Virtual water trade in the SADC region : a grid-based approach

A grid-based approach

! " # $

$

Virtual water trade in the SADC region A grid-based approach

#

$

"

%

&

' &

( ! )

* (!)*

+

* ,--. / &

0 &

! 122. !

(

(!)*

,, 2-3

.

1224',--5

(!)* 6

* # + ,--7

(!)* & 8 8

$ (!)* 69 &

11 -73

(!)* 6 ;

/ ! * # ( ! (!)* & /

* ! $ (!)*

,? .,3 7? 513 14 ,,3

(!)* ( ! 8

(!)*: ==, ^?@ @

1,7? ^?@ @ 0 (

1=5? ^?@ @ 9 (!)*

& 223 13

- ?23

(!)* " 1 ??3

( ! 8 /

153 '?-3 > (!)* ' < .23

9 113 (!)*

;& ( (

4-3 2.3

9 (!)*

; ( ! / 8 !

< ,=

0 ,=

! (!)*

6

(!)* &

9

(

(!)* 9

9

( &

(

&

PREFACE...VII 1 INTRODUCTION... 1

1 1 +; 6! ;% 900 B% / !/) +; $ % A!C 6! ;% %!); *0/*;B ,

1 , +; %;> 0/ 09 +;(0A +;%/!9% *!/);$;C0B ;/ *0 A/ D (!)* 5

1 ? %;(;!%*+ 0EF;* $; 4

1 7 %;(;!%*+ G A;( 0/( 4

1 5 0A C /; 09 +; %;B0% =

2 METHOD & DATA... 8

, 1 ; +0) .

, 1 1 6 1-

, 1 , ,1

, 1 ? 6 ,,

, , )! ! ,7

3 RESULTS...30

? 1 6! ;% 900 B% / %;C! ;) 0 B%0)A* 0/ ?1

? 1 1 6 ?1

? 1 , 6 7-

? 1 ? 6 7,

? , / ;%/! 0/!C $ % A!C 6! ;% 9C06( / +;(!)*%;> 0/ 7?

? ? 6! ;% 900 B% / ( %;C! ;) 0 /! 0/!C *0/(A B 0/ 72

? 7 6! ;% 900 B% / ( 09 B%0)A* 0/ / +; *0/ ;H 09 6! ;% !$! C!E C D 5-

? 5 B!* ( 09 6! ;% A(; !/) $ % A!C 6! ;% %!); 0/ 6! ;% %;(0A%*;( 55

? 5 1 (!)*: 55

? 5 , 5=

? 5 ? 6 4?

? 5 7 * 4?

? 4 *0 B!% (0/ 09 +; 6! ;% 900 B% / ( 09 + ( ( A)D 6 + +; ( A)D 09*+!B!> ! /# +0;I( %! ,--7 47 4 UNCERTAINTIES AND LIMITATIONS...68

7 1 A/*;% ! / ;( )A; 0 +; (*0B; 09 +; ( A)D 4.

7 , (;/( $ D 09 0);C 0A *0 ;( 0 /BA )! ! !/) !((A B 0/( 4.

7 ? A/*;% ! / ;( / +; /BA )! ! 42

7 7 A/*;% ! / ;( / !/) C ! 0/( 09 +; 0);C A(;) 0 *0 BA ; +; 6! ;% 900 B% / 09 *%0B( =- 5 CONCLUSIONS...72

5 1 +; 6! ;% 900 B% / ( %;C! ;) 0 B%0)A* 0/ =,

5 , / ;%/! 0/!C $ % A!C 6! ;% 9C06( %;C! ;) 0 %!); / *0 0) ;( =,

5 ? /! 0/!C 6! ;% 900 B% / ( %;C! ;) 0 *0/(A B 0/ =?

5 7 ;99;* ( 09 / ;%/! 0/!C $ % A!C 6! ;% 9C06( !/) +; 6! ;% 900 B% / ( %;C! ;) 0 B%0)A* 0/ !/)

*0/(A B 0/ 0/ 6! ;% (*!%* D =7

5 5 B%0$; ;/ / +; 6! ;% 900 B% / 09 *%0B( !/) *%0B B%0)A* ( =5

5 4 B%0$;) /( > + ( 90% 6! ;% !/!> ; ;/ / +;(!)* =5

/

) (

&

& *

' &

<

( ! )

* (!)* !

J K

( ! L +

! L D

! > ( ;& D

; (

! 0 ) ;&

B 0 ) 6 E L 9

6;

B ! I

9 B

D M

E I

; F ,-1-

12 3 1 1

6 ; ( !

&

6 ,--4 +

+ ,--, '

+ ,--? + # * ,--.

$

+ # * ,--.

69 (

+ # + ,--5< + # * ,--. ! + * ,--.

0

+ # + ,--, # ,--5 *

,--5 * # + ,--. !

* + # * ,--.

I ,--. / C 6 % > ,--= (

! ; ,--1

G

;

& * # + ,--7< ,--. + # + ,--5

* # + ,--? !

* ,--4 ( * #

0 ,--. ) * # + ,--= &

& 69

;

69

%

* # +

,--7 J

K

+ # * ,--." 1,='1,. '

/

& "

* #

+ ,--7

'

!

+ # * ,--. "

• <

• <

• &

E

+ # * ,--.

; ,--1 % ,--. 4-

=- ( &

9

& '( ( ( '

12 3 1 ?

$ +

& *

&

'

! ,--?

> <

& 1--- + # + ,--5< * # +

,--?< + # * ,--.

/ 143 & + # *

,--.

) * + + %, '(

) 69 * # 0 ,--." ,

69

"

1 ,

?

7

5 <

* # 0 ,--. B 5

&

* # 0 ,--.

& '

%

&

( # )N ,--. % ,--. ( )N ,--.

% ,--.

2-3

9

69 69 69

+ &

'

* # 0 ,--.

* # 0 ,--.

0 * # 0 ,--.

2-3

. 9

9

! 1222< + # + ,--5< + # *

,--. + *

,--=< ,--.

+ ,--5< > ,--=< 8 # + ,--= %

( ! ) * (!)*

C 6 % > ,--=

12 3 1 5

(!)* 1 (!)*

1,O ?-:; 55O 7-:; 4O / ??O (

15 & 2 ..? 717 ^, F ,--.

,55 EE* ,--. > )B (!)* 7?1 =. A(P

,--= * ! ,--. ! (!)*

* 1224

, * - . * / + ' ' ++ * '

( - + 0 1' . * 2- 0.3 4 * ' ( 5 +1 6 7 + 1

'' ( 5 ' ) 0 1' 5 8 +1 8 +1 1( 2 - . 93 +

+ * :; 2 93

(!)* &

122.< ! ,--?< ,--5< * ! ,--.< E ,--.

1 ! ! # + 122.

)

&

! C 6 % > ! ,--?

1 ( (!)* ;A%0( !

(!)* !

( ! % ) * (!%)* ( (!)*

F ,--7 J (!)* K +

(!)* ,--. ( (!)* (

(!)*

(!)*

$

&

(!)* % ,--.< * !

,--.< A/9B! 1222 0 ! ,--7<

122.< I # ( 1222

! ,--7

, * < ' * + ' ' - . * ==>? ==@ ?

? A ( * ' * 2 * 5 B3

! "#

L &

' &

(!)*

$ ! % ! !

"

) ' &

(!)*

Q

' "

• 6 ' & Q

• 6

(!)* (!)* Q

• + Q

• 6

(!)* Q

• + ' &

12 3 1 =

9 ? * ,

' & 69 69

* ?

(!)* (!)*

(!)*

!

* 7

* 5

9 4

, * A C '

(

+ # * ,--. * # + ,--7 7

(!)*

' &

+ # * ,--. * # + ,--7 L

' !

* #

+ ,--7 7 (!)*

&

! &

(!)*

* # + ,--7

* #

+ ,--7 7

&

+ # * ,--.

* # + ,--7 7

(!)* * # + ,--7

!

&

14 1 2

! "

"

#

$

%&'

(

%&'

) * (

%&'

( (-(

(-

#

(0 )!

) * $

#

!

"

(

$

, * D + '( ' ( ' ' * ' '

' 2 + . * E # $ 2 D A 3 ; + + ' + *

+ ' + ( '( ' (

1 + %,F( / %,*'F*' 1 ': * ( /.%0F. ( 6 + / F(

/ F / F ' / F / F ' / !%0F

( 6 + / ;%%F ' ( ( ( '/ G - ! FG - + ! 1 / &%,F ' (

' (

+ # * ,--.

(!)*

)

G '' < ' (

9 (!)* 69 5 5

2 ,5 2 ,5 ; . 7- . 7- ( !

5 # 6

78 5 # 6 !

122.

9 ' !;

9

&

5 ! ! ! ! !

9 & 5 #

1 5 #

< &

& /' 5

9 ! ! 122.

&

/ "

[ ]^{t ET} [ ]^{t K} [ ]^{t K} [ ]^{t CWR}[ ]^{t K} [ ]^t

ET_a = ₀ × _c × _s = × _s 1

@ 7 9

@ / ' /

1 5 # & @ 7

; 1

< ; 1

14 1 11

( )

( ⁻ ) ^{< <}

+ −

<

<

<

<

− − +

=

end end

mid prev

c next stage c

prev prev c

end mid start

mid mid

c

start mid end

ini prev

c next stage c

prev prev c

c

J J J

if K

L K L K J

J J J

if K

J J J

if K

L K L K J

t K

*

* )

( ,

. F

122=',--? ,---<

F ?44 <

/ ' <

/ ' <

/ ! ' <

/ ' ' <

/ 7 & ' <

:! <

:

, * B ' + ' * * ( * 2. * E

# $ D =3

4

1 /

? ! 122." 142 "

[ ]

[ ] [ ]

( − )× [ ] [ ]<( − [ ]) [ ]

=

otherwise t S t p t S t if S t p

t S t

K

t t

s

max 1 max

1 1

?

; ₇ & -

! 122. <

; <

! ( & &

' ! 122.

& ( &

/ 9

! 122. * &

&

9 &

! &

< 6

&

- 5

"

[ ]^t ( ) ^z [ ]^{t TAWC z} [ ]^t

S_max =1000θ_FC−θ_WP × _r = × _r 7

R9*

?@ ^?<

R6B ?

@ ^?<

- 5 78 @ '

E L ,--4 <

<

&

A

&

&

#- E

&

& #- &

& "

[ ] [ ]^{t pt S} [ ]^t

RAW = × _max 5

#- <

14 1 1?

, * > C ( '( 1 ' 5 21 '' ' ==93 0 % F ' ' 1'

( 5 2++3/ + <F + < + + ' 1' '( 5 2++3/ F ' '(

5 2++3/- F 5 ' 2++3 1 / F (

2:3

& "

[ ]^{t p} ( ^CWR[ ]^t)

p = _std+0.045− 4

! 5

5 # & @ E - -7 @

9 ! ! 122.

! 122. = "

( )

≥

− <

− − +

=

mid r

ini mid c mid c

ini c J r c

r r

r

J J if Z

J J K if

K K Z K

Z Z

t Z

max min max

min ( )

)

* ( ) (

=

/ ' <

/ : ' <

/ . F F ' <

. F

122=',--? ,---< F

?44 <

. ' F F <

= <

=

- 15 - ,-

= 7 &

,, ! 122.

, * @ ' + 5 * * ( * 2 '' ' ==93

; ? &

6 7 4 = !8; 7 #-

? ; ?

. 4"

[ ]^{t S}[ ]^t ( ^ec[ ] [ ]^{t Rt}) ^I[ ]^{t CR}[ ]^{t ET} [ ]^{t DP}[ ]^t

S_t = _t −1+ Pr − + + − _a − .

; * , <

; * 12, 12 <

* , <

# * , <

3 * , <

5# * , <

* , <

> * ,

! ! 122." 15?@1=1

14 1 15

9 1

( # )N ,--.

&

!

)

"

[ ]= [ ] [ ]− [ ] [ ] [ ]− − − ≥ × [ ]

otherwise

t S t p t S t S if t S t t S

IR ^{t t}

0

1

1 _max

max

max 2

"

[ ]^{t IR}[ ]^t

I =α_a× 1-

3 <

? 3 <

3# &

! & &

! 122.

"

[ ]t =(^Prec[ ] [ ]t −Rt)−I[ ]t −CR[ ]t +ET [ ]t ≥ ⁰

DP _a 11

6

L !

) # I 12=2 %

,--- "

[ ]

[ ] ^m

p d

d p d

d a y

m

a Y

t CWR

t ET K

Y

Y = × ₌ − +

=

=

= 1

lg

1 lg

1 1,

6 @ <

6 & S @ T<

/ ' <

@ 5 #

@ <

<

!

I ! 122.

/ ,7 &

1 ,

% ,---

9!0 ,--2

1224',--5 9!0 ,--2 9

9!0 ,--2

69

0

! &

! (!)*

9!0 ,--5 9!0 ,--5

( (!)*

5 ! ! !

5 U@ 7 '

5

&

E &

+ # *

14 1 1=

(

, ?V1 1 ?V-

; 2%# *?@9,A + !

5

@ V1 V !

1- U@ 1?

"

[ ⁰] ^{10 lgp} [ ][ ⁰]

1

=

×

=

=

=

= α α

d

d a

g ET t

CWU 1?

[^α=0]⁼⁰

CWUb 17

[^α=0]⁼CWUg[^α=0]⁺CWUb[^α=0]⁼CWUg[^α=0]

CWU 15

[ ] [ ] [ ]

[ ⁰]⁰

0

0 =

= =

=

=

= α

α α

α g Ya

WF CWU

WF 14

; 4%3 *?@2,A' + !

5 '

& 1 ?V- , ?V1 "

[^α=1]⁼ g[^α=0]

g CWU

CWU 1=

[α⁼¹]⁼ [α⁼¹]⁻ _g[α⁼¹]

b CWU CWU

CWU 1.

[ ¹] ^{10 lgp} [ ][ ¹]

1

=

×

=

= ⁼

=

α

α ^{ET t}

CWU

d

d

a 12

[ ] [ ]

[ ¹]¹

1 =

= =

= αα

α a

b Y b

WF CWU ,-

[ ] [ ]

[ ¹]¹

1 =

= =

= α

α α

Ya

WF CWU ,1

B + !

9

L * 122.

0 / B I

! L ,--4 0 /

$ I #

1224 !

69

!1 1 ?

"

a leached

a leach applied

grey Y

c N

Y c

f N

WF ^max = ^max

×

= ,,

+ > ^?@ <

!! @ <

/' ' <

@ <

7 & @ ^?<

6 ! @

! !

& ,- ,1

14 ,, "

[ ] ( ) [ ]

[ ] [ ]

( g b ) ( a) g[ ] grey

a

grey a

a

WF WF

WF WF

WF WF

WF WF

+

=

×

− +

= +

=

×

=

+

=

×

− +

=

×

=

0 1

1 1

0 1

1

α α

α α

α

α α

α

α ,?

+ U@

"

[ ] [ ]

[ ]

[ ] [ ]

[ ] [ ]

=

=

×

×

=

= _n

j a n

j

c y x Y

c y x CWU

c Y

c c CWU WF

1 1

cell grid size total

c cultivated cell

grid , area ,

cell grid size total

c cultivated cell

grid , area ,

,7

1

+C!!D U@ ! @

A(P@A(P

[ ]^r

WF U@ U@

* # + ,--. ,5 * # + ,--. "

[ ]^p (^WF[ ]^{r PWU}[ ]^r) ^{f [ ]}_{[ ]}^p

WF = + × ^v ,5

14 1 12

! E

9 (!)* L 2-3

) 9!0 ,--2

(!)* 1224',--5

69 + # * ,--. L

(!)* / &

2-3 ,,

. 2-3 (!)*

1224',--5 1 # . (!)*

#

42%

17%

9% 7%

4%

4%

2%

1%

3%

1%

10%

Cereals Roots & tubers Oil crops Fruit Sugar crops Fiber Pulses Tree nuts Coffee Clove

Crops not included

, * 9 * ( + * * '( + 1 - .

* ==>: B * 1 0 + $ 2 3 ( +

* 1 * * ==>: B

2, C = 3 + ' ' ( %, 2# $ E . * 93

1' C ( ' 1' = H ( + - . * C

'( ' ( + * 21 0 + $ 2 33 * ( ''

' + I ( + *

1 * = H ( 1

- . *

, C : '( J

2 ⁼+^A? 3

H '

( +

- .

G

54 57 - ,5 ?. *

* 1,5 ?, 7 15 72 % #

% ,= ,7 5 11 4. *

( 154 . ?4 7 -, (

B 7.2 = =. ? =4 9

* ?,. . ?1 ? =4 9

* 454 4 ?? ? 17 0

> ,7, 5 =5 , .5 0

* ,72 5 5. , =7 0

( .? 5 7- , 75 *

E 7.4 7 42 , ,= 9

( ,4= ? 27 1 27 0

E 1=4 ? == 1 .7 B

6 15 ? 72 1 =, *

=2 ? ?7 1 52 *

0 ,57 ? 1, 1 5? 0

( 1,, , .4 1 ?5 % #

B 114 1 5, - =7 % #

* ,1= 1 7. - =?

* 42. 1 -4 - 51 0

0 72- - 2. - 7. 9

( ,?4 - 27 - 74 0

1 ' 9 AD = DA

' ( - . * 2 H 3 D

W* @ 1224',--5 9!0 ,--2

69: ^?@ + # * ,--. (!)*

% ' $ ' $

* # + ,--7 69

" 1 # ,

? 7 5 4 = . 2

69 69

+ #

+ ,--5 9 (!)* 69

69 0

9 & 9!0 ,--2

14 1 ,1

* ,--7< ,--. "

[ ] [ ]

[ ]ⁿ

GDP n n IWW

WFi = i ,4

[ ]ⁿ

WF_i U@A(P <

3 ^U@ <

B > > )B A(P@

F

1-- F

* !

2

+ &

& +

+ # * ,--. & +

&

69 & G8 +! &

69 69 &

+! G

$ ^?@

&

# 4

5 7 6

7

7 6

7 6

$, 8

18 4

5

7

$,

$

7

$

$*

, * = ( '( * + ( $ 2+ + & C ' ' =3 ; 1

' 1 ( '( + 2 3 : < '( + 2 3 '( < 2& 3

%, ' 2%, 3 '( ' + ++ 2 3 < '

( ' + ++ 2 3 '( 2 3 ' +

'( 1 * 2 3

; ' '( ' ( * ' '

G ^?@

&

"

[^{n n c}] [^{Tn n c}] ^WF[ ]^{n c}

V _e, _i, = _e, _i, × _e, ,=

@ & +

&

; ' '( ' ( '

,. &

+ ' &

[^{n n c}] ^WF[ ]ⁿ [ ]^c

V _e, _i, = _{i e}×valueofindustrialproductstraded n_e, ,.

) ! !

; ' < '(

6

& $ 0 ,--2

2 "

n i i

e n V

WU V

WF WF ×

= + ,2

6 ,2 2

e i r

e V WF

V_, = − ?-

r e e d

e V V

V_, = − _, ?1

+ U@ &

& &

G₈ + # * ,--. "

d e d i a d e p

i WF V WU WU WU V

WF = − _, = + + − _. ?,

14 1 ,?

'

> 6(B ,--.

( 122= ! ( 122= 1=3

! & 1,3

<

1

# - 78

8

- ??

g a g

g WA WU

RWA = − _, ??

# -'

&

8' 8' 8'

-' 9!0: ,--2 ?7 /

# -' ;9% M *

;9%

/ !

b d b i b a b

b WA WU WU WU

RWA = − _, − _, − _, ?7

# -'H

69

"

( ab agrey) ( ib igrey) ( db dgrey)

b

b WA WU WU WU WU WU WU

RWA^*= − _, + _, − _, + _, − _, + _, ?5

; ' (

/

> ; :

- "

×100

= g

g WAg

WS WF ?4

E ;' :

-'"

×100

= b

b WAb

WS WF ?=

1--3

@

% ( ':

! > & :

+ & + "

×100

= n

e WF

WD WF ?.

' ;; +

+ + "

×100

= n

i WF

WSS WF ?2

"

• ! 122. " & '

• * # + ,--7 ! $ , "

I '

! * # +

,--7

• 9!0 ,--2 " !G A!( !

"@@ @ @ @ @ @ &

• 9!0 ,--2 " 9!0( !

"@@ @ &

14 1 ,5

"@@ @ @ @ @

• + # * ,--. * # + ,--7 ; ,--1 " 69

• B ,--. "

• ( ! ( !

* * > ( " ,?-

)$) * ,--=

"@@ @ @ < 1224',--5

• A/ ( ) ,--2 "

"@@ @ @ @ 9 < 1224',--5

• 6 " ;B! ,--5 C " >

"@@ @ @ @ & X

• > ( "

o ! ; - 1241'122- 1-

"

"@@ @ @ @ @ 9!0 ,--7

> Y 1- !

o ( - 5 5 "

"@@ @AI@! Z( @( Z @> Z @> @6 (;5 5

(% *'6 (;< E L ,--4

o ! 1241'122- ?- "

"@@ @ [ *%A , 1 < ,--5

o * 1=5

,--- 5 "

"@@ @ @ @) @1=5 ,---@ ,--.

o * 1. L 5 "

"@@ @ @ [ Q [ [ V L @/ *)9[5

C ,--7

o ! 5 ( ,--= "

"@@ @ @ @ @ 9!0 ,--2

o !

125-',--- ?- > 6(B ,--. "

"@@ @ & Q V [ # V # V17?# V5,

o ! 1241'122- ?-

> 6(B ,--. "

"@@ @ & Q V [ # V # V7-# V5,

?- > 6(B ,--. "

"@@ @ & Q V [ # V # V151# V5,

) ?- > 6(B ,--. "

"@@ @ & Q V [ # V # V15,# V5,

• C /' !

(!)*

+ ' 5 ==>: B

1224',--5

* ,--=

"

• 1224',--5<

•

1224',--5 9!0 ,--2 <

• ,--- B ,--. ,--,

9!0 ,--5 <

• > '

1241 122-<

• > ' 1=5 122='

,--? ,---

) 1224'

,--5 '

122=',--? ! ,--5

!

1224',--5 ^?@ ^?@

@

- +

E 69

! +

! & !1

5 !! < !

) 9;% ( ! ,--2

(!)* +

I # I ,--=

'( !