Vergelijking van methoden voor de oplossing van elasto-plastische problemen, op basis van de eindige elementen methode

Vergelijking van methoden voor de oplossing van

elasto-plastische problemen, op basis van de eindige elementen

methode

Citation for published version (APA):

Mullekom, van, J. T. J. M. S. (1974). Vergelijking van methoden voor de oplossing van elasto-plastische

problemen, op basis van de eindige elementen methode. (DCT rapporten; Vol. 1974.002). Technische

Hogeschool Eindhoven.

Document status and date:

Gepubliceerd: 01/01/1974

Document Version:

Uitgevers PDF, ook bekend als Version of Record

Please check the document version of this publication:

• A submitted manuscript is the version of the article upon submission and before peer-review. There can be

important differences between the submitted version and the official published version of record. People

interested in the research are advised to contact the author for the final version of the publication, or visit the

DOI to the publisher's website.

• The final author version and the galley proof are versions of the publication after peer review.

• The final published version features the final layout of the paper including the volume, issue and page

numbers.

Link to publication

General rights

Copyright and moral rights for the publications made accessible in the public portal are retained by the authors and/or other copyright owners and it is a condition of accessing publications that users recognise and abide by the legal requirements associated with these rights. • Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the public portal for the purpose of private study or research. • You may not further distribute the material or use it for any profit-making activity or commercial gain

• You may freely distribute the URL identifying the publication in the public portal.

If the publication is distributed under the terms of Article 25fa of the Dutch Copyright Act, indicated by the “Taverne” license above, please follow below link for the End User Agreement:

www.tue.nl/taverne

Take down policy

If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us at:

openaccess@tue.nl

providing details and we will investigate your claim.

d

dp 3 -

P

-I

-k

a c

P

,

P

c

B

P

e P

P

.

Q

I

3

knooppunten

1-2-3

verstevigingsmodel:

<

=

,,he'

2

elementen

en

FLA

2 .

ideaal plastisch

-

g

=

O

lineaire versteviging

---

=

koi

-

( s

- E

Ramberg Osgoods

R . 0 ,

-

2

vrijheidegraden

;tante

2

doorsnede

FLR-2

element

I

m

ELAP(o)

=

( , I 1 $/E)

o g r a m a

nr.

9

gA

g B

14

7A

7B

4

3g45.10

R.

O.

10

1

3

9

?

2045

a

I

Om3

12

,6657

1

Om3

-3

i16

4

5

3,45.10

11,4.10

-3

10

I

3

49

,2998

o

1

O-

1

5998.

Io-

9

I

,9001.10-

20

-

6

4'

5

11,4.10

3,45.10

11,4,1O

10

2

3

7

-3

2

in

N/m

2400

1

,o

1

O

1

3

150*

4

06249,

i

Oe2

2400

1 ,o

R.0.

10

1

1

-3

2400

1

P O

R.O.

10

1

1

56

-4

3374

1

2480

130

240

10

1

1

47

-3

,4119.1

O

2400

190

240

10

1

I

70

-4

,4161.

IOm3

2

in

N/m

SP

(konv.kriterium)

OL

(versn.faktor)

ntal gewenste bel.stappen

ntal iteraties le stap

astische rek na le stap

iteraties 2e stap

.rek, na 20. stap

iteraties 3e stap

.rek na

3e

s t a p

' I

2

1

3

150Y

16

,3230

e

1

O-'

,3877

1

O-2

,7756

e

1

O-2

1

I

64

I

O-1

P

1

42

3354

e

1

3026.

I

6052

0

1 o-2

1

9078.1

Oe2

19

?

1637.10-2

69

898

40

356

22

1

2740

44

789

72

940

76

896

50

2737

1

509

101

1328

91

I082

U

in sec.

U

+

SI8

in sec

lmerking

:

sc

:

geen konvergentie

"h

,

Er

is

gebïuik gemaakt van drie verstevig. gsmodellen

‘i‘

15

knooppunten

.i.

26

vrijheidsgraden

m

4

elementen

TRIM 6

5

=

O

ideaal,

plastisch materiaal

i=

a

lineaire versteviging

$ =

(sig

2-sig

I ) / ( P P ~ P ( S ~ ~

2 )

-

GTW (C

’

met

E T A P

(6)

=

(,i

1

=

zeta

=

hhellingshoek

van de trekkrom

1

t/m

i 5

knooppunt nummering

@

t/m

element nummering

I

1 )

)

Ramberg-Osgood

I,

d e

dikte van de elementen

is

Q , 5 m

Hierdoor de

i s

de dwarsdoorsnede

i

m

De getallen in een cirkeltje boven iedere kolom geven

het nummer aan

2

van het PLASKA-programma waaruit de

gegevens uit die kolom gehaald zijn.

Drograma-

nro

I I

10

10

21

1,

3

2400

1

.%o

O

10

1

1

-3

150***

E

in

N/m

E

I

2400

2400

110

R . 0

10

1

1

75

-4

3 3 7 8

e

I

2400

190

24

1

2

1

150

9%

2

6th

N/m

5

hellingshoek

EPSP

(konvergentie-kriterium)

XPOL

(versnellingsfaktor)

aantal gewenste belestappen

aantal iteraties le stap

90

R.O.

I O

1

1

4 4

-3

1

1

1

1

1

1

I

_I

54

90

i

150%

plast.rek.

,3354.10-~

I

121

1434

24 2

2950

240

2849

instabiel terwijl deze het hele iteratie-groce

w

Na 28

iteratiestappen wordt de spanning

konstant moet blijven.,

,ergentie optreden.

De berekende plastische rek slingert tussen

)3961

IOe4

en

1178.

10-2a

Hierdoor kan geen kol

#>u

Hetzelfde verschijnsel maar nu reeds bij stap

1 2 .

€99

I

06

5

(€1

SI

(€1

91

O?

"0

0L

8'

(I

)

L

o

I

"99Z

I

€-

5-

O

I

'60LV'

€-

€

I

O1

6-

Bh

I

1

#!

59%

9 0K

"Q

6

i

I

QZ

_ . _ _

6SO

I

L5€

(€1

01

OI

"L

9Z

Id

o

I

"O

[L

d

o

i

ZZLV'

E-

(€

)

6

€-

(I

)

E-

€

I I

P

4-Q /

P-

L Y’

/

c

I

d

Y

P

P

-.

S P

a-

/

.

k

k

.<

&

co

K I K T K A N

I V

L L E V E L I 1 3091 0 0 3 2 OU03 U O J 4 OO'J5 O O O 6 O U 0 8 O 0 0 9 U010 3 0 11 O O l ? ùO13 6014 o01 5 3 0 1 6

ouor

301

r

9018 0019 3 0 2 0 00.2 1 0 0 2 2 U023 0024 3 0 2 5 0 0 2 6 0027 O02 6 0029

o

(1

3

o

3031 0 0 3 2 O O j 3 D O ? + )O35 U 0 3 6 V A I N L U G I C A L C U Y V C * * * * € L A S T I C C A L L ' J L A T l i 3 V C A L L S T b t : T ( 1 s - 1 ) C A L L SA C A L L I N F I J N K C A L L I w t L C A L L D A T I N l O v 4 H t O F ) C A L L OA T L X ( O v 4 H N p C O C A L L ELCO C A L L SK C A L L dK C A L L 13H C A L L

S K

C A L L S P C A L L S T C A L L I N I P L C**** I*il T I A L I LE t L A S T O P L A S T i C C A L G I J L A T I O U

c

I U P U T P L A S T I C O A T 4 \r F I N O L L I A D I N ~ A T F i R S T Y I F L I ) C A L L D A T l N ( 0 , 4 H F 1 ' 4 ) C A L L Y L U A n i Y S C A L ) i4 4 I T

F

( h 9 2 U ) Y SC A L C A L L M I I L T S ( 4 i i h H L vYSCALv'+Ht+WL 2 0 F f l K V A T l / I 3 ? Y I t l L i C C 1 L E = f = i 1 . 4 / / 1 C A L L URH C A L L D A T t X I O v 4 H U 3 K I C S t T L C I A U ( F A C T O R ) I f L C k t Y E ' Y T C A P P A D = . 1 C A L L M U L T S í 4 1 R K L 9 C A P P 4 J J v 4 H r < R L 3 )

c

S h T S T A ' X T I N G L 3 A d I N G S T E P N'JYBEP C A L L I N I S M

c

S T R t S S t S A T i I K S T Y l i L l l C C A L L M U L T S I 4 H S I G v Y S L A L f 4 H S I ú C

n

k K t 5 P c! Y U I N S C A L L €OUST C A L L NPST 1- OU I V A L E ;\1 T 5 T R E S S

t

S C A L L D A T t X ( O , L I . ' i N P S T l ~ C e * * * L i l O P OF L0AL)IrVL; S T F P IT0 L O O J = i , 3 C A P P A = 1 . + C A P P A D ~ F L 1 3 A T I J ) W H I T E ( h i 5 O I J p C 4 P P A 9 A T t = 7 3 2 9 9 2 0 / 3 1 / 0 2 P A G E 7001

.

,

. -

-r t z 4 3 >

z

z nn a T- v, o n i3 2 -i i R: r 1 D

-

z w D .-( m li 4 .u N 9 o) N O O oom r- m < 0.v or hi O ‘r w c. \ O N P _{> o m o O} rj u, w 3 \ LLI c ‘r 0 N U B &> n: O O a N

F J P T K A N I V u L t V t L 2 1 L t T 4 U A T f = 7 1 7 9 8 ; > Q / 3 1 / 0 2 P A G E O 0 9 1 (1031 C 311'32

o

O

o

3 0 0 0 4 H F A L FIIIUCTIO'd Z F T A í S I G l . S f G 7 , I ; . I t , I t P , I N P )

L

I N F A I Z € T A = 1 1 . 4 F S R E T U R N FND

r

V t

K

S T E V I G 1 NG L C T A ATE

=

73298 2 0 1 3 1 / 0 2

+LIPT I J mqS

1

h E F F E C T 1 N 01

D

9 5 3 C fl 1 G I 5 O11 H C t 8 'di) t I 5 T 9 '4

(1

3 E CK 9 L fl A D t 'J OM AP

* Q P r i o q s ~b E F F F C T ~ N A Y € = Z F T A

,

L I N E C N T = 5') : < S T A T I S T I C S * S Ü t J M C F S T A T E M F k T S = L t 7 P R J G R A M S I Z E = 4 14 * S T A T I S T I L S * Y3 3 I A G W S T i C S Gt'JEA4TED . " _ _ F U Q T R A N

I V

G L t V E L 21 E T A P D

. -

D A T E = 7 3 2 9 8 2 9 / 3 1 / 0 2

O00 1 @

t

AL F U N C T I (JY f T A P 9 ( F P O M N 9 EPMAX 9 S I GH v 5 I Gt I

:>

9 I E 9 I F P , I VP I

C S L t i A T T I N L V A \ 3 t < ( 3 1 1 1 V A t t N T t TOthilAMt- V A N DE D E F O R Y A T I k C E P í ) Y N kQiJ I d . D E F 3 R Y 4 T I S - T ü € N A Y E V A N n t V f P IGE B E L A T T I N G S S T A P O002 0 0 0 3 R E T U R N 3 0 5 4 FYI) t T A P i ) = t P DVl\l F O R T R A N I V G L E V E L 21 t T A P U D A T F = 711298 2 0 / 3 1 / 0 2 * S T A T I S T l L C * NU IIIAGNCISTICS T H I S S T C " L P A G E 0002 PAGE 0302 ~ i

vi -.( == 72 o m A m C W I Ln

-

.* C 5 D A 2 M z o o 8 J c 3: D w I1 c) z ,n -4 C m z D D 0 m c

3 m W a

zl

z) O E 3 ri z

-

z

f

U n

I-. n O i- I O z I I I u L cl I O < m z

z I v1 c

cj c h’ o vi m n E c

z

4

-

E m n c Ta E izi 5 W z

-

%

“

P c a 3

.-.

L -4 n ‘U m r- m i n CL 4 J, s n- I i

I

rr 7- r 3 V 3 I I ~ o m a z 3 x;

-

v)

-

.

5 rn 3 u n U n O s

z

rn z -4 VI J I rn ui

ll 11 CZ II 2. I/ -i I1 71 /I X" N C Li vi n n -i* I Tp * 3 .n T. C -n !A It 3 i. I-. z n c

-

z n T, c N c9 o m 3 F ~~ I- N- via C o c E I vi

-

NP- 3\r Nr 4N I I I _m

-

_{z u}

₂

_{< m z} it Q Q u U La o m P

c L t- i. * d L s CS

..

CN r3 cc2 c3 o3 n-n 33 c- V I

.-

r i: rr Li r c -U .,I P rr Lr I- > 3 vi 3 n r- I r

..

i. 3 C 73 3 7) 7J 72 L3 it Lo

-

O E D P z Y L

o

-

Ln

-

..

3 C 13

-

3 V r n 3 m z -4 P 4 cj m u n- W J Y R Ln

-

" O

z

D W L I z

o

-

in u rn W z 3 P

-

Ln *

..

W Q C r 3 r n- -2 P Zj O r 3; L d C 3 9 _c>

*

9 o fi x= -i 5; -I X it Q it it o 9 _-u

*

it U P I Ja O c c U O n n G 3 2 rn

z

+

I wl

...

i

I1 11 3 I1 c I1 r- II 4 I1 vi

z

m

*

r < I rn r- c VI o P r- rn 11 c u1 v vi O m 3 U I1 I1 3 I1 D II -i ;I

-

I1 L L o r- 3 5 C i3 rn rn W n C A c VI

-

.

O z P L I z

o

Y,

-

.

3 O c O O n V o U U u 3 n o R U -2 3: m

I1 I1 3 i1 3 I1 3 II 71 II xt. I1 I1 m I1 II 3 II c /I r I! 3 I1 Lo3 IC 15 t)c I O r 4 i/, rn n O c 4 3 m 0 UI 77 c: O Ln In n W? T n v1 rT n -4 4 5 3 m n r- P rL n r

E

L zz n +-i

-

Tz n 4 -l jc D n 4 m ,G f c zz rn 4-i c c zz m -49 3 n

...

.n o L n: -4 -43 P 7 I 1 T n r

-

-A n

o

rn T c em n

-

Y ric T 3 T, 3 't:

-.

d '3 i: P -4 71 z -4 rr 7 rl vl fz c r -4

5

n

-.

4 -4 L 3 c c: P rn m c F O W c U1 c 9 n c 1. M

,-.

...

O rn i2 U _x U m CI z J I o -z m z U % % 9 U P 0 rn -i 5 Lo

-

.

yi

-

.

V u D m i- 9 4? 9 9 Q 9

*

9

*

9 9 a 9 9 a U a- U a U VI

-

II II Ln II i li u II x II c; c- C w II II l,? II 0 II r 11 II m II -i II D II u II n X

-

II -i I1

-

rn I1 z X I1

-

D I1

-

-i G I1-I mc -* mu -i3 P Din rr ri O c tw 'd r o -i 3 a. 4 c W in vi 'T) r, n c Ln vi Ir n n m -4 CI jc I C z II I-. x. i z m --i T 3 c z W o O- L P -I 3-

e'

vi J c 5 X O Ti "7 I1 _{ln n} II _L>7 D r

....

" II o O O 3 rr N 73 ü L vi

-

..

n a -c 3 7-2 m T n- W W =! 15: m

5

c r D -4 w C z z W CA -4 I I I _m M L û I

o

% m z *L c 4 K 3 r D P z Y

z

0

VI

-

.

c E D Q n a W h i e c: X -i < o Y W G u D C'> rn n G 5 I '51 z -4 4 a 4 re Q a it it 9

+

I1 I1 4 II s II vi n c xr O ZE P P L O

zz ern G3 m M -4 m f P 7 9-. 7l io 9 D U "J z O U m hi O o m -I P o I

z

m 9 t- o x, -0 c

.

z 3 N 4 < U .n 71 r- P kJ 2 O C m e 3 0 rn -4 P U 3 L O C F N G ù rn

*

P U 1 7 m 4 c s ú> z o t- " z z L G

p

-

o G m -4 P 3 I c ;3 3 c C v, m r, x C

z

4 I P r 7- c) z c s

rno 4fi DTJ 'ti

#-

.

z m 4

II U I)

C ii

m

3 vir h-4 UI=- NU -3 10 i3 ui v N;? 44 UID -U rn; i- o W O 3

in .D cj N -i z 4 II -n 4

*

ut- 3- 9 4 < U w Ti 4P Dh> U t mr c ci I P 7 o rn

-

" h

..

-4 -< U rn n r- c z 7, U n X

c

-5 i, rx 3 o OT -4 Om 4 P W .J hi T. -i > P a N C C lA W PW cv, vi- m- 30 O0 mi mr Y 5 ui

$:

O0 TPI

.-.

s U r v) i

o

liI rn s rn z -4 B 4

-

c z t I I

o

in C VI O o

<a W -Ju7 9- ulo mo

O W -Ju7 9- vi0 mo O 4l

-

o O

O cn

U n

I1 I1 3 i1 3 I1 3 II 71 II xt. I1 I1 m I1 II 3 II c /I r I! 3 I1 Lo3 IC 15 t)c I O r 4 i/, rn n O c 4 3 m 0 UI 77 c: O Ln In n W? T n v1 rT n -4 4 5 3 m n r- P rL n r

E

L zz n +-i

-

Tz n 4 -l jc D n 4 m ,G f c zz rn 4-i c c zz m -49 3 n

...

.n o L n: -4 -43 P 7 I 1 T n r

-

-A n

o

rn T c em n

-

Y ric T 3 T, 3 't:

-.

d '3 i: P -4 71 z -4 rr 7 rl vl fz c r -4

5

n

-.

4 -4 L 3 c c: P rn m c F O W c U1 c 9 n c 1. M

,-.

...

O rn i2 U _x U m CI z J I o -z m z U % % 9 U P 0 rn -i 5 Lo

-

.

yi

-

.

V u D m i- 9 4? 9 9 Q 9

*

9

*

9 9 a 9 9 a U a- U a U VI

-

II II Ln II i li u II x II c; c- C w II II l,? II 0 II r 11 II m II -i II D II u II n X

-

II -i I1

-

rn I1 z X I1

-

D I1

-

-i G I1-I mc -* mu -i3 P Din rr ri O c tw 'd r o -i 3 a. 4 c W in vi 'T) r, n c Ln vi Ir n n m -4 CI jc I C z II I-. x. i z m --i T 3 c z W o O- L P -I 3-

e'

vi J c 5 X O Ti "7 I1 _{ln n} II _L>7 D r

....

" II o O O 3 rr N 73 ü L vi

-

..

n a -c 3 7-2 m T n- W W =! 15: m

5

c r D -4 w C z z W CA -4 I I I _m M L û I

o

% m z *L c 4 K 3 r D P z Y

z

0

VI

-

.

c E D Q n a W h i e c: X -i < o Y W G u D C'> rn n G 5 I '51 z -4 4 a 4 re Q a it it 9

+

I1 I1 4 II s II vi n c xr O ZE P P L O

zz ern G3 m M -4 m f P 7 9-. 7l io 9 D U "J z O U m hi O o m -I P o I

z

m 9 t- o x, -0 c

.

z 3 N 4 < U .n 71 r- P kJ 2 O C m e 3 0 rn -4 P U 3 L O C F N G ù rn

*

P U 1 7 m 4 c s ú> z o t- " z z L G

p

-

o G m -4 P 3 I c ;3 3 c C v, m r, x C

z

4 I P r 7- c) z c s

rno 4fi DTJ 'ti

#-

.

z m 4

II U I)

C ii

m

3 vir h-4 UI=- NU -3 10 i3 ui v N;? 44 UID -U rn; i- o W O 3

in .D cj N -i z 4 II -n 4

*

ut- 3- 9 4 < U w Ti 4P Dh> U t mr c ci I P 7 o rn

-

" h

..

-4 -< U rn n r- c z 7, U n X

c

-5 i, rx 3 o OT -4 Om 4 P W .J hi T. -i > P a N C C lA W PW cv, vi- m- 30 O0 mi mr Y 5 ui

$:

O0 TPI

.-.

s U r v) i

o

liI rn s rn z -4 B 4

-

c z t I I

o

in C VI O o

<a W -Ju7 9- ulo mo

O W -Ju7 9- vi0 mo O 4l

-

o O

O cn

U n

2 m -! RJ C. C rn 4 D c 7 c c " C c- vi C w c u J. rn O0 3 m 3 rn O O ul ul

z rn 4 r " o P V c " z h, N

.

+

< P m n i- D N z c J rr r 3 O rr -i P 3 3 C 'u7 u4 PP P-J r-cl 10 3 h

P

wim a4 WD

F2

1- Cu N C (u m r-i -J3 .nu rr* 4 IN _{3 %} -z -ic rn c Prr Piu -i c O c -2 Ln A n P 7 ...I rn X ct m o I z

o

T, 3 Nm c.

z

.

P 5

-

r- i- m (r) M c v, I N 3 r.J Li m (/I I- P li? v)

-

z o r m s rn z -i 9 -i

-

O .z I I I rn

-

L O i 5 C m z c it it 4t U P o n ly m r 9 O T

..

O vi O w a r 6 O v1 O in

z

O _m -4 rn i- I. I

IZ IV ILO I9 -i+ rr-l z1;c DD O c c -4 ii Y; m o iub -n -4 rn OE z o (n -4 ti P -4 ,n c z ” o * O

.

o c a 7i 9 9 n I$ X -3 < V N

C wu d m r! o P -4 71 C 71 O

..

û T. r-

..

L rr

-4

O W * I-

*

n 9 hi c \ m X 4 .i U N I 3 9 9 Q