)YDQGH*HLMQ$ ):DJHQLQJHQ1HGHUODQG
*GHO3UDGR/993DUDPDULER6XULQDPH
.YDQ:LMN332/HO\VWDG1HGHUODQG
-DQXDUL
3LORWH[SRUWYHUSDNNLQJ6XULQDDPVHJURHQWHQHQGH
6XULQDDPVHJHNRHOGHNHWHQ
3URMHFW6XULWXLQ3DNJURHQ
$JURWHFKQRORJ\ )RRG,QQRYDWLRQV%9/LGYDQ:DJHQLQJHQ85
3LORWH[SRUWYHUSDNNLQJ6XULQDDPVH
JURHQWHQHQGH6XULQDDPVH
JHNRHOGHNHWHQ
3URMHFW6XULWXLQ3DNJURHQ
)YDQGH*HLMQ$ ):DJHQLQJHQ1HGHUODQG *GHO3UDGR/993DUDPDULER6XULQDPH .YDQ:LMN332/HO\VWDG1HGHUODQG 5DSSRUW$JURWHFKQRORJ\ )RRG,QQRYDWLRQV%9RQGHUGHHOYDQ:DJHQLQJHQ85
&RORIRQ
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sQRSQDPHQRIHQLJHDQGHUHPDQLHU]RQGHUYRRUDIJDDQGHVFKULIWHOLMNHWRHVWHPPLQJYDQGHXLWJHYHU'H XLWJHYHUDDQYDDUGWJHHQDDQVSUDNHOLMNKHLGYRRUHYHQWXHOHIRXWHQRIRQYRONRPHQKHGHQ $OOULJKWVUHVHUYHG1RSDUWRIWKLVSXEOLFDWLRQPD\EHUHSURGXFHGVWRUHGLQDUHWULHYDOV\VWHPRIDQ\QDWXUHRUWUDQVPLWWHGLQDQ\IRUP RUE\DQ\PHDQVHOHFWURQLFPHFKDQLFDOSKRWRFRS\LQJUHFRUGLQJRURWKHUZLVHZLWKRXWWKHSULRUSHUPLVVLRQRIWKHSXEOLVKHU7KHSXEOLVKHU GRHVQRWDFFHSWDQ\OLDELOLW\IRULQDFFXUDFLHVLQWKLVUHSRUW$JURWHFKQRORJ\ )RRG,QQRYDWLRQV%9/LGYDQ:DJHQLQJHQ85
6DPHQYDWWLQJ
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|UGLQHHUGHNHWHQ%LMHHQODQJHUNHWHQYHUEOLMI]DOGHEDVLVNZDOLWHLWYDQKHWSURGXFW VWHUNYHUEHWHUGPRHWHQZRUGHQ2YHULJHQVNDQGLWRRNGRRUJHEUXLNWHPDNHQYDQYHUSDNNLQJHQ GLHLVROHUHQ]RDOVGH36SRO\VW\UHHQYHUSDNNLQJRSXLWGUXNNHOLMNHYRRUZDDUGHGDWKHWSURGXFW JHNRHOGLQGHYHUSDNNLQJZRUGWJHEUDFKW(HQELMNRPHQGYRRUGHHOYDQGH36YHUSDNNLQJLVGH QRRG]DDNPDDU]HNHURRNKHW´JHYRHOµ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
$JURWHFKQRORJ\ )RRG,QQRYDWLRQV%9/LGYDQ:DJHQLQJHQ85
,QKRXGVRSJDYH
6DPHQYDWWLQJ ,QOHLGLQJ 9HUSDNNLQJVSLORW 9DULDEHOHQ 3URGXFW 'RRVW\SH :HOHQQLHWNRHOHQYRRUYHUSDNNHQ ([SRUWHXU 5HVXOWDWHQ 7HPSHUDWXXU .ZDOLWHLW.RXVHEDQG .ZDOLWHLW6RSURSR *HNRHOGHNHWHQ ,QOHLGLQJ ,QLWLsOHSURGXFWNZDOLWHLW +XLGLJHVLWXDWLHHQPRJHOLMNKHGHQ %HUHNHQLQJHIIHFWHQYDQNRHOHOHPHQWHQLQYHUSDNNLQJ 7HFKQLVFKHLQULFKWLQJ .RHOIDFLOLWHLWHQQDELMSURGXFWLH &HQWUDOHNRHOIDFLOLWHLWHQ 9HUSDNNLQJHQJHNRHOGHNHWHQ 'LVFXVVLHHQFRQFOXVLH$JURWHFKQRORJ\ )RRG,QQRYDWLRQV%9/LGYDQ:DJHQLQJHQ85
,QOHLGLQJ
$OVRQGHUGHHOYDQKHW6XULWXLQSURMHFWLVGHHOSURMHFW3DNJURHQJHULFKWRSGH´2SWLPDOLVDWLH H[SRUWYHUSDNNLQJµ'HRIILFLsOHSURMHFWWLWHOLV´'XXU]DPHYHUSDNNLQJYRRU6XULQDDPVH H[SRUWJURHQWHQµ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·ORQGHUOHLGLQJYDQ'KU*RSDOWH+HOHQD&KULVWLQDGLWULFWV:DQLFD 6XULQDPHQDDUGHILUPD1RHSDWH'HQ+DDJ /DQJVGH]HZHJKDUWHOLMNGDQNYRRULHGHUVPHGHZHUNLQJ$JURWHFKQRORJ\ )RRG,QQRYDWLRQV%9/LGYDQ:DJHQLQJHQ85
9HUSDNNLQJVSLORW
%LMGHRS]HWYDQGHYHUSDNNLQJVSURHILVJHNR]HQYRRUGHYROJHQGHYDULDEHOHQ 3URGXFW 'RRVW\SH :HOHQQLHWNRHOHQYRRUYHUSDNNHQ ([SRUWHXU 9DULDEHOHQ 3URGXFW 'HSURGXFWHQYRRUGHSURHI]LMQ.RXVHEDQGHQ6RSURSR.RXVHEDQGLVJHNR]HQYDQZHJHGH NZDOLWHLWVJHYRHOLJKHLGLQGHNHWHQ6RSURSRLVJHNR]HQYDQZHJHKHWEHODQJYDQGLWSURGXFWDOV 6XULQDDPVH[SRUWSURGXFWULFKWLQJ1HGHUODQG 2RUVSURQNHOLMNZDVKHWGHEHGRHOLQJKHWSURGXFWYDQpp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·OROY'KU*RSDOWH+HOHQD &KULVWLQD'LVWULFW:DQLFDQDDUGHILUPD1RHSDWH'HQ+DDJ
$JURWHFKQRORJ\ )RRG,QQRYDWLRQV%9/LGYDQ:DJHQLQJHQ85 ([SRUWNHWHQ ZRHQVGDJRNWREHUYDQGHILUPD1L]DDPROY'KU,EUDKLPWH3DUDPDULER QDDUGHILUPD$0$5,PSRUWWH'HQ+DDJ 'HYHUVFKLOOHQWXVVHQGHWZHHNHWHQV]LMQQLHWJURRW(FKWHUYRRUKHWYHUJURWHQYDQGH EHWURNNHQKHLGYDQGHVHFWRULVKHWZHQVHOLMNJHZHHVWGH]HSURHIQLHWWRWppQH[SRUWHXUWH EHSHUNHQ,QEHLGHJHYDOOHQLVGHRUJDQLVDWLHRSGHORFDWLHLQKDQGHQJHZHHVWYDQ/99'H SURGXFWNHWHQODDW]LFKDOVYROJWEHVFKULMYHQ • 'HRRJVWJHEHXUWLQGHRFKWHQGYDQGHH[SRUWGDJ6RSURSRZRUGWLQSODVWLFYXLOQLV]DNNHQ JHRRJVW.RXVHEDQGZRUGWLQERVVHQRQYHUSDNWJHRRJVW • $DQYRHUELMH[SRUWHXUJHEHXUWLQEXVMHVHQLQRSHQDXWR·VSLFNXS • 'HDDQYRHUYDQ6RSURSRLVHHUGHUGDQYDQNRXVHEDQG/DDWVWJHQRHPGHZRUGWPHHVWDOYDQDI XXUSDVDDQJHYRHUG • 'HSURGXFWHQZRUGHQRSGHH[SRUWORFDWLHYLVXHHOEHRRUGHHOGHQXLWJH]RFKW2SEHLGH ORFDWLHVLVKHWSURGXFWRQJHZDVVHQYHUSDNW • 'HKHOIWYDQKHWSURGXFWZRUGWLQLMVZDWHUJHNRHOGGHDQGHUHKHOIWEOLMIWGURRJHQZRUGW YHOGZDUPYHUSDNW • 1DKHWDINRHOHQLVKHWSURGXFW]RJRHGPRJHOLMNJHGURRJG • +HWYHUSDNNHQJHEHXUWWXVVHQHQXXU • 1DYHUODGHQLVKHWSURGXFWRPVWUHHNVXXUJHUHHGYRRUKHWLQNODUHQRS=DQGHULM • 'HYOXFKWYHUWUHNWRPRQJHYHHUXXU$DQNRPVWLQ1HGHUODQGLVRPRQJHYHHUXXU ORFDOHWLMG1/1DKHWXLWNODUHQZRUGWKHWSURGXFWWXVVHQXXUHQXXURSJHKDDOG ELMGHLPSRUWHXUVLQ'HQ+DDJ+HWSURGXFWLVKLHUQDLQ:DJHQLQJHQLQHHQNRHOFHO & JHSODDWVWHQLVKHWGHYROJHQGHRFKWHQGEHRRUGHHOG • 1DXLWVWDOELM &LVKHWSURGXFWGDJHQODWHU.RXVHEDQGHQGDJHQODWHU6RSURSR RSQLHXZEHRRUGHHOG 5HVXOWDWHQ 'HUHVXOWDWHQYDQGHSURHI]LMQLQJHGHHOGLQGHWHPSHUDWXXUUHJLVWUDWLHHQGH NZDOLWHLWVEHRRUGHOLQJHQ'HNZDOLWHLWEHRRUGHOLQJHQ]LMQ]RZHOLQJHWDODOVLQEHHOGZHHUJHJHYHQ 7HPSHUDWXXU ,QGHRQGHUVWDDQGHJUDILHNHQ]LMQVWHHGVGHWHPSHUDWXXUUHJLVWUDWLHVYDQGHWZHHH[SRUWNHWHQ ZHHUJHJHYHQ2PGDWHUHQNHOHORJJHUVRYHUZDUHQ]LMQORJJHUVELMGH6RSURSRJHNRHOGHQ RQJHNRHOGHSURGXFWLQ36YHUSDNNLQJLQJHOHJG ,QGHJUDILHNHQLVKHWWHPSHUDWXXUYHUORRSYDQGHYHUSDNNLQJWH]LHQYDQDIKHWPRPHQWYDQ SODDWVHQXLWJHGUXNWLQ1HGHUODQGVHWLMGRQJHYHHUXXU6XULQDDPVHWLMG+HWHHUVWH UHJLVWUDWLHWLMGVWLSLVKHWPRPHQWJHZHHVWNRUWYRRUGDWKHWSODDWVHQYDQGHORJJHUELMDDQYDQJYDQ KHWYHUSDNNHQ'LWJHOGWYRRUDOOHWHPSHUDWXXUJUDILHNHQ'HORJJHUUHJLVWUHHUGHGHWHPSHUDWXXU SHUPLQXWHQ
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wQYORHGLVGRRUGHNOLPDDWEHKHHUVLQJLQKHWYOLHJWXLJ
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·VHQJUDILHNHQYRRUGHEHODQJULMNVWHNZDOLWHLWVEHYLQGLQJHQ 'HNZDOLWHLWYDQ.RXVHEDQGLVEHRRUGHHOGELMRQWYDQJVWLQ:DJHQLQJHQRQJHYHHUXXUQDKHW PRPHQWYDQLQSDNNHQ 'HNZDOLWHLWEHRRUGHOLQJYDQ.RXVHEDQGLVYRRUDOJHULFKWRSKHWRSWUHGHQYDQEHVFKDGLJLQJHQ DIZLMNLQJHQLQNOHXUHQKHWRSWUHGHQYDQURHVWYHUNOHXULQJHQURWHQVFKLPPHOSUREOHPHQ,Q RQGHUVWDDQGHIRWR·VLVYRRUGHYHUVFKLOOHQGHYHUSDNNLQJVYDULDQWHQHHQNZDOLWHLWVEHHOGWH]LHQQD KHWRSHQHQYDQGHYHUSDNNLQJ9DQGHHHUVWH]HQGLQJLVHHQNZDOLWHLWVEHHOGRYHUGHYDULDQWHQ YDVWJHOHJG%LMGHWZHHGHH[SRUWNHWHQ]LMQDOOHHQGHH[FHVVHQYDVWJHOHJG )RWR 9HUSDNNLQJHQPHWNRXVHEDQGDDQNRPVW1HGHUODQG
$JURWHFKQRORJ\ )RRG,QQRYDWLRQV%9/LGYDQ:DJHQLQJHQ85 %LMGHEHRRUGHOLQJYDQGHEHKDQGHOLQJHQ]LMQDIKDQNHOLMNYDQKHWDDQWDOERVVHQSHUGRRVHHQ DDQWDOERVVHQLQGHEHRRUGHOLQJEHWURNNHQ2PGDWHHQDDQWDONZDOLWHLWSUREOHPHQRSVSHFLILHNH SODDWVHQLQGHYHUSDNNLQJRSWUDGLVKLHUPHHPHWGHPRQVWHUQDPHUHNHQLQJJHKRXGHQ'H SUREOHPHQLQGH36YHUSDNNLQJRQJHNRHOGVSHHOGHQ]LFKDILQKHWPLGGHQYDQGHYHUSDNNLQJ 2SRQGHUVWDDQGHIRWRLVGLWSULPDLQEHHOGJHEUDFKW )RWR 5RWRQWZLNNHOLQJLQPLGGHQYDQ36YHUSDNNLQJHQ 'H]HEUXLQYHUNOHXULQJ]HWWH]LFKLQGHXLWVWDOSHULRGHGRRULQURWHQVFKLPPHOSUREOHPHQ9RRU GHYHUVFKLOOHQGHREMHFWHQYHUSDNNLQJHQNRHOPHWKRGH]LMQGHYHUVFKLOOHQVRPVJHHQ JHFRQVWDWHHUGXXUQDYHU]HQGLQJHQEHRRUGHOLQJLQ:DJHQLQJHQLQEHHOGJHEUDFKW'HIRWR·V ]LMQJHPDDNWYDQGHH[SRUWNHWHQ
$JURWHFKQRORJ\ )RRG,QQRYDWLRQV%9/LGYDQ:DJHQLQJHQ85 )RWR .RXVHEDQGJHNRHOGHQRQJHNRHOGDDQNRPVW1HGHUODQG36 )RWR .RXVHEDQGJHNRHOGHQRQJHNRHOGDDQNRPVW1HGHUODQGSDSULNDGRRV
$JURWHFKQRORJ\ )RRG,QQRYDWLRQV%9/LGYDQ:DJHQLQJHQ85 )RWR .RXVHEDQGJHNRHOGHQRQJHNRHOGDDQNRPVW1HGHUODQG6WDQGDDUGQHW]DN %LQQHQGHEHKDQGHOLQJHQZRUGHQJURWHYHUVFKLOOHQLQNOHXUZDDUJHQRPHQ'HHOV]LMQGH]H YHUVFKLOOHQELQQHQGHERVZDDUWHQHPHQGHHOVOLJJHQGHYHUVFKLOOHQMXLVWWXVVHQGHERVVHQ0HW RQGHUVWDDQGHDIEHHOGLQJZRUGWGLWGXLGHOLMNJHPDDNW )RWR 6SUHLGLQJLQNZDOLWHLWHQNOHXUELQQHQppQEHKDQGHOLQJELMDDQNRPVW1HGHUODQG
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
$JURWHFKQRORJ\ )RRG,QQRYDWLRQV%9/LGYDQ:DJHQLQJHQ85 JHPDDNW'HYHUVFKLOOHQKDQJHQRQGHUDQGHUHDIYDQGHSRVLWLHYDQGHERVLQGHYHUSDNNLQJ 2QGHULQ]LMQGHSUREOHPHQPHWVFKLPPHORQWZLNNHOLQJJURWHUGDQERYHQLQGHGRRV )RWR .RXVHEDQGJHNRHOGQDGDJHQXLWVWDOXLW36YHUSDNNLQJ )RWR .RXVHEDQGJHNRHOGHQRQJHNRHOGQDGDJHQXLWVWDOXLWSDSULNDGRRV
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
$JURWHFKQRORJ\ )RRG,QQRYDWLRQV%9/LGYDQ:DJHQLQJHQ85 +LHUQDDVWLVQDGDJHQRRNQDDUURHVWYRUPLQJJHNHNHQ,QRQGHUVWDDQGHWDEHOLVGLWPHWHHQ VFRUHXLWJHZHUNW'HRQJHNRHOGH36YHUSDNNLQJLVQLHWPHHULQGHEHRRUGHOLQJYDQGH]H NZDOLWHLW]DNHQPHHJHQRPHQRPGDWKLHUKHWEHGHUILQGHYRUPYDQERVURW]LHJUDILHNDO ZDV )RWR 5RHVWYRUPLQJQDXLWVWDOGDJHQ )LJXXU 5RHVWQDXLWVWDOGDJHQLQGLYHUVHYHUSDNNLQJVYRUPHQJHNRHOGHQRQJHNRHOGYRRU NRXVHEDQGH[SRUWNHWHQOLQNVHQUHFKWV
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·VJHPDDNW'HDOJHPHQHNZDOLWHLWLV JRHG'HGR]HQKHEEHQGHNHWHQUHGHOLMNRYHUOHHIG%LMGHJDQJEDUHYHUSDNNLQJUHFKWVLVWH]LHQ GDWKHWNDUWRQQDDUEXLWHQLVJHZHNHQ )RWR 9HUSDNNLQJHQPHW6RSURSRDDQNRPVW1HGHUODQG 9DQHONREMHFW]LMQHHQDDQWDOYUXFKWHQEHRRUGHHOGRSXLWZHQGLJHNZDOLWHLW2SRQGHUVWDDQGH IRWR·VLVKHWEHRRUGHOLQJVPRPHQWQDXXUZHHUJHJHYHQYDQ]RZHOGHJHNRHOGHDOVRQJHNRHOGH YDULDQW
$JURWHFKQRORJ\ )RRG,QQRYDWLRQV%9/LGYDQ:DJHQLQJHQ85 )RWR 6RSURSRJHNRHOGHQRQJHNRHOGDDQNRPVW1HGHUODQG36 )RWR 6RSURSRJHNRHOGHQRQJHNRHOGDDQNRPVW1HGHUODQGSDSULNDGRRV )RWR 6RSURSRJHNRHOGHQRQJHNRHOGDDQNRPVW1HGHUODQGVWDQGDDUG 'HNOHXUYHUVFKLOOHQ]LMQRSPRPHQWYDQEHRRUGHOHQ]HHUEHSHUNWHQZRUGHQYRRUDOYHURRU]DDNW GRRUQDWXXUOLMNHYDULDWLH'HYUXFKWHQ]LMQHYHQHHQVEHRRUGHHOGRSLQZHQGLJHNZDOLWHLW+LHUELM ]LMQJHHQDIZLMNLQJHQJHFRQVWDWHHUG
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sOHNZDOLWHLWULMSKHLGELMRRJVWKLHUDOVEHODQJULMNVWHRRU]DDNDDQWHZLM]HQ %LQQHQGHREMHFWHQ]LMQGHNZDOLWHLWYHUVFKLOOHQ]HHUJURRW
$JURWHFKQRORJ\ )RRG,QQRYDWLRQV%9/LGYDQ:DJHQLQJHQ85 )RWR 6RSURSRJHNRHOGHQRQJHNRHOGQDGDJHQXLWVWDOXLW36 )RWR 6RSURSRJHNRHOGHQRQJHNRHOGQDGDJHQXLWVWDOXLWSDSULNDGRRV )RWR 6RSURSRJHNRHOGHQRQJHNRHOGQDGDJHQXLWVWDOXLW6WDQGDDUGYHUSDNNLQJ
$JURWHFKQRORJ\ )RRG,QQRYDWLRQV%9/LGYDQ:DJHQLQJHQ85
,QRQGHUVWDDQGHJUDILHNZRUGWDOOHUHHUVWGHJURQGNOHXUZHHUJHJHYHQLQHHQEHRRUGHOLQJVJHWDO JURHQWRW JHHO+LHUELMLVGHYROJHQGHNODVVHLQGHOLQJDDQJHKRXGHQ
6FRUH
JURQGNOHXU 9HUJHOLQJYDQRSSHUYODNWH %HHOG
1LHWYHUJHHOG RSSHUYODNWHYHUJHHOG RSSHUYODNWHYHUJHHOG YHUJHHOG YHUJHHOG YHUJHHOG ,QGH]HJUDILHN]LMQRRNGHZDDUQHPLQJHQQDGDJHQDOOHHQGHWZHHGHH[SRUWNHWHQHQGDJHQ XLWVWDORSJHQRPHQ$OQDGDJHQH[SRUWNHWHQLVGHYHUJHOLQJIOLQNWRHJHQRPHQ )LJXXU .OHXUEHRRUGHOLQJQDXXUHQQDHQXLWVWDOGDJHQLQGLYHUVHYHUSDNNLQJVYRUPHQJHNRHOG HQRQJHNRHOGYRRU6RSURSRH[SRUWNHWHQOLQNVHQUHFKWV
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wQYORHGRILVGRRUGHODJHUHSURGXFWWHPSHUDWXXUGHEHVFKDGLJLQJPDNNHOLMNHU RSJHWUHGHQ8LWHUDDUGNDQRRNGHRYHUPDDWDDQYRFKWWRWKHWSUREOHHPKHEEHQJHOHLG
$JURWHFKQRORJ\ )RRG,QQRYDWLRQV%9/LGYDQ:DJHQLQJHQ85
*HNRHOGHNHWHQ
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sOHSURGXFWNZDOLWHLW %LMNZDOLWHLWYHUEHWHUHQGHPDDWUHJHOHQLVKHWEHwQYORHGHQYDQGHLQLWLsOHNZDOLWHLW]HHUEHODQJULMN 8QLIRUPLWHLWYDQKHWSURGXFWLVEHODQJULMN'LWJHOGWQLHWDOOHHQYRRUGHYRUPNOHXUPDDW EHVFKDGLJLQJHQPDDURRNYRRUPLQGHU]LFKWEDUHHLJHQVFKDSSHQ]RDOVULMSKHLGHQEHZDDUSRWHQWLH 'HEHYLQGLQJHQPHWGH6XULQDDPVHSURGXFWHQ.RXVHEDQGHQ6RSURSROHUHQGDWHUJURWH YHUVFKLOOHQEHVWDDQLQGHLQLWLsOHNZDOLWHLW9RRUDOLQGHXLWVWDOSURHYHQEOLMNHQGHYHUVFKLOOHQLQ KRXGEDDUKHLG]HHUJURRW %LMNRXVHEDQGEOLMNW]RZHOELMKHWLQ]HWWHQYDQGHYHUSDNNLQJVSLORWDOVELMDDQNRPVWLQ1HGHUODQG HHQJURRWYHUVFKLOWH]LMQWXVVHQGHKHUNRPVWHQ1LHWDOOHHQYHUVFKLOOHQGHXLWZHQGLJHNZDOLWHLW YDQGHERQHQLQGH]LQYDQPDDWJHOLMNKHLGLQPDDWNOHXUULMSKHLGERRQGLNWHRRNGH EHZDDUSRWHQWLHZRUGWKLHUGRRUEHwQYORHG %LM6RSURSRLVGHVFKLOJHYRHOLJKHLGYDQKHWSURGXFWHHQ]HHUEHODQJULMNSUREOHHP-XLVWGLUHFWQD GHRRJVWWUHGHQYHHOEHVFKDGLJLQJHQRS'HNHX]HYRRUGH´RRJVWYHUSDNNLQJµLQGHYRUPYDQ HHQYXLOQLV]DNHQKHWWUDQVSRUW]LMQGHEURQ%LMGLWSURGXFW]DOKHWEHSHUNHQYDQ VFKLOEHVFKDGLJLQJHQYHHONZDOLWHLWVYRRUGHHOJHYHQ(YHQWXHHONDQEHVORWHQZRUGHQQDKHWNRHOHQ KHWSURGXFWYHUJHOLMNEDDUPHWGH1HGHUODQGVHNRPNRPPHUWHJDDQVHDOHQ %LMKHWLQULFKWHQYDQHHQJHNRHOGHNHWHQYRRUNZDOLWHLWVSURGXFWHQ]DOODQJVYHUVFKLOOHQGHZHJHQ JHZHUNWPRHWHQZRUGHQDDQGHLQLWLsOHNZDOLWHLWYDQSURGXFWHQ+RRJVWZDDUVFKLMQOLMNLVGH ]DDGNZDOLWHLWYDQKHWSURGXFWGHEDVLV=RQGHUGXLGHOLMNKHLGRYHUGH]DDGNZDOLWHLW]DODOELMGH RSJURHLYHUVFKLOLQNZDOLWHLWYRUPULMSKHLGNOHXURQWZLNNHOVWDGLXPRQWVWDDQ$JURWHFKQRORJ\ )RRG,QQRYDWLRQV%9/LGYDQ:DJHQLQJHQ85 ,QGHRRJVWIDVH]DO]RZHOELM6RSURSRDOVELM.RXVHEDQGGHIUHTXHQWLHYDQRRJVWPRPHQWHQDDQ KHWJHZDVVWDQGPRHWHQZRUGHQDDQJHSDVW7LMGHQVGHLQSDNSURHIKHEEHQZHHUYDUHQGDWGH VSUHLGLQJLQNZDOLWHLWELQQHQHHQKHUNRPVWHQRUPJURRWNDQ]LMQ%LMpp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·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
%HVFKULMYLQJ /RNDOHWLMG 1/WLMG $EVROXXWJHPLGGHOG
2RJVW WRWXXU WRWXXU 7
9HUSDNNHQ WRWXXU WRWXXU 7 7UDQVSRUWHQODGHQ
=DQGHULM WRWXXU WRWXXU 7
6WDUWYOXFKW XXU XXU 7
(LQGHYOXFKW XXU XXU 7
$DQNRPVWWRNR WRWXXU WRWXXU 7 XXU
%HRRUGHOLQJNZDOLWHLWNHWHQSURHI 7 ,QGHKXLGLJHNHWHQLVZHLQLJWRWJHHQWLMGRPKHWSURGXFWDIWHNRHOHQ'RRUHFKWHUKHWSURGXFW HHQGDJHHUGHUWHRRJVWHQZRUGHQYHUVFKLOOHQGHYRRUGHOHQEHKDDOG KHWSURGXFWNULMJWGHNDQVRPPHWQRUPDOHNRHOWHFKQLHNHQRSWLPDDODIJHNRHOGWH ZRUGHQ GRRUGHDDQZH]LJKHLGYDQNRHOFHOOHQNDQKHWSURGXFWRRNRSHHQZDUPHUPRPHQWRS GHGDJZRUGHQJHRRJVWRQGHUYRRUEHKRXGGDWKHWSURGXFWZHO]RVQHOPRJHOLMNYDQ KHWODQGZRUGWYHUZLMGHUG
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
$JURWHFKQRORJ\ )RRG,QQRYDWLRQV%9/LGYDQ:DJHQLQJHQ85 YORHLVWRIQDDUJDVGRRUPDDNWLVHYHQHHQVZDUPWHQRGLJ9RRULMVVSUHNHQZHRYHU VWROOLQJVZDUPWH 6WROOLQJVZDUPWHLMV N-NJ (QNHOHFKHPLVFKHPLGGHOHQRDSRO\PHUHQVFKLMQHQHHQVWROOLQJVZDUPWHHQRIHHQZDUPWH LQKRXGWHKHEEHQGLHWRWPDDOKRJHUOLJWDOVLMV+LHUPHHNDQYRRUHHQJHOLMNNRHOHQGHIIHFWGXV ELMQDGHKHOIWPLQGHUPDWHULDDOQRGLJ]LMQZDWRQGHUDQGHUHLQGHWUDQVSRUWNRVWHQNDQVFKHOHQ (FKWHUGLWPDWHULDDO]DOLQNRVWSULMVGXLGHOLMNGXXUGHU]LMQ 2Ppp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½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
$JURWHFKQRORJ\ )RRG,QQRYDWLRQV%9/LGYDQ:DJHQLQJHQ85 9ORHU 'HYORHUPDJZRUGHQJHwVROHHUGPDDUQRGLJLVKHWQLHW,VROHHUPHWPLQLPDDOFP385 SODWHQRIFP36'HYORHUGLHQWYODNHQJODGWHZRUGHQDIJHZHUNWPHWHHQYHUGLFKWH EHWRQYORHU'H]HPRHWJHVFKLNW]LMQYRRUKHWJHZLFKWGDWHURSZRUGWJHSODDWVW ,VRODWLH 'HFHOOHQGLHQHQUXLPWHZRUGHQJHwVROHHUG1LHW]R]HHUYDQZHJHSURGXFWHLVHQPDDU YRRUQDPHOLMNYDQZHJHFRQGHQVSUREOHPHQELMWHZHLQLJLVRODWLHHQYDQZHJHKHWEHSHUNHQYDQ HQHUJLHYHUEUXLN&RQFUHHW]DOPLQLPDDOPP3853RO\XUHWKDDQSDQHOHQRIPP36 SRO\VW\UHHQWHPSH[SLHSVFKXLPPRHWHQZRUGHQWRHJHSDVW%LMVDQGZLFKSDQHOHQLVRODWLH PHWDDQZHHU]LMGHHHQVWDDOSODDWGLHQHQGHQDGHQJRHGDIJHNLWWHZRUGHQ%LMDQGHUH LVRODWLHPDWHULDOHQGLHQWGHEXLWHQ]LMGHYDQGHFHOWH]LMQYRRU]LHQYDQHHQJHVORWHQ GDPSODDJ=RQGHUGH]HGDPSODDJEHVWDDWHHQUHsHOULVLFRGDWGHLVRODWLHQDWZRUGWHQKLHUPHH ]LMQLVRODWLHZDDUGHYHUOLHVW9DQRYHULJHPDWHULDOHQLVRRNHHQLVRODWLHZDDUGHEHNHQGPDDUOLJW GH]HODJHUGDQYDQJHQRHPGHPDWHULDOHQ+LHURPLVYRRUGH]HPDWHULDOHQYDDNHHQYHHO JURWHUHGLNWHQRGLJ 'HXU 'HFHOPRHWXLWHUDDUGYRRU]LHQZRUGHQYDQHHQJHw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
$JURWHFKQRORJ\ )RRG,QQRYDWLRQV%9/LGYDQ:DJHQLQJHQ85
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w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wQYORHG]LMQGRRUKHWNRHOHQYDQKHWSURGXFWPHWZDWHU:DDUVFKLMQOLMNKHHIWKHWSURGXFWDOVGLW GURRJJHNRHOGZRUGWPLQGHUNZDOLWHLWVSUREOHPHQLQGH]HYHUSDNNLQJ'XLGHOLMNLVZHOGDWGLW SURGXFWYRRUKHWYHUSDNNHQLQGH36YHUSDNNLQJPRHWZRUGHQJHNRHOG
$JURWHFKQRORJ\ )RRG,QQRYDWLRQV%9/LGYDQ:DJHQLQJHQ85
'LVFXVVLHHQFRQFOXVLH
'HNZDOLWHLWYDQ6XULQDDPVH.RXVHEDQGHQ6RSURSRNDQRSYHOHUOHLPDQLHUHQZRUGHQYHUEHWHUG 'XLGHOLMNLVGDWKHWRSORVVHQYDQHHQHQNHORQGHUGHHOYDQGHNHWHQZDDUVFKLMQOLMN]RQGHUKHW JHZHQVWHHIIHFWEOLMIW'HNZDOLWHLWZRUGWLPPHUVGRRUHHQRSHHQVWDSHOLQJYDQ]DNHQEHw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w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´KLJKYDOXHSURGXFWµHQ KLHUQDDUPRHWZRUGHQJHKDQGHOG8QLIRUPHULQJYDQGHNZDOLWHLWLVQDDVWKHWLQULFKWHQYDQGH JHNRHOGHNHWHQ]HNHU]REHODQJULMN0RJHOLMNELHGWKHWLQULFKWHQYDQNRHOFHOOHQZHOPRJHOLMNKHGHQ RPUHODWLHINOHLQHUHSURGXFWLHKRHYHHOKHGHQWHEXQGHOHQWRWDI]HWKRHYHHOKHGHQPHWHHQJURWHUH JHOLMNKHLGLQPDDWHQNZDOLWHLW +LHUQDDVWYHUGLHQWKHWGHDDQGDFKWRPKHWSURGXFWRRNRS=DQGHULMWHNXQQHQNRHOHQRIRP EHWHUHDIVSUDNHQWHPDNHQPHWGHOXFKWYHUYRHUGHURYHUKHWNOLPDDWDDQERRUG'HWHPSHUDWXXU OLMNWLQYOXFKWSHULRGHIOLQNEHwQYORHGWHNXQQHQZRUGHQILJXXUGRRUGHNOLPDDWUHJHOLQJDDQ ERRUG