKEJVKPI VG ITQQV KU( 4G VKLFURCPPG VWUUGP JGV DGUNWKV XCP FG IGOGGPVGTCCF KP CRTKN ,*+/ GP + UGRVGODGT ,*+/ JGDDGP YKL JCTF PQFKI QO KP DGGNF VG DTGPIGP QH YKL JGV PKGWYG IGOGGPUEJCRUJWKU #9NGRGN QH RCVGTUMNQQUVGT$ YGN MWPPGP DGMQUVKIGP OGV FG DGUEJKMDCCT IGUVGNFG HKPCPEK\NG OKFFGNGP( 4G IGOGGPVGTCCFXGTICFGTKPI XCP CRTKN ,*+/ IGNFV XQQT QPU FCCTQO CNU WKVGTUVG FCVWO(

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

4G QRMQOUV DKL FG GGTUVG IGDTWKMGTUCXQPF YCU JQQI& OCCT PCCTOCVG FG HTGSWGPVKG GP JGV CCPVCN VQGPCO YGTF JGV CCPVCN IG]PVGTGUUGGTFGP JGNCCU OKPFGT( ?QOOKIG IGDTWKMGTU YCTGP OGV

OGGTFGTG RGTUQPGP CCPYG[KI YCCTFQQT LG CNU XGTGPKIKPI GGP ITQVGTG UVGO KP JGV IGJGGN JCF( 5GP IQGF DWTIGTNKLM TGEJV YCV GNMG IGDTWKMGT JCF MWPPGP FQGP( 7GV KU CNNGGP LCOOGT FCV VQV PW VQG PKGV CNNG IGDTWKMGTU XCP JWP TGEJV VQV OGGDGUNKUUGP JGDDGP IGDTWKM IGOCCMV(

BKL [KLP XQN NQH QXGT FG KP[GV XCP FG CODVGPCTGP XCP FG IGOGGPVG 1UVGP KP FKV RTQLGEV( 7WP OGGFGPMGP KP FKV XQQT XGGN 1UVGPCTGP DGNCPITKLMG FQUUKGT GP JWP KP[GV DKL FG

IGDTWKMGTUDKLGGPMQOUVGP [KGP YKL CNU [GGT YCCTFGXQN(

4GUIGOGGPTEJCRTJVKT,QPUOQGUGP"WGSDKPFGP"NGSGPGPQPUTRCPPGP

1GDGJGGSTUKEJUKPIGPWCP1G/GKCCSFGP1G7NGRGNXKNNGPHVTGSGPGPXGSMGPTCOGPOGUFGDVSIGSTWCP.TUGP"FG IGDSVKMGSTGPFGIGOGGPUG"QOZZPPKGVXIGOGGPTEJCRTJVKTKP.TUGPUGICCPOCMGP$BKLXKNNGPJVKTWGTUKPIDKGFGP CCPUCNWCPWGSGPKIKPIGPGPISQGRGP$1CCSOGGOQGUJGUGGPIGOGGPTEJCRTJVKTWCPGPWQQSCNNG.TUGPCSGPXQSFGP$

;PYGOKTTKG

>Yb]YhjYfg]W\g]b[m]Yg\YgU`f\UUegUU_YYb[cYXZhbWg]cbYeYbXYbeYbXUVY`[YaYYbfW\Udf\h]ficce;fgYbgYeYU`]fYeYb*

Q]^j]`XUg\YgYYb`UU[XeYadY`][YcdYbVUeYcbgacYg]b[fd`UUgf]f(X]YX]iYef]gY]giYbjY]_cagYbiYeV]bXg(jUUeeh]agY]ficce YXhWUg]YYbcbgfdUbb]b[*

;PYGWKTKG

GUUgfW\UddY`]^_Ycbgd`cc]]b[CfYffYbg]YY`icceY`_aYbf(cb[YUW\gm]^b`YYZg]^X*?`_Y[YaYYbfW\Ud\YYZgVY\cYZgYUUb cbgacYg]b[Ybeh]agYicce[YmUaYb`]^_YUWg]i]gY]gYbYbYXhWUg]Y*?Yb[cYXYVUf]ficcem]Yb]b[]fXUUeicceiUb[eccgVY`Ub[*

%!!"

(7)

?Yb[YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f]fXnd`Y_caY`_UUegYcbgacYgYb(YYbd`Y_X]Y]bfd]eYYeg(X]YYYbdcX]haV]YXgicceiYeb]Yhj]b[*

?Yb[YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f\YYZgbUXb^__Y`]^_YYbaUUgfW\UddY`]^_YgUU_*

>Yfg]W\g]b[j]`YYb[YaYYbfW\Udf\h]feYU`]fYeYbYbYkd`c]gYeYbicceXY[YaYYbfW\UdiUb;fgYb*BYg]fiUbXYVhe[Yef(XY fg]W\g]b[VY\YYegXYmYiccem]Yb]b[bUaYbfXYVhe[YefYb[YVeh]_Yef*

>UUeV]^i]bXgm]^XYic`[YbXYmU_YbVY`Ub[e]^_6

s BYg[YaYYbfW\Udf\h]fjceXgYYbcbgacYg]b[fd`UUgficceU``YVhe[Yef(XUgVYgY_YbgXUg\Yg[YVeh]_`UU[XeYadY`][

acYgm]^b*

s BYgV]YXgYYbg\h]fUUbiYeYb][]b[YbYb[ecYdYb6XYfg]W\g]b[mce[gYeicceXUgm]^[cYX[YVb^]__hbbYbaU_YbiUb

\Yg[YVchj*

s BYgj]`YYb\h]f_UaYem]^b6\YgacYg;fgYbUeYbYYbiYegechjXYca[Yi]b[V]YXYb(jUUeaYbfYbgYeYW\g_hbbYbicce YYb_cd^Y_cZZ]Y(YYbcbgacYg]b[cZ[YjccbcaYiYbgYm]ggYb*

s BYgj]`Vhe[Yef(iYeYb][]b[Yb(ie]^j]``][YefYbdYefcbYY`i]bXYb(V]bXYbYbiYeV]bXYb*>cceXYj]^mYiUbVY\YYe(XY ]be]W\g]b[iUb\Yg[YVchjYbXYce[Ub]fUg]Yfg]ah`YYegXYfg]W\g]b[WcbgUWgYbghffYbaYbfYbYb[ecYdYb*

s BYg]fah`g]ZhbWg]cbYY`6\YgXcY`caiY`Yb[YVb^]_gY`UgYbaU_YbiUbXYmYiccem]Yb]b[\chXgcc_]bXUgYefdeU_Y acYgm]^biUbah`g]ZhbWg]cbU`]gY]g*>UgVYgY_YbgXUgYefcafWcbWYff]YfacYgYbjceXYb[YXUUbYbXUgYe fUaYb[YjYe_gacYgjceXYb*

s BYg]fjY`]fjUUeY][YbXcaiUbXYfg]W\g]b[(aUUem]^VYfW\chjgXYiccem]Yb]b[U`fiUbYbiqqeXYVhe[Yef*>Ug_cag gcgh]g]b[]bXYVYbUXYe]b[iUbaYbfYbYb[ecYdYb*

s >Yfg]W\g]b[_UbXYmYiccem]Yb]b[b]Yg]bfgUbX\chXYb(U`fXY[YaYYbfW\Udm]W\Yeb]YgaYXYiYeUbgjcceXY`]^_icce icY`g*>YmYiYeUbgjcceXY`]^_\Y]XacYggcgh]g]b[_caYb]bXYiceaiUb\h`d(fUaYbjeYe_]b[(iYeUbgjecceX[YVeh]_Yb UbXYeYV]^XeU[Yb]beh]aYeYm]b*

<* ;Ubih``YbXY _UXYef U`f eUbXiccejUUeXYb icce XY fWYbUe]c#f

Ia XY gcYgf]b[faUge]k gcg m]^b eYW\g gY `UgYb _caYb ]f Ye icce [Y_cmYb ca YYb UUbgU`

eUbXiccejUUeXY`]^_Y cbXYeXY`Yb aYY gY [YiYb U`iceYbf XY iYefW\]``YbXY fWYbUe]c#f icce XY VY]XY

`cWUg]Yf jceXYb cd[YfgY`X* Id XYmY j]^mY jceXYb Ye _UXYef [YfgY`X UUb XY iYefW\]``YbXY fWYbUe]c#f(

jceX \Yg WeYoeYb iUb `hW\g_UfgY`Yb icce_caYb Yb jceXg UUb XY icce_Ubg bU[YXUW\g ciYe jY`_

#fdYY`iY`X# iUb gcYdUff]b[ ]f jUUe]b X]iYefY fWYbUe]c#f \UU`VUUe mchXYb _hbbYb m]^b* >UUeV]^ jceXg jY` XY cdYb]b[ [Y`UgYb icce YYb iYeeh]a]b[ Yb+cZ iYe`U[]b[ U`f XY iYefW\]``YbXY fWYbUe]c#f XY aYYejUUeXY Yb ac[Y`]^_\YXYb _hbbYb UUbgcbYb*

>YmY UUbih``YbXY _UXYef jceXYb ]b \Yg cbXYefgUUbXY bUXYe gcY[Y`]W\g*

<C* FYb]b[Yb

>Y `Yb]b[ ghffYb Lg]W\g]b[ AYaYYbfW\Udf\h]f ;fgYb Yb XY [YaYYbgY ;fgYb VYXeUU[g acaYbgYY`

WU* w 4,*,,,()* >Y `Yb]b[fciYeYYb_cafg `][g icce h gYe ]bmU[Y* BYg iccefgY` ]f ca U`f _UXYe cd gY bYaYb XUg XYmY `Yb]b[ mU` jceXYb UZ[Y`cfg cd \Yg acaYbg iUb iYeieYYaX]b[ iUb XY E`YdY` * OYeXYe ]f Ye YYb `Yb]b[ ghffYb OYeYb][]b[ Dcb[ HYXYe`UbX $ODH% Yb Lg]W\g]b[ <Y\YYe XY <Y]UUeX*

BYg iYefW\]` $w -/*2-1()% ]b XY eYbgY _cag h]gY]bXY`]^_ ^UUe`]^_f( i]U [YaYYbgY`]^_Y fhVf]X]Ye]b[ UUb ODH ]b \Yg ^UUe`]^_fY gY_ceg( icce eY_Yb]b[ iUb XY [YaYYbgY* BYg iccefgY` ]f ca U`f _UXYe cd gY bYaYb XUg XYmY `Yb]b[ YiYbYYbf ]b YYb _YYe jceXg UZ[Y`cfg V]^ \Yg geUbfdceg + iYeieYYaX]b[ iUb XY `cWUg]Y #XY <Y]UUeX#*

<.* PUUeXYb]bVeYb[ ie]^_caYbXY `cWUg]Yf

>Y [YaYYbgY mU` ZUW]`]gYeYbX cbXYefgYhbYb ]b XY ZhbWg]YiYeUbXYe]b[ iUb XY ie]^_caYbXY `cWUg]Yf* Cb

\Yg iYe`YXYb ]f UZ[Yfdec_Yb XUg XY jUUeXYiYeaYYeXYe]b[ iUb XY ie]^_caYbXY `cWUg]Yf* <Y]UUeX Yb+cZ E`YdY`( ]b jceXg ]b[YVeUW\g icce XY eYU`]fUg]Y $iYeVchj]b[f_cfgYb% iUb \Yg $iYe%b]Yhj$X%

[YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f* KYWYbg \YYZg XY Lg]W\g]b[ <Y\YYeXY <Y]UUeX gY _YbbYb [Y[YiYb XUg \UUe

&!!"

(8)

m]Ybfj]^mY ]f [Yj]^m][X Yb XY YiYbghY`Y ciYejUUeXY b]Yg aYYe jYbfg ]b gY VeYb[Yb* BYg iccefgY` ]f ca XY ]bVeYb[jUUeXYcbXYemcY_ iUb XY _`YdY` gY \Ye]^_Yb Yb U`f _UXYe cd gY bYaYb icce XY

`cWUg]Y_YhmY*

</* ?kd`c]gUg]YV]^XeU[Y

>Y [YaYYbgY [YYZg UUb iYefW\]``YbXY $dcgYbg]o`Y% [YVeh]_Yef iUb \Yg $iYe%b]Yhj$X%

[YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f fhVf]X]Y* Ia gY icce_caYb XUg Ye YYb fgehWgheY`Y `UfgYbiYemjUe]b[ mU`

d`UUgfi]bXYb ]f \Yg iccefgY` ca XY cdgY`fca iUb XY \h]X][Y fhVf]X]YVYXeU[Yb icce XY $dcgYbg]o`Y%

[YVeh]_Yef7 LI=C;;F M?;G ;LM?H $]bW`* Ib]f% Yb <]V`]cg\YY_( gY \UbgYeYb U`f aUk]aha* >hf \Yg

$iYe%b]Yhj$X%Y [YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f aU[ ]b VY[]bfY` b]Yg `Y]XYb gcg YYb fgehWgheY`Y `UfgYbiYemjUe]b[

]b XY VY[ecg]b[*

OYeXYe m]Yb jY YYb _Ubf ca XY ZhbWg]Yf iUb XY V]V`]cg\YY_ Yb LI=C;;F M?;G ;LM?H gY

WcaV]bYeYb aYg \Yg $iYe%b]Yhj$X% [YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f gcg YYb [YaYYbfW\UddY`]^_Y #\h]f_UaYe iUb

;fgYb#*

2KDNKQVJGGM

>UUeV]^ ]f gYiYbf \Yg iccefgY` ca XY i]f]Y iUb XY V]V`]cg\YY_( \Yg $iYe%b]Yhj$X%Y [YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f Yb LI=C;;F M?;G ;LM?H $]bW`* Ib]f% YZZ]W]obg Yb YZZYWg]YZ cd Y`_UUe UZgYfgYaaYb ]b \h]fiYfg]b[fVY\cYZgY( Ykd`c]gUg]Yicea Yb fhVf]X]YiccejUUeXYb* ?iYbghY`Y j]^m][]b[Yb ]b XY fhVf]X]YeY`Ug]Y U`f [Yic`[ iUb XY dUeg]W]dUg]Y iUb XY V]V`]cg\YY_ ]b \Yg b]YhjY [YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f mh``Yb g]^X][ aYg XY V]V`]cg\YY_ jceXYb VYfdec_Yb Yb iUfg[Y`Y[X* Occe .,-5 ]f YYb VhX[YgfhVf]X]Y iUb w ./4*324() cd[YbcaYb ]b XY VY[ecg]b[ $fhVf]X]Ydec[eUaaU .,-5%* >]g ]f

\Yg fhVf]X]YVYXeU[ iUb .,-4 ' .(1! ]bXYkYe]b[*%

?=3811: @51; 1?@5< #KPENWUKGH =PKU$

N]g XY jYe_V]^YYb_cafgYb _cag bUUe iceYb XUg Ye YYb bUXeh__Y`]^_Y iYeV]bX]b[ ]f ghffYb \Yg [YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f Yb LI=C;;F M?;G ;LM?H $]bW`hf]YZ Ib]f%* BYg iccefgY` ]f ca XY \h]X][Y

\hhede]^mYb ^UUe`]^_f gY ]bXYkYeYb aYg XY [YaYYbgY`]^_Y $VY[ecg]b[% ]bXYk( iUbUZ .,-5( Yb XYmY U`f _UXYe gY \UbgYeYb icce \Yg $iYe%b]Yhj$X%Y [YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f*

<0* KYfYeiYe]b[ VY[ecg]b[ .,-5

Cb XY VY[ecg]b[ iUb .,-5 m]^b acaYbgYY` VYXeU[Yb [YeYfYeiYYeX U`f V]^XeU[Y UUb \Yg

$iYe%b]Yhj$X%Y [YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f* >]g ]f YYb Ykd`c]gUg]YV]^XeU[Y iUb w -4*201()&& Yb YYb YYbaU`][Y ]biYfgYe]b[ iUb w 512*.,,() BYg iccefgY` ]f ca XYmY VYXeU[Yb U`f _UXYe gY \UbgYeYb icce XY fWYbUe]c#f X]Y jceXYb cd[YfgY`X Yb U`f UUbih``]b[ cd XY ^UUe`]^_fY V]^XeU[Y ]b cbXYeXYY` </*

QcU`f ]b \Yg iceYbfgUUbXY U` UUb[Y[YiYb jceXg XY cdYb]b[ [Y`UgYb icce YYb iYeeh]a]b[ Yb+cZ iYe`U[]b[ U`f XY iYefW\]``YbXY fWYbUe]c#f XY aYYejUUeXY Yb ac[Y`]^_\YXYb _hbbYb UUbgcbYb*

OYeXYe acYgYb jY eY_Yb]b[ \chXYb aYg \Yg MeYUfhelfgUghhg $.,-0%*

&&%BYgfgehWgheY`YVYXeU[]bXYYkd`c]gUg]Y]fw-4*201(8Yb]fiUbh]g\YgiYe`YXYbU`fic`[gcd[YVchjX6

>Y\h]X][YfgehWgheY`YV]^XeU[YiUbXY[YaYYbgY]fw04*2-1(8YbVYfgUUgh]g.dcfgYb6

s w /1*,,,(8V]^XeU[YUUbXY<Y]UUeX$fgehWgheY`YgY[YacYg_ca]b[]bXY\hhe`UfgYb%*

s w -/*2-1(8V]^XeU[YUUb^cb[HYXYe]UbX$fgehWgheY`YV]^XeU[YgYeUZ`cff]b[iUbXY]Yb]b[X]YXcceDcb[

HYXYe`UbX]fiYefgeY_gg*V*i*iYeVchj]b[iUbXY<Y]UUeX%*

Cb\YgiYe]YXYb]ficce[YfgY`X caX]gVYXeU[VYfW\]_VUUegYfgY``Yba]bhfXYYkgeU_cfgYbicceXY[YaYYbgYXcce

\hheiYe\c[]b[fgYhbdhbgAh]XcYbcbXYe\chXf_cfgYbiccegh]bYbdUe_YYed]UUgfYb*

>YYkgeU_cfgYbVYgeYZZYb6

s w -3*31.(86YkgeU\hhe_cfgYbX]YLcW]UU`MYUa;fgYb]b\YgchXYd`Ubmch[UUbVYgU`Yb]b\Ygb]YhjY [YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f$YejceXYbaYYea.[Y\hheXgY[YbYYb\c[YeYde]^f(]bW`hf]YZfW\ccbaUU__cfgYb%7 TTTTTTTTT v w .*3-4(8icce\YgcbXYe\chXUUbXYdUe_YYed]UUgfYb*TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT

'!!"

(9)

w 5*1,,(8icce\YgcbXYe\chXUUb\YgXcceXY[YbbYYbgYciYegYbYaYbXYY`iUbXY_`ccfgYegh]b*

BYgVYXeU[XUgeYfgYYeg]fw-4*201(8*

<1* @hf]Y Lg]W\g]b[ <Y\YYe XY <Y]UUeX Yb Lg]W\g]b[ AYaYYbfW\Udf\h]f ;fgYb

>Y ]b]g]o`Y ]bgYbg]Y icce XY b]YhjY `cWUg]Y iUb \Yg $iYe%b]Yhj$X%Y [YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f ]f cbgfgUUb iUbh]g \Yg ZhfYeYb iUb XY Lg]W\g]b[ <Y\YYe >Y <Y]UUeX Yb Lg]W\g]b[ AYaYYbfW\Udf\h]f ;fgYb* BYg iccefgY` ]f XUg XYmY Zhf]Y acYg [YfW\]YXYb U`f eUbXiccejUUeXY gY \UbgYeYb V]^ XY `cWUg]Y_YhmY Yb XUg X]g acYg V`]^_Yb h]g YYb UZfW\e]Zg iUb XY ciYeYYb_cafg ghffYb VY]XY dUeg]^Yb Yb YYb UZfW\e]Zg iUb XY cde]W\g]b[fU_gY*

<2* ?kd`c]gUg]YacXY``Yb

N]g XY \]fgce]fW\Y [Y[YiYbf Yb XY jYe_V]^YYb_cafgYb ]f Xh]XY`]^_ bUUe iceYb [Y_caYb XUg \Yg

$iYe%b]Yhj$X% [YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f YYb aUUgfW\UddY`]^_ Ykd`c]gUg]YacXY` Yb ]bih``]b[ acYg \YVVYb*

BYg iccefgY` ]f ca \Yg _UXYe aYY gY [YiYb XUg XY [YaYYbgY [YYb Ykd`c]gUg]Y mU` icYeYb Yb XUg YYb

$fgYe_% WcaaYeW]YY` + mU_Y`]^_ acXY` cc_ b]Yg iUb gcYdUff]b[ ]f*

<3* J`UbfW\UXY Yb VYfgYaa]b[fd`Ub

BYg iccefgY` ]f ca iUbh]g \Yg [Y`]^_\Y]Xfde]bW]dY( bYg U`f ]b IaaY` Yb BYhfXYb( YYb Z]bUbW]o`Y V]^XeU[Y gY `YiYeYb UUb XY VYfgYaa]b[fd`UbdecWYXheY Yb XY d`UbfW\UXY( U``YYb V]^ XY

icce_Yhef`cWUg]Y* >Y _cfgYb mh``Yb ]b XY gcgU`Y Z]bUbW]o`Y cdfgY``]b[ jceXYb aYY[YbcaYb*

r* CbgYbg]YciYeYYb_cafg

Cb XY V]^`U[Y geYZg h XY ghffYb XY [YaYYbgY Yb XY Lg]W\g]b[ AYaYYbfW\Udf\h]f ;fgYb gY f`h]gYb ]bgYbg]YciYeYYb_cafg* Eceg\Y]Xf\U`iY iYej]^mYb j]^ h bUUe XY ]b\chX iUb XYmY ciYeYYb_cafg*

?Yb VY`Ub[e]^_ cbXYeXYY` iUb XY ciYeYYb_cafg ]f XUg Ye YYb Zhf]Y gcg fgUbX acYg _caYb ghffYb Lg]W\g]b[ <Y\YYe XY <Y]UUeX Yb Lg]W\g]b[ AYaYYbfW\Udf\h]f ;fgYb* >]g ]f cc_ U`f eUbXiccejUUeXY cd[YbcaYb ]b cbXYeXYY` < iUb X]g iccefgY`* >]g ]f iUfg[Y`Y[X ]b XY V]^ XY ]bgYbg]YciYeYYb_cafg [YicY[XY ]bgYbg]YiYe_`Ue]b[*

HUUfg XY ]bgYbg]YciYeYYb_cafg mU` XY _ccdciYeYYb_cafg iUb XY `cWUg]Y JUgYef_`ccfgYe ac[Y`]^_

cc_ UUbih``YbXY eUbXiccejUUeXYb \YVVYb X]Y U`f _UXYe acYgYb jceXYb aYY[YbcaYb ]b XY iYefW\]``YbXY fWYbUe]c#f*

ACU XKNNGP XG DGSGKMGP

>Y gcYgf]b[faUge]k ]f VYXcY`X ca cV^YWg]YiY dUeUaYgYef iUfg gY fgY``Yb jUUeUUb XY h]gjYe_]b[ iUb XY X]iYefY fWYbUe]c#f mc eUg]cbYY` ac[Y`]^_ [YgcYgfg _hbbYb jceXYb V]^ XY `cWUg]Y_YhmY*

IaXUg XY eUbXiccejUUeXYb Yb XY ]b\chX iUb XY ]bgYbg]YciYeYYb_cafg VY`Ub[e]^_ m]^b V]^ XY iYeXYeY iYe`ccd iUb \Yg decWYf ]f \Yg VY`Ub[e]^_ XUg hj eUUX \]YeciYe jYbfYb Yb VYXYb_]b[Yb _YbVUUe aUU_g mcXUg \]YeaYY V]^ XY iYeXYeY iYe`ccd iUb \Yg decWYf eY_Yb]b[ _Ub jceXYb [Y\chXYb*

(!!"

(10)

ACU ICCP XG FCCSWQQS FQGP

JUeeU`Y` UUb XY VYf`h]gicea]b[ ecbX X]g iccefgY` ]f YYb VY[]b [YaUU_g aYg XY h]gicYe]b[ iUb fgUd CO g+a OC iUb \Yg d`Ub iUb UUbdU_* Cb X]g _UXYe mh``Yb( iUbh]g XY cd[Y\UU`XY ]bZceaUg]Y ]b XY jYe_V]^YYb_cafgYb( icceXY VY]XY `cWUg]Yf $XY E`YdY` Yb \Yg JUgYef_`ccfgYe% a]b]aUU` Xe]Y

fWYbUe]c#f jceXYb cd[YfgY`X* >]g m]^b YYb bccXmU_Y`]^_ fWYbUe]c( YYb jYbfY`]^_ fWYbUe]c Yb cdg]cbYY`

fWYbUe]c* >]g eYfh`gYYeg Xhf ]b a]b]aUU` 2 fWYbUe]c#f* BYg ]f b]Yg h]g[Yf`cgYb XUg V]^ XY iYeXYeY h]gjYe_]b[ Yb icea[Yi]b[ bc[ U`gYebUg]YiY fWYbUe]c#f cbgfgUUb X]Y aYY[YbcaYb _hbbYb jceXYb*

Ia hj eUUX U`iUfg ]bm]W\g gY [YiYb ]b XY jYe_]b[ iUb gcYgf]b[faUge]k ]f XY gcYgf]b[faUge]k h]g[YjYe_g gcg WcbWYdg)VYcceXY`]b[faUge]k* >YmY VYcceXY`]b[faUge]k ]f aYg YYb gcY`]W\g]b[ U`f V]^`U[Y V]^ X]g iccefgY` [YicY[X*

BYg decWYf mU` h]gY]bXY`]^_ `Y]XYb gcg YYb iccefgY` UUb XY [YaYYbgYeUUX jUUe]b cd VUf]f iUb XY gcYgf]b[f) Yb VYcceXY`]b[faUge]k YYb `cWUg]Y_YhmY _Ub jceXYb [YaUU_g*

Oc`[Ybf XY \h]X][Y d`Ubb]b[ Yb VY\chXYbf cbiccem]YbY cafgUbX][\YXYb _Ub YYb XYe[Y`]^_Y iccefgY` ]b XY eUUXfiYe[UXYe]b[ iUb -2 Ude]` .,-5 jceXYb icce[Y`Y[X*

HUXUg Xcce XY [YaYYbgYeUUX YYb `cWUg]Y_YhmY ]f [YaUU_g mh``Yb XY cbXYe`][[YbXY XcWhaYbgYb UUb XY b]YhjY $[YZhfYYeXY% fg]W\g]b[ jceXYb ciYe[YXeU[Yb* >YmY _hbbYb XUb Xcce XYmY fg]W\g]b[ U`f h]g[Ub[fdhbg jceXYb [Y\UbgYYeX icce XY iYeXYeY h]gjYe_]b[* >Y iYeXYeY h]gjYe_]b[ iUb \Yg dec^YWg mU` Xhf d`UUgf i]bXYb cbXYe eY[]Y iUb \Yg VYfghhe iUb XY b]YhjY fg]W\g]b[*

9QIGNKLMG CNUGSPCUKGWGP

?e m]^b [YYb U`gYebUg]YiYb icce XY iUfg gY fgY``Yb gcYgf]b[faUge]k icce \UbXYb* BYg cdfgY``Yb iUb U`gYebUg]YiYb mU` gcg cb[YjYbfgY iYegeU[]b[ iUb \Yg decWYf `Y]XYb*

<KTKEQ T

<]^ XY iYeXYeY h]gjYe_]b[ m]^b bc[ YYb UUbgU` e]f]Wc#f gY iccem]Yb X]Y iUb ac[Y`]^_ iUb ]bi`cYX m]^b cd \Yg iYeXYeY iYe`ccd iUb \Yg decWYf* >Y ic`[YbXY e]f]Wc#f _hbbYb jceXYb VYbcYaX*

;Ub_ccd dUgYef_`ccfgYe

GcaYbgYY` m]^b XY Zhf]YdUeg]^Yb Lg]W\g]b[ AYaYYbfW\Udf\h]f ;fgYb Yb Lg]W\g]b[ <Y\YYe XY <Y]UUeX Xeh_ XcYbXY aYg XY UUb_ccd iUb \Yg dUgYef_`ccfgYe* ;UbXUW\gfdhbg ]f XY UZfdeU_Yb X]Y \]YeV]^

Xcce XY [YbcYaXY fg]W\g]b[Yb jceXYb [YaUU_g* >Y UUb_ccd) Yb Zhf]YWcbX]g]Yf m]^b iUb VY`Ub[

icce XY \UU`VUUe\Y]X Yb mh``Yb XUUeca geUbfdUeUbg aYY[YbcaYb jceXYb U`f _UXYe+

eUbXiccejUUeXYb ]b XY `cWUg]Y_YhmY* GcaYbgYY` m]^b XY [YfdeY__Yb bc[ [UUbXY Yb ]f Ye bc[ [YYb XYZ]b]g]YZ U__cceX* >Y fg]W\g]b[fVYfgheYb [YiYb jY` UUb XUg Ye aYg dUeg]^Yb ciYe

XcceiYe_ccd jceXg [Yfdec_Yb ]bX]Yb XY `cWUg]Y_YhmY b]Yg cd \Yg dUgYef_`ccfgYe mU` iU``Yb* OYeXYe [YiYb mY UUb XUg XYmY dUeg]^Yb jY` VY`Ub[ \YW\gYb UUb YYb XYU` jUUe XY ie]^_caYbXY `cWUg]Yf cbXYeXYY` iUb h]g aU_Yb* >Y fg]W\g]b[fVYfgheYb iYejUW\gYb Y]bX bciYaVYe aYYe WcbWeYgY Xh]XY`]^_\Y]X gY _hbbYb iYefW\UZZYb ciYe XY UUb_ccdWcbX]g]Yf X]Y m]^b [YaUU_g Yb \cdY`]^_ YYb _ccdciYeYYb_cafg gY _hbbYb ciYe`Y[[Yb*

Lg]W\g]b[ AYaYYbfW\Udf\h]f ;fgYb " Lg]W\g]b[ <Y\YYe XY <Y]UUeX

QcU`f UUb[Y[YiYb m]^b VY]XY fg]W\g]b[Yb Xeh_ XcYbXY ca XY UUb_ccd iUb \Yg

JUgYef_`ccfgYe gY WcbWeYg]fYeYb ca mc YYb `cWUg]Y_YhmY gY _hbbYb $V`]^iYb% ZUW]`]gYeYb*

Occe XY fghhe[ecYd ]f \Yg YYb UUbXUW\gdhbg [Y`Y[Yb ]b XY g]^XfVYfgYX]b[ X]Y Xeh_g cd XY ]bmYg iUb XY VYfghhef`YXYb Yb XY Xeh_ X]Y iUbh]g XY fUaYb`Yi]b[( iYeYb][]b[Yb Yb XY dc`]g]Y_ fdYY`g cd X]g Yacg]cbY`Y VY`UXYb Xcff]Ye* <]^ XY fgUeg iUb XY VYfghhefcdXeUW\g

\YVVYb XY \h]X][Y VYfghhef`YXYb iUb VY]XY fg]W\g]b[Yb gY _YbbYb [Y[YiYb XUg Ye ]b XY UUb`ccd bUUe XY `cWUg]Y_YhmY Yb XY ]b[YmYggY Zhf]Y cc_ bU[YXUW\g mU` jceXYb ciYe XY gcY_cafg][Y VYfghheficea Yb XY VYbcX][XY YkdYeg]fY iUb XY VYfghhef`YXYb X]Y

acYgYb dUffYb V]^ XY b]YhjY Ykd`c]gUg]Yicea* >Y h]g_cafgYb \]YeiUb m]^b YW\gYe bc[ b]Yg VY_YbX Yb Xhf bc[ cbmY_Ye*

)!!"

(11)

>eUU[i`U_

M]^XYbf \Yg [Y\Y`Y decWYf ]f XY m]Ybfj]^mY iUb XY fUaYb`Yi]b[ cd \Yg decWYf XUg jceXg Xcce`cdYb Yb \Yg dec^YWg VY`Ub[e]^_* >UUeca ]f UUbXUW\g icce geUbfdUeUbg]Y Yb cbUZ\Ub_Y`]^_\Y]X iUb [eccg VY`Ub[ ca \Yg VYbcX][XY XeUU[i`U_ gY VY\chXYb Yb jUUe bcX][ gY iYe_e]^[Yb*

Oe]^_caYbXY `cWUg]Yf

>Y iYe_ccdVUUe\Y]X iUb XY ie]^_caYbXY `cWUg]Yf ]f iUb VY`Ub[ icce XY \UU`VUUe\Y]X Yb XY VYbcX][XY Z]bUbW]o`Y a]XXY`Yb icce XY Lg]W\g]b[ AYaYYbfW\Udf\h]f ;fgYb cZ XY b]YhjY

fg]W\g]b[* Occe XY _cdYbXY dUeg]^Yb m]^b XY d`Ubc`c[]fW\Y mY_Ye\Y]X iUb XY ie]^_caYbXY `cWUg]Yf iUb VY`Ub[ ca XY $XYZ]b]g]YiY% jUUeXY gY _hbbYb VYdU`Yb* ;UbXUW\gfdhbg icce XY

[YaYYbgY ]f XY iYeVcbXYb\Y]X ghffYb XY cdVeYb[fg iUb XY ie]^_caYbXY `cWUg]Yf Yb XY

VYbcX][XY Z]bUbW]o`Y a]XXY`Yb gYb VY\cYiY iUb \Yg $iYe%b]Yhj$X%Y [YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f* CbX]Yb XY Lg]W\g]b[ [YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f ;fgYb icce XYmY Z]bUbW]o`Y a]XXY`Yb YYb `Yb]b[ iUb XY [YaYYbgY

;fgYb bcX][ \YYZg mU` XYmY acYgYb dUffYb V]bbYb \Yg MeYUfhelfgUghhg $.,-0% Yb ]b m]^b U`[YaYYb\Y]X e]f]Wc#f aYg m]W\ aYYVeYb[Yb*

<Yfghhe`]^_Y cdXeUW\g V]V`]cg\YY_

GcaYbgYY` ]f XY V]V`]cg\YY_ fgYe_ VYgec__Yb Yb UUb[Yf`cgYb V]^ XY cbgj]__Y`]b[Yb iUb

\Yg $iYe%b]Yhj$X%Y [YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f* >]g ]f VY[e]^dY`]^_ U`f [Y_Y_Yb jceXg bUUe XY V]^XeU[Y h]g XY jYe_V]^YYb_cafgYb ]b eY`Ug]Y gcg XY i]f]Y X]Y XY V]V`]cg\YY_ acaYbgYY` UUb

\Yg h]gjYe_Yb ]f* B]Ye]b m]^b fgYe_Y flbYe[]ob ]b mcjY` ZhbWg]Y U`f XcY`fgY``]b[Yb Yb f`h]gYb [cYX UUb V]^ XY VYfghhe`]^_Y cdXeUW\g Yb cd[UiY X]Y ]f UZ[Yfdec_Yb*

;UbXUW\gdhbg ]f XY UUbf`h]g]b[ gY \chXYb aYg \Yg decWYf icce \Yg $iYe%b]Yhj$X%

[YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f Yb jUU_mUUa gY V`]^iYb cd \Yg [YmUaYb`]^_ VY`Ub[*

OYeXYe iceag \Yg $[ecgY% iYefW\]` ]b fhVf]X]YV]^XeU[Yb UUb XY V]V`]cg\YY_ Yb Lg]W\g]b[

AYaYYbfW\Udf\h]f ;fgYb YYb UUbXUW\gfdhbg*

Lg]^[YbXY Vchj_cfgYb Yb eYbgY cbgj]__Y`]b[Yb

GcaYbgYY` m]^b Ye ]b XY aUe_g iYY` f][bU`Yb iUbh]g X]iYefY dec^YWgYb XUg XY Vchj_cfgYb Ye[ fg]^[Yb Xcce aUgYe]UU`) Yb dYefcbYY`ffW\UUefgY* >]g _Ub jY` YYb XYeaUgY \cc[ e]f]Wc m]^b XUg X]g V]^ \Yg XcceeY_YbYb iUb XY ]biYfgYe]b[Yb YYb [ecgY ec` _Ub [UUb

fdY`Yb ]b XY \UU`VUUe\Y]X iUb VY]XY `cWUg]Yf*

Id X]g acaYbg jceXg fgeUgY[]fW\ cbXYemcW\g cZ Ye ac[Y`]^_\YXYb m]^b ca

YkgYeb _Ud]gUU` UUb gY geY__Yb* >Y UUb^U[Ye iUb X]g cbXYemcY_ ]f XY $\h]X][Y% `U[Y eYbgYfgUbX( XY VY[ecg]b[fcd[UiY Yb XY cbmY_YeY dec[bcfY icce XY gcY_cafg][Y eYbgY cbgj]__Y`]b[* B]YeXcce _Ub ac[Y`]^_ \Yg e]f]Wc iUb [ecgY _cfgYbfg]^[]b[Yb jceXYb ]b[YdYe_g*

BceYWU ;fgYb

BceYWU ;fgYb \YYZg UUb[Y[YiYb VYgec__Yb gY j]``Yb V`]^iYb V]^ XY cbgj]__Y`]b[Yb* Cb XY iYeic`[fgUddYb mU` \Yg dec^YWggYUa mY decUWg]YZ VYbUXYeYb ca ]b \Yg decWYf cc_ YYb ]b\chXY`]^_ YYb V]^XeU[Y gY `YiYeYb* B]YeV]^ _hbbYb U`f UUbXUW\gfdhbg XY ZhbWg]Y iUb XY

\ceYWU Yb XY cdYb]b[fg]^XYb ]b \Yg $iYe%b]Yhj$X%Y [YaYYbfW\Udf\h]f jceXYb [YbcYaX*

0QOOVPKECUKG

Cb \Yg iYeXYeY iYe`ccd iUb \Yg decWYf mU` bc[ YYb jYe_V]^YYb_cafg jceXYb [Y\chXYb jUUeicce XY ]bjcbYef( XY iYeYb][]b[Yb Yb UbXYeY VY`Ub[\YVVYbXYb jceXYb h]g[YbcX][X* B]Ye]b mh``Yb XY YYefgY

$fW\YgfYb iUb XY% ]bdUff]b[ffWYbUe]c#f jceXYb [YdeYfYbgYYeX*

>UUebUUfg mU` icce XY cajcbYbXYb iUb XY VY]XY `cWUg]Yf bc[ YYb ]bZceaUg]YUicbX jceXYb [Y\chXYb*

! #!"

(12)

ACU OCI JGU MQTUGP

<]^ XY iUfgfgY``]b[ iUb XY VYfghhefcdXeUW\g jYeX Xcce XY [YaYYbgYeUUX YYb jYe__eYX]Yg VYfW\]_VUUe [YfgY`X* ?Yb ciYem]W\g iUb X]g VhX[Yg ]f U`f V]^`U[Y 4 V]^ X]g iccefgY` [YicY[X*

BYg mU` Xh]XY`]^_ m]^b XUg Ye cd X]g acaYbg bc[ [YYb ]bm]W\g _Ub jceXYb [Y[YiYb ]b XY _cfgYb X]Y aYg \Yg dec^YWg m]^b [YacY]X* N]gYe`]^_ V]^ XY `cWUg]Y_YhmY _Ub \]Ye]b ]bm]W\g jceXYb [Y[YiYb* QcU`f ]b \Yg iceYbfgUUbXY U` ]f UUb[Y[YiYb jceXg i]U \Yg \UbgYeYb iUb XY eUbXiccejUUeXYb U`f

UUb[Y[YiYb ]b cbXYeXYY` < ]b XYmY ZUfY iUb decWYf XY _cfgYb VY\YYefVUUe gY \chXYb*

.FWKGT EQOOKTTKG /VSIGST

>Y Wcaa]ff]Y <he[Yef \YYZg ]b XY iYe[UXYe]b[ iUb -5 bciYaVYe jYbfYb Yb VYXYb_]b[Yb h]g[Yfdec_Yb Yb [YUXi]fYYeX ca VYf`]fdhbg . gcY gY icY[Yb UUb \Yg WcbWYdg)eUUXfVYf`h]g*

BYg WcbWYdg)eUUXfVYf`h]g ]f ciYeYYb_cafg][ X]g UXi]Yf UUb[YdUfg*

/KLNCIG P!%UGS KPYCIG KPEN$ .=>#PS!

-* J`Ub iUb UUbdU_ $;LM+.,-421.-1%

.* J`Ub iUb UUbdU_( decWYffW\Ygf $;LM+.,-4,21.-2%

/* N]g_cafgYb jYe_V]^YYb_cafgYb $m]Y `]b_ cd[YbcaYb ]b \Yg iccefgY`%

0* IiYeYYb_cafg [Y`X`Yb]b[ aYg Lg]W\g]b[ AYaYYbfW\Udf\h]f ;fgYb $;LM+.,-4,21.,,%

1* McYgf]b[faUge]k $;LM+.,-4,21.-.%

2* =cbWYdg h]g[YjYe_gY VYcceXY`]b[faUge]k $;LM+.,-4,21.,5%

3* McY`]W\g]b[ cd WcbWYdg h]g[YjYe_gY VYcceXY`]b[faUge]k $;LM+.,-4,21,30%

4* IiYem]W\g dec^YWgVhX[Yg $;LM+.,-4,21.-0%

5* CbgYbg]YciYeYYb_cafg $;LM+.,-4,21.-/%

X*fW\e]]bYaU_Yef:UfgYb*b`

!!"!"

Referenties

GERELATEERDE DOCUMENTEN

Het Steunpunt kan op loopafstand van de gemeente in het nieuwe gemeentehuis worden gehuisvest in een gebouw waar ook andere gelieerde professionele en

Voorgesteld wordt het onderhoud voor rekening te nemen, met als onderzoeksopdracht aan de initiatiefnemers dat in beeld wordt gebracht welk deel van het onderhoud door

In principe bereid te zijn een financiële bijdrage aan een nieuw gemeenschapshuis Asten te leveren, welke in geval van locatie Heilig Hart Klooster in beginsel bestaat uit een

Indien u besluit om de locatie Heilig Hart Klooster niet aan te wijzen als voorkeurslocatie of indien u niet bereid bent tot het leveren van een financiële bijdrage komt er een

Dit onderzoek is nodig omdat bijzondere natuurwaarden (die denkbaar zijn in dit gebouw en bijbehorende tuin) in de vervolgfase tot extra kosten kunnen leiden.. Deze extra

in te stemmen met wijziging van de bestuursopdracht zoals vastgesteld door de raad op 13 maart 2018 en hiertoe de gewijzigde bestuursopdracht, zoals die als bijlage bij dit besluit

Hoe realiseren we, onder regie van de gemeente en in samenwerking met de stichtingsbesturen, verenigingen en andere belanghebbenden, één nieuw/vernieuwd centraal

Er is nog geen keuze voor een locatie gemaakt; u heeft het college opdracht gegeven de regie over het project over te nemen, een nieuwe projectorganisatie in te stellen en