• No results found

Space, Power, and Street Performers: The Effects of Regulation and Exclusionary Space in Victoria, B.C.

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "Space, Power, and Street Performers: The Effects of Regulation and Exclusionary Space in Victoria, B.C."

Copied!
1
0
0

Bezig met laden.... (Bekijk nu de volledige tekst)

Hele tekst

(1)

Poster Print Size:

This poster template is 36” high by

48” wide. It can be used to print any

poster with a 3:4 aspect raAo.

Placeholders

:

The various elements included in

this poster are ones we oCen see in

medical, research, and scienAfic

posters. Feel free to edit, move,

add, and delete items, or change

the layout to suit your needs.

Always check with your conference

organizer for specific requirements.

Image Quality:

You can place digital photos or logo

art in your poster file by selecAng

the Insert, Picture command, or by

using standard copy & paste. For

best results, all graphic elements

should be at least 150-200 pixels

per inch in their final printed size.

For instance, a 1600 x 1200 pixel

photo will usually look fine up to

8“-10” wide on your printed poster.

To preview the print quality of

images, select a magnificaAon of

100% when previewing your poster.

This will give you a good idea of

what it will look like in print. If you

are laying out a large poster and

using half-scale dimensions, be sure

to preview your graphics at 200% to

see them at their final printed size.

Please note that graphics from

websites (such as the logo on your

hospital's or university's home page)

will only be 72dpi and not suitable

for prinAng.

[This sidebar area does not print.]

Change Color Theme:

This template is designed to use the

built-in color themes in the newer

versions of PowerPoint.

To change the color theme, select

the Design tab, then select the

Colors drop-down list.

The default color theme for this

template is “Office”, so you can

always return to that aCer trying

some of the alternaAves.

PrinAng Your Poster:

Once your poster file is ready, visit

www.genigraphics.com to order a

high-quality, affordable poster

print. Every order receives a free

design review and we can deliver as

fast as next business day within the

US and Canada.

Genigraphics® has been producing

output from PowerPoint® longer

than anyone in the industry; daAng

back to when we helped MicrosoC®

design the PowerPoint® soCware.

US and Canada: 1-800-790-4001

Email: info@genigraphics.com

[This sidebar area does not print.]

The Socio-Geographical Effects of Exclusionary

Space on Street Performers in Victoria, B.C.

Dimitri P. Giannoulis

March 7, 2018

Department of Geography

This research was supported by the Jamie

Cassels Undergraduate Research Awards,

University of Victoria

Supervised by R. Rose-Redwood

Street performers are persons who will entertain in publicly accessible urban areas, receiving income solely by donation (Simpson, 2011). Street performers are valued for the spontaneity and conviviality they bring to public spaces, and are important for sense of place (Simpson, 2008; 2011). For a street performer, location is paramount. Important factors include foot traffic, sense of place, and the physical layout of space. The laws and regulations governing street performers, which differ between municipalities, effect these factors. Increasingly legalized since the 1980s (Smith, 1996), street performance is now mostly allowed in North America, but regulated by bylaws and permitting systems. The way these formal regulations attempt to control a street performer’s use of space is significant to their existence because street performers do not have fixed wages. The Lower Causeway is Victoria’s most illustrious place to perform, but permits are limited and must be auditioned for.

IntroducAon

Summarized in Table 1 are the key differences between the regulations of public streets and the Lower Causeway. Most notably, the permits for the Lower Causeway are substantially more expensive, and may only be acquired through an audition process. However, it is also significant that panhandlers are not allowed on the Lower Causeway, and that performance times are scheduled by the performers. Since the Greater Victoria Harbour Authority (GVHA) is a distinct entity from the municipality, they hire a contractor to organize the street performers and vendors, and private commissionaires to enforce regulations.

Regulatory Differences

Public Streets

The Lower

Causeway

Governing body

City of Victoria

Greater Victoria

Harbour Authority

Annual permit cost

$25

$200—musicians

$500—jugglers

ApplicaAon process

• 

Complete a form

• 

Have two pieces of

ID

• 

AudiAons every

April

• 

Limited spots

Panhandlers

Allowed

Prohibited

Timing

• 

Two hours at a

locaAon

• 

First come first

served

• 

Schedule made

weekly

• 

Guaranteed Ame

every day

Since the GVHA implemented these regulations in 2003, the street performer community has been divided spatially and socially. Those who are unable to afford a permit, win at the audition, or wish to travel, are excluded from the space. Also excluded are the panhandlers, who are then concentrated on other public streets. By these exclusions, the Lower Causeway becomes a structured experience for the tourists to enjoy, and the Lower Causeway is important to their impression of the city. By granting selectivity, the audition process shapes the space to be diverse, but demands quality and image standards. Street performing has historically been dominated by men (Harrison-Pepper, 1990), but the audition process allows women to be preferentially selected. However, seniority means an equal gender split will take time to achieve. Additionally, certain types of acts do not work well with the regulatory structure. For example, clowns, chalk artists and bag pipers are not accepted. By dividing performers geographically, the places themselves are altered in the perceptions of the pedestrians that visit them.

The SpaAal Effects of RegulaAon

Every exclusive space is simultaneously an inclusive space also. There is no evidence that the GVHA or the City of Victoria have exploitive intentions, and street performers spoke well of the bylaw officers, security guards, and organizers of the Lower Causeway. However, the Lower Causeway is a valuable resource for performers —and deciding who may use it is a geographical and political affair. The Lower Causeway offers a controlled environment for developed street performers to benefit from. Although excluded street performers are left with more flexibility, they must compete with other individuals for resources and space on the street.

Conclusion

References

•  Google Earth Pro. (August 18, 2016). V 7.3.1.4507. [Victoria BC Map]. lat 48.422111°, lon -123.369325°, eye alt 427m. Google 2018.

•  Harrison-Pepper, S. (1990). Drawing a circle in the square: Street performing in New York’s Washington Square

Park. University Press of Mississippi.

•  Simpson, P. (2008). Chronic everyday life: Rhythmanalysing street performance. Social & Cultural Geography,

9(7), 807-829. doi:10.1080/14649360802382578

•  Simpson, P. (2011). Street performance and the city: Public space, sociality, and intervening in the everyday.

Space and Culture, 14(4), 415-430. doi:10.1177/1206331211412270

•  Smith, M. (1996). Traditions, stereotypes, and tactics: A history of musical buskers in Toronto. Musicultures, 24. Retrieved from https://journals.lib.unb.ca/index.php/MC/article/view/21667

Acknowledgements

Thank you to my supervisor Reuben Rose-Redwood and my second reader Jennifer Mateer for their dedicated support. I also appreciate the assistance of the University of Victoria

Learning and Teaching Centre, and the support of the Jamie Cassels Undergraduate

Research Awards. A special thank you is also owed to my interviewees for donating their time, knowledge and experiences: without you this work would have been impossible. Table 1. Comparing regulations of street performers between public streets and the Lower

Causeway of Victoria, B.C.

Figure 1. Area regulated by the Greater Victoria Harbour Authority and designated locations for musicians and jugglers. Victoria, BC. Imagery from Google Earth Pro, August 18, 2016.

•  Explore the socio-spatial consequences of formal regulation on street performers

•  Identify individuals who this exclusionary space benefits or harms •  Seek solutions for those who do not benefit

Research Goals

•  Semi-structured interviews •  ParAcipant observaAon

•  Textual analysis of online videos •  Transect walks

Methods

Figure 2. Street performers in Victoria, BC. Left: a Darth Vader costumed musician plays on Government Street. Right: a human statue poses on the Lower Causeway.

Notes:

1.  Background image of the Inner Harbour, Victoria, B.C., was captured by the author on Feb. 1st, 2018.

Referenties

GERELATEERDE DOCUMENTEN

and excluding the non-airfoil blade sections near the root) to investigate the influence of the tip gap size on the predicted aerodynamic performance of the fan with small

Error analysis broke new ground in the study of learner errors by postulating that there are sources of error other than first language interference.. For the learner, error

None of the studies mentioned above, dealt with the use of social media in building and maintaining positive relationships between the university and their alumni,

In a recent study, an assessment strategy was composed for the prediction of practical fitness to drive in patients with Alzheimer’s dementia (AD), consisting of clinical interviews,

Voor een bedrijf zonder recirculatie van drainagewater en daarmee ook geen bassinwaterlozingen, is de totale potentiële emissie in grammen is het hoogst voor afvoer van het restant

Er is beoordeeld OP: Gootdiepte Kleur Blad/stengelverhouding Struikopbouw Sprantvorming Uniformiteit Gebruikswaarde hoger hoger hoger hoger hoger hoger cijfer hoger

Inspired by problems and results in this stochastic setting we present necessary and sufficient conditions in terms of the parameters in the recurrence relation for the smallest

War die Mutter, die sie auch nach ihrem Tode indirekt unterstützte, in Aschenputtel noch die wichtigste Bezugsperson für die Tochter, stellt es sich während der Handlung in